Scribd
Upload
121 views

Analysis Comparison Final

This document compares the stress analysis reports from CAESAR-II and ROHR2 software for three main steam pipes: the main steam pipe, hot reheat pipe, and cold reheat pipe. It lists the maximum induced forces and moments at the terminal point, as well as the thermal movement, as calculated by each software for each pipe. It also provides the allowable force and moment limits at the terminal point.

Uploaded by

gopaltry
Copyright
© Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
Available Formats
Download as XLSX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
121 views

Analysis Comparison Final

This document compares the stress analysis reports from CAESAR-II and ROHR2 software for three main steam pipes: the main steam pipe, hot reheat pipe, and cold reheat pipe. It lists the maximum induced forces and moments at the terminal point, as well as the thermal movement, as calculated by each software for each pipe. It also provides the allowable force and moment limits at the terminal point.

Uploaded by

gopaltry
Copyright
© Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
Available Formats
Download as XLSX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 1

COMPARISON OF CAESAR -II & ROHR2 STRESS ANALYSIS REPORTS MAIN STEAM PIPE (HAH91-LBA10)

Description Direction FX North (N) = FY Vertical (N) = MAX INDUCED FORCES FZ West (N) = AND MOMENTS AT MX NORTH (N.M) = TERMINAL POINT MY Vertical (N.M) = MZ West (N.M) = DX North (mm) = THERMAL MOVEMENT AT TERMINAL POINT DY Vertical (mm) = DZ West (mm) = Induced in CAESAR-II 0 -30112 0 0 0 0 15.915 8.404 -75.236 -26.9 Induced in ROHR2 Allowable Forces & Moments AT Terminal Point F_North Max = Not critical F_ East_Max = 65 KN M_North Max = 15 KNm M_elev Max = 10 KNm M_ East_Max = 15 KNm Allowable Forces & Moments AT Terminal Point F_North Max = 35 KN F_elev Max = No Lift F_ East_Max = 35 KN M_North Max = 40 KNm M_elev Max = 15 KNm M_ East_Max = 40 KNm Allowable Forces & Moments AT Terminal Point F_North Max = 70 KN 30455 F_elev Max = 70 KN -6 F_ East_Max = 70 KN M_North Max = 35 KNm M_elev Max = 35 KNm M_ East_Max = 35 KNm -

-36852 F_elev Max = Not critical

HOT REHEAT PIPE (HAJ31-LBB10)


Description Direction FX North (N) = FY Vertical (N) = MAX INDUCED FORCES FZ West (N) = AND MOMENTS AT MX NORTH (N.M) = TERMINAL POINT MY Vertical (N.M) = MZ West (N.M) = DX North (mm) = THERMAL MOVEMENT AT TERMINAL POINT DY Vertical (mm) = DZ West (mm) = Induced in CAESAR-II -2051 -15963 4327 0 0 0 -26.803 0 59.43 Induced in ROHR2 -

COLD REHEAT (HAJ11-LBC10)


Description Direction FX North (N) = FY Vertical (N) = MAX INDUCED FORCES FZ West (N) = AND MOMENTS AT MX NORTH (N.M) = TERMINAL POINT MY Vertical (N.M) = MZ West (N.M) = DX North (mm) = THERMAL MOVEMENT AT TERMINAL POINT DY Vertical (mm) = DZ West (mm) = Induced in CAESAR-II -113 -398 40 0 0 0 -8.903 9.572 23.11 Induced in ROHR2 -

You might also like