The document provides an overview of Apollo Hospitals and Apollo Pharmacy. It describes Apollo Hospitals as a major hospital chain in India founded in 1983. It then discusses Apollo Pharmacy as a retail pharmacy chain owned by Apollo Hospitals with over 1500 stores across major Indian cities. The document also briefly outlines some of the private label products offered by Apollo Pharmacy.
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0 ratings0% found this document useful (0 votes)
397 views
Final Report Hitesh
The document provides an overview of Apollo Hospitals and Apollo Pharmacy. It describes Apollo Hospitals as a major hospital chain in India founded in 1983. It then discusses Apollo Pharmacy as a retail pharmacy chain owned by Apollo Hospitals with over 1500 stores across major Indian cities. The document also briefly outlines some of the private label products offered by Apollo Pharmacy.
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 56
Institute of Management, Nirma University
Final Report on:
The Summer Internship Programme (April10 June14) Organization: Apollo Pharmacy
Submitted by Hitesh Gulati 121322 (MBA Full Time: 2012-14) On July 1 st , 2013 Submitted to: Prof. Jayesh Aagja & Placement Office
2 DECLARATION
I hereby declare that my Summer Internship Project titled Performance of Private Labels" and "Pharmacy Store Insights" are original work done by me under the guidance of Mr. Atul Ahuja, Vice President- Retail at Apollo Pharmacy Div of Apollo Hospitals Enterprises Ltd., E-18/B-1, Mohan Cooperative Industrial Area, Mathura Road, New Delhi-110044. This project has been submitted to Prof. Jayesh Aagja & Mr. Neeraj Arora - Institute of Management, Nirma University in partial fulfilment of academic requirement for the Master of Business Administration (MBA) programme. I also confirm that the project has not been submitted to any other university nor has it been done by any other student earlier for an academic requirement.
3 AUTHOR OF THE PROJECT : Hitesh Gulati
COMPANY NAME : Apollo Pharmacy, Div of Apollo Hospitals Enterprises Ltd.
PURPOSE OF REPORT : Performance of Private Labels and Pharmacy Store Insights
PREPARED FOR : Apollo Pharmacy, Div of Apollo Hospitals Enterprises Ltd.
SUBMITTED TO : Professor Jayesh Aagja & Mr. Neeraj Arora, Manager, Corporate Relations
4
Table of Contents
Executive Summary ............................................................................................ 5 Part A: Profile of the Organization ................................................................ 6 Apollo Hospitals ............................................................................................... 6 Company Vision ................................................................................................ 7 Mission Statement ........................................................................................... 7 Apollo Pharmacy .............................................................................................. 7 Private Label ...................................................................................................... 8 Apollo Hospitals - Directors ......................................................................... 9 MCKINSEYs 7S Model .................................................................................. 21 The Seven Interdependent Elements in the Mckinsey Framework ............................................................................................................................. 22 Competitive position in the Industry (Using Porters Framework) ............................................................................................................................. 24 Part B Project Work ..................................................................................... 27 Private Label Growth:.................................................................................. 27 Evolution Of Private Labels: ...................................................................... 27 Trends In Market .......................................................................................... 28 Future Trends: ............................................................................................... 30 Private Labels at Apollo Pharmacy: ........................................................ 31 Design and Pricing Strategies Followed for PL products: ............... 34 Commercial Implications Of Private Label .......................................... 34 Price Of Private Label Products ............................................................... 35 Performance of Private Label Products (Research Based Project) ............................................................................................................................. 37 Pharmacy Store Insights (Research Based Project).......................... 49 Part C Learning .................................................................................................. 55
5 Executive Summary
Apollo Hospitals is a major hospital chain based in Chennai, India. It was founded by Dr. Prathap C. Reddy in 1983. Its net worth is Rs 2,300 cr. Apollo Pharmacy a unit of Apollo Hospitals is a 30 years old retail pharmacy chain having 1500 stores spread over major cities of India, which includes Delhi, Chennai, Bengaluru, Mumbai, Ahmedabad, Jaipur, Patna, Kolkata, Hyderabad and also in district level in states like Tamil Nadu, Andhra Pradesh. The closest competitor in terms of number of store is Med Plus with 1250 store. Other competitor includes Guardian (120 stores), Religare (110 stores), Dial for Health and 98.4. Apollo Pharmacy has various Private Label products ranging from Instant Energy, Health Food, Vitamin / supplements, Baby Care, Skin Care, Oral Care, Men's Grooming, Hygiene, OTC, Clinical Aid, Home Aid and Generics. PL products accounts for 5% of total sales of the store. Various projects implemented during internship period consisted of comparing PL products based on their performance using measures like Returns per Shelve. Next viability of opening up a new store was analyzed by taking Net Present Value instead of Breakeven time. Also various customer insights were collected like activities a customer go through when in store, thus finding various opportunities for cross selling.
6 PART A: Profile of the Organization Apollo Hospitals Apollo Hospitals is a major hospital chain based in Chennai, India. It was founded by Dr. Prathap C. Reddy in 1983. Its net worth is Rs 2,300 cr. Company Overview It is often said that nothing happens, unless there is a dream first. At the genesis of the Apollo story there was a dream. A dream so powerful, that it helped transform the medical landscape in India. The dream nurtured and grew within Dr. Prathap C Reddy, the founder Chairman of Apollo Hospitals, until the point of inflection happened in 1983. A young man succumbing to an ailing heart was what it took to ignite Dr. Reddy's vision into a reality - a vision where quality healthcare was given, where the pursuit of clinical excellence was daily endeavor, India a hub in the medical tourism map and where the Apollo family touches and enriches lives every minute, every day. Today, with over 8500 beds across 50 hospitals, and a significant presence at every touch- point of the medical value chain, Apollo Hospitals is one of Asias largest healthcare groups. Commenced as a 150 bed hospital, today the group has grown exponentially both in India and overseas. Its growth is often said to be synonymous with India emerging as a major hub in global healthcare. Apollo Hospitals is driven by a single thrust, to provide the best standards of patient care. It is this passion that has lead to the development of unique centers of excellence across medical disciplines, within the Apollo Hospitals network. Apollo Hospitals has JCI accreditations for 7 of its hospitals, the largest by any hospital group in the region. True to its founding principles, the group has made quality healthcare accessible to the people of India, and even overseas. It has become an institution of trust, and a beacon of hope to so many searching for a cure for their ailments.
