
inroads — SIGCSE Bulletin - 146 - Volume 40, Number 4 — 2008 December
3.1.2 Scaffolding
"Scaffolding" refers to support given to students in problem
solving. Initially substantial help and guidance are provided;
subsequently, the "scaffolds" are gradually removed, and
students are required to do more and more on their own.
Systems support scaffolding in a variety of ways.
WISE provides a hinting facility [33] with which a curriculum
author may scaffold students.
CSILE (Computer-Supported Intentional Learning) [132] is a
networked learning environment intended to foster higher-level
processes of inquiry among elementary school students. It
includes scaffolds to support students in areas such as text
analysis, theory-building, and debating, along with a construct
called a "Thinking Type" that guides students to engage in
deepening inquiry.
Belvedere [78] is another system aiming to foster critical
inquiry skills. It suggests candidate steps for proceeding further,
and structures access to materials and activities.
3.1.3 Reflection
By “reflection”, we mean learning from experience. Different
ways to encourage reflection are briefly described below.
A WISE curriculum author can include prompts to explicitly
encourage reflection.
Vision Quest included a "reflective follow-up" step, to be
completed after a decision has (provisionally) been made.
ALEL [76], which was developed to teach experimental
research methodology and statistical inference, displays a tree
that represents a student's activity path; this graphical
representation can be used as a tool for collaborative reflection.
3.1.4 Multiple representations
Multiple representations of a concept—for example in diagrams,
animations, or physical activities—contribute to richer
understanding of the concept. ALEL's tree representation of
actions has already been noted in support of the decision-
making process. To foster better knowledge organization, WISE
supports the creation and sharing of concept maps [101]. A
concept map is a diagram showing relationships between
concepts. The diagram consists of nodes, which represent
concepts, and labeled edges connecting pairs of nodes, which
represent how one of the pair of concepts is related to the other.
3.1.5 Support for "what if ...?" activities
This problem solving process typically includes choice points
where the solver tries out two or more solution approaches.
Future Learning Environments (FLE) [75] is a web-based
learning environment that focuses on creating and developing
expressions of knowledge (i.e., knowledge artifacts) and design.
FLE maintains a tree diagram of artifacts. When a choice is
made to modify an artifact, the system extends the tree diagram,
thus making clear the "inheritance structure" of artifact
modifications.
3.1.6 Authoring
Authoring with the typical LMS is free-form, using a text editor
or web form to specify each activity. In contrast, the Pattern-
Annotated Course Tool (PACT) [24] allows a course to be
authored based on pedagogical patterns, descriptions of
outstanding teaching practices recorded in a format that
facilitates a common vocabulary for pedagogical research and
practice, is accessible to novice instructors, and encourages the
repurposing and reuse of techniques that are solidly grounded in
modern pedagogy. Its visual interface displays the association
between curriculum activities and the corresponding
pedagogical patterns; patterns may be easily instantiated and
associated with corresponding activities.
PACT has been found to be useful in several scenarios,
including the following [25].
• Annotation by expert course authors. Expert content
developers have acquired substantial understanding of
what works in a course and what does not. Often,
however, this knowledge is difficult to uncover. The
process of annotating a course with references to
pedagogical patterns seems to help experienced
instructors articulate their own understanding of their
design and thereby make it more accessible to others.
• Content creation by novice instructors. PACT makes
it easy to copy large chunks of an existing course to a
newly created course. With typical courses, one
instructor hands copies of homework, exams, lecture
notes, and course syllabi to the next instructor. These
artifacts, however, are probably insufficient to reveal
the underlying rationale for the various course
activities, precisely the information that PACT is
designed to provide.
• Mediation for discussion. As a highly visual medium,
the PACT interface makes an excellent visual aid for
describing and discussing issues in pedagogy and
curriculum design. It allows the pedagogical expert to
review their own annotation with fellow teachers and
researchers (both novice and experienced) to elicit
ideas and stimulate discussion of improvements to
content and structure.
3.2 Augmented Learning
Augmented Learning approaches try to support the "classical",
lecture-based teaching style using computer support. They thus
provide support for teaching that goes beyond simply plugging a
laptop into a projector and running PowerPoint, without
targeting distance education. The underlying rationale is that the
lecture setting, whilst by no means perfect, plays an important
social role in presence teaching: it provides both a focal point
and a meeting place between lecturer and students and among
students. It therefore also helps to build a sense of "community"
and of "social presence" [131].
Applications in this area typically aid the presenter by providing
features such as an annotation layer for writing on PowerPoint
slides or whiteboards, as done in the Lecturnity [62] or E-Chalk
products [46]. Apart from annotations, both systems also
support recording the lecture materials, including annotations.
Ubiquitous Presenter [50] adds another layer by proving a
"teacher" and a "learner" perspective. In this mode, the teacher
can see a different version of the learning materials, for
example, annotated with the model answer. They can then
simply use a pen on a tablet PC to draw the highlighted
elements of the model answer and thereby "develop" the answer
in-class [50, 151].