Hedging: Long and Short
Hedging: Long and Short
1
Arguments For Hedging
Companies should focus on their main
business and minimize risks arising from
interest rates, exchange rates, and other
market variables
– Non-intrusive risk management tool
Hedging may help smooth income and
minimize tax liabilities
Hedging may help smooth income and
reduce managerial salaries
2
Arguments Against Hedging
Well-diversified shareholders can make
their own risk management decisions
It may increase business risk to hedge
when competitors do not
Explaining a loss on the hedge and a
gain on the underlying can be difficult
3
Basis Risk
Basis is the difference between spot and
futures prices
Basis risk arises because of uncertainty
about the price difference when the hedge
is closed out
Basis risk usually less than the risk of price
or rate level changes
Basis risk depends on futures pricing forces
4
Choice of Hedging Contract
Delivery month should be as close as
possible to, but later than, the end of the
life of the hedge
If no futures contract hedged position,
choose the contract whose futures price
is most highly correlated with the asset
price
– Called cross-hedging
– Additional basis risk
5
Naive Hedge Ratio
Divide the face value of the cash position by
the face value of one futures contract
Problems:
– Market values should be focus
– Ignores differences between the cash and
futures instruments
Variation: divide the market value of the
cash position by the market value of one
futures contract
6
Minimum Variance Hedge
Ratio
Proportion of the exposure that
should optimally be hedged is
S S,F
h 2
F F
hedge per dollar of cash market value
Hedge ratio estimated from:
CPt FPt
7
Hedging Stock Portfolios
If hedging a well-diversified stock portfolio
with a well-diversified stock index futures
contract, what are implications?
– No diversifiable risk in the cash stock portfolio
and futures hedge removes systematic risk
– Since no risk, systematic or unsystematic,
what can an investor expect to earn by
hedging a well-diversified stock portfolio?
8
Hedging Stock Portfolios
But has all risk been eliminated?
Problems:
– Stock portfolio being hedged may have a
different price volatility than the stock-index
futures
– Hedging goal is not to reduce all systematic
risk
Price sensitivity to market movements
determined by beta
9
Hedging Stock Portfolios
Optimal number of contracts to
hedge a portfolio is
(S )
*
MV of spot portfolio
F MV of one futures contract
Future contracts can be used to
change the beta of a portfolio
– If * >(<) S, hedging implies a long
(short) stock index futures position
10
Rolling The Hedge Forward
What if hedging further in the future than
available delivery dates?
Series of futures contracts used to
increase the life of a hedge
Each time a futures contract matures,
switch position into another, later
contract
– Basis risk, cash flow problems possible
11