Rock Core Evaluation Manual: Geotechnical Engineering Manual GEM-23
Rock Core Evaluation Manual: Geotechnical Engineering Manual GEM-23
AUGUST 2006
EB 06-039
Page 1 of 20
TABLE OF CONTENTS
I.
INTRODUCTION ...................................................................................................................4
II.
III. ROCK CORE EVALUATION PROCEDURE ......................................................................7 A. Recovery................................................................................................................................7 B. Rock Quality Designation (RQD) .........................................................................................7 C. Rock Type.......... ...................................................................................................................8 1. Igneous.................................................................................................................................8 2. Metamorphic.... ....................................................................................................................8 3. Sedimentary...... ...................................................................................................................8 a. Compaction.... ....................................................................................................................9 b. Cementation........................................................................................................................9 D. Color....................................................................................................................................13 E. Mineralogy, Grain Size, and Texture ..................................................................................13 F. Bedding.............. .................................................................................................................13 G. Fractures............. .................................................................................................................14 H. Size Range of Pieces ...........................................................................................................15 I. Hardness........... ...................................................................................................................16 J. Weathering....... ...................................................................................................................17 K. Additional Observations......................................................................................................17 L. Photographs...... ...................................................................................................................17 M. Rock Core Logs...................................................................................................................18 REFERENCES ........................................................................................................................ 19-20 APPENDIX A APPENDIX B Rock Core Evaluation Sheet............ ........................................................ A1-A2 Sample Rock Core Log...................................................................................B1
EB 06-039
Page 2 of 20
LIST OF TABLES
Igneous Rocks.................................................................................................................10 Metamorphic Rocks ........................................................................................................11 Sedimentary Rocks .........................................................................................................12 Sedimentary Rock Bedding ............................................................................................13 Fracture Density..............................................................................................................14 Fracture Healing..............................................................................................................15 Rock Hardness ................................................................................................................16 Weathering Categories....................................................................................................17
EB 06-039
Page 3 of 20
I. INTRODUCTION This manual presents a procedure for describing rock core samples, obtained for the New York State Department of Transportation, by State work forces and/or private drilling companies, for foundation, rockslope, and other engineering purposes. The evaluation is intended to provide a comprehensive word description of the core samples to those involved in the planning, design, construction, and maintenance processes. The procedure involves visual and manual examination of core samples with respect to rock type, color, composition, bedding, structure, hardness and degree of weathering. This information will be used to generate an official Rock Core Log, for each evaluated boring, which will be made available to interested parties, including designers and prospective bidders. NYSDOT obtains large quantities of rock core samples but only those samples necessary to advance the required geologic designs are evaluated and the corresponding Rock Core Logs developed. The standardized charts and tables herein, used as descriptive aids in the evaluation procedures, are adopted from various organizations, such as the U.S. Department of Interior, Geological Survey, the American Institute of Professional Geologists (AIPG), the U. S. Department of the Navy, Naval Facilities Engineering Command, etc.). It should be understood, however, that the final core descriptions and rock quality assessments are based on the judgment of the individual performing the evaluation. Additional tests that may be performed, such as Point Load tests and/or Unconfined Compressive Strength tests, are not intended to be used to verify the descriptions but to provide further information that will be reported separately.
EB 06-039
Page 4 of 20
Banding:
Layering in the rock. The layers may be bedding, parallel to bedding, or be at an angle to bedding in sedimentary rock. In metamorphic rock, the layering is called foliation. The foliation is a result of the alignment of platy (flat) and/or elongated minerals due to the heat and pressure of metamorphism. The foliations may be parallel with or at an angle to the original bedding. Sometimes the original bedding has been obliterated and only the foliations can be observed. Igneous rocks normally do not exhibit banding except in cases of differential settlement during hardening.
