Iim B Case Study Dainik Bhaskar Groups Maharashtra Success Story
Iim B Case Study Dainik Bhaskar Groups Maharashtra Success Story
Aspiring Growth
This case has been written by Seema Gupta, Assistant Professor of Marketing at the Indian Institute of Management Bangalore. The author is grateful to the management team at Dainik Bhaskar Group for their support in writing the case. This case has been written solely as a basis for classroom discussion. It is not intended to serve as an endorsement, source of primary data or an illustration of either effective or ineffective management. 2012 Indian Institute of Management Bangalore
Not for reproduction, distribution or commercial use. Reproduction of any content in any format requires prior approval from IIM Bangalore.
Preface
ainik Bhaskar Group with its ambitious growth plans exemplifies gutsy business strategy and marketing. It changed the contours of the marketplace by entering into markets with strong and entrenched incumbents. This task was even more arduous considering the nature of the category as it is difficult to change the habit of newspaper readers. Newspaper touches the life of every consumer and hence the case would drive strong emotional connect and animated discussion in the classroom. The focus of the company on tier II and tier III towns makes it an apt material for case study as such towns would be the drivers of future growth of Indian economy.
SEEMA GUPTA Assistant Professor, Marketing Indian Institute of Management Bangalore (IIMB)
Aspiring Growth
On May 8, 2012; Pawan Agarwal, Director, Dainik Bhaskar Group (DBG) and winner of the Asia-Pacific entrepreneur of the year (2010) award,1 called for a meeting of the executive team to choose a market for further expansion of the group, after its stupendous success in Maharashtra. DBG was Indias largest newspaper group having 19.2 million readers (Exhibit 1). In 2011, it had revenues of ` 12 billion (1$ = ` 55, June 2012) and net profit of ` 2.5 billion (Exhibit 2). The groups ability to simultaneously consolidate in existing markets and expand in new markets resulted in its consistent growth in revenues and profitability.2 Besides newspaper, DB group also owned radio channel MY FM, which operated 17 stations across 7 states. The group also had a strong digital presence with four portals dainikbhaskar.com (Hindi), divyabhaskar.com (Gujarati), divyamarathi.com (Marathi) and dailybhaskar.com (English). The Hindi news portal dainikbhaskar.com itself attracted more than 10 million unique users and 245 million page views per month.3 The group also had four magazines Aha Zindagi (positivity in life), Bal Bhaskar (in Hindi for kids), Young Bhaskar (in English for kids) and Lakshya (for career grooming). The group published newspapers in four languages Hindi (Dainik Bhaskar and Business Bhaskar), English (DNA), Gujarati (Divya Bhaskar) and Marathi (Divya Marathi) in 65 editions across 13 states (Exhibit 3). Its newspaper had different supplements City Bhaskar (city-based activities and a youth-centric coverage), Madhurima (for women), Rasrang (for literary) and Navrang (for entertainment). With its unrelenting focus on tier II markets (cities with population between 1 and 4 million); the group had acquired dominant No. 1 position in markets such as Madhya Pradesh (MP), Chandigarh, Haryana and Chhattisgarh (Exhibit 4). Its nonmetro urban focus ensured that the group was the market leader in major cities such as Jaipur, Ahmedabad and Amritsar while being a formidable challenger in the respective states Rajasthan, Gujarat and Punjab (Exhibits 5, 6 and 7).
1 2
The award was given by Enterprise Asia, a leading private organisation for entrepreneurship development in Asia. DB Group was listed in Bombay Stock Exchange and National Stock Exchange in 2010. Despite the recessionary trends, the IPO (initial public offering) was oversubscribed 39 times. 3 Source: Google Analytics Data.
