0% found this document useful (0 votes)

130 views

Chapter 01. Chapter 02.EDITED

This document is a textbook on ethics that covers ethical theory and contemporary issues. It includes 18 chapters that discuss topics such as ethical relativism, egoism, utilitarianism, Kant's moral theory, contractarianism, virtue ethics, feminist thought, euthanasia, abortion, sexual morality, equality and discrimination, economic justice, legal punishment, environmental ethics, animal rights, and issues in biotechnology.

Uploaded by

TwinRose524

We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.

Available Formats

Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

0% found this document useful (0 votes)

130 views

Chapter 01. Chapter 02.EDITED

Uploaded by

TwinRose524

We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.

Available Formats

Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

You are on page 1/ 47

THEORY AND

CONTEMPORARY
ISSUES
SEVENTH EDITION
WITH READINGS

BARBARA MACKIN NON

Enhance your learning experience

with the text's Premium Website
&mamma 1171.

Usaalsose blimnollos Lemke Mollellm

Irtnallorstoollem ArripmfaspIpfthene lardaike drplortmuilla sore ad,Oda ollimewho slismaillihIllmily.1111saulipliWONMerado~o
wreMpurairnailsoMm...04...vorpowsulorinemo.

the texts nevi

admit, a one-stop online suite of digital

resources, offers fa.

ia- and interesting online learning

resources desigied to help Imo siceeed. Chapter resources are

correlated with key draper Woo* concepts, making it easy for
you to browse or sew!, for ormileot r a variety of ways.
V

Ethical Isaias Cmlailss

your aiticai thinking skills to the test.

These new sirmuiatior :

The flash-ba

me desigried around current and

relevant ethical ts..- -

- :1 abortion, economic equality and

discrimination, amd &nal rights_ Each one will help you form your
own opinion about what it !airs to make key decisions and think
critically on ethica' ssues.
Abdo lectures
You'll find an audio lecture recap ior ever/ chapter in the text.
Summaries. quizzing, and krf terms are all easy to find.

CENGAGE
Visit CengageBrain.com
If an access

hrain
coni

-?.1 in your text. you can log on right away

and begin using the res..- Jrces on the Pre-"um Website. If an access
card is not packaged with your text viso www,CengageBrain.com,
where you can purchase an access code tor the term of your course.
a

3 ..--

Try it today!

ETHICS

i1111111111111111111M11:019NIMINOUNINIEWW

AMMAR,

For Edward, Jennifer, and Kathleen

Contents
Pr/'ace xv
Histog of Ethics 7Tme Line xviii

PART ONE ETHICAL THEORY 1

Ethics and Ethical Reasoning

Why Study Ethics? 1

Metaethics 2
What Is Ethics? 2
Ethics and Religion 3
Ethical and Other Types of Evaluation 4
Ethical Terms 6

Ethics and Reasons 6

Alternate Theories: Intuitionism and Emotivism 7

Ethical Reasoning and Arguments 7

The Structure of Ethical Reasoning and Argument 7
Evaluating and Making Good Arguments 8

Ethical Theory 9
Types of Ethical Theory 10
Can Ethics Be Taught? 11
READING Plato Euthyphro 12
C. L. Stevenson The Emotive Meaning of Ethical Terms 15

Review Exercises 19

Ethical Relativism 20
What Is Ethical Relativism? 20
Two Forms of Ethical Relativism 21
Strong versus Weak Interpretations of Ethical Relativism 21
Reasons Supporting Ethical Relativism 22
The Diversity of Moral Views 22
Moral Uncertainty 22
Situational Differences 22

Are These Reasons Convincing? 22

The Diversity of Moral Views 22
Moral Uncertainty 23
Situational Differences 24

Further Considerations 24
Moral Realism 25
Moral Pluralism 26
27
Friedrich Nietzsche Master and Slave Moralities 30

READING Mary Midgley TryingOutOne'sNewSword

Review Exercises 32

viii CONTENTS

3 Egoism

Psychological Egoism 34
What Is Psychological Egoism? 34
Is Psychological Egoism True? 35

Ethical Egoism 35
What Is Ethical Egoism? 35
Is Ethical Egoism a Good Theory? 36

The Moral Point of View 37

Why Be Moral? 38
READING Plato The Ring of Gyges 39
Thomas Hobbes Self Love* 45
Joseph Butler Upon the Social Nature of Man

Review Exercises 51
4 Utilitarianism 52
Historical Background 53
Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill 53

The Principle of Utility 54

A Consequentialist Principle 54
The Intrinsic Good: Pleasure or Happiness 54
Calculating the Greatest Amount of Happiness 55

