José Batista, "The Bigoted Education of A Dominican Young Man or The Narrator-Protagonist of El Masacre Se Pasa A Pie As Dilettante."
José Batista, "The Bigoted Education of A Dominican Young Man or The Narrator-Protagonist of El Masacre Se Pasa A Pie As Dilettante."
Jos Batista
In the 1973 novel El masacre se pasa a pie written by Freddy Prestol Castillo, an
you be a great free pen of Spanish America Por qu no podra ser usted una gran
pluma libre de Amrica (Prestol Castillo 188).1 The narrator is flattered by the
vocation: writing. The exchange underscores the position of the narrator as subject to the
godhead of the dictatorship and the elder scholar a proxy of the same godhead. More
the role of the intellectual in a repressive state, and the submission of the scholar or
masacre se pasa a pie in order to highlight the authors representation of the ideological
formation of the notion of the Haitian as Other. In the analysis, I discuss the impact of
the persona and work of Jos Enrique Rod and Pedro Henrquez Urea on the narrator-
protagonist as the young lawyer and aspiring writer who fantasizes about being a great
1
All translations are mine.
PAC
Postscript
Batista:
The
Bigoted
Education
2
free pen of Spanish America una gran pluma libre de Amrica (Prestol Castillo 188). I
look into the role of arielismo in the narrators adoption of an identity as writer, the
possible motives for donning a writers mask, and the social and personal implications of
Latin America and a symbol of its historical ills: authoritarianism, violence, corruption,
and poverty. I consider the narrators allegiance to the dominant ideology through
episodes that occur in the hallowed spaces of school, home, and prison: the recollection
of the so-called geography lesson taught by his primary school teacher Sr. Maestro, the
recollection of his childhood home and friend Pablo while under the tutelage of Aunt
Elosa, the mule ride through the countryside, and the dream sequence that passes for the
Jos Enrique Rodos two influential essays: Ariel and Prometheuss Motives
The impact on Spanish American letters of Uruguayan Jos Enrique Rods most
influential work, Ariel, published in 1899, can hardly be overestimated, for it shaped the
intellectual field for the first half of the twentieth century. According to the Costa Rican
scholar Arnoldo Mora Rodrguez, up until the 1940s to think or produce scholarly works
was synonymous with to Arielize arielizar (151). Jos Enrique Rod deemed Greco-
Roman culture and Christian ethics as twin pillars of Western Civilization and, by
extension, universal culture (qtd. in Mora Rodrguez 186). Thus, any local or Creole
terms, the metanarratives of modernity. Jos Enrique Rod aimed his work at the
PAC
Postscript
Batista:
The
Bigoted
Education
3
studious white-identified young men of the middle class, the university graduates that
were critical, sensitive, and least contaminated by ambition or avarice (Mora Rodriguez
186). Yet, Ariel had a broader and more profound appeal to the Latin American
intelligentsia and ruling elites, for the Uruguayan scholar adopts and propagates a Latin
American identity based on a shared culture and spiritual ideal that strategically contested
the materialist and utilitarian ethos of the nascent imperialism of the United States
(Juregui 314; Mora Rodrguez 132, 136). It should be noted that Jos Enrique Rods
utopian ideal excluded the majority of its own people: laborers, unionists, women, as well
Ariel is composed of a famous frame story and essay. The frame story that
envelops the long literary and philosophical ruminations of Ariel takes place in a
classroom in which a teacher prepares to impart lessons to his pupils who listen
Prspero by the students, in a direct reference to Shakespeares The Tempest, and the
espoused by the author (Rod 139). Caliban is conspicuously absent from the imagined
space yet ever present given that he represents, as Mabel Moraa confirms, the
countervailing forces that threaten Western Civilization (qtd. in Juregui 342). Through
said Shakespearean allegory, Rod canonizes the concept of Latin American identity as
an inheritor of spiritual and aesthetic values in the character of Ariel (Juregui 329). On
an individual level, the allegory is meant to show that the function of a true teacher is to
PAC
Postscript
Batista:
The
Bigoted
Education
4
challenge students to strive for a higher ideal, that is, to vanquish their inner Caliban
(Motivos de Prometeo) published in 1909. In the spirit of Plato and Seneca, the book is a
collection of brief articles on fulfilling ones life purpose. The writings reflect two basic
philosophical tenets: first, to be oneself is to know oneself, and second, to know oneself
is to understand the mutable nature of the self. In Prometheuss Motives, Rod uses
Rodrguez 196-197). Authenticity, assures Rod, comes from fulfilling ones true
vocation, and existence is meaningful only when ones actions combine moral rectitude
In sum, Ariel, an essay that points Latin Americans to a utopian ideal of spiritual
and aesthetic attainment during a period of uneasiness with their North American
reflections that demand collaboration from the reader in the construction of meaning,
helped inspire many arielistas as well as several distinct arielismos across Latin America.
