Septum Magnet Injection
Septum Magnet Injection
Abstract
An accelerator has limited dynamic range: a chain of accelerators is required
to reach high energy. A combination of septa and kicker magnets is
frequently used to inject and extract beam from each stage. The kicker
magnets typically produce rectangular field pulses with fast rise- and/or fall-
times, however the field strength is relatively low. To compensate for their
relatively low field strength, the kicker magnets are generally combined with
electromagnetic septa. The septa provide relatively strong field strength but
are either DC or slow pulsed. This paper discusses injection and extraction
systems with particular emphasis on the hardware required for the septa.
1 Introduction
An accelerator has limited dynamic range: a chain of accelerators is required to reach high energy.
Thus beam transfer into (injection) and out of (extraction) an accelerator is required. The design of the
injection and extraction systems aims to achieve the following:
minimize beam loss,
place the newly injected or extracted particles onto the correct trajectory, with the correct
phase space parameters.
A combination of septa and kicker magnets is frequently used for injection and extraction. Septa
can be electrostatic or magnetic: they provide slower field rise- and fall-times, but stronger field than
kicker magnets. Some septa are designed to be operated with DC. Kicker magnets provide fast field
rise- and fall-times, but relatively weak fields.
This paper of the CERN Accelerator School discusses the processes of injection and extraction
as well as the hardware associated with the septa. The hardware associated with the kicker magnets is
covered in the paper Injection and extraction magnets: kicker magnets.
In general, a septum (plural: septa) is a partition that separates two cavities or spaces. In a
particle accelerator a septum is a device which separates two field regions. Important features of septa
are an ideally homogeneous (electric or magnetic) field in one region, for deflecting beam, and a low
fringe field (ideally zero magnetic and electric field) next to the septum so as not to affect the
circulating beam. Hence a septum provides a space separation of circulating and injected/extracted
beam. By contrast a kicker magnet provides time selection (separation) of beam to be
injected/extracted.
2 Injection
Injection is the process of transferring a particle beam into a circular accelerator or accumulator ring,
at the appropriate time, while minimizing beam loss and placing the injected particles onto the correct
trajectory, with the correct phase space parameters. Injection methods include
single-turn (fast) hadron injection,
multi-turn hadron injection,
charge-exchange H- injection,
lepton injection.
The injected beam passes through the high field region of the septum once only and thus the
degree of field homogeneity is not as critical as for a dipole magnet installed in an accelerator ring.
However, the circulating beam passes through the field-free region many times, so that achieving a
very low level of stray field in the field-free region is important.
The kicker magnet is installed in the accelerator and hence the circulating beam is in the
aperture of the kicker. Thus the kicker field must rise from zero to full field in the time interval
between the circulating beam and the start of the injected beam (Fig. 1, top right) and fall from full
field to zero field in the time interval between the end of the injected beam and the subsequent
circulating beam (Fig. 1, top right). The kicker magnet is discussed in more detail in the proceedings
of this CERN Accelerator School, in the paper Injection and extraction magnets: kicker magnets.
Figure 2 shows an example of fast single-turn injection in two planes: a Lambertson septum (see
Section 5.2.4) is used for a two-plane injection scheme. The injected beam passes through the
homogeneous field region of the septum: circulating beam is in the field-free region of the septum. In
the example shown in Fig. 2 the septum deflects the beam horizontally to the centre of the kicker
magnet; the kicker magnet deflects the beam vertically onto the closed orbit. The septum and kicker
are either side of an F-quadrupole (horizontally focusing and vertically defocusing) to minimize the
required strength of the kicker magnet.
Figure 3 shows an example of multi-turn hadron injection: no kicker magnet is required. The
orbit bump is reduced with time so that the early beam occupies the central region of the horizontal
acceptance and the later beam the periphery of the acceptance: this technique is known as phase space
painting. At the end of the injection the beam bump is reduced to zero.
2.3 Charge-exchange H- injection
Multi-turn injection is essential to accumulate high intensity. Disadvantages inherent in using an
injection septum include [2]
septum thickness of several millimetres reduces aperture,
beam losses resulting from circulating beam hitting the septum render it radioactive,
number of injected turns limited to 1020.
Charge-exchange injection provides an elegant alternative method of injection. A uniform
transverse phase space density is painted by modifying a closed orbit bump and steering injected beam
[1, 2] (Fig. 4 and Fig. 5). The conversion from H- ion to p+ means that the protons can be accumulated
into already-occupied phase space, which allows very high densities to be achieved with relatively low
losses.
3 Extraction
Extraction is the process of removing a particle beam from an accelerator to a transfer line or a beam
dump, at the appropriate time, while minimizing beam loss and placing the extracted particles onto the
correct trajectory, with the correct phase space parameters. Extraction methods include
single-turn (fast) extraction,
non-resonant multi-turn extraction,
resonant multi-turn (slow) extraction.
Extraction usually occurs at higher energy than injection, hence stronger elements (larger B.dl)
are required. At high energies many kicker and septum modules may be needed. To reduce the
required strength of the kicker magnet, the beam can be moved near to a septum by a closed orbit
bump.
