Boiler Operation & Control
Boiler Operation & Control
Note: The source of the technical material in this volume is the Professional
Engineering Development Program (PEDP) of Engineering Services.
Warning: The material contained in this document was developed for Saudi
Aramco and is intended for the exclusive use of Saudi Aramcos employees.
Any material contained in this document which is not already in the public
domain may not be copied, reproduced, sold, given, or disclosed to third
parties, or otherwise used in whole, or in part, without the written permission
of the Vice President, Engineering Services, Saudi Aramco.
Chapter : Vessels
File Reference: MEX10402
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
Contents
Pages
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
Standby ....................................................................................................................21
Normal Shutdowns...................................................................................................21
Shutdown for Maintenance.......................................................................................21
Emergency Shutdowns .............................................................................................22
Boiler Layup ............................................................................................................22
WORK AID 1: HP BOILER STARTUP INSTRUCTIONS, RT REFINERY .....................23
WORK AID 2: HP BOILER SHUTDOWN INSTRUCTIONS, RT REFINERY ................34
WORK AID 3: BOILER SAFETY SYSTEMS FOR WATERTUBE TYPES .....................45
GLOSSARY........................................................................................................................50
REFERENCE......................................................................................................................52
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
Table of Figures
Pages
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
2.
3.
4.
5.
Level Measurement
SAES-J-602 (Boiler Safety Systems for Water Tube Boilers) specifies that the water level in the
steam drum shall be measured by 3 independent differential pressure type transmitters. Each
transmitter is to have separate tap points. Two transmitters will be connected to the same end of
the steam drum. One will be used for control and the other will be used for local and control room
indication. The third transmitter located on the other end of the steam drum will be used for
control room indication of low and high level alarms. In addition two externally mounted level
switches directly connected to the drum with their own taps are required for high and low drum
level shutdown functions. The level switches are mounted on the same end of the drum as the
control transmitter and dedicated to shutdown functions only. Level gage glasses are also provide
on each end of the steam drum with their own taps.
While the level gage glass is the basic level measurement, the indication it provides is usually in
error. The reason for the error is that the level gage acts like a condenser/cooler for boiler steam
causing a circulation of condensate through the gage glass. This cooling also cools the
condensate to a lower temperature than the water in the steam drum. The greater density of the
cool water in the gage glass results in a level reading that is often 1 to 3 inches lower than the
actual level in the steam drum. These errors can be corrected by installation and calibration of the
gage glass to show the proper level at operating conditions but the level will be in error at
atmospheric conditions.
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
Control Valves
Two parallel control valves are provided for BFW supply to the steam drum. Only one valve is in
service at one time as per SAES-J-602. A motor operated valve (MOV) located upstream of each
control valve selects which control valve is in service. Indication is provided for the position of
the MOVs. The BFW control valves remain in their last position on air failure.
Shrink and Swell
When the steam load is increased more steam bubbles are generated in the riser tubes. This
results in some water being displaced in the tubes and results in an initial sudden rise in water
level. This swell effect which results in an increased water level normally would decrease the
BFW rate but the steam load indicates that the BFW rate should be increased.
When the steam load is decreased fewer bubbles are generated in the riser tubes. Water then
replaces the space formerly occupied by steam bubbles and results in an initial sudden decrease in
water level. The shrink effect which results in a decreased water level will increase BFW rate
when the steam load indicates that the BFW rate should be decreased.
The increase in pressure on a load decrease can enhance shrink because the steam bubbles get
smaller due to the pressure change. Likewise a decrease in pressure on a load increase can
enhance swell because the bubbles get larger due to the pressure decrease.
The amount of water in the boiler in any one time is called the water inventory. Increasing boiler
loads causes an apparent swell of this inventory. The increase in BFW rate to supply increased
steam production must be delayed due to the swell to maintain level at its setpoint. The level
effect of shrink and swell will decrease with larger steam drums (less % volume change) and
higher boiler operating pressure (the density difference between water and steam is less).
Control
The proper control action will balance the effect of swell and shrink with steam production to
minimize major swings in steam drum level and BFW rate. A high high steam drum level can
result in boiler water being carried over into the steam system with associated problems
downstream especially in turbines. A low low steam drum level will result in inadequate water
supply to some tubes which can result in tube over heating and possible rupture. Shutdown
switches at high high and low low level shutdown the boiler when the level control system cannot
adequately control the steam drum level.