7 The legacy of touching and enriching lives stems from the pillars of the Apollo philosophy - experience, excellence, expertise and research. We pride ourselves for constantly being on the cutting edge, and going the extra mile to stay relevant and revolutionary. The Apollo Hospitals Group is the pioneer of integrated healthcare delivery in India. This vision led the group to earmark time and resources to strengthen each vital cog in the process of healthcare delivery. As a result of these efforts, the group today is in a unique position to exponentially increase its healthcare cover. This will be critical in order to meet future requirements. Apollo Hospitals Group, today, is an integrated healthcare organization with owned and managed hospitals, diagnostic clinics, dispensing pharmacies and consultancy services. In addition, the groups service offerings include healthcare at the patients doorstep, clinical & diagnostic services, medical business process outsourcing, third party administration services and health insurance. To enhance performance and service to customers, the company also makes available the services to support business, telemedicine services, education, training programs & research services and a host of other non-profit projects. Company Vision Apollo's vision for the next phase of development is to 'Touch a Billion Lives'. Mission Statement "Our mission is to bring healthcare of International standards within the reach of every individual. We are committed to the achievement and maintenance of excellence in education, research and healthcare for the benefit of humanity" Apollo Pharmacy Apollo Pharmacy is a 30 years old retail pharmacy chain with its first outlet opened in 1983. It is spread over major cities of India, which includes Delhi, Chennai, Bengaluru, Mumbai, Ahmedabad, Jaipur, Patna, Kolkata, Hyderabad and also in district level in states like Tamil Nadu, Andhra Pradesh.
8 Apollo Pharmacy is the largest pharmacy chain of India having 1500 stores all over India, the closest competitor in terms of number of store is Med Plus with 1250 store. Other competitor includes Guardian (120 stores), Religare (110 stores), Dial for Health and 98.4. Private Label
Apollo pharmacy provides a range of private label brands which includes Instant Energy, Health Food, Vitamin / supplements, Baby Care, Skin Care, Oral Care, Men's Grooming, Hygiene, OTC, Clinical Aid, Home Aid and Generics. PL products accounts for 5% of total sales of the store.
9 Apollo Hospitals - Directors ACG Worldwide Chairman Mr. Ajit Singh Chairman, Apollo Hospitals Group
Mr. Ajit Singh efforts at ACG have always been focused on creating innovative and practical solutions for the global pharmaceutical and healthcare industries. In the future, we shall continue to pioneer new technologies and products, and work towards achieving improved inclusive growth for all our stakeholders," said Mr. Singh, Chairman at ACG Worldwide (formerly Associated Capsules Group), Asia's largest pharma machinery and consumables supplier. Since 2005, Mr. Singh has served on the Board of Pharmaceutical Sciences of the International Pharmaceutical Federation (FIP) as an Expert Member. He also served as Vice-President and now continues as an Executive Committee Member of the Organization of Pharmaceutical Producers of India (OPPI). He was also nominated on the International Board of the Controlled Release Society, USA.
Executive Directors Gurmit kaur - Corporate HR at ACG Worldwide Hemant Mharte - Head Sales & Marketing at ACG Worldwide Sunil jha - President HR at ACG Worldwide Gargi lad - Assistant Manager - Corporate Marketing
10 V.C shaju - General Manager - Corporate HR at ACG Worldwide Anuj Kabra - Head - Global Business at ACG Worldwide Nikunj Desai - GM Strategic Sourcing at ACG Worldwide (Pam,Pampac,Pam Glatt & ACG Inspection)
11
Stores In Delhi Apollo Pharmacy have 119 stores In Delhi located at following location: S.N O. LOCATION ADDRESS PHONE NO. 1. Sarita Vihar Indraprastha Apollo Hospital Delhi-Mathura Road, Sarita Vihar,New Delhi 110076 011-41626200 011-26825536 2. Noida, Sector - 26 Indraprastha Apollo Hospitals E 2, Sector 26 Noida, Uttar Pradesh 0120-4338867 0120-4548498 3. Vasant Kunj, IMCL Clinic Building No, 1, Sector- B, Pocket- 7, Nelson Mandela Road, Vasant Kunj, New Delhi 110070 011-26139972 011-40574262 4. Connaught Place Shop No. : G - 8, Marina Arcade, Connaught Place, New Delhi 110001 011-23711838 011-43631726 5. Hamdard Nagar Majeedia Hospital, Jamia Hamadard, Hamdard Nagar, New Delhi 110062 011-29959756 011-64648710 6. Dwarka, Sector - 4 G 1, Flat No.- 11, Block MLU Manish Abnav Plaza, Sector 4, Dwarka, New Delhi 011-28081709 011-43601961 7. Supreme Court of India Chamber No. 2, New Chamber Supreme Court of India, Bhagwan Das Road, New Delhi 110001 011-23388582 8. Karol Bagh, Shree Jeewan Hospital Shree Jeewan Hospital 67/1, New Rohtak Roat , Karol Bagh, New Delhi 110005 011-23517338 011-64648755 9. Laxmi Nagar C-1, Aruna Park, Laxmi Nagar, New Delhi 110092 011-22440313 011-43601953 10. East of Kailash, The Apollo The Apollo Clinic F- 4, East of Kailash, New Delhi 011-26451002 011-40576131
12 Clinic 11. East Patel Nagar Shop No. -10A/31, East Patel Nagar New Delhi 110008 011-25882629 011-43466193 12. Kailash Colony Shop No. 2, Plot No. : HS 20, Kailash Colony Market, New Delhi 011-29245612 011-40574327 13. Gole Market Shop. No. - 121, Plot No.-I, Block -88, Lady Harding Road (Bangla Sahib Marg) Gole Market, New Delhi - 110001 011-23363743 011-64648752 14. Rohini, Sector - 9 Shop No- A-16 & 23, North Ex Mall Sector - 9, Rohini, New Delhi- 85 011-27552210 011-43466203 15. Malviya Nagar Shop No. - 18, Old Market, Malviya Nagar, New Delhi 011-26672056 011-40570389 16. Jang Pura Shop No. 370 - 371/3, Lachman Chamber, Sahi Hospital Road, Jangpura, Bhogal, New Delhi 011-24374849 011-43602750 17. Alaknanda Shop No-1, Building No, H-3, Shopping Centre, Kalkaji (Alaknanda) New Delhi-19. 011-26030990 011-64648754 18. Mayur Vihar, Phase - II Shop No-11, 12, Durga Complex, B Block, Mayur Vihar - II, New Delhi 011-22727887 011-43466186 19. Dwarka, Sector - 10 Shop No. : G-3, Ground Floor, Manish Royal Plaza, Plot No. 20, Sector - 10, Dwarka, New Delhi 011-25073491 011-43089564 20. Vasundhara Enclave Shop No.G - 1 & G-4, Vardhaman Plaza, Vasundhara Enclave, Delhi - 91 011-22624655 011-43588223 21. R.K. Puram, Sector - 9 Shop No.- 7, Sector 9, R.K. Puram, New Delhi 011-26183936 011-64648748 22. Khanna Market Shop No.- 46, Khanna Market, New Delhi 011-24641258 011-64648751 23. Krishna Nagar No. : F-3/17, Krishna Nagar, Delhi - 51 011-22099435 011-43465649 24. Rohini, Sector - 13 Shop No. - 18, CSC 2, DDA Market, Sector - 13, Rohini, Delhi 85 011-27550848 011-
