Environ Law & Policy Syllabus
Environ Law & Policy Syllabus
Instructors:LauraKing&ChristinaValerino
Spring2013,Tuesday&Thursday4:305:45
OfficeHours:5:45to6:45everyThursday
ContactInfo:[email protected]
Ifyouhaveanyquestionsregardingthematerialoranyotherissueplease
contacttheteachersattheemailabove.
Description
Welcome to Environmental Law and Policy. The purpose of this course
is twofold: (1) to teach you the foundational concepts of the American
legal system, and (2) to expose you to the major doctrines of
environmental law. Environmental law seeks to address a broad range
of environmentalchallenges,includingthe overuse of shared resources
such as water and air; the pollution of those resources; the handling of
hazardous waste; species protection; land use planning; and the use of
federal public lands. This semester we will explore the basic legal
remedies of environmental law through landmark cases, making
connectionstocurrentissuesinallaspectsofenvironmentallaw.
RequiredText:
EnvironmentalLawandPolicy:Nature,Law,andSociety,4
th
Edition
(Plater,Abrams,Graham,Hall,Heinzerling,Wirth)
Additionalmaterialswillbeprovidedbytheinstructorsonthecourse
Blackboardwebsite.
GoalsfortheCourse:
1. Gainfamiliaritywiththestructuresanddoctrinesofthelegal
process.
2. Learnhowtoreadlegalcasesandstatuteswithaviewtoward
problemsolving.
3. Becomefamiliarwiththevarietyoflegalapproachesto
environmentalissuesinmajorcasesandstatuteswithin
environmentallaw.
Grading:
ClassParticipation,worth15%ofyourgrade
MockTrialPerformance,worth15%ofyourgrade
ShortPaperAssignments(4Total;2-3pageseach),30%ofyourgrade
(NOTE:FirstPaperAssignmentwillNOTbegraded.)
FinalExamORLegalResearchMemoranda(Yourchoice),40%ofyour
grade
PossibleWritingTopics(forLegalMemoranda)
NOTE:Ifyouhaveanareaofinterestoranideafeelfreetoproposethat
aswell.FinaltopicselectiondueFebruary31
st
.FinalPaperdueMay3
rd
bynoon.
1. What are the positive and negative effects (for the industry,
political implications etc oflistinggreenhousegasemissionsas
anairpollutantundertheCleanAirAct?
2. Why is there a lack of federal regulation regarding climate
control? States have picked up the slack. How has the U.S. (both
federal and state) response to climate control been similar
to/differentfromtheEUresponse?
3. What are the benefits and drawbacks of harm-based as opposed
to technology-based standards? Where have each of these
standardssucceeded?Failed?
4. Examine the pros/cons of a carbon tax and cap-and-trade
program. You may cite examples such as RGGI (New England
States anu Califoinias new cap-andtradeauction.
5. Which of the statutes we have studied best facilitate public
participation and/or community action? Which statutes make
publicparticipationdifficult?
Policies:
Attendance - This is a discussion-oriented class. Regular attendance is
expected. If you know you will be absent, please let one of the
instructorsknowbyemailinadvance.
LateWrittenAssignmentsOne+/-gradedownforeachdaylate.You
mustspeaktoaninstructorforextensionsinextenuating
circumstances.
Disabilities-Studentswithspecialinterests,ordisabilities,orother
requirementsshouldletusknowaboutthemearlyinthesemester.
ClassAssignments:
January15:IntroductiontoLawandtheLegalProcess:Tragedyofthe
Commons
ReadingAssignment:Noreadingassignment,butrefertopp.25-36.
January17:Publicv.PrivateNuisance
ReadingAssignment:pp.75-82(Boomeretal.v.AtlanticCement
Company)
January22:HowfarcanwetakePublic/PrivateNuisance?SolveGlobal
Problems?
ReadingAssignment:pp.90-109
January24:MockTrialWoburn
ReadingAssignment:Handout
January29:MockTrial-Woburn
ReadingAssignment:Handout
January31:DebriefofMockTrial;ACivilAction:Viewing
ReadingAssignment:Handout
February5:ACivilAction:ViewingandDiscussion
ReadingAssignment:Handout;ShortPaper#1Due
February7:IntroductiontoRegulatoryOptions:CleanAirActPartI
ReadingAssignment:pp.187-192;465-481
February12:CleanAirActPartII
ReadingAssignments:pp.482-487(Massv.EPA);handout(CAA
Highlights)
February14:CleanAirActPartIII
ReadingAssignment:CAASimulation
In-ClassAssignment:Simulation
February19:CleanAirActPartIV
ReadingAssignment:pp.498-516
February21:CleanWaterActPartI
ReadingAssignment:pp.187-192(review);pp.523-539
February26:CleanWaterActPartII
ReadingAssignment:pp.539-556
February28:CleanWaterActPartIII
ReadingAssignment:pp.556-570;ShortPaper#2Due
March5:SpringVacation
March7:SpringVacation
March12:Cost-BenefitAnalysis
ReadingAssignment:pp.575-589
March14:Market-EnlistingStrategiesPartI
ReadingAssignment:pp.607-629
March19:Market-EnlistingStrategiesPartII
ReadingAssignment:pp.629-646
March21:RemedialLiabilityRegulatoryStrategy:CERCLA
ReadingAssignment:pp.681-691;handout
March26:ControlofHazardousSubstances:RCRA
ReadingAssignment:pp.743-754;handout;ShortPaper#3Due
March28:NoClass/EasterWeekend
April2:NEPAPartI
ReadingAssignment:pp.319-327
April4:NEPAPartII
ReadingAssignment:pp.327-344
April9:PublicPlanningPartI
ReadingAssignment:pp.353-368
April11:PublicPlanningPartII
ReadingAssignment:handout
In-Class:speaker
April16:PublicPlanningPartIII
ReadingAssignment:pp.379-386
April18:PublicTrustDoctrinePartI
ReadingAssignment:pp.857-870;ShortPaper#4Due
April23:PublicTrustDoctrinePartII
ReadingAssignment:pp.870-889
April25:EndangeredSpeciesActPartI
ReadingAssignment:pp.425-443
April30:EndangeredSpeciesActPartII
ReadingAssignment:pp.443-459
May2:Review/PaperPresentations