Risk Management in Merchant Establishment Trogh EDC Machines in Credit Card Trans at Ions
Risk Management in Merchant Establishment Trogh EDC Machines in Credit Card Trans at Ions
PROJECT REPORT ON
STUDY CONDUCTED AT
Profilers Inc.
Profilers Inc. (HUBLI)
A Project report
Submitted to Karnatak University In partial fulfillment of the
requirement for the degree of
SUBMITTED BY:
MBA 08001004
DECLARATION
To
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Areef ali. P
(MBA 08001004)
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
2 INTRODUCTION OF STUDY 3-8
3 COMPANY PROFILE 9-13
6 METHODOLOGY 24-25
7 ANALYSIS 26-74
8 FINDINGS 75-76
9 ADVANTAGES & 77
DIS-ADVANATAGES
10 IMPACT OF CARD FRAUDS 78-79
11 RECOMMENDATION 80-82
13 CONCLUSION 103-104
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
In India, popularity of using Credit or Debit cards for day to day financial
transactions is increasing at a very fast pace, while most of the card transactions on
Electronic Data Capture are genuine, some of them are un-authorized or fraudulent, the
trend of un-authorized card swipes is growing at an alarming pace & there is an urgent
need for awareness to customer as well as merchants to elaborate the importance of
holding the confidential information or the cards themselves in a secured manner.
Credit card fraud is a wide-ranging term for theft and fraud committed using a
credit card or any similar payment mechanism as a fraudulent source of funds in a
transaction. The purpose may be to obtain goods without paying, or to obtain
unauthorized funds from an account. Credit card fraud is also an adjunct to Identity theft.
According to the Federal Trade Commission, while identity theft had been holding steady
for the last few years, it saw a 21 percent increase in 2008. However, credit card fraud,
that crime which most people associate with ID theft, decreased as a percentage of all ID
theft complaints for the sixth year in a row.
When a credit card is lost or stolen, it remains usable until the holder notifies the
issuer that the card is lost. Most issuers have free 24-hour telephone numbers to
encourage prompt reporting. Still, it is possible for a thief to make unauthorized
purchases on a card until it is canceled. Without other security measures, a thief could
potentially purchase thousands of dollars in merchandise or services before the
cardholder or the card issuer realize that the card is in the wrong hands.
The frauds relating to credit cards are committed in the following ways:
Lost or stolen card, Identity theft, Skimming or Cloning, Counterfeit cards, Mail
intercept frauds and Etc.
The plastic culture is influencing into the daily purchasing habits of Indian
consumers, and the payment card business is growing as never before. As it had
happened elsewhere, traditionally the consumer begins with patronizing credit cards.
Therefore credit cards comprise the bulk of payment cards in India. However, debit cards
and stored value cards have also made an entry into consumer wallet in the last two years.
India is offering a potentially explosive growth in payment cards and numbers are
estimated to double in the next two years.
The merchant should know all the basics related to credit cards like AVS
(Address Verification Service), DCC (Dynamic Currency Conversion), the rules for
accepting the card and the rules for return and exchange, CVV2 (Card Verification
Value2), and the Authorization process and Chargeback process in the transactions
relating to card payment. The other essential aspect in the Chargeback is the chargeback
reason code.
Contrary to popular belief, merchants are far more at risk from credit card fraud
than the cardholders. While consumers may face trouble trying to get a fraudulent charge
reversed, merchants lose the cost of the product sold, pay chargeback fees, and fear from
the risk of having their merchant account closed.
Increasingly, the card not present scenario, such as shopping on the internet poses
a greater threat as the merchant (the web site) is no longer protected with advantages of
physical verification such as signature check, photo identification, etc. In fact, it is almost
impossible to perform any of the ‘physical world’ checks necessary to detect who is at
the other end of the transaction. This makes the internet extremely attractive to fraud
perpetrators. According to a recent survey, the rate at which internet fraud occurs is 12 to
15 times higher than ‘physical world’ fraud. However, recent technical developments are
showing some promise to check fraud in the card not present scenario.
Introduction of Study
When an individual uses another individuals credit card for personal reasons
while the owner of the card and the card issuer are not aware of the fact that the card is
being used, Further, the individual using the card has no connection with the cardholder
or issuer, and has no intention of either contacting the owner of the card or making
repayments for the purchases made.
FRAUD TECHNIQUES:
There are many ways in which fraudsters execute a credit card fraud. As
technology changes, so do the technology of fraudsters, and thus the way in which they
go about carrying out fraudulent activities. Frauds can be broadly classified into three
categories, i.e., traditional card related frauds, merchant related frauds and internet
frauds. The different types of methods for committing credit card frauds are described
below:
APPLICATION FRAUD:
This type of fraud occurs when a person falsifies an application to acquire a credit
card. Application fraud can be committed in three ways:
Financial fraud, where an individual provides false information about his or her
financial status to acquire credit.
Not-received items (NRIs) also called postal intercepts occur when a card is
stolen from the postal service before it reaches its owner’s destination.
A card is lost / stolen when a legitimate account holder receives a card and loses it
or someone steals the card for criminal purposes. This type of fraud is in essence the
easiest way for a fraudster to get hold of other individual's credit cards without
investment in technology. It is also perhaps the hardest form of traditional credit card
fraud to tackle.
ACCOUNT TAKEOVER
This type of fraud occurs when a fraudster illegally obtains a valid customers’
personal information. The fraudster takes control a legitimate account by either providing
the customer’s account number or the card number. The fraudster then contacts the card
issuer, hidden as the genuine cardholder, to ask that mail be redirected to a new address.
The fraudster reports card lost and asks for a replacement to be sent.
The creation of counterfeit cards, together with lost/stolen cards poses highest
threat in credit card frauds. Fraudsters are constantly finding new and more innovative
ways to create counterfeit cards. Some of the techniques used for creating false and
counterfeit cards are listed below:
terminal several times, before realizing that the metallic strip does not work.
The cashier will then proceed to manually input the card details into the
terminal. This form of fraud has high risk because the cashier will be looking at
the card closely to read the numbers. Doctored cards are, as with many of the
traditional methods of credit card fraud, becoming an outdated method of illicit
accumulation of either funds or goods.
4. Skimming:
MERCHANT COLLUSION:
This type of fraud occurs when merchant owners or their employees conspire to
commit fraud using their customers’ (cardholder) accounts and personal information.
Merchant owners or their employees pass on the information about cardholders to
fraudsters.
TRIANGULATION:
The fraudster in this type of fraud operates from a web site. Goods are offered at
heavily discounted rates and are also shipped before payment. The fraudulent site appears
to be a legitimate auction. The customer while placing orders online provides information
such as name, address and valid credit card details. Once fraudsters receive these details,
they order goods from a legitimate site using stolen credit card details. The fraudster then
goes on to purchase other goods using the credit card numbers of the customer.
The Internet has provided an ideal ground for fraudsters to commit credit card
fraud in an easy manner. Fraudsters have recently begun to operate on a truly
transnational level. With the expansion of global, social, economic and political spaces,
the internet has become a New World market, capturing consumers from most countries
around the world. The most commonly used techniques in internet fraud are described
below:
1. Site cloning:
Site cloning is where fraudsters clone an entire site or just the pages from
which you place your order. Customers have no reason to believe they are not
dealing with the company and they wished to purchase goods or services from
because the pages that they are viewing are identical to those of the real site. The
cloned site will receive these details and send the customer a receipt of the
transaction via email just as the real company would. The consumer suspects
nothing, at the same time as the fraudsters have all the details they need to commit
credit card fraud.
These sites offer the customer an extremely cheap service. The site
requests a customer’s complete credit card details such as name and address in
return for access to the content of the site. Most of these sites claim to be free, but
require a valid credit card number to verify an individual’s age. These sites are set
up to accumulate as many credit card numbers as possible. The sites themselves
never charge individuals for the services they provide. The sites are usually part
of a larger criminal network that either uses the details it collects to raise revenues
or sells valid credit card details to small fraudsters.
Credit card number generators are computer programs that generate valid
credit card numbers and expiry dates. These generators work by generating lists
of credit card account numbers from a single account number. The software
works by using the mathematical algorithm that card issuers use to generate other
valid card number combinations. The generators allow users to illegally generate
as many numbers as the user desires, in the form of any of the credit card formats,
whether it be Visa or MasterCard.
Methods Percentage
Lost or stolen card 48%
Identity theft 15%
Skimming or cloning 14%
Counterfeit cards 12%
The above graph represents that the higher percentage of occurrence of the credit
card frauds are the lost or stolen cards and further identity theft, skimming or cloning,
counterfeit cards, and mail intercept frauds are lies in the same figure as 15%, 12%, and
etc.
