Acoustics
Acoustics
Introduction ......................................................................... 2 Behaviour of Sound in a Room ............................... 3-4 Build-up and Decay of Sound in a Room ............... 5-6 Sabine's Formula for Reverberation Time ............. 7 Measuring the Reverberation Time ................... 8-10 Measuring the Sound Absorption .......................... 11-13 Measuring the Sound Distribution ......................... 14-15 Speech Intelligibility ......................................................... 16 How is Speech Intelligibility Quantified? .................... 17 Rapid Speech Transmission Index (RASTI) ....... 18-19 Real-Time Analysis in Room Acoustics ............. 20-21 Acoustics of Buildings. What Should be Measured? ........................................ 22 Sound Reduction Index of a Wall .................................... 23
What is the Coincidence Effect? ........................... 24-25 Laboratory and Field Measurements ............................. 26 Airborne Sound Insulation .......................................... 27 Measuring Airborne Sound Insulation .................. 28-29 Impact Sound Insulation ................................................. 30 Measuring Impact Sound Insulation .............................. 31 Outdoor - Indoor Noise Insulation ..................... 32-33 Insulation between Offices Influence of Background Noise .................................................... 33 Comparing Results with Requirements (R'w, L'n,w).. 34 Vibration Measurements ................................................. 35 Survey of Building Acoustic Measurements (ISO) ............................................ 36-43 Further Reading ............................................................... 44
January 1988
Introduction
The influence of acoustics on the design of buildings can be observed through the ages from Roman amphitheatres to the modern houses or buildings in which we spend our working hours and our leisure. The great difference, however, between life in ancient Rome and life in our crowded modern cities is the presence of noise from an ever increasing number of sources, from neighbours, traffic and industry. Consequently, the science of building acoustics is no longer limited to the acoustic design of theatres, but has increased in scope to cover noise control and abatement in all types of buildings.
Absorption of Sound
We can understand the effect of absorption by measuring, at a given position in a room, the sound pressure level caused by a steady sound power source. Instead of rising indefinitely as an increasing number of reflections arrive at the measuring position, the sound pressure level soon stabilizes. This must mean that the rate of energy input is exactly compensated by the rate at which the energy is absorbed by the different surfaces of the room. If more absorption material is put in the room, the sound pressure level is less because the energy in the reflections is reduced. Typical absorbing surfaces in a room include carpets and curtains. These are simple porous absorbers which absorb sound energy by restricting the movement of air particles, the frictional forces causing the dissipation of energy as heat. Porous absorbers are most effective when placed at a point on the sound-wave which has maximum particle velocity. This position is a quarter wavelength away from a reflecting surface (when a wave is incident at right-angles) and is therefore frequency depedent. A carpet is an example of a porous absorber close to a reflective boundary. It absorbs best at high frequencies because the dimensions of the quarter wavelengths are then comparable with the thickness of carpet. Other surfaces in the room absorb different frequencies to different extents, and by controlling the proportions of these absorbers it is possible to adjust the warmth of a room for music, or its clarity for speech.
4
Importance of Reverberation Time in the Design of Rooms and Auditoria In a room with highly reflecting surfaces, such as a bathroom, the reverberation time is relatively long, while in an anechoic chamber where all the walls, the ceiling and the floor are covered by a highly absorbent material, the reverberation time is nearly zero. The absorption of different materials varies widely with the frequency of the incident sound and the angle of incidence. It follows that the reverberation time is liable to vary with frequency. Generally, the reverberation time is longer at lower frequencies because these are usually less effectively absorbed than higher frequencies. It is important that the reverberation time suits the intended use of the room. Too long a reverberation time renders speech less intelligible and music more cacophonous and produces higher background noise levels. A short reverberation time deadens background noise, but muffles speech and makes music sound "thin" and staccato.
