Transparency Guide
Transparency Guide
A Designers Guide to
Transparency for Print Output
with Adobe Soware
15
19
25
29
Adobe Systems Incorporated 345 Park Avenue, San Jose, CA 95110-2704 USA www.adobe.com
Adobe, the Adobe logo, Acrobat, Distiller, Illustrator, InDesign, PageMaker, Photoshop, PostScript, and Tools for the
New Work are either registered trademarks or trademarks of Adobe Systems Incorporated in the United States and/
or other countries. Mac is a trademark of Apple Computer, Inc., registered in the United States and other countries.
All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners. Pantone is the property of Pantone, Inc.
Sales-enabled PDF. Web-enabled PDF. Print-ready version.
2003 Adobe Systems Incorporated. All rights reserved. Printed in the USA. 95002114 6/03
A Designers Guide to Transparency is for designers who use Adobe Illustrator 10 and Adobe
InDesign 2.0 so ware.
is guide is an educational resource for Illustrator and InDesign users who create transparency
effects when designing for print output. Its purpose is:
1. To identify and explain the transparency-related features in Illustrator and InDesign, including
how to create, display, import, export, and print transparency effects.
2. To teach designers how to build pages with transparency effects that print correctly and produce
the intended results.
3. To provide information about known issues and solutions relating to transparency.
A Designers Guide to Transparency contains six chapters, which are described below. Most
chapters begin with an introduction and then present Illustrator-specic information followed by
InDesign-specic information. While this guide focuses on Illustrator and InDesign, it also includes
information about Adobe PDF (Portable Document Format) les and their use of transparency.
Chapter 1: Introduction to Transparency explains the transparency-related capabilities in Adobe
graphics applications and how they have evolved over the past several years. It also includes an
explanation of several key terms and concepts related to transparency and printing.
Chapter 2: Creating and Viewing Transparency lists and explains the transparency-creation and
Chapter 3: Importing Files That Contain Transparency lists importable le formats that can contain
Chapter 4: Building Pages with Transparency explains how to build pages with transparency effects
Chapter 5: Saving and Exporting Files with Transparency lists the le formats you can export using
Illustrator and InDesign and explains the transparency capabilities of the various formats and their
suitability for print output.
Chapter 6: Printing Files with Transparency explains how to prepare les for low-resolution proof
CHAPTER 1
Introduction to Transparency
Real-world Transparency vs. Digital Transparency
e real world is made up of objects that are either transparent, such as clear glass, semi-opaque
(tinted glass), or opaque (not see-through, like granite). ings are similar in the digital world.
Designers who use Adobe Illustrator 10 and Adobe InDesign 2.0 can create objects that are transparent, semi-opaque, or opaque, but they also have options that arent possible in the real world.
For example, digital designers can use Illustrator and InDesign to specify the opacity of virtually
any object from totally opaque to totally transparent and change the appearance of objects by
applying transparency effects such as blending, so drop shadows, and feathered edges that fade
smoothly into whatever lies behind.
In the context of this guide, the term transparency refers to a collection of features and capabilities in Adobe Illustrator 10 and Adobe InDesign 2.0 that lets you modify the appearance of objects,
particularly the way objects affect the appearance of underlying objects.
Create transparent overlays. The
Multiply blending mode is applied
to the top object; an opacity value of
30% is applied to the bottom object.
Note: Adobe Photoshop and Adobe Acrobat soware also include transparency-related capabilities,
however, these applications are not covered in this guide.
Opaque Beginnings
For many designers, creating see-through (that is, transparent) objects is a relatively new option.
In the early days of desktop publishing, illustration and page layout programs let users create only
opaque objects. Special effects such as transparent overlays and so drop shadows required either
a dedicated image-editing program like Adobe Photoshop, which at the time required page layout
artists to atten transparency and export les in non-native formats or manual prepress work that
incurred added expense. Today, several Adobe graphics applications offer transparency features for
print and Web publishing.
Clear Benefits
Add soft drop shadows.
e transparency features that are now native in Adobe graphics and layout programs provide several benets to designers and publishers, including:
shadows, feathered edges, and layered graphics that blend into one another, gives designers
unprecedented creative freedom. Designers can use transparency effects to blend text with
pictures, pictures with pictures, anything with anything. e possibilities are endless.
Photoshop le for every transparency effect, Illustrator and InDesign users can create a single
document with as many transparency effects as they want. e one-program, one- le approach
makes it easy for designers and their clients to make changes whenever they want. Because all
design elements can be contained in a single le, even last-minute changes to transparency
effects are quick and easy.
Flexible workflows. e option to use any of several applications to create transparency effects
INTRODUCTION TO TRANSPARENC Y
e early days of transparency were not problem-free, and pioneers occasionally endured the tribulations of a technology in its infancy. e good news is that Adobe has been listening to feedback
and weve learned. One of the main purposes of this booklet is to let you know what weve learned
and to show you how you can make transparency work for you.
INTRODUCTION TO TRANSPARENC Y
If you use Illustrator or InDesign, you may already know many of the basic terms related to transparency, such as opacity, feathering, and blending. (If not, refer to the glossary that follows.) However, to get the most out of the transparency features in Illustrator and InDesign and to help ensure
you get the results you want when you print documents that contain transparency, you should be
aware of several other transparency-related terms and concepts.
Opacity
Both Illustrator and InDesign let you vary the degree of transparency of an object or a group of
objects from 100% opacity (opaque) to 0% opacity (transparent). When you decrease an objects
opacity, the underlying artwork becomes visible through the object.