COMPANY PROFILE
Profilers Inc.
Risk Intelligence, Investigation & Management Services
COMPANY PROFILE:
At the outset they introduce as Profilers Inc. an independent risk management &
credit Collections Company operating in State Capital (Bangalore) & 14 districts of
North Karnataka. They are first professionally managed company of North Karnataka
formed in 2002 to provide result oriented, practical & cost effective solutions in risk
management & related services.
The primary strength is data & they posses largest negative database in North
Karnataka, this negative database also contains list of criminals & anti social elements,
database related to professionals, DMA, DME Chartered Accountants, Advisors,
Valuators, Merchants, Companies, Business Establishments, Builders, Real Estate
Agents, & un-authorized business associates involved in unethical business practices with
negative history.
Profilers Inc has highly experienced professionals who are experts in Collections,
Sampling, Field Verifications, Tele-verification, Investigation, Seeding, Skip Trace,
Asset Verification and allied risk services, we have expertise to authenticate & detect
fraud document like IT returns, Bank Statement, Salary Certificate, Repayment Track
Records, Etc. we enjoy considerable rapport with all the Govt. departments, law
enforcement authorities to achieve this.
Profilers Inc has been responsible to detect & detain many fraud & Skip cases in
its regular course of business
Head Office:
HUBLI: Swamy Plaza, No. 1, Byahatti Plots, 2nd Main, 2nd Cross,
Deshpande Nagar, Hubli - 580029
Regional Offices:
GULBARGA: 1-8/A, Naidu Building, 1st Floor, Khuba Plots, Opp. KBN Hospital,
Station Road, Gulbarga – 585 102
BANGALOARE: 23/3, 2nd Floor, Fort ‘F’ Street, Behind Bangalore Medical
College,
Bangalore – 560 002
CPA & Field Verification Agency – CPA & handling all activities related to CPA,
Authorized RV, BV & CPV agency for verifying credentials of customer availing Auto
Loan
CPA Locations – Hubli
Area of Operation – North Karnataka
Collections, Verifications & Bill delivery Agency – Handling RV/BV verifications, Bill
deliveries for Post Paid connections & collection activities for Gulbarga Cluster
Area of Operation – Gulbarga, Bidar, Raichur & Bijapur Districts
PREVIOUS ASSOCIATIONS:
Risk Containment Unit – Handling Risk Containment Unit, which had authorization
from ICICI for sampling, screening, verification, authentication the various processes
involving Personal Loan, Two Wheeler Loan, Auto Loan, Commercial Vehicle Loan,
Agriculture Equipment Loan, Medical Equipments Loan, Construction Equipment Loan,
Home Loan etc. We were also responsible to verify the credentials of DMA/DME for
recruitment, Authentication of documents like site map / Blue print, ITR, Salary
Certificate, Bank Statement, repayment track records. In addition to the time to time
check of tracing of skip customer, Non Starters, Seeding, Cross Check of Valuation
reports, Cross Check of FI reports & overall process control of various operations.
Area of Operation – 14 districts of North Karnataka.
ICICI Bank Ltd. – Credit Cards / Business Cards / Fleet Cards & Liabilities
OUR STRENGTHS:
OUR SERVICES:
We at Profilers Inc strive to work according to the codes and upheld the highest
ideals in professional activities, it is also our constant endeavor to train & manage our
employees to work in accordance with the Codes mentioned below:
1) Prompt Investigation:
In the event any prospect we shall complain that, any individual/company/group
which may have engaged in any improper course of conduct pertaining to the
presentation of goods or services we shall promptly investigate the complaint and shall
take all such steps as it may find appropriate and necessary under the circumstances to
cause the redress of any wrongs for which its investigation discloses to have been
committed and the same will be reported immediately to our office & respective clients
of the concern.
2) Working Habits:
Behave ethically and with integrity. Integrity implies not merely honesty but fair
dealings and truthfulness also. We shall observe the basic rule of professional ethics; we
shall accurately represent ourselves and the agency, maintain the highest standards of
professional and personal conduct, while dealing on behalf of company we shall conduct
ourselves with courteously to all people with whom we may come into contact during the
course of work; we shall carry out professional work with diligence, care, skill and with
proper regard to professional standards. We shall Keep ourselves updated with all
developments relevant to our filed & adhere to all applicable laws and regulations in
India, we shall not use or appear to use any confidential information acquired or received
by us in the course of our professional work for our personal advantage or forward the
same to third party.
Address:
H.O: Swamy Plaza, No. 1,
Byahatti Plots, 2nd Main, 2nd Cross,
Deshpande Nagar, Hubli – 580029
Tel.: 92436 00481/484 Tele fax: 836 4250726
E Mail: [email protected]
A credit card is part of a system of payments named after the small plastic card
issued to users of the system. It is a card entitling its holder to buy goods and services
based on the holder's promise to pay for these goods and services. The issuer of the card
grants a line of credit to the consumer (or the user) from which the user can borrow
money for payment to a merchant or as a cash advance to the user.
A credit card is different from a charge card, where a charge card requires the
balance to be paid in full each month. In contrast, credit cards allow the consumers to
'revolve' their balance, at the cost of having interest charged. Most credit cards are issued
by local banks or credit unions, and are the shape and size specified by the ISO/IEC 7810
standard as ID-1.
Credit card
Credit cards are issued after an account has been approved by the credit provider,
after which cardholders can use it to make purchases at Merchants accepting that card.
When a purchase is made, the credit card user agrees to pay the card issuer. The
cardholder indicates consent to pay by signing a Receipt with a record of the card details
and indicating the amount to be paid or by entering a personal identification number
(PIN). Also, many merchants now accept verbal authorizations via telephone and
electronic authorization using the Internet, known as a 'Card/Cardholder Not Present'
(CNP) transaction.
Electronic verification systems allow merchants to verify that the card is valid and
the credit card customer has sufficient credit to cover the purchase in a few seconds,
allowing the verification to happen at time of purchase. The verification is performed
using a credit card payment terminal or Point of sale (POS) system with a
communications link to the merchant's acquiring bank. Data from the card is obtained
from a magnetic stripe or chip on the card.
Each month, the credit card user is sent a statement indicating the purchases
undertaken with the card, any outstanding fees, and the total amount owed. After
receiving the statement, the cardholder may dispute any charges that he or she thinks are
incorrect. Otherwise, the cardholder must pay a defined minimum proportion of the bill
by a due date, or may choose to pay a higher amount up to the entire amount owed. The
credit issuer charges interest on the amount owed if the balance is not paid in full
(typically at a much higher rate than most other forms of debt). Some financial
institutions can arrange for automatic payments to be deducted from the user's bank
accounts, thus avoiding late payment altogether as long as the cardholder has sufficient
funds.
Benefits to customers:
The main benefit to each customer is convenience. Compared to debit cards and
checks, a credit card allows small short-term loans to be quickly made to a customer who
need not calculate a balance remaining before every transaction, provided the total
charges do not exceed the maximum credit line for the card.
Detriments to customers:
Credit cards with low introductory rates are limited to a fixed term, usually
between 6 and 12 months after which a higher rate is charged. As all credit cards assess
fees and interest, some customers become so encumbered with their credit debt service
that they are driven to bankruptcy. Credit cards will often stipulate a default rate of 20 to
30 percent in the event a payment is missed. That is, if a consumer misses a payment, the
rate will automatically increase to a very burdensome level. This can lead to a snowball
effect in which the consumer is drowned by unexpectedly high interest rates. Further
most card holder agreements enable the issuer to arbitrarily raise the interest rate for any
reason they see fit.
Grace period:
A credit card's grace period is the time the customer has to pay the balance before
interest is charged to the balance. Grace periods vary, but usually range from 20 to 40
days depending on the type of credit card and the issuing bank. Some policies allow for
reinstatement after certain conditions are met.
Benefits to merchants:
For merchants, a credit card transaction is often more secure than other forms of
payment, such as checks, because the issuing bank commits to pay the merchant the
moment the transaction is authorized, regardless of whether the consumer defaults on the
credit card payment (except for legitimate disputes, which are discussed below, and can
result in charges back to the merchant). In most cases, cards are even more secure than
cash, because they discourage theft by the merchant's employees and reduce the amount
of cash on the premises. Prior to credit cards, each merchant had to evaluate each
customer's credit history before extending credit. That task is now performed by the
banks which assume the credit risk. Credit cards can also aid in securing a sale, especially
if the customer does not have enough cash on his or her person or checking account.
