Is It Safe To Eat
Is It Safe To Eat
Contents
General Guidelines.................................................................................................................209
Conditions/Things One Might Encounter.............................................................................216
Should I Eat This?..................................................................................................................228
Literature Cited.......................................................................................................................229
Bolded words within the text indicate terms that are defined in the Glossary.
Chapter 5
animals becoming diseased and infecting others. Unfortunately, no matter how much we know about the meat being
considered for consumption, there always will be some degree
of risk. Some hazards can be invisible and thus, at times,
impossible to avoid (e.g., eggs and salmonellosis, hamburger
and Escherichia coli).
General Guidelines
What you dont know can hurt you (Anonymous)
Knowledge is the antidote to fear (Ralph Waldo
Emerson)
Figure 5.1 Game meat serves the food, cultural, and social needs for a wide variety of peoples.
Table 5.1. Characteristics of game-meat consumers in the USA and sources for that meat.
Typical role
of game meat
in diet
Primary
source of
meat
Primary
harvest of
meat
Subsistence
Primary
source of
animal protein
Wild
Personal
Local to
regional
Supplemental
Frequent and
important
source of
animal protein
Wild
Personal
Local to
regional
Recreational
Occasional
source of
animal protein
Wild
Personal
Local to
international
Many individuals infrequently harvest wildlife and may have little knowledge of their
diseases. Levels of knowledge vary and range
from high to low.
Novelty
Infrequent
novelty food
Wild
Other
Local to
international
Meat typically provided by friend who harvests wildlife; consumer with very limited
information relative to harvest conditions and
care of meat.
Cultural
Important
component to
satisfy food
needs
Wild/ commercial
Other
Local to
international
Meat, organs, powders, and other consumables from wildlife for medicinal, spiritual,
sexual, and other purposes. Primary native
peoples; minority of general public.
Gourmet
Other
Local to
international
Other
Local to
international
Consumer
type
Commercial
Primary
origin
of meat
Comments
Internal Exam:
How does the carcass smell?
Do any of the tissues or organs appear irregular or
abnormal in shape or color? (Fig. 5.8AF)
Do any of the tissues or organs appear to contain
abscesses? (Fig. 5.8G)
Are there any tissues or organs that contain what
appear to be parasites? (Fig. 5.8HJ)
Use all of your senses when examining a carcass. Bad
odors generally arise from rotting tissues, perhaps from
an old injury that has abscessed. However, the spillage of
intestinal tract content into the body cavity during removal or
from rupture during harvest may also be the source for such
odor. The food source of the animal may also result in strong
odors that are not an indication of disease. Cedar, sagebrush,
and bivalves (mussels) are examples of foods consumed by
Figure 5.5 Aberrations in hair/feather coat, emaciated body condition, deformities, sores, and soiling of the vent area are
common external indications that an animal may be afflicted by disease. (A) The extensive loss of feathers on the head of this
loon is believed to have been caused by ringworm resulting from infection by Trichophyton sp. fungi. (B) The white, wooly-like
hair within the hair coat of this white-tailed deer also is aberrant, but has genetic rather than a pathologic basis. (C) Emaciation
such as that seen in the breast of the lower pheasant and (D) by the rib cage of this gray wolf may result from food deprivation
(malnutrition), chronic infectious diseases, and other causes. (E) The shorter than normal lower jaw of this white-tailed deer is
genetic, while the deformed upper portion of the bill on this white pelican (F) was likely caused by injury rather than infectious
disease. In contrast, (G) the nodule on the face of this canvasback duck was caused by avian tuberculosis. (H) The greatly swollen
mammary glands of this white-tailed deer (mastitis) and (I) the swollen lower portions of the feet of another white-tailed deer are
caused by different types of pathogenic bacteria capable of causing disease in humans. Handling these types of animals without
protective gloves is hazardous as contact with drainage from infected areas can cause human infection through abrasions in the
skin. (J) The lesion on the tongue of this white-tailed deer was caused by bluetongue virus, one of the causes of hemorrhagic
disease in deer, livestock, and some other mammals. (K) The lesion under the tongue of this mallard duck was caused by duck
plague virus. (L) The blood-soiled vent area of this mallard duck also is due to duck plague, a viral disease of waterfowl and (M)
the green soiled vent area of this Canada goose is due to lead poisoning.