The Receiver A typical receiving section may consist of a sound level meter fitted with an octave or a 1/3 octave filter set and a portable level recorder. A filter centred on the same frequency as the filter in the transmitting section reduces the influence of background noise. Since reverberation decreases in an exponential manner and is recorded on a logarithmic scale, the decay will be a straight line on the recording paper. The reverberation time result (for a given frequency band) is estimated directly from the recording. The jagged appearance of the decays at low frequencies is due to the uneven distribution of the normal room modes at these frequencies. When the pulse method of noise transmission is used, the graphical results represent the Impulse Response of the room and the reverberation time cannot be obtained directly from the decay. By using the appropriate software, it is possible to calculate reverberation time results from the impulse response. An advantage of the pulse (or Schroeder) method is that accurate and reproducible results are obtained faster than with the "cut-off" method.
Using a Building Acoustics Analyzer A Building Acoustics Analyzer is an instrument containing both the transmitting and the receiving sections. It supplies random noise in 1/3 octave bands to a power amplifier and a loudspeaker, analyzes the microphone signal through a second set of 1/3 octave band filters, and calculates the reverberation time for each frequency band. Position of the Source and the Receiving Microphone Due to room modes and echoes, the reverberation time of a room depends on the position of the source and the receiving microphone. In some cases the position of the source is obvious (e.g. the rostrum in a lecture theatre). To avoid exciting only some of the normal modes of the room, the sound-source is usually placed in a corner where every mode has a pressure maximum. The receiving microphone should be placed at several positions in large rooms and auditoria because the reverberation time can vary from place to place. If required, the measured times should then be averaged for each frequency band by one of the following methods: (a) a single microphone moved from place to place; (b) several microphones scanned by a multiplexer; (c) a single microphone on a rotating boom.
10
11
Measuring the Change of Reverberation Time "in situ" A similar method can be used in practical situations when determining the amount of absorbent material necessary to obtain a suitable reverberation time in a room. From the absorption coefficient, , calculated from measurement in a reverberation chamber, one calculates the area of absorbent necessary to produce a required change in reverberation time in a particular room. The absorbent material is installed, the reverberation time is measured in the actual room and, if necessary, adjusted by adding or subtracting some of the absorbent material. Standing Wave Method In this method a loudspeaker is used to produce standing waves in a tube terminated by the sample to be investigated. By measuring the ratio between the maximum and minimum sound pressures by means of a probe microphone moved along the axis of the tube, the absorption coefficient can be calculated. The advantage of the method is that it only requires small samples of material, gives reproducible results and yields a direct scale reading for the value of a. The disadvantages of the method are that is obtained for normal incidence only and that the method can only be used where the sample is representative of the material.
12
Tone Burst Method This method enables the absorption coefficient of a material to be determined for various angles of incidence of sound energy. No special reverberation room is required for this test. A short tone burst is emitted from a loudspeaker into the room at a distance x from the receiving microphone. The loudspeaker is then aimed at the test speciment at an angle of incidence, , such that the total path length for the reflected sound is the same as in the first case. By comparing the sound pressure level, Lp,r, of the reflected sound to the sound pressure level, Lp,d of the direct sound, the reflection coefficient can be calculated and the absorption coefficient determined from: ,f = 1 - r,f
where
13
14
Measurements on Models Before the construction of a costly new theatre or auditorium, it can be economically advantageous to investigate the acoustics of the new design in a scaled-down model. Provided certain precautions are taken, model techniques can be used to investigate amongst other things, reverberation time, speech intelligibility and sound distribution. The frequency of excitation of the source should be increased by the same factor as that by which the model has been scaled down. This may be achieved in three ways: (a) By using a signal generator capable of producing noise at the higher frequencies required in the model; (b) By recording audio range excitation noise on a tape recorder and playing back the signal in the model room at a correspondingly higher speed; (c) By using a sound-source which has a frequency spectrum including relatively high frequencies e.g. an electrical spark or an ultrasonic whistle. At these high frequencies, both the transmitting and receiving transducers should be of small dimensions to avoid disturbing the sound-field. Small condenser microphones can be driven as transmitters, the advantage being the stability of their frequency response, which can extend up to 140kHz. The signal at the receiving position in the model is then recorded at high speed on a tape recorder. For analysis, the tape is played back at low speed, which brings the recorded signal into the audio frequency range.