For each purchase, the bank charges the merchant a commission (discount fee) for
this service and there may be a certain delay before the agreed payment is received by the
merchant. The commission is often a percentage of the transaction amount, plus a fixed
fee. In addition, a merchant may be penalized or have their ability to receive payment
using that credit card restricted if there are too many cancellations or reversals of charges
as a result of disputes. Some small merchants require credit purchases to have a minimum
amount to compensate for the transaction costs, though this is strictly prohibited by credit
card companies attempt to get consumers to report such merchants.
Costs to merchants:
Merchants are charged many fees for the privilege of accepting credit cards. The
merchant may be charged a discount rate of 1% to 3%+ of each transaction obtained
through a credit card. Usually, the merchant will also pay a flat per-item charge for each
transaction. Thus in some instances of very low value transactions, use of credit cards
may actually cause the merchant to lose money on the transaction. Merchants choose to
pay these costs in exchange for the increased profitable sales they can create. Thus, they
are considering part of the overall cost of marketing. Merchants with very low average
transaction prices or very high average transaction prices are more averse to accepting
credit cards. But rates are often reduced in an attempt to include more of these types of
merchants.
Parties involved:
Cardholder: The holder of the card used to make a purchase; the consumer.
Card-issuing bank: The financial institution or other organization that issued the
credit card to the cardholder. This bank bills the consumer for repayment and
bears the risk that the card is used fraudulently. American Express and Discover
were previously the only card-issuing banks for their respective brands, but as of
2007, this is no longer the case. Cards issued by banks to cardholders in a
different country are known as offshore credit cards.
Merchant: The individual or business accepting credit card payments for
products or services sold to the cardholder
Acquiring bank: The financial institution accepting payment for the products or
services on behalf of the merchant.
The flow of information and money between these parties — always through the
card associations — is known as the interchange, and it consists of a few steps.
Transaction steps:
Authorization: The cardholder pays for the purchase and the merchant submits
the transaction to the acquirer (acquiring bank). The acquirer verifies the credit
card number, the transaction type and the amount with the issuer (Card-issuing
bank) and reserves that amount of the cardholder's credit limit for the merchant.
An authorization will generate an approval code, which the merchant stores with
the transaction.
Batching: Authorized transactions are stored in "batches", which are sent to the
acquirer. Batches are typically submitted once per day at the end of the business
day. If a transaction is not submitted in the batch, the authorization will stay valid
for a period determined by the issuer, after which the held amount will be
returned back to the cardholder's available credit (see authorization hold). Some
transactions may be submitted in the batch without prior authorizations; these are
either transactions falling under the merchant's floor limit or ones where the
authorization was unsuccessful but the merchant still attempts to force the
transaction through. (Such may be the case when the cardholder is not present but
owes the merchant additional money, such as extending a hotel stay or car rental.)
Clearing and Settlement: The acquirer sends the batch transactions through the
credit card association, which debits the issuers for payment and credits the
acquirer. Essentially, the issuer pays the acquirer for the transaction.
Funding: Once the acquirer has been paid, the acquirer pays the merchant. The
merchant receives the amount totaling the funds in the batch minus the "discount
rate," which is the fee the merchant pays the acquirer for processing the
transactions.
A secured credit card is a type of credit card secured by a deposit account owned
by the cardholder. Typically, the cardholder must deposit between 100% and 200% of the
total amount of credit desired. Thus if the cardholder puts down Rs.1000, they will be
given credit in the range of Rs.500 – Rs.1000. In some cases, credit card issuers will offer
incentives even on their secured card portfolios. In these cases, the deposit required may
be significantly less than the required credit limit, and can be as low as 10% of the
desired credit limit. This deposit is held in a special saving account. Credit card issuers
offer this because they have noticed that delinquencies were notably reduced when the
customer perceives something to lose if the balance is not repaid.
The cardholder of a secured credit card is still expected to make regular payments,
as with a regular credit card, but should they default on a payment, the card issuer has the
option of recovering the cost of the purchases paid to the merchants out of the deposit.
The advantage of the secured card for an individual with negative or no credit history is
that most companies report regularly to the major credit bureaus. This allows for building
of positive credit history.
Although the deposit is in the hands of the credit card issuer as security in the
event of default by the consumer, the deposit will not be debited simply for missing one
or two payments. Usually the deposit is only used as an offset when the account is closed,
either at the request of the customer or due to severe delinquency (150 to 180 days). This
means that an account which is less than 150 days delinquent will continue to accrue
interest and fees, and could result in a balance which is much higher than the actual credit
limit on the card. In these cases the total debt may far exceed the original deposit and the
cardholder not only forfeits their deposit but is left with an additional debt.
Secured credit cards are an option to allow a person with a poor credit history or
no credit history to have a credit card which might not otherwise be available. They are
often offered as a means of rebuilding one's credit. Secured credit cards are available with
both Visa and MasterCard logos on them. Fees and service charges for secured credit
cards often exceed those charged for ordinary non-secured credit cards, however, for
people in certain situations, (for example, after charging off on other credit cards, or
people with a long history of delinquency on various forms of debt), secured cards can
often be less expensive in total cost than unsecured credit cards, even including the
security deposit.
A prepaid credit card is not a credit card, since no credit is offered by the card
issuer: the card-holder spends money which has been "stored" via a prior deposit by the
card-holder or someone else, such as a parent or employer. However, it carries a credit-
card brand (Visa, MasterCard, American Express or Discover) and can be used in similar
ways just as though it were a regular credit card.
After purchasing the card, the cardholder loads the account with any amount of
money, up to the predetermined card limit and then uses the card to make purchases the
same way as a typical credit card. Prepaid cards can be issued to minors since there is no
credit line involved. The main advantage over secured credit cards is that you are not
required to come up with 500 or more to open an account. With prepaid credit cards you
are not charged any interest but you are often charged a purchasing fee plus monthly fees
after an arbitrary time period. Many other fees also usually apply to a prepaid card.
Prepaid credit cards are sometimes marketed to teenagers for shopping online
without having their parents complete the transaction.
Because of the many fees that apply to obtaining and using credit-card-branded
prepaid cards, the Financial Consumer Agency describes them as "an expensive way to
spend your own money". The agency publishes a booklet, "Pre-paid cards", which
explains the advantages and disadvantages of this type of prepaid card.
OBJECTIVES
- To understand the work undertaken by merchant while accepting the cards or making
the card transaction.
For the regular customers and as well for the first time shoppers.
- To study the process of merchant acquiring by financial institutions & analyze the risky
fields or business where the scope for fraudulent or fake cards usage may occur, involve
the card users by investigating their usage/purchases.
- Needless to say flush-out the fake merchant entities that encourage un-authorized or
fraudulent transactions & for devising a risk procedure to analyze merchant acquiring
process by financial institution.
METHODOLOGY
The methodology is the plan, structure and strategy of the investigation process
that sets out to obtain answer to the study. The methodology followed for collecting the
information is using two sources of data namely.
Primary Data:
The method which was collected to collect the information is “In depth Personal
Interview” method.
The personal Interview and discussion was done with project guide (Branch
Head) & other personnel in the organization in this process.
There was no formal questionnaire designed for collecting the data and here we
have used only personal interview and discussions with the people who come in the way
of the project.
Secondary Data:
Websites like
www.euromonitor.com/FinancialCardsinIndia
www.myiris.com/cards/index.php
www.thehindubusinessline.com
Wikepedia.com, Etc
Economic Times,
Business Line, Etc
Magazines like
Professional Banker
Business world.
ANALYSIS
The Merchants operating the Electronic Data Capture Machines and accepting the
Credit and Debit cards for the payment of Goods and Services offered by them in Hubli
region.
I have met the following Merchant’s and had a personal interview which helped me to get
the idea about merchant processing activities.
SWATANTRATA BAFNA
PETROLEUMS OPPNEW BUS STAND C H BAFNA
SHRIKANT T
RAMESH TAILOR COLLECTIONS KOPPIKAR ROAD BELAMKAR
RAJAN R RAYKAR
CITY PETROLEUMS CLUB ROAD
LADDHA
NAVRATANRAJ C
RATNADEEP JEWELLERS DURGA BAIL SANGHVI
HOTEL NAVEEN
OPP GYMKHANA
CITY PETROLEUMS CLUB RAJAN R RAYKAR
Some of the Merchants have shown their approximate Average turnover of the
credit and Debit card transactions amount in Rupees for one month period.