20 : 31 - 32 113. Gurgaon, Sushant Lok Shop No. - GF - 53, Sushant Vyapaar Kendra, Sushant Lok, Phase -1, Gurgaon, Haryana 0124-4477603 114. Gurgaon, Sun City Shop No. - 23, LGF, Suncity Arcade,Suncity, Gurgaon, Haryana 0124-4233972 115. Gurgaon, South City - II (Block - B) Shop No. - 11, Shopping Plaza, Block - B, South City - II, Sohna Road, Gurgaon, Haryana. 0124-4233971 116. Gurgaon, Vatika City Shop No. : GF - 05, Vatika City Market, Sector - 49 Gurgaon, Haryana 0124-4285263 8826992282 117. Gurgaon, The Sapphire Shop No. : G - 86, Ground Floor, The Sapphire, Sector - 49 Gurgaon, Haryana 0124-4510462 8826992281 118. Gurgaon, Sector - 14 Shop / Booth No. - 118, Sector : 14, Near Huda Office Gurgaon, Haryana 0124-4265376 8826992284 119. Gurgaon, Aryan Hospital Plot No. - 4, Ranjan Garden, Cant Area, Old Railway Road, Gurgaon, Haryana 0124-4510472 8826992328
21 MCKINSEYs 7S Model The McKinsey 7S Framework is a management model developed by well business consultants Robert H. Waterman, Jr. and Tom Peters (who also developed the MBWA Management by Walking Around" and authored In Search of Excellence in the 1980s. This was a strategic vision for groups, to include l and performance) the model can be used to understand how the organizational well-known businesses, business units, and teams. The 7S are structure, strategy, systems, skills, style, staff and shared values. The model is based on the theory that, for an organization to perform well, these seven elements need to be aligned and mutually reinforcing. So, the model can be used to help identify what needs to be realigned to improve performance, or to maintain alignment during other types of change.
The Seven S Framework first appeared in "The Art of Japanese Management" by Richard Pascale and Anthony Athos in 1981. They had been looking at how Japanese industry had been so successful, at around the same time that Tom Peters and Robert Waterman were exploring what made a company excellent. The Seven S model was born at a meeting of the four authors in 1978. It went on to appear in "In Search of Excellence" by Peters and Waterman, and was taken up as a basic tool by the global management consultancy.
Objective of the Model: To analyze how well an organization is positioned to achieve its intended objective.
Use of this model: The model is most often used as a tool to assess and monitor changes in the internal situation of an organization. 1. Improve the performance of a company 2. Examine the likely effects of future changes within a company 3. Align departments and processes during a merger or acquisition 4. Determine how best to implement a proposed strategy
22 The Seven Interdependent Elements in the Mckinsey Framework The basic premise of the model is that there are seven internal aspects of an organization that need to be aligned if it is to be successful. They are categorized into 2 broad headings: 1. Hard Elements Strategy Structure Systems 2. Soft Elements Shared Values Skills Style Staff
HARD ELEMENTS SOFT ELEMENTS Strategy Structure System Shared Values Skills Style Staff
"Hard" elements are easier to define or identify and management can directly influence them: These are strategy statements; organization charts and reporting lines; and formal processes and IT systems. "Soft" elements, on the other hand, can be more difficult to describe, and are less tangible and more influenced by culture. However, these soft elements are as important as the hard elements if the organization is going to be successful.
7 Elements 1. Strategy: the plan devised to maintain and build competitive advantage over the competition. 2. Structure: the way the organization is structured and who reports to whom. 3. Systems: the daily activities and procedures that staff members engage in to get the job done. 4. Shared Values: called "super ordinate goals" when the model was first developed, these are the core values of the company that are evidenced in the corporate culture and the general work ethic. 5. Style: the style of leadership adopt 6. Staff: the employees and their general capabilities.
23 7. Skills: the actual skills and competencies of the employees working for the company.
1. Strategy: Strategy signifies the course of action that an organization adopts in order to expand and excel its business. It reflects on all those steps and actions that an organization plans in order effectively handle its customers & competitors. Apollo Pharmacy is a leader in pharmacy retail with 1500 stores all over the country strongly capitalizing on its parent brand (Apollo Hospitals) brand name. Under the retail sector, Apollo Pharmacy aims to provide health care related products in its stores. Along with many national brands it also provides many Private Label Health Care Products. 2. Structure: With 1500 stores all over country, each store is sized around 100 sq meters. The stores also provide home delivery covering a radius of 2 km around the store. 3. System: Apollo Pharmacy store is a mix of convenience stores located in residential areas and hospitals and specialty stores having narrow product line confined to health care products and deep assortments. Stores are seven day open from 8 am to 11 pm in summers and 8 am to 10 pm in winters. 4. Shared Values: One of the central objectives of each employee at store is to provide best service to the customer.
