Comparative Evaluation of Single-Phase Unity Power Factor
Comparative Evaluation of Single-Phase Unity Power Factor
A Pandey, Non-member
Prof B Singh, Fellow
Prof D P Kothari, Fellow
This paper presents a comparative evaluation of five topologies of single-phase ac-dc boost converters having power
factor correction (PFC). These converter topologies are evaluated on the basis of performance and their salient features
are discussed to analyze their applicability. Operation of these converters and their control schemes are described and
modeled using first-order differential equations. Performance of these converters is simulated and conformity of these
converters is shown to relevant international standards. This work aims to provide an exposure of PFC converters to
researchers and application engineers dealing with power quality issues.
Keywords: ac-dc power converter; PFC; Power quality improvement; Comparative study
Figure 1(a) Boost converter Figure 1(f) Control scheme of PFC converter
CONTROL SCHEME
idc The objective of the control scheme of the boost converters is
is Ls to regulate the power flow ensuring tight output voltage
vs Cd Load regulation as well as unity input power factor. Cascaded
vdc control structure shown in Figure 1(f) is the most extensively
used control scheme for these converters and essentially
similar control philosophy is applied to all the other
Figure 1(b) Symmetrical semi-boost converter topologies of boost converter. In this scheme, the output of
voltage regulator, limited to a safe value, forms the amplitude
of input reference current. This reference amplitude is then
multiplied to a template of input voltage to synchronize the
idc
reference with input voltage, as required for unity power
is L factor operation. The inductor current is forced to track its
s
vs Cd Load reference current using current controller, which generates
vdc
appropriate gating signals for the active device(s).
Modelling of PFC Converters and the PWM voltages and current are as
The converters are modelled using first order non-linear i p 1 = S1 i L (19)
differential equations. The number of equations is equal to the
number of energy storage components in the system. i p 2 = S 2 iL (20)
Single-phase Boost PFC Converter vp1 = S1 v C 1 (21)
The boost converter is modelled using two differential
equations for inductor current iL and dc link capacitor voltage vp2 = S 2 v C 2 (22)
vdc . here S1 and S2 are switching states of respective switches.
The converter is described by two differential equations for Rectifier Number of Number of Number of Power Flow
inductor current iL and dc link voltage across capacitor vdc . Power Diodes Voltage
p iL = ( v s − v p − r i L ) / L (23) Switches Drop
Across
p v dc = ( i p − v dc / R ) / C d (24) Semi-
conductor
where PWM voltage and current are Devices
vp = v dc ( Sa − Sb ) (25)
Boost 1 5 3 unidirectional
i p = iL ( Sa − Sb ) (26)
Semi-boost 2 4 2 unidirectional
respectively;
Half Bridge 2 2 1 bi-directional
where
Sa = 1 if switches S1 and S4 are ON, otherwise Sa = 0. VSC 4 4 2 bi-directional
Voltage, V
Input
Performance simulation of converters modelled and described 0
in the previous section is carried out for different loading 200
conditions at 100-kHz switching frequency. The values of 0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25 0.3
inductor and capacitor are calculated for desired input current 10
Current, A
Input
Semi-
boost 0.4789 1.8680 1.000 0.999 2.41/3 47/47 0
0 10 20 30 40 50 60
Half-
Harmonic Order
bridge 0.4394 1.8137 1.000 0.999 2.8/3.4 27/37
Figure 2(b) Harmonic spectrum of input current for single-phase boost
VSC 0.4699 1.9093 1.000 0.999 2.41/3 37/27
converter at light load (325 W)
8 8
7 7
Magnitude, A
6 6
Magnitude, A
5 5
4 4
3 3
2 2
1 1
0 0
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 0 10 20 30 40 50 60
Harmonic Order Harmonic Order
Figure 2(c) Harmonic spectrum of input current for single-phase boost Figure 3(c) Harmonic spectrum of input current for single-phase semi-
converter at heavy load (1625 W) boost converter at heavy load (1625 W)
Voltage, V
200
Voltage, V 200
Input
0
Input
0
200
0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25 0.3 200
0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25
10
Current, A
10
Current, A
0
Input
0
Input
10
10
0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25 0.3 0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25
450
720
Voltage, V
Voltage, V
Output
400
Output
700
350 680
0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25 0.3 0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25
5 5
Current, A
Current, A
Output
Output
0 0
0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25 0.3 0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25
Time, s Time, s
Figure 3(a) Dynamic performance of single-phase semi-boost converter Figure 4(a) Dynamic performance of single-phase half-bridge converter
2 2
1.5 1.5
Magnitude, A
Magnitude, A
1 1
0.5 0.5
0 0
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 0 10 20 30 40 50 60
Harmonic Order Harmonic Order
Figure 3(b) Harmonic spectrum of input current for single-phase Figure 4(b) Harmonic spectrum of input current for single-phase half-
semi-boost converter at light load (325 W) bridge converter at light load (325 W)
9 9
8 8
7 7
Magnitude, A
Magnitude, A
6 6
5 5
4 4
3 3
2 2
1 1
0 0
0 10 20
30 40 50 60 0 10 20 30 40 50 60
Harmonic Order Harmonic Order
Figure 4(c) Harmonic spectrum of input current for single-phase Figure 5(c) Harmonic spectrum of input current for single-phase voltage
half-bridge converter at heavy load (1625 W) source converter at heavy load (1625 W)
200
Voltage, V
Efficiency
Input
0
200 Voltage drops across semi-conductor devices can have
0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25 0.3 significant effect on the overall efficiency of the converters.