Computer shopee
1 lakh
Darpan Garments
5 lakhs
Sky tech computers
20 lakhs
Hubli Systems
Treatment by the Merchant’s for the Regular Customer and First time
shopper:
For regular customers the merchant will not go for the identification services they
will just swap the card and let the customer to go, Because the Merchant’s will have trust
their regular customers.
For the irregular or the first time shopper merchant will take care while making
the card transaction. The merchant will ask for ID or any other personal identification
cards if the customer is failed to do so they will go for Address verification service and
Customer verification value services.
For swiping of Master card the 4-digit pin is required. And swiping of Visa card
the confidential pin is not required. Just the merchant will swipe the card and return back
the card to customer with the bill details.
Whereas the new rule is taking place in two months that the Visa card should also have to
swipe by entering the 4-digit confidential pin code.
The maestro Debit card also requires the 4-digit confidential pin number to complete a
card transaction.
By accepting Visa cards at your point of sale, you become an integral part of the
Visa payment system. That’s why it’s important that you start with a clear picture of the
Visa card transaction process: what it is, how it works, and who’s involved. This basic
knowledge will provide you with a conceptual framework for the policies and procedures
covered in this guide. It will also help you to understand the major components of
payment processing and how they affect the way you do business.
- Visa transaction information moves from merchant banks to issuers for posting to
cardholders’ accounts.
2. Merchant swipes the card, enters the dollar amount, and transmits an
authorization request to the merchant bank. For card-not-present transactions, the
account number and other information may be digitally or key-entered.
6. VisaNet forwards the card issuer’s authorization response to the merchant bank.
10. Merchant bank credits the merchant’s account and electronically submits the
transaction to Visa for settlement.
11. VisaNet:
Facilitates settlement.
Pays the merchant bank and debits the card issuer account, then sends the
transaction to the card issuer.
Merchants or their agents that store, process, or transmit data may not
store sensitive authentication data (full magnetic-stripe or chip) contents. Card
Verification Value 2 (CVV2), or PIN Verification Value (PVV)—even if it is
encrypted. Once an authorization is processed, such data should no longer exist. The
only components of the magnetic stripe that can be stored are name, account number, and
expiration date.
Visa Rules:
Merchants must follow basic card acceptance rules for all Visa transactions.
Careful and consistent adherence to the Visa rules outlined in this section will help you to
enhance customer satisfaction and increase your profitability.
Acceptance option:
To offer the broadest possible range of payment options to consumers, most
merchants choose to accept all categories of Visa debit and credit cards.
Merchants accepting any category of Visa cards must honor all foreign-issued Visa cards
presented for payment.
Visa logo:
Display the Visa logo at the merchant location or on catalogs, sales materials, or
web sites. Depending on the card acceptance option you choose, both card- present and
card-not present merchants must display the appropriate Visa logo or word mark to
advice customers of your payment options. Visa has developed the following logos:
Always treat Visa transactions like any other transaction; that is, you may not
impose any surcharge on a Visa transaction. You may, however, offer a discount for cash
transactions, provided that the offer is clearly disclosed to customers and the cash price is
presented as a discount from the standard price charged for all other forms of payment.
Convenience Fees:
For merchants who offer an alternate payment channel for customers to pay for
goods or services, a convenience fee may be added to the transaction amount. If the
merchant chooses to assess a convenience fee to its customers, the merchant must adhere
to the following rules:
The fee is being charged for a bona fide convenience of using an alternative
payment channel outside of the merchant’s normal business practice (see example
below).
The fee:
Example:
The merchant provides utility services to its customers, and the customary way to
pay is by mail or in person at the merchant’s location. For the convenience of its
customers, the merchant also offers a website for payments. In this example, the
merchant may apply a convenience fee to payments made via the website.
Taxes:
Taxes include any required taxes in the total transaction amount. Do not collect
taxes separately in cash. This policy reflects the needs of the many Visa cardholders who
must have written records of the taxes they pay for goods and services.
Laundering:
Deposit transactions only for your own business. Depositing transactions for a
business that does not have a valid merchant agreement is called laundering or factoring.
Laundering is not allowed; it is a form of fraud associated with high chargeback rates and
the potential for promoting illegal activity.
Zero-Percent Tip:
No cash Refunds:
If a transaction was conducted with a Visa prepaid card and the cardholder is
returning items, but has discarded this card, you may give a cash refund or in-store credit.
Deposit your Visa transaction receipts within five calendar days of the transaction
date. The sooner you deposit transaction receipts with your merchant bank, the sooner
you get paid! For card-not-present transactions, the transaction date is the ship date, not
the order date. Transactions deposited more than 30 days after the original transaction
date may be charged back to you.
Delayed Delivery:
For a delayed delivery, obtain two authorizations: one for the deposit amount and
one for the balance amount. Some merchandise, such as a custom-covered sofa, requires
delivery after the transaction date. In these delayed-delivery situations, the customer pays
a deposit at the time of the transaction and agrees to pay the balance upon delivery of the
merchandise or services. To complete a delayed-delivery transaction, you should:
Create two transaction receipts—one for the deposit and one for the balance.
Write “Deposit” or “Balance,” as appropriate, on the receipt.
Write “Delayed Delivery” along with the authorization code on each transaction
receipt. You may deposit the receipt for the deposit portion of the transaction
before delivery of the goods or services. However, you must not deposit the
transaction receipt for the balance amount prior to delivery.
Data Storage:
Avoid CVV2 Storage. All merchants are prohibited from storing CVV2 data.
When asking a cardholder for CVV2, merchants must not document this
information on any kind of paper order form or store it on any database.
Know your liability. Many merchant agreements now include provisions that hold
businesses liable for losses resulting from compromised card data if a business (or
its third-party processor) lacks adequate data security.
As a merchant, they are responsible for establishing the merchandise return and
adjustment (credit) policies that will provide your business with maximum profitability
and customer service. Clear disclosure of these policies can help you avoid
misunderstandings and potential cardholder disputes. Visa will support your policies,
provided they are clearly disclosed to cardholders before the completion of a transaction.
If they are unsure about how to disclose the return and adjustment policies, they
should contact the merchant bank for further guidance.
For card-present transactions, Visa will accept that proper disclosure has occurred
before a transaction is completed if the following (or similar) disclosure statements are
legibly printed on the face of the transaction receipt near the cardholder signature line.
For proper disclosure, card holder refund and credit policies must be mailed, e-
mailed, or faxed to the cardholder. To complete the sale, the cardholder must sign and
return the disclosure statement to merchant.
Internet:
The refund and credit policies should be available to online customers through
clearly visible links on internet home page. Merchant should also provide “click-through”
confirmation for important elements of the policy. For example, when purchasing tickets
for a sporting event, customers should be able to click on a button— accept or I agree—
to acknowledge that they understand the tickets are nonreturnable unless the event is
postponed or cancelled.
It's up to Visa Merchant banks to help their merchants understand and follow Visa
payment acceptance rules if they elect to implement a PIN-less payment option for
alternative debit cards. To this end, you are encouraged to work closely with your
merchants and their third-party agents to ensure that the following practices are adopted
prior to system implementation.
Confusion can often arise when customers believe they're paying using one
payment brand, but the transaction is processed using another brand. For example, a
customer who selects payment by Visa should always have that choice honored. Options
such as “Debit” and “Credit” may be misleading and may have different meanings
depending upon the customer’s understanding. Selection of a payment brand provides a
clear choice to the consumer. This is why it is best for merchants to provide their
customers with a menu of acceptable brands.
For Internet merchants, providing a menu or radio button that presents all of the
payment brand options and allowing the customer to make an informed choice as
shown in the example to the right.
For telephone merchants who instruct customers to select their preferred payment
method through a Voice Response Unit (VRU) or customer service agent, it
means identifying specific payment brand options, rather than generic terms such
as credit, debit, and ATM, and allowing the customer to make an informed
choice.
If the customer indicates that he or she wants to pay with a Visa card, the
merchant must make sure that choice is honored. A merchant is allowed to steer the
customer to other forms of payment, but cannot confuse or mislead the customer or omit
important information in the process. In other words, the choice is ultimately the
customer’s. A transaction can only be processed as something other than Visa if the
customer has selected another form of payment. However, if a customer chooses Visa, it
must be processed as a Visa transaction.
In a typical DCC transaction, the purchase price is converted from the merchant’s
pricing currency into another currency, the “transaction currency.” This is the
cardholder’s billing currency. This conversion is performed at the point of sale, before a
merchant bank presents the transaction for authorization. The transaction amount is based
on a labeled price in the merchant’s pricing currency and converted at a rate agreed upon
by the merchant and the cardholder, plus any other charges for currency conversion.
merchant’s pricing currency. This way, the cardholder knows exactly how much the
goods or services cost, and is able to make value judgments quickly and easily.
