The Complete Recorder Care Guide
The Complete Recorder Care Guide
4
Author: Dr. Brian Blood
CONTENTS
Naming The Parts of Your Recorder Assembling Your Recorder Before Playing Your Recorder Allergic To Your Recorder? For How Long Can You Play Your Recorder Playing-In Your Recorder Looking After Your Recorder After Repair Or Extended Periods Of Non-use Your Recorder Maker Is There To Help You Dont Leave Things To The Last Minute How Long Should Your Recorder Last Have Your Recorder Serviced Regularly Cleaning And Disinfecting Your Recorder Anti-Condensation Liquids And Your Recorder The Dealer Versus The Maker Why Oil Your Recorder Water And Your Recorder Which Oil Can You Use? Should You Oil Your Recorder? Can You Fix The Problem Yourself? Recorder Servicing Re-voicing Re-tuning Sleeving General Work How To Pack Your Recorder Safely How To Send Instruments From Abroad Contact Details Appendix One - Symptoms And Solutions - Does Your Recorder Need Servicing Appendix Two - A Note About Recorder Oils Appendix Three - Glossary of Useful Terms
The numbering system assumes the player uses the left hand uppermost - i.e. left hand above the right. Note: 6a in covered for G# (D# on C instruments). 7a is covered for bottom F# (C# on C instruments)
Other woods, in particular highly decorative members of the Dalbergia species (i.e. commonly called rosewoods), do occasionally cause owners problems, for example, blistering of the lips, tenderness of the gums and reddness of regions in contact with the instrument like the chin.
If, after this, you need to play your instrument heavily (say for more than 40-60 minutes at a time) seriously consider having a second instrument to share the work load. A Dolmetsch Nova plastic recorder would be an excellent choice.
Ask your repairman or maker whether that is his or her policy before sending the instrument through the post. You may wish to read about the symptoms that indicate that your recorder may need professional servicing. This will be found at the end of this Guide.
If you have any doubts about the service your dealer will give you, consider purchasing over the Internet from the maker. This is an increasingly common event and most makers will be happy to make the exercise painless and, from your point of view, risk free. Obviously, it is important that you work with a maker on the basis that you are seriously looking for an instrument in the price range and to the quality that the maker can supply. It may be nice to look at as much stock as you can but most makers carry quite small stock and they are happier being left to choose the best instrument they have available at the time. In any case, always make sure the maker agrees to take the instrument back if it displeases you. Even if the instrument was made to special order, most 'sale of goods' regulations require that there be an approval period and that if the instrument fails to please, the purchaser can return the instrument for a full refund of the instrument's price. However, most makers will expect you to meet the cost of post and packing in both directions.
With the highest quality models, those which are not impregnated with paraffin wax, water is taken up by the block, by the other windway surfaces and by the internal bore, but the makers will treat the bore with varnish or oil and will recommend further post-purchase treatment of the bore with a mineral or vegetable oil. This will preserve the inner surfaces of the instrument as well as strengthening the tone, particularly if the oil can 'dry' or harden to a high finish.
RECORDER SERVICING
We expect to service your recorder every two or three years if use is heavy - every five years if use is light. If you believe there is a problem with your instrument but you don't know quite what it is, first contact us. Our details are given later in this guide. We service a wide range of recorders made by other makers - we provide this service for many leading musical instrument retailers in the UK If we believe the work would be better done by the original maker, and where that is still possible, we would tell you so. Dolmetsch is the world's most experienced recorder repairer. We have been making recorders since 1919 and repairing them even before that.
RE-VOICING
Re-voicing entails removing and cleaning the block and other windway surfaces and resetting the windway dimensions to the positions where they were when the recorder was made. We use chisels, knives and abrasive papers to re-cut and sharpen surface details, disinfectant and degreasing agents and detergents. In this way, the windway surfaces are 'renewed' and you would expect to get back a rejuvenated instrument.