The kicker magnet is installed in the accelerator and hence the circulating beam is in the
aperture of the kicker. Thus the kicker field must rise from zero to full field in a beam-free time
interval deliberately created in the circulating beam (Fig. 7, top right). The entire beam is generally
extracted and hence fast fall-time is typically not required: however, sometimes, bunch-by-bunch
transfers are made and then the field of the kicker magnets must have fast rise- and fall-times [3]. The
kicker magnet is discussed in more detail in the proceedings of this CAS, in the paper Injection and
extraction magnets: kicker magnets.
4 Deflection of beam
The force used to direct a charged particle beam is known as the Lorentz force. The Lorentz force is
given by Eq. (1):
(1)
where
F is the force (N),
E is the electric field (V/m),
B is the magnetic field (T),
q is the electric charge of the particle (C),
v is the instantaneous velocity of the particle (m/s),
is the vector cross product.
The deflection of a charged particle beam in a magnetic field is given by Eq. (2) [5]:
(2)
where
By is the magnetic flux density in the y-direction (T),
p is the beam momentum (GeV/c),
leff is the effective length of the magnet [usually different from the mechanical length, due to
fringe fields at the ends of the magnet] (m), and
B,x is the deflection angle, in the x-direction, due to magnetic field By (radians).
The deflection of a charged particle beam in an electric field is given by Eq. (3) [5]:
(3)
where
V is the potential difference between plates (V),
d is the separation of the plates (m),
Ex is the electric field in the x-direction (V/m),
is a unit-less quantity that specifies the fraction of the speed of light at which the particles
travel (v/c), and
E,x is the deflection angle, in the x-direction, due to electric field Ex (radians).
5 Septa
Two main types of septa exist, namely electrostatic septa and magnetic septa:
an electrostatic septum is a DC electrostatic device with very thin (typically 100 m)
separation between the zero field and high field regions,
a magnetic septum is either a pulsed or DC dipole magnet with a thin (typically 2 mm to
20 mm) separation between the zero-field and high-field regions.
One of the significant challenges associated with the design of a septum is to achieve a low
leakage field next to the septum, to avoid affecting the circulating beam, and the required field
homogeneity in the gap for deflecting beam.
In order to minimize losses during the extraction process, the goal is to construct a magnetic or
electrostatic septum with as thin a septum as possible. The thinnest septa are of the electrostatic type:
beam is deflected by accelerating the beam perpendicular to the initial beam direction using an electric
field. Using a septum which is as thin as possible increases extraction efficiency, reduces activation of
the equipment and minimizes the strengths required for other extraction elements such as kicker
magnets and/or preceding septa.
Fig. 14: Third harmonic circuit and example waveforms for a pulsed magnetic septum
Fig. 17: Idealized septum magnet; minimum clearance between single-turn coil and C-type yoke
However, in reality, there is a small space between the coil and yoke which is not occupied by
conductor. In addition, a multi-turn septum has, by necessity, insulation between the individual
windings, thus the current density is not uniform. Further the presence of cooling channels (e.g.,
Fig. 12) affects the uniformity of the current density. The overall effect of insulation and cooling is to
increase the leakage field which, if other measures are not taken, could be up to ~2% of the gap field:
in addition the field inhomogeneity in the gap can be up to 2%.
In a thin edge-cooled septum the high temperature gradient changes the local resistivity of the
septum conductor and thus the uniformity of the current density: to achieve a more uniform current
density, the septum is profiled to compensate for the resistivity change resulting from the temperature
gradient. In addition a significant increase in the temperature of the coil and power connections can
lead to load changes as seen by the power supply: thus suitable regulation of the power supply is
required.
A small septum conductor thickness results in high current density, high thermal loads and high
mechanical stress on the coil. Thus cooling is a major design consideration for a septum magnet. The
flow characteristics (laminar/turbulent/mixed) in the cooling tube are dependent on the Reynolds
number (Re):
(4)
where
is the density of the cooling fluid (kgm3),
Um is the mean velocity of the cooling fluid (m/s),
D is the diameter of the cooling tube (m), and
is the dynamic viscosity of the cooling fluid (Nsm2).
Excessive cooling flow rate will lead to cavitation and erosion. Thus the cooling circuit must be
designed for optimum flow conditions: turbulent flow results in best heat exchange, but laminar flow
results in low erosion and cavitation. An optimum flow-condition typically corresponds to a turbulent
flow with water speeds up to 10 m/s [11].
Fig. 18: To reduce apparent septum thickness, complex, thin-walled, vacuum chambers can be used (LHS),
around which the septum magnet can be clamped (RHS)
To reduce apparent septum thickness even further, the magnetic septum can be put under
vacuum. To reach UHV, pumping is required and bake-out may be necessary which requires suitable
mechanical design and all the relevant heating equipment. In this case under vacuum heaters, heating
jackets, reflectors, ceramic insulators, etc. are required. In some cases, where pressure is critical, a
Non-Evaporable Getter (NEG) coating may have to be applied to the chambers, which requires
activation systems.