With DCC, there are no surprises, the amount agreed and verified by the
cardholder using either a PIN or signature at point of sale is exactly the amount charged
on the his or her payment card statement. DCC is currently prohibited for ATM and cash
disbursement transactions.
Visa requires that all new electronic Point Of Sale terminals provide account
number truncation on transaction receipts. This means that only the last four digits of an
account number should be printed on the customer’s copy of the receipt. The expiration
date should not appear at all. Existing Point Of Sale terminals must comply with these
requirements. To ensure your Point Of Sale terminals are properly set up for account
number truncation, contact your merchant bank.
A DCC transaction receipt must not contain misleading text, layout, and font sizes
or use of text highlighting that may lead to cardholder confusion or disputes.
There must be a clear statement that the cardholder recognizes that he or she has
been given a choice of currencies.
Must not use any contractual language or procedures that result in the cardholder
choosing DCC transaction by default. The merchant must inform the cardholder
that the service is optional.
Card-Present Transactions:
Card-present transactions are those in which both the card and cardholder are
present at the point of sale. Merchants associated with this sales environment include
traditional retail outlets such as department and grocery stores, electronics stores, and
specialty shops and boutiques. Gas stations and other businesses where customers use
unattended payment devices are also defined as card-present merchants.
1. Swipe the card to request the transaction authorization. Hold the card through the
entire transaction.
2. While the transaction is being processed, check the card’s features and security
elements to make sure the card is valid and has not been altered in any way.
3. Obtain authorization and get the cardholder signature on the transaction receipt
4. Compare the name, number, and signature on the card to those on the transaction
receipt.
On the back of every Visa card, you’ll find a magnetic stripe. It contains the
cardholder name, card account number, and expiration date, as well as special security
information designed to help detect counterfeit cards. When the stripe is swiped through
the terminal, this information is electronically read and relayed to the card issuer, who
then uses it as crucial input for the authorization decision.
Verifying the Account Number:
Most Point Of Sale terminals also allow merchants to verify that the account
number embossed on the front of the card is the same as the account number encoded on
the card’s magnetic stripe. How you check the numbers depends on your POS terminal.
In some cases, the magnetic stripe number is displayed on the terminal or printed on the
sales receipt. In others, the terminal may be programmed to check the numbers
electronically. In such instances, merchant will be prompted to enter the last four digits of
the embossed account number, which will then be matched against the last four digits of
the account number on the If the account number is printed on the receipt, in many cases
only the last four digits will be used . If the numbers don’t match, you will receive a “No
Match” message. In such instances, should make a Code 10 call.
In some instances, when you swipe a card, the terminal will not be able to read the
magnetic stripe or perform an authorization. When this occurs, it usually means one of
the three things:
The terminal’s magnetic-stripe reader is not working properly.
Damage to the card may happen accidentally, but it may also be a sign that the card is
counterfeit or has been altered.
Check the terminal to make sure that it is working properly and that the card is
swiped correctly.
If the terminal is okay, take a look at the card’s security features to make sure the
card is not counterfeit or has not been altered in any way
If the problem appears to be with the magnetic stripe, follow store procedures. He
may be allowed to use the terminal’s manual override feature to key-enter
transaction data for authorization, or he may need to make a call to the voice
authorization centre.
These below are the best practices can help the merchant in keep key-entered
transactions at acceptably low levels and should be incorporated into your daily
operations and staff training and review sessions.
If key-entry rates are greater than one percent per terminal or sales associate, you
should investigate the situation and try to find out why. The following chart summarizes
the most common reasons for high key-entry rates and provides possible solutions.
Train your sales staff to take a few seconds to look at the card’s basic features and
security elements after they have swiped the card and are waiting for authorization.
Checking card features and security elements helps to ensure that the card is valid and
has not been altered in anyway.
Sales staff should be instructed to keep payment cards in their possession during
transaction processing. Holding onto the card allows time to check card features and
security elements and to compare the cardholder signature on the card with the signature
on the transaction receipt.
These are the points to look for in the Visa card as above Shown in the above
Diagram:
1. The Signature Panel has an updated tamper evident design, as shown here, or
has a custom design. It may vary in length dependent on card type. If someone
has tried to erase the signature panel, the word “VOID” will be displayed.
2. The Magnetic stripe is encoded with the card’s account number, expiration
date, and other identifying information.
4. Visa Brand Mark appears in blue and gold on a white background. It must
appear in either the bottom right, top left, or top right corner.
5. Ultraviolet "V" is visible over the Visa Brand Mark when placed under an
ultraviolet light.
6. “Good Thru” (or “Valid Thru”) Date is the expiration date of the card. It is
located below the embossed account number. If the current transaction date is
after the “Good Thru” date, the card has expired.
7. Four-Digit Number must be printed directly below the account number. This
four-digit number must match exactly with the first four digits of the account
number. Both must begin with a “4.”
8. Embossed or Printed account Number on valid cards begins with “4.” The
account number must be even and straight; on altered cards, they may have fuzzy
edges, or you may be able to see “ghost images” of the original numbers.
9. The Mini Dove Design hologram may appear on the back anywhere within the
outlined areas shown in these images. A three-dimensional dove hologram should
reflect light and seem to change as you tilt the card. Most counterfeit cards
contain a one-dimensional printed image on a foil sticker.
If any of the Visa card security features is missing or looks altered, the card
should be kept with merchant in possession and make a Code 10 call to the authorization
center and may be instructed to try to recover the card or simply to return it to the
cardholder and decline the transaction.
Authorization:
Authorizing Transactions
To authorize credit card transactions, the merchant obtains approval from the
card-issuing bank or from a third party approved by the card-issuer. This authorization
process is structured to prevent transactions being approved for cardholders who have not
satisfactorily maintained their credit card account or who are over their credit limit, as
well as to protect against the unauthorized use of stolen and fraudulent cards.
Typically, the clerk at the point of sale swipes the credit card through a terminal
to obtain the information stored on the magnetic stripe on the back of the card, then
inputs the amount of the transaction. This information is then transmitted to the merchant
bank or its processor, who captures the transaction and forwards the information to the
card-issuing bank through the bankcard association network. Depending on the status of
the cardholder’s account, the transaction will be approved or declined, and this decision
will be transmitted back through the bankcard association network to the point of sale.
After the transaction is authorized, the clerk prints a sales draft that the customer signs.
Authorization Responses:
During the authorization process, the sales associates should receive one of the
following responses, or one that is similarly worded.
Response Meaning
Card issuer approves the transaction. This is the
The final step in the card acceptance process is to ensure that the customer signs
the sales receipt and to compare that signature with the signature on the back of the card.
When signing the receipt, the customer should be within your full view, and you should
check the two signatures closely for any obvious inconsistencies in spelling or
handwriting.
While checking the signature, you should also compare the name, account
number, and signature on the card to those on the transaction receipt.
Match the name and last four digits of the account number on the card to those
printed on the receipt.
Match the signature on the back of the card to the signature on the receipt. The
first initial and spelling of the surname must match.
Note: Embossed name and signature do not need to be the same.
For suspicious or non-matching signatures, make a Code 10 call and ask for further
instructions.
Note: If the transaction is accepted with a non-matching signature and it turns out to be
fraudulent, merchants business may be liable, even if all other procedures were followed.
Unsigned Cards:
While checking card security features, you should also make sure that the card is
signed. An unsigned card is considered invalid and should not be accepted. If a customer
gives you an unsigned card, the following steps must be taken:
Check the cardholder’s ID card. Ask the cardholder for some form of official
government identification, such as a driver’s license or passport. Where
permissible by law, the ID serial number and expiration date should be written on
the sales receipt before you complete the transaction.
Ask the customer to sign the card. The card should be signed within your full
view, and the signature checked against the customer’s signature on the ID card.
A refusal to sign means the card is still invalid and cannot be accepted. Ask the
customer for another signed Visa card.
Compare the signature on the card to the signature on the ID Card. If the
cardholder refuses to sign the card, and you accept it, you may end up with
financial liability for the transaction should the cardholder later dispute the
charge.
Although Visa rules do not preclude merchants from asking for cardholder ID,
merchants cannot make an ID a condition of acceptance. Therefore, merchants cannot
refuse to complete a purchase transaction because a cardholder refuses to provide ID
card. Visa believes merchants should not ask for ID as part of their regular card
acceptance procedures. Laws in several states also make it illegal for merchants to write a
cardholder’s personal information, such as an address or phone number, on a sales
receipt.