RE-TUNING
Re-boring is the best way to correct tuning problems that are the result of bore shrinkage. This is the most common reason for tuning problems. Only the original maker's reamers can perform the necessary magic. To correct the problem by undercutting or filling holes with wax or glue may prevent the possibility of using a reamer in the future.
All recorders sent back to us for re-tuning are re-reamered with the same reamer as was used when the recorder was made - we have retained reamers going back as far as the 1920s when the company began making treble recorders under the direction of Arnold Dolmetsch himself. After re-boring or, if it is not possible because the recorder has distorted through warping (a common problem with older European boxwood instruments that have been allowed to dry out too much), individual holes can be adjusted to correct note-to-note intonation. If the problem is too severe we can, and on occasions do, replace the head, middle or bell section.
SLEEVING
Cracks are secured with wood or ivorine sleeves. Head cracks normally result from overplaying; for example, the swollen block has applied too much pressure to the surrounding head sleeve, or an over-wet head sleeve has dried too quickly and surface cracking has developed on the outer surfaces of the head section. Cracks at the sockets are often the result of careless handling. When taking a recorder apart, avoid lateral pressure on the sockets. Always twist the sections in the same direction or, if there joint has seized, apply gentle bending pressure around the joint - this manoeuvre usually releases stubborn joints. Leaving the recorder to dry thoroughly can also help!
GENERAL WORK
Re-corking, cleaning, re-varnishing are all part of day-to-day work we carry out on Dolmetsch and, for many of the UK's leading recorder dealers, other makes of recorder. We can also strip varnish of an old recorder to give it a matt finish with teak oil.
CONTACT DETAILS
Send instruments to our trading address, workshop & shop: Dolmetsch Musical Instruments Unit 1b, The Unicorn Trading Estate Weydown Road, Haslemere, Surrey GU27 1DN telephone from within UK: telephone from outside UK: fax number from within UK: fax number from outside UK: e-mail address: 01428-643235 +44-1428-643235 08700-560190 +44-8700-560190 [email protected]
Instruments sent to us by post are done so at your own risk. You should insured them.
All the most up to date information and advice you might require is available on our web site: http://www.dolmetsch.com
APPENDIX ONE SYMPTOMS AND SOLUTIONS - DOES YOUR RECORDER NEED SERVICING
It is too easy to find fault with the recorder when it may very well lie with the player. You might answer this by saying that as a recorder maker, I would say that. In fact, I am a player and a maker and, after forty years in these fields, I know that most players have a 'love-hate' relationship with their instruments, whether they play recorders, flutes or violins, and whether the instruments are inexpensive or of a professional quality. Good makers are happy to have their instruments back for servicing where there are real problems. In this article, I identify the source of the most common problems you might have with your recorder. After reading this article you should understand your instrument a little better and should gain the confidence you need to distinguish between problems arising from the player and those arising from the instrument.
g. Paetzold large square bass recorders solution: poor bottom notes on these instruments can occur if the sections are not firmly pushed together while tightening the wing nuts. If the seals are damaged go back to Paetzold or their local agent for replacements. h. The recorder is improperly voiced solution: have the recorder re-voiced. There is no reason why a mechanically sound, properly voiced recorder should not produce clear bottom notes. Some recorders do not like to be tongued aggressively on the lower register tending to jump up to the second octave or to squeak. In that situation you will need to reduce your breath pressure and tonguing strength.