(5)
where
B is the flux-density in the gap (T),
Is is the current in the septum conductor (A), and
ls is the length of the septum conductor (m).
The force on the conductor can exceed 10 kN: such force results in deflection of the conductor,
of up to 40 m, which can result in fatigue failure for a pulsed septum. The coil fixation, for a pulsed
septum, is designed to be flexible and therefore uses springs (Fig. 19). The springs can be made of
beryllium copper alloy and are inserted at regular intervals along the length of the coil: the spring is in
contact with the septum via a lever which is then clamped in a slot in the magnet yoke (Fig. 19).
Acknowledgements
The authors wish to acknowledge the contributions of B. Balhan, J-M. Cravero, M. Gyr, and
T. Masson to this article.
References
[1] G.H. Rees, Injection, CAS - CERN Accelerator School: 5th General accelerator physics course,
Jyvskyl, Finland, 1992, CERN 94-01 v 2.
[2] B. Goddard, Transfer lines, Introduction to Accelerator Physics 2009, February 2327, 2009, La
Villa du Lac, Divonne, France, http://indico.cern.ch/conferenceDisplay.py?confId=43703
[3] G.H. Rees, Extraction, CAS - CERN Accelerator School: 5th General accelerator physics
course, Jyvskyl, Finland, 1992, CERN 94-01 v 2.
[4] O. Bruning, CERN complex, Introduction to Accelerator Physics 2009, February 2327, 2009,
La Villa du Lac, Divonne, France, http://indico.cern.ch/conferenceDisplay.py?confId=43703.
[5] C. Bovet, R. Gouiran, I. Gumowski, K.H. Reich, A selection of formulae and data useful for the
design of A.G. synchrotrons, CERN/MPSSI/Int. DL/70/4.
[6] J-M. Cravero and J.P. Royer, The new pulsed power converter for the septum magnet in the PS
straight section 42, CERN PS/PO/ Note 97-03, 1997.
[7] J.P. Royer, High current with precision flat-top capacitor discharge power converters for pulsed
septum magnets, CERN/PS 95-13 (PO), 1995.
[8] M.J. Barnes, B. Balhan, J. Borburgh, T. Fowler, B. Goddard, W.J.M. Weterings, A. Ueda,
Development of an eddy current septum for Linac4, Proc. 11th European Particle Accelerator
Conference (EPAC'08), Genoa, Italy, June 2327, 2008, pp. 14341436.
[9] P. Lebasque et al., Eddy current septum magnets for booster injection and extraction and
storage ring injection at synchrotron soleil, Proc. 10th European Particle Accelerator Conference
(EPAC'06), Edinburgh, Scotland, June 2630, 2006, pp. 35113513.
[10] S. Bidon et al., Steel septum magnets for the LHC beam injection and extraction, Proc. 8th
European Particle Accelerator Conference (EPAC'02), Paris, June 38, 2002, pp. 25142516.
[11] R.L. Keizer, Calculation of DC operated septum magnets cooling problems, CERN SI/Int.
MAE/71-1.
Bibliography
J. Borburgh, M. Crescenti, M. Hourican, T. Masson, Design and construction of the LEIR extraction
septum, IEEE Trans. on Applied Superconductivity, Vol. 16, No. 2, June 2006.
J. Borburgh, B. Balhan, T. Fowler, M. Hourican, W.J.M. Weterings, Septa and distributor
developments for H- injection into the booster from Linac4, Proc. 11th European Particle Accelerator
Conference (EPAC'08), Genoa, Italy, June 2327, 2008, pp. 23382340.
Y. Yonemure et al., Beam extraction of the POP FFAG with a massless septum, Proc. 20th Particle
Accelerator Conference (PAC03), Portland, Oregon, USA, May 1216, 2003, pp. 16791681.
S. Fartoukh, A semi-analytical method to generate an arbritrary 2D magnetic field and determine the
associated current distribution, LHC Project Report 1012, CERN.
Y. Iwashite, A. Noda, Massless septum with hybrid magnet, Proc. 6th European Particle Accelerator
Conference (EPAC'98), Stockholm, Sweden, June 2226, 1998, pp. 21092110.
I. Sakai et al., Operation of an opposite field septum for the J-Parc main ring injection, Proc. 10th
European Particle Accelerator Conference (EPAC'06), Edinburgh, Scotland, June 2630, 2006,
pp. 17501752.
M. Benedikt, P. Collier, V. Mertens, J. Poole, K. Schindl (Eds.), LHC Design Report, volume III, The
LHC injector chain, http://ab-div.web.cern.ch/ab-div/Publications/LHC-DesignReport.html, CERN,
Geneva, 2004, CERN-2004-003.
E. Dallago, G. Venchi, S. Rossi, M. Pullia, T. Fowler, M.B. Larsen, The power supply for the beam
chopper magnets of a medical synchrotron, 37th IEEE Power Electronics Specialists Conference, 2006,
(PESC '06), Jeju, Korea, June 1822, 2006.