HISTORY
The first edition of DBG was launched in Bhopal in 1958. It then entered the cities of Gwalior, Ujjain and Jhansi. In 1983, it entered Indore, the business center of Madhya Pradesh (MP) with a strong incumbent Nai Dunia. On the back of fair reporting and quality printing, it soon became the No. 1 newspaper in Indore and subsequently in the whole of MP in 1995. This success in a market dominated by an incumbent enhanced the groups confidence to expand outside MP. It explored options in the Hindi belt comprising Uttar Pradesh (UP), Bihar, Rajasthan, Delhi, Punjab and Haryana. UP and Bihar suffered from low levels of literacy and per capita income, Punjab was reeling under the threat of terrorism and Delhi was dominated by English newspapers. In 1996, the DB group zeroed in on Rajasthan as it was culturally similar to MP and being a vast geographical territory offered scope for expansion. Moreover, Jaipur had high readership of Hindi dailies among SEC AB and high per capita income indicating potential to attract advertisers. It was dominated by a single player Rajasthan Patrika (RP), which had 80% market share.7 Readership had not grown much in the past, indicating untapped potential and a need gap which DBG could potentially fill. Jaipur was even more challenging than Indore as unlike Nai Dunia which was strong only in Indore, RP was the market leader in the entire state. Traditional approach for launch of a newspaper was to produce a good paper and wait for readers to subscribe. However, DBG took a leaf out of the automobile industrys book where pre-booking was a practice and
4 5
Girish Agarwaal won the award in 2006 in IT, Communication & Entertainment category. As per IMRB Survey Report (Aurangabad) initiated by DBG. 6 Socioeconomic classification was a tool for segmenting households in India. Originally developed by Indian Market Research Bureau (IMRB), it was standardised and adopted by the Market Research Society of India to categorise consumer behaviour. The urban SEC classified households into 5 groups A, B, C, D, and E on the basis of Education and Occupation. SEC A had the highest purchasing power. The rural SEC classified households into 4 groups R1, R2, R3 and R4 on the basis of education and type of house (mud, brick and mix). SEC R1 had the highest purchasing power. 7 Out of 5.16 lakh people that read any Hindi newspaper in Rajasthan, 4.41 lakh people read RP (IRS 95).
EDITORIAL
DBG believed in unbiased, credible and courageous journalism. It was non-aligned be it a religious group or community or political party or client. It did not patronise any particular religion, rather covered activities of different religions and communities. Other papers had a section on spirituality based on the belief that it would transcend all religions. However, DBG believed that such reporting comes from the lowest common denominator! It muted the religion factor! Similarly, it gave expression to many communities and castes and therefore created a plural identity. Owing to its non-alignment with politicians, it was not surprising that one day it would criticise a politician for an inappropriate action and the next day applaud him for a good decision. Yatish Rajawat, Group Managing Editor said: As any other media, we too at times face pressure from various segments regarding the news coverage. Under such situations, we are guided by our philosophy that our first commitment is to our readers. But, we always offer to carry alongside their point of view. Such is our commitment to the readers that if we believe that our own event may not be of relevance to our readers, we would not give it coverage. DB groups journalism was credible because it told both sides of the story. For instance, when the nation was all gaga over the anticorruption movement led by Anna Hazare,9 DBG too covered it on the front page. However, DBG also considered the point of view of Annas critics and covered the critique in its editorial page. It followed courageous journalism despite the common occurrence of threats to underplay arrest or scam or crime news. For instance, news about Chinkara deer (black buck) poaching by Bollywood celebrity Saif Ali Khan and Salman Khan was broken by it as it was relevant to the Bishnoi community living in the area.10 Similarly, in the murder case of Bhanwari Devi in Rajasthan in which prominent politicians were accused, DBG pursued the case and kept it alive until the government was forced to take action. Rajawat said: With time, such elements have realised that our paper will not succumb to any threats or pressure and hence the pressure on the editorial has also decreased. DBG followed local and hyper-local journalism which focussed on local news from the city. It further divided cities into sectors and reported events specifically on that sector. For instance, in Jaipur, M.G. Road and Mansarovar were distinct sectors. Rajawat said: Our front page is on national affairs, but our pages after that up to eight are on the city. We are classified as a city newspaper. If you look at Los Angeles Times or Ohio Times, they have deep sections on the city. Most newspapers were founded as city newspapers. New York Times was a New York newspaper and Washington Post was a Washington paper. But over time, this genesis was lost, so the connect with the readers was lost. Some papers thought that celebrities will touch everyones lives and so embraced
9
10
Anna Hazare was one of Indias well-acclaimed social activists. Black Buck was listed as an endangered species. Bishnoi was a community of Rajasthan that protected the wild life and environment with a missionary zeal. Their history was peppered with stories about martyrs who died fighting to save the environment.
Narendra Modi was the chief minister of the state of Gujarat. It won CMO Asia award for best corporate social responsibility practice.
