Production & Operation Management
Production & Operation Management
PRODUCTION AND
OPERATIONS
MANAGEMENT
Managing Director
Akshaya Management Consultancy Services
Bangalore - 560 085
Karnataka, India
MUMBAI NEW DELHI NAGPUR BENGALURU HYDERABAD CHENNAI PUNE LUCKNOW AHMEDABAD
ERNAKULAM BHUBANESWAR INDORE KOLKATA GUWAHATI
Author
No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means,
electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording and/or otherwise without the prior written permission of the publishers.
Published by
Branch Offices
New Delhi
: Pooja Apartments, 4-B, Murari Lal Street, Ansari Road, Darya Ganj,
New Delhi - 110 002. Phone: 011-23270392, 23278631; Fax: 011-23256286
Nagpur
Bengaluru
: No. 16/1 (Old 12/1), 1st Floor, Next to Hotel Highlands, Madhava Nagar,
Race Course Road, Bengaluru - 560 001. Phone: 080-32919385;
Telefax: 080-22286611
Hyderabad
Chennai
Pune
Lucknow
: Jai Baba Bhavan, Church Road, Near Manas Complex and Dr. Awasthi Clinic,
Aliganj, Lucknow - 226 024. Phone: 0522-2339329, 4068914;
Mobile: 09305302158, 09415349385, 09389593752
Ahmedabad
: 114, SHAIL, 1st Floor, Opp. Madhu Sudan House, C.G. Road,
Navrang Pura, Ahmedabad - 380 009. Phone: 079-26560126;
Mobile: 09327324149, 09314679413
Ernakulam
Bhubaneswar
Indore
: Kesardeep Avenue Extension, 73, Narayan Bagh, Flat No. 302, IIIrd Floor,
Near Humpty Dumpty School, Narayan Bagh, Indore - 452 007 (M.P.).
Mobile: 09301386468
Kolkata
Guwahati
: House No. 15, Behind Pragjyotish College, Near Sharma Printing Press,
P.O. Bharalumukh, Guwahati - 781009. (Assam).
Mobile: 09883055590, 09883055536
DTP by
Printed by
: New Delhi.
Preface
Production and Operation Management (POM) is about the transformation of
production and operational inputs into outputs, that when distributed, meet the needs of customers.
POM incorporates many interdependent tasks which can be grouped under five main headings
viz., Product, Plant, Processes, Programmes and People. Production and Operations Managers
ensure that quality products are produced and delivered as quickly and cost effectively as
possible. Therefore, a basic knowledge of this subject is essential for students of MBA
programmes.
This book comprises 11 chapters covering various important topics such as Operations
Strategy, Production Planning and Control, Design of Production Systems, Design of Work
Systems, Aggregate Production Planning, Project Management, Scheduling of Operations,
Maintenance Management, Quality Management and Facility Location and Layout.
This book is specifically designed to cover the syllabus of MBA programme offered by
Biju Patnaik University of Technology. However, it may be found useful to students of MBA
programme of any other Indian university as well. The book has special features such as
illustrations, solved problems, review questions, problems to be solved and case illustrations
and case exercises.
I have great pleasure to express my sincere thanks to Sri Niraj Pandey and Sri Anuj Pandey
of Himalaya Publishing House for their keen interest and effort to publish this book. I am also
thankful to Sri Vijay Pandey for his effort in printing and promoting this book in a very short time.
I thank Sri B.S. Madhu and Smt. Divya of M/s Page Designers for their excellent D.T.P.
work. I am also thankful to Smt. Nimisha, Sri Rajesh, Sri Yogesh of HPH production unit
for their effort in designing the cover page and printing this book.
I also thank my family members, friends and well-wishers for their constant support and
encouragement for this endeavour. I also thank one and all who have directly or indirectly helped
or supported me in my work. I invite readers, both students and teachers to offer their valuable
suggestions as a feedback to me so as to improve the book in its future editions.
K. SHRIDHARA BHAT
No.680, Akshaya, 1 C Main,
Kempegowda Layout, 3rd Block,
3rd Phase, Banashankari III Stage
Bangalore - 560 085.
Phone : (080) 26694761
Email : [email protected]
Contents
CHAPTER 1. OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT - AN OVERVIEW
1 - 30
31 - 46
47 - 70
71 - 111
112 - 156
157 - 185
186 - 209
210-237
Project Management Project Life Cycle Project Organisation The Role of a Project
Manager Problems in Managing a Project Project Planning and Control Techniques
Network Fundamentals Commonly Used Network Symbols Terms used in Network
Based Scheduling Techniques Networking Conventions Project Scheduling
Techniques Scheduling Chart (Gantt Chart or Horizontal Bar Chart) Programme
Evaluation and Review Technique (PERT) and Critical Path Method (CPM) Critical Path
Method (CPM) Purpose of CPM Procedure for Drawing up a CPM Network CPM
- Time Analysis Programme Evaluation and Review Technique (PERT) Determining
Probability of Meeting Scheduled Date in PERT Analysis Crashing CPM Networks
Steps in Network Crashing Solved Problems Review Questions
238 - 270
271 - 300
301 - 363
364 - 395
396 - 426
427 - 483
ANNEXURE
484 - 486
CASE ILLUSTRATIONS
487 - 501
CASE EXERCISES
502 - 510
INDEX
511 - 522
CHAPTER ONE
Meaning of "Production"
Production implies the creation of goods and services to satisfy human needs. It involves conversion
of inputs (resources) into outputs (products). It is a process by which, raw materials and other inputs are
converted into finished products. Earlier the word "manufacturing" was used synonymously with the word
"production", but nowadays, we use the term "manufacturing" to refer to the process of producing only
tangible goods whereas the word "production" (or operation) is used to refer to the process of creating both
goods (which are tangibles) as well as services (which are intangibles).
