Compressor Instrumentation PDF
Compressor Instrumentation PDF
WHEELER
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
1
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002
CONTENTS
PAGE
1.0
GENERAL
2.0
2.1
2.2
Pressure Controls
Anti-Surge Control
4
5
5
6
6
3.0
4.0
7
9
10
11
11
12
12
INSTRUMENTATION
13
4.1
13
13
14
14
15
16
4.2
4.3
5.0
Clearance Control
Inlet Valve Unloading
External Bypass
Throttling Control
Speed Control
Automatic Capacity Control
Controlling Suction Pressure
EXAMPLES
30
FOSTER
WHEELER
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
2
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002
CONTENTS
LIST OF FIGURES
FIGURE
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
FIGURE DESCRIPTION
PAGE
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
FOSTER
WHEELER
1.0
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
3
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002
GENERAL
The function of process control systems is to maintain yields and product quality by
holding certain operating variables at the desired values, and to return them to those
values after an upset. The operating variables concerned with compressors are
flowrate, temperature and pressure.
This standard presents ways in which the operating variables of centrifugal and
reciprocating compressors can be controlled. It deals only with situations that are
encountered most frequently by process engineers, and is devoted mainly toward
petroleum refining applications. Nevertheless, it may be used as a general
reference and a guide involving control of compressors.
The systems presented represent a starting point for the development of a proper
compressor control system, both for load and for the prevention of surge on
centrifugal or axial machines. Each application must be carefully considered as to
the details of the machine selected and its use in the process system.
FOSTER
WHEELER
2.0
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
4
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002
Pressure Controls
Pressure controls must be provided on both the suction and discharge to
maintain the required pressure levels and assure stable operation of the
compressor. Generally, one of the two pressures is set by process
requirements and is controlled elsewhere. The suction pressure is usually
controlled upstream of the compressor using a split range controller.
Controlling the suction pressure is an indirect way of controlling the capacity
and head output of the compressor and can be done by one of the following
two ways:
a)
b)
FOSTER
WHEELER
2.2
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
5
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002
Anti-Surge Control
Anti-surge control systems for centrifugal compressors are provided to
protect the machine from damage caused by pulsations in flow or surge.
Surge is an unstable, pulsating condition that can occur when a compressor
is improperly operated. If the flowrate decreases to the compressor, the
compression ratio (Pd/Pi) will increase to a point where a momentary flow
reversal occurs within the machine. Surge is detected by an audible boom,
piping vibrations and pressure pulsations.
The anti-surge control system maintains a minimum flow through the
compressor at a value safely away from the surge point. A typical
compressor performance curve is illustrated in Figure 2. The anti-surge
control system maintains the compressor operation in the safe operating
zone by allowing some gas to be recycled from the discharge back into the
suction which increases the flow through the compressor. The recycled gas
must be cooled before it flows to the compressor suction. This type of antisurge control is normally applied to closed processes such as gas plant or
refrigeration system compressors.
2.2.1 Minimum Flow Anti-surge Control
The anti-surge control system shown in Figure 3 consists of a single
flow controller which can be located either on the compressor suction
or discharge line (discharge is preferred to minimize power
consumption). A fixed minimum flow through the compressor is
maintained by varying the flow through the anti-surge valve. In Figure
4, the vertical control line represents the fixed minimum flowrate. If a
turbine driven compressor is normally operating at point A, no
recirculation is required. If at turndown conditions, the net flowrate to
the compressor is at point B, the anti-surge valve will open and
recirculation will be established until flow is maintained at point C.
Air compressors which take suction from the atmosphere do not
require any recirculation of gas to the suction. An anti-surge control
scheme for this type of service is shown in Figure 5. The air supply to
the compressor is measured and maintained at a fixed rate above the
surge point. If the demand flow approaches the surge rate, the vent
control valve is opened and excess air is vented to the atmosphere.
FOSTER
WHEELER
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
6
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002
FOSTER
WHEELER
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
3.0
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
7
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002
Clearance Control
Clearance Control is based on the fact that the greater the clearance volume
in a cylinder end, the lower will be the volumetric efficiency of that end and,
therefore, the lower the cylinder output.
Volumetric efficiency is the ratio of the actual delivered capacity to the piston
displacement and is expressed by:
VE = C - CL (r 1/k -1)
Where:
VE
C
=
=
CL
r
k
=
=
FOSTER
WHEELER
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
8
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002
During compression the piston does not travel to the end of the cylinder but
leaves a clearance volume. Clearance control operates simply by increasing
cylinder clearance over the normal volume by means of clearance pockets.
These pockets may be either fixed or variable volume and can be located as
follows:
a)
One or two separate pockets built into the head end of the cylinder
head, which are usually limited in volume to about 20% of the total
cylinder swept volume.
b)
FOSTER
WHEELER
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
9
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002
It should be noted that this sketch showing 4 pockets per cylinder is for
illustration purposes only. Due to the large volume usually required for
clearance pockets and other mechanical limitations, the number of pockets
which can be built into a cylinder of a typical process compressor is usually
limited to two. Generally more than two pockets may be mechanically and
economically feasible only for small air compressors. A combination of
control methods may sometimes be employed to obtain the required capacity
regulation.
Clearance control method provides efficient operation since the energy
required for compression of the gas in the clearance pockets is returned in
the re-expansion step with little power loss. There are some limitations and
disadvantages. Clearance volumes must be built into the machine and will
provide design capacity reduction only when operating at the design
compression ratio. This limits its flexibility in alternate services. Also, if
condensate is present it may accumulate in the pockets and result in possible
slugging problems or introduce a corrosion problem if the liquid is corrosive.