24 5. Skills: Skills refers to the expertise of the organization in being successfully able to deliver services as per the expectations of the customer. The key attributes which could be associated with Apollo Pharmacy store are understanding the mood of customer and helping them accordingly. Being a pharmacy store many customers come with mild health problems like light fever and wants recemendations from store helpers for the possible medicine. So store employees should have basic understanding of common disease and their cure. 6. Style: In the IT Services - Apollo Pharmacy practices centralized distribution system where all products national brands and private labels stock is maintained in godown and the sent to each store. Fast moving items are automatically ordered when minimum level is attained, while slow moving items are reordered on store manager's request. In ungent requirment a store can also get products from another store having excess stock. Delivery model is period based with period of two days. 7. Staff: Apollo Pharmacy employs one regional store manager, one store manager and 4 helpers. Mix of male and female helpers is preferred b the company. An operational team is also present to look into the logistics of the products. For Private label products there is an Executive for each product category, with merchandising manager governing all products on whole.
Competitive position in the Industry (Using Porters Framework) The five force framework reputedly known as the Porters Five forces Model has been developed by Michael Porter Professor, Harvard Business School and has been published in his book Competitive Strategy: Techniques for Analyzing Industries and Competitors in the year 1980. Since then, the model is considered as a significant tool for analyzing an organizations industry structure in terms of strategy. Porters Five Force model is institutionalised on the concept that a corporate strategy should be able to capitalize on the opportunities and safeguard the organisation from the
25 potential threats of the external environment. Porters Five Forces are briefly classified into Horizontal & Vertical competition which includes: Competitive Rivalry (Horizontal) Bargaining Power of Suppliers (Vertical) Threat of New Entrant (Horizontal) Bargaining Power of buyers (Vertical) Threat of Substitution (Horizontal) Porter's Five Forces
Horizontal Competition: Competitive Rivalry: In pharmacy retail chain Apollo Pharmacy is leader with 1500 stores country wide and closest competetior Med Plus having 1250 stores. Main threat for Apollo is from unorganized sector as they are present for long time and haave built relations with local customer. Also they are able to provide additional discount by not providing the bill of purchase.
26 Threat of Substitution: Health care products being a vary basic necesity wont decline in near future. As the concept require the have wide assortments other stores are reluctant of keep its inventory. So threat of substitution is of less magnitude. Threat of New Entry: Retail stores having high operational cost and high fixed costs reuire business to run on loss for initial time. Apollo has 1500 stores country wide and thus enjoys superior position. Although threat of new entrant is there but it will be gradual. Vertical Competition: Supplier Power: National Brands supplier enjoys the supplier power and can dictate their terms but private labels are effective way to reduce the power. Apollo Pharmacy outsource the manufacturing of private label products to regional players and thus enjoys less or no supplier power. Buyer Power: Generally there are more than one pharmacy stores present in one locality and customers are not loyal to any one store specially to organized store the customer have buying power. But here again private label products helps company to hold the customers as those private label products are avaliable only on their stores. Stores also provides services like Loyalty Membership cards and Home Delivery to hold their customers.
27 Part B Project Work
PRIVATE LABEL GROWTH:
Growth in private label sales at retail stores is basically owing to the consumers perception of the brand image of that particular store. The name Apollo has become synonymous with trust and values that it has imbibed over the years and the same are reflected in each transaction at Apollo Pharmacy. Consumers think that any in house product being offered by Apollo would be certainly good in terms of quality and offer value for money, a name that they can always rely upon EVOLUTION OF PRIVATE LABELS: PHASE 1: IMPORT In the late 19 th century,cooperative retailers in particular imported exotic products that were sold loose or were pre packed under the traders logo RETAILER CONSUMERS Well informed, well educated Consumer trust Long market presence of PL RETAIL ENVIRONMENT Highly developed market Highly concentrated market International players High density of outlets Fierce price competition Discounter expansion
28 PHASE 2: VALUE ALTERNATIVES In the 20 th century retailers began to evaluate value alternatives to established brands especiallly in categories as paper products with lower levels of brand loyalty. PHASE 3: SEGMENTATION BY PRICE While economy lines have been used to defeat price aggressive retailers such as discount stores,standard lines,sold mostly under the retailers banner name,have offered brand like quality at lower price while premium priced lines have been developed to expand the price and quality spectrum. PHASE 4: SEGMENTATION BY CATEGORIES(SUB BRANDING) Many retailers have started to develop special interest brands catering for specific consumer segment.Depending on the ranges concerned,sub brands have been either used or totally new fantasy labels. PHASE 5: SEGMENTATION BY BRAND ATTRIBUTES,ETHICAL CREDENTIALS The development of private labels satisfying consumer demand for products thst embrace ethical credentials.
TRENDS IN MARKET (1) PRIVATE LABEL SHARE TRENDS Over the past several years, private label has consistently accounted for about 16% of CPG spending and one-fifth of products purchased. Though not remarkable, the growth trend has been slightly positive each of the past four years. This past year has seen escalating growth rates as consumers increasingly turn to private label in order to save money on packaged goods. Private label share growth has accelerated across all income segments over the past year as consumers struggle under intense economic pressures.
29
(2) CHANNEL SHARE
Private label share varies across retail channels, and is highest among grocery retailers. Share growth, however, is strongest among retailers in the drug channel. Over the past year, private label share of drug sales (dollar and unit) climbed one full point. The catalyst behind this growth is likely multi-pronged. As illustrated in IRIs Transforming Economy: Shoppers in Crisis drug channel basket rings have grown as consumers increasingly turn to the channel for local fill-in trips. At the same time, self-care behavior is up sharply, reflective of consumer efforts to limit expenditures wherever possible, including efforts to reduce trips to the doctor.
(3) DEPARTMENT SHARE Private label offerings of OTC products have grown significantly over the past year, lifted by growing numbers of prescription products moving to OTC, and retailer efforts to capitalize on functional and customized product features to create a unique private label offering (e.g. fast-melt variations, slow release, etc). Across channels, private label now represents one-third of healthcare department units and one-quarter of department sales. Private label unit growth within the healthcare department has significantly outpaced growth in any other department. This is good news for drug retailers. As a destination location for healthcare products, the channel is well- positioned to compete
(4) PRIVATE LABEL PURCHASE SEGMENT The concentrated nature of private label extends beyond the number of categories offered, also describing the number of habitual private label purchasers in CPG today.
30 Though nearly everyone purchases some private label products at some point- private label penetration remains firm at 100%- a notable 33% of shoppers are considered heavy buyers of private label goods. This valuable private label consumer segment actually accounts for nearly two-thirds of private label sales.
