Syracuse University

SURFACE
Architecture Senior Theses

School of Architecture Dissertations and Theses

Spring 5-2016

Memory + Architecture | The Act of Forgetting

Mariel Mora Llorens

Follow this and additional works at: http://surface.syr.edu/architecture_theses

Part of the Architectural History and Criticism Commons, Architectural Technology Commons,
Cultural Resource Management and Policy Analysis Commons, Historic Preservation and
Conservation Commons, and the Urban, Community and Regional Planning Commons
Recommended Citation
Mora Llorens, Mariel, "Memory + Architecture | The Act of Forgetting" (2016). Architecture Senior Theses. Paper 344.
http://surface.syr.edu/architecture_theses/344

This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the School of Architecture Dissertations and Theses at SURFACE. It has been accepted for
inclusion in Architecture Senior Theses by an authorized administrator of SURFACE. For more information, please contact [email protected].

MEMORY + ARCHITECTURE
THE ACT OF FORGETTING

MARIEL MORA LLORENS

THESIS ADVISOR: KYLE MILLER

ABSTRACT
This thesis proposes the activation and
repurposing of buildings associated
with traumatic memories as a means of
studying the ways in which architecture
embodies memories and aids in the
process of forgetting. Architecture
and the built environment are linked
to the creation and recollection of
memories because they trigger four
of the senses that are related to
memory.
To forget is an active, not passive
endeavor. Conscious forgetting is
not an act of erasing memories, but
transforming them by removing
the emotional responses that are
produced by our recollection of
these memories. Like memories in
our brains, buildings that have been
recognized as sites of traumatic
events are held back in an endless
cycle of recollection and repression
of memories.
Opposed to demolition, this thesis
explores the historic, material
and structural value of sites of
traumatic memory. Specifically, this
thesis proposes the activation and
repurposing of the Genbaku Dome
and The Peace Memorial Park.
This thesis proposes to retroactively
redesign the Hiroshima Peace Memorial
Park as an episodic overlapping of
architectural
and
infrastructural
interventions that represent the
stages of acknowledgement, grief,
remembrance
and
conscious
forgetting. Rather than proposing
a monumental or static memorial,

the project takes and evolving/

transformative approach to sites of
memories, influenced by methods of
temporality and ritual in traditional
Japanese architecture.
In the redesign of the Hiroshima Peace
Memorial Park, episodic overlapping
of architectural and infrastructural
interventions occurs over a period of
50 years. Each episode occurs within
a 10-year period and is characterized
by the addition and overlapping of
specific formal interventions that
challenge the ways in which the
users inhabit the city. These five
interventions are carving, bridging,
framing, enclosing and programing.
They work at different scales within a
500-meter radius of the hypocenter
of the atomic bomb.

TABLE OF CONTENT

01. Japan + Memory

02. Architecture + Trauma
03. Architecture + Memory
04. Episode 1: Unveil
05. Episode 2: Traverse
06. Episode 3: Contemplate
07. Episode 4: Inhabit

01

Japan + Memory
The creation and recollection of memories

500

600

Ise Shrine
700

800

900

1000

1100

1200

1300

Kinkakuji: Golden Pavilion

1400

Ryoan-Ji
1500

Itsukushima Shrine
Himeji Castle

Nijo Castle

1600

1700

1800

Kaichi Primary School Rokumrikan

1900

Hiroshima Peace Memorial Park

2000

Japan: History + Architecture

ASUKA PERIOD (538-710)
The arrival of Buddhism from China set forth significant social, political and artistic transformations. Shinto
had been the native religion for many centuries.

NARA PERIOD (710-794)

Elements of Buddhism were incorporated into Shintoism and the design of many Temples. Agricultural society centered on the worship of natural elements.

HEIAN PERIOD (794-1185)

Period of stability, considered to be the peak of Japanese imperial court. Capital moved to modern day
Kyoto. Return to local styles of architecture in temples, palaces and dwellings.

KAMAKURA PERIOD (1185-1333)

Period after Genpei War. The war led to the destruction of many traditional buildings in Nara and Kyoto.
Technological advances in building methods as a response to nature requirements such as earthquakes
resistant and shelter against heavy rainfall.

MURIOMACHI PERIOD (1336-1573)

Period after Genpei War. The war led to the destruction of many traditional buildings in Nara and Kyoto.
Technological advances in building methods as a response to nature requirements such as earthquakes
resistant and shelter against heavy rainfall.

MOMOYAMA PERIOD (1568-1603)

Period of unification after civil war. Rebuilding of castles as a symbol of political stability.