Any process which involves the conversion of raw materials and bought-out components into finished
products for sale is known as production. Such conversion of inputs adds to the value or utility of the
products produced by the conversion or transformation process. The utility or added value is the difference
between the value of outputs and the value of inputs. The value addition to inputs is brought about by
alteration, transportation, storage or preservation and quality assurance.
Meaning of Operations
The term operations refers to a function or system that transforms inputs into outputs of greater value.
Operations are often defined as a transformation or conversion process wherein inputs such as materials,
machines, labour and capital are transformed into outputs (goods and services). In a productive system, if the
outputs are strictly tangible goods, such a system is referred to as a production system and the
transformation process is referred to as production. Nowadays, the service system in which the output
is predominantly a service or even a pure service, is also treated as a productive system and often referred
to as an operating system instead of a production system
9
10
NATURE OF PRODUCTION/OPERATIONS
The nature of production or operations can be better understood by viewing the manufacturing function
as :
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
Production/operations as a system,
Production/operations as an organisational function,
Production/operations as a conversion or transformation process and
Production/operations as a means of creating utility.
Production/Operations as a System
This view is also known as "systems concept of production". A system is defined as the collection of
interrelated entities. The systems approach views any organisation or entity as an arrangement of interrelated
parts that interact in ways that can be specified and to some extent predicted. Production is viewed
as a system which converts a set of inputs into a set of desired outputs. A production system has the
following elements or parts : (i) Inputs, (ii) Conversion process or transformation process, (iii) Outputs
(iv) Transportation subsystem, (v) Communication subsystem and (vi) Control or decision making
subsystem.
11
External Environment
Inputs
Customer/Client Participation
Materials
Labour
Equipment
Capital
Energy
Money
Management
Information
Conversion/
Transformation
Process
Output
Goods and/or
Services of
Utility
Control Subsystem
.
Feedback
Decision Maker
(Production
Management)
Feedback
External Environment
Inputs
Outputs
(A simple production system)
The conversion process may include manufacturing processes such as cutting, drilling, machining,
welding, painting, etc., and other processes such as packing, selling, etc.
Any conversion process consists of several small activities referred to as "operations" which are some
steps in the overall process of producing a product or service that leads to the final output.
12
Table 1.1 illustrates some examples of conversion processes used in the production systems.
Table 1.1 : Examples of Conversion Processes used in Production Systems
Production
System
Conversion
Process
Inputs
Outputs
Steel Plant
Smelting, rolling
Steel sections,
sheets
Restaurant
Cooking and
serving food
Satisfied
customers
Automobile
Plant
Fabrication of
parts and assembly
of automobiles
Automobile
Oil Refinery
Chemical processes
Petroleum
(Fractional distillation) Products
Supermarket
Selling/retailing
Satisfied customers
College or
University
Teaching (Imparting
knowledge and skills)
Graduates (Educated
persons)
Airline
Air transportation
Satisfied customers
to their destinations
13
The activities carried out while creating the utilities discussed above are referred to as production
functions.
Production Function
Production function may be defined as the creation of useful products for sale with the help of inputs
such as materials, machines, labour, land, capital and management. The production function represents
basically a physical relationship between inputs and outputs. It may be represented as
Q = (a, b, c, d...)
where Q is the quantity of output and a, b, c, d, etc., represent the quantities of various inputs such as
material, machine hours, labour hours, energy, etc., The production function specifies the amount of outputs
resulting from the amount of inputs used during a specified period of time. The productive use of the
resources is described by the term productivity. Productivity is an index that measures outputs (goods and
services) relative to the inputs (materials, energy and other resources).
Output
It is usually expressed as, Productivity =
Input
Productivity is also known as productive efficiency or the efficiency of the production process. It
indicates how well a productive process is carried out to convert a set of inputs into a set of outputs of value
to the customer which also provides reasonable profits to the manufacturer or seller.
Importance of Production Function
The production is the core function of any business organisation. Production function creates goods
and services and organisations exist primarily to create goods and/or to provide services. Without production
function, there would be no need for any other function such as marketing, finance or human resource
function. Also, more than 50 per cent of employees in a business organisation have jobs in the area of
production. Moreover the production function is responsible for a major portion of assets in most organisations.