discovered the correct breath pressure and can deliver this pressure every time (i.e. Securelyslurring the two notes in succession), you are ready to try tonguing the two notes in succession. Don't worry if it doesn't work the first time you try tonguing. Return to the slurred exercise, get that right, and then try the tongued exercise again. e. The recorder needs re-voicing If you are still having problems, pass your recorder to an experienced player and ask him or her to try the same exercise for you. If they can do it, then you need not worry about the recorder. If they cannot do it then your recorder may need re-voicing. Re-voicing is a serious adjustment of the block and windway settings necessary to give your recorder back its high notes. A good repairer will tell you if the recorder is worn out before doing any work - this is something we recorder makers can judge in an instrument - in which case, Dolmetsch makes no charge and returns your instrument back to you postage free. In some circumstances it can be traded in against a new recorder with a generous discount. High note problems are generally problems of player technique. However, if neither you nor any of the better players you know, is able to produce clear high notes on this instrument, send it off to a good repairman. When a recorder needs re-voicing, it is problems with high notes as well as weakness at the bottom that are commonly the first symptoms
B. Tuning Problems
First let me say a little about the use of electronic tuning meters. Recorder makers use them, so dont be shy about using them yourself. You do need, however, to understand what a meter can tell you and what it cannot. No recorder 'plays in tune'. It is the player who 'plays it in tune'. On every note on the recorder, blowing harder sharpens the pitch and blowing softer flattens the pitch. Small recorders, sopraninos and descants (sopranos), are much more sensitive to this problem than larger instruments like tenors and basses. Most makers, if they use meters at all, are concerned to set the fundamental note, the note produced with all fingers down on the instrument. The bottom note is the least flexible with respect to blowing pressure and, for this reason, the maker sets it as carefully as he can. After that, the approach divides between those who religiously check every note against the meter and those who rely on their 'ears'. The relationship between notes is highly subjective and will depend on the context of the note in the harmony of the moment. Some individuals hear intervals as they might be set on a piano (equal temperament) while others, particularly string players, are more comfortable with 'mean' or 'just' intonation which, while richer, demands greater flexibility and skill from the player. A good maker gives the player the possibility of exploiting this flexibility and so what is important is not that the recorder 'is in tune' but that it can be 'played in tune' without great changes in fingering or breath pressure. This subtlety can be lost on even very experienced professional players, so beware! You should be able to blow a note below and above the zero point on the meter - in the upper octave some adjustment of the size of the thumbhole opening produced by 'pinching' the thumb may be necessary because it too has an effect on tuning. If the flexibility is there then the control of the intonation, choosing the correct breath pressure, fingering and, in the case of the upper register, the thumbhole position is up or down to you. So, as you will now understand, an electronic meter tells you more about your playing than about the recorder. When you buy a new recorder always check that the fundamental (the lowest note the recorder will play - the note with all holes covered) can be played in tune to a meter. When the recorder is completely cold it should actually play slightly flat but when very warm it will play slightly sharp. Most recorder players adjust for sharpening as the recorder warms up by pulling the middle section tenon out of the head section socket by no more than 0.5 mm. This extension flattens the
lower octave while having a relatively small effect on the upper register. The greater the extension, the more the two octaves move apart, making the instrument increasingly more difficult to play in tune on itself. If your recorder is seriously flat then the other recorders with which you are playing should flatten their pitch down to yours because you cannot shorten your instrument to bring it up to their pitch. Generally, however, new recorders should be made to a=440 Hz, if designated 'modern pitch' or made to a=415 Hz if designated 'baroque or low pitch'. There are a number of specialist pitches used by professionals and for renaissance repertoire but these need not concern us here. The fundamental is one of the least flexible notes on the recorder, one which is relatively difficult to blow up or down in pitch. If you blow harder the note tends to squeak or jump to the next octave; if you blow too weakly the note sounds starved. Because all the fingers are down, there is no alternative fingering; this note must be naturally 'to pitch' from the start. We are going to assume therefore that your recorder is 'in tune' after about 15 minutes of playing and that whatever tuning problems you are having relate to odd individual notes elsewhere on the instrument. We discuss F recorders below: the equivalent fingerings on C recorders may need similar adjustment. I would like to make one last comment about tuning flaws on larger recorders. The bores of tenor, bass and even larger instruments are wide enough so that extraneous items can wedge themselves inside the instrument - grease pots, cleaning mops and fingering charts are all known culprits and make the instrument, if it produces any note at all, seem out of tune. It will save you a lot of embarrassment and wasted time if you check that the recorder's bore is free of any obstruction. There is a second problems particularly with plastic recorders. If the grease provided with the instrument is applied too generously to the joints it may get into some of the finger holes where it can effect the tuning of individual notes. The main problem with joint grease is that it tends to be translucent so can be quite difficult to spot when it lies in the smaller double finger holes.