Bedding:
The layers in sedimentary rock parallel to the original surface of deposition. The original bedding planes were often, but not always, horizontal. The rock will often tend to break along bedding planes. The material, usually chemically precipitated, which binds the particles of some sedimentary rocks together (see grains and matrix). Closely spaced parallel planes along which rock can break. The cleavage may be a result of weakness along bedding planes in sedimentary rock (fracture cleavage) or may be a secondary development by alignment of platy minerals in metamorphic rock (slaty cleavage). Slaty cleavage may be parallel with or at an angle to original bedding. The process of chemical, physical and/or biological change in deposited sediment during its conversion into rock, exclusive of metamorphosis and weathering (see lithification). The fizzing action that occurs when a carbonate rock (containing CaCO2 or CaCO3) is placed in contact with hydrochloric acid (HCl).
Cement:
Cleavage:
Diagenesis:
Effervescence:
Fault:
A fracture in rock along which there has been observable movement (see joint). In rock cores, a fault can sometimes be recognized by the displacement of mineral veins. The alignment of platy (flat) or elongate minerals, usually in metamorphic rocks, giving the rock a banded appearance. The foliation is usually a result of the heat and pressure rock is subjected to during metamorphism.
Foliation:
EB 06-039
Page 5 of 20
Fracture:
Breakage in rock. The fracture may be parallel with or at an angle to banding, bedding, cleavage, foliation or lamination. Faults and joints are examples of fracture. The particles of which a rock or sediment is composed (see cement and matrix). A fracture in rock along which there has been no observable movement (see fault).
Grains: Joint:
Lamination: Very thin layering in rock, less than 0.4 inches (1 cm). The layers may be a result of physical or chemical variations. Laminations may be parallel with or at an angle to bedding (cross-laminations) in sedimentary rock. Lithification: The process by which loose sediment becomes rock (see diagenesis). Lithology: The character of a rock described in terms of its structure, color, mineral composition, grain-size, and arrangement of its component parts. The fine-grained portion, not necessarily cement, of some sedimentary rocks (sandstone, conglomerate, etc.) in which the coarser particles are embedded. The matrix may or may not be cemented (see cement). An inorganic substance, not necessarily of inorganic origin, that has (1) a definite chemical composition, or range of composition and (2) distinctive physical properties and/or molecular structure. The basic building block of rock. Solid material, either mineral or organic, that has been transported from its site of origin, by air, water, ice or biological activity, and has been re-deposited on the earth's surface, above or below water.
Matrix:
Mineral:
Sediment:
Weathering: The process by which rocks are broken down and decomposed by the action of external agencies such as wind, water (rain and/or ground water), temperature change, plants and bacteria.
EB 06-039
Page 6 of 20
III. ROCK CORE EVALUATION PROCEDURE A proper description of rock obtained in drill cores is a valuable aid to the Engineering Geologist in determining the properties of bedrock with regard to rock slope and structure foundation design. When evaluating rock core, the Engineering Geologist should make note of the following: A. Recovery, B. RQD, C. Rock type, D. Color, E. Mineralogy, Grain size & Texture, F. Bedding, G. Fractures, H. Size range of core pieces, I. Hardness, J. Weathering, K. Additional observations, L. Photographs, and M. Rock Core Log. The results are to be recorded on a Rock Core Evaluation Sheet (See Appendix A) and used to prepare an official Rock Core Log (See Appendix B). A. RECOVERY The recovery of each core run is usually determined by the Driller and recorded on the official Boring Log. Where the recovery is not made available, the Engineering Geologist should record the recovery (in percent) as the length of core recovered divided by the total length of the core run, multiplied by 100. Areas where loss is likely to have occurred (soft seams, fractures with edges that don't match, zones of decay, etc.) should be noted. B. RQD The Rock Quality Designation (RQD) is a modified measure of recovery, calculated in order to estimate the quality of the intact rock mass. The Engineering Geologist is responsible for the determination of RQD. The RQD (in percent) is obtained by dividing the sum of all the recovered pieces of core equal to or greater than 4 inches (10 cm) in length by the total length of the core run, then multiplying by 100. In effect, the RQD is a measure of the spacing of the discontinuities (bedding, fractures, faults, joints, shear zones, etc.) in the rock mass. When calculating RQD, it is important to try to distinguish between naturally occurring discontinuities and mechanical breaks which occur during coring procedure. Only naturally occurring discontinuities will be considered when calculating RQD. When there is uncertainty about a break, it should be considered as natural in order to be conservative in the calculation of RQD. In addition, only sound bedrock is used in the calculation of RQD. Weak and/or weathered rock core is not included in the RQD calculation.