Suspicious Behavior:
Asking no questions or refusing free delivery on large items (for example, heavy
appliances or televisions) or high-dollar purchases
Making purchases, leaving the store, and then returning to make more purchases
Making purchases either right when the store opens or just before it closes
Merchant know what kind of behavior is normal for your particular place of
business. If he feels really uncomfortable or suspicious about a cardholder or transaction,
keep the card in your possession and make a Code 10 call. In any situation where making
the call with the customer present feels inappropriate or unsafe, complete the transaction,
return the card, and make the call immediately after the customer leaves.
At Service Stations:
With their mix of attended and unattended POS devices, service stations are
somewhat different from traditional retail environments. Customer behavior that signals
potential fraud is also different here, both at the counter and at the pump.
Skimming:
If merchant suspect skimming activity at his place of business, he should call your
merchant bank or company security immediately.
Card-Not-Present Transactions:
The growth of the mail order, telephone order, and Internet markets means
increasing numbers of merchants are now processing transactions in situations where the
card and cardholder are not present and fraud may be especially difficult to detect. Of
necessity, card acceptance procedures for these transactions are different from procedures
for card-present transactions, but must still allow merchants to verify to the greatest
extent possible the cardholder’s identity and the validity of the purchase.
Findings show that merchants who include CVV2 validation in their authorization
procedures for card-not-present transactions can reduce their fraud-related charge backs.
4. CVV2 Processing:
Ask card-not-present customers for the last three numbers in or beside the
signature panel on the back of their Visa cards.
If the customer provides a CVV2, submit this information with other transaction
data (card expiration date and account number) for electronic authorization.
Merchant should also include one of the following CVV2 presence indicators,
even if he is not including a CVV2 in your authorization request:
Evaluate the CVV2 result code you receive with the transaction authorization, and
take appropriate action based on all transaction characteristics.
S – CVV2 should be on the card, but Follow up with the customer to verify that
The cardholder has reported that it the correct card location has been checked
isn’t. for CVV2.
Merchant should evaluate the Address Verification Service response code and
take appropriate action, based on all transaction characteristics and any other verification
information received with the authorization (expiration date, CVV2, etc.). An
authorization response always takes precedence over Address Verification Service. Do
not accept any transaction that has been declined, regardless of the Address Verification
Service response.
The Merchant Direct Access Service (MDAS) offers merchant’s access to AVS
by a toll-free number, using a touch-tone phone. The service is specifically targeted to
small Mail Order/Telephone Order or Internet merchants for whom AVS may not be
cost-effective. Merchants using MDAS are charged on a per-transaction basis. To use
MDAS, you need a touch-tone phone with an outgoing line and a Merchant Access Code
(MAC), which you get from your merchant bank. To request address verification, call the
Merchant Direct Access Service responses are similar to AVS, but do not include a
single-letter response code.
Internet Transactions:
Today, more and more merchants are joining the “click and mortar” market,
adding online sales to their traditional card-present operations. As a result, Visa has
developed guidelines and fraud prevention services especially for the web.
Merchant bank may recommend or require that you include certain content or
features on your web site. These elements are intended to promote ease of use for online
shoppers and reduce cardholder disputes and potential charge backs.
Complete description of goods and services. Remember you have a global market,
which increases opportunities for unintended misunderstandings or
miscommunications. For example, if you sell electrical goods, be sure to state
voltage requirements, which vary around the world.
Return, refund, and cancellation policy. This policy must be clearly posted.
Delivery policy. Merchants set their own policies about delivery of goods, that is,
if they have any geographic or other restrictions on where or under what
circumstances they provide delivery. Any restrictions on delivery must be clearly
stated on the web site.
Country of origin. You must disclose the permanent address of your establishment
on the web site. Check with your merchant bank to ensure your disclosure is made
in accordance with the Visa Inc. Operating Regulations and local law.
Export restrictions.
Privacy statements.
Information on when credit cards are charged: Merchant should not bill the
customer until merchandise has been shipped.
Today’s e-commerce merchant has many options for combating payment card
fraud. To protect your business, you need to build a reliable risk management system.
Visa continues to develop online fraud-prevention tools to complement your own internal
fraud avoidance efforts.
Verified by Visa
The service is free to cardholders, who register their account numbers online at
Visa’s consumer web site, www.visa.com. Each cardholder creates a unique password at
the time of registration. Then when a cardholder makes a purchase by clicking Buy, or a
similar button, on a participating merchant web site, the merchant server recognizes the
Visa account number and a Verified by Visa window appears. The cardholder is
prompted to enter the password. The password is forwarded to the cardholder’s card
issuer, who confirms the cardholder’s identity and the Visa account number.
Fraud Screening:
Every time a cardholder clicks the Buy button on a web site using Cyber Source
Advanced Fraud Screen, the transaction is evaluated based on over 150 data points.
Running 24 hours a day, seven days a week, the service uses the world’s largest database
of global fraud and payment-card usage patterns, including online and offline
transactions, and is updated frequently. Risk scores are calculated using a combination of
neural networks, rules-based modeling, and Visa hybrid fraud technologies.
Suspicious Transactions:
Merchant’s sales employees should be on the lookout for any of the following signs of
suspicious customer behavior:
Rush orders: Urgent requests for quick or overnight delivery the customer who
“needs it yesterday” should be another red flag for possible fraud. While often
perfectly valid, rush orders are one of the common characteristics of “hit and run”
fraud schemes aimed at obtaining merchandise for quick resale.
Random orders: Watch out also for customers who don’t seem to care if a
particular item is out of stock” You don’t have it in red? What colors do you
have?” or who order haphazardly” I’ll take one of everything!” Again, orders of
this kind may be intended for resale rather than personal use.
Suspicious shipping address: Scrutinize and flag any order with a ship to
address that is different from the billing address on the cardholder’s account.
- Keep lists of zip codes where high fraud rates are common and verify any
order that has a ship-to address in these areas.
- If your business does not typically service foreign customers, use caution
when shipping to addresses outside the United States, particularly if you are
dealing with a new customer or a very large order.
Experience suggests that Internet orders with certain characteristics can be tip-offs
to possible fraud. Suspicious online transactions are similar to suspicious sales in other
card-not-present environments, although the Internet offers additional opportunities for
“virtual” scams. The following list of potential fraud characteristics—compiled from the
advice of various experts—is offered to help you avoid being victimized by Internet fraud
. An Internet transaction with any one of these characteristics by itself is seldom cause for
alarm; however, a transaction with several potential risk markers may mean you are the
target of a fraud scheme.
First-time shopper:
Criminals are always looking for new victims. They usually hit a merchant once
and don’t go back a second or third time.
Larger-than-normal orders:
Because stolen cards or account numbers have a limited life span, crooks
need to maximize the size of their purchases. Of course, the sizes of “normal”
orders vary from merchant to merchant.
These items have maximum resale value and therefore maximum profit
potential.
Orders shipped “rushed” or “overnight”:
Crooks aren’t concerned about extra delivery charges. They want their
fraudulently obtained items as soon as possible for the quickest possible resale.
These services have no billing relationships with their user, which in turn
means no audit trail or verification that a legitimate cardholder has opened the
account.
The next several characteristics are ones that require regular monitoring of
company’s transactions. Ideally, merchant should have a database or account history files
against which to compare individual sales for possible fraud.
To minimize the risk associated with all recurring transactions, merchants should:
Keep the cardholder’s expiration date on file and include it in all authorization
requests.
1. The card issuer sends information to the Visa Account Updater that includes
account number, card expiration date changes, and account closures.
2. The merchant bank sends inquiries to Visa Account Updater for cardholder
accounts that their enrolled merchants have on file.
3. Visa Account Updater sends a response to the merchant bank for each inquiry,
including updated information.
Check customer logs daily for cancellation or non-renewal of services paid for
with a recurring transaction. Comply with all cancellation and nonrenewal
requests in a timely manner, and notify the cardholder that the recurring payment
account has been closed.
FINDINGS
Many of the merchant’s just swipe the card when the customer agrees to pay
through credit card for the goods and services offered to him.
In Hubli region the terminologies like AVS (Address verification service), CVV2
(card verification value 2). DCC (Dynamic currency conversion) and Etc are not
being in use.
It is found that merchant will swipe the card if and only the cost of goods and
services provided by him is more. If the card holder wants to pay Rs. 500 through
card merchant will not to make the card transaction if possible please pay the
cash, if the transaction amount is more that the purchaser can’t carry such amount
they will accept the card transaction.
