HAYDARIA 4xGE Fr.

9E GPP / CANTEEN BUILDING STRUCTURAL COMMENTS REVIEW

MOE review transmital no. 150,151
ENKA response
MOE response
status
To keep the same sum of steel area for both ground floor & slab Chosen reinforcement RC areas are quite enough to
1. Use 10@200 both directions for ground floor,
2. open
reinforcement ; Change reinforcement of ground floor from meet the internal forces arising from the considered
Use 12@150 T&B for slabr,
3.
12@200 mm both directions to 10@200 mm both directions And loads. RC calculation of slabs is done as per bending
Change reinforcement of slab top reinforcement of
change slab reinforcement from 12@200 T&B both directions to moments of most critical slabs (S110S112) and bar
14@200 to 16@200 in some areas.
12@150 mm T&B both directions , - Change reinforcement of slab areas are chosen almost 1,50 2,00 times greater than
top reinforcement of 14@200 to 16@200 in some areas.
required and applied to all slabs. If spacing of RC bars
are decreased as commented capactiy ratios will be
more than 2,00 times.

TBC Remarks (24 Apr 2013)

With reference to our previous response, the
present design provides capacity ratios that
are more than adequate. We do not
understand your request to further increase
the reinforcement quantity. Please provide the
technical reasoning behind this request.

- Change reinforcement of beams B105 , B139 , B142 , B145 , RC design of most critical beams of building is done as
Use 2 layers of 6 25 , first layer consist of 4 25 while
B149 , B154 , B157 , B160 , B165 , B169 , B170 , from 4 25 T&B to per maximum bending moment of sways (to prevent to the second layer consist of 2 25
6 25 T&B
use any additional bar) and chosen bar areas for top and
bottom sections are almost 1,50 2,00 times greater
than required. Chosen number of reinforcement bars,
minimum 6,67 cm clear space is provided between
longitudinal bars to allow reliable concrete pouring
during site work If number of longitudinal bars are
increased to 6 instead of 4 clear space between bars will
be only 3 cm and there will be no gap at overlapping
sections.So it will be a must to put bars at 2 layers to be
able to pour concrete. Finally we would like to inform you
that there is no technical reason to increase number of
bars from 4 to 6 which will cause concrete pouring
problems during site work.

open

With reference to our previous response, the

present design provides capacity ratios that
are more than adequate. We do not
understand your request to further increase
the reinforcement quantity. Please provide the
technical reasoning behind this request.

- Change reinforcement of link beams from 3 16 T&B to 416 Average capacity ratio of link beams for chosen RC bars Use 416 T&B
T&B
is almost 60%. So chosen RC areas are quite enough to
meet forces. Clear space between bars is almost 9 cm
and enough for reliable pouring concrete. By increasing
number of bars, capacity ratio will decrease to almost
40%. Decreasing the clear space between bars from 9
cm to 5,5 cm causes difficulty during the concrete
pouring.

open

OK. Your request will be complied although it

is not technically required. Please close this
comment.

MOE review transmital no. 240,241,242

HAYDARIA 4xGE Fr.9E GPP / ELECTRICAL CONTROL BUILDING STRUCTURAL COMMENTS REVIEW
MOE review transmital no. 313
ENKA response (transmital 332)
MOE response

ENKA
MOE review transmital no. 281,282,283
response

Add structural supporting element to the

landing of the main stair case, structural
calculations is needed.

no

Add structural supporting element to all

landing of the main stair at each level (such
as bearing wall,beams, etc).

no

1. Add structuralsupporting element to for

landing of the main stair at ground level. &
Specify the suggested supporting element
under landing of main stair at axis 3 as
shown in section D.

OK. We will add steel supporting frames to waiting

the inquired landing of ground level as
well.
& A dedicated Steel Detail
Drawing will be issued which includes
such details.

Add water proof protection layers for RC

basement wall with protection brick wall.

no

Add water proof protection layers for RC

basement wall with protection brick wall.

no

Add water proof protection layers for RC

basement wall with protection brick wall.

Add drain pit at basement level with

reinforcement details.

no

Add drain pit at basement level with

reinforcement details.

Water stop is used at water proof

structures such as water tanks or any
other kind of structure that contains
liquids where there will be severe effect of
liquid and may results leakage problems.
Here, we would like to inform you that we
will use asphalt bitumen at all outlet
surface of walls and raft foundation
remain below ground level to protect
concrete against environmental conditions

Top reinforcement of slab panels (with

stair openings) of <1>12mm@l00 should
be continuous from support to support in
both directions.

done

Add water stop in walls of basement at kicker

& around openings in RC basement wall, or
specified the method of watersealant.

done

no

Add water stop in walls of basement at kicker

& around openings in RC basement wall, or
specified the method of watersealant.