(5) CONSUMER SPENDING BY SEGMENT Private label penetration and share of spending is strongly impacted by demographics. Transforming Economy: Shoppers in Crisis report reveals, though, that in these tough economic times, wealthier consumers have stepped up private label purchase activity as they seek value through substitution rather than opting out of a category completely. Another key indicator of private label spending is household size. Private label penetration increases sharply with household size. Particularly in todays economy, larger households are looking to stretch their CPG dollars as far as possible. Private label products go a long way to answering this need for value. To compete effectively, retailers must strictly adhere to segmented private label strategies. Multi-tiered offerings will bring broader appeal, and those retailers that successfully establish a halo brand will reap sizable private label share increases.
FUTURE TRENDS: (1) Multiple Availability of private labels in co-operation with other retailers: This goes hand in hand with decreasing brand availability. Safeway in the US launched the Better Living Brands Alliance in a bid to expand its organic and healthy eating private labels via third parties Waitrose, UK, sells its private label products via Indian Retailer K Raheja in its Hyper CITY stores (2) Channel Blurring: Foodservice companies bring their products on retailers shelves and vice versa. McDonalds tomato ketchup is available from supermarkets, for instance in Germany Wal-Mart sells chilled drinks under its private labels
31 (3) Co-branding and tailor-made solutions as a result from co-operation with manufacturer brands to tailor their offers to their target groups French Fromagerie Bels cheese brand Babybel with Aldis Be light healthy eating private label. Private Labels at Apollo Pharmacy: Category Products Instant Energy Drinks Glucose D ORS
Herbal Juice Aloe Vera Juice Amla Juice Karela Juice Noni Juice Honey Green Tea Diet Green Tea Sweetner Breakfast Cereals Granola Bar Oil
Digestive Health Antacid Triphala Sat-Isabgol
Vitamin/ Supplements Multi Vitamin Dietry Supplement Chawanprash Protein Supplement
32 Baby Care Hygiene Bibs Matt Feeding Bottle Diapers Wipes
Skin Care Moisturisers Lotions Rose Water Scrubs Shampoo Soaps Face Wash Shower Gel
Oral Care Toothbrush Adult Toothbrush Kids Toothpaste Mouthwash
Men's Grooming Shave Gel Shave Cream After Shave Lotion Deodrant Soap Hair Gel Deodrant Spray Shaving Brush Shaving Razor
33 Hygiene Refreshing Wipes Soft Tissues Nail Clippers Cotton Buds Cotton Balls Adult Diapers Sanitary Pad Hand Sanitizers Hand Wash
Clinical Aid Povidone Iodine Solution Povidone Iodine Ointment Disinfectant Crepe Bandage Medical Support Microporous Surgical Tape
34
Home Aid Nebulizer Blood Pressure Moniter Vapourizer Thermometer Pregnancy Test Card Hot Water Bottle Pain Relief Adhesive Bandage Antiseptic Liquid First Aid Kit Design and Pricing Strategies Followed for PL products: 1. Price Competetion: The Prices of PL products are less than their National Brand counter part, thus giving consumers benefit of low price. 2. Me-Too: The design of PL products are similar to their national brands counter part thus conveying the message of what products it substitutes. COMMERCIAL IMPLICATIONS OF PRIVATE LABEL Retailers are focusing on Private Label as a means to delivering gross margin and Brand Enhancement objectives. Higher and unavoidable overhead costs are driving the need for improving Gross Margins Private label allow Retailers to design for their specific target market Increased channel control allows Retailers flexibly to be responsive to trend cycles Increased product differentiation protects the Retailers market share The commercial implications of Private label are: Improve Profitability
35 Build and maintain consumer loyalty. Reinforce Market Position Increase Consumer Choice Match Products more precisely to Retailers Customers
Some other factors include: Enhancement of Store Image Better control of Supply Chain and Product quality Differentiation from competitors
PRICE OF PRIVATE LABEL PRODUCTS Private Label products may be cheaper to produce for a number of reasons: (i) Where private label uses the manufacturer brands as the benchmark it might be seen as capitalizing upon some of the original product development and marketing; (ii) Manufacturers may produce private label at prices that reflect only the direct manufacturing costs in order to fill excess production capacity; (iii) If the manufacturers sales force and distribution channels are not used, the retailers buying price can be reduced; (iv) If the retailer has enough (marginal) buying power, it might be able to negotiate a reduction in the manufacturers profit margin An Example of the Costs Avoided with Private Label
36 SN COMPONENT MANUFACTURED BRAND PRIVATE LABEL 1. Raw Materials 35 35 2. Packaging Material 12 12 3. Manufactured Costs Variable Fixed
9 5
9 -- 4. Research & Development 3 -- 5. Sales Force 4 -- 6. Advertising & Promotion 9 5 7. Transport & Distribution 5 2 8. Other Costs 10 10 9. Operating Profit 8 2 10. Retailer Buying Price 100 75
In the above mentioned example, all costs are an approximate prediction. The actual costs may actually vary across different product categories. PRICE
37 Pricing by Private Brand may either be: Premium Pricing Value for money pricing Both of them contribute towards Store Image Store LoyaltyCustomer FootfallsStores Bargaining PowerStore marginStore Profits
In sum, the benefits to a retailer from the introduction of store brands are (i) Higher unit margin on national brands (ii) Expansion of the category sales and (iii) Higher category margin from sales volume
Performance of Private Label Products (Research Based Project) Central Problem: Apollo having variety of PL products of different sizes and different prices it complicated to compare their performances. Objectives Summer Internship Programme To compare the performance of PL products in most appropiate way. Action Plan: To compare the performance interview was conducted with merchandising manager and executive of all product categories. In all three methids were used to eveluate the performance of PL products quantitatevily.
