Using Comics in The Development of EFL R
Using Comics in The Development of EFL R
Usi
ngComi
csi
nt
heDevel
opmentof
EFLReadi
ngandWr
i
t
i
ng
Cl
audeAndr
eDr
ol
et
SungKyul University
Abst
r
act
Reading comprehension research tells us that second language students
should be working with authentic materials as much as possible.
Moreover, it has been recommended that teachers include extensive
reading of authentic material in their writing classes. It follows that
ESL teachers have to find ways to connect the English classroom literacy
practices to the real world. This is particularly important in EFL settings
where realistic samples of everyday language are sorely needed. A
strong method to encourage reading is the use of popular texts such
as comic strips. Comic books and strips have been suggested as classroom
material due to their broad appeal to almost any age group or learner
level because they depict real dialogue and culture. Students enjoy
the simple style and amusing characters, while at the same time get
proven practice in their reading skills. Comic books and strips can
act as an intervening step to more difficult ideas: their use can scaffold
to more difficult disciplines outside of language arts. This paper presents
four methods of using comic strips in the teaching of reading and
writing. These sorts of lessons are adaptable to students of various
levels, but within this paper specific levels are targeted.
Keywords: Comic books, Reading, Writing, Authentic materials
I
.I
nt
r
oduct
i
on
Most reading authorities agree that students should be working with
authentic materials as much as possible. For learning to be effective
and permanent, the students must have material that is meaningful
I
I
.Pr
i
orResear
ch
A review of the pertinent literature supports the use of comics in
the Language Arts classroom. Current research has shown that in the
reading of comic books more advanced cognitive abilities are needed
to understand the interplay of text and image than in the case of traditional
text on its own (Schwarz, 2002). Versaci (2001) found that comics are
more likely to encourage students to participate in discussions on comic
books than with more accepted forms of traditional literature. Indeed,
in a survey of teachers using comics in their Language Arts classrooms,
Annett (2008) showed that students, being familiar with the form and
style of comics, are more engaged with the material and were more able
to discuss the texts than with traditional text books. Furthermore, comics
can act as an intervening step to more difficult ideas (Yang, 2003) and
so comics have been suggested as a model to be used to help students
develop their writing skills, especially of story writing (Cary, 2004).
Unfortunately, there has not been a great deal of research into the
use of comics in ESL or EFL settings. Williams (1995) described his
usage of comic strips in an intensive ESL course and found that the
strips were a good medium to demonstrate common aspects of spoken
English. Norton and Vanderheyden (2003) looked at ESL students in
Vancouver, and the appeal of Archie Comics. They found that students
would form peer groups that would trade the comics amongst themselves,
and in so doing would discuss the comics in English. Furthermore, they
contend that using comics in ESL classes is beneficial in all four aspects
of language learning. This is supported by research done by Mangubhai
(2001) with Fijian Elementary school students. In a study on the impact
of non-traditional literature, including comic books, Mangubhai found
that students who read for a short time every day over an eight month
period had marked improvement in reading and listening comprehension.
More interestingly, after twenty months they found that daily reading
of comic books also had positive effects on writing and speaking.
More recently Liu (2004) found that comics were an effective material
for improving reading comprehension for second language learners.
He looked at high and low level ESL learners at a university in the
United States and showed that the use of comic strips greatly helped
low-level students. Ranker (2007) also looked at the use of comics
as reading material for ESL students and found that they help English
language learners with both reading and writing.
I
I
I
.Lesson Pl
ansf
orUsi
ng Comi
cSt
r
i
psi
n
EFL Set
t
i
ngs
This paper presents four methods of using comic strips in the teaching
of reading and writing. These sorts of lessons are adaptable to students
of various levels, but within this paper specific levels, child, adolescent,
teen and young adult, are targeted.
Process
Students should each be given a copy of some comic strips, Peanuts
(available at http://comics.com/) for example, that have examples of
reported speech. Then the teacher tells the students that they will be
reading these comics, but before reading they will talk about a few
things. The teacher then asks the students a few leading questions to
activate prior knowledge about:
Daily newspaper strips in general and Peanuts characters in particular
Children and their daily lives (school, sports and other activities)
Cleaning supplies
The students then do a quick reading of the strips to get a basic
idea of the contents. When they are finished, the teacher explains or
gives definitions of the difficult vocabulary words.
The teacher will then ask the students to tell what he/she had said.
Then the teacher explains that what they are doing is reported speech:
they are reporting what another person said. Explain that in reported
speech generally, we change the pronouns and that the tense jumps
back. Demonstrate an example on the board:
Anxious means a feeling of discomfort or
You said that anxious meant
Then have the students go back to the strips and underline all of
the incidences of reported speech and write down who originally said
the reported speech (Ophthalmologist, Teacher, etc). Some class discussion should then focus on why writers of comic strips would use
reported speech and what functions this type of discourse serves in
writing or every day speech. For example:
To report what someone said in the past.
