How
How
Helga Kolb
Anatomy and Physiology Imaging techniques ranging from old- like those observed in other neurons.
Understanding the anatomy of the pri- style Golgi silver staining, first used However, the first recordings of im-
mate retina is essential to understand- over a century ago by Ramón y Cajal, pulses within the retina by Gunnar
ing its function. Again, the photore- to electron microscopy and modern- Svaetichin in the 1950s showed very
ceptors lie in a layer against the back day antibody staining have revealed odd responses to light. Neurons in the
of the eyeball. In the second of three the shapes and sizes of the retina’s cell outer retina—it was not immediately
cell layers, called the inner nuclear lay- types and how the different cells con- clear which cells he was recording
er, lie one to four types of horizontal nect to form synapses. Staining tech- from—responded to stimulation not
cells, 11 types of bipolar cells and 22 to niques have revealed electrical junc- with depolarizing spikes but with slow
30 types of amacrine cells. The numbers tions between cells and the identity hyperpolarization. These “S potentials”
vary depending on species. The sur- and location of neurotransmitter recep- are now known to originate with the
face layer of the retina contains about tors and transporters. We now know photoreceptors and to be transmitted to
20 types of ganglion cells. Impulses that the neurotransmitter (chemical horizontal cells and bipolar cells. The
from the ganglion cells travel to the signal) passed through the vertical membrane hyperpolarization starts on
brain via more than a million optic pathways of the retina—from photore- exposure to light, follows the time
nerve fibers. The spaces separating ceptors to bipolar cells to ganglion course of a light flash and then returns
these three layers are also anatomically cells—is glutamate. The horizontal and to the baseline value when the light is
distinct. The region containing synaps- amacrine cells send signals using vari- off. This reflects the counterintuitive
es linking the photoreceptors with ous excitatory and inhibitory amino fact that both rods and cones release
bipolar and horizontal cell dendrites is acids, catecholamines, peptides and ni- neurotransmitters during the dark,
known as the outer plexiform layer; the tric oxide. when the membrane is depolarized
area where the bipolar and amacrine Electrophysiological investigations and sodium ions flow freely across the
cells connect to the ganglion cells is the of the retina started 60 years ago. Stud- photoreceptors’ cell membranes. When
inner plexiform layer. ies of the optic nerve fibers showed that exposed to light, ion channels in the
Decades of anatomical studies have they could be stimulated to give tradi- cell membranes close. The cells go into
shed light on how the retina works. tional depolarizing action potentials, a hyperpolarized state for as long as
© 2003 Sigma Xi, The Scientific Research Society. Reproduction
with permission only. Contact [email protected].
2003 January–February 29
cells to respond to photoreceptor input
choroid
differently (Figure 7). Some bipolar cells
pig
sclera are tuned to faster and some to slower
me
retina fluctuations in the visual signal; some
cornea
nt
glutamate receptors resensitize rapidly
ph
ep
oto
and others more gradually. The cells
ou
ith
ter
rec
pupil thus fire either quickly in succession or
eli
inn
ep
um
inn
ple
relatively slowly in response to the
er
tor
x
er
same amount of stimulation. These re-
nu
ifo
ga
s
ple
cle
ceptors respond to glutamate by acti-
rm
ng
xif
ar
vating what’s known as an OFF path-
lio
orm
n
lens way in the visual process, detecting
ce
optic dark images against a lighter back-
lls
iris nerve
ground. (Recall that photoreceptors
ciliary constantly release glutamate unless ex-
body
posed to light.) Other bipolar cells
have inhibitory glutamate receptors;
Figure 2. Diagram of a human eye shows its various structures (left). A thin piece of retina is
enlarged in a photomicrograph (right), revealing its layers. The photoreceptors lie against a in other words, they prevent the bipo-
dark row of cells called the pigment epithelium. (Drawing by the author. Except where noted, lar cell from firing when the cell is ex-
photographs by Nicolas Cuenca and the author.) posed to the neurotransmitter. These
receptors activate the ON pathway, de-
the light continues to shine on them images into separate parts. Both rods tecting light images against a darker
and do not release a neurotransmitter. and cones respond to light directly background.
