Scribd
Upload
109 views

Defence 4

This document discusses the debate around citizenship laws in India. It summarizes different perspectives on who should be considered a citizen and debates around proposed amendments to citizenship laws. It discusses views from various political parties and groups on balancing inclusive and exclusive definitions of citizenship. The document examines arguments around protecting certain communities versus broader principles of equality before the law.

Uploaded by

mujeebcrc9112
Copyright
© Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
109 views

Defence 4

This document discusses the debate around citizenship laws in India. It summarizes different perspectives on who should be considered a citizen and debates around proposed amendments to citizenship laws. It discusses views from various political parties and groups on balancing inclusive and exclusive definitions of citizenship. The document examines arguments around protecting certain communities versus broader principles of equality before the law.

Uploaded by

mujeebcrc9112
Copyright
© Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 3

Xo{hhmZw apkvenansâ e£ytam?

- 4
apPmlnZv {]Øm\amWv Zo\nsâ t]cnepw XuloZnsâ t]cnepw XÃpsIm− {]Øm\w. XuloZnsâ t]cn Bcpambpw
C\nbpw PnlmZn\v Hcp¡amWv. ]s£, AXv AÃmlpthm dkqtem ]Tn¸n¨ cq]¯nemIWw F¶XmWv. ]q\qÀ
A_q_¡À lmPn h[n¡s¸«Xv XuloZnsâ t]cnemWv. AXpt]mse Hcp]mSv Øe§fn XuloZnsâ t]cn ItÃdv
sIm−n«p−v, XÃpsIm−n«p−v, {]Øm\¯nsâ Øm]\§Ä Fdnªps]mfn¨n«p−v, t_mws_dnªv \in¸n¡phm³
hsc {ian¨n«p−v. C´ym almcmPy¯v XuloZnsâ t]cn apkvenw kaqlw sam¯¯n Häs¸SpItbm
A{Ian¡s¸SpItbm ]oTn¸n¡s¸SpItbm sNbvXn«nÃ. AÃmlphns\ am{Xw hnfn¨p{]mÀYn¡p¶hsc Xncªp]nSn¨p
sImÃp¶ {]hWX apw_bntem KpPdm¯ntem aodäntem `oh−nbntem D−mbn«pt−m? A{IanIÄ¡v apkvenw
kapZmb¯nÂs]«hcmbm aXn. Ah³ AÃmlphÃm¯ Bsc hnfn¨p {]mÀYn¡p¶h\mbmepw Ahs\
A{Ian¨m aXn.

