Problem21 93
Problem21 93
93: a) The y-components of the electric field cancel, and the x-components from both
charges, as given in problem 21.87 is:
1 2Q 1 1 1 2Qq 1 1 ˆ
Ex 2
2
F 2 i .
y (y a ) a y ( y a 2 )1
2 1 2
4πε0 a 4πε0
1 2Qq 1 Qqa
If y a, F 4πε (1 (1 a 2 2 y 2 ))iˆ .
0 ay 4πε0 y 3
b) If the point charge is now on the x-axis the two charged parts of the rods provide
different forces, though still along the x-axis (see problem 21.86).
1 Qq 1 1 1 Qq 1 1 ˆ
F qE iˆ and F q E i
4πε0 a x a x 4πε0 a x x a
So,
1 Qq 1 2 1 ˆ
F F F i
4πε0 a x a x x a
1 Qq a a 2 a a2 ˆ 1 2Qqa ˆ
For x a , F
1 . . .
2
1 . . . i i.
4πε0 ax x x 2
x x 2
4πε0 x 3