Although both rods and cones re- over them. Thus, their receptive fields
spond to light with a slow hyperpolar- are very narrow. Parallel Processing
izing response, they report quite differ- An image continues to be broken The parallel sets of visual channels for
ent image properties. Rods, detecting into component elements at the first ON (detecting light areas on dark
dim light, usually respond to relatively synapses of the visual pathway, those backgrounds) and OFF (detecting dark
slow changes. Cones, dealing with between photoreceptors and bipolar areas on light backgrounds) qualities
bright signals, can detect rapid light cells. Different bipolar cells have differ- of an image are fundamental to our
fluctuations. In both cases, photorecep- ent types of receptors for the neuro- seeing. Vertebrate vision depends on
tors begin the process of decomposing transmitter glutamate, allowing the perceiving the contrast between im-
ages and their backgrounds. For ex-
pigment
ample, we read black letters against a
epithelium white background using the OFF chan-
nels that start in the retina. Parallel
rods bipolar channels transmit inputs to
ganglion cells. Early in development
cones the architecture of the inner plexiform
layer, full of synapses between bipolar
outer
plexiform and ganglion cells, shows that synaptic
layer connections become segregated in dis-
tinct, parallel pathways. Connections
horizontal occur between ON bipolar cells and
cells ON ganglion cells and also between
bipolar
OFF bipolar cells and OFF ganglion
cells cells in demarcated portions of the in-
ner plexiform layer.
amacrine If the retina were simply to transmit
cells
opposite-contrast images directly from
inner the photoreceptors to the brain, the re-
plexiform sulting vision would probably be
layer coarse-grained and blurry. Further pro-
ganglion
cessing in the retina defines precise
cells edges to images and allows us to focus
on fine details. The honing of the im-
nerve fiber age starts at the first synaptic level in
layer
the retina, where horizontal cells re-
Figure 3. Cells in the retina are arrayed in discrete layers. The photoreceptors are at the top of ceive input from cones. Each horizontal
this rendering, close to the pigment epithelium. The bodies of horizontal cells and bipolar cells cell actually receives input from many
compose the inner nuclear layer. Amacrine cells lie close to ganglion cells near the surface of cones, so its collection area or receptive
the retina. Axon-to-dendrite neural connections make up the plexiform layers separating rows field is large. Horizontal cells’ receptive
of cell bodies. fields become even broader because
© 2003 Sigma Xi, The Scientific Research Society. Reproduction
with permission only. Contact [email protected].
30 American Scientist, Volume 91
N
rhodopsin disc
surface C
rhodopsin
light O
Figure 4. Cone photoreceptors from a monkey are stained with a fluorescent green dye (left). When the outer segments of cones or rods are mag-
nified further, stacked membrane disks are visible inside (middle). The disks are studded with thousands of rhodopsin complexes. Each
rhodopsin consists of a membrane-traversing protein with a retinal molecule embedded in its core (right). When exposed to light, one of the
bonds in the retinal molecule rotates, changing the shape of the protein (lower right). (Middle photograph courtesy of Carlos Rozas.)
their plasma membranes fuse with cone photoreceptor. This complicated cir- these cells in the organization of visual
those of neighboring horizontal cells at cuit from horizontal cell to cone to bipo- messages. Horizontal cells respond to
gap junctions. The membrane potentials lar cells is still a subject of hot debate in more than the photoreceptors that link
of a whole sheet of cells become the the community of retina scientists. to them. Feedback signals from the inner
same; consequently, horizontal cells re- Horizontal-cell function has occupied plexiform layer influence horizontal-cell
spond to light over a very large area. many vision scientists for decades, and activity as well. These feedback signals
Meanwhile, a single bipolar cell receives much is now known about the role of are transmitted via substances such as
input from a handful of cones and thus
has a medium-size receptive field. human retina turtle retina
Whereas a single bipolar cell with its
OFF or ON light response would carry
a fairly blurry response to its ganglion
cell, horizontal cells add an opponent
visual streak
signal that is spatially constrictive, giv-
ing the bipolar cell what is known as a
center surround organization (Figure 9). fovea optic
The bipolar center signals either ON or nerve
OFF, and the horizontal cells add an
OFF or ON surround signal, by one of optic nerve
two means. The horizontal cells can ei-
ther signal the bipolar cell or feed infor-
mation back to the cone photoreceptors
themselves, which then feed forward
information to the bipolar cells the
Figure 5. An ophthalmologist’s view of the human retina (left) shows the optic nerve head,
cones contact. Feedback to the cones is from which blood vessels radiate to nourish every part of the tissue, as well as the fovea,
now proposed to occur by means of an which is where images focus most directly and is specialized for sharp daylight vision. The
unusual electrical synapse consisting of fovea is densely packed with more than half of the human cone photoreceptors. The turtle reti-
half a gap junction; these hemi gap junc- na (right) has no blood vessels radiating from the optic nerve and no fovea. Instead, it has a vis-
tions are thought to change the ionic en- ual streak, a region of specialized cells running horizontally above the optic nerve, which can
vironment across the membrane of the detect fleeting movements and orient those movements relative to the horizon.