Findings show that merchants who include Card Verification Value 2 validation
in their authorization procedures for card-not-present transactions can reduce their
fraud-related charge backs.
Many card holders have never seen credit reports and do not realize the impact
that reports have on their ability to utilize their valued property rights.
In Hubli region the Merchants like Tanishq stores, Jain jewelers and Big Bazaar
and Etc will go for the card transaction if the amount of goods sold is more and
the Merchants like Nokia Priority, Reliance fresh, More and Etc will not prefer
mostly for the Card transactions because the amount of transaction is not high and
the level of risk involved in the transaction will be more.
If the card holder seems to be suspicious the store merchants will not accept his
payment through credit/debit card they only prefer to cash transaction.
Many of the Electronic data capture merchants do not go for proper reference of
the card holder, they just swipe the card amounted to bill and give back a receipt
of payment.
The Bank will install the Electronic Data Capture Machines in those outlets where
the outlets Bank account is managing by that particular bank.
The Electronic Data Capture machines installed by bank in the stores will be
having Monthly rental Machines, Non-rental Machines and Discount Machines.
For swiping of Master card the 4-digit pin is required. And swiping of Visa card
the confidential pin is not required. Just the merchant will swipe the card and
return back the card to customer with the bill details.
Whereas the new rule is taking place in two months that the Visa card should also
have to swipe by entering the 4-digit confidential pin code.
The maestro Debit card also requires the 4-digit confidential pin number to
complete a card transaction.
ADVANTAGES:
- They allow you to make purchases on credit without carrying around a lot of cash. This
allows the lot of flexibility.
- They allow accurate record keeping by consolidating purchases into a single statement.
- They allow convenient remote purchasing – Ordering/ Shipping online or by the phone.
- They allow you to pay for large purchases in small, monthly installments.
- Under certain circumstances, they allow to withhold payment for merchandise which
proves defective.
- They are cheaper for short term borrowing and interest is only paid on the remaining
debt.
- Many cards offer additional benefits such as additional insurance cover on purchases,
cash back, and Air miles and discount on holidays.
DIS-ADVANTAGES:
- You may become an impulsive buyer and tend to over spend because of the ease of
using credit cards. Cards can encourage the purchasing of goods and services you cannot
really afford.
- Credit cards are relatively expensive way of obtaining credit if you don’t use them
carefully, especially because of higher interest rates and other costs.
- Lost or stolen cards may result in some unwanted expense and inconvenience.
- The usage of large number of credit cards can get you even further into debt.
- Using a credit card, especially remotely, introduces and element of risk as the card
details may fall into the wrong hands resulting in fraudulent purchases on the card.
Fraudulent of unauthorized charges may take months to dispute, investigate and resolve.
The cardholders are the least impacted party due to fraud in credit card
transactions as consumer liability is limited for credit card transactions by the legislation
prevailing in most countries. This is true for both card present as well as card not present
scenarios. Many banks even have their own standards that limit the consumer's liability to
a greater extent. They also have a cardholder protection policy in place that covers for
most losses of the cardholder. The cardholder has to just report suspicious charges to the
issuing bank, which in turn investigates the issue with the acquirer and merchant, and
processes chargeback for the disputed amount.
Merchants are the most affected party in a credit card fraud, particularly more in
the card-not-present transactions, as they have to accept full liability for losses due to
fraud. Whenever a cardholder disputes a credit card charge, the card-issuing bank will
send a chargeback to the merchant, reversing the credit for the transaction. In case, the
merchant does not have any physical evidence (e.g. delivery signature) available to
challenge the cardholder’s dispute, it is almost impossible to reverse the chargeback.
Therefore, the merchant will have to completely absorb the cost of the fraudulent
transaction. In fact, this cost consists of several components, which could add up to a
significant amount. The cost of a fraudulent transaction consists of:
2. Shipping cost:
More relevant in a card-not-present scenario, since the shipping cost is
usually bundled in the value of the order, the merchant will also need to absorb
the cost of shipping for goods sold in a fraudulent transaction.
5. Administrative cost:
Every transaction that generates a chargeback requires significant
administrative costs for the merchant. On average, each chargeback requires one
to two hours to process. This is because processing a chargeback requires the
merchant to receive and research the claim, contact the consumer, and respond to
the acquiring bank or issuer with adequate documentation.
6. Loss of Reputation:
Maintaining reputation and goodwill is very important for merchants as
excessive chargeback and fraud monitoring could both drive cardholders away
from transacting business with a merchant.
Based on the scheme rules defined by both MasterCard and Visa, it is sometimes
possible that the Issuer bears the costs of fraud. Even in cases when the Issuer is not
bearing the direct cost of the fraud, there are some indirect costs that will finally be bear
by them. Like in the case of chargeback issued to the merchant, there are administrative
and manpower costs that the bank has to incur. The issuers and acquirers also have to
make huge investments in preventing frauds by deploying sophisticated IT systems for
detection of fraudulent transactions.
RECOMMENDATIONS
Merchants should verify the card before swiping of the card when the card holder
needed to make a card transaction.
Visa Card do not need the 4-digit pin while swiping, this may be risk oriented, so
Visa Card also have the confidential pin for safe transactions.
For the first time shoppers the Merchant have to take the Id or any other Identity
proof for the card transactions.
Merchants should not accept the card payment or make the card transaction if the
cost of the purchases is low. Example: if a person purchased the goods or
services which costs up to 250 or 500, if he wants to pay with card it is better to
ask him for the cash payment.
- Information on when credit cards are charged. Merchant should not bill the
customer until merchandise has been shipped.
- Use directory assistance or Internet search tools—not the telephone number given
for a suspect transaction—to find a cardholder’s telephone number.
- Confirm the transaction, resolve any discrepancies, and let the cardholder know
that you are performing this confirmation as a protection against fraud.
There must be a clear statement that the cardholder recognizes that he or she has
been given a choice of currencies.
authorization requests. Including the date helps to verify that the card and
transaction are legitimate. A Mail Order/Telephone Order or Internet order
containing an invalid or missing expiration date may indicate counterfeit
or other unauthorized use.
4. CVV2 Processing:
Ask card-not-present customers for the last three numbers in or beside the
signature panel on the back of their Visa cards.
If the customer provides a CVV2, submit this information with other transaction
data (card expiration date and account number) for electronic authorization. Merchant
should also include one of the following CVV2 presence indicators, even if he is not
including a CVV2 in your authorization request:
Within each of these categories, the suggestions and recommendations for merchant
action are further classified by action type.
(PR) Possible Remedy. Steps merchant could take to help their merchant bank re-
present (resubmit) a chargeback item.
(PM) Preventive Measures. Possible steps merchant could take to minimize future
recurrence of the particular type of chargeback being discussed.
Non-Receipt of Information
Definition:
The card issuer requested a copy of the sales receipt and received an illegible
copy, or an incomplete substitute receipt, or something other than the requested item.
The merchant submitted a substitute sales receipt that did not contain all of the
required information or the transaction receipt was not legible, or was other than the
requested item because:
The point-of-sale printer ribbon was worn and the ink was too light.
The point-of-sale paper roll was nearing the end, and the colored streak indicating
this obscured transaction information.
The carbonless paper of the original sales receipt was mishandled, causing black
blotches and making copies illegible.
The original sales receipt was microfilmed at a reduced size, resulting in blurred
and illegible copies.
The document submitted was not the requested copy of the sales receipt.
Owner/Manager:
(Preventive Measure) For fraud-related retrieval requests, provide a copy of the signed
sales receipt.
Definition:
The card issuer received a complaint from a cardholder stating that the transaction
appearing on the billing statement is not recognized. This code applies to both card-
present and card-not-present transactions.
For example:
Sales receipt.
Owner/Manager:
Merchant Name
(Preventive Measures) The merchant name is the single most important factor in
cardholder recognition of transactions. Therefore, it is critical that the merchant name,
while reflecting the merchant’s “Doing Business As” (DBA) name, also be clearly
recognizable to the cardholder. Work with your merchant bank to ensure your merchant
name, city, and state are properly identified in the clearing record.
Definition:
The card issuer received a written claim from the cardholder, acknowledging
participation in at least one transaction at the merchant outlet but disputing participation
in the remaining transaction. The cardholder also states the card was in his or her
possession at the time of the disputed transactions.
The merchant:
Failed to void multiple transactions
Merchant Actions:
Back-office Staff:
Owner/Manager
Definition:
The card issuer received a written complaint from the cardholder claiming:
The merchant:
Failed to compare the first four-digits of the embossed account number on the
card with the preprinted digits below the embossed number for a card-present
transaction.