214 Disease Emergence and Resurgence: The WildlifeHuman Connection
Table 5.2 Common techniques for home preparation of game meat within the USAa,b
Method
Description
Comments
Smoking
Many types of
meat including
venison, birds, fish,
and occasionally
shellfish.
Jerky
Deer, caribou
and other large
mammals.
Popular for venison and sometimes used for novelty preparation of species not typically prepared for food. Insufficient
heating during the drying process may result in the survival
of larval forms of parasites encysted within game meat along
with contamination by bacterial organisms during processing
of the carcass. Examples include human cases of trichinellosis from the consumption of cougar jerky40 and Esherichia
coli 0157:H7 from venison jerky.41
Sausage
Same as jerky.
Popular use for less prized cuts of game meat from deer and
elk. Commonly served as snacks at the homes of hunters,
distributed to friends, and used as sandwich meat. Because
of the relative low meat temperatures (about 150F) reached
during preparation, it is important that both the game and
domestic meat be from wholesome animals. Secondary
bacterial contamination that may occur when processing the
carcass is especially important and requires that basic sanitation be incorporated throughout all aspects of processing
the animal and during sausage preparation.
Canning
Same as smoking.
Canning is the oldest and most important means of preparing ambient, stable long shelf-life foods.42 Clostridium botulinium is the pathogen of greatest concern for the commercial
canning industry43 and also for home-canning. The anaerobic
environment resulting from canning facilitates the germination of Cl. botulinium spores that may be present. The combination of temperature and time required to destroy botulinum
toxin produced by these bacteria is 212F for 10 minutes.39
The thermal death time for spores of Cl. botulinium at 250F
is 2.45 minutes. These temperatures must be maintained at
the center of the interior of the container.38
Direct cooking
Mammals, birds,
fish, shellfish and
incidental species,
such as frogs and
turtles.
Other
Various
a
Game meat is generally wholesome. All of the methods identified in this table are generally safe when properly applied. Unlike domestic meats, the health status of the animal
is not known nor is there a regulatory inspection process to evaluate game meat. Therefore, the burden for inspection and quality control from harvest through processing and food
preparation lies with those involved in the utilization of game meat.
b
Extreme examples of the edibility of meat from wild mammals are reports of meat eaten from a young mammoth frozen in the Siberian tundra for about 15,000 to 20,000 years and
bone marrow from a horse that had been frozen in Alaska for 50,000 years and was served at a dinner in New York.39
wildlife that may make them smell odd, but do not represent
potential human health hazards. The appearance of internal
organs and tissues is often compromised by damage during
the harvest of the animal and may be difficult to evaluate.
However, the appearance of abscesses, fungal growth, and
tumors within the body cavity should generally result in the
rejection of the carcass for consumption.
Most wildlife are wholesome and do not pose any significant risks for disease when cleanly harvested, properly
handled, and prepared appropriately as food. Nevertheless,
External Parasites
Photo courtesy of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Center for Great
Lakes and Aquatic Sciences
Figure 5.7 (A) Tumors within the mouth area of some fish, such as the brown bullhead, have been associated with environmental
contaminants; (B) the tumor on this northern pike is of unknown cause. Fish that have external tumors should not be consumed.