© 2003 Sigma Xi, The Scientific Research Society. Reproduction
with permission only. Contact [email protected].
2003 January–February 31
ter and surround even further than the
horizontal-cell input does. In human
retinas, two basic types of ganglion
cells—ON center and OFF center—
polarization
form the major output of the retina to
the visual centers in the brain (Figure
10, left). ON-center ganglion cells are ac-
tivated when a spot of light falls in the
center of their receptive field and are
green flash inactivated when light falls on the
field’s periphery. OFF-center ganglion
time cells react in the opposite way: Their ac-
tivity increases when the periphery of
their receptive field is lit and decreases
receptive field
when light falls on the center of the
field. (The receptive fields of ganglion
cells are modeled as the difference be-
tween Gaussian distributions, giving
hyperpolarization
hyperpolarization
amacrine cells make synaptic connec-
tions with about 20 different types of
ganglion cells.
It was already clear from Cajal’s de-
scription in the 19th century that
amacrine-, ganglion- and bipolar-cell
dendrites and axons were organized
into distinct layers; Cajal himself divid-
ed the inner plexiform layer into five
strata. But what sorts of synapses were Figure 8. Photomicrograph of a cat retina shows the elongated cone photoreceptors and the hor-
formed among the tangle of intermesh- izontal and bipolar cells to which they connect (left). The horizontal cells are stained yellow;
ing processes and what this organiza- the bipolar and amacrine cells lie below them, stained green and red. Horizontal cells modu-
tion meant were not immediately ap- late the responses of photoreceptors and bipolar cells. The receptive fields of horizontal cells
are very wide (right) because of electrical coupling among the cells.
parent. Electron microscopy helped to
unravel this neurocircuitry. Now the
interconnections of nine types of bipo- in a direct pipeline to bipolar cells to ner plexiform layer and create elegant
lar cells, 14 types of amacrine cells and ganglion cells, the bipolar cells that re- meshworks of dendrites. Usually, they
eight types of ganglion cells are under- ceive input from rods do not synapse emit GABA as a neurotransmitter.
stood quite well. We can say we are with ganglion cells directly. The bipolar Sometimes they connect to neighbor-
half way to the goal of understanding cells connected to rods are all of one ing amacrine cells by gap junctions, in-
the neural interplay between all the type, solely transmitting an ON signal, creasing their sphere of influence and
nerve cells in the retina. and use the AII and A17 amacrine cells the speed at which signals transmit
Much is now known about what as intermediaries to get signals to gan- across large areas of retina.
types of neurotransmitters different glion cells. The small-field AII cell col- Most GABA-releasing amacrine
amacrine cells contain and about the lects from about 30 rod-connected cells also release at least one other
organization of receptors at the differ- bipolar cells and transmits a depolariz- neuroactive substance. The secondary
ent synapses. Amacrine cells are about ing message both to ON (light-detect-
equally divided between those that use ing) cone bipolar cells and to their ON
glycine and those that use GABA ganglion cells and to OFF cone bipolar cones
(gamma-aminobutyric acid) neuro- cells and OFF ganglion cells (Figure 11).
transmitters. It is as if the AII cells developed in the
Glycinergic amacrine cells are usu- rod-dominated parts of the retina as an
ally “small field.” Their processes can afterthought to the cone-to-ganglion
spread vertically across several strata cell architecture and now takes advan-
within the inner plexiform layer, but tage of the preexisting cone pathway
they extend relatively short distances circuitry.