Consumption of goods and services is an integral part of any society and production function facilitates
creation of goods and services for the benefit of people in the society.
Box 1.1 lists some of the areas in which production/operations management can offer competitive
advantage to a firm.
Box 1.1 : Areas in which Production/Operations Management can offer Competitive
Advantage
(i) Shorter new product lead time (i.e., speed to market)
(ii) Higher inventory turnover (i.e., low inventory)
(iii) Shorter manufacturing cycle time
(iv) Higher product quality (i.e., reduced defects)
(v) Greater flexibility
(vi) Better customer service
(vii) Reduced wastages
(viii) Higher productivity (i.e., reduced costs)
14
Production management is the process which combines and transforms various resources (inputs) used
in a production system into value added outputs (products/services) in a controlled manner. The term production
management is usually used for a production system which produces tangible goods whereas, the term
operations management is more frequently used where the inputs are converted into intangible services.
However, many authors use the common term "production and operations management" to represent either
a manufacturing system or a service system.
15
: Capacity, location, products and services, make or buy, layouts, projects and scheduling.
(iv) Directing
16
A better insight to how production/operations managers manage can be had by examining the decisions
in production and operations management, since all managerial functions such as planning, organising,
staffing, directing and controlling involve decision making.
The decisions which production/operations managers make may be classified into three general categories:
(i) Strategic Decisions: Decisions about products, processes and facilities. These decisions are strategically
important and have long-term significance for the organisation.
(ii) Operating Decisions: Decisions about planning production to meet demand.
(iii) Control Decisions: Decisions about controlling operations concerned with day-to-day activities of the
workers, quality of products and services, production costs, overhead costs and maintenance of plant
and equipment.
Some examples of strategic, operating and controlling decisions are discussed below :
Strategic Decisions: These are decisions concerning long range production/operations strategies. Some
of the examples of strategic production/operations management (POM) decisions are :
(i) Deciding about launching of a new-product development project.
(ii) Deciding on the design for a production process for a new product.
(iii) Deciding on how to allocate scarce resources such as materials, machine and labour capacities and
utilities.
(iv) Deciding about what new facilities are needed and where to locate them.
Operating Decisions: These decisions must help to resolve the issues concerned with planning production
to meet customers demands for products and services and to achieve customer satisfaction at reasonable
costs. Examples of operating decisions are :
(i) Deciding how much finished goods inventory to be carried for each product.
(ii) Deciding the next months production schedule for producing the products.
(iii) Deciding about hiring of casual (temporary) workers for the next month.
(iv) Deciding about the volume of purchase from each vendor for the next month.
Control Decisions: These decisions are concerned with problems in production such as variations in
labour output (productivity), variations in product quality, breakdown of production equipment, etc. Production/
operations managers need to control poor worker performance, inferior product quality and excessive equipment
breakdowns so that the profitable operation of the productive system is not affected. Examples of control
decisions are :
(i) Deciding the course of action about a departments failure to meet the planned labour cost target.
(ii) Developing labour cost standards for a new or modified product design which is about to be taken
up for production.
(iii) Deciding about the new quality control acceptance criteria for a product for which the design has
been changed.
(iv) Deciding about the frequency of preventive maintenance for key machinery or equipment.
17
Table 1.2 lists the types of production management decisions and their applications.
Table 1.2 : Production management decisions and their applications
Type of
Decisions
Area of
Involvement
Nature of
Activities
1. Strategic
decisions
(Planning
products,
processes
and facilities)
2. Operating
decisions
(Matching
production
with demand)
(ii) Quality
(iii) Projects
(iv) Maintenance
Box 1.3 shows ten important decision areas of production and operations management.
Box 1.3 : Ten decision areas of production/operations management
(i) Managing quality
The ten decision areas in production/operations management shown in Box 1.3 are illustrated in detail
in Table 1.3 below :
18
Table 1.3 : Ten critical decision areas of POM and their related issues
Decision Area
Related Issues
1. Quality
management
2. Product and
service design
3. Process strategy
(Process design)
(a) What process will these products or capacity design services require
and in what sequence?
5. Layout design
6. Human resources
7. Supply-chain
8. Inventory
9. Scheduling
10. Maintenance
19
Production/Operations
Finance/Accounting
(a) Disbursements/credit
(i) Accounts receivable
(ii) Accounts payable
(b) Funds management
(i) Money market
(ii) International exchange
(c) Capital requirements
(i) Stock issue
(ii) Bond issue and recall
Marketing
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
Personal selling
Advertising
Sales promotion
Market research
Distribution
Operations
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
(v)
(vi)
(vii)
(viii)
Teller scheduling
Check clearing
Collection
Transaction processing
Facilities design/layout
Locker operations
Maintenance
Security
Finance
(i) Investments
(Securities, Real Estate)
(ii) Accounting
(iii) Auditing
Marketing
(i) Loans (Commercial,
Industrial, Financial,
Personal, Mortgage)
(ii) Trust department
Operations managers need feedback from the accounting function to understand their current performance.