DISTRIBUTION
DBG set up a strong distribution channel of distributors, vendors and hawkers to ensure timely delivery of the paper. In bigger and strategically important markets such as Jaipur, Ahmedabad and Chandigarh, it supplied directly to vendors as it had the infrastructure and in smaller markets, it supplied to distributors who in turn supplied to vendors who hired hawkers. Typically, distributors were paid 5% commission and vendors 30%. Vendors in turn hired hawkers at ` 7001000 per month.14 Commissions of the channel were protected even if the newspaper sold at a lower price, it had to pay 80 paise (1 ` = 100 paise) per copy to the channel.15 If the paper had more pages, the hawkers would often ask for more money. They were paid extra for inserting leaflets and sometimes levied service charge for delivery in bigger cities. They were also incentivised by publishers for acquiring new readers. DBG created a bond with the hawkers, as hawkers were the last mile of connectivity. DBG recognised them it issued identity cards (which protected them from police questioning in the early morning hours), arranged for group insurance and scholarships for their children and printed a newsletter totally dedicated to this hawker agent community. Maheshwari said:
13
DBG as a policy overinvested in capacity. To utilise the idle machinery during day time, it took printing contracts for magazines and supplements of other publication groups. 14 ABC mandated that only those copies where the commission was 40% or less were considered as sold copies. 15 For instance, in Delhi, DBG had 70 centres.
LAUNCH IN MAHARASHTRA
The quest for growth led DBG to launch its newspaper in Maharashtra in 2011. The choice was guided by two criteria. Firstly, the high GDP growth rate of 14.5% and high per capita income of ` 80,000 per annum, indicating potential to attract advertisers. Secondly, the huge gap between people who could read Marathi (88%) and those who read any Marathi daily (44%), indicating the potential to attract new readers. Nishit Jain, Business Head, Maharashtra said:
17
M.S. Dhoni was a popular and well acclaimed cricketer and captain of the Indian cricket team.
Lokmats Chairman Vijay Darda was the Member of Parliament from Rajya Sabha since 1998 and his brother Rajendra Darda was the minister for education in the Maharashtra State government.
18
The launch was a resounding success with Divya Marathi becoming No. 1 on the first day itself.20 Moreover in the next six months after the launch of Divya Marathi, the average circulation of Lokmat declined from 73,158 copies to 59,548 copies and that of Sakal from 55,972 copies to 40,370 copies.21 (Exhibit 20). Divya Marathi also earned attractive advertising revenues. With capital expenditure of ` 130 million and one-time operating expenses of ` 55 million, DBG projected to break even in 4 years. The successful launch of Divya Marathi in Aurangabad was followed by launches in other cities Nasik, Jalgaon, Ahmednagar and Solapur. Not only did DBG successfully enter new markets, it also warded off threat from competition in its home turf. For instance, when RP entered Bhopal, DBG introduced a lower priced variant without any supplements Jan Jagruti, also called Green Bhaskar. Its flagship brand Red Bhaskar had all the supplements free and was priced higher (the two variants had green and red lines, respectively under the mastheads). Patrika (Rajasthan Patrika was branded as Patrika in markets other than Rajasthan) on its entry had to fight Green Bhaskar. Later, Green Bhaskar was phased out. Another threat was posed by Dainik Jagran (DJ) when it entered Indore. However, due to loyalty of readers towards Dainik Bhaskar, DJ could not make much headway and eventually closed operations. The fierce competitiveness of the DB group stemmed from its vision of being the dominant player in each of the markets it operated in. Pawan Agarwal said: We want to not only maintain our readership, but also widen our lead over competition. Our goals are very clear if we are in a 4-player market, we have to be ahead of our nearest rival by 25%; in a 3-player market by 30% and in a 2-player market by 40%. We also have the responsibility to grow the market as the penetration levels of print media are very low. Although 71% of Indias population is literate, only 20.1% read newspapers daily, leaving a huge potential for readership growth in future. We can do this by consolidating our existing markets as well as by expanding into new territories.
Which is the next market that Dainik Bhaskar Group should enter?
