December 2012

The Magazine for ENERGY EFFICIENCY in Compressed Air, Pneumatics, Blower and Vacuum Systems

Air Compressor
& Blower Controls

18 Aeration Efficiency Through Design and Control

28 Analyzing Interval Data to Establish Compressed Air Flow

1
SP 2 A
EE PP
D lYI
Co NG
M V
PR AR
ES IA
So Bl
RS E

24 Blow Molder Sequences 40 Bar Compressors

Keeping your production on track

Hi, I'm Daniel and Ive been a service technician working with Atlas Copco products
for over 26 years. Ive seen technology race ahead over that time, but the one thing
always setting the pace is our commitment to keep your productivity on track.
The key behind Atlas Copcos service offering is that its fully customizable, with a
selection of plans and programs that put you in the drivers seat. We understand how
important compressed air is within your workplace and keeping your production fine
tuned is our number one priority. Looking after your processes and applications is
part of every Atlas Copco employees mission and this goes far beyond the compressor
room. Inspecting your piping system for leaks, assessing pressure drops, and checking
condensate drains is all in a days work for our service teams.
Our driving force is to continue to bring sustainable productivity through safer, cleaner,
more energy-efficient and cost-effective compressed air technology. Simply log onto
www.atlascopco.us/danielusa or call 866-688-9611 to learn more about us, our
products, and how we have earned and will continue to earn our reputation.

Copyright 2011 Atlas Copco Compressors LLC. All rights reserved.

The NexT GeNeraTioN of

oil-free
air
ree Compressed a
ir
hitachi continues to innovate newer
and more efficient compressed air
technologies. This innovation enables
our expansion of the dsp series
oil-free Compressors to the dsp
Next Generation. The dsp Next
series is a continuation of our focus
towards environmentally friendly
and energy conscious products.

The dsp Next series contains rotors with a revised

profile resulting in greater efficiency. hitachi patents for
thermally compensated non-contact rotor profile with
1st and 2nd stage stainless rotors and hitachi hx series
pTfe free Coatings are the foundation for the increased
efficiency and high reliability. standard on hitachi dsp
series and dsp Next series compressors.

Gearcase oil mists are not vented to atmosphere, but recaptured,

using hitachis patented oil mist remover. oil mists are recycled,
saving maintenance oil, eliminating possibility of emissions into
the environment, and ensuring purity of air compression. standard
on hitachi dsp series and dsp Next series compressors.

hitachi srl series: The oil-free design of hitachi scroll

croll compressors contains absolutely
no oil. This results in an oil-free compressor that has zero harmful emissions to the
environment. With industry leading sound levels (48-61 dBa), the srl series can be
placed in most any setting within the workplace.

hitachi compressors are designed with market leading technology for increased
customer satisfaction. innovation of compression, air quality, protection of process,
longevity of design, and efficiency of application all combine to provide an
unparalleled sum of value for the discriminating air user.

Hitachi America, Ltd. / Air Technology Group

6901 Northpark Blvd., Charlotte, NC 28216 Tel: 704.972.9870
www.hitachi-america.us/ice/atg; [email protected]
Hitachi Industrial Equipment Systems Co., Ltd.

Columns

1 2 / 1 2

SUSTAINABLE MANUFACTURING
FEATURES

Applying Variable Speed Compressors 12

in Multiple Applications
By Neil A. Mehltretter,
Kaeser Compressors

Improved Aeration Efficiency Through Design and Control 18

By Matthew Gray and Steve Kestel, BioChem Technology

Blow Molder Sequences 40 Bar Compressors 24

By Nicolas De Deken, EnergAir

Analyzing Interval Data to Establish Compressed Air Flow 28

By Hank van Ormer, Air Power USA

Stop Operating Blind Use a Flow Meter 40

By Ron Marshall for the
Compressed Air Challenge

|
|

12

|
|

18

COLUMNS

|
Compressed Air, Pneumatics, | 8

From the Editor 6

Vacuum & Blower Industry News

Resources for Energy Engineers 45

Technology Picks

|
The Marketplace | 49
Advertiser Index 48

Jobs and Technology

airbestpractices.com

24

Meet Us At the Corner of InsIght & exeCUtIon...

for new IdeAs set Into ACtIon
C o n v e r t i n g K n o w l e d g e In t o So l u t i o n s
Since 1948, SPX has provided innovative air treatment products for
critical applications. Our new product development initiatives are driven
by customer INSIGHT meeting the challenges of today and anticipated
opportunities of tomorrow. Through precise EXECUTION, ideas are
transformed into powerful solutions that bring value and a competitive
advantage to our customers.
G e t t i n g It D o n e
Our commitment to innovation is realized with the development of the
new HES series high capacity refrigerated air dryer and HCD Series heat
of compression desiccant air dryer. The designs are inspired by market
demand for sustainable energy savings, fault-tolerant operation and ISO
quality class performance.

Come join us to learn more. Visit us at www.spx.com.

724.745.1555

Columns

1 2 / 1 2

From the e ditor

How much energy is needed for maximum productivity and how can
it be provided in the most efficient manner possible? That question
applies to almost everything in life when you think about it.
The 35th World Energy Engineering Conference was held, in early
November, in Atlanta. I was again motivated by the experiences
shared by industrial Energy Managers from firms like Archer Daniels
Midland and Toyota who are dedicating their careers to reducing
kW, natural gas, water and waste at their factories. We were pleased to again chair a session
on Best Practices in Compressed Air and thank our speakers for sharing their knowledge.
You can find a summary in our Industry News column.

Control the Waste

COMPRESSED AIR BEST PRACTICESEDITORIAL ADVISORy BOARD

Industrial Energy Managers

Measuring flow in compressed air systems is, in my opinion, the next step for compressed
air systems. Point-of-use flow meters can tell users if compressed air is being used
unnecessarily while supply-side flow meters can verify compressor performance and
allow for billing to different compressed air customers. Hank van Ormer provides us an
excellent article on how to read the interval data that provides users with feedback from
flow meters. Ron Marshall, on behalf of the Compressed Air Challenge, also contributes
the article, Stop Operating Blind-Use a Flow Meter.
Blower technology and how to control it, in the wastewater treatment industry, is the focus of
an excellent article from BioChem Technology titled, Improved Aeration Efficiency Through
Design and Control. This is one of those articles that require multiple reads to absorb.
We thank the authors above for sharing their knowledge and thank you for your support
and for investing in Compressed Air Best Practices.
ROD SMITH
Editor
Contact: 412-980-9901, [email protected]

Technology/System Assessments

Applying Variable Speed Compressors in Multiple Applications is the article penned

by Neil A. Mehltretter, from Kaeser Compressors. Its an excellent real-world recount on
the technology and how to best apply it. Many factories have multiple air compressors.
Nicolas De Deken, from EnergAir, provides us with a nice case study on how a blow
molder was able to use a master controller to control multiple 40 bar air compressors
at a blow molding facility.

Thomas Mort

Global Program Manager,

Energy Efficiency

Archer Daniels
Midlands

Richard Feustel

Corporate Energy
Services Manager

Briggs & Stratton

Brad Runda

Manager, Energy

Saint Gobain

Eric Battino

Environmental Sustainability
Manager

PepsiCo

Doug Barndt

Manager, Demand Side

Energy-Sustainability

Ball Corporation

Jennifer Meier

Global Environmental, Energy

& Plant Engineering Manager

Visteon

Mike Seiter

Engineering Coordinator,
Equip. Reliability Group

Honda of America

William Jerald

Energy Manager

CalPortland

Engineering Professional
Nate Altfeather
Development

University
of Wisconsin

Ron Marshall

Customer Engineering Services

Compressed
Air Challenge

Bill Scales

CEO

Scales Industrial
Technologies

Ted Clayton

Energy and Power

Management Services

KAMAN Industrial
Technologies

Paul
Humphreys

Vice President
Communications

Atlas Copco

Wayne Perry

Technical Director

Kaeser
Compressors

David Brittain

Director of Engineering
& Marketing

Becker Pumps

Jay Francis

Vice President Marketing

SPX Flow
Technology

Jon Jensen

Energy Conservation Manager

SMC Corp.
of America

Hank Van
Ormer

President

Air Power USA

Les Ottinger

President/CEO

THP Inc.

Senior Manager,
Nitin Shanbhag
Industrial Division

Hitachi America

Mike Gembala

Vice President

Blake &
Pendleton, Inc.

Pierre Noack

President

Aerzen USA

Clint Hodge

National Accounts Manager

ASCO Numatics

Principal

Quality
Maintenance
Services

Peter Stern

supports the following organizations:

airbestpractices.com

AIR COMPRESSORS

CLEAN AIR IN MOTION

TM

INDUSTRIAL HOSPITALS LABORATORIES PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION

sO
las lity
C
ISO r Qua
Ai
Oil-less scroll design for 100%
clean air
Various configurations for OEM
applications
Scroll enclosures up to 50 HP
Multiplex units are microprocessor
controlled
Compressors can be individually
mechanically & electrically isolated
D Series with a built-in refrigerated
dryer

OEM PRODUCT OFFERINGS

Base mounted scroll compressors

-horizontal configuration

As an industry leading manufacturer of oil-less scroll and

oil-less piston compressors, we are able to offer the market
innovative compressor designs. Whether you require a
bare compressor or a 50 hp scroll enclosure, we have the
perfect fit for your application. Our products can save on
both energy and maintenance costs. All of our products
are built in an ISO registered facility. If you require oil-less
compressed air, look no further than Coaire.

www.coaire.com

Base mounted
scroll compressors
-vertical configuration

Oil-less piston air ends

1 through 7.5 hp

Interested in becoming
a distributor? Call or
email us today!

[email protected]

562-991-3289

Columns

1 2 / 1 2

C o m p r e s s e d A i r , p n e u m At i C s ,
VACuum & Blower industry news

Gardner Denver Confirms Exploration

of Strategic Alternatives

appearance, wed like to provide our readers a

brief description of the excellent presentations.

Gardner Denver, Inc. confirmed that its

Board of Directors is exploring strategic
alternatives to enhance shareholder value.
These alternatives could include, among other
things, enhancing the Company's existing
strategic plan or a possible sale or merger
of the Company.
The Company stated that no decision has been
made and that there can be no assurance
that the Board's exploration of strategic
alternatives will result in any transaction
being entered into or consummated.
TPG Capital, Onex Corp., KKR & Co., the
Blackstone Group and Bain Capital are among
the private-equity firms considering offers,
Reuters reported. They went on to say that
sources said TPG and Onex may bid together
on a sale that may exceed $3 billion.
Gardner Denver shares jumped 21 percent when
the news broke on October 26 to $66.00. They
finished the week at $69.96 against a declining
market worried about the fiscal cliff.
www.gardnerdenver.com

The 35th World Energy Engineering

Conference a Success
The Association of Energy Engineers (AEE)
announced a highly successful World Energy
Engineering Conference (WEEC), held October
31-November 2 in Atlanta. Attendees came
from the AEEs strong membership base of over
16,000 professionals in 89 countries. Founded
in 1977, the AEE is widely recognized for its
energy certification programs most notably its
C.E.M. (Certified Energy Manager) Certification.
8

airbestpractices.com

Albert Thumann, P.E., C.E.M., Executive Director,

Association of Energy Engineers.

Compressed Air Best Practices Magazine

has been fortunate to be associated with the
Association of Energy Engineers since we
launched the publication. Most of our Editorial
Board Members are Energy Managers who
are AEE Members. Representing companies
like PepsiCo, Archer Daniels Midland, Visteon,
Saint Gobain, Briggs & Stratton, CalPortland,
we meet once a year at the World Energy
Engineering Conference and hold our Annual
Editorial Board Dinner.

Frank Moskowitz is a Compressed Air Systems

Analyst with Atlas Copco Compressors.
His presentation was titled, The 14 Rs of
Compressed Air. Frank outlined ways to
reduce leakage losses, reduce pressure at
points of use, reduce pressure at the source,
reduce system pressure fluctuations, reduce
the number of compressors at reduced
capacity, remove inappropriate applications,
reduce system pressure drop losses, remove
the presence of moisture, remove condensate
without air-loss, reduce production downtime
through preventive maintenance, record
system data and maintenance, review air
usage patterns regularly, recover heat, and
reduce energy costs.
Pierre Noack is the President of Aerzen USA.
His presentation was titled, Energy Savings
in Low-Pressure Air: Pneumatic Conveying,
Wastewater Treatment, and Gas Compression.
Pierre identified pressure drop due to piping
design and incorrect blower technology as
areas to focus on to improve pneumatic
conveying systems. In wastewater plants,

Every year over the past four years, the WEEC

has allowed our Editor, Rod Smith, to chair a
session titled, Best Practices in Compressed
Air. Part of the Industrial Energy Management
track, we invited four speakers this year; Frank
Moskowitz from Atlas Copco Compressors,
Pierre Noack from Aerzen, Nitin Shanbhag
from Hitachi America, and Neil Mehltretter
from Kaeser Compressors.
Attendance was excellent. We estimated at least
fifty people attended the session. In order of

Chris Davis, Steve Clasen, Jimmy Ford, Frank Moskowitz

from Atlas Copco and Walter Smith from ETSI Consulting
(left to right).

Columns

1 2 / 1 2

Neil Mehltretter, System Design Manager for Kaeser

Compressors.

DO control, air flow management, and blower

selections was reviewed. In gas compression,
areas such as landfill gas, biogas, gas flared
from industrial plants, and waste heat were
the areas where we need to achieve a balance
between safety, reliability and costs.
Nitin Shanbhag is the Senior Manager,
Charlotte Business Operations, for Hitachi
Americas Air Technology Group. His
presentation was titled, The Need for OilFree Compressed Air. Nitin began with an
explanation of where oil comes from in a
compressed air system whether from ambient
air or from compressor lubrication. He
then gave a description of how an oil-free
air compressor works and listed common
oil-free applications. ISO 8573.1 Air Quality
Classes were introduced as a good way to
develop an air quality specification in a
manufacturing organization. Finally a list of
oil-free compressed air users was provided

Pierre Noack, President of Aerzen USA.

Reaching for the optimum

there is nothing else better:
The new BOGE C series.
Michael Jschke, Sales Manager BOGE Germany
The C series has set new standards, and now it is in pole position:
Less noise, less pipelines, less pipe joints but, instead, more output, more customized configurability, and more efficiency requiring
a minimum of space only. C 15, C 20 and C 30: Oil lubricated screw
compressors from 15 hp to 30 hp with unparalleled efficiency.
Integrated heat recovery as a standard option, decisively optimized
maintainability: We have listened to the wishes of our customers
so as to generate the added value to provide the air to work.

