Shift Work: A Risk Factor For Central Serous Chorioretinopathy
Shift Work: A Risk Factor For Central Serous Chorioretinopathy
Chorioretinopathy
PURPOSE: To investigate if shift work or sleep distur- and focal serous detachments of the neurosensory retina
bances are risk factors for central serous chorioretinop- and retinal pigment epithelium alterations. The role of
athy (CSCR). choroid hyperpermeability in the pathogenesis of CSCR
DESIGN: Prospective case-control study. has been well documented recently with multimodal imag-
METHODS: Forty patients with active CSCR and 40 ing modalities.2 In CSCR patients, a thick choroid has
controls (age- and sex-matched) were prospectively been reported not only in the affected eye but also in the
recruited from the Ophthalmology Department of Hotel fellow eye, which is consistent with bilateral choroidal
Dieu Hospital, Paris, between November 2013 and hyperpermeability.2,3
December 2014. All patients were asked to complete a To date, several risk factors for CSCR have been
questionnaire addressing previously described risk factors identified,3 and the most consistent is corticosteroid
and working hours, as well as the Insomnia Severity exposure from therapeutic administration or from endog-
Index (ISI), a validated instrument for assessing sleep enous overproduction, as in Cushing syndrome.46
disturbances. Corticosteroids were recently shown to induce
RESULTS: The mean age of the CSCR group was 44 9 choroidal vasodilation through mineralocorticoid
years, whereas the mean age of the control group was receptor activation in animal models.3 CSCR has also
43 10 years. By use of multivariate analysis, shift been associated with increased sympathetic activity7
work (odds ratio [OR] [95% confidence interval]: 5 and sympathomimetic medication.8 Psychological stress9
[1.220.4]; P [ .02), steroid use (OR: 5.5 [1.126.2]; and type A personality10 with narcissistic traits11
P [ .03), and recent psychological stress (OR: have also been identified as contributing factors.
15.3 [4.154.5]; P < .001) were found to be indepen- Additional associations have been reported with hyper-
dently associated with CSCR. tension, coronary heart disease, peptic ulcer disease,
CONCLUSION: The outcomes of this study suggest that antihistamines, antibiotics, and psychopharmacologic
shift work is an independent risk factor of CSCR. Further medications.6,12
studies are required to confirm these results and to Shift work includes work hours that fall outside the
examine if work reconversion would be beneficial in the standard daylight hours (7 AM to 6/7 PM),13 including
treatment of patients with chronic/recurrent evening, night, morning, rotating, and irregular shifts.14
CSCR. (Am J Ophthalmol 2016;165:2328. 2016 In industrialized countries, 15%20% of the work force
Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.) have regular shift work.1315 It leads to circadian
misalignment and sleep disturbances that have been
associated with increased risk of obesity, diabetes,
C
ENTRAL SEROUS CHORIORETINOPATHY (CSCR) IS A
cardiovascular disease, depression, and cancer.16,17
chorioretinal disease that most often affects
Mechanisms underlying these health problems are not
middle-aged men.1 It is characterized by posterior
fully elucidated but are thought to be related to sleep and
circadian disruption.14 Indeed, sleep disturbances have
Supplemental Material available at AJO.com. been associated with increased activities of the
Accepted for publication Feb 15, 2016. hypothalamic-pituitary adrenal axis and the autonomic
From the Department of Ophthalmology (E.B., M.D., M.L., P.-R.R., sympathoadrenal system, characterized by altered secretion
T.B.) and Sleep and Vigilance Center (V.B., D.L.), Hotel-Dieu of Paris,
Assistance Publique-Hopitaux de Paris, AP-HP, Paris, France, of cortisol and catecholamine hormones.18
Universite Sorbonne Paris Cite, Paris, France; Inserm U1138, Team 17, Since CSCR patients have higher levels of urine and
Universite Sorbonne Paris Cite, Universite Pierre et Marie Curie,
Centre de Recherche des Cordeliers, Paris, France (E.B., P.-R.R., F.B.-
plasma cortisol compared with the control group 19,20
C.); and Department of Ophthalmology University of Lausanne, Jules and increased levels of plasma catecholamines,21 we
Gonin Ophthalmic Hospital, Fondation Asile des Aveugles, Lausanne, questioned whether shift work and/or sleep disturbance
Switzerland (C.B., A.D., F.B.-C.).