15
Speech Intelligibility
Speech transmitted across a room by a person or a public address system is never received at a listening position as an exact replica of the original signal. Not only is background noise added but the signal is also distorted by the reflective and reverberant properties of the room. Often a direct consequence of these distortions is a reduction in the intelligibility of speech. To improve intelligibility, speakers usually adapt their speech to suit the room - talking slowly in a very reverberant room, or loudly either in a highly absorbent room or one with dead-spots. However, in some situations, such as when making an announcement over a public address system, speakers cannot adjust their speech. The result is often an unintelligible announcement. By quantifying speech intelligibility and measuring it in a room, the extent to which acoustical treatment is required to solve such problems is known. Typical remedies to improve the clarity of speech include: sound reinforcement in auditoria, reduction of reverberation time in meeting rooms, prevention of echoes in large enclosures, optimisation of public address systems and attenuation of background noise.
16
17
18
Interpretation of RASTI Measurements RASTI may be related to the subjective intelligibility scale shown opposite, which has been derived by comparing the phonetically balanced word score and STI methods. Information regarding the acoustical properties of the enclosure may also be derived from the RASTI measurements by using the Modulation Transfer Function (MTF). The MTF is simply a plot of modulation-reduction factor (m) against modulation frequency (M}. If the MTF is flat then the source of interference is noise, if it has negative slope then the interference is reverberation. Examples of these two types are shown in the figure. A complicated MTF suggests that there is interference by a discrete echo. Applications of RASTI The RASTI method identifies areas of poor speech intelligibility in a room and, because it is a quick method, the results can be displayed in the form of an iso-RASTI contour plot. Public address and sound reinforcement systems can be tested, either with the source placed at the microphone position or connected electrically to the system. The method may also be used to assess the suitability of a room for the recording of speech, or determining the acoustical privacy of a room from adjoining rooms. In the latter case, a RASTI of less than 0,3 should be obtained if the transmitter were set up inside a room, with the receiver outside.
19
20
Real-Time Analysis A real-time analyzer frequency-analyzes a sound signal and displays the results on a screen in the form of a bar graph of level against frequency band. By continuously updating the screen a fluctuating picture is obtained which closely follows the changes in level within the room. This enables "real-time" tests to be made within the room for the voice or for musical instruments so that the result can be observed immediately on the screen. For example, differences in reverberation times between lower and higher frequency bands will clearly appear on the screen as different decay rates of the columns representing the instantaneous level in the different frequency bands of the spectrum. Real-time analysis is especially useful in the detection of echoes, the positioning of reflectors, measurement of reverberation time, etc. Reverberation Decays in Three Dimensions The reverberation time decay curves of a sound produced in a room may be represented as a three-dimensional amplitude-frequency-time landscape by using a real-time analyzer in conjunction with a computer and a graphics plotter. If the sound-source can be started and stopped automatically by the computer, then a large number of reverberation decays can be measured and averaged to produce a final "decay curve" for each frequency band of interest.
21
22
Wi = Sound power incident on wall Wt = Sound power transmitted through wall R = Sound Reduction Index, dB For a solid homogeneous wall the curve of the sound reduction index as function, of frequency can be divided into several regions according to which property of the wall has most influence on the sound reduction. These properties are the stiffness, resonance, mass- and coincidence-controlled regions. The damping present in the structure affects only the profile of the curve in the resonance and the coincidence regions. The Mass Law In the mass controlled region, the Sound Reduction Index increases by 6dB for each doubling in the frequency for a given mass per unit area of the wall or for each doubling of the mass per unit area (e.g. a doubling of the thickness) at a given frequency.
23
24
Double-Leafed Partition One way of moving the coincidence effect to a higher frequency range without reducing the sound insulation is to use a double-leafed partition. For a double-leafed partition, the coincidence frequency is determined by the thickness of each element, while the Sound Reduction Index is even higher than that predicted by the Mass Law for a single partition of the same mass. Moreover, it is an advantage to choose two different thicknesses for both half-elements in order to avoid both coincidence effects being situated at the same frequency. The Resonance Frequency Generally, the sound insulation of a double-leafed partition is better than that of a single wall of the same overall mass. However, at the mass-spring-mass resonance frequency (fr) of the partition, the sound insulation is not better so care must be taken to keep fr out of the frequency range of interest (i.e. below 100 Hz). Note that the resonance effect can be used advantageously when it is desired to absorb lower-frequency sound energy in a noisy/reverberant room. A thin panel is fixed at a distance d from a rigid wall and the resonance frequency of the panel is chosen in that case to fall in the frequency region where the noise has to be reduced.