Figure 5.8 Abnormal coloration, size, and shape of organs, the presence of
growths within the body, and other indicators of disease are often readily seen when
carcasses are opened. Examples include: (A) pale coloration of tissues, such as
that caused by stress associated with improperly handling live animals (capture
myopathy); (B) the accumulation of white, gritty deposits in the surface of organs,
such as the heart of this bird due to dietary protein imbalances (visceral gout); (C)
encasement of the heart and part of the liver by a fibrous covering in this bird, and
(D) the translucent covering of the liver in another bird are the result of infection
by the bacterium Escherichia coli. (E)The numerous, raised, firm nodules seen in
this whooping crane are the result of avian tuberculosis. (F) The nodular area in
the lung of this deer is a malignant tumor. (G) Abscesses, such as those in the leg
of this muskrat, are sufficient reason to reject the use of meat from the carcass.
(H) Parasites, such as these roundworms in the intestine of a raccoon, (I) stomach
worms in a white-tailed deer, and (J) tapeworms in the intestine of this goose are
commonly seen in wildlife carcasses. These parasites do not represent a state of
disease and are not reasons to discard the carcass.
Table 5.3 Examples of parasite infections that may be observed in North American wildlife harvested for human
consumptiona
Disease/
parasite
Parasite
type
Primary
wildlife for
occurrence
Observations
Human
risks
Recommended action
Tracheal worm
Syngamus trachea
Nematode
(roundworm)
Upland game
birdsb
None
Meat is edible
Gizzard worms
Amidostomum spp.
Nematode
Upland game
birds
None
Histomoniasis
Histomonas
meleagris
Protozoan
Upland game
birds
None
Sarcosporidiosis
Sarcocystis spp.
Protozoan
Waterfowl
None
Trichomoniasis
Trichomonas gallinae
Protozoan
Doves,
pigeons
None
Meat is edible
Thorny-headed
worms
Acanthocephalan
None
Meat is edible
Dog tapeworm
Taenia pisiformes
Cestode
(tapeworm)
Rabbits
None
Myiasis
Warble and
bot fly larvae
Nonec
Larva migrans
Baylisascaris
procyonis
Nematode
Raccoon
Yes
Mange
Sarcoptes scabiei;
Notoedres douglasi
Mites
Squirrelsd
Yes
Demodectic mange
Demodex odocoilei
Mite
Deer
None
Liver fluke
Fascioloides magna
Trematode
(Fluke)
Deer
None
See text
Cysticercosis
Cestode
Moose
None
See text
Ich
Ichthyophthirius
multifiliis
Ciliate
Fish
None
Table 5.3 Examples of parasite infections that may be observed in North American wildlife harvested for human
consumptionaContinued.
Disease/
parasite
Parasite
type
Primary
wildlife for
occurrence
Observations
Human
risks
Recommended action
Black spot/grub
Uvulifer ambloplitis
Digenetic
trematode
(fluke)
Fish
None
White grub
Posthodiplostomum
minimum and others
Digenetic
trematode
Fish
None
Yellow grub
Clinostomum
complanatum
Digenetic
trematode
Fish
None
Heterosporis
Heterosporis spp.
Microsporidian
Fish
None
See text
a
Information provided is for wildlife species commonly eaten by humans. Some of these parasites also infect a wide range of other species. There are many parasites observed (some
of which are pathogenic for humans) in other wildlife species that generally are not eaten by humans with access to commercial sources of food.
Upland gamebirds = species such as wild turkey, grouse, pheasant, quail, and partridge.
Humans can become infested by some species of fly larvae following the deposition of eggs on the human body by adult flies.
Sarcoptic mange is most commonly seen in canids such as coyotes and foxes, species not commonly used by humans for food.
The most commonly seen and questioned internal parasites of wild game in North America are Sarcocystis spp. and
acanthocephalans in birds, the dog tapeworm in cottontail
rabbits, liver flukes in white-tailed deer, and cysticercosis
in moose. Lesions caused by other parasites are commonly
seen, but those parasites may be too small to be seen without
magnification or are not readily visible because of their locations within the host (Table 5.3).