The three most important were Jos Vasconcelos in Mxico; Pedro Henrquez Urea in
the Dominican Republic; and Jos Maritegui in Per. Of the three, we shall consider
Henrquez Urea for two reasons. First, as Maestro de Nuestra Amrica he best
Pensamiento 160; Mora Rodriguez 218). Second, according to the author of El masacre
PAC
Postscript
Batista:
The
Bigoted
Education
5
se pasa a pie, the elderly scholar in the novel named Dr. Fadrquez, who interpellates the
Pedro Henrquez Urea, the Dominican philologist, scholar, critic, educator, and essayist
may very well be the first disciple of Jos Enrique Rods arielismo. Arguably,
reworking of the Charles Eliot Norton Lectures he delivered at Harvard University from
1940 to 1941 (Girardot, Ensayos 250). He also contributed prolifically to the fields of
philology and education with essays and articles. I would like to address two classic
essays that are pertinent to the discussion at hand: The Fatherland of Justice Patria de
discontent and the promise El descontento y la promesa, a conference for Amigos del
comes before the ideal of culture: superior is the passionate man of justice to the man
who only aspires to his own intellectual perfection. El ideal de la justicia est antes que
propia perfeccin intelectual. In the same essay, Henrquez Urea considers the latter
collective effort to build a utopian society based on Greco-Roman ideals where each
individual is free to pursue his or her own vocation as defined by Rod. In the essay, the
United States is singled out as a champion of democracy that had lost its way to become a
state of tyranny given that its people are no longer free to pursue their own vocations
because they are slaves to utilitarianism (Prez 151). Through this critique of a spiritual
decline in the U.S., Henrquez Urea resurrects the notion of Latin America as a vessel of
Western Civilization: If in Latin America utopias are not to flourish, where shall they
find refuge? Si en Amrica no han de fructificar las utopas, dnde encontrarn asilo?
Latin America that can counter US imperial power, he still insists on attempting to build
a utopia that does not betray its origins, as did the United States. The US as cautionary
non-western cultures and, by extension, ethnic and racial minorities. In spite of Girardots
insistence that Rods and Henrquez Ureas utopian visions are not racist because they
incorporate the so-called lessons of Bartolom de las Casas, the stance promotes an
Asian, African, and indigenous cultures are of necessity excluded from this polity
because, according to Rod, historically they seek stasis or equilibrium, while the West
strives for progress and innovation (Prez 73). Ironically, the racially mixed Caribbean
islander Pedro Henrquez Urea uncritically shares the orientalist views of Rod, a
expense of the masses (Juregui 338). In this light, Dr. Fradrquezs rhetorical question
to the narrator Could you not be a great free pen of Spanish America? becomes a call to
help build an exclusionist society for the good of the elite (Prestol Castillo 188; my
emphasis).