BOGE AI R. TH E AI R TO WORK.
Phone 770-874-1570 or go to www.boge.com/us
airbestpractices.com

Columns

1 2 / 1 2

C O M P R E S S E D A I R , P N E U M AT I C S ,
VA C U U M & B L O W E R I N D U S T Ry N E W S
Compressed Air Best Practices
Magazine had the opportunity to
interview the Founder and Executive
Director, Mr. Albert Thumann, P.E.,
C.E.M., during the Conference.

The
Power
of Red...

CABP: Good morning. How do AEE

membership trends look?
Thumann: Good morning. Reflecting

CPF

growing market demand for energy

professionals, membership in the AEE has
doubled, over the past five years to 16,000
members. Weve been at this since 1977
and its exciting to see the arrival of the
demand for the principles and skills weve
been preaching for a long time.
CABP: What are your members from
industrial companies telling you about
their energy priorities?

QRS

CPC

Thumann: We have trained and certified

energy managers from the largest U.S.
manufacturing and process industries.
3M Corporation, for example, was our first
Corporate Member and at last years WEEC
in Chicago, held their annual meeting with
all managers associated with their energy
conservation and sustainability strategies.
Industrial Energy Managers are telling us
more than ever that energy conservation
not only greatly assists their corporate
efforts to reduce their carbon footprintbut that energy management is a profitable
endeavor that can be conducted without
the help of energy incentives dollars
coming from utilities.

www.cp.com

2012 Chicago Pneumatic. All Rights Reserved.

10

airbestpractices.com

12-CP-142 CABP Ad Resize_rv.indd 3

9/10/12 1:49 PM

CABP: How common are Sustainability

Policies with your members?
Thumann: The AEE Survey of the Energy
Industry 2012: Market Trends Survey
provided us with many insights into our
members activities. Most AEE Members
work for companies significantly engaged
with sustainability. Fifty-nine percent (59%)
of respondents said they have an established
policy concerning sustainability and/or
sustainable development with a further
nineteen percent (19%) stating that a policy
was in development.
Further, eighty-one percent (81%) of survey
respondents stated that they have a set
of established goals associated with their
sustainability policy.
Survey respondents identified the
components included in their sustainability
policies. The top three areas identified
were energy efficiency (87%), employee
education (67%), and waste reduction
and management planning (64%).
CABP: What impact does the cost of
electricity have on your members?
Thumann: The AEE Survey of the Energy
Industry 2012: Market Trends Survey
provided us with insights into this area as
well. Sixty-six percent (66%) surveyed said
their electric rate had increased, twentyone (21%) saw no change, and thirteen
percent (13%) experienced a rate decrease
over the past year.
Of those who experienced a change in their
electric rate versus the prior year, nine

Columns

1 2 / 1 2

percent (9%) of respondents experienced

an increase greater than 15%, another nine
percent (9%) saw an increase between
11-15%, 31% experienced an increase
of 31%, and 38% saw a 1-5% increase.

NEW

CABP: What kind of work does the AEE

do outside the U.S.?
Thumann: The AEE has 3,000 members
outside the U.S. and a network of
membership chapters is being added
to our total of 87 chapters. We have
regional directors, managing this growth,
and our focus is on our core Certified
Energy Manager training sessions.
We just finished, for example, a C.E.M.
course in Madrid.
When you look at Germany and Japan,
for example, you have two countries
who have just committed to a nonnuclear future. This means that for
them, the topics of energy conservation,
alternative energy, and CHP (combined
heat and power) projects enabling
decentralized power generation are
more important than ever.
This is a good example of why the demand
for professional energy management
training and products has never been
greater than it is today. This year, we are
seeing a record turnout of equipment
vendors here at our Expo. Conference
attendees come, here from all over the
world, for training and project ideas. Its an
exciting time to be a energy professional!
CABP: Thank you for your time. Readers
can visit www.aeecenter.org for more
information.

Nitin Shanbhag, Senior Manager Charlotte Business

Operations, for Hitachi Americas Air Technology Group.
RCP-C

along with examples of industries that are recently

adopting oil-free air as their air quality standard.
Last and certainly not least, Neil Mehltretter is the
System Design Manager for Kaeser Compressors.
His presentation was titled, Applying Variable
Speed Compressors in Multiple Compressor
Applications. The article supporting his
presentation is published in this issue of
Compressed Air Best Practices Magazine. Using
a lot of interesting interval data, Neil reviewed the
proper application of variable speed compressors,
differences between variable speed and fixed speed
compressors, master controls and the demand
profile, control gaps, and example systems with
variable speed compressors.
We strongly encourage the compressed air
industry to be involved with the Association of
Energy Engineers. They are, in our opinion, the
leading educational and training organization
in the U.S. on energy efficiency. This is why
Compressed Air Best Practices Magazine is such
a good fit and we feel fortunate to continue our
association with the AEE in 2013. The AEE offers
many ways to receive training and to promote
technology through their three yearly conferences/
expos, their membership chapters, and their
Certified Energy Manager training courses.
Visit www.aeecenter.org for more information.

To read more Industry News articles,

visit www.airbestpractices.com

Keeps
Getting
Stronger.

NEW

CPN

Check out our full line of air

compressors, dryers and
filters at www.cp.com or call
us at 877.861.CPAC (2722).

People. Passion. Performance.

2012 Chicago Pneumatic. All Rights Reserved.

airbestpractices.com
12-CP-142 CABP Ad Resize_rv.indd 4

11

9/10/12 1:49 PM

SUSTAINABLE MANUFACTURING FEATURES

1 2 / 1 2

Applying Variable
Speed Compressors in
Multiple Applications
Application Success Stories
and Improvement Stories
By Neil A. Mehltretter, System Design
Manager, Kaeser Compressors, Inc.

Abstract

kW

c Variable speed control for all types of industrial equipment is now

readily available on the market with competitive pricing to non-variable
speed controlled alternatives, including in the air compressor industry.
With the advent of prescriptive rebate programs for variable speed
compressors and other equipment, the demand for these types of
controls has increased. General wisdom would recommend a variable
speed compressor for all applications, or multiple variable speed
compressors within each system. There are significant benefits for
systems where the demand changes rapidly to be served by variable
speed compressors; by varying the frequency of the input electricity
to the motor, a variable speed compressor can speed up and slow down
to match supply output to the customers demand while maintaining
a stable operating pressure within the system. However, many factors
should be considered when selecting new air compressors especially
for multiple compressor systems. This paper will provide guidance
on the design of variable speed compressors, how they can operate
most efficiently with existing compressors, explain the tools necessary
to consider when applying variable speed compressors to multiple
compressor stations (or any compressors within a system), and provide
examples of systems which required improvement as well as systems
which were well optimized.

CO2

How Variable Speed Compressors Fit Within

the Overall System
Variable Speed Compressors
Variable speed control for air compressors is not the panacea for
compressed air system efficiency. It can be an important component
of an optimized system, provided that it is properly applied. Many
factors must be considered before choosing to add even a properly
sized variable speed compressor to a system. To understand the part
a variable speed compressor would play in creating an efficient system,
it is important to take all of the system factors into consideration.
With regard to the variable speed compressor itself, factors to consider
include the losses associated with the drive, the increased losses in
the motor caused by harmonics in the power supply and the efficient
operating range of speeds of the compressor. Drive losses can reduce
efficiency 3-5% when compared to a fixed speed compressor. A variable
speed drive improves the total energy efficiency only if such additional
losses are exceeded by the benefits resulting from the capability to
regulate the speed at less than full load conditions. An application
where the compressor runs at any steady speed for prolonged periods
of time could be made more efficient by using a properly-sized and
controlled fixed speed compressor (or compressors) that does not
have the losses mentioned above.

In poorly designed systems, it is not at all unusual for compressors

to switch from load to idle every 20 seconds. This can result in an
average power consumption of 90%+ to supply a demand of ~50%.

Neil A. Mehltretter, System Design Manager, Kaeser Compressors, Inc.

12

airbestpractices.com

SUSTAINABLE MANUFACTURING FEATURES

Fixed Speed Compressors

Fixed speed compressors are typically switched between load (the
compressor is running and producing full flow), idle (the compressor
is running but is not producing air) and stand-by (the compressor is
off but ready to restart). Idle operation is necessary when the required
switching frequency between full flow and zero flow exceeds the
maximum permissible starting frequency of the motor.
Power consumption during idle is typically 15-35% of full load power
consumption. However, for lubricated screw compressors, this low
power level is reached only after the pressure in the separator has been
relieved. This can take 30-60 seconds. In poorly designed systems, it is
not at all unusual for compressors to switch from load to idle every 20
seconds. This can result in an average power consumption of 90%+
to supply a demand of ~50%.
Overall System Design
Designing a proper and efficient compressed air system requires
knowledge of the strengths and weaknesses of each compressor

1 2 / 1 2

type and how they should be applied. Because compressed air is

an essential part of the manufacturing process and therefore an
indispensable part of the infrastructure like electricity, interruption
of compressed air supply can cause an interruption of production
and also possible consequential damage. Reliability and availability of
compressed air supply should be ensured by a certain redundancy to
compensate for planned maintenance or breakdown. Generally this
means that the number of compressors, the individual compressor
sizes and the total combined flow of all compressors have to be
chosen in such a way that an uninterrupted compressed air supply is
ensured, even if the largest compressor is shut down for maintenance
or if it fails. This philosophy can be extended to dryers and filters
to ensure complete system redundancy.
For example, in a compressed air station with only two compressors,
the smaller one would have to be sized to provide enough flow to
meet the peak demand or that in a compressed air station with three
compressors, the two smallest would have to be sized to provide enough
flow for the peak demand. This example shows that realizing redundancy

airbestpractices.com

13

1 2 / 1 2

SUSTAINABLE MANUFACTURING FEATURES

APPLyING
APPL
APPLy
ING VARIABLE SPEED COMPRESSORS IN MULTIPLE COMPRESSOR APPLICATIONS
Application Success Stories and Improvement Stories

in compressed air stations with only two or three compressors is

associated with large additional investment, as this typically increases
the overall horsepower of the station. These circumstances in addition
to possible improvements regarding controllability typically lead to the
installation of several compressors in industrial compressed air stations.
In addition to the multiple compressor considerations weighing the
costs and the benefits from including one or more variable frequency
drive compressors should be analyzed. The costs would include capital
as well as potential increased maintenance cost over the lifetime of the
equipment, plus the increased complexity of the compressor requires
advanced training in maintenance and operation.
It is well known that in multiple compressor installations the energy
efficiency is significantly improved by the use of a master control
which coordinates the operation of the individual compressors. The
most important aspect of coordination in this context is to control
the operational modes and the transition between these modes
appropriately (e.g. load, idle, stand-by for fixed speed compressors,
operating speed of variable speed compressors, shut down or startup for all types of compressors).
The master control decouples the individual compressors from the system
demand pattern by translating the actual values and the trend of the total
demand along with the storage pressure, the actual and previous operating
conditions, and the availability of the compressors, to an efficient control
scheme for all compressors minimizing the total energy consumption.
In particular the control scheme applied should benefit from the
individual advantages and avoid the individual disadvantages of the
compressors in the system. These include:
p Supply short-term demand fluctuations using the

control capability of variable speed compressors, but

avoid long-term operation in less efficient operating
points and frequent shut down or start-up

Figure 1: Sample demand flow profile.

14

airbestpractices.com

p Use the high full load efficiency of fixed speed

compressors, but avoid long-term idle operation

and frequent switching between operational modes
Installations with several fixed speed compressors combined with one
or two variable speed compressors are very energy efficient over a large
range of flows, if a master control is applied. The master controller
will allow the variable speed compressor(s) to supply the short and
medium-term fluctuation of the total demand to eliminate the need for
frequently switching fixed speed compressors. The master controller will
also operate the fixed speed compressors in such a way that the actual
base-load demand is supplied by an adequate and efficient combination
of compressors in load and in stand-by. In such installations with two
variable speed compressors and one or more fixed speed compressors,
the additional losses of the variable speed compressors should be
exceeded by the efficiency gain of the entire system as the system rarely
sees frequent switching and/or idling of fixed speed compressors.
An overall cost analysis can be completed to determine the return
on investment by adding a variable speed compressor(s) to the system
as opposed to other alternative solutions.

System Sizing and Compressor Selection

Measuring the System Demand
Given the assumption that a variable speed compressor will be one of
several compressors required to meet the total demand, the first thing
required for properly applying a variable speed compressor, or any
fixed speed compressor for that matter, is a demand profile. A demand
profile is best if measured using a flow meter installed downstream of
air treatment equipment and downstream of dry storage. This way the
profile reflects the actual system demand and is not a supply profile.
Measuring compressor response to system demand, a supply profile,
will produce an approximation of the demand, but storage becomes a
demand in that case and must be considered. Without a profile, it is very
difficult to properly size the variable speed compressor that can cover

Figure 2: Multiple compressor system operated by a master controller.

SUSTAINABLE MANUFACTURING FEATURES

1 2 / 1 2

the variations in demand in an efficient manner. This demand profile

should accompany individual compressor operational signals, along
with power consumption, and multiple system pressures. These signals
together will provide an overall baseline of whether the supply is able
to meet the demand.
Understanding the System Operation
An example of a possible, and simplified, flow profile is shown in
Figure 1. The overall flow percentage is graphed against time in seconds.
Figure 2 shows how a master controller should operate individual
compressors (in this example two fixed speed compressors and one
variable speed compressor) to match the system demand illustrated
in Figure 1 with minimum pressure fluctuations.
The compressors have been sized for the application so that the
base-loaded, fixed speed compressors have a capacity that fits within
the control range of the variable speed compressor. This allows the
fixed speed compressors to be started and stopped when significant
changes in demand occur while the variable speed compressor adjusts

Figure 3: Sample efficiency of variable speed compressor.

for variations in demand that are within its control range. Frequent
switching between load and idle on the fixed speed compressors is
eliminated. The fixed speed machines are either at full load or standby (offline entirely).
Compressor Selection
In the example above, the compressor sizing includes two smaller fixed
speed compressors and one larger variable speed compressor. When

Zero Air-Loss Condensate Drains

COMPRESSED AIR ALSO PRODUCES OILY CONDENSATE*

Electronic

Help ensure it doesnt impact our

ENVIRONMENT.