horizontally. Glycinergic amacrine cells At the same time, the A17 amacrine
receive information from bipolar cells cell collects rod messages from thou-
and transmit information to ganglion sands of rod-connected bipolar cells. It horizontal gap
cells and to other bipolar and amacrine somehow amplifies and modulates the cells junctions
cells. Some glycinergic amacrine cells information from the rod bipolar cells
provide interconnections between ON to transmit to the AII cells, but how it
and OFF systems of bipolar and gan- does this is not completely understood. bipolar
cell
glion cells. The most famous of these In any case, the rod pathway with its center surround
is called the AII cell; the AII and a series of convergent and then diver-
GABA-releasing amacrine cell called gent intermediary neurons is clearly
A17 are pivotal in the circuitry of rod- well designed to collect and amplify
based, dim-light vision in the mam- scattered vestiges of light for twilight
malian retina. These cells aren’t found and night vision.
in mammalian species that are active Wide-field amacrine cells sometimes
Figure 9. Horizontal cells accumulate informa-
solely in daylight and have very few stretch horizontally across the inner tion from a wide field of cones and influence
rods—for example, squirrels. plexiform layer for hundreds of mi- the signals bipolar cells transmit by adding an
In the earlier discussion of ON and crons and interact with hundreds of opponent surround signal to their receptive
OFF channels emanating from cones, I bipolar cells and many ganglion cells. fields. The horizontal cells influence bipolar
neglected to talk about the channels Such amacrines are usually confined to cells either directly or by feeding back infor-
from rod cells. Whereas cones connect one of the five different strata of the in- mation to the cones—probably both.
© 2003 Sigma Xi, The Scientific Research Society. Reproduction
with permission only. Contact [email protected].
2003 January–February 33
in fovea
midget
ganglion
cells
ganglion cells
ON- OFF-
center center ON OFF
to
to brain to brain brain
hyperpolarization
depolarization
depolarization
hyperpolarization
Figure 10. Human retinas have two types of ganglion cells—ON-center and OFF-center. ON-center ganglion cells are activated when a spot of
light falls in the center of their receptive fields, whereas OFF-center ganglion cells fire in response to light falling on their fields’ periphery leav-
ing their center dark. Horizontal cells convey antagonistic surround signals to bipolar cells and thence to ganglion cells. Ganglion cells have re-
ceptive fields with a Mexican-hat shape, reflecting their integration of opposing information about centers and surrounds. This kind of pro-
cessing helps sharpen the boundaries of images. In the fovea (right), ganglion cells have much narrower receptive fields; in fact, each carries
information from a single cone. A cone feeds information to two of these midget ganglion cells; at all times each foveal cone transmits either an
ON or an OFF signal to the brain. This signal also carries a color message regarding the type of cone (red or green) it comes from.
rods cones
AII
amacrine
ON ON ON OFF
cell
bipolar
cells
gap
junction
ganglion
ON cells OFF
Figure 11. AII amacrine cells play an important role in transmitting information from rod photoreceptors to ganglion cells. The amacrine cells
collect messages from many rod-connected bipolar cells, allowing the perception of very dim light. The amacrine cells feed information directly
to OFF ganglion cells. They also co-opt the ON cone bipolar-to-ganglion cell architecture by means of gap junctions.
© 2003 Sigma Xi, The Scientific Research Society. Reproduction
34 American Scientist, Volume 91 with permission only. Contact [email protected].
example, the major neural pathway
from the rods depends on direct elec-
trical connections. Some other fast-act-
ing signals pass from amacrine cells
into ganglion cells at gap junctions.
Neuromodulators change the milieu of
the neuron circuits but act from a dis-
tance by diffusion rather than at closely
apposed synapses. Again, this is a sur-
prising concept compared to the previ-
ous view that all neural interactions
take place via neurotransmitters at spe-
cialized isolated patches of membrane
apposition—that is, synapses. The
most recent surprise has been that a
previously unknown ganglion cell type
appears to function as a giant photore-
ceptor itself, without needing input
from rods or cones. This ganglion’s cell
membrane contains light-reactive mol-
Figure 12. Photographs highlighting two different kinds of amacrine cells show their dense ecules known as melanopsins. Given
network of dendrites and axons, which send information to various types of cells. One is such unexpected findings, it appears
stained for its neuromodulator, dopamine (left), and the other for its neurotransmitter, acetyl- that there may still be much more to
choline (right). Many amacrine cells are electrically coupled by gap junctions, creating a mas- learn about how the retina works.
sive sheet of cells able to transmit information quickly and in unison.