Feathering
Feathering soens the edges of an object by fading from opaque to transparent over a user-denable
distance. Feathering the edge of an object causes the object to fade smoothly into the page background or into any objects behind it.
Opacity (50%)
Blending mode
Blending modes let you vary the way the colors of objects blend with the colors of underlying objects.
Flattening
All transparent objects in a le as well as all linked graphic les that interact with transparency
must be attened for print output. At its simplest, the process of attening converts all overlapping
areas in a stack of transparent objects into a collection of opaque objects that retains the appearance
of the original transparent objects when printed. (For additional information about attening, see
Chapter 6, Printing Files with Transparency.)
Live transparency
Transparent content in les can be either live or attened (see Flattened transparency below). Files
that contain live (that is, unattened) transparency, such as native Illustrator, Illustrator 10 EPS, native InDesign, and PDF 1.4 and 1.5 les, can be opened and the transparent objects can be modied
in the source application.
Flattened transparency
Flattened transparency results when you export a le in a non-native format. e transparency
effects in attened les cannot be modied using the source application and any application into
which the le is imported. Flattened le formats include PostScript, EPS, DCS, PDF 1.3 , GIF, JPEG,
BMP, and TIFF images not created with Photoshop 6.0 . PDF 1.4 and 1.5 les can contain attened
transparency or live transparency.
Note: e Illustrator 10 EPS format is actually two concatenated les: one in native Illustrator format
that only Illustrator can open; the other in EPS format that other applications can import.
INTRODUCTION TO TRANSPARENC Y
Rasterization
e process of changing vector graphics, vector fonts, gradients, and gradient meshes into bitmap
images for display and printing is called rasterization. During attening, Illustrator and InDesign
look for areas where transparent objects overlap other objects and divide the artwork into a collection of regions. Each region is analyzed to determine if it can be represented in vector format or if it
must be rasterized to achieve the expected transparency effect.
Atomic region
When overlapping transparent objects are attened, each discrete shape that results from the overlapping objects is called an atomic region. e shape of atomic regions typically follow the natural
lines, curves, and shapes of the objects involved.
Complexity region
A complexity region is an area where many transparent objects with multiple transparency effects
overlap. A complexity region is not retained in vector form except at the highest-delity (rightmost)
Raster/Vector Balance attener setting. (For more information about attener settings, see Chapter
6, Printing Files with Transparency.) As transparency effects become more complex, the time
required to display and print them increases.
Artifact
An artifact is a visible defect in an image, usually caused by limitations in the RIP or the printers
ability to process the atomic regions generated through attening. For example, a moir is an undesirable printing artifact that can result when two halone screen patterns interact. Flattener stitching (see below) is a display and printing artifact that can result from attening.
Flattener stitching
Flattener stitching is the visible color transition between atomic regions whose coloring would
otherwise be similar or identical. Stitching on low-resolution devices (such as your monitor and
desktop color laser printers) results when different screening or antialiasing methods are applied
to adjacent atomic regions. is artifact is especially noticeable when a single object contains both
pixel and vector regions, as can occur during attening.
To reduce the possibility stitching when printing an Illustrator document, check Clip Complex
Regions in the Transparency pane of the Document Setup dialog box (File > Document Setup >
Transparency). To prevent stitching when printing an InDesign document, check Clip Complex
Regions in the selected attener style (Edit > Transparency Flattener Style).
CHAPTER 2
Before you use Illustrator to create transparency effects for print, you should make sure that you
choose the CMYK color space (File > Document Color Mode >CMYK Color). In InDesign, choose
Edit > Transparency Blend Space > Document CMYK. When you apply transparency effects in
Illustrator and InDesign, colors are converted to the selected color space. You should also use the
CMYK color space for placed graphics, if possible. (If youre creating graphics for the Web, use the
RGB color space.)
e illustration below shows the Illustrator Transparency palette and the name of each of the controls it contains. Additional transparency-creation features are found in the Effect > Stylize menu
and are explained in the chart that begins on the next page.
Illustrator 10 Transparency palette
Transparency palette menu
Blending Mode menu
Thumbnails area
Artwork/Mask thumbnails;
Link icon
Opacity field/slider
Clip checkbox
Invert Mask checkbox
Illustrator 10 Feature
Description
Transparency palette
Contains controls for applying transparency effects to selected objects and groups. The Transparency palette menu contains commands for
showing and hiding thumbnails and other palette options, as well as commands for working with opacity masks.
Provides 16 choices that let you vary the way the colors of objects blend with the
colors of underlying objects. (See page 20 for information about using blending
modes with spot colors.)
Opacity field/slider
Thumbnails area
Displays controls for working with opacity masks. (An opacity mask lets you
partially hide artwork using the masks shape and luminosity. )
Artwork Thumbnail
Displays a thumbnail view of the currently targeted objects or groups. If an opacity mask is present, the objects are displayed unmasked.
Link icon
Mask Thumbnail
Clip checkbox
Makes an opacity mask double as a clipping mask, which causes the masked
objects to be fully transparent (i.e., invisible) outside the boundaries of the
masking artwork.
Normal Mask
Clipping Mask
Reverses the luminosity values of the masking artwork, which reverses the
opacity of the masked artwork. For example, areas that are 10% transparent
become 90% transparent after inversion.
Normal Mask
Inverted Mask
No blending
100% opacity
50% opacity
No Opacity Mask
Opacity Mask
Illustrator 10 Feature
Description
Prevents blending modes applied to objects within a group from being applied
to objects beneath the group.