Figure 5.10 (A) Fly larvae embedded in the tissues of a nestling cottontail rabbit, and (B) more mature larval stages (bots)
embedded in an adult cottontail.
C
B
Figure 5.11 Mange is a common disease of wildlife that affects numerous mammal species including the (A) gray squirrel,
(B) red fox, and (C) wolf.
Photos A and B, Milton Friend. Photo C, USGS National Wildlife Health Center file photo
Figure 5.14 (A) Large numbers of acanthocephalan parasites may be seen protruding from the intestine of some birds; (B)
these parasites attach to the inner surface of the intestine. Severe infections by some species, such as in this sea otter (C),
may be pathogenic for the animal.
Figure 5.17 The pale areas within the liver of this partridge
are due to histomoniasis, or blackhead.
Figure 5.18 The bladder-like structure (arrow) in the body cavity of this cottontail rabbit contains large numbers of cysticerci
(larvae) of the dog tapeworm. These larvae have also been found encysted in other parts of the body, (B) such as within the
fascia of the leg of this snowshoe rabbit and in its liver.
Photos by Ed Addison
Figure 5.19 (A) The large American liver fluke is a common parasite of white-tailed deer in some regions of the USA.
(B) Tissue damage to this organ can be extensive.
Figure 5.20 Larval forms of the tapeworm Taenia ovis krabbei are commonly found encysted in the muscle tissue of moose.
Viruses
Wildlife are affected by a broad spectrum of viral diseases.
However, in North America few of these diseases are likely
to be encountered by people harvesting wildlife for food.
Many of these diseases primarily occur in species not typically eaten by most people (e.g., small rodents) or the disease
has caused severe illness or death that makes the harvest of
infected animals unlikely.
Viral diseases that cause external tumors typically occur
infrequently, seldom are lethal, and are readily observed.
Cutaneous fibromas of deer are hairless tumors that hang from
the skin and generally are of no significance for the animal
unless their location interferes with sight or feeding (Fig.
5.23). These papillomas pose no health hazards for humans
and the meat from these animals is suitable for consumption.
Aggregations of tumors, or especially large tumors, often
become abraded, which then can allow infection by bacteria
and fungi. These animals should not be eaten.
contain Salmonella and other enteric pathogens, when processing game meat, it is important to avoid contamination of
meat by fecal material. In general, the presence of lesions on
internal organs suspected to be caused by infectious bacterial
diseases is reason to discard the carcass.
Brain abscesses are occasionally found by deer hunters,
but these lesions do not pose a health threat for humans and
should not result in disposal of the carcass. These abscesses
are thought to result from invasion by skin-inhabiting bacteria. They are much more prevalent in males than females,
often are associated with the antler pedicel, and generally
occur following velvet shedding to shortly after the antlers
are shed.20 Brain tissue from infected animals should be
discarded. Even if not infected, brain should no longer be
utilized in any foods because of the emergence of chronic
wasting disease (see Prions, this chapter).
Figure 5.22 Examples of visible evidence of infectious disease associated with some bacterial diseases of wildlife are:
(A) nodules along the rib cage of this white-tailed deer with
bovine tuberculosis; (B) numerous, small, yellow and white
spots on the liver of this beaver that died from tularemia; and
(C) hemorrhages on the heart of a goose that died from avian
cholera.
Table 5.4 Examples of potential bacterial infections in North American wildlife commonly harvested for human consumptiona
Disease
Pathogen
Primary
wildlife for
occurrence
Observations
Human
risks
Recommended action
Brucellosis
Yes
Brain abscessation
ActinomyDeer
ces spp.,
Staphylococcus spp.,
Streptococcus spp.
