Scribd
Upload
61 views2 pages

Writing Reflection Kite Runner

The student wrote a reflection on a theme essay about the book "The Kite Runner." In the reflection, the student identified their strengths as writing clear topic sentences and inserting relevant quotes. However, they noted that explanations of the quotes' significance needed improvement. The student felt the outline structure ("loop cycle") helped organize their paper. They rated themselves as strong in topic sentences and quote incorporation, but weak in explanations and concluding relevance. Based on this feedback, the student's new goal is to more directly connect explanations to the topic sentence instead of overly describing the story. They want to focus on quality over quantity.

Uploaded by

api-285764024
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
61 views2 pages

Writing Reflection Kite Runner

The student wrote a reflection on a theme essay about the book "The Kite Runner." In the reflection, the student identified their strengths as writing clear topic sentences and inserting relevant quotes. However, they noted that explanations of the quotes' significance needed improvement. The student felt the outline structure ("loop cycle") helped organize their paper. They rated themselves as strong in topic sentences and quote incorporation, but weak in explanations and concluding relevance. Based on this feedback, the student's new goal is to more directly connect explanations to the topic sentence instead of overly describing the story. They want to focus on quality over quantity.

Uploaded by

api-285764024
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 2

WRITING REFLECTION # ___2___

Mrs. Cracchiolo (2014-2015)


_The Kite Runner Theme Essay_
Out of class writing
1. Looking at the feedback, what/where do you think you did particularly well?
I think I did well writing my topic sentences and inserting quotes that relate to the topic
sentence.
I also did well in the organization of the paper and staying on topic.
2. Looking at the feedback, what do you think was the area you need the most
improvement in and why? (Be Specific)
I need to improve on further explaining my quotes and how they relate the main ideas.
After putting in quotes my explanations would be very weak and only wordy.
3. Did the loop cycle work for you? Why or why not?
It did because its what I used for all my main body paragraphs. I followed the steps and
it helped me layout my paper to be organized and not off topic.
4. Body paragraph construction is the most important part of your paper since this is the
area that uses evidence to back up your claims. Looking at your paper and feedback,
rate yourself overall on the following elements that correspond to the loop structure.
STRONG
AVERAGE
WEAK
MISSING
Topic Sentences

___X__

_______

_______

________
Supporting Details (SD)

___X__

_______

_______

________
Explanations (EXP)

______

_______

___X___

________
Closings (CLOS)
________
Transitions
________
Incorporating Quotes

______
______

___X___
___X___

_______
_______

__X___

_______

_______

______

___X___

_______

_______

_______

________
Set up quotes
________
Used quote and documenting properly __X__
________

Explain relevance

______

_______

___X___

________
Concluding sentences
________
OVERALL RATING
________

______
______

___X___
___X___

_______
_______

5. The big question: based on your comments, checklist where you rated yourself on body
paragraph structure, and overall score, what NEW GOAL do you have for your next
writing assignment? In other words, what skills will you try to focus on in the future and
why?

GOAL:
My new goal would be to not be too wordy on explaining what happens in the story but to
correlate it towards the topic sentence.
WHY:
I tend to try to make my papers worthy just to fill in the page requirement, but that only
makes my paper longer and not better.
6. Any other feedback youd like to share??
The Kite Runner was an excellent book that I wish I had paid more attention to towards the
middle. Maybe if I did my paper could have been a better written.

You might also like