EB 06-039
Page 7 of 20
Note: RQD was originally developed for use with NX-size (47.5 mm [2.16 in.]) core drilled in crystalline rock and used to describe rock quality for tunneling conditions. It has since become virtually standard practice in drill core logging for a variety of core sizes and rock types. ASTM International indicates core sizes from BQ (36.5 mm [1.44 in.]) to PQ (47.5 mm [3.35 in.]) are normally acceptable for measuring RQD. RQD calculated for cores smaller than BQ, e.g., AX-size (30.2 mm [1.19 in.]), may not be representative of the true quality of the rock mass. C. ROCK TYPE Geologists divide rocks into three groups based on origin and then subdivide them into smaller groups on the basis of composition and texture. 1. IGNEOUS ROCKS Rocks formed from the solidification of molten material (magma or lava). Igneous rocks can be intrusive (solidifying below the surface from magma) or extrusive (solidifying at the surface from lava). Intrusive igneous rocks are generally composed of larger crystals/grains (coarser texture) while extrusive igneous rocks are generally composed of smaller crystals/grains (finer texture). In general, igneous rocks tend to have an interlocking, crystalline texture with little to no appearance of layering, banding, or bedding. 2. METAMORPHIC ROCKS Metamorphic rocks are Igneous and/or Sedimentary rocks whose textures and /or mineral content have been changed by heat, pressure and/or chemically active solutions (invading gasses and/or liquids). In some instances, metamorphic rocks have been re-metamorphosed into other higher or lower grade metamorphic rocks. Metamorphic rocks can appear banded or layered (due to the alignment of platy, tabular, or elongated mineral grains or the concentration of different minerals into distinct bands). 3. SEDIMENTARY ROCKS Sedimentary rocks are formed by lithification of accumulated sediments that were transported and deposited by water, wind, ice, biological activity and/or chemical precipitation. In general, sedimentary rocks are composed of the weathering products of pre-existing rocks. Sedimentary rocks usually, but not always, have a layered appearance due to the presence of bedding planes. The grains of sedimentary rocks can range from sharply angular to well-rounded and from very fine to very coarse. Sedimentary rocks may contain fossils.
EB 06-039 Page 8 of 20
Two important processes in the formation of sedimentary rocks from original sediments are compaction and cementation. a. Compaction is the physical process by which the volume of a sediment is reduced by pressure. The weight of overlying deposits compact the underlying sediments, forcing out water and air and decreasing the porosity by squeezing the grains of sediment closer together. When muds are compacted in this manner, weak attractive forces may cause the grains to adhere to one another, converting the loose sediment into rock. Claystone, mudstone and shale are examples of sedimentary rocks which may be formed in this manner. b. Cementation occurs as water circulates through the sediment and dissolved elements in the water precipitate out and bind the grains of sediment together. Changes in the physical and/or chemical environment initiate the precipitation. Common cementing agents include silica compounds and calcium carbonate (calcite or aragonite, CaCO3). Various iron compounds (such as FeCO3, FeS2, and Fe2O3) can also act as cements. The cement may partially or completely fill the pore spaces in the sediment. Rocks formed by cementation of sediments can range from very soft to very hard. Cemented claystone, mudstone, shale, siltstone, sandstone and limestone are examples of rocks which may be formed by cementation. Note: For engineering purposes, rocks formed by cementation (with or without compaction) are more durable than rocks formed by compaction alone.
EB 06-039
Page 9 of 20
GRANITE
Light colored
White, gray or pink. Quartz is a major constituent. Can have a salt and pepper texture. Feldspar is white, pink or green. Moderately difficult to drill.
SYENITE
Little or no quartz. Feldspar is white or pink. Can have a salt and pepper texture. Moderately difficult to drill.
DIORITE
Often greenish in appearance. Often contains quartz (quartz diorite). Feldspar is white or gray. Moderately difficult to drill.
No quartz. Feldspar is white or gray. Difficult to drill. The intrusive variety of basalt.