Inquiries to Elodie Bousquet, Hopital Hotel Dieu, 1 Parvis Notre Dame, evaluated by the Insomnia Severity Index (ISI) could
75004 Paris, France; e-mail: [email protected] be risk factors for CSCR.
Society of Ophthalmology approved this study. Informed Age, years 44.1 6 8.6 43 6 10.1 - - .6
signed consent was obtained from all subjects in compli- (mean 6 SD)
ance with the tenets of the Helsinki agreement. Male (%) 85 85 - - 1
Patients of working age between 20 and 60 years and Sleep disorders 23 (57.5%) 6 (15%) 7.6 2.721.7 <.001
presenting symptoms of CSCR were enrolled. Active (ISI >10), n (%)
CSCR was defined as a localized serous retinal detachment Shift work, n (%) 17 (42.5%) 6 (15%) 4.6 1.511.9 .007
on optical coherence tomography associated with angio- Steroid use, 15 (37.5%) 4 (10%) 5.4 1.717.3 .007
graphic leakage on fluorescein angiography without signs n (%)
Stress, n (%) 27 (67.5%) 5 (12.5%) 14.5 4.844.1 <.001
of choroidal neovascularization, polypoidal choroidal
Hypertension, 9 (22.5%) 3 (7.5%) 3.6 0.9613.3 .06
vasculopathy, or inflammation. Chronic CSCR was defined
n (%)
by the persistence of serous retinal detachment (SRD) for Depression, n (%) 7 (17.5%) 9 (22.5%) 0.7 0.22.1 .6
more than 6 months and/or with recurrent SRD associated Allergic disease, 13 (32.5%) 14 (35%) 0.9 0.42.2 .8
with widespread decompensation of the retinal pigment n (%)
epithelium.22 Tobacco use, 17 (42.5%) 12 (30%) 1.7 0.74.3 .2
Control patients were matched for age and sex at a ratio n (%)
of 1:1 and recruited at the emergency consultation with Alcohol use, 6 (15%) 4 (10%) 1.6 0.45.8 .5
ocular complaint but with no previous or ongoing retinal n (%)
pathology. The frequency of diseases including conjuncti-
CSCR central serous chorioretinopathy; ISI insomnia
vitis, blepharitis, chalazion, dry eye, keratitis, anterior
severity index.
uveitis, refractive disorders, vitreous floaters, eye contu-
sion, endophthalmitis, and migraine could not exceed
10% of the whole sample.
off score of 10 has been previously selected to detect
insomnia (86.1% sensitivity and 87.7% specificity).17
STUDY PROTOCOL: All patients were asked to complete
study questionnaires, which included an ISI questionnaire STATISTICAL ANALYSIS: The data obtained were
in addition to questions addressing previously identified analyzed with independent t test or Mann-Whitney test for
risk factors such as history of systemic diseases (hyperten- continuous variables. Categorical variables were compared
sion, depression, allergic disease), current medication (cur- using x2 or Fisher exact test. Risk factors were initially
rent or recent [<3 months] corticosteroid intake [oral, analyzed using univariate linear regression analysis. Those
intranasal, inhalational, topical skin application, intrave- with statistical significance on univariate analysis were
nous, intramuscular, eye drop]), and degree of alcohol or included in multivariate analysis using logistic regression
tobacco use. Recent psychological stresses including life with forward stepwise selection (stepAIC, MASS package).
changes (death, divorce, familial strife, layoff) and stress Statistical analyses were performed with R version 3.1.3 (R
at work were also assessed. Participants provided informa- foundation of Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria). A
tion on present and past (<1 year) working hours. Shift P value of less than .05 was considered significant.
work was defined as work starting before 7:00 AM or finish-
ing after 7:00 PM, and thus included evening, night, or
early morning working within this broader schema.
RESULTS
INSOMNIA SEVERITY INDEX: Sleep disturbances were PATIENT CHARACTERISTICS: A total of 40 CSCR
evaluated using the ISI, which is a widely used instrument patients were compared with 40 sex- and age-matched con-
for evaluating insomnia symptoms and severity.23 The ISI trol patients (Table 1). The mean age (6 standard devia-
is a 7-item self-report questionnaire assessing the severity tion [SD]) of the CSCR group was 44.1 6 8.6 years,
of sleep onset, sleep maintenance, early-morning awak- whereas the mean age of the control group was 43 6 10.1
ening problems, sleep dissatisfaction, interference of sleep years (P .6). Both the CSCR and the control groups
difficulties with daytime functioning, noticeability of sleep were composed of 34 male (85%) and 6 female patients
problems by others, and distress caused by the sleep diffi- (15%), with a male-to-female ratio of 5.6:1.