Quantity and Quality of Pleasure 56

Evaluating Utilitarianism 57
Application of the Principle 57
Utilitarianism and Personal Integrity 58
Ends and Means 58
The Trolley Problem 58

Act and Rule Utilitarianism 59

"Proof" of the Theory 60
READING Jeremy Bentham An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation (1789) 62
John Stuart Mill Utilitarianism

Review Exercises 72
5 Kant's Moral Theory 74
Historical Background: Immanuel Kant 75
What Gives an Act Moral Worth? 76
What Is the Right Motive? 76
What Is the Right Thing to Do? 77

The Categorical Imperative 78

The First Form 78
The Second Form 79

Evaluating Kant's Moral Theory 80

The Nature of Moral Obligation 80
The Application of the Categorical Imperative 80
Duty 81

CONTENTS lx

Moral Equality and Impartiality 81

Perfect and Imperfect Duties 82

Variations on Kantian Moral Theory 82
READING Immanuel Kant Fundamental Principles of the Metaphysic of Morals 84

Review Exercises 95
6 Contractarianism 96
READING Thomas Hobbes The Leviathan* 97
T. M. Scanlon Contractualism and Utilitarianism

103

Review Exercises 107

7 Morality and Human Nature 108
Natural Law Theory 109
What Kind of Law is Natural Law? 109

Historical Origins: Aristotle 109

Nature, Human Nature, and the Human Good 110
Evaluating Natural Law Theory 111
Natural Rights 112
Evaluating Natural Rights Theory 113
Is There a Human Nature 114

READING Thomas Aquinas On Natural Law 115

John Locke Second Treatise of Civil Government 117
Jean-Paul Satre Existentialism Is a Humanism 120

Review Exercises 123

8 Virtue Ethics 124
Virtues and Everyday Life 124
What Is Virtue? 125
Evaluating Virtue Ethics 126
READING Aristotle The Nicomachean Ethics 128
Philippa Foot Virtues and Vices 134

Review Exercises 143

9 Feminist Thought and the Ethics of Care 144
An Ethics of Care 144
Is There a Gender Difference in Morality? 146
The Source of Feminine Morality 147
Feminine versus Masculine Morality 148

Feminist Thought 148

Evaluation of Feminist Thought and the Ethics of Care 150
READING Nel Noddings Caring 152
Annette Baier The Need for More Than Justice

Review Exercises 161

155

x CONTENTS

PART TWO ETHICAL ISSUES 162

Euthanasia 162
Brain Death, Coma, and Persistent Vegetative State 162
Meaning and Types of Euthanasia 164
Active and Passive Euthanasia 164
Physician-Assisted Suicide 166
Pain Medication that Causes Death 168
Ordinary and Extraordinary Measures 169
Voluntary and Nonvoluntary Euthanasia 170
Combining the Types of Euthanasia 171

Morality and the Law 171

Making Moral Judgments About Euthanasia 172
The Moral Significance of Voluntariness 172
Active versus Passive Euthanasia 173
Ordinary versus Extraordinary Measures 175

Infant Euthanasia 175

READING J Gay-Williams The Wrongfulness of Euthanasia

178
James Rachels Active and Passive Euthanasia 181
Carl B. Becker Buddhist Views of Suicide and Euthanasia

185

Review Exercises 194

Discussion Cases 194

11 Abortion 196
Stages of Fetal Development 197
Methods of Abortion 198
Abortion and the Law 199
Abortion: the Moral Question 201
Arguments That Do Not Depend on the Moral Status of the Fetus 202
Utilitarian Reasoning 202
Some Rights Arguments 202

Arguments That Depend on the Moral Status of the Fetus 203

Method I 203
Method II 205

READING Judith Jarvis Thomson

A Defense of Abortion
Don Marquis Why Abortion is Immoral 220

209

Review Exercises 228

Discussion Cases 228

Sexual Morality 230

Conceptual Problems: What is and is Not Sexual 233
Relevant Factual Matters 234
Sexual Morality and Ethical Theories 234
Consequentialist or Utilitarian Considerations 234
Nonconsequentialist or Kantian Considerations 235
Naturalness Considerations 236

Homosexuality 237

CONTENTS xi

READING Thomas Nagel Sexual Perversion 240

Richard D. Mohr Prejudice and Homosexuality

246

Review Exercises 251

Discussion Cases 252
13 Equality and Discrimination 253
Civil Rights Laws: a Brief History 257
Racism and Sexism 258
The Principle of Equality 260
Justice 260
Social Benefits and Harms 260
Proof 261
Real Differences 261
Relevant Differences 262
Challenges to the Principle 262