Financial measures help the operations managers to assess labour costs, the long-term benefits of new
technologies and quality improvement projects. Accounting helps in computing the production costs and in
bills payment to suppliers.
20
(iii) Industrial Engineering (or Work Study): Method Study, Work Measurement.
(iv) Production Planning and Control: Estimating, Forecasting, Routing, Scheduling, Dispatching and
Progressing.
(v) Inventory Control: Purchasing, Storing and Controlling Inventory Levels and Material Issues.
(vi) Quality Control: Inspection, Quality Control, Quality Assurance and Reliability, Statistical Quality
Control and Total Quality Control.
(vii) Maintenance: Servicing, Repairing, Breakdown/Preventive Maintenance, Spare Parts Inventory Control
and Equipment Replacement.
Long-Run Decisions
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
(v)
(vi)
21
Short-Run Decisions
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
(v)
Short-run decisions related to the operations and control of the system are :
Inventory and Production Control: Decisions made are concerned with allocation of productive
capacity consistent with demand and inventory policy. Feasible schedules must be worked out and the
load on machines and labour and the flow of production must be controlled.
Maintenance and Reliability of the System: Decisions must be made regarding the maintenance
effort, maintenance policy and practice recognising the fact that machine down time may lead to idling
of labour and production stoppage resulting in lost sales.
Quality Control: Decisions must be made to set permissible levels of risk that bad parts are produced
and shipped or the risk that good parts are scrapped due to sampling inspection. Inspection costs must
be balanced with the probable losses due to passing defective materials or products. Decisions regarding
controlling the quality of on-going processes must be taken.
Labour Control: Labour is the major cost element in most products and services. Hence, work
measurement and wage incentive systems must be developed to control labour costs and to increase
labour productivity.
Cost Control and Improvement: Day-to-day decisions which involve the balance of labour, material
and overhead costs must be made by production supervisors.
The relative importance of these problems of production management varies considerably depending
on the nature of the production system. The production manager must be able to sense the relative importance
of these various problems in a given situation and take appropriate decisions to solve these problems.
22
F.W. Harris developed the concept of "Economic Order Quantity" in 1915 which is still recognised as
a classical work in inventory control systems. In 1931, Dodge and Romig and W. Shewhart developed the
concept of sampling inspection and use of statistical tables for acceptance sampling plans. Earlier in 1924,
Shewhart developed the concept of statistical quality control and use of control charts to control the quality
of on-going processes.
The "human relations movement" was started by Elton Mayo in 1930s, through his famous experiments
at Western Electric's Hawthorne plant and his findings came to be known as "Hawthorne effect". His studies
revealed that in addition to physical and technical aspects of work, worker motivation is critical for improving
productivity.
During the 1940's, Abraham Maslow developed motivational theory known as "Hierarchy of Needs
Theory" which was later refined by Frederick Herzberg as "Motivation-Hygiene" theory in 1950s. Douglas
McGregor added "Theory X" and "Theory Y" in 1960. In 1970, William Ouchi added "Theory Z" which
combined the Japanese approach and the traditional Western approach to management.
After World War II, operations research and quantitative techniques were applied to production
management resulting in decision models for forecasting, inventory management, project management and
other areas of production management. Widespread use of personal computers and user-friendly softwares
have popularised application of these quantitative techniques in production management since the 1980's.
Development in Management Information Systems (MIS) and Decision Support Systems (DSS) provided a
further boost to the developments in production management.
Advanced manufacturing technology enabled production managers to use Computer-Aided-Design
(CAD), Computer-Aided-Manufacturing (CAM), Computer Numerically Controlled (CNC) machines, Robots,
Computer Integrated Manufacturing (CIM), Flexible Manufacturing System (FMS), etc., in the field of
production management.
Moreover, a number of Japanese manufacturers have developed modern management practices that
have increased the productivity of their operations and the quality of their products. The new approaches in
production management emphasise quality (Total Quality Management) and continuous improvement (Kaizen),
worker teams and empowerment to achieve customer satisfaction. The Japanese have spawned the "quality
revolution" and adopted Just-In-Time (JIT) production system to put themselves in the forefront of timebased competition. [Table 1.4 provides a chronological summary of some of the key developments in the
evolution of production/operations management.]
23
Contribution/Concept
Originator
1776
Division of labour
Adam Smith
1790
Interchangeable parts
Eli Whitney
1911
Principles of management
F.W. Taylor
1911
1912
Henry Gantt
1913
Henry Ford
1915
F.W. Harris
1930
Elton Mayo
1935
F.W. Dodge,
H.G. Romig, W. Shewhart
1940
1947
Linear programming
George Dantzig
1951
Sperry Univac
1950s
Automation
Numerous
1960s
Numerous
1975
W. Skinner
1980s
Japanese
manufacturers
1990s
Internet
Numerous
(ii) Growing importance of quality: Quality is a key component of operations management. Quality
is no longer limited to manufacturing function but important in all functional areas throughout the
organisation. With the integration of manufacturing and services operations, quality is no longer
limited to technical requirement of tangible goods but also equally important for service. Improvement
in quality in all areas of the business improves customer satisfaction and increases customer loyalty.