3.2
FOSTER
WHEELER
3.1
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
10
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002
Two double acting cylinders are used for one compression stage.
Inlet valve unloading in combination with another method of control
such as clearance pockets.
External Bypass
External bypass is a relatively simple and smooth acting control method. If a
process review indicates the need for bypassing significant quantities of gas,
a cooler and KO drum will be necessary to prevent excessively high
discharge temperatures. This should be checked by determining the blend
FOSTER WHEELER ENERGY LIMITED 2002
FOSTER
WHEELER
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
11
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002
Throttling Control
Capacity reduction with this method is obtained by throttling the intake flow
by means of a valve. The BHP per unit gas volume as well as the discharge
temperatures increase. This method of control is used in a few special
applications, generally vacuum services or very small compressors. For
large size machines, the suction valve cannot always give tight enough shutoff to permit unloading during start-up.
3.5
Speed Control
This is an ideal means for controlling the capacity of a reciprocating
compressor. Since variable speed drivers are required, internal combustion
and steam engines are indicated although turbines and motors coupled with
speed reducers have been used. The table below indicates the possible
speed variation of various drivers.
DRIVERS
SPEED VARIATION
Induction Motors
Synchronous Motors
Steam Engine
Steam Turbines
Combustion Gas Turbines
Integral Gas Engine
Integral Diesel. Engine
Coupled Gas or Diesel
Engine
Constant
Constant
20 - 100%
25 - 100%*
55 - 100%
60 - 100%*
60 - 100%*
60 - 100%*
FOSTER
WHEELER
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
12
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002
On-Off
On-off control is generally used with compressor storage drum combinations
under conditions of intermittent demand. Electric motors are mostly used in
this service and since these have a limited permissible number of starts per
hour without overheating, the storage or surge capacity must be adequately
specified.
3.6
3.7
FOSTER
WHEELER
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
4.0
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
13
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002
INSTRUMENTATION
4.1
High and low pressure alarms on the inlet suction line (control room).
Very low inlet suction pressure alarm (control room).
Suction drum high level alarm (control room).
Suction drum very high level alarm (control room).
Pressure indicator and controller on inlet suction line.
Pressure indicator on each discharge line (local and control room)
Pressure indicator on each suction line (local).
Temperature indicator on each discharge line (local and control room).
Temperature indicator on each suction line (local and control room).
High discharge temperature alarm on each stage (control room).
Very high discharge temperature alarm on each stage (control room).
Flow indicator for each anti-surge recycle line (control room).
FOSTER
WHEELER
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
14
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002
FOSTER
WHEELER
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
15
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002
A safety relief valve must also be provided for knockout drums. The
set pressure must be consistent with the discharge relief valve. The
discharge drum may be protected by a relief valve on downstream
equipment as long as there is no block valve between the relief valve
and the drum.
Centrifugal compressors do not require discharge relief valves
however, the knockout drums will require their own relief valves. The
compressor casing and lines are designed for the maximum discharge
pressure at surge (maximum suction pressure plus head at surge).
Sometimes a small relief valve is provided to protect the casing if high
pressure nitrogen is used for purging.
4.2
Service
Oil Cooler Inlet and Outlet
Differential Pressure Across Oil Filter
Water Inlet & Outlet of each Oil Cooler
Gas Engine Driver Inlet Manifold
CW Inlet and Outlet of Gas Engine
Gas Engine Exhaust
Pressure
Indication
Temperature
Indication
X
X
X
X
X
X
Instrument
FOSTER
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
16
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002
WHEELER
4.3
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
In typical 100 psig service, monitors which activate lights and alarms may
also shutdown the compressor. A typical panel will have the following:
Condition
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Lights
Alarm
Shutdown
6.
7.
8.
Excessive vibration
9.
In addition, an hour meter (10,000 hr range) which registers only when the
unit is running will provide information that facilitates sound maintenance
(optional).
FOSTER
WHEELER
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
17
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002
FOSTER
WHEELER
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
18
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002
FOSTER
WHEELER
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
19
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002
FOSTER
WHEELER
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
20
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002
FIGURE 4
MINIMUM FLOW ANTI-SURGE CONTROL CURVE
FOSTER
WHEELER
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
21
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002
FOSTER
WHEELER
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
22
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002
FOSTER
WHEELER
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
23
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002
% INLET FLOW
FIGURE 7
FLOW/DIFFERENTIAL PRESSURE ANTI-SURGE CONTROL CURVE
FOSTER
WHEELER
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
24
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002
FOSTER
WHEELER
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
25
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002
FOSTER
WHEELER
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
26
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002
FOSTER
WHEELER
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
27
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002
FOSTER
WHEELER
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
28
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002
FOSTER
WHEELER
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
29
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002
FOSTER
WHEELER
5.0
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
30
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002
EXAMPLES
The figures in this section show typical compressor services and their control
systems. It is not meant to contain all possible schemes and they are not the only
ones that can be used. This section is provided as a quick reference and guide
when specifying control systems on Process Flow Diagrams, P&IDs, sketches, etc.
FOSTER
WHEELER
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
31
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002
FOSTER
WHEELER
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
32
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002
FOSTER
WHEELER
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
33
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002
FOSTER
WHEELER
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
34
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002
FOSTER
WHEELER
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
35
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002
FOSTER
WHEELER
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
36
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002
FOSTER
WHEELER
INSTRUMENTATION
COMPRESSORS
PROCESS STD
509
PAGE
37
REV
10
DATE
JULY 2002