10 Number of voltage drops across single-phase boost converter
Current, A
400
increased cost of additional active switches and fast recovery
350 diodes. Low efficiency of half-bridge converters in
0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25 0.3
5 applications requiring bi-directional power flow cannot be
avoided as the capacitors are discharged into supply.
Current, A
Output
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
First named author expresses sincere thanks to the Council of
Figure 6 Input current and voltage waveforms of diode rectifier
Scientific and Industrial Research for the financial assistance
provided under Award No 9/86(456)/2000-EMR-I to carry
out this research.
REFERENCES
1. J D Van Wyk. Power Quality, Power Electronics and Control. in
Proceedings EPE.93, 1993, pp 17-32.
Figure 7(a) Input voltage and current waveforms of single-phase boost 4. H Endo, T Yamashita and T Sugiura. A High Power-factor Buck
converter Converter. in Proceedings IEEE PESC92, 1992, pp 1071-1076.
6. L G Lopez, de Vicuna and M Castilla. Sliding Mode Control Design of a 23. G V Covic, G L Peters and J T Boys. An Improved Single Phase to Three
Boost High-power-factor Pre-regulator Based on the Quasi-steady-sate Phase Converter for Low Cost ac Motor Drives. in Proceedings IEEE PEDS95,
Approach. in Proceedings IEEE PESC01, 2001, pp 932-935. 1995, pp 549-554.
7. S B Monge, C Crebier, S Ragon, E Hertz, J Wei, J Zhang, D Boroyevich and 24. W J Ho, J B Lio and W S Feng. A Line-interactive UPS Structure with
Z Gilrdal. Optimization Techniques Applied to the Design of a Boost Power Built-in Vector-controlled Charger and PFC. in Proceedings IEEE PEDS97,
Factor Correction Converter. in Proceedings IEEE PESC01, 2001, pp 920-925. 1997, pp 127-132.
8. L Ping and K Yong. Design and Performance of an ac/dc Voltage Source 25. G J Su, D J Adams, L M Tolbert. Comparative Study of Power Factor
Converter. in Proceedings IEEE INTELEC00, 2000, pp 419-423. Correction Converters for Single-phase Half-bridge Inverters. in Proceedings
IEEE PESC01, 2001, pp 995-1000.
9. H S H Chung, S Y R Hui and D Y Qiu. Control of Active Power-factor
Corrector using a Single Current Sensor. in Proceedings IEEE PESC00, 2000, 26. R Srinivasan and R Oruganti. A Unity Power Factor Converter using Half-
pp 577-582. bridge Boost Topology. IEEE Transactions Power Electronics, vol 13, June 1997,
10. H S H Chung, S Y R Hui and D Y Qiu. Control of Active Power-factor pp 487-500.
Corrector using a Single Current Sensor. in Proceedings IEEE PESC00, 2000, 27. J T Boys and A W Green. Current-forced Single-phase Reversible
pp 577-582. Rectifier. IEE Proceedings, vol 136, September 1989, pp 205-211.