BASALT
No quartz. Feldspar is white or gray. Difficult to drill. The extrusive variety of gabbro.
EB 06-039
Page 10 of 20
QUARTZITE
MARBLE SERPENTINITE
GNEISS
SCHIST
Foliated (coarse-grained)
Foliation due to alignment of platy minerals. Contains a lot of mica. Drills easily.
SLATE/ PHYLLITE
Foliated (fine-grained)
Foliation due to alignment of platy minerals. Can be distinguished from shale by its usually shiny surface. Moderately easy to drill.
EB 06-039
Page 11 of 20
CONGLOMERATE
Rock fragments.
Major portion composed of pebbles up to or more than an inch in diameter. Moderate to difficult to drill (depending on type of fragments & matrix).
SANDSTONE
Moderate to difficult to drill (depending on type of fragments & matrix). Often dense. Effervesces freely in dilute (5%) hydrochloric acid. Often fossiliferous. May contain veins of calcite. Can be scratched with a knife or nail. Easy to drill. May contain chert (microcrystalline quartz) which is very difficult to drill. May contain Dolomite. Similar to limestone but effervesces feebly in dilute (5%) hydrochloric acid. Can be scratched with a knife or nail. Drills easily. May contain chert which is very difficult to drill. May contain Calcite. Generally dull in appearance. Can be confused with fine-grained limestone but will not effervesce (when pure) in hydrochloric acid. May contain pyrite (fool's gold) crystals. May contain calcite and/or quartz veins. Can be scratched with a knife or nail. Drills easily. The different names (siltstone to claystone) are based on diminishing grain size.
LIMESTONE
Calcite
DOLOSTONE
Dolomite
Laminated
EB 06-039
Page 12 of 20
D. COLOR The color of the recovered rock is determined by comparing the core pieces with color chips in the Geological Society of America (GSA) Rock Color Chart. Variations in color, if considered important, are noted. E. MINERALOGY, GRAIN SIZE, AND TEXTURE A description of the major minerals composing the rock. If possible, the size of the individual grains/crystals and the texture of the rock (very fine to very coarse) are noted. General descriptions of mineralogy, grain size, and texture for the various rock types are included in the rock type tables. F. BEDDING The following table lists the categories of bedding used in describing sedimentary rock: Table 4: Sedimentary Rock Bedding BEDDING DESCRIPTION
Very Thick-Bedded Greater than 4 feet (> 121 cm) Thick-Bedded Medium-Bedded Thin-Bedded Very Thin-Bedded Thickly Laminated Thinly Laminated None For igneous and metamorphic rocks, any observable planar features (foliation, banding, etc.) may be recorded using the same thickness designations as sedimentary bedding. 12 inches to 4 feet (30 cm to 121 cm) 4 inches to 12 inches (10 cm to 30 cm) 1.2 inches to 4 inches (3 cm to 10 cm) 0.5 inches to 1.2 inches (1.2 cm to 3 cm) 0.1 inches to 0.5 inches (0.3 cm to 1.2 cm) Less than o.1 inches (< 0.3 cm)
EB 06-039
Page 13 of 20
G. FRACTURES The spacing, orientation, filling, and degree of healing of the fractures can be important in determining the properties of the rock mass for structure foundation design. The following tables list the fracture density (FD) and fracture healing (FH) categories: Table 5: Fracture Density DEGREE OF FRACTURING Unfractured Very slightly fractured Slightly to very slightly fractured Slightly fractured
DESCRIPTION No observed fractures. Core recovered in lengths greater than 3 feet (1 m). Core recovered in lengths from 1 to 3 feet (300 to 1000 mm). Core recovered mostly in lengths from 1 to 3 feet (300 to 1000 mm) with few scattered lengths less than 1 foot (300 mm) or greater than 3 feet (1000 mm).