Smart Guard Ultra

Smart Guard

No Electricity Required

JORC Zero Air-Loss Condensate

Drains and Oil/Water Separators provide
SUSTAINABLE CONDENSATE
MANAGEMENT

Mag-11 - 230 psi

POD-DC Non-Electric

Lock-Down Air Leaks

Sepremium Oil/Water Separator
*

A 250 hp compressor can produce 40,515 gallons of oily condensate per year.

JORC Industrial LLC. 1146 River Road New Castle, DE 19720

Phone: 302-395-0310 Fax: 302-395-0312 [email protected] www.jorc.com
Air-Saver G2

airbestpractices.com

15

1 2 / 1 2

SUSTAINABLE MANUFACTURING FEATURES

APPLyING
APPL
APPLy
ING VARIABLE SPEED COMPRESSORS IN MULTIPLE COMPRESSOR APPLICATIONS
Application Success Stories and Improvement Stories

controller, if the compressor selection is not appropriately made from

the beginning, then the efficiency potential of the system can suffer.
Figure 4 illustrates how the master controller translates changes in
system pressure into a suitable control scheme for the compressors using
the same example in Figure 1 and 2. Note that none of the compressors
are following the system demand. The controller separates their controls
from the demand and determines how they should run to maintain
a stable pressure and above the minimum required pressure.
Figure 4: Characteristics of a compressed air system master controller.

base-load compressors are sized within the control range of the variable
speed compressor, this ensures the ability of the station to maintain
a stable plant pressure and maintain the highest efficiency possible
throughout the prevailing demand profile.
The control range of the variable speed compressor is defined as the
difference between maximum output flow of the compressor at rated
pressure and the minimum flow of the compressor at rated pressure.
When the base-load compressors are sized within this range, and
the compressed air station includes a master controller, then the
compressed air station can maintain a stable operating pressure at
various flow levels. In the example, there are two different horsepower
base-load compressors. This can allow the variable frequency drive
compressor to operate within its maximum efficiency range at varying
flow levels. Figure 3 highlights the general efficiency of a 350 hp
variable speed compressor by graphing the percentage of full load
flow against the compressor's specific power (kW / 100 cfm-fad).
Note that the most efficient points are typically between 40% and
85% of full load which is supported by the data in Figure 3. These
efficiency gains using a single variable speed drive compressor can
be expanded to a multiple compressor station as a whole through
advanced compressor controls.

By using the correct combination of master control and properly sized

compressors, concerns about part-load efficiency of the fixed speed
compressors is eliminated. They will not run any significant time in idle
mode, running instead in full load or stand-by. It should also be noted
that a back-up compressor in the system example would need to have a
flow rate as great as, or greater, than the largest machine in the system.
In an actual application, this flow profile would likely have resulted in
more than just three compressors being specified. Breaking the demand
into smaller units could reduce the size of individual compressors and
allow for smaller back-up or back-up covered by multiple machines.
Selection by Analysis Revisited
It is critical to revisit the compressor selection. By designing
the compressed air station based on measured data, the system
is in a better position to be optimized at demands within the
production than without measured data. In many cases, compressors
are added as production equipment is added to the facility. In these
cases, common wisdom suggests that simply adding a variable speed
compressor on top of existing fixed speed compressors can provide
significant energy savings. However, this typically does not address key
areas of operation as it does not include a full understanding of the
overall system dynamics. In these cases it is always recommended to

Advanced Compressor Controls: The Master Controller

The key to effectively addressing changes in demand within a multiple
compressor system is the correct type of master controller. The master
controller should not simply generate multiple pressure bands and
control each compressor within its assigned band. The controller must
be able to maintain the most effective pressure band and control all
compressors within that band. It must monitor the rate of change of
the pressure to determine the change in flow demand and calculate
the appropriate and most efficient response to that change. It must be
able to monitor the starting frequency of all compressors in the system
so that they can be quickly or immediately switched to stand-by and
avoid any idle mode running. However, even with a sophisticated master
Figure 5: System selection to avoid control gap.
16

airbestpractices.com

SUSTAINABLE MANUFACTURING FEATURES

1 2 / 1 2

complete a comprehensive air demand analysis, or air assessment,

to understand the compressed air dynamics.

What Is Control Gap?

Control Gap Explained
Often times the variable speed compressor selected is the same size
as a base-load compressor or smaller. When designing a compressed
air system, if the control range of the variable speed compressor is not
considered, this can result in one or more compressors operating in an
inefficient manner, such as cycling between load and idle of a fixed speed
compressor or significant ramping up and down of the variable frequency
drive or both at the same time. When these types of events occur, the
plant often refers to the compressed air system as out of control, and
an unusual pressure fluctuation in the facility persists which can affect
production. This is commonly referred to as a control gap.
The control range of the variable speed compressor is critical to avoiding
a control gap. When one or more fixed speed compressor is sized within
the variable speed compressors control range, the control gap can be

Figure 6: Control gap example 1 highlight.

avoided. Figure 5 shows an example system with 150 hp variable speed

drive compressor and multiple 100 hp fixed speed compressors. The
maximum flow of the 150 hp variable speed compressor is 735 cfm-fad
at 110 psig and the minimum speed is 150 cfm-fad, therefore the control
range of the variable speed compressor is 585 cfm-fad at 110 psig.
Continued on page 34.

METPOINT OCV

BEKOKAT

Advanced hydrocarbon monitoring

systems for compressed air

Advanced hydrocarbon removal

systems for compressed air

Each technology featured above is unique and

exclusive to BEKO worldwide.

airbestpractices.com

17

SUSTAINABLE MANUFACTURING FEATURES

1 2 / 1 2

Improved Aeration
Efficiency through
Design and Control
By Matthew Gray, Senior Process Engineer and Steve Kestel,
Lead Systems Engineer, BioChem Technology, Inc.

c With the recent and future increases of the cost of energy, operating
a wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) as efficiently as possible has
become one of the most important factors that operators and managers
are facing today. The implementation of a properly designed aeration
control system has been reported by the United Sates Environmental
Protection Agency to reduce aeration energy by 25 to 40 percent.
An aeration system can be broken into three separate parts: airflow
generation, airflow distribution, and aeration control. Airflow generation
consists of aeration blowers. Airflow distribution consists of air piping,
air control valves, and diffusers. Aeration control consists of blower
control, air flow calculations, airflow meters, and dissolved oxygen
meters. A good aeration system will need all three parts to work well
together. If one aspect of design is lacking, the other two aspects will
be affected and will likely cause the DO set point to be missed, with a
potential of a permit to be violated and energy to be wasted. The goal
of this article is to describe the process of designing an aeration system
and present a case study of an advanced aeration control system.

or Biowin by Envirosim, Hamilton, Ontario that can calculate the OTR

dynamical, will provide values closer to reality. As with all activated
sludge simulations, the better the influent data the better the results.
Influent diurnal loading data of BOD, TKN and TSS is recommended,
if possible. The results from the simulation will provide the complete
range of OTR needed to calculate airflow requirements both
dynamically and spatially.

Air Flow Calculation

Calculation of airflow is the next step after calculation of the process
oxygen requirement. The amount of airflow required to achieve oxygen
transfer requirement is dependent upon the diffuser selection and
layout. Therefore, the calculation of airflow can only be completed after
diffuser design is complete.
There are two basic types of diffusers available on the market, finepore and coarse bubble. Fine-pore has become the design standard for

The following sequence of calculations and design decisions can be used

to provide a cost effective and energy efficient aeration system.

Process Oxygen Requirements

The first step of designing an aeration system is calculation of oxygen
transfer requirements (OTR). The amount of oxygen required is
dynamic, and will vary by time and location within the aeration basin.
Oxygen demand is dynamic because the influent loading is diurnal,
as shown in Figure 1 which depicts the diurnal pattern of influent
ammonia concentration.
The calculation of OTR can be done by hand or spreadsheet for steadystate assumptions, but commercial activated-sludge-model simulation
software packages such as GPS-X by Hydromantis, Hamilton, Ontario
18

airbestpractices.com

Figure 1: Seven days of influent ammonium readings.

SUSTAINABLE MANUFACTURING FEATURES

1 2 / 1 2

Let Gardner Denver

activated sludge process because of the higher standard oxygen transfer
efficiency (SOTE) compared to coarse bubble. SOTE is the percentage
of the airflows oxygen that is transferred into clean water at standard
conditions. Fine-pore diffusers provide higher oxygen transfer because
a larger volume of smaller diameter bubbles are created by the diffuser,
thereby increasing the surface area of gas transfer.

Take ConTrol

The SOTE is not only influenced by the diffuser type, but also the depth
of the diffusers and the airflow per diffuser ratio. All SOTE values are
based on testing performed at the diffuser manufacturers facility with
clean water at standard conditions. A conversion from SOTE into field
oxygen transfer efficiency (OTE) that takes into account the influence of
the activated sludge on gas transfer is necessary. The Fine Pore Aeration
Systems Design Manual by the USEPA provides the methods to calculate
the ratio of (OTE/SOTE) that is seen in the field and is used to calculate
the airflow needed to meet the OTR.
The design of the activated sludge process affects the overall efficiency,
so layout of the diffusers needs to take account of the OTR to ensure
the design conditions are meet in a energy efficient way.
Hydraulic Design: The aeration tank reactor type, complete mix
or plug flow, has different effects on the OTE. The plug flow reactor
will have a higher concentration of pollutants in the beginning of the
process that decreases the alpha value and increases the potential for
fouling. As the concentration of pollutants decreases along the length
of the reactor, the alpha values will increase and the potential fouling
will decrease. Complete mix reactors have a uniform alpha value and
fouling within the tank. A complete mix tank uses more air compared
to a plug flow tank meeting the same effluent quality because the
volume of the complete mix tank must be larger.
Processes Selection: Low Food/Biomass Ratio (F/M Ratio) or high
solids retention time (SRT) processes tend to have a higher alpha value
compared to high F/M ratio or low SRT processes.
Diffuser Layout: After choosing the alpha for each aeration zone,
the airflow calculation can be performed. The number of diffusers
required per zone can be calculated using an airflow to diffuser ratio at
a specific design scenario (i.e. max month). Then the ratio is checked
against other scenarios to make sure it is within the design guidelines
of the diffuser type. The airflow per diffuser ratio and diffuser density
may change the SOTE, so the calculation should be re-analyzed after
completion of the diffuser layout.
If possible, it is recommended that a calibrated dynamic activated
sludge model is used to calculate the airflows using the diffuser transfer

GD Connect 12

Compressed Air system Controller

Intelligently control up to 12 fixed speed

and/or variable speed compressors
Potential Savings up to 35%

www.gardnerdenverproducts.com
airbestpractices.com

19

SUSTAINABLE MANUFACTURING FEATURES

1 2 / 1 2

I M P R O V E D A E R AT I O N E F F I C I E N C y T H R O U G H D E S I G N A N D C O N T R O L
Blower Selection and Sizing

Figure 2: Airflow histogram with blower range.

efficiency parameters and layout. The results

from the simulation will provide the complete
range of airflows needed for analysis. Airflow
can be analyzed by creating a histogram
of the data, and calculating maximum and
minimum month and day values at current
loadings and design loadings. Figure 2 is
an example of a histogram chart of airflow
at a biological nutrient removal facility. The
histogram allows the user to locate potential
data outliers, and shows the complete airflow
range required for the aeration system piping,
control valves and blowers.

Process Piping

kW

The sizing of the piping system is the next step

after the airflow range has been determined.

CO2

If the pipes are too big, the aeration system

may be difficult to control. Likewise if the
pipes are too small, the potential head loss
may require larger horsepower blowers.
Calculating the pressure drop within the
aeration piping system can be accomplished
using a spreadsheet using the Darcy-Weisbach
method as described in Flow of Fluids
Technical Paper 410. For more complex
aeration systems with several control zones, it
is recommended that piping design software
be used, such as Flow of Fluids by Engineered
Software Inc., Lacey, WA. The software has an
easy to use interface, can also be used to size
the control valves, and can be applied to both
airflow and water piping systems.

The selection and sizing of the blower

system is the next step. The total airflow and
pressure requirements were calculated during
the sizing of the piping, control valves and
diffusers. Blower power is directly related
to airflow so it is essential for the blowers
to supply the required airflow range during
both current and future loadings. To meet
the broad range of airflow requirements,
adequate blower turndown is needed.
Turndown can be accomplished by installing
multiple blowers with turndown capabilities.
All blowers have limited turndown, some better
than others. Blower turndown depends upon
how the turndown is accomplished (e.g. VFD,
inlet valves). The use of the airflow histogram
can help determine the number of blowers
and the required turndown. A blower range
overlaid on the airflow histogram is shown in
Figure 2. It is important to note that there is
a required airflow operation overlap between
blowers to allow easy transition between
blowers turning on and off.

Aeration Control System

Excessive and inadequate aeration can lead to
operational problems for the treatment process
efficiency and settling. Inadequate aeration
during high loading can lead to ineffective
treatment of ammonia, and increased SVI due
to low DO sludge bulk. Excessive aeration
can also lead to higher SVI because of floc
breakup. Process control is the only practical
way a well designed activated sludge system
can effectively be manipulated to meet

The implementation of a properly designed aeration control

system has been reported by the United Sates Environmental
Protection Agency to reduce aeration energy by 25 to 40 percent.

Matthew Gray, Senior Process Engineer and Steve Kestel, Lead Systems Engineer, BioChem Technology, Inc.

20

airbestpractices.com

SUSTAINABLE MANUFACTURING FEATURES

treatment goals, satisfy oxygen demand,

minimize operational problems associated
with inadequate or excessive aeration, and
minimize aeration energy consumption.
The successful application of an aeration
control system is dependent upon the
successful integration of control system
components. Control system components
must be correctly sized and installed to insure
successful operation. Each aeration control
zone should have the following equipment
and control components:

Equipment Components
Air Control Valves: The valves need to be
sized to operate between 30 to 70% open.
Below or above that range, the control valves

1201 W US Hyw 20
Michigan City, IN 46360

1 2 / 1 2

become difficult to control. The valves should

also be installed downstream of the air flow
meters to minimize airflow disturbances.
Air Flow Meters: There are several
different types of airflow meters in the
market (i.e. mass flow rate, orifice plates,
etc.) Each work well when installed correctly.
All airflow meters require a minimum
setback distance upstream and downstream
of a disturbance to allow accurate readings.
Review and apply the manufacturers airflow
meter installation guidelines.
DO Meters: The optical-based DO meters
have become the standard at municipal WWTPs
in recent years due to reliable readings and
limited maintenance required or the device.
The DO meters should be installed half way

800-438-6203
219-874-2497

to two-thirds of the way down the length of the

aeration control basin.