11. M Fu and Q Chen. A DSP Based Controller for Power Factor Correction 28. A I Takahashi and K Utsunomiya. A Simple Sensorless Method for
(PFC) in a Rectifier Circuit. in Proceedings IEEE APEC01, 2001, pp 144-149. Sinusoidal PWM Converters. in Proceedings IEEE PCC-Nagaoka97, 1997,
12. R Zane and D Maksimovic. A Mixed-singal ASIC Power-factor-correction pp 241-246.
(PFC) Controller for High Frequency Switching Rectifiers. in Proceedings 29. M Y Chang, J Y Lin and Y Y Tzou. DSP Based Fully Digital Control for
IEEE PESC99, 1999, pp 117-122. ac dc Converter with a Non-linear Digital Current Mode Control. in
13. T -Fu Wu, T -W Yu and Y -J Wu. A Microprocessor-based Toggle-control Proceedings IEEE PESC96, 1996, pp 1702-1708.
Lighting System. IEEE Transactions Industrial Electronics, vol 45, June 1998, 30. G V Covic, G L Peters and J T Boys. An Improved Single Phase to Three
pp 525-528. Phase Converter for Low Cost ac Motor Drives. in Proceedings IEEE PEDS95,
14. M Kazerani, P D Ziogas and G Joos. A Novel Active Current Wave 1995, pp 549-554.
Shaping Technique for Solid-state Input Power Factor Conditioners. IEEE 31. M G Kim, W C Lee and D S Hyun. Instantaneous Control of a Single-phase
Transactions Industrial Electronics, vol 38, February 1991, pp 72-78. P/VM Converter Considering the Variation of Observer Parameter. in
15. T C Chen and C T Pan. Modelling and Design of a Single Phase ac to dc Proceedings IEEE IECON97, 1997, pp 839-844.
Converter. IEE Proceedings, vol 136, September 1992, pp 465-470. 32. F Flinders and W Oghanna. Simulation of a Complex Traction PWM
16. M Morimoto, K Oshitani, K Sumito, S Sato, M Ishida and S Okuma. New Rectifier using SIMULINK and the Dynamic Node Technique. in Proceedings
Single-phase Unity Power Factor PWM Converter-inverter System. in IEEE IEEE IECON97, 1997, pp 738-743.
PESC89, 1989, pp 585-589. 33. F Flinders and W Oghanna. The Characteristics of a New Model Based
17. D Abud, F Canles and J Arau. Design of Two Stage, 1 kW ac/dc Power- Controller for Single-phase PWM Rectifier. in Proceedings IEEE IECON97,
factor Pre-regulator using the FB-ZVS-PWM Topology. in Proceedings IEEE 1997, pp 895-900.
CIEP93, 1993, pp 129-134. 34. Y Miyashita, T Nishida, O E Ohtsuji and T Haneyoshi. High Power
18. G Venkataramanan. A Direct ac-dc Converter for Battery Chargers. in Factor PWM Rectifier with Analog Pulse-width Predictor. in Proceedings IEEE
Proceedings IEEE PESC97, 1997, pp 126-130. APEC94, 1994, pp 563-568.
19. D Xu and F C Lee. Two-lower-switch PFC Converter with Active 35. T Shimizu, Y Jin and G Kimura. dc Ripple Current Reduction on a Single-
Snubber. in Proceedings IEEE PESC01, 2001, pp 942-946. phase PWM Voltage Source Rectifier. in Proceedings IEEE IAS99, 1999,
pp 810-817.
20. J Rajagopalan, F C Lee and P Nora. A General Technique for Derivation of
Average Current Mode Control Laws for Single-phase Power-factor 36. O Stihi and B T Ooi. A Single-phase Controlled-current PWM Rectifier.
Correction Circuits without Input Voltage Sensing. IEEE Transactions Power IEEE Transactions Power Electronics, vol 3, October 1988, pp 453-459.
Electronics, vol 14, July 1999, pp 663-672.
37. T Shimizu, T Fujita, G Kimura and J Hirose. Unity-power-factor PWM
21. S Manias. Novel Full Bridge Semi Controller Switch Mode Rectifier. IEE Rectifier with dc Ripple Compensation. in Proceedings IEEE IECON94, 1994,
Proceedings, vol 13, September 1991, pp 252-256. pp 657-662.