Moderately to slightly fractured Core recovered mostly in lengths averaging 1 foot (300 mm). Moderately fractured Intensely to moderately fractured Intensely fractured Very intensely to intensely fractured Very intensely fractured Core recovered mostly in lengths from 0.33 to 1.0 foot (100 to 300 mm) with most lengths about 0.67 foot (200 mm). Core recovered mostly in lengths of 0.33 to 0.67 foot (100 to 200 mm) with most lengths about 0.5 foot (150 mm). Core recovered mostly in lengths from 0.1 to 0.33 foot (30 to 100 mm) with most lengths less than 0.33 foot (100 mm) and with fragmented intervals. Core recovered as short core lengths averaging less than 0.1 foot (30 mm). Core recovered mostly as chips and fragments with a few scattered short core lengths.
EB 06-039
Page 14 of 20
DESCRIPTION Fracture is completely healed or re-cemented to a degree at least as hard as surrounding rock. Greater than 50% of fracture material, fracture surfaces or filling is healed or re-cemented and/or strength of the healing agent is less hard than surrounding rock. Less than 50% fracture material, filling or fracture surface is healed or re-cemented. Fracture surface(s), fracture zone, or filling is not healed or recemented.
Moderately Healed
H. SIZE RANGE OF CORE PIECES Indicate the range of size of pieces of core recovered in the run. The size may range from fragments too small to measure up to a single piece the entire length of the run. Note the locations of significant fragmented zones.
EB 06-039
Page 15 of 20
I. HARDNESS The following table lists the rock hardness categories: Table 7: Rock Hardness DESCRIPTION Very soft rock Soft rock Moderately soft rock LONG DESCRIPTION Can be scratched with fingernail. Slight indentation produced by light blow of point of geologic pick. Requires power tools for excavation. Hand-held specimen crumbles under firm blows with point of geologic pick. Shallow indentations (1 to 3 mm) can be made by firm blows with point of geologic pick. Can be peeled with pocket knife with difficulty.
Moderately hard rock Can't be peeled or scraped with knife. Can be distinctly scratched with a steel nail. Hard rock Very hard rock Extremely hard rock Intact hand-held specimen requires more than one hammer blow to break it. Can be faintly scratched by steel nail. Cannot be scratched with a steel nail. Intact specimen breaks only by repeated, heavy blows with geologic hammer. Intact specimen can only be chipped, not broken, by repeated, heavy blows of a geologic hammer.
EB 06-039
Page 16 of 20
Table 8: Weathering Categories DEGREE OF WEATHERING Residual soil DETAILED DESCRIPTION Advanced state of decomposition resulting in plastic soils. Rock fabric and structure completely destroyed. Large volume change. Minerals decomposed to soil but fabric and structure preserved (saprolite). Specimens easily crumbled or penetrated. Most minerals somewhat decomposed. Specimens can be broken by hand with effort or shaved with knife. Core stones present in rock mass. Texture becoming indistinct but fabric preserved. Discoloration throughout. Strength somewhat less than fresh rock but cores cannot be broken by hand or scraped with knife. Texture observed. Slight discoloration inwards from open fractures. No visible sign of decomposition or discoloration. Rings under hammer impact.
Completely weathered
Highly weathered
K. ADDITIONAL OBSERVATIONS Any observed properties of the core not covered in the previous categories (e.g. handling and/or labeling discrepancies, marked difference in recovery calculations between the driller and the evaluator, etc.). L. PHOTOGRAPHS The Geotechnical Engineering Bureau (GEB) Geologist will take representative digital photographs of the individual core runs and additional photographs of important portions of the cores (fragmented zones, soft seams, lithology changes, etc.) where applicable.
EB 06-039
Page 17 of 20
M. ROCK CORE LOGS The appropriate information from the Subsurface Exploration Log is imported from the Boring Log Automation Program (BLAP) into the Rock Core database. The results of the Geologist's rock core evaluation (See Appendix A) are entered into the Rock Core database and official Rock Core Logs are then produced (See Appendix B). If the Subsurface Exploration Log information is not available through BLAP, the official Rock Core Logs are produced manually. The final Rock Core Logs, signed by the GEB's Engineering Geology section manager, are then sent to the GEB's Highway Design & Construction (HD & C) section for distribution.