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
The three element control system takes into account the drum level and steam flow to adjust the
BFW rate as shown in the control schematic of Figure 1. The steam drum pressure may also be
used to avoid conflict with the firing control system. The control system in Figure 1 can be
described as a combination feedforward plus feedback cascade control. When boiler load
increases the level control will delay a BFW rate increase required by the steam rate increase until
the level swell has been reduced by boiling due to the load change. A similar control is initiated on
a reduced load change except the BFW continues at the original rate until the shrink has been
reduced and then the BFW is reduced to be proportional to the steam rate. Proper tuning of the
control system results in a desired response so that the control system meets all control objectives.
Steam Out
Steam Drum
Level
Controller
Steam
Flow
BFW Flow
Controller
Boiler
Feedwater
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
Large rapid changes in the steam or mud drum blowdown rate can adversely affect the steam
drum level control.
Steam Drum Pressure/Steam Production Rate
The overall steam production rate is set by user demand. The steam production rate is
proportional to the firing rate. The steam pressure is the primary control of firing. As user
demand increases there is a slight decrease in pressure until firing rate can be increased so that
steam production will match steam demand. The reverse holds true for a decrease in steam
demand. In a single boiler installation the steam pressure controls the firing directly. In multiple
boiler installations a master firing rate pressure controller resets the set point for the steam rate on
individual boilers. The steam rate controls the firing rate on each boiler. The master controller
can allocate steam rate to individual boilers based on the boiler size or on a least cost basis.
Individual boilers may be base loaded by placing them on a constant steam flow control with no
adjustment by the master controller.
Steam production can drop off if the heating value of the fuel decreases. The reduced steam flow
will correct the boiler firing in a multiple boiler installation. In a single boiler installation, the
reduced steam flow will result in decreased steam pressure which will correct the firing. If there
are frequent fluctuations in fuel quality, firing controls can be made more responsive by adding a
fuel heating value feed-forward control component.
Fuel Flow/Pressure
Fuel flow is controlled to meet a boiler demand by the firing control signal through the
combustion control system. Fuel flow can change due to boiler load changes and from heating
value changes in the fuel. Fuel flow should not be a function of fuel supply pressure. Supply
pressure to the control valve should have an independent control as shown in the typical gas and
fuel oil installation flow schematics shown in Figure 2 and Figure 3 which are the minimum fuel
system specified by SAES-J-602 for automatic startup of water tube boilers. Work Aid 3
contains all fuel supply figures from SAES-J-602. The oil supply system also controls the
differential pressure between oil and steam for proper atomization of the oil.
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
A
B
C
D
E
F
H
FT
PI
PS
Pressure Regulator
Manual Vent Valve
Flow Transmitter
Pressure Gauge
Pressure Switch
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
A
B
C
D
E
G
H
BMS
CCS
PDS
TS
Strainer
Manual Bleed Valve
Burner Management System
Combustion Control System
Differential Pressure Switch
Temperature Switch
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
Air Flow
In a forced draft boiler air flow is controlled in proportion to fuel flow by a flow ratio controller.
The air flow is measured by a minimal pressure drop flow measurement such as a venturi. The air
to fuel ratio is normally fairly constant in most systems because ratio does not change rapidly
with heating value and the heating value of the fuel is usually fairly constant. The air to fuel ratio
may need to be adjusted when there is a major change in fuel heating value, because higher
heating value fuels require more air for complete combustion.
Figure 4 shows a schematic of air control. Air flow from fans is normally controlled by throttling
the suction of the forced draft fan to minimize power usage.
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
Natural Draft
Natural draft boilers are limited to fire tube boilers in Saudi Aramco. In a natural draft boiler the
air supply is drawn from the atmosphere by the negative pressure (draft) in the fire tube. The
draft must be carefully controlled because it affects the supply of combustion air through the
burner. Too low of a draft can result in inadequate combustion air with the production of smoke,
long flames and possible flame impingement.
Forced Draft
Saudi Aramco water tube boilers are all forced draft in which air is supplied by a fan. The draft in
the firebox may be either negative or positive depending on the pressure drop through the boiler
to the stack. The draft is controlled by the stack damper when the burner air registers are in a
given position.
Balanced Draft
Balanced draft is usually used when there is an air preheater. A balanced draft boiler has an
induced draft fan at the base of the stack to control the firebox pressure and to compensate for
preheater system pressure drop. The firebox draft is controlled by the damper in the suction or
the induced draft fan.
Excess Air/Oxygen
Excess air and excess oxygen are numerically equivalent since air always has 21% oxygen.
Percent excess air or oxygen is defined as the amount of air in excess of that required for
complete combustion divided by the amount of air required for complete combustion times 100.
