Fdi Food Retailing
Fdi Food Retailing
The Indian Food and Beverage Services market is expanding rapidly. The compounded annual rate of growth is expected to be 25% and will continue to grow with similar pace in the next few years. The overall scenario of the F&B market has evolved over the few years. There was a time when handful of brands were available in the market to eat out. But today, the customers are spoilt for choices. We have witnessed immense activities in F&B Services industry in the last 5 years, including exciting new concepts, food and beverage offerings and new and innovative service elements.. We have also seen increased interest in the investment circle for this segment with some big investments deals taking place in the recent times. Therefore, what are the emerging and current trends in the F&B Services industry? How will people eat, behave and be served in coming years? In this document we look at some of these foreseeable trends that will become part of the everyday life soon.
www.technopak.com
a quar terly repor t by technopak | Outlook June, 2012
Contents
Authors: Inderpreet Kaur, Associate Director | [email protected] Shruti Garyali, Senior Consultant | [email protected] Ravindra Yadav, Senior Consultant | [email protected] Samridhi Sancheti, Consultant | [email protected] Design & Development Bharat Kaushik, Sr. Design Manager I [email protected] Arvind Sundriyal, Senior Designer I [email protected]
01 11
TRANSFORMATION OF CUISINE
03 14
05 18
07 19
09
SOCIAL MEDIA SUSTAINABILITY GAINING TRANSFORMING CRITICAL IMPORTANCE RELATIONSHIP WITH IN F&B CONSUMERS
ABOUT TECHNOPAK
Outlook June, 2012 | Emerging Trends in Food & Beverage Services Retailing in India
Trend 1
Transformation of Cuisine
Despite Indias great tradition of food, eating out was not as common as in the West until recently. Now, eating out is a regular form of entertainment, especially in the metros, mini-metros and Tier I cities, driven by rise in income, greater number of nuclear families and working women, and urbanization. Focused marketing by brands, with more emphasis on the menu, is also attracting customers, as is the dissemination of culinary concepts and preferences through print and television media. Closely linked to these developments is the transformation of cuisine from simple and familiar offerings to a menu that offers diversity in taste, style and origins. At the customer end, a greater willingness to experiment with novelties, exposure to international cuisines, and a fast-paced lifestyle have contributed to changing cuisine preferences. Ingredients like truffles, artichokes, asparagus, Australian lamb, Norwegian salmon, black bean sauce etc. have found their way to the Indian F&B space. Blending of cuisines, e.g. Italian with Thai is another customer choice. The trend is increasing for customers to choose cuisines that reflect their lifestyle, and in the process reject the traditional options. Consequently, industry-side trends are also changing, with international players also entering the arena. Even casual dining players are prepared to provide such flavors as quick Chinese, raw and rustic Italian, fine French, convenient American, etc. which were once specialty and fine-dining dishes. On the other hand, customers are also being wooed with street food options served in a hygienic setting and good ambience. Another industry innovation is the dual format, e.g., caf + bar, caf + grill, bar + lounge, etc. While these give more choice to customers and can also make more profits for the brands, they need to be clearly positioned to avoid any confusion in the customers minds. Multi-cuisine restaurants, which offer a non-specialized feel, are however losing ground to specialist players with customers willing to pay more but unwilling to compromise on quality. 1
The way forward is likely to be an adoption of both lesser known Indian flavors from the Himalayan and tribal belts as well as other international cuisines. While South Indian, Punjabi and Mughlai cuisines tended to dominate the Indian offerings, there is now also demand for such dishes as Andhra Chicken Pepper Fry. Similarly, Bhutanese, African and Korean cuisines can also find acceptance among customers. Thus, there is opportunity for F&B players to mix the traditional and new Indian flavors while offering both individually. Further, while a niche segment may be created around specific international cuisines, customization may be needed to ensure that they suit the Indian palate.
Fine Dining
Street Food
Outlook June, 2012 | Emerging Trends in Food & Beverage Services Retailing in India
Trend 2
Alcohol has not only become an occasional part of our lives but it has evolved into one of the strongest influences on our civilization.