EB 06-039
Page 18 of 20
REFERENCES American Institute of Professional Geologists (formerly the Association of Professional Geological Scientists), May 1977, Geologic Logging and Sampling of Rock Core for Engineering Purposes (Tentative). ASTM International, Rev. 2002, Designation D6032 - 02, Standard Test Method for Determining Rock Quality Designation (RQD) of Rock Core, 5 pp. Chernicoff, S. and Whitney, D., 2007, Geology, An Introduction to Physical Geology, 4th ed, Pearson Prentice Hall, 720 pp. Deere, D. U. and Deere, D. W., "The Rock Quality Designation (RQD) Index in Practice," Rock Classification Systems for Engineering Purposes, ASTM STP 984, Louis Kirkaldie, ed., American Society of Testing and Materials, Philadelphia, 1988, pp. 91-101. Hyndman, D. W., 1972, Petrology of Igneous and Metamorphic Rocks, McGraw-Hill, Inc., 533 pp. Leet, L. D., Judson, S. and Kauffman, M. E., 1978, Physical Geology, 5th ed, Prentice-Hall, Inc., Englewood Cliffs, N. J., 490 pp. New York State Department of Transportation, Geotechnical Engineering Bureau, 1996, Design Manual, Working Draft, Section DM3.11, Subsurface Investigations, Field Identification of Rock Samples. New York State Department of Transportation, Geotechnical Engineering Bureau, December 1994, Soil Control Procedure STP-2, An Engineering Description of Soils, Visual-Manual Procedure, 9 pp. Pettijohn, F. J., 1975, Sedimentary Rocks, Harper & Row Publishers, New York, N.Y., 628 pp. Press, F. and Siever, R., 1978, Earth, 2nd ed, W.H. Freeman and Company, 649 pp. Tarbuck, E. J. and Lutgens, F. K., 1987, The Earth, An Introduction to Physical Geology, 2nd ed, Merrill Publishing Company, Columbus, Ohio, 590 pp. Thrush, P. W., and the staff of the Bureau of Mines, comp. & ed., 1968, A dictionary of mining, mineral, and related terms, U. S. Department of the Interior, Bureau of Mines, 1269 pp. U. S. Department of Interior, Geological Survey, 1976, Earth Science Information in Land-Use Planning - Guidelines for Earth Scientists and Planners, Geological Survey Circular No. 721.
EB 06-039
Page 19 of 20
U. S. Department of the Navy, Naval Facilities Engineering Command, May 1982, Design Manual 7.1 (NAVFAC DM - 7.1), 364 pp. Whitten, D. G. A., with Brooks, J. R. V., 1972, The Penguin Dictionary of Geology, Penguin Books Ltd., Harmondsworth, Middlesex, England, 517 pp.
EB 06-039
Page 20 of 20
APPENDIX
Top of Rock _______________ (Depth) _______________ (Elevation) Top of Sound Rock _______________ (Depth) ______________ (Elevation)
RUN #1
Photo(s) ______________________
Rock Type ________________________________________________________________________________ Color ____________________________________________________________________________________ Mineralogy, Grain Size, & Texture _____________________________________________________________ Bedding __________________________________________________________________________________ Fractures _________________________________________________________________________________ Size Range of Pieces ________________________________________________________________________ Hardness __________________________________________________________________________________ Weathering ________________________________________________________________________________ Additional Comments _______________________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________________________________________ Page 1 of y
EB 06-039
A-1
Rock Type ________________________________________________________________________________ Color ____________________________________________________________________________________ Mineralogy, Grain Size, & Texture _____________________________________________________________ Bedding __________________________________________________________________________________ Fractures __________________________________________________________________________________ Size Range of Pieces ________________________________________________________________________ Hardness __________________________________________________________________________________ Weathering ________________________________________________________________________________ Additional Comments _______________________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________________________________________
RUN # __________
Rock Type ________________________________________________________________________________ Color ____________________________________________________________________________________ Mineralogy, Grain Size, & Texture _____________________________________________________________ Bedding __________________________________________________________________________________ Fractures _________________________________________________________________________________ Size Range of Pieces ________________________________________________________________________ Hardness __________________________________________________________________________________ Weathering ________________________________________________________________________________ Additional Comments _______________________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________________________________________ Page x of y
EB 06-039 A-2