To report what someone thinks.
To report a piece of advice.
Continue the lesson by asking the students to practice some reported
speech with each other in groups of three. One student says something
and the second repeats it to the third.
Following the practice drill, give each student a copy of some other
strips, potentially Calvin and Hobbes or Garfield. Explain that they
are to use this handout to help them practice using reported speech.
For each panel they should write down who spoke and what the character
said. Allow students to work individually or in pairs. Encourage discussion
and sharing of what is being said in the strips. The teacher should
circulate among the students to monitor progress, provide support in
writing, and to assess their understanding of reported speech.
Extensions
Take some of the sample strips and blank out the speech balloons,
then using an overhead projector, have students tell the class the
dialogue.
This lesson can easily be adapted for adult learners by using
more complex adult oriented strips, for example Doonsebury,
Shoe, and For Better or For Worse (all available at http://www.
gocomics. com/features)
Process
The teacher will give each student a copy of the some strips, ideally
with well defined characters like Garfield or Calvin and Hobbs, and
tell the students that they will be reading these comics. However, before
reading you will want to talk about a few things. Ask the students
leading questions to activate prior knowledge about character traits
and physical descriptions.
The students then do a quick reading of the strips to get a basic
idea of the contents. When they are finished, explain or give definitions
of the difficult vocabulary words. Then ask the students to tell you
what they think of each character. Asking questions such as:
Who do you like?
How would you describe character X?
Students then write down a list of the characters in the strips and
then a list of the descriptive adjectives they can see in the strips. Once
they have a complete list, the students make small groups and discuss
the strips. They can ask and answer these or similar questions:
Who is your favourite character? Why?
Who do you dislike? Why?
Who is the funniest?
Which character are you similar to?
Which character is similar to someone you know?
Once they have completed the discussion, the students can practice
using the adjectives to write descriptions of themselves and their family
members.
The teacher then gives each student a copy of some other strips,
perhaps Peanuts, and explains that they will use this handout to help
them practice writing character descriptions. For each character they
should:
Write a short list of descriptive adjectives.
Then write a short descriptive paragraph for each character.
Give students time for their descriptions. Allow students to work
individually or in pairs. Encourage discussion and sharing of what is
being written. Circulate among the students to monitor progress and
provide support in writing.
Extension
Have some students read aloud their character descriptions and
have other students guess who is being spoken about.
For adult learners, political cartoons featuring well known politicians
and public figures could be used. Either western cartoons with
world famous figures (available at http://www.gocomics.com/explore/editorials0), or regionally focused political cartoons featuring
prominent local figures (for example http://joongangdaily. joins.com/article/list.asp?cat_code=010401).
Process
Students should first be given a copy of some sample strips. A
number of Calvin and Hobbs Sunday strips are very good for this
sort of activity as they are without dialogue. Tell the students that
they will be reading these comics but that they will have to use visual
clues to help them understand the story.
After the students have done a quick reading of the strips to get
a basic idea of the contents, as a class, discuss one of the strips, asking
students to describe the scene and then explain what is happening in
each panel. Students should be encouraged to suggest what each character
is saying in the comic. Once the class has gone through one strip
as a group, the students should then form pairs and take turns to tell
each other the stories in the other strips.
As the students speak, the teacher can write down on the board
some transitional words and phrases: Then, next, after that, as soon
as, first, second, etc. Point out to the students how they can use the
words to put the story in sequence.
After the students have had chance to go through a few strips,
the teacher will hand out the Story Map sheets (See Appendix). The
teacher can choose one of the strips and work together with the class
to fill in the information.
Ask students to choose one of the other strips to story map for
themselves. As the students fill in the information, circulate through
the class and help as needed. Finally, give each student a copy of
the Comic Strip Mapping Sheet (Appendix) and explain that they are
to use this handout to help them write out the story they had just
mapped. For each panel, they should write down the scene, who is
involved, what happened, and anything the characters might have said.
Give students enough time to work on their mapping sheets. Allow
students to work individually or in pairs. Encourage discussion and
sharing of what is being written about the strips. Circulate among the
students to monitor progress, provide support in writing, and to assess
their use of transitional words.
Extensions
Have some students tell the class their story.
For more advanced students or adults a series of daily strips could
be used. For example the Calvin and Hobbes sequence titled Attack
of the Killer Snow Goons published daily from December 31st
1990 to January 19th 1991. Elements of fiction, such as plot, pacing
and irony can then be brought into the classroom discussion.
Process
Each student needs a copy of appropriate strips. A good example
could be Peanuts comic strips that ran between January 5th and 20th,
1972 (available online at http://comics.com/peanuts#). In this strip, one
character, Peppermint Patty, becomes subject to a new school dress
code. She attempts to fight the dress code and engages a lawyer to
help her.