Merchant Actions:
Back-office Staff
Point-of-Sale Staff:
Key-entered Transaction
(Preventive Measures) If you key-enter a transaction because the magnetic
stripe cannot be read, be sure to get an imprint of the front of card either on the printed
sales receipt or a manual sales receipt form, which should be signed by the customer .
Definition:
The card issuer received a sales receipt that is missing required information,
indicating a potentially fraudulent transaction. Specific situations where this chargeback
code may be used include the following:
The card issuer received a sales receipt that has no imprint of the card’s embossed
or magnetic-stripe information or the cardholder’s signature, and either: the
Did not make a manual imprint of the card account information on the sales
receipt for a key-entered transaction.
Merchant Actions:
Back-office Staff
Card Imprint from Magnetic Stripe was obtained
(Possible Remedy) If the account number was not obtained from either the
magnetic stripe or manually, accept the chargeback.
Point-of-Sale Staff:
Swipe Cards or use a Manual Imprinter
(Preventive Measure) Obtain a record of the card’s account and expiration
date information on the sales receipt by (1) swiping the card through a terminal to
capture the account information from the card’s magnetic stripe, or (2) using a
manual imprinter to obtain the card’s embossed information. If you use a manual
imprinter, make sure the imprint can be positively matched with other transaction
information to prove the card was present. For example, if you take an imprint on
a separate receipt for a key-entered transaction, you should write the transaction
date, amount, and authorization code on this document before completing the sale.
Owner/Manager:
Remind Staff to obtain an electronic or Manual Imprint
Definition:
The card issuer received:
The merchant:
Processed a card-not-present transaction from a person who was fraudulently
using an account number.
The cardholder:
Did not recognize a card-not-present transaction on his or her statement due to an
unclear or confusing merchant name.
Merchant Actions:
Verified AVS or CVV2 and the card issuer gave a "U" response, you have a
representment right Inform the merchant bank.
Definition:
The card issuer received a transaction for which authorization had been declined.
Forced posting. After a decline response, the merchant forced the transaction
through without attempting another authorization request.
Merchant Actions:
Transaction was authorized
Owner/Manager:
Definition:
The card issuer received a transaction for which authorization was not obtained.
For Automated Fuel Dispenser (AFD) transactions, the card issuer may only chargeback
the amount exceeding any of the following:
The merchant did not obtain an authorization for a transaction or, for card- present
transactions, obtained it after the transaction date.
Merchant Actions:
Back-office Staff
Point-of-Sales Staff
Obtain an authorization
(Preventive Measure) Obtain an authorization before completing
transactions. The authorization request is sent automatically when you swipe the
card and enter the dollar amount. A receipt is printed if the transaction is
approved; if it is not approved, merchant will receive a Decline (or Call Center or
Pick Up) message on his POS terminal.
Card-Not-Present Transactions
Floor limits
(Preventive Measure) Floor limits are zero for all card-not-present
transactions with the exception of prestigious lodging merchants. This means they
always require authorization regardless of the dollar amount of the transaction.
Owner/Manager
Merchant Actions:
Back-office Staff
Card not expired—Key-entered Transaction
(Possible Remedy) For key-entered transactions, the expiration date
should be on the manually imprinted copy of the front of the card. If the expiration date
on sales receipt shows the card had not expired at the time of the sale, send a copy of the
receipt to your merchant bank. The chargeback is invalid regardless of whether
authorization was obtained.
(No Remedy) If the card is expired and you did not obtain an
authorization, accept the chargeback.
Point-of-Sale Staff:
Owner/Manager:
Definition:
The card issuer received a complaint from a cardholder, stating that a debit was
received for a transaction that should have been credited to the account.
The merchant issued a credit voucher, but the transaction was posted as a sale.
Merchant Actions:
Back-office Staff
(No Remedy) Accept the chargeback. In this case, the chargeback amount
will be double the original transaction.
Point-of-Sale Staff:
Owner/Manager:
(Preventive Measure) Ensure all sales staff knows procedures for issuing a
credit voucher, including correct use of transaction codes on POS terminals.
Definition:
The account number transmitted to the card issuer did not match any account
number on the card issuer’s master file, and the transaction was not authorized.
Merchant Actions:
Back-office Staff
Account Number Matches
(Possible Remedy) If the account number on the sales receipt matches the
account number cited on the chargeback, and the transaction received an
authorization approval, return the chargeback to your merchant bank and request
your bank to include the authorization log for this transaction when returning it to
the card issuer.
Card-Not-Present Transactions:
Recording account Numbers
(Preventive Measure) For phone orders read the account number back of
the customer to verify it.
Obtaining authorization
(Preventive Measure) Authorization is required for all card-not-present
transactions.
Owner/Manager
Card acceptance Procedures
(Preventive Measure) Review card acceptance procedures with your point-
of-sale staff. Staff should compare the account number embossed on the card with
the account number printed on the related sales receipt or shown on the point-of-
sale terminal. The two numbers must match. Do not accept the card if these
numbers do not match, instruct staff to call the voice authorization center and ask
for a “Code 10 authorization,”
Processing Errors:
The card issuer received a transaction after the 30-day time frame and account
number is blocked or closed.
The merchant or service establishment did not deposit the sales receipt with its
merchant bank within the time frame specified in its merchant agreement.
Merchant Actions:
(No Remedy) If the sales receipt was not deposited within 30 to 180 days
of the transaction date and the cardholder account has been closed, the
chargeback is valid.
(No Remedy) If the sales receipt was deposited more than 181 days after
the transaction date, accept the chargeback. (In this situation, the cardholder
account status is not a factor).
Owner/Manager
Manual Deposit of Paper Sales Receipts
(Preventive Measure) If you deposit paper sales receipts, ensure your staff
deposits them on a regular schedule within the time frame required by your
merchant bank.
Definition:
The card issuer received a transaction that exceeded the allowable amount from a
Limited-Amount, Self-Service Terminal, or Automated Fuel Dispenser (AFD)
transaction.
Merchant Actions:
Back-office Staff
Transaction was less than the allowable amount or amounts specified for
Automated Fuel Dispenser
(No Remedy) – If the appropriate credit has not yet been processed on the
disputed transaction, accept the chargeback. Do not process a credit since the
chargeback has already performed this function.
Definition:
The card issuer received a claim by a cardholder that:
The merchant was notified to cancel the recurring transaction but has since billed
the customer.
The transaction amount exceeds the pre-authorized dollar amount range, OR the
merchant was supposed to notify the cardholder prior to processing each recurring
transaction but has not done so.
The cardholder:
Charged back a previous recurring transaction and the cardholder did not
expressly renew.
The merchant:
Received notice before the transaction was processed that the cardholder account
was closed.
Exceeded the pre-authorized dollar amount range and did not notify the
cardholder in writing within ten days prior to processing the transaction.
Merchant Actions:
Back-office Staff
Definition:
The merchant:
Issued the credit but did not deposit the credit with its merchant bank in time for it
to appear on the cardholder’s next statement.
Did not issue a credit because the business does not accept returns, but did not
properly disclose its return policy.
Merchant Actions:
Back-office Staff
(Preventive Measure) Ensure credits are properly issued to the same Visa
account that was used for the original Visa purchase.
Owner/Manager
CONCLUSION
The good news is that technology for preventing credit card frauds is also
improving many folds with passage of time. Reducing cost of computing is helping in
introducing complex systems, which can analyze a fraudulent transaction in a matter of
fraction of a second.
The quality of risk management is (strong, satisfactory, and weak). The quality of
risk varies from merchant to merchant.
In expanding the credit card market, the existing foreign players, SBI and the
domestic private sector banks are expected to pursue complementary strategies. Foreign
banks with the advantages of technology and industry experience are likely to concentrate
on increased cardholder spending and customer loyalty. SBI, on the other hand, is
expected to use its superior distribution network to radically expand acceptance in the
smaller towns. The private sector banks will capture significant market share by
combining the strengths of foreign banks and nationalized ones.
Debit cards will grow up and will act as catalyst in increasing the electronic spend
with its extensive use in low value transactions.
Concluding Remarks:
Credit cards, smart cards and other electronic transactions will apparently replace
the cash medium in our near future. We need to understand our rights regarding credit
cards frauds and credit reports.
We need to be ready to improve our laws when faced with changes in technology.
Many card holders have never seen credit reports and do not realize the impact that
reports have on their ability to utilize their valued property rights in their reputation and
credit worthiness.