Homer Simpson
Going forward, brands are expected to focus on the beverage segment, which offers high margins and also a point of differentiation from competitors. However, such factors as complementary food, ambience and engagement activities will also be crucial in determining the vitality of the business model and will help in creating a niche for this segment.
Outlook June, 2012 | Emerging Trends in Food & Beverage Services Retailing in India
Trend 3
And in my opinion, entertainment in its broadest sense has become a necessity rather than a luxury in the life.
Walt Disney
One benefit of such extras is the buzz it can create among customers, who then become an alternative marketing tool by spreading the word about the F&B brand. This talk value is vital for brands as their customers are also passive advertisers. Brands which host musical events, for instance, may also capture indirect media attention through such customers. However, the onus is on the brands to ensure higher consumer interaction and engage younger consumers, who are more likely to seek such venues as hang-outs and visit frequently. Brands also have to make a studied choice in terms of these bonus offerings, which are limited in number and have different levels of appeal among customers. Music is generally the strongest crowd-puller, and positively impacts a restaurants business, image and customer experience. It can be offered variously through live performances, as songs played on request and karaoke. Blue Frog, The V Spot Caf+Bar and Hard Rock Caf are some examples of successful players offering music. Another entertainment choice is Comedy, which gives customers a much-needed laughter break in a stressful world. This has been successfully adopted in the West, but is still novel to India, with The Comedy Store, Bombay Elektrik Project and Kyra the pioneers here. Also attracting a good number of customers are Sports offerings, with themed outlets cashing in on the popular 6
love for football (soccer), cricket, Formula 1 racing, etc. Players in this space include The Manchester United Caf Bar, Delhi Daredevils Sports Bar and Golfworx. One relatively new option which is still being explored is Art & Literature. Its connection with the F&B space is not well understood, and thus the existence of only a few players such as Mocha Arthouse and Indian Art Caf, which encourage art and art appreciation, and places which provide books to read for customers, like Caf Turtle. Going forward, the need of the hour is to find unique ways to engage the consumer in ways that ensure a long term relationship between the brand and the consumer. The primary goal in this space is creating excitement for the consumer and giving them more than they asked for in terms of beyond-the-palate, entertainment options in a bid to encourage repeat visits.
Outlook June, 2012 | Emerging Trends in Food & Beverage Services Retailing in India
Trend 4
is an opportunity for a variety of F&B brands, in various formats. Players in this space have already begun to cash in on this Caf Coffee Day, for instance, has spread into Bihar, Jharkhand and West Bengal, while Barista operates in Kolkata. Smaller cities like Patna, Guwahati and Ranchi are also coming up on the radar of F&B brands. Evolving consumer needs have also contributed to the growth of niches within the F&B sector. Initially, their sensitivity to price made the 25 to 40 age bracket the core target for F&B brands. With consumers now desiring customization and showing a willingness to experiment and indulge themselves, F&B brands need to reposition
Improved transport options have created new retail avenues at airports and metro stations and along highways.
according to customer lifestyles and aspirations. Healthconscious customers are one such segment for such F&B brands as Soya Express. Restaurants have also introduced themes and entertainment options to suit patrons who are looking to have a good time. Eating-out is also trending in smaller cities as a result of lifestyle changes, viz. increase in disposable income, greater number of working women, etc. Again, consumers are switching loyalties from tea stalls and roadside eateries to more hygienic dining options which have better service options, despite the higher expense involved. Improved transport options have created new retail avenues at airports and metro stations and along highways. In the West, it is common to see quick service restaurants and cafs along freeways, unlike India, where are only unorganized players like dhaabas. This opportunity for F&B brands is accentuated by consumers focusing more on hygiene and quality. The high footfall and captive customer population at railway and metro stations and airports has resulted in a mushrooming of F&B brands in these locations. There is also more demand for to go food options at transit locations, offering another window for F&B players. Rising income levels and changing lifestyle has given the F&B sector a chance to expand and tap new markets. Going forward, higher retail presence is one way of exploiting this opportunity, while creating niche segments is another. The sector is also expected to expand its presence at transit locations.