Add water stop in

walls of basement
at kicker & around
openings in RC
basement wall, or
specified the
method of
watersealant.

ENKA response (transmital 350)

status

TBC Remarks (24 Apr 2013)

open

This comment should be closed. A separate

drawing was issued for stairway support
frame structure (see dwg. No. HPP-TBC-C90-ECB-2890, submittal no. 407.)

Your comment is not clearly understood.

Please provide explanation with a sketch.
As stated in our previous letter we would like
to repeat that;
Water stop is used at water
proof structures such as water tanks or any
other kind of structure that contains liquids
where there will be severe effect of liquid and
may result leakage problems. Here, we would
like to inform you that we will use asphalt
bitumen at all outlet surface of walls and raft
foundation remaining below ground level to
protect concrete against environmental
conditions.

Therefore, we do not see any technical

necessity for use of water stops with this
structure. We kindly request removal of this
comment or provision of further clarification
on other technical reasons for use of water
stops.

open

Drain pit is already added. Please refer to

the latest revisions of Electrical & Control
Building architectural and structural
drawings (submittal no. 263, 281, 385).
Please close this comment.

A general note for provision of water stops

is already added to the drawings. Please
close this comment.

MOE review transmital no. 273 -- 276

1.
For part 3, omitted expansion joint between
exterior stair and slab at level +4.15.

HAYDARIA 4xGE Fr.9E GPP / ADMINISTRATION BUILDING STRUCTURAL COMMENTS REVIEW

ENKA response
MOE response
MOE review transmital no. 390-393
closed
1, 2.c There is no stability problem of exterior stair as shown in
O.K. we will wait your revised drawings
attached calculation sheet. The safety factor against overturning is as soon as possible
9,11 at windy conditions where it is 2,71 for earthquake condition.
So,
we would like to inform you that we will keep expansion
joint between building and exterior stair to prevent any damages
at joint such as cracks may be occurred due to differential
settlements.

status
closed

CLOSED

TBC Remarks (24 Apr 2013)

O.K. we will wait your revised drawings

as soon as possible

closed

closed

CLOSED

O.K. we will wait your revised drawings

as soon as possible

closed

closed

CLOSED

O.K. we will wait your revised drawings

as soon as possible

closed

closed

CLOSED

c. Merge foundation of exterior stair with adjacent

strip foundation of building for stability purposes.

1, 2.c There is no stability problem of exterior stair as shown in

O.K. we will wait your revised drawings
attached calculation sheet. The safety factor against overturning is as soon as possible
9,11 at windy conditions where it is 2,71 for earthquake condition.
So,
we would like to inform you that we will keep expansion
joint between building and exterior stair to prevent any damages
at joint such as cracks may be occurred due to differential
settlements.

closed

closed

CLOSED

3.
Use 4-16mm bar diameter for link beams to
ensure minimum reinforcement area requirements.

For most critical Link Beam; Asrequired = 4,17 cm2 Asminimum O.K. we will wait your revised drawings
= 5,54 cm2
(As per ACI 10.5.3) Asused =
6,03 cm2
as soon as possible
(3 no 16 mm steel bar) As seen above used 3 no 16 mm steel
bar is quite enough to meet both Asrequired and Asminimum.
Although we will like to inform you that we will increase number of
bars as 4 instead of 3 as you inquired in your letter for extra safety.

closed

closed

CLOSED

. For slab panelat interior stair(part 2):

open

2.

For exterior stair:

a. Extend cantilever beam from RC wall to support each 2.a

landing.

OK we will add RC beams to the landings

b. Stair reinforcement in short direction should be

2.b OK we will revise reinforcement put at short direction (steel
developed by 90 standard hook in RC wall (i.e. one side mark 6) as you inquired.
leg of steel mark 6 should be at least 75cm).

4.

For slab panel at interior stair:

O.K. we will wait your revised drawings

as soon as possible

a. Check slab thickness for deflection control.

4.a,b,d We will add steel frame members to the landings to limit

deflection and provide extra safety.

O.K. we will wait your revised drawings

as soon as possible

open

b. Add supporting members at intermediate landing of

interior stair.

4.a,b,d We will add steel frame members to the landings to limit

deflection and provide extra safety.

O.K. we will wait your revised drawings It is suggested to support he cantilever

as soon as possible
slab by adding inclined {hypotenuse) RC
beam or provide us with the details of
steel frame supporting slab panel.{drawing
no. C-18060)

open

c. Check design of beams B1062, B2062, B1044 and

B2044 for combined effect of shear and torsion. d. It is
suggested to support the cantilever slab by adding
inclined (hypotenuse) RC beam.