The subscription offer varies from market to market. In Maharashtra, the classified advertisement coupons were a success. However, these have not been used in any other launches by DBG. 20 According to the IMRB Survey (Aurangabad) initiated by DBCL Divya Marathi had the highest number of readers: 3.42 lakh and hence was the leader. 21 As per Audit Bureau of circulation (ABC) Lokmat had an average circulation of 73,158 copies in Aurangabad city during January-June 2011 but after the launch of Divya Marathi on 29th May, 2011, the average circulation for Lokmat for the period July-December 2011 dropped to 59,548 copies. Similarly, the average circulation of Sakal dropped from 55,972 copies in January-June 2011 to 40,370 copies during July-December 2011.
19
10
Dainik Bhaskar Group: Aspiring Growth EXHIBIT 1: THE TOP NEWSPAPER GROUPS
DAINIK BHASKAR GROUP Publication AIR Dainik Bhaskar 14876 Divya Bhaskar 3627 Saurashtra Samachar 255 Business Bhaskar 68 DNA 47 DB STAR 272 Dainik Prabhat Kiran 63 Total 19208 DAINIK JAGRAN GROUP Publication AIR Dainik Jagran 16458 I Next 655 Midday (Eng) 380 Midday (Guj) 147 Inquilab 145 Total 17785 TOI GROUP Publication AIR The Times of India 7467 The Economic Times (Eng) 812 Maharashtra Times 1217 Navbharat Times 2581 Vijay Karnataka 3487 Mumbai Mirror 760 Ahmedabad Mirror 53 Bangalore Mirror 169 Total 16546 HT MEDIA GROUP Publication AIR Hindustan 12033 Hindustan Times 3733 Mint 253 Total 16019 MALAYALA MANORAMA GROUP Publication AIR Malayala Manorama 9912 Total 9912
DNA is the English newspaper, DB Star is a tabloid and Prabhat Kiran is the afternoon newspaper in MP. Average Issue Readership (AIR) is the number of people who have read the publication within its publication interval. For instance, for a daily, AIR is the number of people who have read the newspaper yesterday. Indian Readership Survey (IRS) is the largest continuous study of the world with a sample size of more than 250,000 households across India. It collects readership information of print media, viewing habits of television and channels, listening habits of radio and usage of internet. It also collects information on consumption of over 100 product categories. It is conducted by Market Research Users Council (MRUC), a not-for-profit industry body and Hansa Research, a private market research company.
11
Source: Company Annual Report (Selling, General & Administrative Expenses were ` 1,204 mn, ` 1,167 mn and ` 1,458 mn for years 2008-09, 2009-10 and 2010-11, respectively).
12
13
Dainik Bhaskar Group: Aspiring Growth EXHIBIT 4: DAINIK BHASKAR GROUP COVERAGE MAP
Jammu - 2010
DB(1)
Chandigarh-2000
DB(1)
Uttarakhand - 2008
DB(1)
Rajasthan - 1996
Gujarat - 2003
DvB(6) & DNA(1)
Jharkhand 2010
DB(3)
Chhattisgarh 1988
DB(4), BB(1) & DB Star(1)
Maharashtra - 2004
DvB(1) & DvM(5)
DB DvB DvM BB -
Source: Company ( ) Indicates number of editions Divya Bhaskar was launched in Mumbai in 2004 and Divya Marathi in Maharashtra in 2011.