38 1. Average sales per month: This method gives clear picture about cash flow due to the product and its movement. But as different product had different margins comparing based on sales itself is not enough. 2. Average returns per month: This method being more closely related to margin is prefered over Average sales per month. 3. Returns per Shelve: In a small retail store of size 200-250 sq ft, physical space is also a matter of concern. There are only limited shelves where products can be displayed. So products of small size have advantage over products acquring more space. In this method a hypothetical shelve is considered which is filled only with one type of pruduct. The returns (returns=sales-cost) of this shelve will denote much accurate performance measure as it include store's operational cost. A basket of products was chosen as adviced by the merchandising manager. Following products was considered for the pilot study. ITEM NAME Category MRP AP THERMOMETER DIGITAL Home Aid 195 AP AMLA JUICE 1 LTR. Health Food 205 AP SENSITIVE TOOTH BRUSH 12S Oral care 35 AP COUGH DROPS 300S JAR OTC 1 AP BP MONITOR Home Aid 1999 AP AMLA JUICE 500ML Health Food 130 AP GREEN TEA 25'S Health Food 85 AP NONI JUICE 500ML Health Food 550 AP ALOE VERA JUICE 500 ML Health Food 160 AP ALOEVERA JUICE 1 LTR Health Food 245 AP HAND SANITIZER 100ML Hygeine 55 AP HAND SANITIZER 250 ML Hygeine 99 AP HAND SANITIZER 50ML Hygeine 35 AP PREMIUM TOOTHBRUSH Oral care 28
39 AP DAILY FRESH TOOTHBRUSH TWIN PACK Oral care 35 AP POPULAR TOOTHBRUSH Oral care 18 AP SUPER CLEAN TOOTH BRUSH Oral care 10 AP PREMIUM SERIES TOOTH BRUSH Oral care 22 AP TOOTHPASTE MENTHOL 80GM Oral care 33 AP TOOTHPASTE RED GEL 80GM Oral care 33 Now the sales figure of all products were collected for past year from April '12 to March '13. Problems faced at this step was that some products was released only 6 months back, some products were out of stock due to operational problems and thus suffered sales drop. To avoid this average quantity sold per month was calculated ignoring period of out of stock. Also the prices were inflated during past year quite a few times and for almost all products. As described by the merchandising manager prices were inflated not to affect sales but due to increased manufacturing cost and to maintain constant margin. Thus in order to measure their performance their quantity sold was multiplied by current price to calculate hypothetical average sales per month. ITEM NAME Category MRP Average quantity sold per month Average Sales per month AP BP MONITOR Home Aid 1999 592.5714286 1184550.29 AP THERMOMETER DIGITAL Home Aid 195 5228.75 1019606.25 AP AMLA JUICE 1 LTR. Health Food 205 4549.333333 932613.33 AP GREEN TEA 25'S Health Food 85 10699.77778 909481.11 AP NONI JUICE 500ML Health Food 550 1388.9 763895.00 AP SENSITIVE TOOTH BRUSH 12S Oral care 35 21558.41667 754544.58
40 AP COUGH DROPS 300S JAR OTC 1 697278.1667 697278.17 AP AMLA JUICE 500ML Health Food 130 5297.5 688675.00 AP ALOE VERA JUICE 500 ML Health Food 160 3383.916667 541426.67 AP ALOEVERA JUICE 1 LTR Health Food 245 2204 539980.00 AP HAND SANITIZER 100ML Hygeine 55 7109.5 391022.50 AP PREMIUM TOOTHBRUSH Oral care 28 7625.416667 213511.67 AP PREMIUM SERIES TOOTH BRUSH Oral care 22 8536.166667 187795.67 AP HAND SANITIZER 50ML Hygeine 35 4659.416667 163079.58 AP DAILY FRESH TOOTHBRUSH TWIN PACK Oral care 35 4364.333333 152751.67 AP POPULAR TOOTHBRUSH Oral care 18 8470.333333 152466.00 AP HAND SANITIZER 250 ML Hygeine 99 1487.166667 147229.50 AP SUPER CLEAN TOOTH BRUSH Oral care 10 11617.66667 116176.67 AP TOOTHPASTE MENTHOL 80GM Oral care 33 3164.166667 104417.50 AP TOOTHPASTE RED GEL 80GM Oral care 33 851.5714286 28101.86
41 Thus at this stage we got products ranked based on average sales per month. To get returns by each product costing of each product was considered. The cost included following : 1. Manufactures Price 2. Excise 3. Freight Charges 4. Logistics 5. Sales Tax A list was complied with cost of each product and its margin percent was calculated. ITEM NAME Category MRP Cost Margin Margin Percent AP THERMOMETER DIGITAL Home Aid 195 60.544 134.456 68.95% AP AMLA JUICE 1 LTR. Health Food 205 82.28 122.72 59.86% AP SENSITIVE TOOTH BRUSH 12S Oral care 35 13.112 21.888 62.54% AP COUGH DROPS 300S JAR OTC 300 136.29 163.71 54.57% AP BP MONITOR Home Aid 1999 926 1073 53.68% AP AMLA JUICE 500ML Health Food 130 45.804 84.196 64.77% AP GREEN TEA 25'S Health Food 85 28.27 56.73 66.74% AP NONI JUICE 500ML Health Food 550 288.2 261.8 47.60% AP ALOE VERA JUICE 500 ML Health Food 160 72.138 87.862 54.91% AP ALOEVERA Health Food 245 135.124 109.876 44.85%
42 JUICE 1 LTR AP HAND SANITIZER 100ML Hygeine 55 19.437 35.563 64.66% AP HAND SANITIZER 250 ML Hygeine 99 49.874 49.126 49.62% AP HAND SANITIZER 50ML Hygeine 35 14.3 20.7 59.14% AP PREMIUM TOOTHBRUSH Oral care 28 14.212 13.788 49.24% AP DAILY FRESH TOOTHBRUSH TWIN PACK Oral care 35 18.458 16.542 47.26% AP POPULAR TOOTHBRUSH Oral care 18 9.724 8.276 45.98% AP SUPER CLEAN TOOTH BRUSH Oral care 10 5.434 4.566 45.66% AP PREMIUM SERIES TOOTH BRUSH Oral care 22 12.144 9.856 44.80% AP TOOTHPASTE MENTHOL 80GM Oral care 33 19.998 13.002 39.40% AP TOOTHPASTE RED GEL 80GM Oral care 33 22.429 10.571 32.03% The margin percent when multiplied by sales gives the returns per month for the product. ITEM NAME Category MRP Margin Percent Sales Returns AP THERMOMETER DIGITAL Home Aid 195 68.95% 1019606.2 5 703036.81 AP BP MONITOR Home Aid 1999 53.68% 1184550.2 9 635829.14