Control Components
Air Flow Calculation: The airflow calculation
is the amount of air change required to bring
the DO reading back to DO set-point. There
are two methods used for calculating the
airflow: Proportional-Integral (PI) control
and Deterministic algorithm:
PI Control is a common feedback controller
widely used in industrial control systems. The
controller uses the proportional and integral
values of the difference between the DO set
point and reading to calculate airflow change.
PI controllers are meant for linear-type
systems. When PI control is used as aeration

www.sullivanpalatek.com
[email protected]
airbestpractices.com

21

SUSTAINABLE MANUFACTURING FEATURES

1 2 / 1 2

I M P R O V E D A E R AT I O N E F F I C I E N C y T H R O U G H D E S I G N A N D C O N T R O L
control, which is nonlinear, the controller
needs to be detuned for stability purposes.
Deterministic algorithm is a feedback
control approach for calculating the required
airflow change based upon a model of the
aeration system.
Blower Control: The blower control adjusts
the blower speed or inlet valves to supply
the amount of airflow required to meet the
DO set-points. The blower control can use
pressure or total air flow to control the
blower airflow change.
In a constant pressure system, the blower
control is provided with an air header
pressure measurement and an air header

Figure 3: Pressure versus flow-based blower control.

ENERGY KAIZEN EVENTS

p

Food Packaging Plant Saves $70,000 or 1.1 Million kWh per year.
p Paper Mill Saves $207,000 or 4.5 Million kWh per year.
Get your FREE Subscription to Compressed Air Best
Practices Magazine to learn how to save energy.

Subscribe at

airbestpractices.com

22

airbestpractices.com

SUSTAINABLE MANUFACTURING FEATURES

pressure set point, with the goal of

maintaining the given pressure set point
through the manipulation of either the
motor speed or the inlet guide vane position.
In operation, the blower control system
responds to the increases and decreases
in header pressure caused by changing
air control valve positions, and the valve
positioning algorithm opens and closes valves
to attain an individual zone's DO or Airflow
set point. It should be noted however, the
pressure based system requires valves to
throttle the blower back to attain the desired
airflow. This is directly counter-intuitive
from an energy savings standpoint, where
it is generally accepted that operating at a
lower system pressure yields greater energy

1 2 / 1 2

savings. Traditionally, these savings can be

realized through the implementation of a
most open valve (MOV) control logic however
this valve control scheme is incompatible
with a constant pressure methodology unless
additional logic is included to change the
design pressure setpoint, adding to the
complexity of the system.
The flow based blower control system
requires first that an airflow target is set;
this is usually accomplished through the
use of a deterministic or model derived
control approach. Once the airflow target is
set, the blower is permitted to operate at any
non-surge inducing VFD speeds and guide
vane positions to attain the desired airflow.

As mentioned before, with this type of control

methodology, MOV control schemes can
be employed for additional energy savings
and improved process flexibility as shown
in Figure 3.

Aeration System Case Study

The methodology mentioned above for
designing an aeration system was used for
a project where a facility was upgraded to a
22,700 m3/d (6 mgd) rated Modified Ludzack
Ettinger process from the existing 11,350
m3/d (3 mgd) rated sequencing batch reactor
process. The project required a complete new
aeration system including blowers, diffusers,
and control equipment. The upgraded facility
has been operational since May of 2010.
Continued on page 38.

Changing your compressor lube?

Expect more performance.
Ultrachem synthetic lubricants offer:
higher performance
longer life
greater efficiency
lower maintenance cost
less environmental impact
Plus Ultrachems unparalleled technical expertise,
customer support and private label capability.

Ultrachem.
Superior Synthetic Lubrication.

www.ultracheminc.com 302-325-9880
airbestpractices.com

23

1 2 / 1 2

SUSTAINABLE MANUFACTURING FEATURES

Blow Molder Sequences 40 Bar

Compressors
By Nicolas De Deken, EnergAir

c A recently completed energy efficiency

improvement programme at the Britvic
Beckton bottling plant has resulted in
substantial energy savings and a positive impact
on the companys carbon emissions allocation.
The program employed independent auditors
to review and make recommendations
on improvements to the high-pressure
air generation system on site. The
recommendations resulted in a new
EnergAir control system for each existing
piston compressor, the integration of a new
compressor and the installation of an overall
management, control and PC visualization
package from EnergAir that provides integrated
live control and reporting functions for the
entire system, including the cooling, air
preparation and building ventilation systems.

24

airbestpractices.com

Kevin Cunningham, on the Britvic site

management team comments, Minimising
the environmental impact of our operations
is important to Britvic and reducing Energy
Consumption is a key aspect of that policy.
We were aware that a large part of our
energy expenditure is in compressed air
and commissioned energy auditors Air
Compression Technology (ACT) to benchmark
and audit the high-pressure compressed air
system during October 2004. ACT collated
all the operational data, analyzed it and then
met with us to discuss the plant operational
requirements in detail. From this meeting we
were able to establish accurate estimates for
the possible savings and create a clear strategy
for delivering and maintaining tangible energy,
cost and carbon savings.

Graham Coats, Director of EnergAir Solutions

Ltd, adds PET bottling plants tend to work
on far higher pressures than normal automated
production lines, typically 40bar as opposed
to ~7bar, requiring more power and often
providing a greater opportunity for energy
saving. With the recent rises in energy costs
and the experience we had gained form
systems we have completed on other PET

SUSTAINABLE MANUFACTURING FEATURES

plants, we were confident significant savings

could be realized.
Kevin Course, of Air Compression Technology
Ltd, the independent Site Auditor, Importantly
from the clients point of view the results are
also highly measurable; we now remotely
collate data on a weekly basis from the on-site
EnergAir communications module. The data
is analyzed and reported back to the client on
a quarterly basis. The reporting and ongoing
support from ACT Ltd. ensures that Britvic is
able to continually maintain optimum efficiency
levels (measured in input kW against output
m3/min) regardless of any future change
in their compressed air demands.
The table below summarizes the improvement
in system performance since the introduction
of the compressor management/control
system. The system has achieved the energy
gains by optimizing the installed compressor
set, stabilizing the system pressure and
allowing a careful but precise reduction
in the system operating pressure. Further
energy gains are expected in the short term
through effective management and further
fine-tuning of the system.
This installation also presented a number of
practical challenges for EnergAir to overcome,
not least that the original control cabinets for
the four original high-pressure reciprocating
piston type compressors had to be replaced in
order to update to the new control technology.
A recently installed fifth compressor was also
integrated into the system and only required
the replacement of its PLC controller.
Graham Coats, The EnergAir SX unit
manages the sequencing and duty cycles of
the compressors, but because the original
solid state controls did not afford any of
the connectivity or fine tuning required to
optimize the system, we built a new stateof-the-art compressor controller for each
compressor. The new controls allowed us

1 2 / 1 2

KPIS

RESULT

Generation efficiency

Improved on average by 5.46%

Cost per delivered m

Decreased on average by 5.26%

Annual generation costs

Decreased by 29.36%

Annual kWh used

Net saving of 1,797,131 kWh

Net annual carbon saving

Saving of 772 tons

Note: All summary calculations are based on the cost per unit of electrical energy @ 0.032/kWh and is based on the system being operational for 8,400 hours/annum.

to fully utilise the variable load capability

of the compressors and sequence the different
sizes of compressors on site to match demand
in the most efficient combination possible.
The control installation included new cabinets,
I/O modules, an Airmaster machine controller,
user interface panel LCD HMI, terminals,
switchgear, cabling and commissioning.
The previous control system required a
complex sequenced start-up and shutdown
procedure that required a long list of checks

Intake valve

Manifold

and switches to complete. Now, the process

has been automated to the point where a single
physical start button pressed either locally or
on virtually the PC will carry out the complete
timed and sequenced start routine including
all the parameter checks and power switching.
This improvement not only saves time for the
operating crew, but it also contributes towards
increased plant safety.
The compressor control elements were
supplied by (EnergAir sister company)

Air-end

Integrated system

VMC offers a range of integrated sCrew

CoMpressor solutions up to 100 Hp.
in addition to our total solutions
we offer HigH perforManCe
innoVatiVe CoMponents up to
420 Hp.
siMply tHe best for your
appliCation.
VMC-usa
1209 Lowell St.
Elyria, OH 44035
Phone: 440 322.0652
Fax: 440 323.5215

airbestpractices.com

25

SUSTAINABLE MANUFACTURING FEATURES

1 2 / 1 2

BLOW MOLDER SEqUENCES 40 BAR COMPRESSORS

through to the dryers, cooling system and out
across the plant is represented visually on
screen in a Windows XP environment using
EnergAirs EnerSoft Visual software package,
with key indicators such as system pressure
and efficiency displayed clearly on screen as
analogue style dials.
The data is updated every few seconds and
so the information seen on screen is virtually
live, Britvic are able to predict and plan for
any changes made to the plant and report
effectively on incremental positive changes
made to keep efficiency maximized.
Kevin Cunningham, The project has been
judged a real success as we have achieved
all our predicted goals for energy saving and
improvement in control and reporting. The
system will now continue to reduce energy
usage and improve efficiency on an ongoing
basis. Based on the success at Beckton other
Britvic Group company plants are now also
implementing similar carbon saving upgrades.

CMC Controls based in Belgium, one of

the worlds leading suppliers of onboard
compressor machine controllers and custom
compressor control HMIs. Once installed, the
energy savings are derived from applying a
combination of system pressure optimisation
principles, matching air generation closely
to demand, ensuring compressors are working
at their optimum efficiency and only running
when they are needed.
26

airbestpractices.com

Air pressure sensors are fitted throughout

the system and used to feed live data into
EnergAir EnerSoft Analysis data manager
software that is hosted on an onsite PC,
this collates and records all the data and
makes it available online to ACT Ltd. where
it is compiled into specific Key Performance
Indicator (KPI ) reports. For day-to-day
maintenance monitoring The complete
compressed air system, from compressor,

In an additional stage of process integration

at the plant; the air dryers, compressor
water-cooling system, and ventilation system
are integrated into the overall management
and optimisation package. A triplex dryer
arrangement was installed and connected
to the management system, valves on the
discharge pipes are operated and closed based
on the quality of air treatment if a dryer
goes into a fault state or changes to a high
dewpoint mode, another dryer is started up,
the valve on the unit that requires attention is
closed and the airflow is directed to another
dryer. The system will even automatically alert
the relevant service provider that the dryer
requires servicing.
The new process control system also monitors
pressure and the dewpoint (air quality) at
the point of entry into the bottle blowing
hall, it monitors and meters the amount
of compressed air delivered to each of the

SUSTAINABLE MANUFACTURING FEATURES

1 2 / 1 2

blowing machines, allowing Britvic to use the

efficiency values and the line-flow values to
cost each bottle blower precisely. The flow is
held in the permanent memory of the EnergAir
I/O box making the device both a reliable and
tamper proof data logger.
Two additional control panels were built
for the HVAC system, delivering the same
style of fine control that has been applied
to the compressors, and replacing what was
again a crude, but standard ventilation and
temperature control system. The water is
pumped around the system and so more CMC
control equipment was employed to manage
the pump. Temperature and flow sensors were
placed at key stages around the cooling system
and inside the building; the feedback loop was
then connected through a controller and to
the extraction fans in both towers. The system
optimizes energy usage, heats the building
when required and is fully integrated into
the control and visualization packages.
Graham Coats, the completeness of the system
and the level of data logging at the plant
provides an unparalleled level of diagnostic
ability. Comparing data from different areas
of the system, we can track down a fault far
faster than would ever be possible using
physical methods. Prior to the system being
installed a potential fault could have been
attributed to a huge list of potential causes,
now however, being able to drill down into
the individual machine controllers and view
the data files of individual components, a
problem can often be narrowed down to a
single component or a very precise part of the
process and solved with out it ever affecting
overall production.

To read more Technology articles,

visit www.airbestpractices.com/technology/
compressor-controls

Oil Free Scroll!

Silent / Clean

TECHNOLOGY

toll free: 800-440-0282

www.anestiwata.com
airbestpractices.com

27

1 2 / 1 2

SUSTAINABLE MANUFACTURING FEATURES

The SySTem ASSeSSmenT

Analyzing Interval Data to Establish Compressed Air Flow
By Hank van Ormer, Air Power USA

c Energy management requires accurate and repeatable measurement

of critical data, which is easily monitored and analyzed as required
to stimulate required action. When a compressed air system assessment
is implemented, the basic minimum measurement protocol to establish
the baseline (pre-measurement) and qualify and quantify the results
(post-measurement) is often:
p Flow (scfm), pressure (psig), input power (kW)
p By individual air compressor
p For the whole air system
p Pressure dew point

This data trended and applied to the identified operating profile

generates an accurate annual operating energy cost baseline and
proposed modified operating cost. The post-measurement will then
generate an accurate new baseline with the modified air system.

How Do We Get Data During a System Assessment?

Sometimes the data comes from the plants current data acquisition
system if it is accurate (we often find current systems are old and/
or basically out of calibration, etc.). What is most often the case,
the assessment team installs temporary metering equipment. With
this data, the operating health problems of the system are identified,
the recommended changes implemented and the results measured
and identified.

Plan to Leave the Flow Meters in Place!

On a recent audit at an appliance manufacturer, the pre-assessment
meetings led to the plant purchasing insertion flow meters able to read
and log (500,000 data points) accurately in wet air along with
pressure and temperature. The assessment team installed the meters
in prepared locations and developed the data required for the complete
pre- and post-measurement. At the end of the assessment project,
the assessment team worked with plant personnel to complete the
permanent monitoring and measurement system including reporting
critical data to plant management on a continuing basis. Future plans
will expand the monitor/measurement system.
Stabilizing the compressed air flow relative to identified compressed air
demand now allows accurate measurement of true input energy savings
for future projects such as lowering operating pressure, continued leak
repair, shutting off air supply to equipment not in use and installation
of air-saving devices.