Yes
Dermatophilosis
Dermatophilus congolesis
Numerous;
deer to
rabbits
Yes
Tuberculosis
Mycobacterium bovis
Deer, elk,
bison
Yes
Avian tuberculosis
M. avium
Birds
Yes
Tularemia
Francisella
tularensis
Rabbits,
beaver,
muskrat
Yes
Furunculosis
Aeromonas
salmonicida
Troutb,
salmon
No
a
Information provided is for wildlife species commonly eaten by humans. Some of these bacteria also infect a wide range of other species. There are many bacteria observed (some of which are pathogenic for humans) in other wildlife species that generally are not eaten
by humans with access to commercial sources of food.
b
c
Classical disease produces boil-like lesions on skin and in muscle tissue; pathology varies widely with age of fish, type of disease
caused, and whether typical or atypical A. salmonicida infections are involved. 48
Prions
Prion diseases continue to be a relatively little understood
yet heavily studied group of emerging infectious diseases.
They include scrapie, a long existing sheep disease; bovine
spongiform encephalopathy (BSE) of cattle; Creutzfeld-Jacob
disease (CJD) and kuru of humans; a variant CJD (vCJD)
associated with BSE that causes disease in humans; mink
spongiform encephalopathy; and most recently chronic wasting disease (CWD) of deer and elk.30,31
CWD is of great concern to hunters and game ranchers
as it is ultimately fatal and affects several deer species (Fig.
5.28). Unlike the vCJD associated with BSE, no link has
been found between CWD and disease in humans. However,
because there are many unanswered questions about CWD,
Fungi
Wildlife may either become infected by fungal organisms,
such as Aspergillus spp. (Fig. 29), or they may be affected by
toxins produced by fungi (e.g., mycotoxins). Aspergillosis is
the most common fungal disease likely to be seen in birds and
is likely to be highly visible. Typically, infected birds have
yellow plaque-like lesions that have a cheesy appearance and
consistency and are found in the lungs and airsacs. Lesions
similar to bread mold also may be present.33 Severely infected
birds often are very thin and are likely to be discarded on this
Figure 5.29 The presence of cheesy plagues and the bread mold present on the surface of tissues within this Canada
goose is indicative of the fungal disease aspergillosis.
basis. The potential for human infection resulting from exposure to fungi present in the carcass is very low and properly
cooked meat would be safe to eat. Nevertheless, consumption
of these carcasses is not recommended.
Individuals harvesting mammalian wildlife may encounter superficial (skin) fungi that may or may not be involved
with skin lesions that appear as discrete round areas of scaling, crusting, and hair loss. Typically, these lesions appear
on the head and back, may result in depigmentation and a
thickening of the skin in areas of infection. These infections are commonly referred to as ringworm or tinea and,
medically, as dermatophytosis. Several genera of fungi are
involved. Microsporum spp. and Trichophyton spp. are the
most likely to be transmissible from animal to humans.34 Meat
from infected carcasses poses no known human health risks.
Human exposure is prevented by wearing protective gloves
when handling carcasses and hides.
Toxins
Wildlife may be exposed to a wide variety of toxins in
addition to infectious agents. These toxins may be of natural
(e.g., microbial) or synthetic (e.g., pesticides) origin. Rarely
will the carcass reveal any obvious signs that the animal had
been exposed to these toxins. Therefore, coverage of these
types of agents is beyond the scope for this chapter. Birds
clinically ill from diseases, such as avian botulism and aflatoxicosis (Fig. 5.30), may be seen in the field because the
time between intoxication and death often extends for several
days.35 Those concerned about natural and synthetic toxins
should avoid consuming wildlife that appear to be excessively
thin and, prior to harvesting wildlife, check with the state
Department of Natural Resources to determine if any health
advisories have been issued.
The type of food eaten is a personal choice. The popularity and high nutritional value of finfish and shellfish are
reflected in the rapid growth of aquaculture during recent
years, because wild stocks can no longer meet the demands
for those food items. Greater demands for venison, bison,
and other wildlife meats have resulted in substantial increases
in the captive-rearing of various wildlife as alternatives for
domestic species whose meat has higher fat and cholesterol
content (see Chapter 3, Fig. 3.18). From a human nutritional
perspective, wildlife often are a better choice than livestock
and poultry.