14
Dainik Bhaskar Group: Aspiring Growth EXHIBIT 5: READERSHIP TRENDS IN DAINIK BHASKAR MARKETS
RAJASTHAN 1995 R2 POPULATION CRH AHD RP DB POPULATION CRH AHD PK DB POPULATION CRH AHD PK DB POPULATION CRG AGD GS DvB SNDH POPULATION CRH AHD DB NB ND NvD RE PAT POPULATION CRH AHD DB NB 32061 3976 3359 12508 1650 1243 15426 1893 1877 1999 R2 35647 7593 4919 4848 13979 1859 1342 17145 1337 1337 34161 8335 4338 4851 2000 R2 36415 9468 6482 6810 2002 R2 38746 10616 5966 7284 2003 R2 40094 21050 9512 5865 6354 2005 R2 41886 24005 10176 6038 6696 2007 R2 44478 24268 10268 7353 5745 18837 12976 3529 868 1669 21033 12069 2516 1132 265 43098 29492 10503 4421 3295 3591 47862 25428 4794 3314 739 467 488 16378 9292 1984 1095 790 2009 R2 46883 26646 10230 6363 5693 20012 14110 3526 850 1498 22007 12909 2780 1111 893 45239 32454 10334 4603 3359 3234 50223 29213 4770 3025 456 790 139 547 463 17019 10414 2261 1115 819 2010 Q4 48132 29855 11103 7026 6379 20626 13978 2869 1069 1571 22509 13223 2579 1070 849 46345 33022 10068 4365 3507 3303 51443 30639 6092 3534 200 1209 291 574 1080 17349 11007 2339 1016 771 2011 Q3 48642 30502 10951 6796 6434 20922 15817 3583 959 1432 22770 13462 2346 955 814 47190 34648 10575 4450 3591 3206 52373 32253 6447 3881 144 1213 361 508 1430 17599 11644 2356 1067 745
CHANDIGARH & HARYANA 14286 15377 16103 17333 2414 1629 17398 1531 1531 34724 8542 4688 4722 3579 1283 1909 10862 3829 1168 1847 11581 4597 1436 2227 19745 11777 2796 1604 100 40486 25533 10825 5444 3991 3944
37 GUJARAT 36731 38054 8374 4334 4738 25024 9446 4914 2215 4204
MADHYA PRADESH 42994 45159 24196 5362 3541 1828 709 24768 5206 3547 1745 789 -
CHHATTISGARH 14942 15640 7818 2251 1240 1235 8703 2599 1675 1301
Source: IRS Figures in 000s Readership is Average Issue Readership; CRH Can Read Hindi, AHD Any Hindi Daily, RP Rajasthan Patrika, DB Dainik Bhaskar, PK Punjab Kesari, CRG Can Read Gujarati, AGD Any Gujarati Daily, GS Gujarat Samachar, DvB Divya Bhaskar, NB Nav Bharat, SNDH Sandesh, ND Nai Dunia, NvD Nav Duniya, RE Raj Express, PAT Patrika. Till 2009 figures refer to R2 (Round 2) as IRS was half yearly. In 2010, IRS adopted Quarterly reporting and the data refers to Q4. For 2011, Q3 was the latest data available at the time of case development.
15
GUJARAT
AHMEDABAD
Source: IRS Figures in 000's Readership is Average Issue Readership CRH Can Read Hindi, AHD Any Hindi Daily, RP Rajasthan Patrika, DB Dainik Bhaskar, PK Punjab Kesari, CRG Can Read Gujarati, AGD Any Gujarati Daily, GS Gujarat Samachar, DvB Divya Bhaskar, DJ Dainik Jagran, SNDH Sandesh. Till 2009 figures refer to R2 (Round 2) as IRS was half yearly. In 2010, IRS adopted Quarterly reporting and the data refers to Q4. For 2011, Q3 was the latest data available at the time of case development.
16
Dainik Bhaskar Group: Aspiring Growth EXHIBIT 7: READERSHIP (AIR) OF TOP 20 PUBLICATIONS
PUBLICATION Dainik Jagran Dainik Bhaskar Hindustan Malayala Manorama Amar Ujala The Times of India Daily Thanthi Lokmat Rajasthan Patrika Mathrubhumi Eenadu Ananda Bazar Patrika Dinakaran Sakshi Gujarat Samachar Daily Sakal Hindustan Times Divya Bhaskar Vijay Karnataka Prajavani Source: IRS 2011 Q3 Figures in 000s URBAN+RURAL 16458 14876 12033 9912 8836 7467 7447 7438 6918 6630 6101 6098 5253 5219 5186 4273 3733 3627 3487 3366 PUBLICATION Dainik Bhaskar Dainik Jagran The Times of India Hindustan Daily Thanthi Amar Ujala Lokmat Gujarat Samachar Ananda Bazar Patrika Hindustan Times Rajasthan Patrika Dinakaran Eenadu Malayala Manorama Divya Bhaskar Sakshi Navbharat Times Daily Sakal Punjab Kesari Mathrubhumi URBAN 9649 8748 7278 5870 4452 4400 4121 3989 3820 3670 3285 3165 2988 2962 2750 2595 2549 2402 2251 2070