43 AP GREEN TEA 25'S Health Food 85 66.74% 909481.11 606998.39 AP AMLA JUICE 1 LTR. Health Food 205 59.86% 932613.33 558294.19 AP SENSITIVE TOOTH BRUSH 12S Oral care 35 62.54% 754544.58 471870.62 AP AMLA JUICE 500ML Health Food 130 64.77% 688675.00 446028.31 AP COUGH DROPS 300S JAR OTC 1 54.57% 697278.17 380504.70 AP NONI JUICE 500ML Health Food 550 47.60% 763895.00 363614.02 AP ALOE VERA JUICE 500 ML Health Food 160 54.91% 541426.67 297317.69 AP HAND SANITIZER 100ML Hygeine 55 64.66% 391022.50 252835.15 AP ALOEVERA JUICE 1 LTR Health Food 245 44.85% 539980.00 242166.70 AP PREMIUM TOOTHBRUSH Oral care 28 49.24% 213511.67 105139.25 AP HAND SANITIZER 50ML Hygeine 35 59.14% 163079.58 96449.93 AP PREMIUM SERIES TOOTH BRUSH Oral care 22 44.80% 187795.67 84132.46 AP HAND SANITIZER 250 ML Hygeine 99 49.62% 147229.50 73058.55 AP DAILY FRESH TOOTHBRUSH TWIN PACK Oral care 35 47.26% 152751.67 72194.80 AP POPULAR Oral care 18 45.98% 152466.00 70100.48
44 TOOTHBRUSH AP SUPER CLEAN TOOTH BRUSH Oral care 10 45.66% 116176.67 53046.27 AP TOOTHPASTE MENTHOL 80GM Oral care 33 39.40% 104417.50 41140.50 AP TOOTHPASTE RED GEL 80GM Oral care 33 32.03% 28101.86 9001.96 In above table products are arranged according to returns per month. Next to calculate returns per shelve, a typical shelf was cleared and then fully filled by each product. The number of products that can be accommodated on each shelve was noted. ITEM NAME Category MRP Self Use type Box Size Capacit y in one Shelf Total Units in one shelf AP THERMOMETER DIGITAL Home Aid 195 Box 10 8 80 AP AMLA JUICE 1 LTR. Health Food 205 Individu al Units 1 32 32 AP SENSITIVE TOOTH BRUSH 12S Oral care 35 Box 11 9 99 AP COUGH DROPS 300S JAR OTC 1 Box 300 10 3000 AP BP MONITOR Home Aid 1999 Individu al Units 1 7 7 AP AMLA JUICE 500ML Health Food 130 Individu al Units 1 32 32 AP GREEN TEA 25'S Health Food 85 Individu al Units 1 40 40
45 AP NONI JUICE 500ML Health Food 550 Individu al Units 1 32 32 AP ALOE VERA JUICE 500 ML Health Food 160 Individu al Units 1 32 32 AP ALOEVERA JUICE 1 LTR Health Food 245 Individu al Units 1 32 32 AP HAND SANITIZER 100ML Hygeine 55 Individu al Units 1 50 50 AP HAND SANITIZER 250 ML Hygeine 99 Individu al Units 1 40 40 AP HAND SANITIZER 50ML Hygeine 35 Individu al Units 1 75 75 AP PREMIUM TOOTHBRUSH Oral care 28 Box 11 9 99 AP DAILY FRESH TOOTHBRUSH TWIN PACK Oral care 35 Box 11 9 99 AP POPULAR TOOTHBRUSH Oral care 18 Box 11 9 99 AP SUPER CLEAN TOOTH BRUSH Oral care 10 Box 11 9 99 AP PREMIUM SERIES TOOTH BRUSH Oral care 22 Box 11 9 99 AP TOOTHPASTE MENTHOL 80GM Oral care 33 Individu al Units 1 119 119 AP TOOTHPASTE RED GEL 80GM Oral care 33 Individu al Units 1 119 119 To calculate returns per shelve number of shelves were calculated to store one month's inventory.
46
ITEM NAME Category MRP Total Units in one shelf Average Monthly Sales Total Shelves AP THERMOMETER DIGITAL Home Aid 195 80 5228.75 65.36 AP AMLA JUICE 1 LTR. Health Food 205 32 4549.33 142.17 AP SENSITIVE TOOTH BRUSH 12S Oral care 35 99 21558.42 217.76 AP COUGH DROPS 300S JAR OTC 1 3000 697278.17 232.43 AP BP MONITOR Home Aid 1999 7 592.57 84.65 AP AMLA JUICE 500ML Health Food 130 32 5297.50 165.55 AP GREEN TEA 25'S Health Food 85 40 10699.78 267.49 AP NONI JUICE 500ML Health Food 550 32 1388.90 43.40 AP ALOE VERA JUICE 500 ML Health Food 160 32 3383.92 105.75 AP ALOEVERA JUICE 1 LTR Health Food 245 32 2204.00 68.88 AP HAND SANITIZER 100ML Hygiene 55 50 7109.50 142.19 AP HAND SANITIZER 250 ML Hygiene 99 40 1487.17 37.18 AP HAND SANITIZER 50ML Hygiene 35 75 4659.42 62.13 AP PREMIUM TOOTHBRUSH Oral care 28 99 7625.42 77.02
47 AP DAILY FRESH TOOTHBRUSH TWIN PACK Oral care 35 99 4364.33 44.08 AP POPULAR TOOTHBRUSH Oral care 18 99 8470.33 85.56 AP SUPER CLEAN TOOTH BRUSH Oral care 10 99 11617.67 117.35 AP PREMIUM SERIES TOOTH BRUSH Oral care 22 99 8536.17 86.22 AP TOOTHPASTE MENTHOL 80GM Oral care 33 119 3164.17 26.59 AP TOOTHPASTE RED GEL 80GM Oral care 33 119 851.57 7.16 Now monthly margin was divided by number of shelves to get returns per shelve. ITEM NAME Category MRP Total Shelves Average Monthly Margin Returns per shelve AP COUGH DROPS 300S JAR OTC 1 23 380504.70 16371.00 AP THERMOMETER DIGITAL Home Aid 195 65.36 703036.81 10756.48 AP NONI JUICE 500ML Health Food 550 43.40 363614.02 8377.60 AP BP MONITOR Home Aid 1999 84.65 635829.14 7511.00 AP AMLA JUICE 1 LTR. Health Food 205 142.17 558294.19 3927.04 AP ALOEVERA JUICE 1 LTR Health Food 245 68.88 242166.70 3516.03 AP ALOE VERA JUICE 500 ML Health Food 160 105.75 297317.69 2811.58 AP AMLA JUICE 500ML Health 130 165.55 446028.31 2694.27
48 Food AP GREEN TEA 25'S Health Food 85 267.49 606998.39 2269.20 AP SENSITIVE TOOTH BRUSH 12S Oral care 35 217.76 471870.62 2166.91 AP HAND SANITIZER 250 ML Hygiene 99 37.18 73058.55 1965.04 AP HAND SANITIZER 100ML Hygiene 55 142.19 252835.15 1778.15 AP DAILY FRESH TOOTHBRUSH TWIN PACK Oral care 35 44.08 72194.80 1637.66 AP HAND SANITIZER 50ML Hygiene 35 62.13 96449.93 1552.50 AP TOOTHPASTE MENTHOL 80GM Oral care 33 26.59 41140.50 1547.24 AP PREMIUM TOOTHBRUSH Oral care 28 77.02 105139.25 1365.01 AP TOOTHPASTE RED GEL 80GM Oral care 33 7.16 9001.96 1257.95 AP PREMIUM SERIES TOOTH BRUSH Oral care 22 86.22 84132.46 975.74 AP POPULAR TOOTHBRUSH Oral care 18 85.56 70100.48 819.32 AP SUPER CLEAN TOOTH BRUSH Oral care 10 117.35 53046.27 452.03
Thus the products were ranked according to returns per shelve.