Affirmative Action and Preferential Treatment 264

Consequentialist Considerations 265
Nonconsequentialist Considerations 267

READING Robert K. Fullinwider Affirmative Action and Fairness 270

Martin Luther King, Jr. Letter from a Birmingham Jail

Review Exercises 277

Discussion Cases 277
14 Economic Justice 279
Income Inequality 280
Health Care 281
Justice, Charity, and Efficiency 281

Process Distributive Justice 281

End-State Distributive Justice 282
Equal Opportunity 283
Political and Economic Theories 285
Libertarianism 285
Capitalism 285
Socialism 286
Modern Liberalism 287
John Rawls's Theory ofJustice 288
Communitarianism 290
READING John Rawls Justice as Fairness 291
Robert Nozick Distributive Justice 298
Amartya Sen The Idea of Justice 306

Review Exercises 310

Discussion Cases 310
15 Legal Punishment 312
The Nature of Legal Punishment 315
The Deterrence Argument 316
Problematic Aspects 316

274

xli CONTENTS

The Retributivist Argument 31 7

Problematic Aspects 319

Punishment and Responsibility 319

The Death Penalty 320
On Deterrence Grounds 321
On Retributivist Grounds 322
Other Concerns 323
READING Ernest Van Den Haag The Ultimate Punishment: a Defense
Hugo Bedau How to Argue About the Death Penalty 331

325

Review Exercises 338

Discussion Cases 338

16 Environmental Ethics 340

The Environment 341
Value 341
Anthropocentrism 342
Cost-Benefit Analysis 342
Human Environmental Impact 343

Ecocentrism 348
Deep Ecology 350
Ecofeminism 351
Sustainable Development 352
READING William F. Baxter People or Penguins: the Case for Optimal Pollution 355
Bill Devall and George Sessions Deep Ecology 359
Ramachandra Guha Radical American Environmentalism and Wilderness Preservation:
A Third World Critique 368

Review Exercises 373

Discussion Cases 373

17 Animal Rights 375

Sentience 377
Animal Rights 378
Animal Experimentation 380
Endangered Species 382
READING Peter Singer All Animals Are Equal

385
Bonnie Steinbock Speciesism and the Idea of Equality

393

Review Exercises 400

Discussion Cases 400

18 Stem Cell Research, Cloning, and Genetic Engineering 402

Stem Cell Research 402
Legal and Ethical Issues 403

Human Cloning 405

Therapeutic Cloning 405
Reproductive Cloning 405
Ethical Issues 406

CONTENTS xili

Genetic Engineering 410

Ethical Issues

411

Genetically Modified Plants and Animals 412

Ethical Issues 413

Genetic Screening 414

The Value of Privacy 415
Screening and Conflicts of Interest 415

READING Leon R. Kass The Wisdom of Repugnance 419

Kerry Lynn Macintosh Illegal Beings: Human Clones and the Law 424
Review Exercises 431
Discussion Cases 431

Violence, Terrorism, and War 433

Violence 433
Terrorism 435
Ethical Issues 437

Pacifism 438
Just War Theory 439
_kis Ad Bellum 439
Jus In Bello 440

Non-Traditional Military Conflicts 441

Weapons of Mass Destruction 442
War Crimes and Universal Human Rights 443
Torture 445
READING Jean Bethke Elshtain What Is a Terrorist? 447
Michael Walzer The Triumph of Just War Theory (and the Dangers of Success)

Review Exercises 456

Discussion Cases 457

Global Issues and Globalization 458

Rich and Poor Nations 458
Causes 460
Some Solutions 462
Ethical Considerations 462

Globalization 464
Values 466
Free-Market Capitalism 466
Modernization 467

READING Peter Singer Famine, Affluence, and Morality 469

Herman E. Daly Globalization and Its Discontents 477
Vandana Shiva Principles of Earth Democracy 481
Review Exercises 484

Discussion Cases 485

451

xiv CONTENTS

APPENDIX HOW TO WRITE AN ETHICS PAPER 486

The Content of the Paper 486
The Paper's Structure 486
Format 487
Grammar, Spelling, and Gender 489
Types of Ethics Papers 489
A Historical Approach 489
A Problem in Ethical Theory 490
A Contemporary Moral Issue 490

Is it an Ethics Paper? 491

Structuring or Analyzing An Ethical Argument 491
Reasons and Conclusions 491
Types and Sources of Evidence 491
Types of Reasons 492
Top-to-Bottom or Bottom-to-Top Reasoning? 492
Using Analogies 493