Words of Caution When Using Air Compressor Input Power

(kW) to Estimate Compressed Air Flow
A significant percentage of compressed air system assessments estimate
compressed air flow use, in the plant, by using air compressor input
kW measurements. Estimating air flow, from basic air compressor

At the end of the assessment, these meters are often removed, yet the
true objective of this whole exercise was not just to identify, implement,
and create savings, but also to maintain these savings on a continuing
basis throughout the future and even to improve on them. We call this
savings persistence or savings sustainability.
The main thought that should jump out here is: Why did we remove the
measurement equipment that allowed us to identify the problem during
the system assessment? Plants require the same or even a more complete
measurement and monitoring system to give the operating personnel the
ability to maintain the optimization profile and to continue to monitor
and report the current situation with their compressed air system.

28

airbestpractices.com

Figure 1. Projected operational energy savings after a system assessment and project
Implementation using measurement instrumentation.

SUSTAINABLE MANUFACTURING FEATURES

1 2 / 1 2

performance input kW at actual pressure, can be used to estimate the

scfm flow from an air compressor when the accurate OEM operating
data is available, particularly in positive displacement compressors.
Its important, however, to understand when this method can go wrong.
When relying on kW to estimate the flow at the discharge pressure,
be sure to evaluate:
p How is the kW measured? Check the known

measurement against a calibrated motor analyzer

(such as a Fluke 41 or 43)
p Identify by measuring each leg for amps, volts, power

factor, etc. Determine all the legs are in balance and

what is the estimated motor efficiency
It is important to realize that there are other things that can cause
higher kW in addition to the direct work utilized in producing
the compressed air flow at discharge pressure.
Figure 3 shows the measured kW of two identical air compressors and
identified aMassflow_US.pdf
significant disconnect
These two identical 300 hp
1 05.09.2012 problem.
12:42:56

Figure 2. Achieving Savings Sustainability. Compressed air usage with effective use
of permanent measurement/monitoring.

class units were installed next to each other (full load rated input kW
at 100 psig = 225 kW each). Unit #2 consumed 215 to 225 kW
that was OK. Unit #1 consumed up to 325 kW up to 100 kW more
than Unit #2! Unit #1 had been running this year for seven years. At
$48,000 per year of extra energy cost, this represented $336,000 of
wasted energy. The reason was a problem on the disconnect. Other

Monitoring of Compressed Air

and Industrial Gases
Thermal Mass Flow Sensors
C

CM

From (DN15) to 12 (DN300) and up to 580 psi (40 bar)

Highly accurate, calibrated at working pressure
Interchangeable sensing head
Mounting/dismounting without flow interruption

MY

CY

CMY

Dew Point Sensors

Down to -78F (-60C) dew point

Ability to measure flow and
dew point at one access point

PH: 508-530-3068 www.epluse.com [email protected]

airbestpractices.com

29

SUSTAINABLE MANUFACTURING FEATURES

1 2 / 1 2

THE SySTEM ASSESSMENT

Analyzing Interval Data to Establish Compressed Air Flow

issues can cause the kW number to not
accurately represent flow such as motor
rewinds causing deteriorating efficiency and
connective wiring issues. In this example, if
this kW number had been used to represent
air flow, it simply would have been false.

The Data Sampling Interval,

of kW, is Critical
Step-controlled positive displacement
compressors deploy either 2-step, 3-step, or
5-step capacity controls. Trended data can
be used to identify the time frame for both

loaded and no-load periods and identifying

the percent of flow for each unit. Again, using
the air compressor rated performance data for
full load acfm/scfm flow allows this method to
generate a relatively accurate flow volume for
the trended condition. This method also has
to be implemented with care.
Whenever the protocol calls to generate a
flow volume estimate at pressure from input
power data, the data point sampling interval is
very critical. Any time logged data is used for
diagnosis, as opposed to establishing averages
as in the case of step-type capacity controls,
the sample rate must be close enough to be
sure every cycle point is included or the result
will not accurately reflect the load/unload
profile, and therefore, the generated flow data
will be skewed. It should be noted that when
using kW to project probable flow, kW should
be measured directly reading amp, volts and
power factor simultaneously.

Figure 3. Both No. 1 and No. 2 Units delivered approximately 1,335 scfm at 100 psig (flow meter measures).

The chart in Figure 4 shows data taken,

at the same time, with a 30-minute sampling
rate between data points for six 400 hp,
two-stage, double-acting, water-cooled XLE
compressors with 5-step unloading (100%,
75%, 50%, 25%, and idle) over a 24-hour
period. Usually 3-4 units run at any one time
and they are set to load in sequentially. The scfm
(flow) is calculated by the control monitoring
system using the percent of time at load. With
the 30-minute intervals, the number of part load
units on at any one time is not evident and you
cannot see the various levels of unloading as a
percent of full load of any unit. The cycling rate
is much too fast for the sample rate.
The chart in Figure 5 is the same data, with a
5-second sampling rate, over a 6 hour period.
Reviewing the curves produced by each of
these during the same 6 hour period reveals:
p The 5 second data point chart

Figure 4. 30-minute data sampling interval of six 400 hp air compressors.

30

airbestpractices.com

clearly shows the 5 step unloading

for each applicable unit

SUSTAINABLE MANUFACTURING FEATURES

1 2 / 1 2

p The minimum calculated flow

with the 30 minute data points

was 5,000 cfm. The more accurate
minimum flow with the 5 second
data points was 6,000 cfm
p The maximum flow calculated

with the 30-minute data point

was 7,600 cfm for a very short
duration. The maximum flow,
using the 5 second sampling rate,
is 8,000 and occurs ten separate
times during the six hours of
logging and one time for over
a 20 minute sustained duration
To conclude, the protocol to correctly identify
input power (kW) and interpret the data per
situation and to identify the air flow is correct.
Proper implementation depends on personnel
familiar with the specific air compressors and

Figure 5. 5-second data sampling interval of six 400 hp air compressors shows different results.

DONT LOSE CONTROL OF YOUR

COMPRESSED AIR MOISTURE!
Avoid:

Lost production

Out-of-spec product

Equipment damage
Prevent costly downtime by measuring compressed
air moisture with the Michell Easidew

Fully calibrated dew-point transmitter

Low cost to install and operate
As easy as temperature and
pressure measurement

See full product specication

Michell Instruments, Inc
319 Newburyport Turnpike, Suite 207, Rowley, MA 01969
Tel: 978 484 0005, [email protected]
www.michell.com/us

Dew Point - Humidity - Oxygen

airbestpractices.com

31

1 2 / 1 2

SUSTAINABLE MANUFACTURING FEATURES

THE SySTEM ASSESSMENT

Analyzing Interval Data to Establish Compressed Air Flow

the operation of the specific capacity controls
along with the knowledge and experience
to properly acquire and process the data.

Interpreting Flow Meter Charts

As discussed, with kW measurement, it is
important to be able to read all critical data
to analyze what is or is not occurring. This
is often dependent on data point times when
logging data with trended measurement. The
measurement interval can provide significantly
different data when trying to determine
maximum sustained peak flow i.e. any flow
that will have to be supplied or the system will
fall in pressure to ineffective levels. This is
a function at peak flow, duration at peak and
available effective storage. Care must be taken.

Figure 6. Flow Chart 1 represented an average flow of 586 scfm at 92 psig.

We provide an example of the same installation

where we installed flow meters, during the
system assessment, and created four flow
charts with different measurement intervals.
p Flow Chart 1 (Figure 6)

represented five days of

measurement with data points
plotted and averaged every 15
minutes. Conclusion: an average
flow of 586 scfm at 92 psig. There
are apparent short duration flow
peaks up to about 900 scfm.
p Flow Chart 2 represented 16.5

Figure 7. Flow Chart 4 represented an average flow of 630 scfm at 90 psig pressure.

hours of measurement with data

points plotted and averaged
every 5 seconds. Conclusion: an
average flow of 618 scfm at 92
psig pressure. The pressure at one
point is below 92 psig for over
6 hours out of the 16.5 hours.
Furthermore, the pressure fell to
below 85 psig for over 1 hour and
below 90 psig for almost 5 hours.
There are several sustained peak
demands in this short time, one
of which is 90 minutes long at
or near 900 cfm.
p Flow Chart 3 represented 17

hours of measurement with data

32

airbestpractices.com

SUSTAINABLE MANUFACTURING FEATURES

points plotted and averaged

every 1 minute. Conclusion: an
average flow of 536 scfm at 93 psig
pressure.
p Flow Chart 4 (Figure 7)

represented 2 hours of
measurement with data points
plotted and averaged every 5
seconds. Conclusion: an average
flow of 630 scfm at 90 psig
pressure.
After reviewing Flow Charts 1 through 4, this
operating profile is now much more detailed.
Enough time must be logged and plotted,
even with flow meters, to allow not only these
important pieces to become visible, but also
to allow the profile to be compared to
apparent demand activity and ensure the charts
only reflect plant flow demand and not piping
or external issues. Further observations made
from Flow Chart 4 were:
p At 13:20 the pressure began to fall

as the demand increased

p By 13:27 (after 7 minutes) the

pressure had fallen from 93 to

almost 75 psig while the demand
increased from about 615 scfm
to almost 950 cfm
p The flow demand stayed above

800 scfm for over 3 minutes

p During this 24-minute run the

pressure never returned to 93 and

generally was well below 90 psig
p If production was not negatively

affected by the sustained low

pressure, for almost 24 minutes,
then it may be most likely the
plant can and could run at a
lower pressure

1 2 / 1 2

convert the peaks to low average

flow by some ingenious use of
storage. Flow chart 4 does not tell
all, but it does identify probable
areas of opportunity to be fully
investigated.

p Help identify energy projects

and document savings to collect

utility rebates
p Troubleshoot, find and diagnose

air system problems, leaks and

bottlenecks

Conclusion

p Allocate compressed air system

The key to compressed air system

measurement is to produce verifiable,
repeatable and sustainable data and results that
can not only be used to reduce energy costs
but to sustain the savings. After a full audit
is completed and implemented, establish an
ongoing monitoring program that will allow the
plant to maintain your optimized savings by:

costs at the department level based

on consumption measurement for
individual departments and at key
points of use
For more information contact Hank van Ormer;
tel: 740-862-4112, email: [email protected],
www.airpowerusainc.com

To read more System Assessment

articles, visit www.airbestpractices.com/
system-assessments

p Tracking air system efficiency

to maintain savings levels

(savings persistence)

Air Composition Monitor

FOR COMPRESSED AIR APPLICATIONS
Monitors up to 4 Gas Conditions
at the Same Time
Continuous, Real-Time Hydrocarbon
Monitor
User-Programmable Alarm Relays
for Control Functions
Available for VOCs, Dew Point,
O2 and Toxic Gas in One Monitor
Meets NFPA-99 Requirements
Classified to UL 60601-1, IEC 60601-1
& CSA 22.2, No. 601-1
ProAir 2200

ProAir 2200 is available for a wide range of toxic gases, including ETO, NH3, NO,
NO2, Cl2 HCl, CO, etc.

p It would be a good idea for plant

personnel to identify this 300400 scfm event, particularly if it

shows up in a continuing manner.
Perhaps action can be taken to
eliminate some of this and/or

www.enmet.com [email protected]
Phone: 734-761-1270 Fax: 734-761-3220
Ann Arbor, Michigan

airbestpractices.com

33

1 2 / 1 2

SUSTAINABLE MANUFACTURING FEATURES

APPLyING
APPL
APPLy
ING VARIABLE SPEED COMPRESSORS IN MULTIPLE COMPRESSOR APPLICATIONS
Application Success Stories and Improvement Stories
Continued from page 17.

production periods and the 350 hp variable speed compressor would

trim. The master controller would transition the 200 hp fixed speed
compressor off when higher production periods occurred, allowing
the 350 hp fixed speed compressor to run at full load and the 350 hp
variable speed compressor to trim. This would operate the station
more efficiently at each possible production level.

Figure 7: Control gap example 2 sample operation.

Figure 8: Control gap example 3 highlight.

The two fixed speed compressors are both rated for 497 cfm-fad
at 110 psig and therefore fit within the control range of the variable
speed compressor. As can be seen in Figure 5, the system can provide
a steady operating pressure throughout the flow range of the system
as long as the system is properly controlled with a master controller.
Control Gap Example 1: Same Sized VFD
and Fixed Speed Compressors
Figure 6 shows a system which exhibits a control gap between the
variable speed compressor and one base-load compressor. In this
system there was one fixed speed 350 hp compressor, one variable
speed 350 hp compressor, and one 200 hp fixed speed compressor.
This system did not have a master controller for all the compressors.
Figure 6 highlights a period where the medium load unit (200 hp
fixed speed compressor) was operating fully loaded. This consequently
resulted in multiple periods where the variable speed compressor
and the same sized base-load compressor were cycling between load
and unload together producing a fluctuating pressure of 8 psi and an
uncharacteristically high specific power (kW / 100 cfm) for the facility.
Master Controller Benefits
With a properly selected master controller for all compressors available,
the 200 hp fixed speed compressor would only load during lower
34

airbestpractices.com

Control Gap Example 2: Same Sized VFD

and Fixed Speed Compressor
Typically, with a same sized variable speed compressor and base-load
compressor, the variable speed compressor is operated as the first-on
compressor. This usually ensures the facility will have the best potential
energy efficiency during off-production periods. However, during peak
production without a master controller, and the compressors operating
in a cascade control, the variable speed compressor can run fully
loaded with the base-load compressor trimming resulting in higher than
normal specific power. This can actually increase operating costs, and
will result in a fluctuating plant pressure. Figure 7 shows a 150 hp fixed
speed compressor operating as the trim compressor, and the 150 hp
variable speed compressor operating 100% of full load.
Since the variable speed compressor control range is smaller than
the fixed speed compressor there is an inherent control gap within the
station. The variable speed compressor could operate as the trim load
unit during peak demands with the installation of a master controller;
however, the benefits of the variable speed at lower demands may not
be realized. With the variable speed compressor as the base-load and
the fixed speed compressor as the trim-load compressor, the facility is
spending 20% more in energy than a system with one 150 hp variable
speed compressor, one 75 hp fixed speed compressor, one 150 hp
fixed speed compressor, and a master controller. The master controller
would properly select all existing units to match supply to demand while
maintaining a stable operating pressure rather than a fluctuating system

Figure 9: Properly designed system with master controller.

kW

SUSTAINABLE MANUFACTURING FEATURES

CO2

1 2 / 1 2

An overall cost analysis can be completed to

determine the return on investment by adding
a variable speed compressor(s) to the system
as opposed to other alternative solutions.

