A Bandwidth EfficientmethodforcancellationofICIinOFDMsystems
A Bandwidth EfficientmethodforcancellationofICIinOFDMsystems
Abstract
Orthogonal frequency division multiplexing (OFDM) is a very important modulation technique in wideband wireless com-
munication and multimedia communication systems. While, it can effectively deal with multipath delay spread produced by
frequency fading channels, its main drawback is the effect of frequency offset (FO) produced by the receiver local oscillator
or by motion-induced Doppler. The FO breaks the orthogonality among the subcarriers and hence causes intercarrier inter-
ference (ICI). In this paper, ICI caused by frequency drift is eliminated by equalizing the complex weighting coefficients
of interference. In most of the commonly used ICI cancellation schemes, bandwidth efficiency suffers because of the re-
quirement of redundancy in the transmission. In the proposed scheme, repetition of data symbols or transmission of training
sequence is not required. Thus, the bandwidth efficiency of normal OFDM system is maintained. The improved performance
of the present scheme is confirmed through extensive simulations.
䉷 2008 Elsevier GmbH. All rights reserved.
A number of methods, namely self-ICI cancellation schemes effect of noise as considered in [8], the demodulated signal
[8–11], discrete Fourier transform (DFT)-based ICI cancel- is given by
lation scheme [12], and channel estimation and frequency
N −1
domain equalization [13,14], have been developed to reduce
y(t) = e( j2 f t+0 ) xk,i q(t − kT /N ) (3)
this sensitivity to FO. The self-ICI cancellation scheme re-
k=0
quires repetition of input data which reduces the bandwidth
efficiency of the normal OFDM system. The DFT-based where q(t) is the combined impulse response of the channel,
scheme performs well only for a small FO. The channel es- transmitter, and receiver filters. 0 is the difference between
timation methods require pilot signals, which also limits the the phase of the receiver local oscillator and the carrier phase
throughput. at the start of the received symbol. As in [8], we assume
In the present work, a new bandwidth-efficient ICI can- that the q(t) satisfies the Nyquist criterion for samples taken
cellation scheme is presented. The proposed scheme cancels at intervals T /N . If y(t) is sampled at the optimum instant,
interference in OFDM systems by equalization of interfer- then the samples of y(t) are given by
ence coefficients without requiring any training data.
The paper is organized as follows. First we introduce yk,i = e( j 0 ) xk,i e( j2k /N ) (4)
the structure of the OFDM system in Section 2. In Section where = f T is the normalized FO.
3, the self-ICI cancellation schemes of [8,9] and the DFT- These samples are applied to the receiver DFT, after re-
based ICI cancellation scheme of [12] are briefly discussed moving the cyclic prefix. The output of receiver DFT is again
and analyzed. Then the proposed scheme is introduced in converted into serial form. The output of the DFT is given
Section 4. Section 5 presents the analysis of the performance by
of these schemes through simulation. The efficacy of all the
schemes considered in this study is judged on the basis of
N −1
symbol error rate (SER) at different values of signal to noise Ym,i = yk,i e(− j2km/N ) (5)
ratio (SNR) and FO. Finally, the overall findings of the study k=0
are summarized in Section 6. Then from (4) and (5) it can be shown that
N −1
1 ( j 0 )
Ym,i = e X l,i
2. System model N
l=0
N −1
Fig. 1 shows the structure of the OFDM communica- × exp( j2k(l − m + )/N ) (6)
tion system. The N bits of high-speed input data signal
k=0
X 0 , X 1 , . . . , X N −1 modulate the N orthogonal subcarriers
to produce the output of the OFDM transmitter for the ith- After some simplification this can also be expressed as
transmitted symbol as −1
N
( j 0 )
−1 Ym,i = e cl−m X l,i (7)
N
( j2 f c t)
x(t) = e xk,i p(t − kT /N ) (1) l=0
k=0 where
N −1
where f c is the carrier frequency and p(t) is the impulse 1
response of the low-pass filter in the transmitter and the cl−m = exp( j2k(l − m + )/N ) (8)
N
inverse discrete Fourier transform (IDFT) xk,i of X k,i , in the k=0
ith symbol, is given by
From (7), it can be seen that if = 0 then Ym,i = e( j 0 ) X m,i
N −1 and each decoded value is simply the phase-rotated version
1 of the transmitted value. If 0, the ICI will occur and each
xk,i = X l,i exp( j2kl/N )
N output-decoded value will depend on all the input values.