25
26
27
Intensity Approach Sound intensity measurements provide an alternative approach for measuring airborne sound insulation. Intensity is a vector quantity which describes the sound energy flowing through an area. Units are W/m2. It can be measured directly by using a two-microphone probe and an intensity analyzer. Measurements in the source room are carried out in exactly the same way as previously. In the receiving room, a grid applied to the measurement surface defines the areas of interest. The average sound intensity flowing through each grid-segment can be measured directly by using a sound intensity analyzing system. The sound power emitted by each segment in the grid is simply the average sound intensity multiplied by the segment's area. Since the flow of sound intensity through any surface in the room may be examined, it is possible to measure the contribution of the various flanking and leakage transmissions towards the total power in the receiving room. In this way results can be compared with those obtained by the previous method. A significant advantage of the intensity approach is that the apparent sound reduction index of R'n for any area on the measurement grid may be found. So if a compound partition is to be studied, for example a wall containing a window, R'n may be found for both the wall material and the glass.
29
31
32
Sound Insulation of a Facade by Using Loudspeaker Noise In the absence of traffic noise or when the insulation of a facade or a facade element has to be investigated as function of the angle of incidence, a loudspeaker may be used as a sound-source. The loudspeaker emits a random noise filtered in 1/3 octave bands and the Sound Reduction Index, R is calculated for each frequency band from the difference between the sound pressure levels with and without the test specimen. The measurements may be repeated for each value of the angle of incidence, , of interest.
33
Single Figure Indices ISO 717-1982 describes a method for obtaining single figure indices from the airborne and impact sound insulation curves measured according to ISO 140. Weighted Apparent Sound Reduction Index, R'w The airborne sound insulation is characterized by an single number, R'w, which is found by shifting in steps of 1 dB the reference curve towards the measured curve until the conditions* specified in the ISO standard are satisfied. The weighted apparent sound reduction index, R'w is defined as the value of the shifted reference curve at 500 Hz. Weighted Normalized Impact Sound Pressure Level, Ln,w L'n.w is found in a similar way by shifting the reference curve towards the measured curve and is the value at 500 Hz of the shifted reference curve. If a Building Acoustics Analyzer is used to measure the sound insulation curves, the indices R'w and L'n,w can be calculated and displayed directly.
34
* The mean unfavourable deviation, , should be as large as possible but not greater than 2 dB. The max. unfavourable deviation, max, must be recorded if it exceeds 8 dB at any frequency.
Vibration Measurements
Many installations in a modern building, for example lifts and washing machines, produce both noise and vibration. Noise measurements must therefore be complemented by vibration measurements. Vibration Isolation Measurements These are carried out by using small mechanical transducers called accelerometers, which are attached to the vibrating structure. The accelerometer is connected to a preamplifier which may contain networks allowing the measurement of vibration velocity and displacement to be measured as well as acceleration. The output signal is analyzed by the same type of instrumentation as used for sound measurements. A frequency analysis of the vibration signal is often needed for determining the most appropriate means of damping the troublesome vibrations. Measuring the Loss Factor of a Partition The Loss Factor, 77, is determined from the mechanical reverberation time of a partition which is excited by a shaker driven by white noise in 1/3 octave bands. When the partition has reached a steady level of vibration, the shaker is abruptly stopped. The reverberation time for each 1/3 octave band is determined from the decay curves recorded by an accelerometer, and the Loss Factor, , calculated from: = 2,2 fT where f is the centre frequency of the 1/3 octave band and T the corresponding reverberation time.