narrowed by flattening the third, while minor thirds need to be widened by sharpening the third. In the eighteenth century, players published sets of enharmonic fingering where E flat and D sharp were fingered slightly differently to make the former slightly sharper and the latter slightly flatter. On equi-tempered instruments (keyboard instruments in particular) we set the two notes to be identical but this is only true when the scale is divided so that the ratio of the frequencies of successive notes in a chromatic scale is constant through the scale. That constant is the twelfth root of two. If you multiply the twelfth root of two by itself twelve times you get two which is the ratio of the frequencies of two notes, one octave apart, the high over the lower. This having been said, it is possible for sharpness in certain parts of the instrument, e.g. sharpness of the higher notes relative to the lower notes, to be the result of bore shrinkage. Here only the re-reamering of the bore by the original maker will cure the problem - but cure the problem it will!
assist them, this is a profitable way of extending the instrument's literature. One should never assume, however, that what is proposed by a composer is an intrinsic property of the recorder itself. It may just be an accident of the instrument with which he or she haspersonal experience. If you are minded to carry out advanced study that requires an instrument that can perform all these special effects you must be patient in your search for a suitable instrument. So far as I am aware no recorder maker maintains a production line dedicated to the production of accidents!
C. Mechanical Problems
Fifth: To find the best place for the thumb rest we recommend placing the instrument on it's side on the floor. Bending over, pick it up with the fingers of the right hand on the appropriate holes used during performance and if you lift it up successfully, you will have placed the right hand thumb in the correct position on the back of the instrument.
C. Is It Me?
In 80% of the cases where a player is having problems with a recorder, the problem lies with the player - sad but true - but if you are certain there is a problem with your recorder contact the maker or send it back for advice and reassurance.
If you want to learn more about the finer details of recorder playing why not look at our recorder lessons online web pages for descant/soprano in C, treble/alto in F and bass recorder in F.
Raw linseed oil is oil pressed from flax seeds. It is also sold as "flax oil," especially if you buy it in food grade at the local health food store. It really is a nasty tasting cooking oil, but an effective laxative. Even if you sit a pot of it on the stove and try to boil it, it will still be "raw" linseed oil. I usually soak woodwind instruments in raw linseed oil before final finishing. Most nut oils, including raw linseed oil are very slow drying (if they dry at all) and will get "gunky" if left on the surface of the wood. Oils that don't dry are termed "non-drying oils" (surprise, surprise!) Almond oil, linseed oil, walnut oil, peanut oil, cashew oil, olive oil, grape seed oil, sunflower seed oil, rape seed oil, etc. are all non-drying oils. They are all edible to humans, so they are all edible to other forms of earth life, including bacteria and fungi. They can go rancid (stinky) and also grow mould. A little vitamin E will keep this from happening. I was surprised the other day to find a bottle of food grade almond oil (Hain brand) that looked clean, smelt clean, and even had the vitamin E already added. Again, non-drying oils should be wiped away as much as possible after oiling the bore: any oil left on the surface is going to do the gunky rancid thing (sounds like a new dance!). Their job is to replenish the little bit of the wood's own oils that get carried out of the instrument each time you wipe the bore, or leave it in a hot place, or run detergent (Dupanol, etc.) through it. Throughout most of history, musical instruments were not oiled. Then again, throughout most of history, instruments were not manufactured in Germany in the winter, placed on an aeroplane, taken up to near vacuum at 35,000 feet (10 km), and delivered 10 hours later to the