Isolate Blending On
Makes every object of a group knock out that is, visually block out
underlying objects that are part of the group. When you select Knockout
Group, only objects within the selected group knock out. Objects beneath the
selected group are still visible and are affected by the blending modes and
opacity values applied to objects within the group.
Knockout Group On
Unshaped Knockout
Shaped Knockout
Displays several commands for working with opacity masks, as well as commands for showing and hiding options displayed in the palette.
The Blur effects (Effect > Blur > Gaussian Blur and Effect > Blur > Radial Blur) also introduce transparency into a document, as does the
Rasterize effect (Effect > Rasterize) when used with the Transparent Background option.
Drop Shadow
Adds a soft-edged shadow behind any object. You can place a drop shadow
any distance from the original object along the x or y axis, and you have the
option to apply a blending mode and specify the opacity, blur, and color of a
drop shadow. (Note: if a drop shadows opacity is set to 0, the result can be a
bitmapped raster effect rather than a soft edge.)
Shadowed Text
Feather
Softens the edges of an object by fading them from opaque to transparent over
the distance you specify. By feathering the edge of an object, you can make the
object appear to fade smoothly into the page background or into any objects
behind it. Behind the scenes, the Feather effect creates a raster image and
applies it as an opacity mask to the original object.
Shadowed Graphic
Feathered Text
Feathered Graphic
Let you add glows that spread inside or outside the edges of the selection. When
you add an inner glow, a colored and feathered version of the original object
(which introduces a raster opacity mask) is created on top of the selection;
when you add an outer glow, a transparent raster object is created behind the
selection.
Inner Glow
Outer Glow
In Illustrator, the attener Rasterization Resolution (File > Document Setup > Transparency >
Flattening Settings) is taken into consideration only during attening, however, all effects that
require rasterization in the Illustrator Effects menu are rasterized at the value specied in the
Resolution eld in the Document Raster Effects Settings dialog box (Effect > Document Raster
Effects Settings). For performance reasons, the default Resolution setting in Illustrator is 72ppi.
If you are printing to a high-resolution output device or exporting a le for eventual highresolution output, you should increase the Resolution setting for each object (in the Document
Raster Effects Settings dialog box) to a value that is appropriate for the printer.
Because the Resolution setting (in the Document Raster Effects dialog box) is used each time you
apply a raster effect, you should specify a resolution value thats appropriate for the printer before
you apply a raster effect, such as a drop shadow. In general, you should use the same resolution
for all raster effects in a document.
When you apply transparency effects to a group in Illustrator, the group is treated like a
single object relative to underlying objects; however, individual objects retain their applied
transparency effects (if any) relative to other objects in the group. is capability lets graphic
artists create nested transparency effects that would be difficult or impossible to create otherwise.
If you make changes to transparency settings in Illustrator when no objects are selected, the
modied settings are applied to newly created objects unless New Art Has Basic Appearance is
selected in the Appearance palette menu.
To edit effects that youve applied in Illustrator, double-click on the effect in the Appearance
palette. If you choose an already-applied effect from the Effect menu, a new effect is created
and added to the selection. For example, its possible to apply multiple drop shadows to a single
object. is is different from InDesign, which requires you to choose the original command
(Drop Shadow or Feather) to modify an applied effect.
10
Note: e controls in the Flattener Settings area let you specify how transparency is printed. For
information about modifying attening settings, refer to Achieving Reliable Print Output from Adobe
Applications with Transparency in the Customer Support area of adobe.com and the Illustrator 10
Flattening Guide (http://www.adobe.com/products/illustrator/indepth.html).
Overprint Preview
e Overprint Preview option (View > Overprint Preview) provides an on-screen ink preview that
approximates how overprinting will look in color-separated output. However, its important that you
carefully check overprinted colors using integral or overlay proofs before you send a document to your
service provider for nal output.
Transparency grid showing.
You can also see overprinting effects when you output to a composite printing device. To print a
composite proof using Illustrator, disable Ignore Overprinting in Composite Output in the Print
dialog box.
11
As in Illustrator, many of the transparency controls in InDesign are located in the Transparency
palette (Window > Transparency). e illustration below shows the InDesign Transparency palette
and the name of each of the controls it contains. Additional transparency-creation features are
found in the Object menu and are explained in the chart below.
InDesign 2 Transparency palette
Transparency palette menu
Blending Mode menu
Opacity field/slider
Knockout Group checkbox
Description
Transparency palette
Contains four controls for applying transparency effects to selected objects and groups. The Transparency palette menu has a Show/Hide Options
command for displaying and hiding the Isolate Blending and Knockout Group checkboxes at the bottom of the palette.
Provides 16 choices that let you vary the way the colors of objects blend with
the colors of underlying objects. (See page 20 for information about using
blending modes with spot colors.)
Opacity field/slider
No blending
100% opacity
50% opacity
Prevents blending modes applied to objects within a group from being applied
to objects beneath the group.
Isolate Blending On
Makes every object of a group knock out that is, visually block out
underlying objects that are part of the group. When you select Knockout
Group, only objects within the selected group knock out. Objects beneath the
selected group are still visible and are affected by the blending modes and
opacity values applied to objects within the group.