Bibliography
substances are usually neuromodulators sulting uncoupling of the AII cells Dowling, J. E. 1987. The Retina: An Approach-
rather than fast-acting neurotransmit- makes the effective field of influence of able Part of the Brain. Cambridge, Mass.:
ters. The substances include peptides— the rod-system amacrine cells much Belknap Press.
“substance P,” somatostatin, vasointesti- less significant in lighter conditions. Hattar, S., H.-W. Liao, M. Takao, D. M. Berson
and K.-W Yau. 2002. Melanopsin-containing
nal peptide and cholecystokinin—as Similarly in bright light conditions, an- retinal ganglion cells: Architecture, projec-
well as the more familiar biomolecules other wide-field amacrine cell releases tions, and intrinsic photosensitivity. Science
serotonin, dopamine, acetylcholine, nitric oxide to uncouple the AII cell 295:1065–1070.
adenosine and nitric oxide. A variety of from the cone-bipolar system. All this Kolb, H. and E. V. Famiglietti. 1974. Rod and
receptors have been found on ganglion removes the interference of the large- cone pathways in the inner plexiform layer
of the cat retina. Science 186:47–49.
and bipolar cells—for example, recep- field rod pathway from the narrow-
Kolb, H. , R. Nelson, P. Ahnelt and N. Cuenca.
tors for peptides, nicotine and mus- field cone pathways. 2001. Cellular organization of the vertebrate
carine (mushroom toxin) in addition to The above broad sketch of retinal retina. In Concepts and Challenges in Retinal
different forms of GABA receptors—in- circuitry suggests that the retina is re- Biology: A Tribute to John E. Dowling, pp.
dicating that amacrine cells are releasing markably complex. As vision research 3–26, ed. H. Kolb, H. Ripps and S. Wu. Am-
such agents. Most of these neuro- advances, the retina seems to take on sterdam: Elsevier Press.
modulators are not active at convention- an increasingly active role in percep- Kolb, H., E. Fernandez and R. Nelson. 2002. Web-
vision: The Organization of the Retina and Visual
al synapses; their release is thought to tion. Although we do not fully under- System. http://www.webvision.med.utah.edu
influence neurons even at a distance by stand the neural code that the gan- Nelson, R., E. V. Famiglietti and H. Kolb. 1978.
diffusion. Such neuromodulators appar- glion-cell axons send as trains of spikes Intracellular staining reveals different lev-
ently influence the retinal circuitry un- into the brain, we are coming close to els of stratification for on-center and off-cen-
der changing light conditions or even understanding how ensembles of gan- ter ganglion cells in the cat retina. Journal of
Neurophysiology 41:427–483.
cause retinal activity to reflect the differ- glion cells respond differently to as-
Rodieck, R. W. 1998. The First Steps in Seeing.
ent times of day in the circadian clock. pects of the visual scene and how fields Sunderland, Mass.: Sinauer Associates.
A specialized amacrine cell releases of influence on particular ganglion
dopamine when the retina is stimulat- cells are constructed. Much of the con-
ed with intermittent flashing light. struction of the visual images does
Dopamine causes the gap junctions seem to take place in the retina itself,
among horizontal cells to become un- although the final perception of sight Links to Internet resources for further
coupled, reducing the size of their re- is indisputably done in the brain. exploration of “How the Retina
ceptive fields. Furthermore, the neuro- Given how much is now known, it Works” are available on the American
transmitter affects the glutamate might be fair to ask, are we finished Scientist Web site:
receptor on horizontal cells so that the with the retina, or are there more sur-
amplitude of the light response de- prises on the horizon? Earlier surprises http://www.americanscientist.org/
clines. Again in the inner plexiform included finding that much of the in- articles/03articles/kolb.html
layer, dopamine closes gap junctions, formation transfer depended on elec-
this time the ones that link AII ama- trical connections among cells rather
crine cells in large networks. The re- than standard chemical synapses. For
© 2003 Sigma Xi, The Scientific Research Society. Reproduction
with permission only. Contact [email protected].
2003 January–February 35