(iii) Expansion of operations management concepts to other functions: In addition to quality, concepts
of operations functions such as product design and process analysis are applied in other functional
areas such as marketing, software development, finance and accounting, human resources, etc.
(iv) A new paradigm for operations management: In the post World Wide II period, upto 1970s, with
demand significantly exceeding supply, operations managers emphasized on utilization of available
production capacity a reactive approach rather than planning pro-active for the future. In the
early 1970s, competition world-wide became intensive and forced operations managers to assume a
proactive role in developing the overall strategy for an organisation. They realized the role of
operations function in adding value to the products manufactured (that is affecting how much a
customer is willing to pay for the products). In this paradigm shift, operations strategies included
other dimensions such as quality, speed of delivery and process flexibility for adding value to
products, other than cost to increase profit margins. This approach to operations strategy resulted in
a new paradigm for the operations functions.
Today, the scope of operations management ranges across the organisation. Operations management
people are involved in product and service design, process selection, technology choice, design of work
24
systems, location planning, facilities planning and quality planning and control. The operations function
includes many inter-related activities such as forecasting, capacity planning, scheduling, inventory
management, quality assurance, employee motivation, facilities location and layout, etc. There are other
areas which are interrelated with operations function, for example, purchasing, industrial engineering,
maintenance and physical distribution operations managers apply ideas and knowledge to:
(i) Cut production time to improve speed of launching new products to market.
(ii) Improve flexibility to meet rapidly changing customer needs.
(iii) Enhance product quality.
(iv) Improve customer service and
(v) Increase productivity and reduce costs and thereby improve profitability of the company.
Operations management is the management of productive resources that are used to create saleable
products or services. It is that sale of products and services that provide an opportunity for profitability
for an organisation. Profitability results from the creation of value and a strategy for maintaining a link
to the customers who define value for the goods or services offered. The creation of value at a level that
exceeds the cost of creating it provides the potential for profitability. Operations management has responded
well to four dominant environmental forces affecting the business: (i) competition resulting from
globalisation of business (ii) increasing levels of communication and competition brought about by the
Internet and other disruptive technologies (iii) the impact of natural environment and (iv) regional pressures
having impact on business decisions.
25
26
Conversion
subsystem
Inputs
External
Legal/Political,
Social, technological and
economical
Market
Competition,
Product information, customer
desires
Primary
Resources
Materials and
Supplies,
Personnel, Capital
assets, Utilities,
Money
Physical
Manufacturing,
Mining,
Locational services
(Transportation)
Exchange services
(Wholesaling/
Retailing)
Storage services
(Warehousing)
Other Services
Insurance, Finance,
Banking, Real
Estate, Health and
Personal Services,
Government
services
Outputs
Direct
Outputs
Product,
Services
Indirect
Outputs
Taxes, Wages,
Salaries,
Technological
developments,
Environmental
impact,
Employee
impact,
Societal
impact
Feedback
information
Control
Subsystem
Mass Production
(ii) Continuous or
flow shop
production
Analytical
Process production
Synthetic
Assembly line production
27
Primary
Inputs
Conversion
Subsystem
Automobile
factory
Automobiles
Department
store
Attracts customers,
stores goods, sells goods
(exchange)
Marketed goods
and satisfied
customers
College or
University
Transmits information
and develops skills and
knowledge
Educated
persons
Outputs
28
Having discussed the concepts of the production system, it is necessary to know about the types of
production systems and their features.
1.
Production systems that produce goods are often referred to as manufacturing systems and the
production of tangible goods is called manufacturing. Some common examples of manufactured goods
are chemicals, steel, cement, automobiles, aeroplanes, beverages, packaged food and furniture.
Production systems that produce services are referred to as service systems. Services are intangible
products that satisfy some need of a consumer including the enhancement of tangible goods. Examples of
services systems are: healthcare services, legal assistance, financial services, accounting services,
educational services, transportation services and warehousing services.
Products can also be combination of goods and services. Restaurants produce the tangible products
along with the intangible services of delivery, cleaning of dishes and providing pleasant environment to the
customers. (More about manufacturing systems and service systems will be discussed later in this chapter.)
2.
Production systems may exist in series; for example, when completed products are shipped from the
factory to a warehouse, they are leaving the factory system only to arrive at a second production system,
called a warehouse. The factory and the warehouse are two production systems which are in series.
Production system may also exist in parallel, such as when a number of factories produce similar
products and supply several market areas. These factories may be considered as one large production
system (i.e., an industry). For example, several factories producing automobile spare parts are treated as
part of larger system known as automobile spare parts industry.
3.
Continuous Flow Production Systems are those where the facilities are standardised as to routings
and flow. A standard set of processes and sequence of processes can be adopted. Continuous flow production
systems are represented by production and assembly lines, large scale office operations and chemical
processes.
Intermittent Production Systems are those where facilities must be flexible enough to handle a
wide variety of products and sizes. In situations such as this no single sequence of operations is appropriate.