“Ahsc t\cnSm³ th−n \n§fpsS IgnhnÂs]« FÃm iànbpw, sI«n\nÀ¯nb IpXncIsfbpw \n§Ä Hcp¡pI.
AXpaptJ\ AÃmlphnsâbpw \n§fpsSbpw i{Xpshbpw AhÀ¡v ]pdsa \n§Ä Adnbm¯hcpw AÃmlp Adnbp
¶hcpamb aäp Nnesc \n§Ä `bs¸Sp¯phm³ th−n” (8:60)
AÃmlphnsâbpw \n§fpsSbpw i{Xp¡Äs¡Xnsc Bbp[ tiJcWhpw ]cnioe\hpw \S¯phm³ AÃmlp
I¸n¨ kqd: A³^mense hN\amWnXv. BÀs¡Xnsc k¶mlsamcp¡m\mWv JpÀB³ Bhiys¸Sp¶Xv?
C{_mlow (A) \_nsb hnfn¨p {]mÀYn¨hÀs¡Xnsc, AtÃ? F¦n Cu Bb¯v {]Imcw tIcf¯n Bbp[w
tiJcnt¡−Xpw ]cnioent¡−Xpw BÀs¡XnscbmWv t]m¸peÀImtc? H¶maXmbn sambvXo³ ssiJns\ hnfn¨p
{]mÀYn¡p¶hÀs¡Xnsc, c−maXmbn Cukm (A) \_nsb hnfn¨p {]mÀYn¡p¶hÀs¡Xnsc. ]ns¶ {iocmas\
hnfn¨p {]mÀYn¡p¶hÀs¡Xnscbpw, AtÃ? F¶m t]m¸peÀ {^−pImÀ sN¿p¶tXm? {iocmas\ hnfn¨p
{]mÀYn¡p¶hÀs¡Xnscbpw Cukm (A) \_nsb hnfn¨p {]mÀYn¡p¶hÀs¡Xnscbpw am{Xhpw. F´mWv
AhtcmSv am{Xw \n§fpsS hntcm[w? AXpw inÀ¡v, CXpw inÀ¡v. AtÃ? AsX. C{_mlow (A) \_nsb hnfn¨p
{]mÀYn¨ A_qPlvepw Iq«cpw sNbvXXpw Cukm (A) \_nsb hnfn¨p {]mÀYn¨ \{kmWnIÄ sNbvXXpw
XuloZmtWm? AÃ. ]ns¶sb§ns\ sambvXo³ ssiJns\ hnfn¨p {]mÀYn¡p¶Xv XuloZmbn amdpw? AhnsS
sb´n\m t]m¸peÀImtc \n§Ä hÀKobXbpw PmXobXbpw ImWn¡p¶Xv? AÃmlphnsâ i{Xp¡sf `bs¸Sp¯p
hm³ th−n Bbp[ ]cnioe\w \S¯Ww F¶v AÃmlp ]dbp¶p. \½Ä `bs¸SWsa¶Ã, i{Xphns\ `bs¸Sp
¯Ww F¶mWv. F¶m t]m¸peÀ {^−pImtcm.......... t]meokns\ I−m `bt¶mSp¶p! `cWLS\bpw \nbahpw
t]meokpw kp{]otImSXn hscbpÅ tImSXnIfpapÅ cmPy¯v hmfpw hSnhmfpw I¯nbpw t_mw_pambpw \S
¡pIbmtWm? BÀs¡Xnsc kÖcmbncn¡phm\mWv IzpÀB³ ]dbp¶sX¶v \n§sfm¶v X^vko³ sh¨p ]Tn¨p
a\Ênem¡q ktlmZc·mtc.
I«hsâ ssI apdn¡Wsa¶v Ckveman \nbaantÃ? D−v. apkvenw kapZmb¯nepÅ Bcpw Ifhv \S¯mdntÃ?
AXpap−v. D¯a kapZmb¯nÂs]« F{XbmfpIÄ tamjWw \S¯nsb¶v Hcp Znhks¯ ]{XsaSp¯v H¶p
]cntim[n¨pt\m¡q. F¶ns«t´ CkvemanI \nba{]Imcw B apkvenw kapZmb¯nÂs]«hsâ ssI t]m¸peÀ
{^−pImÀ t]mbn apdn¡m¯Xv? At¸mÄ ]ns¶ lnμphns\bpw {InkvXym\nsbbpw XÃm\pw sImÃm\pw ssI