desert of California or the swamps of Florida. (OK, perhaps these examples are a bit extreme). Oiling the wood makes it harder for water to get in or out of the wood. It doesn't stop moisture gains or losses entirely, but it does provide a bit of a "vapour barrier" and reduces the odds of an instrument warping or cracking, or even raising the bore grain. These things happen when wood in some part of the instrument gets more moisture than that elsewhere, and by expanding more, creates internal stresses. At the microscopic level, stress breaks wood fibres, and loosens the bonds between fibres, so the wood gets softer, and the grain of the bore gets rougher, and the instrument gets "played out." A large stress leads to the more visible cracking and warping. Personally, I don't like cracking, warping, or raised grain. Boiled linseed oil is raw linseed oil with some chemicals added. These chemicals are called "dryers" or "polymerisers." What they do is let the small hydrocarbon molecules in the oil join together to form long chain molecules, called "polymers," which are essentially plastics or lacquers. (Don't worry, good woods are largely lignin, another natural polymer "plastic"). Any oils that turn into natural lacquer are called "drying oils" or "self polymerising oils" or sometimes "boiled" oils. In the good old days (back when they would put toxic mercury in your teeth!) lead oxide was the dryer. It had to be heated into the oil (hence the term "boiled"). There are a lot of modern ways of polymerising linseed oil. Nitric acid will do it, and can stain the wood
2007 Dolmetsch Musical Instruments, Haslemere, Surrey, England Page 21
at the same time if you add a little metal (reddish brown for iron, reddish green for copper, blue black for silver). Cyanoacrylate (CA, super glue) will polymerise linseed oil (and several other oils that are normally not considered "drying" oils, so you can make almond oil lacquer with it!). Methylenemythacrylate will also work. That's enough long chemical names. Tung oil is an oil (I have no idea from what plant, but there is a botanist on this list) that is naturally self polymerising. Drying oils, lacquers, shellac, and common "wood sealers" do something much different from just replacing oil. They alter the bore, sometimes substantially. Something that soaks in a bit and then dries can stiffen the wood. A surface finish gives you a smoother finish. There are limits to how smooth a natural finish you can put on wood (especially maple and pear) due to the grain of the wood. Lacquer can give a maple bore the glassy smoothness of ebony or grenadilla or fine plastic). A sufficiently smooth, stiff, penetrating finish can turn any wood into the equivalent of ABS. These finishes also form a "vapour barrier" at the surface of the wood. "Bore oil" that you buy at the local music store in little bottles is an entirely different story. It's often mineral oil or petroleum oil and has a number of interesting characteristics. First, it's biologically incompatible (except for special bacteria genetically engineered to clean up oil spills) so it does not go rancid. Second, it dries much slower, and is much more immune to natural and man-made detergents, so it stays in the bore much longer. Third, it's a very effective vapour barrier. But it's not as compatible with wood as the nut oils, and it's difficult to clean out of the bore (keeps building up in waxy layers). Personally, I avoid it. Clarinet and oboe players swear by this kind of oil, but then again, these are the same people who take Grenadilla (African Blackwood) which is absolutely beautiful with long streaks of browns, reds, and blacks, and stain it jet black (and lacquer the outside of the instrument) so it looks like plastic. Forgot one important note: the drying oils such as boiled linseed oil or Tung oil contain chemicals that make oils turn into plastic. I seem to recall reading that, if you take these oils internally (or even get them on your skin) before they dry, they can also polymerise your body's skin oils or fat, which is not a pleasant thing, sort of like being cooked from the inside. Again, that's only the boiled oils, and only before they're cured. After the finish has dried, they're harmless.