The students should be told that they will be reading these comics,
but before reading, they should talk about a few things. Ask the students
leading questions to activate prior knowledge about:
The students read through the strips and then discuss as a class
what happened in the story. The students then write down some pros
and cons of having a school dress code. Once they have completed
the task, have the students form groups to discuss the issues in the
strips, answering questions like:
Did your elementary, middle or high school have a dress code?
What sort of dress code?
What do you think of having a dress code?
Do you think there would be a problem with letting students
dress as they like?
Does a dress code cause any problems?
Should we have a dress code at the university?
Is there such a thing as inappropriate dress in university?
The second part of the lesson involves talking about how a person
could express their opinion on social issues like a school dress code:
To address the Student Counsel
To address the Parent Teacher Association
To write a letter to the editor of a local paper
After some discussion, explain that the students will be writing
a letter to express their opinion on school dress codes. The teacher
should review the form of a letter on the board. Then give students
enough time in class to write a first draft of their letter to the editor.
Circulate among the students to monitor progress and provide support
in writing.
Extension
Take some of the sample letters, remove any identifying information,
and make copies to distribute to the class for peer editing.
I
V.Concl
usi
on
Reading is more important than ever. For a person to be successful
in the future, he or she will have to be familiar with many types of
input, from TV to textbooks. Students need to read in order to improve
as readers, and further, to enable them to become better writers. Providing
students with authentic engaging texts will not only promote extensive
reading, it will also provide real-life language that is often missing
from the classroom. A strong method to encourage reading is the use
of popular texts such as comic strips. The use of comics has been
shown to compliment the acquisition of effective comprehension
strategies.
Almost all definitions of literacy include the key components of
communication and expression. As research has shown, the comic strip
format provides a powerful combination of discursive skills, artistic
creativity and expression; its use can scaffold to more difficult disciplines
outside of the language classroom. This paper has outlined a variety
of methods using comic strips in EFL settings. The use of comics
has been suggested as a model to be used to help students develop
their writing skills. Moreover, students enjoy the simple style and amusing
characters, while at the same time get proven practice in their reading
and writing skills.
Ref
er
ences
Annet, D. (2008). Implementing graphic texts into the language arts
classroom. Minnesota English Journal, 44, 150-179.
Anstey, M. (2002). New times, new literacies. Literate Futures, 1-12.
Retrieved from http://education.qld.gov.au/curriculum/learning/
literate-futures/pdfs/reading-part2.pdf
Bitz, M. (2004). The comic book project: Forging alternative pathways
to literacy. Journal of Adolescent & Adult Literacy, 47(1), 574-586.
Bryan, G., Chilcoat, G. W., & Morrison, T.G. (2002). Pow! Zap! Wham!
Creating comic books from picture books in social studies
classrooms. Canadian Social Studies, 37(1), Retrieved from
http://www.quasar.ualberta.ca/css/Css_37_1/FTcomics_in_social_
studies.htm
Cary, S. (2004). Going graphic. Portsmouth: Heinemann.
Combs, J. (2003). Creating comics: Visual and verbal thinking in the
ultimate show and tell. PhD Thesis. College of William and Mary.
Retrieved from
http://www.wm.edu/education/599/pdffiles/combsproject.pdf
Davis, R. S. (1997). Comics: A multi-dimensional teaching aid in
integrated-skills classes. Retrieved from http://www.esl-lab.com
/research/comics.htm
Dardess, G. (1995). Review: Bringing comic books to class. College
English, 57(2), 213-222.
Elley, W., Cutting, B., Mangbhai, F. & Hugo, C. (1996). Lifting literacy
levels with story books: Evidence from the South Pacific, Singapore,
Sri Lanka and South Africa. Paper presented at the World Conference
on Literacy, Philadelphia, PA. Retrieved from http://www.literacy.
org/products/ili/pdf/ilprocwe.pdf
Frodesen, J. (2001). Grammar in writing. In M. Celce-Murcia (Ed.),
Teaching English as a second or foreign language(3rd ed.) (pp.
233-248). Boston: Heinle & Heinle.
Gardill, M.C., & Jitendra, A. K. (1999). Advanced story map instruction:
Effects on the reading comprehension of students with learning
disabilities. The Journal of Special Education, 33(1), 2-17.
Grabe, W. (2004). Research on teaching reading. Annual Review of
Applied Linguistics, 24, 44-69.
Hadley, A. O. (2000). Teaching language in context(3rd ed.). Boston:
Thomson.
Kroll, B. (2001). Considerations for teaching an ESL/EFL writing Course.
In M. Celce-Murcia (Ed.), Teaching English as a second or foreign
language(3rd ed.) (pp. 219-232). Boston: Heinle & Heinle.
Received: 2010-9-14
Peer reviewed: 2010-11-24
Accepted: 2010-12-14
Appendix
Story Map
Name:
Date:
Major Characters:
Minor Characters:
Plot/Problem:
Event 1:
Outcome:
Event 2:
Event 3:
Characters
Present
Caption/Narration
Dialogue