sh«m\pw am{XamtWm IzpÀB³ Bb¯v? hy`nNmcw, _emÂkwLw, kzhÀKt`mKw CsXms¡ apkvenw kapZmb
¯nÂs]«hÀ sN¿p¶ntÃ? D−v. hy`nNcn¨hsc F´psN¿Wsa¶mWv AÃmlphpw dkq (kz) bpw ]Tn¸n¨Xv? \n§
fpsS ho«nepw \m«nepw IÃnÃmªn«mtWm Ahsc Fdnªp sImÃm¯Xv? kv{Xo[\w hm§nb t]m¸peÀ {^−pImÀ
¡pÅ in£sb´mWv? ]mÀ«nbn \n¶v ]pd¯m¡Â. kv{Xo[m\w hm§nb Bsf ]pd¯m¡phm³ Ckvemw
]dªn«pt−m? Ahsâ ssI t]m¸peÀ {^−pImtc \n§Ä apdnt¨m? At¸mÄ ]ns¶ AXmcmWv sNt¿−Xv?
tamjWw \S¯nbhsâ ssI apdn¡epw hy`nNcn¨hs\ FdnªpsImÃepsams¡ ]ckv]cw At§m«pant§m«pw sN¿p
hm\pÅXmtWm? AÃ. “{]Xn{Inbbn \n§Ä¡v PohnXap−v” F¶v IzpÀB³ ]Tn¸n¨ntÃ? B {]Xn{Inb bnÂ
{][m\s¸« H¶mWv I«hsâ ssI apdn¡Â F¶Xv. F´mWv t]m¸peÀ {^−p ktlmZc·msc IzpÀB³ ]Tn¸n¨
PohnXw tht− \n§Ä¡v?
{]mamWnamÀ ]ecpw sXäv sNbvXm ip]mÀi {]Imcw in£ \S¸m¡msX Cfhv \ÂIpIbpw ]mhs¸«hÀ sXäv
sNbvXm in£n¡pIbpw sN¿p¶ k{¼Zmbw ChnsS \S¸m¡nÃ, apl½Znsâ aIÄ ^mXzna Xs¶bmWv Ifhv
\S¯nbsX¦nepw Rm\hfpsS ssI apdn¡pw F¶mWv {]hmNI³ (kz) ]Tn¸n¨Xv. FhnsS t]m¸peÀ {^−pImtc
\n§Ä ^mXznaamcpsS ssIIÄ apdn¡phm³ apt¶m«p hcm¯Xv? At¸mÄ sslμh ktlmZct\bpw ss{IkvXh
ktlmZct\bpw XÃphm³ am{XamtWm IzpÀB³? AhnsSbmWv \½psS hnjb¯nsâ aÀ½w. AXpsIm−v \n§Ä
hkvXpXIfnte¡v Xncn¨p hcWw.
AÃmlp D−v F¶v a¡m apivcn¡pIÄ¡v Adnbmw. AhÀ ISen t]mbm AÃmlphns\ am{Xw hnfn¨v {]mÀYn¡pw.
\½psS \m«pImÀ ISen t]mbm a¼pds¯ X§sfbpw _Zco§sfbpw am{Xw hnfn¨p {]mÀYn¡pw! AÃmlphns\
hnfn¨p {]mÀYn¡phm³ tXm¶pItbbnà AhÀ¡v. A§ns\bmWv apkvenbm¡·mÀ Ahsc ]Tn¸n¨Xv. AXv
sXämsW¶v \n§Ä ]dtªm t]m¸peÀ {^−pImtc? knan¡mcpw PamAs¯ Ckvemanbpw X_veoKpImcpw ]dtªm?
AXns\m¶n\pw kabanÃ.
HcmÄ sXäv sNbvXncn¡p¶psh¶v sXfnbnt¡−XcmWv F¶XmWv ASnØm\]camb ASp¯ hnjbw. HcmÄ Ifhv
\S¯nbncn¡p¶p F¶v \½Ä Bbnc¡W¡n\v BfpIÄ ]dªm AbmfpsS ssI apdn¡phm³ ]äptam,
in£n¡phm³ ]äptam? sXfnbnt¡−Xpw Xocpam\nt¡−Xpw hn[nt¡−Xpw Bcv F¶XmWv {]iv\w. AXv
tImSXnbmWv. tImSXnbmtWm t]m¸peÀ {^−pw, knanbpsams¡?