Knockout Group On
12
InDesign 2 Feature
Description
Adds a soft-edged shadow behind any object. You can place a drop shadow any
distance from the original object along the x or y axis, and you have the option
to apply a blending mode and specify the opacity, blur, and color of a drop
shadow. (Note: If you apply a blur value of 0, Illustrator creates a vector drop
shadow, while InDesign creates a raster drop shadow.)
Shadowed Text
Shadowed Graphic
Feather command
(Object > Feather)
Feathered Text
Feathered Graphic
Importing Transparency
In addition to creating transparent objects within Illustrator and InDesign, you can also add
transparency to a layout by importing graphics that contain transparency, such as a transparent
background (rather than a clipping path). Both Illustrator and InDesign can recognize transparency
information in placed graphic les. For more information about importing graphics that contain
transparency effects, see Chapter 3, Importing Files with Transparency.
13
InDesign lets you set global defaults for displaying transparency in the Display Performance dialog
box (Preferences > Display Performance). e display options in the View menu let you override the
global display settings for individual document windows, and the Display Performance options in
the Object menu let you control the display of individual objects.
Setting transparency-related display preferences
e Display Performance dialog box (Preferences > Display Performance) lets you to control the way
graphics and transparency effects are displayed on-screen. Display Performance settings have no
effect on transparency when it is printed. A slider lets you control the appearance of transparency in
four gradations (Off, Low, Medium, and High) of quality, from fully simulated (High) to completely
disabled (Off ). e High setting allows you, for example, to accurately position objects with drop
shadows, while the Off setting lets you quickly move objects and navigate spreads in a very large
document.
e settings you make in the Display Performance dialog box are global unless you override them
for specic objects or windows. By default, transparency display is enabled and should remain so
unless you have specic reasons for disabling it. (For more information about the controls in this
dialog box, refer to the InDesign User Guide.)
If transparency preview is completely disabled, you wont be able to tell by looking at them if objects
on a page or spread have transparency or transparency-based effects applied to them. You can use
the Pages palette for this purpose (see next page).
The Transparency slider in the Display Performance dialog box (Preferences > Display Performance) lets you control the
display of transparency effects for each of the three display options (Optimized, Typical, and High Quality).
14
Overprint Preview
e Overprint Preview option (View > Overprint Preview) provides an on-screen ink preview that
approximates how blending, transparency, and overprinting will appear in color-separated output.
However, its important that you carefully check overprinted colors on color-separated documents using integral or overlay proofs before you send a document to your service provider for nal output.
You can also see overprinting effects when you output to a composite printing device. To print
a composite proof using InDesign, enable Simulate Overprint in the Output panel of the Print
dialog box.
Note: In InDesign, turning on Overprint Preview and High Quality Display provides the closest screen
representation of the nal printed output thats possible with current technology, however, enabling
both of these options may slow screen redraw.
15
CHAPTER 3
uality
1
This illustration shows an InDesign page with three objects: 1) The Quality text frame is the frontmost object. It was created
in InDesign and has a drop shadow. 2) The placed Illustrator graphic (the two flowerlike shapes and the rounded square
shape) is the middle object in the stacking order. Blending modes are applied to all three shapes. 3) The light blue rectangle,
created in InDesign, is the bottom object. Notice how the transparency effects interact among the three layers.
16
e Place command (File menu) in Illustrator and InDesign lets you import graphics in a variety of
formats into a layout. e process of placing a graphic that contains live transparency is the same as
placing any other graphic. at is, by using the Place command. However, not all graphic le formats support live transparency. e chart below lists the le formats that support live transparency
and can be imported into Illustrator and InDesign. e designers who create transparent graphics
for use in Illustrator and InDesign layouts should save the les in a format that supports transparency. (For information about exporting Illustrator and InDesign les that contain transparency, see
Chapter 5, Saving and Exporting Files with Transparency , on page 25.)
Using le formats that preserve live transparency gives you control over the attener and resolution
settings right up to the time you print or save the job in a non-native le format (such as PostScript)
with one exception: Raster-based live effects are no longer live once they leave their native application. While transparency attributes remain live in PDF 1.4, the resolution of raster elements
including vector objects to which raster-based live effects have been applied cannot be changed
aer conversion to PDF. Also, InDesign 2.0 allows you to link directly to Illustrator 10 and PDF 1.4
les, enabling you to preserve live transparency throughout the page layout workow. Your print
provider can then atten all transparency in a job at once, directly from within InDesign.
Note: Typically, attening for high-resolution output is done by the print provider rather than the designer.
Illustrator and InDesign Import File Formats and Transparency
Transparency Embedded As
Flattened
Live
Flattened*
Flattened**
* Illustrator can open EPS les created with Illustrator, and the transparency can be edited. Illustrator 9
EPS and Illustrator 10 EPS les contain a native, non-attened Illustrator portion that can be read only by
Illustrator and a attened EPS portion that can be read by all EPS-compatible applications. e transparency in an Illustrator EPS le is considered attened if the le is placed into InDesign and other programs.
** Some graphic le formats (EPS not from Illustrator, TIFF, etc.) can not handle live transparency.
17
Whenever possible, you should use le formats that preserve live transparency including native
formats for Adobe applications (i.e., Illustrator 9, Illustrator 10, and InDesign 2.0) or PDF 1.4 as
hand-off les or source les for placement in layouts or other documents and for delivery to your print
provider.
Because InDesign lets you import native Photoshop and Illustrator les, you dont have to save two
versions of your graphic les, as you do if you use QuarkXPress for page layout. QuarkXPress cannot import native Photoshop and Illustrator les. Also, when you place transparent graphics into
InDesign, the placed graphics can blend with other objects in the layout. is isnt possible if placed
graphics have been attened into opaque artwork.