Spanish American literary expression from the colonial period to the avant-garde. The
essay ponders the continued search for Latin American authenticity. As Andrs Bello
in the language of the former imperial master, Spain, but to cherish the unique accents
and phrases that are markers of a national difference. He also underscores that Latin
even though Europe may provide the form of Spanish American literary and artistic
expression, creole culture provides the content. Finally, Henrquez Urea suggests that
creators from the Americas must aim for profundity and purity of expression, the only
path to achieving literary perfection. He especially warns against lack of effort, lack of
discipline, sons of laziness and ignorance, or the life in perpetual disarray and flux, full of
concerns removed from the purity of the work la falta de esfuerzo y la ausencia de
the consecration of any literary expression produced and controlled by the lettered elite is
PAC
Postscript
Batista:
The
Bigoted
Education
8
the manufacture of a national identity and not necessarily representative of an entire
peoples historical reality. More importantly, the gift of writing comes with great
responsibility, motivating Pedro Henrquez Urea to single out those that squander their
century Dominican Republic has powerful reasons to determine his aptitude for writing in
order to contribute to the national culture and join the rank of highly regarded
intellectuals who enjoy great honor and prestige. Such a youth would champion the
Greco-Roman ideal as an ongoing and desirable cultural project at the expense of ethnic
minority subcultures. The same youth would exercise his freedom to pursue a vocation to
confirm that he lives in a just society, and even record his philosophical, ethical or
mystical musings about life without the interference or impurity of current affairs in
sociopolitical matters. The narrator of El Masacre, the young university graduate that
Freddy Prestol Castillos classic 1973 novel El masacre se pasa a pie is about the 1937
genocide that took somewhere between 5,000 and 30,000 lives, and the Dominican social
reality that fostered it through the perspective of a young white-identified (or blanco)
Dominican male of privilege. The novel describes the horrors of the genocide and offers
a perceptive look at the operations of the state in the execution, cover-up, and impact of
the genocide from multiple perspectives crossing social, economic, racial, generational,
PAC
Postscript
Batista:
The
Bigoted
Education
9
and gender lines. We shall now consider four fundamental moments, two of which the
The first chapter opens with a schoolroom scene, a parody of Ariels frame story,
in which the narrator recalls a geography lesson of the nation or Geography of the
Fatherland Geografa Patria taught by his teacher Sr. Maestro. The teacher had
pronounced the strange word: Dajabn El maestro haba pronunciado una palabra
rara: Dajabn, recalls the narrator (Prestol Castillo 17). Dajabn, a frontier town in
the northeast of the Dominican Republic, sounds peculiar to the narrator because it is an
unfamiliar place name of Taino origin. The narrators childhood memory is stirred as he
rides in a car to the remote town to fulfill his new appointment as magistrate, a job he
sympathized with the recent graduates financial predicament. Although the narrator is
of the privileged land-owning class, he witnessed his fathers wealth dry up before his
death due to socioeconomic forces beyond state control (20-21). Now penniless, he must
fend for himself in a country where state employment provides economic security for the
newly minted college graduate. The carefree memories of his early childhood contrast
The narrator characterizes Sr. Maestro as an individual of the privileged class that
lives within the bounds of the colonial zone of the capital city, ignorant of his own
countrys geography (and history), yet well versed in international affairs, sports, arts,
and fashion because he prefers to read the Times and other foreign publications. Sr.
espoused by Rod and Henrquez Urea. In fact, while flipping through a foreign
magazine during the geography lesson, Sr. Maestro says out loud, This is civilization!
Esto es civilizacin! (Prestol Castillo 17). His comment implies that the countrys
region that borders Haiti, with its distinct frontier culture, rich history, and indigenous
place names, merits no more than a scant reference. For Sr. Maestro, the Dominican
Republic is a backwater of the U.S., and the more heavily African-derived cultures within
its borders like Haitian and Haitian-Dominican cultures are even further removed from
civilization. More importantly, the narrator observes that his conscience as a young boy
was forged by the sophisticated maestro, full of empty courtesy las forja un maestro
In other words, the halls of the elementary school, under the direction of Sr.
Maestro, notes the narrator, were the sites of ideological transmission. Aside from a
biased curricular content, Sr. Maestro was a role model whose class interests, attitudes,
an elitist with refined tastes whose open contempt for border towns and frontier culture
echoes Jos Marts characterization of the exotic creole criollo extico, a conceptual
character that has a sense of entitlement to his native countrys resources, and suffers
from false erudition falsa erudicin or knowledge of foreign peoples, histories, and
cultures, yet is ignorant of local people, culture, and history (Mart 23). Or, as Pedro
PAC
Postscript
Batista:
The
Bigoted
Education
11
Henrquez Urea would have it, Sr. Maestro is an egoist dilettante, an individual who
has yet to discover, or fails to fulfill, his own vocation because of his refusal to vanquish
his inner Caliban since he doesnt really know nor cares to know the geography of his
own country, even when its his responsibility to do so as a primary school teacher.