Xo{hhmZw apkvenansâ e£ytam? – 4 apl½Zv bmkÀ hn.sI, A_qZm_n [email protected]   Page 1/3 


Ggv \qämt−mfw apkvenwIÄ C´y `cn¨p. `qcn]£w apkvenwIfmbn«mtWm AhÀ C´y `cn¨Xv? AÃ. ]ns¶? AXn\v
tijw {_n«ojpImÀ C´y ]nSn¨S¡n `cn¨p. Xo{hhmZ¯nsâ ASnthcn\v hgnacp¶n« PamAs¯ Ckveman {_n«ojp
ImÀs¡Xnsc kzX{´ kac¯n ]s¦Sp¯nÃ. BÀ.Fkv.FÊpImtc¡mÄ Gähpw hÀKobhpw cmPyt{ZmlIchpamb
{]Øm\w PamAs¯ CkvemanbmWv. F´psIm−v? BÀ.Fkv.FÊpImtcmSv cmambWhpw alm`mcXhpw {ipXnIfpw
kvarXnIfpsam¶pw kzX{´w kacw ]mSnsöv ]dªn«nÃ. F¶m IzpÀB\pw I¿nte´nsIm−v AsXm¶pw ]mSnÃ
F¶v ]dªv PamAs¯ Ckveman kzmX{´ kac¯n ]s¦Sp¯nÃ. F´psIm−v? kzmX{´yw th−mªn«mtWm?
AÃ. C´y kzX{´amIWw, {_n«ojpImÀ ChnsS \n¶p t]mIWw F¶v Ahcpw ]dªp. ]ns¶ F´mWv {]iv\w?
‘au−v _mä¬ {]`p t]mbm ]Icw PhlÀem s\lvdp hcm³ ]änÃ! Hcp Aapkvenw t]mbn asämcp Aapkvenw
hcm³ ]änÃ! ]Icw Hcp apkvenw hcWw!’ AXmbncp¶p AhcpsS \ymbw. {iocmas\ hnfn¨p {]mÀYn¡p¶ BÄ¡v
]Icw sambvXo³ ssiJns\ hnfn¨p {]mÀYn¡p¶ HcmÄ `cWm[nImcnbmbn h¶m PamAs¯ Ckveman k½Xn¡p
tam? XoÀ¨bmbpw k½Xn¡pw. At¸mÄ CXnt\¡mÄ hensbmcp hÀKobX F´mWv Iq«tc? ‘{_n«ojpImc\mb
Aapkvenan \n¶v C´y¡mc\mb Aapkvenante¡v `cWw amdp¶Xp sIm−v Hcp apkvenansâbSp¡mÂ
bYmÀY¯n Hcp amähpw kw`hn¡p¶nÃ. em¯
t]mbn a\m¯ h¶p F¶ hyXymkw am{Xw. Hcp
hymP ssZh¯nsâ Øm\w asämcp hymP ssZhw
ssI¡em¡n’. CXmWv kzmX{´y kac¯ns\Xnsc
PamAs¯ Ckveman ]dªXv. C{X hÀKobX I«hsâ ssI apdn¡Wsa¶v Ckveman \nbaantÃ?
BÀ.Fkv.FÊpImÀ ]dªn«pt−m? IzpÀBsâ D−v. apkvenw kapZmb¯nepÅ Bcpw Ifhv
BfpIÄ, dkq (kz) bpsS BfpIÄ kzlm_ \S¯mdntÃ? AXpap−v. D¯a kapZmb¯nÂs]«
¯nsâ BfpIÄ, Ckvemans\ ka{Kambpw k¼qÀ
Wambpw kzoIcn¡pIbpw AhXcn¸n¡pIbpw F{XbmfpIÄ tamjWw \S¯nsb¶v Hcp
sN¿p¶ BfpItf (?!) CXnsehnsS Ckvemw aXw? Znhks¯ ]{XsaSp¯v H¶p ]cntim[n¨pt\m¡q.
FhnsS k¼qÀWX? FhnsS ka{KX? CXv Bcv F¶ns«t´ CkvemanI \nba{]Imcw B apkvenw
]Tn¸n¨ aXamWv?
kapZmb¯nÂs]«hsâ ssI F³.Un.F^v.ImÀ
inÀ¡nsâ IqSmc¯nembncp¶bmfpIsf XuloZn t]mbn apdn¡m¯Xv? At¸mÄ ]ns¶
te¡v £Wn¡phm³ AÃmlp dkq (kz) sb BÀ.Fkv.FÊpImcs\ XÃm\pw sImÃm\pw
\ntbmKn¨b¨Xv CkvemanI cmjv{S¯nte¡mtWm? am{XamtWm IzpÀB³ Bb¯v? hy`nNmcw,
apivcn¡o§fpsS sImSnb aÀ±\¯n \n¶pw c£