17
18
Dainik Bhaskar Group: Aspiring Growth EXHIBIT 11: READERSHIP TRENDS IN SELECT MARKETS
Urban + Rural ANDHRA PRADESH Population Can Read Telugu Any Dailies AIR Any Telugu Daily AIR 08 R2 64712 39043 10656 9859 09 R2 65907 40335 12286 11696 10 Q3 66807 41468 12230 11749 11 Q3 68026 42806 12330 11718 Urban 08 R2 09 R2 19092 19578 13599 14290 5339 6181 4575 5647 10 Q3 11 Q3 19945 20444 14709 15213 5944 6052 5490 5495 SEC AB 08 R2 09 R2 4455 4366 4031 3927 2575 2750 2138 2450 10 Q3 11 Q3 4577 5121 4135 4597 2703 2926 2454 2575
Urban + Rural BIHAR Population Can Read Hindi Any Dailies AIR Any Hindi Daily AIR 08 R2 64443 32424 6077 5979 09 R2 66091 33381 5887 5847 10 Q3 67346 35302 6136 6074 11 Q3 69060 38640 6693 6546
Urban 08 R2 09 R2 7660 7907 5445 5613 2009 1950 1943 1910 10 Q3 11 Q3 8097 8356 5839 6200 2114 2351 2077 2266
SEC AB 08 R2 09 R2 2061 1997 1975 1917 1138 1068 1080 1034 10 Q3 11 Q3 2253 2553 2150 2444 1174 1383 1144 1314
Urban + Rural KARNATAKA Population Can Read Kannada Any Dailies AIR Any Kannada Daily AIR 08 R2 45964 29410 8381 7497 09 R2 46934 31165 8380 7349 10 Q3 47668 32015 9787 8718 11 Q3 48665 32596 9808 8538
Urban 08 R2 09 R2 16887 17369 12108 13179 5077 5017 4297 4189 10 Q3 11 Q3 17735 18234 13415 13640 5711 5779 4781 4645
SEC AB 08 R2 09 R2 4070 4577 3555 4104 2340 2451 1879 1990 10 Q3 11 Q3 4972 4991 4402 4315 2745 2746 2237 2059
Urban + Rural KERALA Population Can Read Malayalam Any Dailies AIR Any Malayalam Daily AIR 08 R2 27706 26233 15550 15442 09 R2 28048 26660 17311 17091 10 Q3 28304 27015 18499 18429 11 Q3 28521 27724 18819 18703
Urban 08 R2 09 R2 7277 7365 7026 7145 4730 5207 4687 5121 10 Q3 11 Q3 7431 7520 7258 7370 5482 5439 5443 5389
SEC AB 08 R2 09 R2 1457 1757 1442 1742 1292 1516 1266 1459 10 Q3 11 Q3 1829 1944 1808 1936 1617 1715 1596 1675
Urban + Rural TAMIL NADU Population Can Read Tamil Any Dailies AIR Any Tamil Daily AIR 08 R2 56980 44580 13554 12752 09 R2 57755 45332 13779 12955 10 Q3 58247 46225 13086 12241 11 Q3 59008 47394 13183 12322
Urban 08 R2 09 R2 26866 27433 22942 23454 8550 8861 7791 8087 10 Q3 11 Q3 27786 28343 23959 24573 8490 8558 7701 7744
SEC AB 08 R2 09 R2 5413 5829 5160 5575 3104 3387 2529 2777 10 Q3 11 Q3 6107 6064 5831 5832 3398 3267 2796 2694
Urban + Rural UTTAR PRADESH Population Can Read Hindi Any Dailies AIR Any Hindi Daily AIR 08 R2 130285 76062 16141 15857 09 R2 133397 78518 16313 16028
SEC AB 08 R2 09 R2 7992 8199 7668 7815 4826 5075 4596 4829 10 Q3 11 Q3 8481 9095 8102 8715 5198 5403 4938 5145
10 Q3 11 Q3 08 R2 09 R2 135766 137890 30884 31873 82137 85444 22273 22949 17221 18144 8532 8848 16916 17859 8258 8585
Urban + Rural WEST BENGAL Population Can Read Bengali Any Dailies - AIR Any Bengali Daily - AIR 08 R2 68285 46699 11163 10161 09 R2 69694 49122 11113 10006 10 Q3 70760 50104 11205 10092 11 Q3 72205 52641 10905 9718
Urban 08 R2 09 R2 20903 21343 15291 15793 6264 6212 5306 5231 10 Q3 11 Q3 21676 22126 16229 16587 6651 6569 5595 5455
SEC AB 08 R2 09 R2 5814 5933 5240 5273 3626 3561 3041 2918 10 Q3 11 Q3 6076 6129 5428 5520 3854 3834 3174 3211
Source: IRS Figures in 000s The 2008 and 2009 figures refer to Round 2 as IRS was half yearly.