Placing EPS graphics into Illustrator
You should place-embed (by unchecking the Link checkbox in the Place dialog box) EPS images that
are part of an Illustrator 10 document if they interact with transparency. e attener in Illustrator
10 cannot read the data inside a place-linked le. erefore, place-linked les involved in transparency print rst, beneath everything else on the page, as if they are in the background. Place-embedding
the le in Illustrator 10 enables the attener to correctly process the les contents for transparencybased effects.
In Illustrator 9, a yellow warning icon is displayed next to the names of any linked les that, because of their interaction with transparency, need to be embedded to atten correctly. To improve
performance in Illustrator 10, this feature is disabled by default, but you can reenable it by choosing
Palette Options from the Links palette menu and selecting Show Transparency Interactions.
Note: e colors in place-embedded les automatically convert to match the selected color model in the
Illustrator 10 document into which they are placed if they dont already match. Monotones and duotones are converted to process colors. When spot colors in monotones and duotones must be preserved,
the les must be place-linked. In addition, you should ensure that the placed les do not interact with
transparency.
Placing Illustrator-generated transparent graphics into InDesign
Illustrator 9 and 10 let you save graphics with transparency in the following le formats: native
Illustrator (.AI), EPS created with Illustrator (.EPS), and PDF 1.4 created with Illustrator (.PDF). If
you place .AI or PDF 1.4 les (PDF 1.3 les are attened) created with Illustrator that contain live
transparency into InDesign layouts, the transparency effects are maintained within the graphic and
relative to native InDesign objects. If you place an EPS le created with Illustrator, the transparency
is already attened as far as InDesign is concerned (though the transparency effects are still live if
the le is reopened in Illustrator), and the graphic is attened/opaque relative to InDesign objects.
Note: If you want to place an Illustrator-generated PDF 1.3 le into an InDesign layout, do not use the
Illustrator Save As command (File menu). Instead, you should atten the le in Illustrator using appropriate attener settings, save an Illustrator EPS le or create a PostScript le, and then use Acrobat
Distiller to create a PDF 1.3 le from the EPS or PostScript le.
18
19
CHAPTER 4
Every time you create a new object in Illustrator and InDesign, its placed in front of all existing
objects. (Note: Stacking order becomes a bit more complicated when youre working with a group or
a layer, each of which has its own stacking order.) e layering of objects on a page is referred to as
the stacking order. You can adjust the stacking order of an object by moving it forward or backward
relative to other objects on the page. e stacking order of objects is critical for correct display and
printing of transparency. (To change the stacking order of a selected object, choose Object > Arrange and then choose one of the options from the submenu Bring to Front, Bring Forward, Send
to Back, or Send Backward or change the stacking order of layers).
Transparency effects dont have to involve overlapping objects, but this is oen the case. For example, you can apply an opacity value thats less than 100% to lighten any object regardless of whether
the object is in front of other objects. However, by applying an opacity value, you not only make
an object lighter, you also make it semi-opaque, which causes it to blend with any underlying objects
it overlaps.
When youre working with transparent objects that overlap, you should keep in mind that changing
the stacking order can change the appearance of overlapping areas. When you create transparency
effects that involve overlapping objects, make sure the stacking order is producing the intended
results.
20
You need to know two important things about blending modes. First, when a blending mode is applied to a spot color object, what you see onscreen or in a composite proof may not match what the
press reproduces. Second, certain blending modes specically, Difference, Exclusion, Hue, Saturation, Color, and Luminosity can introduce additional color on the process plates when a blend
involving spot colors is attened, and unexpected results can occur when separations are created.
Note: In general, mixing transparency and spot colors, including blending spot colors with process
colors, should be done with caution. It is possible to get the results you want, however, conversion of
spot colors to process colors can occur.
100% cyan
(process)
100% cyan
(process)
!
In this example, the Difference
blending mode applied to the
Pantone 530-filled object (right)
produces a dark region where it
overlaps the underlying cyan object.
Printing separations produces five
color plates.
No transparency.
21
With Illustrator 10, correct spot color separations are possible only if you export a le in Illustrator
10 EPS format (in which transparency is attened), native Illustrator format, or as PDF 1.4 (in which
transparency remains live). For other formats, such as Illustrator 8 EPS and PDF 1.3, spot colors are
converted to process equivalents.
Note: If you want to place a PDF 1.3 le created with Illustrator into an InDesign layout, do not use the
Illustrator Save As command (File menu). Instead, you should atten the le in Illustrator using appropriate attener settings, save an Illustrator EPS le or create a PostScript le, and then use Acrobat
Distiller to create a PDF 1.3 le from the EPS or PostScript le.
InDesign 2.0 preserves spot colors including spot colors that interact with transparency and that are
set to overprint. You can display overprinted colors by turning on Overprint Preview (View menu).
You can also simulate overprinted colors on your desktop proofer by selecting Simulate Overprint in
the Print or Export dialog boxes. (e output will approximate what you see on screen with Overprint
Preview turned on.) e overprinting color information is simulated by your composite printer and
provides a more complete proof. You should select Simulate Overprint only for composite output.
InDesign will correctly separate spot colors and overprinting when you output separations.
In general, it is best to place Illustrator artwork into InDesign for later processing, attening, etc.,
especially artwork with spot colors and transparency.