Although the narrator clearly attempts to distance himself from Sr. Maestro, the parallels
between Sr. Maestro and the narrator, who were both raised in the urban spaces of Santo
Domingo, rarely ventured beyond the city limits, and harbor prejudice toward the Haitian
people, only strengthen the argument that the narrators own ambiguous behavior in the
face of injustice stems from the fact that perhaps he, like Sr. Maestro, is an egoist
and thus free to create masterworks that would contribute to Dominican culture, he would
In the final chapter, the narrator is under the custody of the municipal court of
Santo Domingo for having fled his post in Dajabn (Prestol Castillo 195). He deserted
his post as magistrate to flee the country, and failed (183). His job as magistrate, initially
reservists (mostly prisoners) for the genocide and exonerate all military personnel (152).
He complied, under the close watch of the despicable Mayor Ozuna who desperately
wanted to bed the narrators girlfriend (175-6). Once discovered to be on the run, Mayor
Behind bars, the narrator recalls his childhood as he did in the first chapter. He
fondly describes the Arcadian scene of a secret garden full of autochthonous plants in his
PAC
Postscript
Batista:
The
Bigoted
Education
12
fathers luxurious home where he would play with black, ugly, poor negro, feo, pobre
Pablo (Prestol Castillo 195). However, the narrators tutor, Aunt Eloisa, would end the
fun and games by accosting the intruding child as if he were a pest in order to drive him
Subtly, the narrator blasts what Paolo Freire calls the banking system of
education on which Rods allegory is based by demonstrating how a child of the slums,
another sort of Caliban, can be a better teacher than a licensed instructor like Sr. Maestro.
Pablo, the narrator confesses, was the first to make him aware of his wealth and privilege,
a powerful civics lesson in a stratified society of haves and have-nots. Indeed, the
narrator did not even understand Pablos simple observation, You are rich, because he
thought everybody enjoyed the same living conditions. Unlike the narrator, Pablo lived
in a makeshift dwelling near the citys major port that his family would have to abandon
during heavy rain falls or floods (Prestol Castillo 195). Ultimately, the narrator learns
from Pablo that class and color are inextricably twined in Dominican society. Yet its
from Aunt Eliosas reaction to Pablos presence in the garden that the narrator learns
about racism and how it sustains the color and socioeconomic divide so characteristic of
the island. Like the halls of the elementary school, the narrators luxurious home, under
the tutelage of Aunt Eloisa, functions as a site of transmission of state ideology. Once
again, the narrator learns to which social group he belongs and, furthermore, regardless of
the attitude he may assume towards the societys other, he inhabits a position of privilege
he explored the province of Dajabn upon a mule. Unlike the locus amoenus of his
childhood homes garden, the memory captures the narrator in a killing field, a veritable
locus terribilis:
Esta es una luna nada potica. Luna acusadora, ms bien. Blanquea sobre ms de
Mientras mi mula va saltando sobre los crneos dispersos como los pedernales del
ro, pienso:
conciencia?... (59)
This moon is not poetic. An accusatory moon, more like it. Whitening the more
than three hundred heads that have remained intact after the fire along the path.
The heads are of young men, the elderly, and women. The devastating locusts
While my mule jumps over the craniums like river stones, I think:
Where is the soul?... Does the soul exist?... What about the conscience?... Does
ponders metaphysical conundrums atop a heap of charred bodies reduced to bone and
cinder. The narrator resorts to a highly poetic form of direct speech to address the
PAC
Postscript
Batista:
The
Bigoted
Education
14
macabre scene and convey a sense of culpability: the biblical allusion of a plague to
characterize the military and reservists, the personification of the moon as his conscience,
and the enumeration of metaphysical and moral rhetorical questions. The shockingly
ghastly scenario seems to brilliantly subvert arielista discourse as it pits the horrors of
genocide against the quaint musings of the narrator as egoist dilettante. The absurdity
of the situation begs for a redefinition of justice, a reformulation of a just society, and a
vocation of identifying with the Haitian Other. However, in context, the critique is
contained, for even though the episode seems to undermine Henrquez Ureas cultural
project based on so-called universal ideals and the deliberate exclusion of local politics, it
actually serves as a reinforcement of the status quo given the narrators willingness to
pose as a poet, for his own literary gain and the potential greater glory of Culture, at the
image that expresses the dark side of the execution of arielismo as a utopian project.