Neil A. Mehltretter, System Design Manager, Kaeser Compressors, Inc.

pressure, and the 75 hp fixed speed compressor would fit within the control range of the 150 hp
variable speed compressor thereby avoiding the control gap.
Control Gap Example 3: Larger Fixed Speed Compressor with Smaller VFD Compressor
With a smaller sized variable speed compressor and a larger base-load compressor typically
the variable speed compressor is operated again as the first-on compressor. This operation
ensures that the facility will have the best potential energy efficiency during off-production
periods, as long as the variable speed compressor is large enough to meet demand alone.
However, during peak production, when the demand is higher than the supply of the variable
speed compressor, the base-load compressor will be needed. This often results in more than
one compressor loading and unloading almost simultaneously, and the compressors fighting
each other for control of the station; again increasing the specific power and increasing the
overall cost of operation of the plant.
Figure 8 shows a system with two 125 hp fixed speed compressors, one 100 hp variable speed
drive compressor and highlights a period where the control gap between the variable speed
compressor and the fixed speed compressors is evident. In this case, one 125 hp fixed speed
compressor is fully loaded, which is a good practice. The demand increases slightly and
therefore the 100 hp variable frequency compressor loads to trim. However, since the variable
speed compressor was not large enough to handle the entire increase in demand, the second
125 hp fixed speed compressor was subsequently loaded. The additional supply flow from both
the 100 hp and the 125 hp compressors was too much for the demand and both compressors
subsequently unloaded. The process continued and the specific power of the station became
less efficient, as well as the increased wear on the units from constant cycling.
In this particular scenario, adding a 75 hp fixed speed compressor along with a master controller
to the existing fixed speed compressors and variable speed compressor would avoid the control
gap and balance the system by maximizing part load power efficiency of the station.

Everything
In Control
(including costs).
The Xe-Series Controller, standard
equipment on Ingersoll Rand rotary
compressors, lets you manage plant
safety, reliability and efciency, anytime,
anywhere. Easy-to-read, intuitive displays
and multiple connectivity options. Precise
pressure control and programmable timers
that maximize energy use. Remote internet
access and adjustment of system data,
plus email alerts of problems, performance
and maintenance. One controller. Endless
opportunities for savings. Ingersoll Rand.
www.ingersollrandproducts.com

Avoiding Control Gap

Properly Sized Equipment
Figure 9 shows a system sized based on a demand profile to avoid any control gaps within
the demand. The system included a 75 hp variable frequency drive compressor, a 40 hp fixed
speed compressor (medium load unit), and a 75 hp fixed speed compressor (base-load unit)
with a master controller. The master controller properly selected between the two differently
sized fixed speed compressors to operate fully loaded while the variable frequency drive
compressor trimmed.
airbestpractices.com
21873.indd 1

35

11/1/12 2:09 PM

SUSTAINABLE MANUFACTURING FEATURES

1 2 / 1 2

APPLyING
APPL
APPLy
ING VARIABLE SPEED COMPRESSORS IN MULTIPLE COMPRESSOR APPLICATIONS
Application Success Stories and Improvement Stories

provided the lowest energy consumption and most efficient station

operation regardless of the demand. The systems which were either
not sized based on a demand profile, did not include a master
controller, or were not sized appropriately resulted in a higher than
expected energy consumption, higher overall maintenance costs, and
the appearance of less stable operating conditions by plant personnel.
Key Points:
1) In typical industrial applications, several compressors supply
the total flow.
Figure 10: Flow and efficiency for properly designed system.

2) Multiple compressor systems should be controlled by a master

controller to operate in different combinations and operating
points or operational modes.
3) In such installations, an individual compressor follows
the control scheme of the master controller and does not
independently respond to or reflect changes in systems
demand.

Table 1: Sample monthly energy consumption and duty cycles

for properly designed system.

The addition of the medium load unit avoided the inherent control gap
between the two 75 hp compressors. Along with the master controller,
the station provided a relatively stable operating pressure throughout
the various demand levels while maintaining an efficient specific power
throughout this sample day of operation. Figure 10 highlights the
consistent specific power over an entire sample day regardless of the
demand profile. The only mild increase in specific power occurred
during a transition to a lower supply range which represents a relatively
small percentage of operation.
This type of operation results in a low specific power, a low overall
energy cost due to the compressors spending little time cycling between
load and unload, as well as little time idling. Table 1 shows a one month
sample for the system discussed. All three units have a duty cycle close
to 100%, meaning that the idle costs are less than 1% of the overall
energy consumption. The added benefit will be lower maintenance
costs to the cycling components of the individual compressors as well
as stable plant pressure. Adding a third 75 hp fixed speed or variable
speed compressor would provide complete redundancy to this station
and would be highly recommended.

4) The combined operation of fixed speed and variable speed

compressors allows the controller to use the individual
advantages of each type of compressor to its full extent and
avoid the disadvantages to achieve high system efficiency by
decoupling the compressors from the actual demand.
5) The proper design of a compressed air system and the choice
of compressors cannot be done without first determining the
demand profile.
6) The design may include multiple variable speed compressors,
one variable speed compressor or none at all depending on
the prevailing demand profile and other mitigating factors such
as capital cost, return on investment, and application.
AUTHORS BIOGRAPHY
Neil Mehltretter has a Bachelors Degree in Chemical Engineering from The University
of Florida. Neil first worked on energy efficiency projects during his time at The
University of Florida, and after graduation, he worked in the alternative energy
industry before joining Kaeser Compressors, Inc. in 2004. Neil is a Master Certified
System Specialist through Kaesers Factory Training Program and has completed the
Compressed Air Challenge Level 1 and 2 training courses. Neil is also a Qualified
AIRMaster+ Specialist. During his time with Kaeser, he has supported numerous
compressed air projects and air audits as well as served as the primary contact for
the installation of Kaesers master controller, the Sigma Air Manager. Currently Neil
manages the design and engineering services for Kaeser, which includes energy
improvements as well as compressed air selection. He can be reached by email
at [email protected].

Summary and Conclusions

In all of the examples shown, the systems which were sized properly
based on a demand profile, and operating on a master controller

36

airbestpractices.com

To read more Air Compressor Technology articles, visit

www.airbestpractices.com/technology/air-compressors

FREE SUBSCRIPTION
DIGITAL EDITION FREE WORLDWIDE | PRINT EDITION FREE TO U.S. SUBSCRIBERS

Learn How To Save Energy & Improve

Productivity In YOUR Industry!
2013 FOCUS INDUSTRIES:
pp

Energy: Biogas

pp

pp

Food Packaging
& Containers

Energy: Compressed
Natural Gas

pp

Pneumatic Conveying

pp

Plastic Blow Molding

pp

pp

System Assessments

Compressed Air System

Automation

pp

Wastewater Treatment

pp

Food Processing

pp

Metal Fabrication
& Machining

pp

Air Compressor Controls

Subscribe at airbestpractices.com
International pricing for print edition $65 in Canada and $95 for other countries.

SUSTAINABLE MANUFACTURING FEATURES

1 2 / 1 2

I M P R O V E D A E R AT I O N E F F I C I E N C y T H R O U G H D E S I G N A N D C O N T R O L
Continued from page 23.

During the design process, GPS-X was used

to simulate the required OTR needed for
the design, using historical influent data
and supplemental diurnal sampling. The OTR
data and minimum required alpha and SOTE
were forwarded to the diffuser manufacturer
to optimize diffuser layout design.
After the diffuser design was complete, GPS-X
simulation was modified with the diffuser
information and the range of airflow required
to meet the oxygen demands was calculated.
Three types of blowers were analyzed, Tri-lobe
positive displacement, multi-stage centrifugal,
and high speed direct drive turbo. Tri-lobe
positive displacement blowers with VFD for
speed control were selected based upon a
10 year present value cost analysis and the
turndown capability. The final design allowed
provisions for the installation of five total
blowers. The blowers have a turndown of 60
to 70% with VFD control, which allows great
operational flexibility.
The aeration control system consists of four
control zones in each train, with each control

zone having an air control valve, air flow

meter, and DO meter. The aeration system
equipment is controlled by the Bioprocess
Aeration Control System (BACS).

BACS Description
The aeration control system uses airflow,
temperature, DO measurements, and oxygen
saturation to calculate an oxygen uptake rate
factor (OURf) in each zone. The OURf can
be used to trend the actual OUR within the
aeration control zone.

Airflow Calculation Technique 1:

Predictive Feedback Control
The calculation of the airflow set point is based
upon the weighted average of two techniques
of calculating the required airflow to meet the
DO set point. The first technique is considered
predictive feedback control which uses two
methods of using the OURf to calculate the
airflow set point. The second technique is
a feed forward method that uses ammonium
measurements to calculate the change in OUR
based upon loading.

Figure 4: Graphical depiction of OURf airflow calculation methods.

38

airbestpractices.com

Method 1: It is assumed that the loading

does not change from control time steps T0
to T1, and the change in OUR is due to the
required change in DO to match the set point.
The concept is that the reaction rate changes
with the DO concentration based upon the
Monod kinetics.
Method 2: The method consists of predicting
the OURf at time T1 based upon the previous
increase in OURf from time T-1 to T0.

Airflow Calculation Technique 2:

Feed Forward Control
The two OURf values calculated in the
predictive feedback technique are averaged
based upon a ratio of the two. The default
value ratio is 30% Method 1 and 70% Method
2. The airflow is then calculated using the
weighted average OURf. The calculation of
airflow is a function of temperature, DO set
point, and oxygen saturation. A graphical
description of the two methods is shown
below in Figure 4.
A challenging aspect of providing a stable
and robust aeration control system is the
proper response to process disturbances.
The most direct way to accomplish the goal
of the control system is to first quantify
the influent load by strategically locating
loading sensitive in-situ instrumentation at
the beginning of (or directly before) the first
oxic zone and then preemptively responding
to this information before the load disturbs
the oxic zones DO reading. Because an
accurate BOD/COD loading measurement
cannot be collected in real time, an online
ammonia analyzer can be utilized as an
indirect indicator of BOD/COD loading. To
do this, first one must correlate BOD/COD
concentrations with ammonia concentrations

SUSTAINABLE MANUFACTURING FEATURES

throughout the day. Tests on the influent for

both BOD/COD and ammonia concentrations
performed at different points throughout
the day allow for the establishment of such
a first-order proportional relationship.
Once an estimate for the current oxygen
demand of the influent is gauged, this
information is processed by an algorithm
based on the Activated Sludge Model (ASM)
to estimate the current OUR and the proper
airflow rate required to correctly compensate
for any changes in the OUR in the incoming
wastewater since the last control calculation.

Airflow Set Point

As mentioned above, the calculation of the
airflow set point is based upon the weighted
average of the predictive feedback and feed
forward techniques of calculating the airflow
required to meet the DO set point. The
ratio of the weighted average is dependent
upon field verification of the feed forward
model. In the event that the ammonia signal
is low quality, lost or not used, the systems
backup control formulates the proper control
response by applying only the predictive
feedback control technique.

Valve Control
At regular intervals, the aeration control system
sends a total airflow set-point to the blower
control, and then positions the air control
valves to distribute the air to each aeration
zone based upon the calculated airflow set
point for each zone.
The valve positioning logic uses the actual
individual butterfly valves Cv curve to
calculate an approximate new valve position
to satisfy the airflow set point. After giving
the valve control logic a sufficient amount

of time to adjust to the desired airflow, the

valve locks in to a final position to prevent
unnecessary additional starts of the actuator
for the remainder of the control cycle. When
a new air flow set point is calculated the valve
lockout is lifted and the control logic restarts.
The valve control includes dynamic most open
valve logic to promote low system pressure
by having one of the control valves become
the most open valve (MOV) at 85% open and
allows the other control valves to seek their
position to meet the airflow requirements.
When a control valve that is not the MOV is
calculated to be at greater percent open than
the MOV, then that valve becomes MOV, and
the previous MOV will be able to close.

Advantages
The process-based control concept allows the
aeration control system to respond accurately
to any changes in the operating conditions
and influent loading. It differentiates the
aeration control system from a PI control
loop that has a fixed gain independent of
the process changes, so outside of a narrow
band for which it is tuned, the PI controller
will either over- or under-react to daily and
seasonally changing conditions. The system is
self-tuning and stabilizes quickly after process
disturbances.
The flow control of the blowers (as
opposed to pressure control) has additional
advantages. The system is not required
to restrict the flow to maintain a constant
pressure, so the most-open-valve logic of
the aeration control system ensures that
the blower is always operating at the lowest
possible system pressure. It also prevents
the often observed cyclical hunting of blower
and valves that is caused by the blower

1 2 / 1 2

control and valve control loops responding

to the control action of the other control
loop, instead of process changes, leading
to unstable DO values and premature failure
of the valve actuators.

RESULTS
The startup flow at the facility was at sixty five
percent less than design, which could have
led to wasted energy or process upset, but the
designed flexibility of the system prevented any
limitations due to low loading. The system has
been able to meet the dissolved oxygen setpoint requirements and control the dissolved
oxygen to within 0.5 mg/l of the set point
94.5% of the time and within 1.0 mg/l of the
set point 99.5% of the time. The measured
aeration power savings is 41 percent compared
to constant speed operation.

CONCLUSION
The Poinciana aeration system installation
confirms that a successful application of an
aeration control system is dependent upon
a successful operation of aeration system
components. System components must
be correctly sized and installed to insure
successful operation. By following the design
procedures described in the methodology of
the paper the implementation of a properly
designed aeration control system can be
achieved.
For more information contact Matthew Gray, BioChem
Technology, Inc.,email: [email protected],
www.biochemtech.com

For more Technology articles

visit www.airbestpractices.com/
technology/blowers

airbestpractices.com

39

SUSTAINABLE MANUFACTURING FEATURES

1 2 / 1 2

SToP oPERATING BlIND

USE A FlowMETER
By Ron Marshall for the
Compressed Air Challenge

kW

c Participants of Compressed Air Challenges

Fundamentals of Compressed Air Systems
seminars are usually surprised to learn that
compressed air is one of the most inefficient
energy sources for machine operation in
your plant. To gain about one horsepower
of mechanical energy from a compressed
air powered motor it costs seven times as
much at the input of the air compressor. And
surprisingly between 20 and 30 percent of this
valuable power is lost even before it gets to the
end use. Further to this another 10 percent
is lost to artificial demand caused by higher
than required pressure, and to top that all off,
another 10 percent is wasted by equipment
that is either inappropriately supplied with

CO2

compressed air or left to consume air even

when the associated production machine
has been turned off.
These facts are surprising to people because
their compressor rooms are notoriously
lacking in even the basic instrumentation
that could tell them the energy and flow
characteristics of their system. Often large
amounts of time and money are expended
in optimizing the production side of a
compressed air system, but the system
operator has no idea if the new upgraded
equipment is producing air as efficiently
as expected or if that efficient produced
air is wasted or misused.