Excess oxygen is not the oxygen concentration in the stack. Excess air is controlled by the air to
fuel ratio controller.
An oxygen trim control system may provide automatic control of excess oxygen (air) using the
stack oxygen analyzer to adjust the ratio of air to fuel. Carbon monoxide analyzers are
recommended but are to be used only for monitoring and alarming as per SAES-J-602.
Total System Interaction of Variables
Tuning of the control system is very important to prevent unwanted system interaction. For
example the level control can affect the firing rate by swings of the cold BFW rate into the steam
drum. If the system is not properly tuned swings in the BFW rate can result in firing rate swings
which will then affect the level control because of the changes in shrink and swell and cause
further swings in the BFW rate. This swinging could be started by a change in steam demand.
Interactions can also occur in other systems such as the draft control and the firing system,
blowdown and steam drum level control, etc..
10
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
11
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
12
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
2.
3.
4.
2.
Low low gas or oil fuel burner header pressure after firing control valve.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
Fan(s) tripped.
9.
10.
The shutdowns above are simply extremes of alarms already discussed. The purpose of the alarm
is to give warning of a situation that can lead to a shutdown.
The following sequence will be initiated by Emergency Shutdown System (ESD):
1.
Close fuel gas and oil header shut off valves and open vent valves
13
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
2.
Close fuel gas and oil burner shut off valves and open vent valves
3.
Close pilot gas header shut off valves and open vent valves
4.
5.
6.
Flame Detectors
SAES-J-602 specifies the there should be a minimum of two flame detectors for each burner for
main flame detection. On multiple fuel burners, two detectors are required for the primary fuel
and at least one detector is required for the secondary fuel if the secondary fuel.
Where burner front space is limited and will not allow a third flame detector to be fitted, singleelement dual sensitivity or dual-element flame detectors are acceptable. Single element flame
detectors shall have automatically selected dual-sensitivity adjustments. There should be two
separate sensitivity adjustments for gas and oil firing.
Startup Interlocks
The primary purpose of startup interlocks is to prevent a boiler explosion. Introducing a flame
into a boiler that contains fuel can result in an explosion if the fuel concentration is within the
explosive (flammable) limits. These interlocks should not be bypassed for normal operation.
Bypassing these interlocks will be required to perform system maintenance. Interlock details are
discussed under boiler startup.
Safety Valves (PZVs)
A typical safety relief valve (PZV) is shown in Figure 8.
14
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
Stem
Spring Adjustment
Bonnet
Spring
Outlet
Disc
Nozzle
Body
Inlet
15
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
16
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
The ASME code requires that no valves be installed between the PZVs and the boiler or between
the PZV and it discharges to atmosphere. Discharge piping should be as short and straight as
possible and located away from any platform or walkway. Discharge piping should also be
supported.
Non-Return Valve
Each boiler is equipped with a non-return (check) valve in accordance with ASME code to
prevent the whole steam system from being depressured by venting through a ruptured tube in a
boiler. Two check valves in series are usually used for a non-return valve function.
17
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
Pre-purge permissives
2.
Purge
3.
4.
2.
3.
Fan running
4.
5.
6.
All burner fuel gas and fuel oil block valves closed
7.
Main fuel gas header block valves closed and vent is open
8.
Main fuel oil header block valve and recirculating valve closed
18
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
9.
Main pilot gas header block valves closed and vent valve open
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
If the status of the above is satisfactory then the indicating lamp Purge Available will be turned
on and the purge can begin.
The purge sequence includes starting the purge timer for a minimum of 5 minutes, turning on
Purge in Progress light and turning off Purge Available light.
Once the purge has been completed, the light off can start provided purge permissives are still
satisfactory. The light off includes:
1.
Turning off Purge in Progress light and turning on Purge Complete light,
2.
3.
Start ignitor/burner light off period timer set for about 10 minutes.
4.
The Burner Available light will be turned on if the permissives are still satisfactory which
enables the pilot start push-button at the local panel only.
Operation of the first pilot or burner start push-button will initiate the following sequence:
1.
2.
3.
Start the pilot flame establishing period timer, open the pilot solenoid valves, and energize
pilot ignitor.
The pilot flame will be proven (flame detected) within 10 seconds (pilot flame establishing
period). Failure to detect the pilot flame shall result in closing the pilot solenoid valves and the
pilot start being inhibited for 2 minutes.
When the pilot flame is proven, the burner sequence can be started resulting in the following:
Saudi Aramco DeskTop Standards
19
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
1.
Enabling the main fuel gas or oil header valve push-button circuit.