Outlook June, 2012 | Emerging Trends in Food & Beverage Services Retailing in India
Trend 5
Outlook June, 2012 | Emerging Trends in Food & Beverage Services Retailing in India
Trend 6
The advent of social media as a marketing tool has seen companies from every consumer-driven segment rush to adapt to the new phenomenon. In a reach out or lose out world, it is no surprise that F&B brands have also entered into the social media space. Further, irrespective of their individual offerings, the brands all need to converse with the consumer: the better this conversation, the greater their share of the pie. The reach of social media primarily covers the age bracket of 13 to 34 years, which overlaps the core target segment for F&B brands. The leading social media channel, Facebook, alone has a total audience of 45 million people in India, with 90 percent in the 13 to 34 years range. Through Facebook, and other popular channels like Twitter, Foursquare and blogs, brands can gather reviews and dispense loyalty incentives. However, social media is not an ideal channel for fine dining brands which have affluent consumers in older age groups, as this might impact their exclusivity and brand image. Even brands that do have, say, a Facebook page (e.g., Bukhara, Olive and Lodi-The Garden Restaurant), do not leverage it currently. Broadly speaking, F&B brands see social media as either a core marketing channel or as a support for traditional media. For brands which do not use traditional media to communicate with consumers Caf Coffee Day, Hard Rock Caf, Mocha etc. social media helps gain visibility and generates talk value. McDonalds, KFC, Pizza Hut and Dominos Pizza use social media in addition to traditional media to connect with consumers and continuing being the top of the mind options. Social media is often seen as a Touch Point, allowing brands to inform consumers about existing and new products, store openings, media coverage, and promotions and offers. However, such communication varies from brand to brand, especially in terms of content and presentation. For example, while both Caf Coffee Day and Pizza Hut advertise products through Facebook, Caf Coffee Day changes product pictures, while Pizza Hut plays around with captions. Also, with such channels as Twitter, the clarity and relevance of the communication is crucial to ensure better reception. In this respect, while Hard Rock Caf focuses on music, Dominos Pizza promotes offers and discounts. Brands also use social media as a tool for Open Communication, which takes the form of contests, polls, and quizzes, e.g., Barista engages its fans on Facebook through such games as Scrabble, Spot the Difference, etc. Social media channels like Twitter and Facebook also provide a space to consumers to air their complaints and grievances, which brands need to immediately address. Reviews and blogs, another form of Open Communication, are consumer-initiated rather than brand-controlled. Websites such as Zomato.com also allow consumers to review and rate restaurants. This trend is being adopted by some of the brands, e.g. Dominos Pizza and Hard Rock Caf, which use blogs as another platform for reaching out to consumers. The use of social media to promote Incentives is presently limited to a few brands and certain social media channels. For instance, consumers receive incentives through Foursquare by means of check-ins. Caf Coffee Day pioneered 11 this initiative in 2011, by rewarding every 3rd customer who checked-in at Caf Coffee Day through Foursquare with a 15 percent discount. Further, a consumer who was a Mayor on Foursquare received a free coffee, besides a 20 percent discount on every 3rd check-in. Incentivizing consumers is yet to take-off in a big way and is a future opportunity to be grabbed through Facebook and Twitter. A Look at How F&B Brands Stack Up Across Popular Social Media Channels The social media presence of F&B brands and their level of engagement on Facebook are discussed in Table 1 below. The channels appeal among the youth is reflected in the statistics, and thus, if an F&B brand wants to be seen and heard through a social media channel, Facebook is its best bet.
Table 1 F&B Brand Pizza Hut CCD Dominos Cocoberry KFC Hard Rock Caf McDonald's Barista Lavazza Number of Facebook Fans* 1,561,035 1,525,451 1,090,198 1,020,337 773,248 142,751 139,544 42,962 Avg. No. of Posts per month** 35 35 75 40 Avg. No. of Interactions per month** 24,100 54,000 45,000 22,400 n.a. n.a. n.a. 1150
n.a.
n.a. n.a. 24
12
Outlook June, 2012 | Emerging Trends in Food & Beverage Services Retailing in India
Trend 7
In comparison, Twitter emerges as a channel buzzing with activity and hype, but is less-understood and hence lower brand presence and activity (Table 2).