culties, with a total score ranging from 0 to 28 In the CSCR group, 26 patients (65%) had an acute form
(Supplementary Material, available at AJO.com).17 A cut- of the disease and 14 patients (35%) had a chronic CSCR,
defined by the persistence of the SRD for more than Recent psychological stress was reported in 27 CSCR
6 months and/or with recurrent SRD associated with bilat- patients (67.5%) and in 5 control patients (12.5%;
eral widespread retinal pigment epithelium alterations.22 P < .001; OR: 14.5 [4.844.1], Table 1). Among the 27
CSCR patients, 14 patients reported stressful life changes
UNIVARIATE ANALYSIS: Previously reported risk factors, (death, disease, divorce, familial strife, layoff) and 13
sleep disturbance, and shift work were first analyzed with patients reported stress at work. The 5 control patients
univariate analysis (Table 1). reported work-related stress.
Sleep disturbances evaluated with the ISI questionnaire Other previously reported risk factors, such as hyperten-
occurred more frequently in patients with CSCR (57.5% sion, depression, allergy, and tobacco or alcohol use, were
had ISI score >10) than it did in the control group not statistically significantly different in CSCR and control
(15%; P < .001; odds ratio [OR] [95% confidence interval]: groups (Table 1).
7.6 [2.721.7]; Table 1). Moreover, the mean of the ISI
score (6 SD) was significantly higher in the CSCR group MULTIVARIATE LOGISTIC REGRESSION
(9.6 6 6.2) than in the control group (4.1 6 4.5; ANALYSIS: A stepwise logistic regression confirmed the
P < .001; Figure). We also examined the relationship following risk factors (Table 2): shift work (P .02; OR:
between CSCR type and sleep disorders, which were 5 [1.220.4]), corticosteroid use (P .03; OR: 5.5
more frequently observed in cases of chronic CSCR [1.126.2]), and recent psychological stress (P < .001;
(78.6% had ISI score >10) than in acute CSCR (46.1%; OR: 15.3 [4.154.5]).
P < .05).
Seventeen CSCR patients (42.5%) had performed shift
work, vs 6 patients (15%) in the control group (P .007;
OR: 4.6 [1.511.9], Table 1). Shift workers had a higher
ISI score than day workers (ISI mean 6 SD, shift workers: DISCUSSION
10.9 6 5.5 vs day workers: 5.2 6 5.5; P < .001).
Previously reported risk factors were also analyzed. IN THIS STUDY, SHIFT WORK AND SLEEP DISTURBANCE WERE
Corticosteroid use was present or reported in the reported significantly more frequently in CSCR patients
3 months before the first CSCR symptoms in 15 patients than in matched control individuals. Shift work was re-
(37.5%) of the CSCR group and 4 patients (10%) in the ported by 15% of individuals in the control group, consis-
control group (P .007; OR: 5.4 [1.717.3], Table 1). tent with the percentage of shift workers in the
Among the 15 CSCR patients, use of corticosteroids industrialized countries.14 However, in the CRSC patients
was topical skin application in 5 patients (33.3%), intra- this was elevated to 42.5%. We can speculate that shift
nasal administration in 4 patients (26.7%), oral medica- work could affect the course and the severity of CSCR.
tion in 4 patients (26.7%), intravenous injection in Indeed, sleep disturbances were found more frequently in
1 patient (6.7%), and intramuscular injection in 1 pa- chronic CSCR than in the acute form. In our study data,
tient (6.7%). In the control group, among the 4 patients shift workers had a higher ISI score than day workers;
reporting corticosteroid use, 2 reported eye drop, this agrees well with previous studies, which reported a
1 topical skin application, and 1 oral corticosteroid strong association between shift work and sleep distur-
administration. bance.15,24,25
FUNDING/SUPPORT: THIS WORK WAS SUPPORTED BY GRANTS FROM THE FONDATION VISIO. FINANCIAL DISCLOSURES: THE
following authors have no financial disclosures: Elodie Bousquet, Myriam Dhundass, Mathieu Lehmann, Pierre-Raphael Rothschild, Virginie Bayon,
Damien Leger, Ciara Bergin, Ali Dirani, Talal Beydoun, and Francine Behar-Cohen. All authors attest that they meet the current ICMJE criteria for
authorship.