l=0
for k = 0, 1, . . . , N − 1 (2) The decoded output Ym,i , therefore, consists of a wanted
component, which is due to X m,i but is subject to a change
If ts is the bit duration of the input, the OFDM symbol in the phase and amplitude given by
duration T will be equal to N t s . Thus the duration of the
N −1
OFDM symbol is increased by N times the duration of the 1
c0 = exp( j2/N ) (9)
input data bit. This greatly reduces the effect of ISI [1]. N
k=0
To reduce the effect of ISI completely, the cyclic prefixing
of the OFDM symbol is done. At the receiver, the noisy Thus, the ICI depends on the N complex weighting coeffi-
signal received is mixed with a local oscillator signal having cients c0 , c1 , . . . , c N −1 . A plot of real and imaginary coeffi-
frequency f above the correct frequency f c . Ignoring the cients of these weighting coefficients, for N = 16, is shown
A. Kumar, R. Pandey / Int. J. Electron. Commun. (AEÜ) 63 (2009) 569 – 575 571
exp( j 2π f c t )
X 0, i x0, i
High speed
• •
data Serial to
•
N-point
•
Parallel to DAC ×
Parallel IDFT Serial and
converter • • Converter LPF
X N −1, i xN −1, i
h(t)
exp(− j 2π ( f c + Δf )t )
n(t)
+
yo , i
Y0, i
•
• N point
•
Serial to LPF ×
• DFT Parallel and BPF
• • Converter ADC
YN −1, i
yN −1, i
where X = [X 0,i , . . . , X N −1,i ]T is the input data and In this process the remaining ICI depends on the factors of
Y = [Y0,i , . . . , Y N −1,i ] is the received data. the form {−c1 + 2c2 − c3 }. If the three weighting coeffi-
572 A. Kumar, R. Pandey / Int. J. Electron. Commun. (AEÜ) 63 (2009) 569 – 575
Weighting coefficients
0.6
3.2. DFT-based ICI cancellation scheme 0.4
In this scheme, the input data symbols, after serial to par- 0.2
allel conversion, are divided into two groups, each of size
0
N /2. These groups are separately discrete Fourier trans-
formed; after this, the two groups are again combined and -0.2
then N point IDFT is taken. At the receiver side, after de-
modulation, the N point DFT of the received data symbols is -0.4
-15 -10 -5 0 5 10 15
taken and after this the symbols are divided into two groups Number of subcarriers
again and each inverse-discrete Fourier transformed, respec-
tively, to rebuild the transmitted symbols. It has been shown Fig. 4. Weighting coefficients of matrix C(1) for N = 16 and
in [12] that by doing this ICI is greatly reduced. f T = 0.2.
For the DFT-based scheme the transmitted data can be
described in matrix form as
4. Proposed scheme
1
x = √ WHN BX (14)
N As discussed in the previous section, the ICI depends
on the weighting coefficients co , c1 , . . . , c N −1 . In order to
where WH N is the N × N IDFT matrix, B is the N × N design an equalizer for equalizing the weighting coefficients
matrix obtained after combining the two N /2 DFT blocks, that cause ICI, the matrix of these coefficients is obtained
X = [X 0,i , X 1,i , . . . , X N −1,i ]T , and H denotes the Hermitian from (11). The received signal at the receiver in the matrix
transpose. The data received are described in matrix form as form is given by
Y = C(1) X (15) Y = W N KW−1
N X
where C(1) = 1/N BH W N KWH j2/N , or Y = CX where W N is an N × N DFT matrix and W−1
N B and K = diag(1, e N
e j4 /N , ... , e j2(N −1)/N ). is an N × N IFDT matrix.