For the most part overprinting and transparency are different animals. Both Illustrator and InDesign
give you the option to overprint (rather than knockout) overlapping objects, and they both include
several features for creating transparency effects. But while overprint is not transparency, transparency can affect overprint.
The Attributes palette (Window>
Attributes) in InDesign (above) and
Illustrator (below) let you apply
overprinting to fills and strokes.
Overprinting is preserved in InDesign documents that dont contain transparency (including nonnormal blending modes). However, if overprinting is mixed with transparency, attening can cause
overprinting to be preprocessed. In some cases, attening may not produce the intended results on
press, especially when spot colors are involved. e following paragraph summarizes how Illustrator
and InDesign handle overprinting.
With Illustrator 10 it is not possible to preserve native overprint instructions when printing composite output overprint can either be ignored or attened. When printing to a composite printer,
checking Ignore Overprinting in Composite Output in the Print dialog box causes overprint information to be ignored (i.e., the overprint instructions are removed) when the document is printed. If
Ignore Overprinting in Composite Output is unchecked, instances of overprinting are attened (i.e.
the visual appearance of overprinting is preserved). e results in InDesign are similar if you check
Simulate Overprint in the Output pane of Print dialog box.
If an overprinted object is involved in transparency, overprint is attened (i.e. the overprinted object
is divided into atomic regions and their color is attened, taking overprint into account). Flattening
of overprinting maintains the visual appearance of the objects involved, and it does not increase the
amount of ink per plate.
In other scenarios, overprint instructions can be generated as a result of attening, even if no
overprint is set manually. is can happen when spot colors that are involved in transparency are
attened. Illustrator and InDesign handle the attening and correctly manage the spot colors.
Its important to note that attening overprint does not affect the ink on the nal plates, nor does it
automatically convert spot colors to process (although both can occur together) or remove all overprint instructions. It simply means that all overprinted objects are broken down into atomic regions.
22
If overprinting instructions are applied to objects that also contain transparency, the attener may
be used to atten these objects. e attener, in effect, executes the overprinting instructions and
renders the results in the attened output stream, much the same as a PostScript RIP. Heres a list of
conditions under which overprinting instructions are preprocessed by the attener:
When overprinting objects have transparency applied directly to them (for example, objects that
are less than 100% opaque).
When overprinting objects are part of a group to which transparency is applied.
When overprinting objects are overlapped by or are within approximately 1/72" of transparent
objects or groups.
When a placed graphic contains overprinted objects and transparency is then applied to the
placed graphic.
When overprinting objects are part of a complex region of transparency that must be rasterized
during attening.
When Simulate Overprinting is selected in the Advanced options of the Export dialog box
(InDesign 2.0 only). (Note: By default this checkbox is not selected and should remain so for
high-end printing workows. It should be selected only when printing proofs to low-end composite
devices that cannot otherwise simulate overprinting.)
When the Preserve Overprinting When Possible checkbox is not checked in the Transparency
pane of the Document Setup dialog box (Illustrator 10 only). (Note: By default this checkbox is not
selected, however, it should be selected for high-end printing workows.)
In many cases, the results of attening overprinting instructions are identical to what happens when
a PostScript RIP interprets the same overprinting instructions and may not cause a problem in your
workow.
Note: With Illustrator, overprinting instructions are not always preserved when a document is attened, although the visual appearance of overprint is preserved. You can preserve overprinting for objects that arent
involved in transparency by checking Preserve Overprint When Possible in the Print dialog box.
23
Despite your best efforts to avoid transparency problems, some may still arise. Below is a list of
problems that can occur in order of likelihood. Generally, problems are the result of the way a le
was created and the attener settings used, as well as the methods and equipment your printer uses
to process your les.
1. Spot colors may display colors on process plates or convert to process. Saving to an older
le format, such as PDF 1.3 from Illustrator 10 may cause this. Some prepress so ware may
inadvertently misinterpret attened EPS les, which results in converting spot colors to process.
In this case, do not use EPS; use native InDesign, native Illustrator, or PDF les.
2. Transparency attening can include objects set to overprint. When this occurs, overprinting
instructions are not preserved aer attening, however, the objects will look correct when
printed because the overprint is taken into consideration when transparency is attened. Printers
need to be aware that changing overprinting instructions at the RIP can affect not only objects
set to overprint, but attened transparency, as well.
3. Vector objects may get rasterized at a resolution thats too low for the output device. is is why
its best for your printer to handle attening. Your printer will use attener settings that are
appropriate for the output device.
4. Stitching or artifacts may appear along the edges atomic regions. If possible, let your service
provider do the attening to avoid these problems.
5. Hairlines and strokes may fatten. Generally this is a problem only on low-resolution output
devices.
6. Type may be converted to lled strokes. at is, the characters may thicken. is can be a
problem on low-resolution devices. It is less of a problem on high-resolution devices.
24
Additional transparency interactions currently have no workarounds for optimal printing. Future
versions of Adobe applications will likely address some of these interactions. Until then, however, be
alert for the following elements when they are mixed with transparency:
Preseparated content (DCS les).
Duotone, tritone, and quadtone images place-linked in Illustrator les (this is not a problem in
InDesign).
Images to be replaced aer attening occurs (for example, in workows using an OPI server).
If low-resolution images are attened, the results will be low-resolution. For this reason, lowresolution images should not be attened. Make sure you use high-resolution images when
attening or sending your documents to a service provider if transparency is involved.
25
CHAPTER 5
Whenever possible, you should use le formats that preserve live transparency including native
formats for Illustrator and InDesign documents or PDF 1.4 when youre creating graphic les for
placement in other documents.