2.
Opening of selected burner fuel block valves and closing vent valves.
3.
The main flame detectors will prove the flame present within 3 - 5 seconds. Failure to prove the
first main burner flame present or a system malfunction will result in the pilot solenoids closing,
the burner fuel block valves closing and vent valve opening and return to Purge Required state.
Satisfactory completion of the first burner light-off will enable the burner start circuits on the
remaining burners. Light off of the remaining burners is possible from either the local panel or the
control room. Failure to ignite a subsequent burner within its light-off period shall close fuel and
pilot gas block valves and open vents on that burner only.
Once all burners are lit, the system is then in the normal run condition. Combustion is controlled
by the combustion (firing) control system which controls steam production. Any ESD event shall
command the logic to initiate a boiler shutdown.
20
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
Standby
2.
Normal shutdown
3.
4.
Emergency shutdowns
5.
Boiler layup
Standby
In standby, the boiler remains at system pressure but all burners and pilots are turned off and
blocked in. The non-return valve will have to be bypassed to maintain pressure if standby is to be
maintained for a long period of time. Standby can be returned to service quicker than other
shutdowns.
Normal Shutdowns
In a normal shutdown, the burners and pilots are blocked in and the boiler is depressured but
water level is maintained in the boiler. See layup if the boiler will be wet and idle for one week or
more.
Shutdown for Maintenance
In a shutdown for maintenance the boiler is completely shutdown. All water is drained and the
fire side is purged. The fireside of tubes may be water washed. See procedure for water washing
tubes in Work Aid 2.
When shutting down a boiler, care should be taken to avoid a vacuum being formed by
condensing of steam. Boilers are usually vented to atmosphere once the pressure reaches about
15 psig.
Work Aid 2 is a detailed shutdown procedure for Ras Tanura Refinery high pressure steam plant
which is an example of a typical boiler shutdown.
21
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
Emergency Shutdowns
In an emergency shutdown, the burners and pilots are shutdown and blocked in so that the boiler
is in a standby condition.
The following sequence will be initiated by an Emergency Shutdown Device:
1.
Close all fuel gas/oil header shut off valves and open vent valves
2.
Close all fuel gas/oil burner shut off valves and open vent valves
3.
Close all pilot gas header shut off valves and open vent valves
4.
5.
6.
Note that the air fan continues to operate purging the boiler and cooling the boiler.
Boiler Layup
Boiler layup procedures are specified in GI 403.001. The layup procedures minimize boiler
corrosion during layup. Layup should be considered for time periods of greater than one week.
The two principle methods used for boiler layup are:
1.
Wet layup in which the boiler is drained and then completely filled with boiler feed water
that contains additional corrosion inhibitors. All vapor space is filled.
2.
Steam layup in which 15 - 60 psig steam pressure is maintained in the boiler. All boiler
water is drained. Steam connections are made to the superheater outlet and steam traps are
installed on the mud drum and superheater drains. Corrosion inhibitors may be added to the
steam.
22
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
Page 1 of 11
23
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
Page 2 of 11
24
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
Page 3 of 11
25
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
Page 4 of 11
26
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
Page 5 of 11
27
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
Page 6 of 11
28
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
Page 7 of 11
29
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
Page 8 of 11
30
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
Page 9 of 11
31
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
Page 10 of 11
32
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
Page 11 of 11
33
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
Page 1 of 11
34
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
Page 2 of 11
35
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
Page 3 of 11
36
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
Page 4 of 11
37
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
Page 5 of 11
38
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
Page 6 of 11
39
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
Page 7 of 11
40
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
41
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
Page 9 of 11
42
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
Page 10 of 11
43
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
44
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
45
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
46
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
47
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
48
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
49
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
GLOSSARY
alloy steel
austenitic steel
BFW
buckstay
carbon steel
compensation
corroded condition
corrosion allowance
draft
ferritic steel
inside radius
interlock
ligament efficiency
maximum allowable
stress
50
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
maximum allowable
working pressure
minimum required
thickness
MOV
non-return valve
operating temperature
outside diameter
pitch
PZV
ratio control
shrink
Shrink takes place when the firing of the boiler is reduced and
less boiling occurs in the riser tubes which results in the water
level dropping
steel
swell
transition
51
Engineering Encyclopedia
Vessels
Boiler Operation And Control
REFERENCE
Saudi Aramco Standards
SAES-J-602
32-SAMSS-021
34-SAMSS-619
WaterTube Boilers
Flame Monitoring and Burner
Management Systems for Boilers
ASME Standards
ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code
52