Transportation facilities between operations must be flexible to accommodate a wide variety of routes
that the inputs may require. Considerable storage between operations is required so that individual operations
can be carried on some-what independently, resulting in ease of scheduling and better utilisation of men
and machines. Intermittent production is represented by custom or job-order machine shops, hospitals and
batch chemical processes.
The production system model shown in Exhibit 1.3 can be made to fit both the intermittent and
continuous-flow situations by the specification of some of the detailed characteristics. Exhibit 1.4 represents
the intermittent production system.
29
In the intermittent production system, inputs may be processed in any specified sequence of operations
and are transported between operations. The number of operations may vary from one to any finite number.
Storage occurs between all operations and the time in storage may vary from essentially negligible to any finite
amount. It should be noted that in Exhibit 1.4, there are interconnections between all operations b through f,
although only those originating at b are shown. The information and control system interconnects all activities
and provides the basis for management decisions. Exhibit 1.5 represents a continuous flow production system.
Exhibit 1.5 : A Continuous Production System
30
In the continuous flow production system the input-output characteristics are standardised, allowing
standardisation of operations and their sequence. Minor storage of input occurs after receipt. Once on the
transportation system, any storage between operations is combined with transportation (for example,
conveyorised assembly line operations). In the ideal situation the operations are also combined with
transportation so that inputs are processed while they are being moved (for example, painting of jobs
which are being moved by means of a conveyor).
Having understood the meaning of production as a function of a production system it is necessary
to understand the nature of various types of production.
The process by which goods and services are produced can be categorised on the basis of the
following classifications.
(a) Job Shop Production: In this type of production a wide variety of customised products are made
by a highly skilled workforce using general purpose equipment. It is also known as unit-production,
one-off production, custom-built or taylor-made production. Ship building, furnace manufacture,
tool making and printing orders are some of the examples of jobshop production.
(b) Intermittent Flow or Batch Production: In this type of production, a mixture of general purpose
and special purpose equipment is used to produce small to large batch of products. Batch production
is one form of intermittent flow production. It is used to produce moderate volumes of similar
products. For example, ready-made garments and book manufacturers adopt batch production. Ice
cream manufacturers produce a batch of ice creams of different flavour such as vanilla and strawberry.
(c) Repetitive Flow or Mass Production: In this type of production several standardised products
follow a predetermined flow through sequentially dependent workcentres. Workers typically are
assigned to a narrow range of tasks and work with highly specialised equipment. Examples are
automobile and computer assembly lines.
(d) Continuous Flow or Flow Shop Production: Continuous processing or continuous production is
employed when a highly standardised product or service is produced or rendered. Processing of
chemicals, oil refineries, sugar and cement production are some of the examples of continuous flow
production. Industries that use continuous processing involving chemical or metallurgical processes
are sometimes referred to as process industries and the type of production adopted is known as
process production. Production processes are usually performed round the clock in process
industries to avoid costly shut-downs and start-ups.
Table 1.6 provides a summary of the characteristics of these four major types of production.
(i)
Degree of Standardisation
The output of production systems can range from highly standardised products to highly customised
products. Standardised output means goods and services having high degree of uniformity. Standardised
goods include radios, televisions, computers, newspapers, pens, pencils, canned foods, soft drinks,
automobile tyres and the like.
Standardised services include automatic car washes, televised newscasts, taped lectures and
commercial airline services. Customised output means that the product or service is designed for a specific
customer (either a business customer or an individual). Customised goods includes eyeglasses, customfitted clothing, window glasses (cut to order) and customised draperies. Customised services include
tailoring, taxi rides and surgery.
31
Batch
Repetitive
or Assembly
Continuous
Description of
outputs
Customised
goods or services
Highly standardised
goods or services
Examples of
goods
Speciality tools
Cookies
Automobiles
Examples of
services
Hair Styling
Education
Car wash
Heating,
air-conditioning
Examples of
manufacturing
facilities
Machine
shop
Bakery
Assembly line
Steel mill,
paper mill
Examples of
service facilities
Beauty shop
Barber shop
Classroom
Cafeteria lines
Central heating
system
Volume
Low
Low to moderate
High
Vary high
Output variety
Very high
Moderate
Low
Very low
Equipment
flexibility
Very high
Moderate
Low
Very low
Advantage
Able to handle a
wide variety of work
Flexibility
Very efficient
very high volume
Disadvantages
Moderate cost
Low flexibility,
per unit, moderate high cost
scheduling
of downtime
complexity
System with standardised output can generally use standardised methods, materials and
mechanisations, all of which contribute to higher volumes and lower unit costs. In systems producing
customised output, each job is sufficiently different so that workers must be more skilled, the work moves
slower and the work is less susceptible to mechanisation.
32
highly uniform products or services. Sometimes the system may use a semi-continuous processing known
as repetitive processing to produce one or a few highly standardised products or services.
Processing of chemicals, photographic film, newsprint and oil products are examples of continuous
processing whereas examples for semiprocessing includes automobiles, television, computers, cameras
and video equipment.
