Platos Ethics
Platos Ethics
intelligible world (unchanging) ---hierarchy of forms: ---mathematical objects ---ideas ---the ood ---ultimate source of all reality! truth! " goodness ---#oral com$onent: ---the good life is lived by %nowing the ood and living in conformity to it ---morality de$ends! ultimately! on &'()*+, + of the ood ---more s$ecifically! )-S,(# (%nowing the ood and discriminating between it and a$$earances) ---)-S,(# alone allows us to be virtuous .-/01+ 2 moral 3ualities of $ersons ree% virtues 2 wisdom! tem$erance! justice! courage! and $iety 'otice that being virtuous does not guarantee that we will e4$erience $leasure and avoid $ain. -n fact! Plato was fiercely o$$osed to the theory that $leasure2good and $ain2evil (5+,('-S#) /efutes this view by showing that some $leasures are bad in the long run! and some $ains good (overeating! e4ercising6dentist) -t is not the $ain6$leasure resulting from our actions that ma%es them right or wrong. 7ut there other 8results8 of our actions which are im$ortant. ood deeds im$rove our character or 8souls8 7ad deeds ma%e our characters worse (e.g. Acting unjustly ma%es us unjust) So why be good9 )hy $ursue virtue9 A: -t im$roves us (benefits us) -- ma%es us more e4cellent! and conse3uently ha$$y 7eing bad ma%es us worse (injures us) So! misdeeds are always committed out of - '(/A':+ )e thin% a deed is to our benefit when it really is not
51#A' 'A01/+ Psyche divided: /eason .S A$$etite .S S$irit /eason is our rational $art which see%s the ood ,esire is irrational! and see%s $leasure S$irit is emotional drives! see%ing success (ambition) :hariot model: A$$etite and S$irit are the horses ($roviding #(0-.+ force) /eason is the driver (choosing the course! controlling the two horses) 0he virtuous $erson is li%e a good charioteer: controls a$$etite and s$irit with reason. .irtues in relation to the divided $syche )isdom 2 reason is effective driver 0em$erance 2 reason is controlling a$$etites :ourage 2 reason is controlling s$irit ;ustice 2 all three $arts in harmony -f virtue is thus a %ind of balance and harmony in the soul! it becomes clear why doing good 2 benefiting us and doing evil 2 harming us. .ice 2 disease of the soul< virtue 2 health of soul 0hus! Socrates famously said: -t is better to suffer injustice than to commit injustice. Suffering injustice at the hands of others harms our bodies but not our souls< doing injustice harms the soul. Forms! again. ---%nowledge is virtue. &nowledge of what9 0he 5ow do we come to %now the ood9 ---using reason ---hence Plato=s advocacy of 8$hiloso$her %ings8 Problems: ---0heory of the forms ood.
---0he good is ineffable (cannot be described in words). So what if two $eo$le claim that their visions of the ood are different9 5ow do we resolve conflicts9 (Plato would deny that differing images of the ood could be had>but then how do we %now it is right one9) ---5ow do you %now the ood is objective9 (Plato: it is rational< all humans can rationally understand a circle< li%ewise the ood< objective li%e mathematics) ---,escri$tion of the $syche (soul) -- material or not9 (nly three $arts9 5ow does Plato %now this9 ---? " @ -- $roblems with Plato=s $olitics< not really im$ortant for us