A plot of interfering coefficients of matrix C(1) is shown in When an equalizer is used, the output is given by
Figs. 3 and 4 for N =16 and at =0.1&0.2 respectively. Fig. Z = DY (16)
3 shows that the value of the coefficient corresponding to
the main symbol is significant compared to other interfering where D = C−1 is a circulant matrix, which denotes the
coefficients at small FOs, for 0.1. It can also be noted that equalizer filter matrix.
the coefficient corresponding to the main symbol decreases Commonly, the equalizer is designed by using training
and the interfering coefficients increase at = 0.2. Thus the symbols. In the present scheme, however, an appropriate
scheme is effective only at small FOs. filter is chosen from a small set of predefined filters. This
is based on the observation that an equalizer designed for a
given value of is effective for a variation ± around .
1
If the maximum expected value of normalized FO is max ,
real
then the given range of can be divided into p segments,
imaginary
0.8 where p = max /2. Let the midpoint of these segments
Weighting coefficients
Fig. 3. Weighting coefficients of matrix C(1) for N = 16 and Theorem. If the objective function of (17) is to be used
f T = 0.1. for selection of the equalizer, then the nonlinear estimator
A. Kumar, R. Pandey / Int. J. Electron. Commun. (AEÜ) 63 (2009) 569 – 575 573
schemes usually suffer from slow convergence and are not 100
suitable for the present case.
10-1
designed at (1) = 0.05, (2) = 0.1, (2) = 0.15 and (3) = 0.2. 0 5 10 15 20 25
SNR (dB)
For better accuracy a lager set of filters may be considered.
The performance of various schemes of ICI cancellation is Fig. 8. SER of standard, self-ICI cancellation, DFT-based ICI
judged on the basis of the SER. In our simulation of the cancellation, and equalized OFDM at f T = 0.1.
OFDM system, QPSK modulation with 64 subcarriers is
considered. We assume the ideal reception of OFDM signals
in the self-ICI cancellation scheme, and DFT-based ICI can- 100
cellation scheme as used in [8] and [12], respectively. For
the computation of SER curves, the transmission of 10 000
10-1
SNR (dB)
10-2
Fig. 10. SER of standard, self-ICI cancellation, DFT-based ICI
stnd-ofdm cancellation, and equalized OFDM at f T = 0.2.
10-3 self-ici-ofdm
DFT-ofdm
equl-ofdm
better than the standard OFDM only for low values of .
10-4 As increases the SER of the DFT-based ICI cancellation
0 5 10 15 20 25
SNR(dB) scheme increases and becomes comparable to the SER of
the standard OFDM.
Fig. 7. SER of standard, self-ICI cancellation, DFT-based ICI It is revealed by Figs. 7–10 that the present scheme
cancellation, and equalized OFDM f T = 0.05. has better SER performance as compared to the standard
A. Kumar, R. Pandey / Int. J. Electron. Commun. (AEÜ) 63 (2009) 569 – 575 575
OFDM, self-ICI cancellation and DFT-based ICI cancel- the consequences and solutions, In: IEEE 46th vehicular
lation schemes at all FOs. Also, the spectral efficiency of technology conference, Atlanta, GA, April 1996. p. 1564–8.
present scheme is maintained as that of the standard or the [8] Armstrong J. Analysis of new and existing methods of
normal OFDM system. reducing intercarrier interference due to carrier frequency
offset in OFDM. IEEE Trans Commun 1999;47:365–9.
[9] Yuping Zhao, Sven-Gustav Häggman. Intercarrier inter-
ference self-cancellation scheme for OFDM mobile commu-
6. Conclusions nication systems. IEEE Trans Commun 2001;49:1185–91.
[10] Wang Yonggang, Zhu Shibua, Li Ying. A method to improve
A new scheme based on equalization of interference co- the bandwidth efficiency of self-ICI cancellation in OFDM
efficients for cancellation of ICI in an OFDM system is systems. In: International conference on signal processing,
presented. The proposed scheme does not need any pilot (ICSP’02), vol. 2, August 2002, p. 1633–6.