s¸Sp¯phm³ th−n {]hmNI³ (kz) kzlm_n _emÂkwLw kzhÀKt`mKw CsXms¡ apkvenw
amsc ]dªb¨Xv CkvemanI cmjv{S¯nte¡m kapZmb¯nÂs]«hÀ sN¿p¶ntÃ? D−v.
tWm? \{kmWnbmb, Im^ndmb \Ömin cmPmhv hy`nNcn¨hsc F´psN¿Wsa¶mWv AÃmlphpw
`cn¡p¶ FtXym]ybnte¡mbncp¶p. AhnsS
sN¶v A\pkcWt¡Sv ImWn¡ph\pw `cW¯n\v dkq (kz) bpw ]Tn¸n¨Xv? \n§fpsS ho«nepw \m«nepw
th−n t]mcmSphm\pamtWm Ahsc At§m«v ]d IÃnÃmªn«mtWm Ahsc Fdnªp sImÃm¯Xv?
ªb¨Xv? AÃ. AhnsS sN¶v B cmPmhns\ kv{Xo[\w hm§nb F³.Un.F^pImÀ¡pÅ
A\pkcn¨v AhnsS Pohn¡phm³. inÀ¡nsâ in£sb´mWv? F³.Un.F^n \n¶v ]pd¯m¡Â.
\m«n \n¶pw asämcp inÀ¡nsâ \m«nte¡v
Ahsc Ab¡phm³ ImcWw AhnsS kzmX{´y kv{Xo[m\w hm§nb Bsf ]pd¯m¡phm³ Ckvemw
ap−v F¶XpsIm−mbncp¶p. CkvemanI `cWan ]dªn«pt−m? Ahsâ ssI F³.Un.F^pImÀ
Ãm¯ B {]tZi¯v B Aapkvenamb `cWm[n apdnt¨m? At¸mÄ ]ns¶ AXmcmWv sNt¿−Xv?
Imcnsb A\pkcn¨v Pohn¡phm³ Xs¶. AhnsS
A\nkvemanI `cWamWv, XzmKq¯n Kh¬saâmWv tamjWw \S¯nbhsâ ssI apdn¡epw
AXv AwKoIcn¡phm³ ]änà F¶v ]dªv AhnsS hy`nNcn¨hs\ FdnªpsImÃepsams¡ ]ckv]cw
`cWw Øm]n¡phm\mtWm PAv^À (d) bpsS t\Xr At§m«pant§m«pw sN¿phm\pÅXmtWm? AÃ.
Xz¯n Hcp kwLamfpIÄ At§m«p t]mbXv?
A\nkvemanI Kh¬saânsâ Iogn bqkp^v (A) “{]Xn{Inbbn \n§Ä¡v PohnXap−v” F¶v
\_n `£y hIp¸v ta[mhnbmbn `cWw \S¯n IzpÀB³ ]Tn¸n¨ntÃ? B {]Xn{InbbnÂ
bntÃ? Cu amXrI F´psIm−v PamA¯v Ckvem {][m\s¸« H¶mWv I«hsâ ssI apdn¡Â F¶Xv.
anbpw, knanbpw, t]m¸peÀ {^−pw kzoIcn¡p¶nÃ?
apl½Zv (kz) \_n, bqkp^v (A) \_n XpS§nb F´mWv F³.Un.F^v ktlmZc·msc IzpÀB³
{]hmNI·mcpw AhcpsS A\pbmbnIfpw F§n ]Tn¸n¨ PohnXw tht− \n§Ä¡v?
s\bmWv Pohn¨Xv F¶ Ncn{Xw ]Tn¨pIqtS?
PamAs¯ Ckveman kzmX{´ kac¯n ]s¦Sp
¡msX AXns\ hnaÀin¨p; ‘Bbncwh«w AXn\v
im]w’ F¶v. C´ym almcmPy¯v AXv ]dªXv PamAs¯ Ckveman am{XamWv. 90 iXam\w AapkvenwIÄ
Pohn¡p¶ Hcp _lpaX P\m[n]Xy cmPy¯v hfsc \yq\]£amb apkvenwIÄ¡v, AapkvenwIÄ `cn¡cpXv Ft¶m,
apkvenw `cn¡Ww Ft¶m ]dbphm\pÅ AhImiapt−m? bYmÀY¯n \mw hfsc Kuch]qÀÆw Nn´nt¡− Hcp
Imcyw, AXp]dbphm³ AhImiapÅ _lp`qcn]£w hcp¶ sslμh kaqlw R§fmWnhnsS `cnt¡−Xv F¶v
]dtªm F¶XmWv. F¶m apkvenw kapZmb¯n s]«hcpsS A]Izamb {]hÀ¯\§fpsS ^eambn Ahsc
sIm−v A§ns\ ]dbn¸n¡pIbmWv sN¿p¶Xv.