Saving les in native formats provides several advantages over the other le format options:
Greater control at print time. Using native le formats gives you control over the attener and
resolution settings up to the time you print, save, or export a job in a non-native le format (such
as PostScript).
Reduce file overhead. By saving a single, native version of a graphic instead of multiple, exported
TIFF or EPS les, you reduce the number of les you have to track, and you also reduce the disk
space required to store your graphics.
Easy editability. InDesign 2.0 allows you to link directly to native Illustrator 10 les and PDF 1.4
les, which allows you to preserve live transparency throughout the page layout workow. If you
need to make changes to a native Illustrator graphic, you can simply open the le in Illustrator
and make the changes. (You can easily open the original Illustrator le within InDesign by
selecting it in the Links palette and then choosing Edit Original from the palette menu.) Other
formats atten Illustrator objects, making them uneditable. is forces you to open the le in
Illustrator, make the changes, export and atten the le again, and nally relink the placed
graphic in InDesign. When you modify a placed native Illustrator graphic, all instances of the
graphic in InDesign documents are updated. When its time to print the nished InDesign
document, the printer can atten all transparency at once directly from within InDesign using
the attener controls in InDesign.
Remember, when you export a document (including Photoshop, Illustrator, and InDesign documents) in any le format that attens transparency, the document is attened in the same way its
rasterized when printed, and you lose the ability to edit the original objects, except for Illustrator 10
EPS les and only if the le is reopened in Illustrator 10.
Exporting EPS files
Illustrator 10 can save les in its own (Illustrator 10) EPS format, as well as in EPS formats that are
compatible with earlier versions of Illustrator. Illustrator 10 EPS les are best suited for use in a
high-end print workow because of the management of spot colors and transparency.
Transparency is always attened when a le is saved to EPS. An Illustrator 10 EPS le, however,
(unless resaved in another application) retains transparency information, so live transparency is
restored if the le is reopened in Illustrator 10.
Note: If you save an Illustrator le using a legacy format (e.g., Illustrator 8), type involved in transparency is converted to outlines, and spot colors are converted to process colors. You can open the le in
Illustrator, but you wont be able to edit any text thats been converted to outlines. Adobe recommends
using the latest version of all its applications to avoid such problems.
26
You can export two kinds of EPS les using InDesign 2.0, however, only one is generally suitable
for high-end printing workows. By default, InDesign 2.0 exports EPS les in which overprinting
instructions are preserved wherever possible in some limited cases, the attening process will
preprocess these and incorporate the overprinting with the transparency information. ese default
EPS les are suitable for output on printing presses. If you select Simulate Overprint in the Export
dialog box, InDesign 2.0 can optionally export EPS les in which all overprinting instructions are
preprocessed and the appearance of overprint is simulated for output on composite devices. ese
EPS les with Simulate Overprint enabled are suitable for desktop printing and proong. As a rule,
you shouldnt use this option for high-end printing workows.
Exporting PDF files
PDF 1.4 (also known as Acrobat 5 PDF) can accurately display live transparency created by any
Adobe transparency-savvy authoring and layout application. Illustrator 10 and InDesign 2.0 can
both import and export live transparency as PDF 1.4. Among other benets, this format preserves
spot colors and overprinting without attening.
If you work with PDF 1.3 (also known as Acrobat 4 PDF), you should be aware that any transparency in the native document from which the PDF was created will be attened when the PDF 1.3
le is saved/exported. PDF 1.3 les created with already-attened artwork may not be acceptable
for high-end prepress workows because overprinting and spot colors arent always preserved and
because the resolution used during attening may not be appropriate for high-resolution output.
Illustrator 10, for example, doesnt preserve overprinting and spot colors when it exports to PDF 1.3.
InDesign 2.0, however, does preserve overprinting and spot colors.
Note: PDF 1.4 les created using Distiller 5 will not contain live transparency because Distiller operates on PostScript, which can contain only attened transparency.
If you intend to use an Illustrator graphic in another Illustrator document or in another Adobe graphics application, such as InDesign or Photoshop, you have the option to save the Illustrator graphic as a
native Illustrator (.AI), EPS, or PDF le, or you can export a native Photoshop (.PSD) or TIFF le. e
chart that follows shows the save/export le format options available in Illustrator and how transparency is saved for each format. Choose File > Save or File > Save As to save an Illustrator document in a
native Illustrator format or as a PDF or EPS le; choose File > Export to save a native Photoshop (.PSD)
or TIFF le.
Note: You can preserve live text, layers, masks, compound vector shapes, and more when you export
Illustrator graphics in .PSD format. For more information see the Illustrator User Guide.
If you use QuarkXPress for page layout, you must save Illustrator graphics as EPS or PDF 1.3 les.
You cannot place native Illustrator les nor graphics with live transparency into QuarkXPress
layouts.
27
Output Formats
Transparency Embedded As
Live or Flattened
Flattened
Flattened
Live or Flattened
EPS
Flattened*
Flattened**
* Illustrator can open AI EPS les, and the transparency can be edited. All other products can place
and use the attened portion of the EPS le. e le may need to be place-embedded.
** Some graphic le formats (EPS not from Illustrator), TIFF, etc.) cannot handle live transparency.
Exporting Illustrator graphics for use in programs that cant handle transparency
If you use Illustrator graphics in page layout programs that cant handle transparency, you should
specify attening settings and save transparent artwork in Illustrator 10 EPS format, especially if spot
colors are involved and you intend to print separations. Currently, InDesign 2.0 is the only page layout
program that can interpret unattened, live transparency in native Illustrator les and PDF 1.4 les.