Fipple: From Webster's Revised Unabridged Dictionary (1913): Fipple \Fip"ple\ (f[~e]r), n. [perh. fr. L. fibula a clasp, a pin; cf. Prov. E. fible a stick used to stir pottage.] A stopper, as in a wind instrument of music. [Obs.] --Bacon. Professor Stanley V. McDaniel comments: Both the Century Dictionary (1898), a rich mine of etymology, and the Oxford English dictionary state that the origin is obscure, but the Oxford asserts that fipple is probably related to Icelandic _flipi_ "the lip of a horse." The word fipple in Engl. dialect refers to "the under lip" and "to fipple" means to look dejected by protruding the under lip. The use of the term for the recorder's block seems to come from an analogy with the flute, where the under lip provides the same narrowing of the windway as the block does in the recorder, i.e. it is the underside of the wind passage. The Century Dictionary provides a quote stating this very idea. So I think it's unlikely that the word derived from "fibula." To go a bit further, note the possible relation between the word "lip" and "flipi." "lip" is related to Middle Swedish lippa and similar forms lippe, lyppe, etc. from a presumed Old Teutonic root lep-. Frequently in word migration a reversal of consonants can occur, and also duplication. It's possible that from "lippe" came a form "plippe" softened to "flipi" as in the Icelandic. What is interesting about the possible relation between fipple and lip is that "lip" variants often refer only to the lower lip, but also by extension they refer in general to the rim of an opening. Thus the fipple, or lip, of a recorder may be thought of as the rim of the windway, which is produced in its lower part by the block, and which takes the place of the lips themselves as the windway for a transverse flute. Dan Chernick adds: I just can't resist an OED request! According to my "Compact Edition of the Oxford English Dictionary" (I'm paraphrasing it): Fipple [Compare to Icelandic(?) "flipi" - lip of a horse] 1. The plug at the mouth of a wind-instrument, by which its volume was contracted. First occurrence in English print: was in 1626 by Bacon in "Sylva": "Let there be a Recorder made with two Fipples, at each end one." 2. (In the northern dialect) The under lip in men and animals, when it hangs down large and loose. The expression "to hang a Fipple" means "to look disappointed, discontented, sulky; also, to weep". A second entry for Fipple says it means "to whimper, whine; to slaver, dribble" from the Swedish "flipa", "to weep with distortion of the mouth". Anyone know what Bacon was talking about -- a recorder with a fipple at each end????
Flautino: usually taken to mean sopranino recorder. Fourth flute: a soprano/descant recorder in B flat. Garklein fltlein: C recorder written in the treble clef, sounding two octaves higher. German fingering: a modern and discredited system in which four fingers down gives F. Still used, principally in Germany and Holland. Avoid it like the plague! Great Bass: C recorder written in the bass clef sounding an octave higher. Hertz: 19th century German physicist whose name is used as a unit of frequency. 1 Hertz, written 1 Hz, is one cycle per second Historic baroque fingering: A variant of the usual fingering.
Knick: German for fold : something sharply bent : (the right hand head is as seen on a standard tenor recorder; the left hand head has the characteristic bend of the knick system designed to shorten the distance from the mouthpiece to the tone holes on the body and foot sections)
Labium: the cutting edge part of the sound generator. Recorder: From Webster's Revised Unabridged Dictionary (1913) : Recorder \Re*cord"er\ (r?*k?rd"?r), n. (Mus.) A kind of wind instrument resembling the flageolet. [Obs.] Flutes and soft recorders.'' --Milton. From WordNet (r) 1.6 : recorder a woodwind with a vertical pipe and 8 finger holes and a whistle mouthpiece [syn: fipple flute, fipple pipe, vertical flute] [Middle English, partly from Anglo-French recordour, Old French recordeur; partly from record (in obsolete sense practise a tune)] Renaissance recorders: These are based on early originals, usually fingered as modern instruments, but models with authentic fingering are available from some makers. The bore is much wider than that of a baroque instrument and tapers less. The compass is usually a twelfth.
Sixth flute: a descant/soprano recorder in D, popular in 18th century England. Soprano: C recorder, the international word for descant recorder - also called a fifth flute. Sopranino: F recorder written in the treble clef, sounding one octave higher. Sub-Bass: also "Sub-Contra-Bass", F recorder written in the bass clef, sounding at written pitch. Tenor: C recorder written in the treble clef, sounding at written pitch. Tone Hole: alternative term for finger hole. Traverso: baroque flute, or, transverse flute. Treble: F recorder, written in the treble clef, sounding at written pitch. The English word for Alto. Voice Flute: D recorder, tenor sized. Window: the area between the exit from the windway and the top of the ramp that forms the top of the labium. Windway: the narrow slot through which the breath passes.