Table 2 F&B Brand CCD Hard Rock Caf Dominos KFC Barista Lavazza Cocoberry Number of Twitter Followers* 5383 4651 3333 1227 510 289 Total No. of Brand Tweets* 5393 2811 2375 156 530 640 Total No. of Brand Retweets* 929 1300 1100 13 104 28 Retweet % 4% 46% 46% 8% 20% 4%
Going forward, F&B brands need to have a clear strategy as regards the tone and theme of communication via social media channels. Further, such communication should be integrated and uniform across various channels. Again, brands need to understand which mode of communication works best with the target consumer group so as not to alienate patrons. Despite the current popularity of Facebook and Twitter, such channels as blogs and YouTube have tremendous potential and may be leveraged to improve brand presence. This is also necessitated due to the competition in the segment and also wavering consumer preferences. Social media is thus an open field which F&B brands can exploit to gain competitive edge.
Use and conservation of energy is one area where restaurants can contribute to sustainability and also save on costs.
While such environment-friendly equipment as computer-controlled fryers, ovens and refrigerators are available in the international markets, their cost, especially with the addition of import duties, is too steep for smaller and unorganized players. Construction of restaurant buildings can also contribute to energy savings. Green residential and commercial
13
14
Outlook June, 2012 | Emerging Trends in Food & Beverage Services Retailing in India
construction projects are currently underway which encourage, inter alia, the use of natural light as a way of lowering electricity costs. Another option in terms of lighting is the use of compact fluorescent lights, or CFLs, and Light Emitting Diodes, or LEDs, which can be expensive, but are increasing in popularity. Recycling and Waste Management is another concern for restaurants, which are required to clean their wastes before releasing them into the environment, usually using air scrubbers and effluent treatment plants. People are also worried about the dangers associated with landfills. In malls and shops, plastic bags are being replaced by paper bags. Some government policies help further such practices, but there is need for stricter regulations relating to recycling practices to be observed by F&B businesses. Restaurants need to switch to using recyclable paper and packaging and cut down on usage of plastic crockery and cutlery. Also rising in prevalence is the use of fresh, organic food and ingredients, with India among the top ten countries in terms of demand for such food. Though organic food is not a part of consumers daily diet due to its higher cost, restaurants are however focusing on developing backend teams to access organic ingredients. The bottleneck, again, is awareness, with customers not knowing the difference between organic and non-organic food. But with more education, organic and locally-grown food could find emphasis with restaurants seeking to create a premium aura and differentiate themselves from rivals. Corporate Social Responsibility, or CSR, is another emerging trend among F&B brands as CSR initiatives help in enhancing brand image and have value in international markets. In India, restaurants have hired specially-abled and impoverished people, e.g., RJ Corp employs over 450 specially-abled people across India. Caf Coffee Day also employs about 90 people with hearing impairments. Encouraging government policies can give a further boost to such efforts. Going forward, intensive and far-reaching educational programs can be useful in promoting sustainability initiatives. Governmental measures, including grading restaurants on their green efforts and providing tax benefits/ subsidies, can also be helpful. Further, F&B brands need to implement sustainable systems at both the front- and back-end, in pioneering ways if needed.
15
16
Outlook June, 2012 | Emerging Trends in Food & Beverage Services Retailing in India
Trend 8
17
18
Outlook June, 2012 | Emerging Trends in Food & Beverage Services Retailing in India
About Technopak
Indias leading management consulting firm with more than 20 years of experience in working with organizations across consumer goods and services. Founded on the principle of concept to commissioning, we partner our clients to identify their maximum-value opportunities, provide solutions to their key challenges and help them create a robust and high growth business models. We have the ability to be the strategic advisors with customized solution during the ideation phase, implementation guide through start-up and a trusted advisor overall. Drawing from the extensive experience of more than 175 professionals, Technopak focuses on six major divisions, which are Fashion & Textile, Retail & Consumer Goods, Healthcare, Education, Food & Agriculture and Leisure & Tourism.
19
20
For further dialogue, please contact: President [email protected] T: +91 98185 98626
Saloni Nangia
Pratichee Kapoor
Inderpreet Kaur
www.technopak.com