Within the USA, most game meat consumed is from
free-ranging rather than ranched wildlife. Emergence and
reemergence of infectious diseases in wildlife and other
species (see Chapters 2 and 3) continues to result in new
Literature Cited
1. Mennes, M.E., and Craven, S.R., 1992, Wisconsins wild
game: enjoying the harvest: Madison, Wis., University of
Wisconsin-Extension, Cooperative Extension Publication
B3573, 33 p.
2. Ruff, R.L., Covell, D.F., Nosek, J.A., and Craven, S.R.,
1993, A bibliography of cooperative extension service
literature on wildlife, fish and forest resources: Madison,
Wis., University of Wisconsin, 116 p.
3. Dowell, V.R., Jr., Gangarosa, E.J., and Armstrong, R.W.,
1970, Clinical and epidemiological aspects of botulism in
the United States, in Herzberg, M., ed., Proceedings of the
first U.S.-Japan conference on toxic micro-organisms, mycotoxins, botulism: Washington, D.C., U.S.-Japan Cooperative Program in Natural Resources and U.S. Department of
the Interior, p. 360364.
4. Sugiyama, H., Bott, T.L., and Foster, E.M., 1970, Clostridium botulinum type E in an inland bay (Green Bay of Lake
Michigan), in Herzberg, M., ed., Proceedings of the first
U.S.-Japan conference on toxic micro-organisms, mycotoxins, botulism: Washington, D.C., U.S.-Japan Cooperative
Program in Natural Resources and U.S. Department of the
Interior, p. 287291.
5. Smith, L.D.S., 1975, The pathogenic anaerobic bacteria:
Springfield, Ill., Charles C. Thomas, 430 p.
6. Todd, E.C.D., 1973, Seafood-associated diseases in
Canada: Journal of Association of Food and Drug Officials,
v. 56, p. 4552.
7. Friend, M. 1999, Lead, in Friend, M., and Franson, J.C.,
eds., Field manual of wildlife diseasegeneral field
procedures and diseases of birds: U.S. Geological Survey,
Information and Technology Report 1999001, p. 317334.
8. Baumann, P.C., Mac, M.J., Smith, S.B., and Harshbarger,
H.C., 1991, Tumor frequencies in walleye (Stizostedion vitreum) and brown bullhead (Ictalurus nebulosus) and sediment contaminants in tributaries of the Laurentian Great
Lakes: Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences,
v. 48, p. 18041810.
9. Baumann, P.C., Smith, I.R., and Metcalfe, C.D., 1996,
Linkages between chemical contaminants and tumors in
benthic Great Lakes fishes: Journal of Great Lakes Research, v. 22, p. 131152.
10. Colwell, D.D., 2001, Bot flies and warble flies (Order Diptera: Family Oestridae), in Samuel, W.M., Pybus, M.J., and
Kocan, A.A., eds., Parasitic diseases of wild mammals (2nd
ed.): Ames, Iowa, Iowa State University Press, p. 4671.
11. Bornstein, S., Mrner, T., and Samuel, W.M., 2001, Sarcoptes scabiei and sarcoptic mange, in Samuel, W.M., Pybus,
M.J., and Kocan, A.A., eds., Parasitic diseases of wild
mammals (2nd ed.): Ames, Iowa, Iowa State University
Press, p. 107119.
12. Hoffman, G.L., 1999, Parasites of North American freshwater fishes (2nd ed.): Ithaca, N.Y., Comstock Publishing
Associates, 539 p.
13. Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources, 2003, Heterosporis (yellow perch parasite), accessed June 28, 2004, at
URL http://www.dnr.state.wi.us/org/water/fhp/fish/health/
disease.htm
14. Lane, R.L., and Morris, J.E., 2000, Biology, prevention,
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
29.
30.
31.
32.
33.
34.
35.
36.
37.