Batch processing is used to produce moderate volumes of similar products. For example, food
products, ice creams and pharmaceutical products produced in batches.
Job-shop processing is used to produce a single unit or a small lot of products or service with
varying specifications according to customer needs.
2. Uniformity of input,
4. Uniformity of output,
6. Quality assurance.
33
Goods
Services
Output
Tangible
Intangible
Customer contact
Low
High
Uniformity of input
High
Low
Labour content
Low
High
Uniformity of output
High
Low
Measurement of productivity
Easy
Difficult
High
Low
34
An FMS is a type of flexible automation system which builds on the programmable automation of
NC and CNC machines. Materials are automatically handled and loaded and unloaded for machining
operations. Programs and tooling setups can be quickly changed and production can be quickly switched
over from one job to another with no loss of change over time.
Key components of an FMS are:
(i) Several computer controlled machining centres or workstations having CNC machines and
robots for loading and unloading.
(ii) Computer Controlled transport system (AGVs) for moving materials and parts from one machine
to another and in and out of the system.
(iii) Computer controlled robots for loading and unloading stations.
(iv) An automated storing and retrieval system.
All the above subsystems of FMS are controlled by a control computer with the needed software.
Raw materials are loaded on the AGVs which bring them to the work centres as per the sequence of
operations unique to each part. The route is determined by the control computer. The robots lift the
materials from the AGV and places on the work station where the required operations are carried out.
After the completion of operations, the robots unload the job and place it on the AGV to move the job to
the next workstation as per the sequence of operations.
The FMS is suitable for intermediate flow strategy with medium level of product varieties and
volumes (40 to 2000 units per part). Also FMs can produce low variety high volume products in the same
way as fixed automation systems.
Advantages
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
(v)
Disadvantages
(i) High initial capital investment
(ii) Limited ability to adopt to product changes
(iii) Substantial preplanning, tooling and fixture requirements
(iv) Standardisation of part designs needed to reduce numbers of tools required
(v) Requires long planning and development cycle to install the FMs.
VERTICAL INTEGRATION
Vertical integration is the amount of the production and distribution chain, from suppliers of
components to the delivery of products/services to customers, which is brought under the ownership of a
firm. The management decides the level or degree of integration by considering all the activities performed
from the acquisition of raw materials to the delivery of finished products to customers. The degree to
which a firm decides to be vertically integrated determines how many production processes need to be
planned and designed to be carried out in-house and how many by outsourcing. When managers decide to
have more vertical integration, there is less outsourcing. The vertical integration is based on make-orbuy decisions, with make decisions meaning more integration and a buy decision meaning less integration
35
and more outsourcing. Two directions of vertical integration are (a) Backward integration which represents
moving upstream toward the sources of raw materials and parts, for example a steel mill going for backward
integration by owning iron ore and coal mines and a large fleet of transport vehicles to move these raw
materials to the steel plant. (b) Forward integration in which the firm acquires the channel of distribution
(such as having its own warehouses, and retail outlets).
The advantages of more vertical integration are disadvantages of more outsourcing and similarly,
advantages of more outsourcing are disadvantages of more vertical integration.
Advantages of vertical integration are:
(i) Can sometimes increase market share and allow the firm enter foreign markets more easily.
(ii) Can achieve savings in production cost and produce higher quality goods.
(iii) Can achieve more timely delivery.
(iv) Better utilisation of all types of resources.
Disadvantages of vertical integration are:
(i) Not attractive for low volumes.
(ii) High capital investment and operating costs.
(iii) Less ability to react more quickly to changes in customer demands, competitive actions and new
techniques.
1.
The world is rapidly transforming itself into a single global economy which is also referred to as
a global village or global landscape. Markets once dominated by local or domestic firms are now
vulnerable to competition from firms in all corners of the world. A country's borders no longer provides
protection from intense competition from foreign firms. To succeed in global competition, companies
must offer quality products at reasonable costs. Also, as companies expand their business to include
foreign markets, so too must the operations management function take a broader, more global perspective
in order for companies to remain competitive. The trend towards globalisation has placed increased
emphasis on the logistics of where to locate facilities and the issues associated with moving materials over
long distances.
2.
Another key factor affecting POM today is quality. Successful firms now recognise that quality is
no longer limited to the POM function, but is important in all functional areas throughout the entire
36
organisation, a new concept known as total quality management (or TQM in short). However, POM is
primarily responsible to ensure that the firm is able to produce the products in the required quantities, in
the required quality level, delivering the products to the customers at the desired time schedule and at the
minimum possible cost.
Quality is no longer limited to the technical requirements of the goods being produced on the
manufacturing shop floor. Service quality (i.e., how we deal with our customers on a wide variety of
issues affecting customer satisfaction) is equally important.
How companies integrate product quality and service quality, to properly meet the needs of the
customers is a major challenge to today's managers. Improving quality in all respects of the business
improves customer satisfaction and increases customer loyalty. Today's customers are demanding better
quality, more variety and increased responsiveness to their needs all at lower prices.