\½psS \mSpIfn \mw I− Gähpw A]Izhpw _p²niq\yhpamb Hcp hmIyambncp¶p ‘C´ybpsS tamN\w Ckvem
aneqsS’ F¶ Npascgp¯v. Ckveman\v F´v t\«amWv B Npascgp¯psIm−p−mbXv? kXy¯n CXnse´v A]I
SamWv F¶v AÂ]_p²nbpÅbmfpIÄ ]et¸mgpw tNmZn¡mdp−v. C¯cw hmIy§sfgpXnb hfsc ]cnanXamb
NpacpIfpsS t^mt«mIÄ FSp¯v sslμh Xo{hXbpsS BfpIÄ tZiob am[ya§Ä hgn, Xo{h sslμh hnImc
anÃm¯hcpsS a\ÊpIsft¸mepw Cf¡n adn¡phm³ ]cn{ian¨p. A§ns\, hfsc \yq\]£w hcp¶ apkvenw kaqlw

Xo{hhmZw apkvenansâ e£ytam? – 4 apl½Zv bmkÀ hn.sI, A_qZm_n [email protected]   Page 2/3 


CkvemanI cmjv{S¯n\v th−n apdhnfn Iq«pt¼mÄ, _lp`qcn]£amb \mw sslμhÀ¡v F´psIm−v sslμh
cmjv{S kwØm]\¯n\v ]cn{ian¨pIqSm F¶ \nebnte¡v km[mcW¡mcmb sslμh hnizmknIfpsS a\ÊpIsf
t¸mepw GtIm]n¸n¡phm³ Ignªp F¶XmWv A¯cw Npascgp¯pIÄ sIm−p−mb Gähpw henb t\«w! c−v
koäv am{Xap−mbncp¶hÀ sslμh thm«pIÄ C§ns\ GIoIcn¨v C{μ{]دnte¡pÅ ]mX kpKaam¡pIbpw
sNbvXp!!
700 hÀjt¯mfw apkvenaIfmbncp¶tÃm C´y `cn¨ncp¶Xv. F¶n«v F{Xt]À apkvenwIfmbn? F{Xt]À¡v Ckveman
s\¸än ]Tn¸n¨psImSp¯p? XuloZpw inÀ¡pw ]Tn¸n¨psImSpt¯m? CÃ. At¸mÄ ]ns¶ \½psS e£ysa´mWv? Cu
cmPys¯ BfpIsf XuloZnte¡v £Wn¡phm\mWv \mw ]cn{iant¡−Xv. AXmWv \½psS ZuXyw. AXv \mw
cmPyt{ZmlnIfmbncp¶n«mtWm th−Xv? PamAs¯ Ckveman, knan, t]m¸peÀ {^−p ktlmZc·mtc \n§sfm¶v
BtemNn¨v t\m¡q. kzmX{´ kac¯n ]s¦Sp¡m¯, AXns\ i]n¨, hnaÀin¨ PamAs¯ Ckveman¡v C´ym
almcmPy¯v P\n¡phm\pw Pohn¡phm\papÅ AhImiapt−m? C´y³ `cWLS\sb ]pNvOn¡p¶ ktlmZc
·mÀ¡pw ktlmZcnamÀ¡pw C´ym almcmPy¯v Pohn¡phm³ AhImiapt−m? C´y³ `cWLS\ AwKoIcn¡p
¶nsæn t]m¸peÀ {^−pImtc, PamAs¯ Ckveman¡mtc, knan¡mtc AXv Xpd¶p ]dbphms\´mWn{X aSn
\n§Ä¡v? kXyw GXv `cWm[nImcnbpsS ap¼nepw sh«n¯pd¶v ]db PnlmZmsW¶tà ]Tn¸n¨ncn¡p¶Xv.
\n§fsXm¶v Xpd¶v ]dbphn³ ktlmZc·mtc!

(XpScpw….…)

apl½Zv bmkÀ hn.sI.


A_qZm_n

Xo{hhmZw apkvenansâ e£ytam? – 4 apl½Zv bmkÀ hn.sI, A_qZm_n [email protected]   Page 3/3 

You might also like