Scribd
Upload
30 views

Team Project Marks 4 Number of Members 3 Team Members Contribution As Per Task Breakdown Sheet Individual Marks

This document summarizes the marks received and feedback provided for a team project submitted by students Yasmin, James, and Umar. Each student contributed equally at 33.3% to the project and received the full 4 marks. The comments note that the report pages were not numbered properly and ask for the names of the submitting students. Specific feedback is provided for the Flood Frequency Analysis, Culvert Design, and Drainage Design sections. Issues are identified with calculations and explanations for the Flood Frequency Analysis and Drainage Design sections. The Culvert Design received full marks but the comments note that more explanation would have been better.

Uploaded by

James Mellan
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
30 views

Team Project Marks 4 Number of Members 3 Team Members Contribution As Per Task Breakdown Sheet Individual Marks

This document summarizes the marks received and feedback provided for a team project submitted by students Yasmin, James, and Umar. Each student contributed equally at 33.3% to the project and received the full 4 marks. The comments note that the report pages were not numbered properly and ask for the names of the submitting students. Specific feedback is provided for the Flood Frequency Analysis, Culvert Design, and Drainage Design sections. Issues are identified with calculations and explanations for the Flood Frequency Analysis and Drainage Design sections. The Culvert Design received full marks but the comments note that more explanation would have been better.

Uploaded by

James Mellan
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 1

FLEX3 Team

Team Project
Marks 4
Number of
Members 3
Contribution as per Individual
Team Members
Task Breakdown sheet marks
Yasmin 33.3% 4.0
James 33.3% 4.0
Umar 33.3% 4.0
0.0% 0.0

Comments:
Write name of the students who submit the report.
Pages are not regular. Multiple starts of page 1.

Flood frequency Analysis (Total marks 2) 0.5

No details on frequency calculations page 36 pdf. You need to show


detail procedure and explain the steps of how did you get the flow of
different return periods. Just showing the magnitude does not
demonstrate if the correct procedure was followed. This is particularly
important where any answer is possible (as in this case) but depends
on the assumptions you made and rational you used to make such
assumptions.

Culvert design: (Total marks 3) 3

Good but more explain would be better.

Drainage Design: (Total Marks 5) 0.5


Longest time of concentration is not to be assumed (page 15)
but to be calculated.
It is not communicated properly how the time of concentration
were determined.
You are mixing the units. Discharge calculated in page 16 is
3.13 m3/s (page16) whereas you used it as 3.13 L/s in page 19.
Pipe should be designed inlet to inlet. You have not identified
inlet locations how did you determine pipe sections like FG or
GH etc?
Why design steps are repeated page 20-22 and 29-33.

You might also like