3.
Advances in technology in recent years have also had a significant impact on the POM function.
Computer-numerical control (CNC) technology, increased automation and robotics have enabled the
companies to improve the quality of products that are being manufactured. Information technology facilitates
collection of data on individual customers so that the products can be mass customised to meet the needs
of individual customers.
However, advances in technology place new requirements on the workforce and even on customers
especially in service operations. For example, skilled workers are replacing unskilled workers in all types
of operations. Employees must now have computer skills to use internet and carryout e-business. An
organisation's workforce is nowadays becoming more and more educated and should be considered as its
most valuable asset.
4.
The service sector is now growing far more rapidly than the manufacturing sector and more and
more workforce is now employed in the service sector. For example, the motion picture industry employs
more people in the United States than does the auto parts industry. Computer software service is the
fastest growing service in the service sector.
Eventhough the majority of issues and concerns faced by managers in both the service sector and the
manufacturing sector are the same, the special nature of services imposes additional constraints which
vary with the kind of service provided.
5.
Operations managers are faced with the problem of scarce production resources and matching the
production resources with anticipated product demand. They are constrained to obtain the scarce resources
such as materials and labour at the minimum possible cost and utilise the same with maximum efficiency.
Operations managers nowadays devote much of their energy to inventory and materials management,
scheduling operations and personnel, reduce wastage of materials and labour, cut costs and improve
productivity in order to improve the competitive positions of their companies. They are responsible to
prepare intermediate plans to consider what to buy, from whom to buy, when to buy and how much
to buy to manage the scarce material resources and also to co-ordinate personnel decisions such as hiring,
lay-offs overtime and subcontracting to make best use of the human and equipment resources.
6.
37
waste materials and energy, reducing packaging, using closed water systems for cooling and waste discharge
and even scheduling employee work hours to reduce traffic and air pollution. Using environmentally
sound production methods is not only the social responsibility but also a means of achieving economic
benefits. The other ethical issues arising in many aspects of operations management are :
(a) Worker Safety: Providing adequate training, maintaining equipment in good working conditions
and maintaining a safe working environment.
(b) Product Safety: Providing products that minimise risk of injury to user or damage to property
or the environment
(c) Quality: Honouring warranties, avoiding hidden defects.
(d) Obeying government regulations, regarding regulation of environment.
(e) The Community: Being a good neighbour, providing employment opportunities to the local
people and improving the standard of living of the community surrounding the company.
(f) Closing Facilities: Taking into account the impact on the community and honouring commitments
that have been made.
To conclude, we can summarise the current issues facing operations managers are as below.
1. Speeding up the time it takes to get new products into production.
2. Developing flexible production systems to enable mass customisation of products and services.
3. Managing global production networks and managing the supply chain (i.e., managing the flow of
information, materials and services from material suppliers through factories and warehouses to the
end customer).
4. Developing and integrating new process technologies into existing production systems.
5. Achieving high quality quickly and keeping it up in the face of restructuring (i.e., achieving quality
parity with the competition through total quality management).
6. Managing a diverse workforce.
7. Conforming to environmental constraints, ethical standards and government regulations.
REVIEW QUESTIONS
1. Define the terms "Production", "Production system" and "Production Management".
2. Discuss the following views of the nature of production :
(i) Production as a system.
(ii) Production/operations as an organisational function.
(iii) Production/operations as a conversion process.
(iv) Production/operations as a means of creating utility.
3. What is a "Production function"? State its importance.
4. Discuss the statement "Production is a means of creating utility."
5. State the objectives of production/operations management.
6. Mention the areas in which production management can offer competitive advantage to a firm.
7. Mention the responsibilities of a production manager. Explain how a production manager amalgamates
the five Ps namely product, plant, processes, programs and people.
38
8. Describe the various decisions made by production managers under three categories, viz., strategic,
operational and control decision areas of production management.
10. Explain what is meant by "organising to produce goods and services". Draw a typical organisational
chart for a manufacturing and a service organisation.
11. Explain the major functions of a production manager.
12. Discuss the problems that may arise in production management and the decisions production managers
have to take to solve these problems.
13. Give a brief account of the historical evolution of production management.
14. Discuss the recent trends in production/operations management and explain how these trends have
helped to improve the efficiency of production management.
15. Distinguish between system design and system operation.
16. Mention various types of production.
17. Discuss a production system model with a diagram. Describe its elements such as inputs,
conversion and control subsystems and outputs.
18. What do you understand by production system diversity?
19. Distinguish between
(a) Manufacturing system and service systems.
(b) Series and parallel systems.
(c) Continuous and Intermittent production systems.
20. Discuss the characteristics of job shop production, batch production, mass production, continuous
or flow production.
21. Explain the differentiating features of production systems.
22. Describe the factors affecting production and operations management today.
23. Discuss the scope of operations management.
24. Distinguish between production management and operations management.
25. Discuss the differences between goods and services.
26. Write short notes on: (a) Flexible manufacturing system, (b) Vertical integration.