49 Pharmacy Store Insights (Research Based Project) Analyzing the business model of the pharmacy retail chains to understand the potential margins and return ratios that the business can generate. These analyses have been done at store level based on discussions with the operational team. Sales mix - Typically in a pharmacy store, prescription drugs account for 70-75% of the total sales, followed by 20-25% sale from OTC products and 5-7% from private label goods. Margin Gross margin on prescription drugs is 20-22%, 8-10% on the OTC products and 35- 40% on private label goods. Fixed costs A store with 250-300 sq ft of area has fixed cost of 1 mn per year, including rentals, electricity expenses, staff costs and other incidental expenses. Investments and working capital Initial investment per store is 2 mn which includes security deposits to the lessor, interiors and pre-operative expenses. Working capital requirements would be negligible as inventory requirements of 30-35 days are offset by credit period of 30-35 for the goods purchased. Various financials reports were collected of the firm of past five years to calculate the Beta for the firm (Apollo pharmacy is not a separately listed company so financials reports of Apollo Hospitals were considered).
Thus WACC (Weighted Average Cost of Capital) for Apollo Hospital comes out to be 11.858%. Using this WACC we can compute Net Present Value (NPV) for a store, which will help in taking decision of opening a store. Assuming a new store generates average of 50 bills per day with average value of Rs 150. Thus daily sales will be Rs 7500. Now with the following details yearly analyses will be: Revenue per day 7500 Growth 15% Growth Period 3 Inflation 0.08 WACC 11.86%
260576.52 333264.50 418790.12 519233.77 565797.00 PAT
569198.48 727976.75 914797.32 1134204.58 1235916.42 Net Cash Flow -2000000.00 569198.48 727976.75 914797.32 1134204.58 10422479.85 Net Present Value 468752.82
Initially a growth of 15% is considered for a period of 4 years from 5th year onwards growth is taken as inflation rate. Here we can see NPV of around 4.5 Lacs. But if we slightly alter our assumption of 50 bills per day to 40 bills, analyses will be as follows:
53 Revenue per day 6000 Growth 15% Growth Period 3 Inflation 0.08 WACC 11.86%
Here we can see although the store has positive cash flow since year one but NPV is less than one. So financially this is not a good option to consider. But again in retail chain increasing number of store is considered as a good option if one can financially support it as in future one can leverage its presence to drive more sales. Measures to drive more sales can be: 1. Upselling: This option is viable for prescription-based customers, as they require specific product of specific quantity. 2. Cross Selling: This option is best suited for pharmacy stores as customer can be persuaded for supplement products to their prescription. To properly implement Cross selling one needs to know Customer Insights. Typically customers are of three types: 1. Prescription-Based customer: This customer has a doctors prescription and requires specific prescription drugs of specific quantity. 2. Prescription Drugs on Advice: These customers have minor sickness and buy prescription drugs based on advice given by the store incharge. 3. Product Seeking: These customers are in store to buy products other than prescription drugs. These customers can be most valuable as they can be influenced to buy PL products that have highest margin. An observational research was conducted across five different store with cumulative sample size of 100 customers. This study revealed that all customers out of the sample can with a specific purpose and belong to one of three categories but while observing the displayed products made impulsive decision to buy additional products. Thus the time a
55 customer spends in a store is also crucial. The time spent by a customer can be broken down into three parts: 1. Entry to order: When customer enters they informs the store in charge about their demands, customer is busy during this time period. According to study customer spent around 11sec in this period. 2. Waiting: While the store in charge collects the order of customer the customer is waiting and this is the crucial time when they can be influenced to cross sell by other in charge. Study revealed that customer spent around 1 min and 41 seconds in during this period. 3. Billing: While customer is not busy during this stage but none was willing to buy more products as billing was already in progress. Customer spent around 29 seconds in this period.
PART C Learning The Internship was extremely helpful for me to understand workings of a big corporate. Various tolls, which were helpful to me included: Research Methodology: I took two projects and both were experiment based. While I got data from secondary sources of from one of the project an in store observational study was conducted with the help of store manager. Financial Investment: At Apollo Pharmacy while opening a new store breakeven point is estimated and if it is somewhere below 18 months it is considered a good investment. I tried to apply the method of Net Present Value to estimate value of a new store taking the cost of capital into account. I also picked up various new skills, which included:
56 Returns itself is not important for any business. There are many constraints to which business has to stick. Like at store physical space is a constraint, so returns per shelve is a better valuation than monthly margin. I learned how a customer behave while in a store and what all activities he go through before leaving the store. Due to this one can find opportunities of increasing sales per bill by cross selling. I also learned about how PL products are able to get good margin and maintaining to quality by enhancing the value chain.