Open your Eyes

An old management axiom is: If you cant
measure it you cant manage it. This is still
as true today as it was when it was first uttered
by wise men many years ago. But in the old
days, where compressed air was concerned,
there may have been some good excuses for
ignoring compressed air flow measurement.
Years ago pretty much the only way to measure
compressed air was to install orifice plate
meters. These units introduced a pressure loss
into the system, which was actually the way
the measurement was done. The flow meter
instrumentation of the time had to measure
the plate pressure differential and equate
this to a particular flow. Due to the square

To gain about one horsepower of mechanical energy from a

compressed air powered motor it costs seven times as much at the
input of the air compressor. And surprisingly between 20 and 30 percent
of this valuable power is lost even before it gets to the end use.

Ron Marshall
40

airbestpractices.com

SUSTAINABLE MANUFACTURING FEATURES

1 2 / 1 2

Fundamentals
of Compressed
Air Systems WE
(web-edition)

Learn about Optimizing Your Air System

Join Compressed Air Challenge for the next session of
Fundamentals of Compressed Air Systems WE (web-edition)
coming in the Spring of 2013. Led by our experienced
instructors, this web-based version of the popular
Fundamentals of Compressed Air Systems training uses an
interactive format that enables the instructor to diagram
examples, give pop quizzes and answer student questions
in real time. Participation is limited to 25 students. Please
visit www.compressedairchallenge.org, to access online
registration and for more information about the training.
If you have additional questions about the new web-based
training or other CAC training opportunities, please contact
the CAC at [email protected].

function characteristics of the pressure drop

the meters could be accurate at higher flows
near full rating, but as the flow decreased
the rapidly diminishing differential pressure
became too small to measure, resulting in
poor turndown characteristics. These also
meters had to be calibrated for a certain
pressure and became inaccurate if the
pressure changed. These meters introduced
costly pressure differential into the system at
high flow and had only limited accuracy for
determining flows at low flows, where leakage
rates are usually measured. Many older plants
still have orifice plates still installed, many
of which have instruments that are out of
service, but the plates are still robbing the
system of energy. If you have one it may me
time to consider removal.

New Old Idea

In these modern days of low cost electronic
instrumentation many new ways to measure
flow have been developed. The most popular
of these is the thermal mass flow meter. The
principal of design of these meters was actually

invented in 1914 by L.V. King who noticed that

his hot wire anemometer measured the mass
velocity at the point of flow. The meter works
using two temperature sensors, one heated
and the other static. Mass flow is proportional
to the amount of power required to keep a
constant temperature difference between these
sensors in a flow of gas. Modern day thermal
mass meters are inserted into a pressurized
compressed air line using a number of
different mounting strategies, including hot
tapping. The result is an accurate signal output
that is not affected by changes in air pressure.
If the flow meter is calibrated for a given pipe
size, and the probes properly positioned in a
turbulence free airstream, an accurate flow
profile can result with a typical turn down
range of about 100:1. Thermal mass meters
suffer from an important issue, they need to be
placed in a airstream that is dry, the presence
of free water interferes with the proper display
of flow due to the much higher cooling effect
of the water. Therefore these flow meters must
be installed after the air dryer and will be
affected if the dryer is not functioning properly.
This downside is offset by the fact that these

flow meters present no pressure differential

to the flow of air and recent advances in meter
design has lowered the cost of some units
to very low levels making them affordable
even for small systems.
Compressed Air Challenges Best Practices
for Compressed Air Manual discusses the
application of flow meters to compressed
air systems. The following is an excerpt:
Many of the meters require a pipe
length of at least 20 times the pipe
diameter upstream and 10 times
the pipe diameter downstream of
the meter to reduce turbulence,
which induces inaccurate results.
The manufacturers' requirements
must be observed for accurate
readings. Mass flow meters are
preferred because they are pressure
and temperature compensated.
It is important to be aware of
the differences between mass
flow (scfm) and compressor
capacity in acfm or icfm. Some
airbestpractices.com

41

SUSTAINABLE MANUFACTURING FEATURES

1 2 / 1 2

STOP OPERATING BLIND USE A FLOWMETER

of the considerations in selecting
a flow meter include estimated
maximum and minimum flow
rates and operating pressures and
temperatures. The performance is

based on an accuracy of perhaps

0.5 percent at full scale and the
tum-down or range ability of the
meter. The turndown capability
is important to be certain that a

specified accuracy is maintained

down to whatever percentage of the
maximum flow is anticipated to be
the minimum. It is recommended
that a flow meter be installed in
the piping where the compressed
air is clean and dry.
Because a mass flow meter
normally is installed downstream
of dryers, the meter will be
measuring a rate of flow of air
from which most of the moisture
has been removed. Knowing the
temperature and relative humidity
of ambient air to the compressor
inlet and the pressure dew point
of the compressed air flowing
through the meter allows you to
determine the difference between
scfm (meter measurement) and
acfm (compressor inlet flow)
(see Section 1.A.6 in the BPM).

Figure 1: Week Profile (scfm).

It also is necessary to know the

scfm standard used by the meter
manufacturer. The old standard
used by CAGI of 14.7 psia, 68F,
and 36 percent relative humidity
has been superseded by the new
standard of 14.5 psia, 68F, and
0 percent relative humidity. The
old standard cubic foot requires
1.38 percent more acfm due to
pressure and 0.83 percent less
acfm due to moisture content,
giving a net positive difference
of only 0.54 percent.
A regenerative dryer can use up
to 15 percent of the incoming
compressed air supply as purge
air to regenerate the desiccant.
Installing flow monitoring sensors
upstream and downstream of the

Figure 2: Day Profile (scfm).

42

airbestpractices.com

SUSTAINABLE MANUFACTURING FEATURES

dryer could be expensive but will

provide the necessary monitoring
to ensure the dryer is not purging
more than is required.
The installation of a compressed
air flow meter in the main
supply header will provide an
accurate usage profile and also
the plant leakage rate during nonproduction periods. In addition,
when combined with electrical
consumption readings, the ratio
of output air flow to input power
provides the basis for measuring
system efficiency.
Flow meters in the system are
measuring plant demand and
not compressor full load outputs.
However, if it is noted that system
pressure is stable or falling when
compressors are fully loaded, the
flow meter reading is the entire
output of the compressors that
are running. Correct interpretation
of the recorded results is very
important before reaching
conclusions. Permanent flow
meters are not usually found
in systems below 1,500 scfm.
In some cases, permanent
insertion measuring ports can be
retained and one portable meter
can be utilized throughout the
system to monitor air usage in
particular departments. Measuring
flow during non-production
hours can provide information
on leakage rates or inappropriate
uses of compressed air. It is
difficult, but often very effective,
to charge departments or processes
for the use of compressed air.

1 2 / 1 2

Use of the Flow Data Real Example

Figure 1 and 2 shows an example of an
output of a flow meter in measuring the
flow profile of a large automotive product
manufacturing plant that operates in a one
shift 5 day a week operation.
On inspection of the profiles we can see from
the data that the plant flow characteristic is
typical of a shift oriented facility. Main work
activity starts at about 7:00 am and finishes
about 3:00 pm with rest and lunch breaks
evident throughout the day. As is normal, the
period just before lunch is the most active part
of the day. It appears the highest activity is on
Monday, with workload decreasing steadily as
the week wears on. The average flow for the
plant is about 750 cfm.
An interesting characteristic of the data
is the compressed air flow in the times between
production shifts. It appears that during off
hours on weekdays the plant flow ranges
between 580 and 700 cfm. During weekends the
flow, presumably due to leakage and production
machinery left on, is about 560 cfm. Amazingly,
this wasted flow, measured during times where
there is no production, amounts to 75% of all
the compressed air produced.

Best Practices for

Compressed Air
Systems Second Edition

When plant staff became aware of this

situation they were interested in knowing
what exactly was causing this wasted air
flow. Because they had a flow meter they
had a ready tool for measurement which
they could use to do an assessment on a
non-production day. Using an ultrasonic leak
detector staff performed a scan of all areas
of production to find areas of use. Whenever
a significant item was found it was isolated
from the system and the corresponding
time was recorded. Once the exercise was
completed a final flow total was tallied by
observing the flow meter and the various
items isolated by noting the flow reduction
on the available data log chart associated
with the time the load was shut off. In this
particular case leaks were not the total cause
of the off-hours flow, amounting to slightly
more than half the total flow:
TABLE 1: CONSTITUENTS OF DEMAND
OFF HOURS
ITEM

FLOW (SCFM)

% OF TOTAL

Paint Agitators

60

11

Laser Desiccant Dryers

100

18

Breathing Air Purifiers

113

20

Leaks

287

51

Total

560

This 325 page manual begins with the considerations

for analyzing existing systems or designing new ones,
and continues through the compressor supply to the
auxiliary equipment and distribution system to the end
uses. Learn how to use measurements to audit your
own system, calculate the cost of compressed air and
even how to interpret utility electric bills. Best practice
recommendations for selection, installation, maintenance
and operation of all the equipment and components within
the compressed air system are in bold font and are easily
selected from each section.

airbestpractices.com

43

SUSTAINABLE MANUFACTURING FEATURES

1 2 / 1 2

STOP OPERATING BLIND USE A FLOWMETER

Armed with this new knowledge the plant
personnel set out to find solutions to the issue
of after-hours flow. These reductions have
been added to a system upgrade project where
the load reduction savings will in part help pay
for a new Variable Speed Drive compressor
and cycling dryer. The flow meter has been
reused and has been placed in service as
part of an innovative permanent air system
monitoring system that generates weekly
efficiency reports that track savings due to
leakage reduction and changes to compressor
control modes. Example outputs of this system
are shown in Figure 3 and 4.
Because this customer is constantly measuring
the flow, and analyzing the data weekly, the
savings for the project can now be verified
by the power utility and the leakage levels
tracked. Before the installation this customer
was operating blind and had no idea of the
level of waste in their system. Use of a flow
meter has opened their eyes to new potential
and the resulting improvements have saved
significant operating costs.

Figure 3: Multi-Day Airflow Comparison (Courtesy Air Power Analytics).

To read similar Measurement Technology

articles, visit www.airbestpractices.com/
technology/instrumentation

kW

Figure 4: Daily Airflow Comparison (Courtesy Air Power Analytics).

CO2

Before the installation this customer was operating blind

and had no idea of the level of waste in their system. Use of a flow
meter has opened their eyes to new potential and the resulting
improvements have saved significant operating costs.

Ron Marshall

44

airbestpractices.com

Columns

1 2 / 1 2

ResouRces foR eneRgy engineeRs

TECHNOLOGy PICKS
Sullair Now Offers V250S Single Stage Compressor
with VSD Technology
Sullair Corporation is pleased to announce its expanded line of
V250S Single-Stage Rotary Screw Air Compressors with Variable
Speed Drive technology. Designed to combine the simplicity of
Sullair's basic single-stage rotary screw air end with todays most
innovative energy saving technology, these versatile compressors
offer a choice of three Variable Speed Drive models ranging from
250 to 350 hp, with capacities of 1085 to 1580 cfm, and pressures
of 100 to 125 psig. All three models are available with Sullairs
exclusive WS Microprocessor Control System.

Designed to optimize energy savings, extend service life and minimize

maintenance, the Sullair V250S VSD Single Stage Compressor features
the same footprint and operating characteristics as comparable Sullair
constant speed models. Additionally, the new V250S Variable Speed
Drive models offer enhanced performance with the addition of Sullair's
WS Microprocessor Controller. Developed for reliability, simplicity
and comprehensive protection, this system features an easy-to-read
graphics display to highlight frequently used compressor information.
This controller is also programmed to monitor all necessary functions,
including protection from abnormalities. It also provides a WSPC
interface for service diagnostics and trending capabilities.
Visit www.sullair.com

New EnergAir Retrofit Compressor Controller

The NEW Metacentre Q1 Retrofit Compressor Controller provides
a cost effective off-the-shelf solution for replacing damaged or
obsolete compressor controllers or to upgrade older electromechanical compressor controls.

With todays energy costs representing nearly 82% of the total

operating expense of a compressed air system, Sullair continues to
utilize the latest technology and develop systems that will help balance
these escalating costs. Among the many new alternatives is Sullair's
Variable Speed Drive system which is designed to match compressor
speed with air demand for maximum operating efficiency and
lower energy costs. By adapting speed to output, the Sullair V250S
single stage compressor with Variable Speed Drive keeps the system
operating at maximum efficiency. This is one of the most effective
ways to conserve electrical power, while reducing stress on electrical
and mechanical components for longer equipment life.