19
Source: IRS 2011 Q3 Figures in % Data for Arunachal Pradesh, Manipur, Meghalaya, Mizoram, Nagaland, Sikkim, Tripura not available.
20
Dainik Bhaskar Group: Aspiring Growth EXHIBIT 13: READERSHIP (AIR) TREND OF TOP DAILIES
ANDHRA PRADESH Publication Eenadu Sakshi Andhra Jyoti Vartha Andhra Bhoomi Deccan Chronicle Hindu Times of India Urban+Rural 6008 5159 2222 356 223 731 308 142 BIHAR Hindustan Dainik Jagran Prabhat Khabar Aj Times of India Hindustan Times 4897 2861 587 303 152 80 UTTAR PRADESH Dainik Jagran Amar Ujala Hindustan Aj Rashtriya Sahara I Next DLA Times of India Hindustan Times 8981 7021 3884 690 662 457 262 558 280 WEST BENGAL Ananda Bazar Patrika Bartaman Sangbad Pratidin Gansakti Aajkaal Uttar Banga Sambad Telegraph Times of India Sanmarg 6015 2881 905 776 663 508 1056 617 472 3744 1512 419 340 349 256 1023 593 460 2382 816 222 163 202 102 875 489 190 4470 3453 1946 258 276 403 217 511 276 2734 1960 1167 108 169 204 123 476 241 Daily Thanthi Dinakaran Dinamalar Dinamani Malai Malar Hindu Deccan Chronicle 1612 1071 229 120 124 63 948 622 135 66 114 55 Malayala Manorama Mathrubhumi Deshabhimani Madhyamam Kerala Kaumudi The Hindu Urban 2914 2545 831 165 99 697 288 142 SEC AB 1532 1096 389 84 44 459 208 120 KERALA 9828 6608 2201 998 665 326 TAMIL NADU 7262 5097 2615 485 451 1097 258 4319 3045 1694 324 325 1023 233 1316 935 781 162 108 737 128 2881 2049 619 231 171 212 973 633 121 67 66 153 Publication Vijay Karnataka Prajavani Kannada Prabha Samyukta Karnataka Udayavani Times of India Deccan Herald KARNATAKA Urban+Rural Urban 3484 3363 1326 1084 923 634 394 1992 1791 599 463 465 629 337 SEC AB 981 794 265 185 144 438 240
21
Dainik Bhaskar Group: Aspiring Growth EXHIBIT 14: LAUNCH PROCESS AT DBG
Source: Company
22
Dainik Bhaskar Group: Aspiring Growth EXHIBIT : NE SPAPER MAKING PROCESS AT DBG
Source: Company
23
MADHYA PRADESH CHHATTISGARH RAJASTHAN PUNJAB HARYANA CHANDIGARH CPH GUJARAT JHARKHAND
430
Source: IRS 2011 Q3 AIR Figures in 000s AIR is for both urban and rural DB Dainik Bhaskar, PAT Patrika, HB Hari Bhoomi, RP Rajasthan Patrika, PK Punjab Kesari, TT The Tribune, DvB Divya Bhaskar (DvB in Gujarat includes Saurashtra Samachar), GS Gujarat Samachar, Htan Hindustan.
24
25
Source: IRS 2011 Q4 Readership AIR Rates: Mediaware, April 2012. Dainik Bhaskar All Editions excluding Jabalpur, Satna, Nagpur and Chhindwara.
26
Source: Company
27
EXHIBIT
: MAHARASHTRA
Source: Company
EXHIBIT HIBIT IT
P Divya Marathi arat Lok Lokmat Daily Sakal Sa Punya Nagari T 342 273 65 25
: READERSHIP IN AURANGABAD
SEC A 28 15 4 1 B 58 38 8 1 C 122 78 14 4 DE 134 140 39 18
28