35
Absorption coefficient
1 1 = 0,16 V ( - - ) -- S ( Ts Te)
ISO 354-1985
Reverberation room
Sound Reduction Index, R R = L1 - L2+ 10 log S A ISO 140/111-1978 Laboratory suite (specified in ISO 140/1)
Source Room Sound/ Vibration Source Non-directional loudspeakers or pistol if T > 1,5s below 1 kHz
Character of Noise Wide-band noise in oct. or 1/3 oct. bands or pistol shots. At least 40 dB above background level in all freq. bands As above or pink noise (40 dB above background level)
Measurements Rev. decays in 1/3 oct. or oct. (125Hz-4kHz) At least 3 micro. positions with 2 records for each position (4 records for pistol shots and 6 records for music breaks) Rev. times at centre freq. of 1/3 octave band series 100 Hz - 5 kHz
Measurements
Observations
Non-directional loudspeakers
Cont. freq. spectrum band-limited noise with a bandwidth of at least 1/3 octave
Loudspeaker
Sound Pressure Sound Pressure Level 1/3 oct. Level (100Hz - 3,15kHz) Rev. time several positions
37
Standardized Level Difference Airborne sound insulation between rooms DnT = L1 L2 +10 log T 0,5 ISO 140/IV-1978 or Apparent Sound Reduction Index, R' R' = L1 L2 + 10 log S A Field measurements in buildings
Standardized Level Difference DnT = Leq,1 - Leq,2 + 10 log Airborne sound insulation of facade elements and facades Sound Reduction Index Rtr = Leq,1 Leq, 2 + 10 log T 0,5 S A ISO 140/V-1978 Sound Reduction Index R = L1 L2 + 10 log 4 S cos A 38 Field measurements
Measurements
Observations
Loudspeaker
Oct. (125 Hz-2 kHz) or 1/3 oct. (100Hz - 3,15kHz) several positions or moving microphone
Evaluation of Weighted Apparent Sound Reduction Index: R'w (ISO R 717/1 1982)
Traffic noise
Fluctuating
Oct. (125 Hz - 2 kHz) or 1/3 oct. (100-3,15 kHz) Several microphones or several positions Oct. (125 Hz - 2 kHz) or 1/3 oct. (100 Hz-3,15 kHz) several positions or moving microphone
39
Normalized Impact Sound Pressure Level Laboratory suite Impact sound insulation of floors Ln = Li + 10 log A2 10 ISO 140/VI-1978 (specified in ISO 140/1)
Norm. Impact Sound Pressure Level Ln = Li + 10 log Impact sound insulation of floors A2 10
ISO 140/VII-1978
Field measurements
40
Measurements
Observations The use of oct. or 1/3 oct. shall be recorded. Evaluation of Weighted Normalized Impact Sound Pressure Level: Ln,w (ISO 717/2 1982)
Oct. (125 Hz - 2 kHz) or 1/3 oct. (100 Hz-3,15 kHz) several positions or moving microphone
Oct. (125 Hz - 2 kHz) or 1/3 oct. (100 Hz-3,15 kHz) several positions or moving microphone
As above. Evaluation of Weighted Normalized Impact Sound Pressure Level: Ln,w (ISO 717/2 1982)
41
Test Environment
ISO 140/VIII
42
Measurements
Receiving Room of Conditions measurements Measurements Oct. (125 Hz - 2 kHz) or 1/3 oct. (100 Hz-3,15 kHz) several positions or moving microphone
Observations The bandwidth used for measurements shall be stated in every graph or table
Sound Pressure Level. Background level. Rev. time Normal surface velocity
Steady,broad-band
Vibration Exciter
43
Further Reading
J. ANDERSON & T. JACOBSEN. "RASTI Measurements in St. Paul's Cathedral, London." Brel & Kjr Application Note BO 0116 -11. BREL& KJR PUBLICATIONS "Sound Intensity" Brel&Kjr Booklet BR 0476-11. "Reverberation Time fast and accurate calculations with a sound level meter." Brel&Kjr Application Note BO 0228-11. T. R. HORRALL & T. JACOBSEN. "RASTI Measurements: Demonstration of different applications." Brel&Kjr Application Note BO 0123-11. T. Q. NIELSEN. "A Powerful Combination for Building Acoustics Measurements." Brel&Kjr Application Note BO 0113-11. "Intensity Measurements in Building Acoustics." Brel&Kjr Application Note BO 0147-11.
We hope this booklet has answered many of your questions and will continue to serve as a handy reference guide. If you have other questions about measurement techniques or instrumentation, please contact one of our local representatives, or write directly to:
44