Illustrator 10 EPS is the only attened le format that can be exported from Illustrator 10 with spot
color plates preserved. Because spot colors are converted to process colors if you export to AI 8 EPS or
PDF 1.3, Illustrator 10 EPS is the only attened format suitable for separations in page layout programs
that cant handle transparency. More importantly, you can open Illustrator 10 EPS les in Illustrator 10
and adjust attener and resolution settings to match output conditions in your workow.
28
If you want to use an InDesign page in another InDesign layout or another program, such as Illustrator
or Photoshop, you can export PDF or EPS les You can also use the Print dialog box to create PostScript
les that can be converted to PDF with Acrobat. e chart below shows the save/export le format options available in InDesign and how transparency is saved for each format.
Note: Choose File > Save or File > Save As to save a native InDesign document (or template); choose
File > Export to save PDF or EPS les; and choose File > Print to create a PostScript le.
InDesign Export File Formats and Transparency
Output Formats
Transparency Embedded As
Live
Flattened
Flattened
Live
EPS
Flattened
If your service provider uses prepress tools that cant interpret PDF 1.4 les, you should save InDesign
2.0 documents that contain transparency as PostScript les or PDF 1.3 les using the High Resolution
attener style, or ask your printer for their recommended attener settings. PostScript and PDF 1.3
les created in this manner in InDesign 2.0 provide high-quality results, preserve overprinting and
spot colors where possible, and separate correctly.
Printers oen prefer to receive les in certain formats. When you provide les to your printer for output, make sure you let them know if transparency is involved. If your printer does not have experience
processing les with transparency, have them contact Adobe technical support or the Adobe Solutions
Network (http://partners.adobe.com/asn/main.html) to receive free training materials and other useful resources.
29
CHAPTER 6
Printing a document that contains transparency is much the same as printing any other document
with one important difference: You should choose a attener style (InDesign) or specify attener
settings (Illustrator) that are appropriate for the printer.
Printing Proofs with Illustrator
Heres a checklist for designers to help ensure reliable printing with Adobe Illustrator 10 when
printing proofs:
1. Specify the CMYK color mode (File > Document Color Mode > CMYK Color) for les that will be
printed on a desktop proof printer.
2. Specify the proper ppi for your document in the Document Raster Effects Settings dialog box.
Medium (150 ppi) is the typical setting for proof printing.
3. Ensure that your resolution-dependent live effects (such as Guassian blur and mezzotint) still look
the way you want them to aer changing the ppi value in the Document Raster Effects Settings
dialog box.
4. Use the Overprint Preview display mode (View > Overprint Preview) to display approximately
how the objects youve specied for overprinting will appear in color-separated output.
30
5. Preview your artwork in the Flattening Preview palette to determine which areas will be affected
by transparency. Or, preview the areas of your artwork that will be rasterized to ensure text will
not be rasterized. Or, speak with your service provider to ensure you have selected the proper
settings.
For detailed information about the Flattening Preview palette, see the Illustrator 10 Flattening Guide (http://
www.adobe.com/products/illustrator/indepth.html).
6. When saving a le as a native Illustrator (AI) le, select Illustrator 10 in the Compatibility pulldown menu for faster le printing and for transparency support when placing the artwork into
InDesign. When saving a le as an Illustrator EPS le (the proper format for placing the artwork
into QuarkXPress), select Illustrator 10 in the Compatibility pull-down menu to preserve editable
transparency.
Printing Proofs with InDesign
In InDesign, you can choose a attener style when you print a document. To choose a attener style,
choose File > Print and click on Advanced in the list of print options on the le side of the Print
dialog box. In the Transparency Flattener area of the Advanced panel of the Print dialog box, choose
an appropriate attener style from the Style menu.
e Style menu includes three default styles Low Resolution, Medium Resolution, and High
Resolution as well as any custom attener styles youve created. (To create custom attener styles,
choose Edit > Transparency Flattener Styles. For information about creating attener styles, refer to
the InDesign User Guide.)
If youre printing a proof to a PostScript printer you should choose the Low Resolution or Medium
Resolution attener style.
Choose the Medium Resolution attener style for desktop proofs printed on black-and-white
desktop printers.
Choose the Medium Resolution style for desktop proofs and print-on-demand documents printed
on PostScript color printers.
If you are printing to a printer that is not a PostScript printer, the Flattener Style menu is not available. In this case you should enable Simulate Overprint in the Output panel of the Print dialog box.
When Simulate Overprint is enabled, the proof print will look the same as its displayed on-screen
with Overprint Preview (View menu) enabled.
31
The transparency flattener style you choose in the Advanced panel of the InDesign Print dialog box determines how transparency effects are flattened when the file is printed or exported in a file format that doesnt preserve live transparency.
As you learned in the introduction to this guide, transparency must be attened for print output. In
most cases, attening produces excellent results when you use an appropriate predened attener
style or a custom attening style with settings appropriate for your nal output. However, attening
may alter colors and transparent objects in ways that can affect output quality. If your Illustrator and
InDesign documents contain complex, overlapping areas and you require high-resolution output,
you should work closely with your print service provider. Your print provider can specify optimal
attener settings based on the le formats used, the resolution of the nal output device, and their
workow. Good communication between you and your service provider will help you achieve the
results you expect.