Finally, in another important chapter, the narrator recounts a disturbing dream that
seems to disinter the historical memory of the 1822 Haitian invasion of Hispaniola
course, is that of the Spanish clergy and colonial officials as well as the landed Creole
elite. The nightmare, as the narrator recalls, parades a chorus of voices including those of
the perpetrators. The Haitian leaders like Toussaint LOuverture are depicted as
bloodthirsty men of superstition motivated by hate and revenge against the French
colonists and Napoleons army (Prestol Castillo 178). The dream makes strikingly vivid
PAC
Postscript
Batista:
The
Bigoted
Education
15
the official historical accounts of the Haitian invasion: the flight eastward to avoid the
invading army, the fires that burned entire towns to the ground, the rapes, mutilations,
unpardonable 1937 genocide. The entire episode begins with the narrator in a state of
delirium and a visit from a clergyman who may or may not be part of the nightmare:
That black priest arrived. He sat by my side. He began to speak to me. Then, at my
bedside, tenebrous shadow figures began to arrive. Lleg aquel sacerdote negro. Se
figuras en sombra, tenebrosas. (Prestol Castillo 178). Given his complicity, the dream
serves as a rationalization for the genocide and subsequent cover up to ease the narrators
conscience. Moreover, the incorporation of the dream in the narrators writings suggests
the inescapable power of the dictatorships ideology. The priest represents the powerful
institution of the church and its collaboration with the state in sustaining the dominant
ideology. Ultimately, the dreamscape underscores the narrators usefulness to the regime
as an unconscious perpetuator of the status quo, even when he seems to undermine the
prevailing discourse as dilettante, or as one who fails to live out his vocation as
Conclusion
The narrator is a youth trying to fulfill the calling of his upper middle-class upbringing
but struggles with the gruesome reality of the states concrete plans to make the utopian
PAC
Postscript
Batista:
The
Bigoted
Education
16
ideal that informs his social group by exterminating its Other, the Haitian. Unable to
silence the horrors by blindly adopting Pedro Henrquez Ureas prescription of purity
off-script and instead of strictly writing a personal journal of self-discovery, he mixes his
personal ruminations of a spiritual quest and keen insights drawn from childhood
experiences with scenes and testimonies of the genocide (which he may or may not have
since it contests the official story of the 1937 genocide, and betrays his class interest.
crimes against humanity and his own stories of personal, artistic and sentimental
challenges condemn him, if not the implied author, as the subject of an ideology that
facilitates the perpetuation of arielista discourse through its own educators like Sr.
Maestro, scholars like Dr. Fradrquez, and, perhaps, the unqualified canonization of
thinkers like Jos Enrique Rod. Ironically, by failing to live up to Henrquez Ureas
ideal of a scholar, and ultimately embodying the disparaged egoist dilettante, the
narrator exposes a thoroughly corrupt society that engenders a people willing to betray
their own human dignity and suppress their own moral compass for the sake of a
Althusser, Louis. Trans. Ben Brewster. Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses
---. La utopa de Amrica en Pedro Henrquez Urea. In Ensayos sobre Alfonso Reyes y
Henrquez, Urea P, and Odals Prez. Pedro Henrquez Urea: Historia cultural,
2010. Print.
Mart, Jos. Nuestra Amrica in Ensayo Cubano del Siglo XX. Antologa. Comp. and
Prologue Rafael Hernndez and Rafael Rojas. D.F.: Fondo de Cultura Econmica,
2002. Print.
Mora Rodriguez, Arnoldo. El arielismo: de Rod a Garca Monge. San Jos, Costa Rica:
Prestol Castillo, Freddy. El masacre se pasa a pie. Santo Domingo: Ediciones de Taller,
1998. Print.
PAC
Postscript
Batista:
The
Bigoted
Education
18
Rod, Jos E, and Beln Castro. Ariel. Series: Coleccin Letras Hispnicas. Madrid:
Sommer, Doris. El Masacre se pasa a pie: Guilt and Impotence under Trujillo. Studies