symbols for equalization, maintaining the high spectral ef- [11] Sathananthan K, Tellambura C. New ICI reduction schemes
ficiency of a standard OFDM system. A comparison with for OFDM system. In: Proceedings of the 54th IEEE VTC’01,
other popular methods of cancellation of ICI shows that the Atlantic City, NJ, vol. 2, 2001. p. 834–8.
proposed scheme outperforms the other methods at all FOs. [12] Bing Han, Xiqi Gao, et al. A DFT-based ICI self-cancellation
The self-ICI cancellation scheme of [8] results in a low SER scheme for OFDM systems, communication technology
Proceedings (ICCT), vol. 2, April 2003. p. 1359–62.
as compared to the standard OFDM and DFT-based ICI can-
[13] Yücek T, Arslan H. ICI cancellation based channel estimation
cellation scheme, but its throughput is just half as compared
for OFDM systems. In: Proceedings of the IEEE radio and
to the DFT-based scheme of [12] and the proposed scheme. wireless conference, Boston, MA, August 2003. p. 111–4.
On the other hand, the DFT-based scheme yields a low SER [14] Yücek T, Arslan H. ICI cancellation based channel estimation
only at low values of FO, and is therefore better than the for OFDM systems. Letter IEICE Trans Commun 2005;E88-
standard OFDM at low values of FO. However, at a high B:2200–1.
value of FO the performance of the DFT-based ICI cancella- [15] Richard Johnson C. et al. Blind equalization using
tion scheme deteriorates over the standard OFDM. The SER the constant modulus criterion: a review. IEEE Proc
resulting from the proposed method is very low as com- 1998;86:1927–50.
pared to the standard OFDM, self-ICI cancellation scheme,
and DFT-based ICI cancellation scheme at any value of FO.
Arvind Kumar was born in India in
Also, in the present scheme repetition of data is not required, 1970 and received his B.Sc. (Maths),
and hence its spectral efficiency is maintained as that of the B.Tech. (Electronics and Telecommuni-
standard OFDM. cation Engineering), and M.E. (Control
and Instrumentation) degrees in 1992,
1996, and 1999 from Rohilkhand Uni-
References versity, Bareilly, Allahabad University,
Allahabad, and N.I.T. Allahabad, re-
[1] Van Nee R, Prasad R. OFDM for wireless multimedia spectively. Presently, he is a Lecturer in
communications. London: Artech House Publishers; 2000. the Department of of Electronics and
[2] Bahai ARS, Saltzberg BR. Multi-carrier digital Communication Engineering at N.I.T Kurukshetra. His research
communications: theory and applications of OFDM. New interests include signal processing and wireless communication
York: Kluwer Academic/Plenum; 1999. systems.
[3] Cimini LJ. Analysis and simulation of a digital mobile
channel using orthogonal frequency division multiplexing.
IEEE Trans Commun 1985;33:665–75. Rajoo Pandey was born in India in
[4] Pollet T, Van Bladel M, Moeneciaey M. BER sensitivity of 1968 and received his B.E., B.Tech.,
OFDM system to carrier frequency offset and Wiener phase and Ph.D. degrees in Electronics and
noise. IEEE Trans Commun 1993;43:191–3. Communication Engineering in 1989,
[5] Moose P. A Technique for orthogonal frequency division 1991, and 2001 from Government En-
multiplexing offset correction. IEEE Trans Commun gineering College, Jabalpur, R.E.C.
1994;42:2908–14. Kurukshetra, and Indian Institute of
[6] Russell M, Stüber GL. Interchannel interference analysis of Technology, Roorkee, India, respec-
OFDM in a mobile environment. In: Proceedings of IEEE tively. He is an Assistant Professor
vehicular technology conference, vol. 2, Chicago, IL, July in the Department of Electronics and
1995. p. 820–4. Communication Engineering at N.I.T Kurukshetra. His research
[7] Yuping Zhao, Sven-Gustav Haggman. Sensitivity to Doppler interests include signal processing, communication systems, and
shift and carrier frequency errors in OFDM systems: neural networks.