4.c
Attached please find calculation sheets of regarding beams O.K. we will wait your revised drawings
to be sure of design.
as soon as possible

closed

closed

A new drawing will be prepared and

submitted. Please close this comment.

CLOSED

d. it is suggesred to support the cantiliver slab by adding 4.a,b,d We will add steel frame members to the landings to limit
inclined ( hypotenuse )RC beam
deflection and provide extra safety.

O.K. we will wait your revised drawings

as soon as possible

Provide us with the details of steel

frame supporting square landing of
stair. (drawing no. C-18060).

open

5.
Width for foundation of interior stair should be
increased to be 1.0 m and to be at the same level of
strip foundation (DWG. C-18025).

OK. Will be revised accordingly.

O.K. we will wait your revised drawings

as soon as possible

closed

closed

CLOSED

6.
Give a suitable detail for all expansion joints in
slab at roof with 2 parapets and cap to prevent leakage
of rain water.

OK. We will add dedicated detail for parapets to the drawings.

O.K. we will wait your revised drawings

as soon as possible

closed

closed

CLOSED

7.
Add detail for expansion joint between part 3 and 4 OK. We will add dedicated detail for this part.
to prevent leakage of rain water (DWG.C-18032)

O.K. we will wait your revised drawings

as soon as possible

closed

closed

CLOSED

8.

O.K. we will wait your revised drawings Add tread reinforcement of bar lOmm
as soon as possible
each 30 em for both exterior and interior
stair. (drawing no.C-18063 and C-18064).

Add tread reinforcement of bar 10 mm each 30 cm. Please clarify to which type of structural members you want to add
thread reinforcement bars?

open

A new drawing will be prepared and

submitted. Please close this comment.

Your comment is not clearly understood.

Please provide explanation with a sketch.

MOE review transmital no. 273 -- 276

ENKA response

HAYDARIA 4xGE Fr.9E GPP / ADMINISTRATION BUILDING STRUCTURAL COMMENTS REVIEW

MOE response
MOE review transmital no. 390-393
Change reinforcement of SB01and Sb02 to
be 416 T&B + stirrups of 10@150 + side
bars of 212 (drawing no. C-18063 and C18064).

status
open

TBC Remarks (24 Apr 2013)

Your comment is not clearly understood.
Please provide explanation with a sketch.

MOE review transmital no. 225-227

ENKA response

HAYDARIA 4xGE Fr.9E GPP / SINGLE ROOMS BUILDING STRUCTURAL COMMENTS REVIEW
MOE response
MOE review transmital no.
314-316

Change longitudinal reinf. of link and slab

According to ACI 318 10.5.1 and 10.5.2, minimum
beams from 316 T&B to 416 T&B to ensure flexural R.C. of beams is calculated as per formula
minimum reinforcement ratio.
given below:

Show stair foundation in general foundation

plan

status

TBC Remarks (24 Apr 2013)

closed

closed

CLOSED

0,0034 x bw x d
But this value need not be applied if as provided it is at
least one-third greater than required area by analysis
(see 10.5.3).

closed
closed

closed
closed

CLOSED
CLOSED

316 bars are used only at beams B201...B240 where

moment rebar is calculated as 4,049 cm2 and
minimum R.C. is 1,33 x 4,049 = 5,39 cm2.

closed

closed

CLOSED

So, 316 (6,03 cm2) is greater than both required area

of analysis and minimum required area.

closed

closed

CLOSED

However, in spite of the above given technical

justification, we will increase number of bars from 3
to 4 at related beams as required by MOE.

closed

closed

CLOSED

Confirmed. We will show stair foundation at general

foundation plan

o.k

Show stair foundation in

general foundation plan

Check cantilever slab thickness requirements Confirmed. Please see note below.
at stair panel

o.k

closed

closed

CLOSED

Apply support member under landing of stair

o.k

closed

closed

CLOSED

Confirmed. We will add support wall under landing of

stair and check slab thickness according to the new
design as commented in your letter.

Add penthouse to the building and stair at first Architectural design of building is prepared by
floor
considering the area requirements specified in
Contract documentation. A penthouse is not required
in the related Contract specification. Therefore, we
kindly request you to remove this comment

kindly be inform that the space

Add penthouse to the building
requirements listed in the contract
document is not intended to cover
every particles aspect & we believe
the small benthouse is necessary for
the single room building.

Provide us with slab

reinforcement drawings for
checking

open

This is already shown in Rev.00 of dwg. No.

HPP-TBC-90-SNB-2479 (submittal no. 314.)
Please close this comment.

open

Access to roof level is already provided with a

ladder. We do not see any necessity to add a
penthouse.

open

All reinforcement drawings are already

provided (dwg. No. HPP-TBC-C-90-SNB2484, ..., 2498, Rev.00, submittal no. 314 &
315.) Please close this comment.