EDO PERIOD (1603-1868)

Rise of the Tokugawa shogunate. Period of relative peace and political unity. Shogun took control of the
country. The emperor lost power and became a symbolic, religious figure. A process of militarization of
Japan occurred along with a division of class system. Prohibited contact with the west.
Bakufu Code: ceremonial set of guidelines to live by based on nostalgic views of feudal Japan.
Development of pleasure houses as a way to escape from social norms

MEIJI PERIOD (1868-1912)

End of Tokugawa Shonugate. The Meiji Restoration restored power of the emperor and opened trade with
the west. Militarization process under the emperor Meiji. Bakufu Code: ceremonial set of guidelines to live
by based on nostalgic views of feudal Japan. Development of pleasure houses as a way to escape from
social norms

Hiroshima: Militarization + Post War Era

EDO PERIOD

1800

(1603-1868)

MEIJI PERIOD
(1868-1912)

Sanjo Railway
8

1900

Hiroshima Prefectural Exhibition Hall

Colonial Architecture

TAISHO PERIOD

10

World War I

(1912-1926)

Bunriha:Modern Architects Organization

SHOWA PERIOD

(1926-1989)
4

9
7

World War II
American Occupation

Hiroshima Peace Memorial Park

Metabolism

HEISEI PERIOD
(1989-PRESENT)

Lost Decade

2000

10

NIPPON EXPRESS DESHIO WAREHOUSE

HIROSHIMA TEISHA HOSPITAL

CHUGOKU REGIONAL MILITARY HEADQUARTERS

FUKUYAMA DEPARTMENT STORE

FUKUROMACHI ELEMENTARY SCHOOL

HONKAWA ELEMENTARY SCHOOL

BANK OF JAPAN HIROSHIMA BRANCH

IMPERIAL BANK HIROSHIMA BRANCH

FUEL HALL

GENBAKU DOME

Hiroshima: Prewar Buildings

NIPPON EXPRESS DESHIO WAREHOUSE
Distance from Hypocenter: 2,670M
Year Built: 1913
Original Use: clothes depot for military uniforms
Material: brick
Significance during the War: temporary aid station
Current Use: Storage / Hiroshima University Dorms

HIROSHIMA TEISHA HOSPITAL

Distance from Hypocenter: 1,370M
Year Built: 1935
Original Use: Teisha Clinic
Material: reinforced concrete
Significance during the War: one of two hospitals within
the hypocenter that remained active after the bomb
Current Use: Teishin Hospital / Post Office

CHUGOKU REGIONAL MILITARY HEADQUARTERS

Distance from Hypocenter: 1,370M
Year Built: 1935
Original Use: Teisha Clinic
Material: reinforced concrete
Significance during the War: one of two hospitals within
the hypocenter that remained active after the bomb
Current Use: Teishin Hospital / Post Office

FUKUYAMA DEPARTMENT STORE

Distance from Hypocenter: 710M
Year Built: 1938
Original Use: Taishoya Kimono Shop
Material: reinforced concrete and glass
Significance during the War: Temporary infectious-disease
hospital
Current Use: Fukuyama Department Store

FUKUROMACHI ELEMENTARY SCHOOL

Distance from Hypocenter: 410M
Year Built: 1928
Original Use: Honkawa Elementary School
Material: reinforced concrete
Significance during the War:
Current Use: Museum / School

HONKAWA ELEMENTARY SCHOOL

Distance from Hypocenter: 410M
Year Built: 1928
Original Use: Honkawa Elementary School
Material: reinforced concrete
Significance during the War:
Current Use: Museum / School

BANK OF JAPAN HIROSHIMA BRANCH

Distance from Hypocenter: 380M
Year Built: 1936
Original Use: Bank of Japan
Material: reinforced concrete and glass
Significance during the War: Resumed operations 2 days
after the Bomb
Current Use: Cultural Center

IMPERIAL BANK HIROSHIMA BRANCH

Distance from Hypocenter:360M
Year Built:
Original Use: Imperial Bank
Material: reinforced concrete
Significance during the War: Temporary operations begun
after the bomb
Current Use: Anderson Bakery / Restaurant

FUEL HALL
Distance from Hypocenter: 170M
Year Built: 1929
Original Use: Taishoya Kimono Shop
Material: reinforced concrete and glass
Significance during the War: Hiroshima Prefecture Fuel
Rationing Union
Current Use: Peace Memorial Park Rest House

GENBAKU DOME
Distance from Hypocenter: 160M
Year Built: 1915 - Jan Letzel
Original Use: products exhibition hall
Material: concrete, brick, steel and glass
Significance during the War: closest building to ground zero
Current Use: Hiroshima Peace Memorial

A-Bomb: Radius of Impact

A-Bomb: Timeline of Effects

Hiroshima + The Collective Memory

Victims of The Atomic Bomb

1st GENERATION: HIBAKUSHA

Survivors of the Atomic Bomb, living within the city of Hiroshima
Born before August 6, 1945

2nd GENERATION:
Born during the reconstruction of the city of Hiroshima

3rd GENERATION:
Born after the reconstruction of the city of Hiroshima

4th GENERATION:
No direct contact to the 1st generation, the Hibakusha

VISITORS / TOURISM
Dark Tourism, Black Tourism, Grief Tourism

02

Architecture + Trauma

Forgetting as an Active Endeavor

Forgetting
The apparent loss or

modification

of information

already encoded and stored in an individual's long term

memory. It is a spontaneous or

gradual process

in which old memories are unable to be recalled from

memory storage.