Flexible hardware, user configurable Inputs/Outputs and preprogrammed application software make this advanced compressor
controller compatible with almost any positive displacement type
air compressor. Q1 features a backlit 240 x 160 graphic display
and membrane switch keypad for easy and intuitive access and
interrogation of software menus.
Inputs/Outputs include 8 digital inputs, 8 relay outputs, 2 x 4-20mA
analog pressure inputs, 1 x user configurable KTY/PT100/PT1000
analog temperature input and 1 x 4-20mA analog output (for
VFD speed control).
Communication features
include AIRBUS485,
our advanced master
control protocol
for connecting with
Metacentre master

airbestpractices.com
airbestpractices
.com

45

Columns

1 2 / 1 2

RESOURCES FOR ENERGy ENGINEERS

TECHNOLOGy PICKS
control products. MODBUS RTU slave device capability is also
provided as standard and PROFIBUS DP or DEVICENET capability
is available via option module.
Regulatory approvals include UL, CSA & CE.
Visit http://www.metacentre.eu/products/airmaster-q1retrofit-std-rotary-compressor-controller or e-mail:
[email protected]

New BOGE Compressor Station Controller

The airtelligence provis 2.0 controls complex compressor stations of
up to 16 rigid or frequency-controlled compressors of various makes
in an intelligent and consumption-independent way. The control
visualizes central parameters (system pressure, volume flow rate,
compressor status and operating times, etc.) on the web server in
a clear manner. In addition, up to 24 accessory components, such
as refrigerated air dryers, filters, fans, dampers or sensors can be
integrated. Based on the actual compressed air consumption, the
airtelligence provis 2.0 determines the increased or reduced demand
and automatically selects the ideal compressor combination. As
a result, users ensure consumer-oriented, energy-efficient and in
particular cost-oriented operation of their compressed air systems.
The PLC control with an intelligent control algorithm makes a pressure
forecast based on the actual consumption data and also includes the
reaction times of the connected compressors. This ensures that the
compressors are always activated at the optimum point of time and
that the specifically required compressed air rate is provided at a
minimum energy input. The airtelligence provis 2.0 optimizes load and
no-load times by reducing or avoiding frequent cycle behaviour. In
addition to an optimization
of the delivery quantity, the
customers can also select
an operating hour
or maintenance hour
optimized mode for
the compressor station.
Despite its sophisticated
functions, the airtelligence

46

airbestpractices.com

provis 2.0 is easy to program and parametrize. On a high-quality

9-inch TFT colour display (800 x 480 pixels) with LED black light,
parameter assignment of the control is made intuitively on the
touchscreen. The touchscreen visualizes, for example, data about
the current operating status, progression charts for volume flow rate
and pressure profile, the current CO2 emissions, trend displays with
historical data as well as the pressure dew point. An integrated USB
connection enables the loading of software updates or a subsequent
parameter assignment.
Visit www.boge.com/us or email: [email protected]

FIPA Introduces Air-Saving Ejectors

FIPA ejectors save energy without compromising cycle times.
Thanks to the integrated pressure regulation of this new product,
consumption of compressed air and energy can be significantly
reduced. Our new ejectors are another example of how FIPA meets
current market needs thanks to a sophisticated solution design, said
Rainer Mehrer, President and owner of FIPA.
When thinking about ways to reduce energy costs, electricity and
heat immediately come to mind. The element of compressed air
however, has considerable
savings potential as well.
FIPAs EKPP, EKP, and EMM
Series Ejectors can make
a substantial impact here.
Equipped with automatic
pressure regulation, they
reduce compressed air
usage by up to 50% per
work piece, regardless of
its porosity. In addition, the EMA and EKP-LSE Series Ejectors can
achieve savings of up to 97%, for airtight work pieces, thanks to the
electronic air-saving function.
Industrial compressed air systems typically operate at around 58
to 116 psi. All FIPA ejectors use 50.8 psi internally, reaching the
maximum vacuum level at a feed pressure of 58 psi. To save energy,
higher feed pressure is automatically reduced to 58 psi internally.

Columns

1 2 / 1 2

TECHNOLOGy PICKS
Because of that the ejector never uses more than 50.8 psi regardless
of the actual feed pressure. Although comparable solutions using
multi-chamber ejectors reduce air consumption as well, they suffer
from a system-induced higher evacuation time. In other words, it
takes longer for the vacuum to build up resulting in increased
cycle times and decreased efficiencies.
Visit www.FIPA.com or email [email protected]

New Ashcroft DG25 Digital Pressure Gauge

The new Ashcroft DG25 digital pressure gauge provides a 5 full digit
LCD in ranges up to 25,000 psi. Available in accuracies of 0.5% and

0.25% FS, this new design boasts a minimum battery life of 2000
hours. Standard features include an IP67 enclosure, selectable units
of measure, a 20 segment bar graph indicator, min-max, tare and a
list of agency certifications. A backlight and rubber protective boot
are also available.
Visit www.ashcroft.com or tel: 1-800-328-8258

New Material for Hot Surfaces Available for piGRIP

Suction Cups

The material HNBR is known for superior mechanical properties

that equates to excellent durability, tear and abrasion resistance.
This material provides an
extended lifetime compared
to conventional suction
cup materials.
A key application for this
new suction cup material is
injection molding. The process
to pick a part out of a mold
can now start earlier without
waiting to cool down the tool
or part. The material provides
an advantage of shorter cycle
times and in many cases
less energy is needed for the
cooling down process. The quicker the robot picks parts from
the mold, the more parts can be produced. Other applications
include handling windshields, wall and floor tiles, pottery,
porcelain and other molding and casting operations with a high
degree of automation.
The suction cups are Silicone-free (PWIS free) meaning it can
be used to handle parts prior to the painting process. Leaving
no mark behind, they are also suitable to use on sensitive
surfaces, such as glass.
The unique modular piGRIP suction cup platform offers this cup
material in four sizes from 29-79 mm. That plus an endless amount
of fittings and bellows combinations makes it easy to find the right
cup for your application. To make a complete program for handling
smaller parts, this material is also available for the smaller Bellows and
Universal models in sizes from 10-20 mm.
Visit www.piab.com

Piab, a leading supplier of industrial vacuum technology, introduces a

new material for its line of piGRIP suction cups as well as its smaller
Bellows and Universal models.

airbestpractices.com

47

Columns

1 2 / 1 2

FREE SUBSCRIPTION

COMPRESSED AIR BEST PRACTICES

PRINT EDITION FREE TO U.S. SUBSCRIBERS

ADVERTISER INDEx

www.airbestpractices.com

DIGITAL EDITION FREE WORLDWIDE

Company

Subscribe at airbestpractices.com
International pricing for print edition
$65 in Canada and $95 for other countries.

COMPRESSED AIR BEST PRACTICES

www.airbestpractices.com
Advertising & :
Editorial

48

Rod Smith
[email protected]
Tel: 412-980-9901

Subscriptions & :
Administration

Patricia Smith
[email protected]
Tel: 412-980-9902

A Publication of :

Smith Onandia Communications LLC

217 Deer Meadow Drive
Pittsburgh, PA 15241

airbestpractices.com

Web Site

Kaeser Compressors

Outside
Back Cover

www.kaeser.com/CABP

Association of Energy
Engineers

Inside
Back Cover

www.aeeprograms.com/shows

Atlas Copco

Inside
Front Cover

www.atlascopco.us/danielusa

Hitachi

www.hitachi-america.us/ice/atg

SPX

www.spx.com

Coaire Compressors

www.coaire.com

BOGE

www.boge.com/us

Chicago Pneumatic

Learn How To Save Energy

& Improve Productivity
In yOUR Industry!

Page

10-11

www.cp.com

Vaisala

13

www.vaisala.com/compressedair

JORC Industrial

15

www.jorc.com

BEKO Technologies

17

www.bekousa.com

Gardner Denver

19

www.gardnerdenverproducts.com

Sullivan Palatek

21

www.sullivanpalatek.com

Ultrachem

23

www.ultracheminc.com

VMC - USA

25

www.vmc-usa.com

Anest Iwata

27

www.anestiwata.com

E+E Elektronik

29

www.epluse.com

Michell Instruments

31

www.michell.com/us

ENMET

33

www.enmet.com

Ingersoll Rand

35

www.ingersollrandproducts.com

Compressed Air Best Practices is published monthly by Smith Onandia Communications LLC., 217 Deer Meadow
Drive, Pittsburgh, PA 15241. Phone 412-980-9902, email [email protected]. Compressed Air
Best Practices is a trademark of Smith Onandia Communications, LLC. Publisher cannot be held liable for nondelivery due to circumstances beyond its control. No refunds. Standard postage is paid at 233 Jefferson Street,
Greenfield, Ohio 45123. Canadian and international distribution: IMEX International Mail Express, 1842 Brummel
Drive, Elk Grove Village, IL 60007. POSTMASTER: Send address changes to Compressed Air Best Practices,
217 Deer Meadow Drive, Pittsburgh, PA 15241. SUBSCRIPTIONS: Qualified reader subscriptions are accepted
from compressed air professionals, plant managers, plant engineers, service and maintenance managers,
operations managers, auditors, and energy engineers in manufacturing plants and engineering/consulting firms
in the U.S. To apply for qualified reader subscriptions, please fill in the reader response cards herein and mail or
fax or go to www.airbestpractices.com. To non-qualified subscribers subscriptions are $65 in Canada and $95
for other countries. When available, extra copies of back issues are $4 plus shipping. Contact Patricia Smith for
subscription information at Tel: 412-980-9902 or email: [email protected]. REPRINTS: Reprints
are available on a custom basis, contact Patricia Smith for a price quotation at Tel: 412-980-9902 or email:
[email protected]. All rights are reserved. The contents of this publication may not be reproduced
in whole or in part without consent of Smith Onandia Communications LLC. Smith Onandia Communications LLC.
does not assume and hereby disclaims any liability to any person for any loss or damage caused by errors or
omissions in the material contained herein, regardless of whether such errors result from negligence, accident,
or any other cause whatsoever. Printed in the U.S.A.

Columns

1 2 / 1 2

THE MARKETPLACE
JOBS
Sustainable Energy Savings with
Compressed Air Best Practices

Searching for Service ManagerS

and Service TechnicianS
One of Gardner Denvers largest compressed air, blower
and vacuum distributors is expanding its roster statewide
by adding to our team of professionals. We are seeking
quality people nationwide, currently focusing on Service
Management and Service Technicians.
Accurate Air Engineering has been servicing the compressed
air marketplace in California since the 1940s and has exclusive
distribution agreements with Gardner Denver and Cameron
Centrifugal (to name a few).
We arent looking for quantity; we are looking for quality
and longevity. Each applicant will be considered based on
experience and desire to join an organization they can take
pride in and retire from.
Successful candidates will be chosen by knowledge and
experience of Reciprocating, Rotary Screw (both lube and
non-lube), VFD Drives, PD Blowers, Vacuum & Centrifugal
compressors.
Join a winning team! Join Accurate Air Engineering, Inc.
All resumes will be held in strict confidence by emailing
Creg Fenwick at [email protected]

www.accurateair.com

Compressed Air Best Practices is a technical

magazine dedicated to discovering Energy
Savings in compressed air systems. Each
edition outlines Best Practice System
Assessments for industrial compressed air
users particularly those managing energy
costs in multi-factory companies.
Retrofitting the 8 case packing machines
with 3-position valves reduced our idle cfm
from 80 to 15 cfm on each case packer.
With the right air compressor controls
allowing the electric motors to turn down,
the annual energy savings from one case
packer paid for the whole project.
Gregory Rhames, Asset Reliability
Manager/Site Energy Manager, Verallia
Glass, Jan/Feb 2012 Edition
of Compressed Air Best Practices

Demand Side and Supply Side information

on compressed air technologies and system
assessments is delivered to readers to help
them save energy. For this reason, we feature
Best Practice articles on when/how to correctly
apply air compressor, air treatment,
measurement and control, pneumatic,
blower and vacuum technology.
Industrial energy managers, utility
incentive program managers, and
technology/system assessment providers
are the three stakeholders in creating energy
efficiency projects. Representatives of these
readership groups guide our editorial content.
The Compressed Air Best Practices Editorial
Advisory Board guides our mission to help
create more energy saving projects.

Contact Rod Smith for ad rates:

[email protected],
Tel: 412-980-9901
airbestpractices.com

49

Columns

1 2 / 1 2

THE MARKETPLACE
TECHNOLOGy
aSSociaTion of independenT
coMpreSSor diSTribuTorS
The AICD is open to all independent compressor
distributors and is committed to serving the
compressed air industry through education,
energy conservation, and best business practices.
Membership Benefits Include:
Annual meeting includes a business focused,
practical, high value speaker program.
AICD Preferred Vendors program offering
extended discounts on products you already
purchase.
Ford Motor Company Customer Association
Incentive program offering fleet discount pricing
on new vehicles.
Service Training Skills courses through a
partnership with TPC to help train and certify
your service technicians.
New members will receive 2 free registrations
to attend the annual meeting.
Contact Cheryl
Kiker at aicd@
aicd.org or visit
www.aicd.org

Universal AutoDual
Compressor Controllers
Control Rotary Screw,
Vane, Scroll or Recip
Compressors
Save Energy
controlling up to
three compressors
and qualify for Utility
Rebates.
Automatic Lead/Lag Control
Pressure Control with Pressure
Transducers
Compressors from 2 to 250 hp
Thousands of Installations Worldwide.
Call for Application Engineering.
Standard Pneumatic Products, Inc.

Tel: 203-270-1400 Toll free: 800-979-9156

Email: [email protected]

www.stdpneumatics.com
50

airbestpractices.com

Rebuild all
brands, makes,
models of Air
Ends, Blowers
and Gear Boxes
Sample of The PROS Company work.

arge & Custom

Air Receivers
Deal direct
with the
manufacturer
ASME certified
Internal liners &
external finishes
Inventory of
popular sizes
Ships from our
central location

Before & After

The PROS Company

601 Texas Avenue
Lubbock, Texas 79401
806-749-7761 (PRO1)
www.thePROSco.com
[email protected]

For more info visit

www.TIGGtanks.com
Or Call
1-800-925-0011

2013 UPCOMING ENERGY SHOWS

PHILADELPHIA LAS VEGAS DC
Globalcon, presented by the Association
of Energy Engineers, is designed specifically
to facilitate those who need to get up to speed
on the latest developments in the energy
field, explore promising new technologies,
compare energy supply options, engage
energy management initiatives and learn
about innovative and cost-conscious project
implementation strategies.

West

31st
Energy Management Congress
June 19-20, 2013

Las Vegas Convention Center

Las Vegas, Nevada

March 6-7, 2013

Pennsylvania Convention Center

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

hosted by

The Energy Management Congress

West, is the largest energy conference and
technology expo held on the U.S. West Coast
specifically for business, industrial and
institutional energy users. It brings together
the top experts in all areas of the field to help
you set a clear, optimum path to both energy
cost control and energy supply security.

Now in its 36th year, the World Energy

Engineering Congress, is recognized as
the most important energy event of national
scope for end users in all areas of the energy
field. A comprehensive forum where you
can assess the big picture and see exactly
how the economic and market forces, new
technologies, regulatory developments &
industry trends all merge.
September 25-27, 2013

Walter E. Washington Convention Center

Washington, DC

www.aeeprograms.com/shows | 770-447-5083

kaeser.com

COMPRESSORS

The buck stops here.

Harry S. Truman

When it comes to service,

Kaeser doesnt pass the buck.
Everyone appreciates a company that stands behind its
products no matter what. Thats Kaeser.
We dont just sell equipment. We help you design
your system, install it, and service it. We can even monitor
it for you. Our goals are the same as yours: efficient
compressed air systems you can rely on.
Innovative technology ultra-reliable products
outstanding service. Its no wonder Kaeser delivers the best
value for the price! Contact us today to learn more about the
powerful benefits of owning a Kaeser compressed air system.

Kaeser Compressors, Inc. 800-777-7873 kaeser.com/CABP

Built for a lifetime is a trademark of Kaeser Compressors, Inc.

2012 Kaeser Compressors, Inc.

Scan this code for more info.