"To forget is an active, not a passive, endeavor."

- Dr. Clarissa Pinkoles Estes

Intervention + Activation
Modification as a Gradual Process
PROCESS OF FORGETTING

recollection

repression

remembrance transformation
of memories

acknowledgement
FORGETTING

This thesis proposes a gradual process of modification

of buildings and landscapes as an act of conscious
forgetting. These modification relate to the different
stages of forgetting; acknowledgement, remembrance
and transformation of memories.

Form of Absence

GENBAKU DOME

CAST

VOID

VOID

FIELD

The Observer + The Observed

Narrative Form

Surviving Buildings
Sites of Memory
Primary Momument Axis
Proposed Axis

AXIS I
2,930 m
2,750 m

1,270 m
410 m
150 m
0m
710 m

Kosaiji Temple

Renshoji Temple

Plane Trees

Honkuwa Elementary Sc
Genbaku Dome

Ground Zero

Fukuyama Department S

AXIS II
5,000 m

1,770 m
150 m
0m
1370 m

Ebisu Shrine

Camphot Tree and Kurogane

Genbaku Dome

Ground Zero

Japanese Black Pine and Gink

2,100 m

Toshogu Shrine

150 m

Genbaku Dome

AXIS III
0m
380 m
460 m

2670 m

2,100 m

Ground Zero

Bank of Japan Hiroahim

Kurogane Holly

Fukuro-machi Elementa

Nippon Express Deshio

Saishoji Temple

The conceptual strategy of narrative form proposes an urban Intervention, a

pilgrimage to the Genbaku dome. It proposes a new axis that defines spaces
between the different zones of impact of the atomic bomb. This intervention
is focused on creating spaces of reflection and remembrance for the first and
second generation of survivors of the atomic bomb. The axis are defined by
buildings that survived the atomic bomb and served as temporary relief stations
and places of memory during the reconstruction of the city of Hiroshima.

2 MILES
1.5 MILES

1 MILE
.5 MILES

This intervention acknowledges that the survivors of the atomic bomb were
outside the hypocenter therefore their places of memory are scattered
around the city. The survivors remember the direction of the physical impact
from the hypocenter. Framing devises are used to mark the axis and buildings
of memory. By decentralizing the space of remembrance, the visitors are
able to experience the process of acknowledgement in remembrance in
a subtler and individual way. This is a strategy to contrast the constant over
memorialization of sites of memory as methods of commercialization.

2 MILES
1.5 MILES

1 MILE
.5 MILES

03

Architecture + Memory
The Act of Forgetting

The Process of Forgetting

short term

episodic

explicit

emotions encoding

long term

semantic

implicit

sensory
storing of
memories
and their
emotional
reaction in
the brain

TRAUMATIC EVENT

recollection and
repression of
memories as a
result of retrieval
ques

MEMORIES

as a coping
mechanis

recollection

repression

remembrance

transformation
of memories

acknowledgement
of emotional
impact

PROCESS OF FORGETTING

erasing of
emotional
impact

FORGETTING

Rethinking the Memorial Site

500 Meter Radius
Peace Memorial
Park

1985: EPISODE 1

500 Meter Radius

Carving

UNIVEIL

1995: EPISODE 2

Bridging

TRAVERSE

2005: EPISODE 3

Framing

CONTEMPLATE

2015: EPISODE 4

Inhabiting

INHABIT

2025: EPISODE 5

TRANSCEND

Reprogram

Existing Site: 2015

Proposed Interventions: 2015

Pre War Site: 1940

04

Episode 1: Univeil
to remove covering from to expose to reveal to present
to display to allow for public view in a public ceremony to
remove layer and expose what is underneath to bring to light
to acknowledge and confront to carve out

05

Episode 2: Traverse
to go over or travel across to move to pass through to lie
or extend across to move to and fro over or along to ascend
descend or cross to travel to pass over to wander to peregrinate
to walk to bridge

Current

Episode 1 - 1985

08

Episode 3: Contemplate
to look thoughtfully for a long time to view to regard to examine
to observe to stare at to gaze at to think about to reflect to
ponder to think profoundly at length and meditate to study
thoughtfully in order to change, transform, rethink, reinterpret

06

Episode 4: Inhabit
to bring together into a group collection or place for a purpose
to occupy a space over time to congregate to concentrate to
incorporate to draw together to unite to assemble to inhabit