Musictherapyandmusic Medicineforchildrenand Adolescents: Olivia Swedberg Yinger,, Lori Gooding
Musictherapyandmusic Medicineforchildrenand Adolescents: Olivia Swedberg Yinger,, Lori Gooding
M e d i c i n e f o r C h i l d re n an d
Adolescents
Olivia Swedberg Yinger, PhD, MT-BC*, Lori Gooding, PhD, MT-BC
KEYWORDS
Music therapy Music medicine Child and adolescent psychiatry Mental health
Research
KEY POINTS
Neuroimaging research indicates that listening to preferred music activates reward cir-
cuitry in the brain and active musical participation engages more areas of the brain
than passive listening.
Music therapy is an established health care profession in which music is used within a
therapeutic relationship with a music therapist to accomplish nonmusic goals.
Emerging research indicates probable effectiveness of specific approaches to music ther-
apy with children and adolescent mental health consumers; however, further research is
necessary.
INTRODUCTION
Defining Music Therapy and Music Medicine
The American Music Therapy Association (AMTA) defines music therapy as: .the
clinical and evidence-based use of music interventions to accomplish individualized
goals within a therapeutic relationship by a credentialed professional who has
completed an approved music therapy program.1 Music therapists use music within
a therapeutic relationship to attend to individuals physical, emotional, cognitive, and
social needs. Although music therapists work with various populations, including indi-
viduals of all ages with medical/surgical needs or intellectual disabilities, more music
therapists work with persons who have behavioral/emotional disorders than any other
single population.2
Funding Sources: Johnson & Johnson/Society for the Arts in HealthCare (O.S. Yinger); National
Institute of Aging (L. Gooding).
Conflict of Interest: None.
University of Kentucky School of Music, College of Fine Arts, 105 Fine Arts, Lexington, KY
40506-0022, USA
* Corresponding author.
E-mail address: [email protected]
observed in the left ventral striatum, left dorsomedial midbrain, right thalamus, and
anterior cingulate cortex. In addition, decreases in cerebral blood flow were found
in the right amygdala, left hippocampus/amygdala, and ventromedial prefrontal cor-
tex. These areas have been associated with brain reward circuitry. Chills were also
associated with increases in heart rate, electromyography, and respiration. The con-
trol condition in this study consisted of participants listening to music that had been
selected by others but that did not elicit chills in the participant. This study shows
the importance of musical preference in eliciting desired results within music medicine
or music therapy.9
Results from a study by Menon and Levitin10 of 13 participants between the ages of
19 and 24 years, who listened to researcher-selected classical music while under-
going functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI), showed that listening to music
strongly modulates activity in mesolimbic structures responsible for reward process-
ing, such as the nucleus accumbens (NAc) and the ventral tegmental area (VTA), along
with the hypothalamus and insula. Correlations between responses in the NAc and the
VTA found in this study indicate that dopamine response may be associated with
musical response. The activation of the hypothalamus corroborates what has been
previously documented, that music listening has an impact on physiologic responses
controlled by the autonomic nervous system. Although the music used in this study
was not selected by participants and it is unclear whether it gave them chills, the
musical excerpts were rated as highly pleasant by a sample of similar individuals.
Results from a more recent study by Salimpoor and colleagues11 support the
findings of Menon and Levitin. In Salimpoor and colleagues11 study, 8 participants be-
tween the ages of 19 and 24 years listened to self-selected music that gave them chills
while undergoing PET scans. Endogenous dopamine release was found in the striatum
during music listening at the time of peak emotional arousal. Follow-up fMRI revealed
that the caudate was more involved during anticipation, whereas the NAc was more
involved during peak emotional arousal. Physiologic responses measured during mu-
sic listening showed a relationship between increases in heart rate, skin conductance,
and respiration, along with decreases in temperature and blood volume pulse ampli-
tude as the reported intensity of chills increased. Research showing the role of music
listening in activating the reward circuitry in the brain has important implications for
treatment of addictions, although more research remains to be done in this area.
Because music activates reward circuitry in the brain that is also activated by food,
drugs, and sex, future research should explore whether music can be used as a sub-
stitute for potentially harmful addictive behavior, or as a cue for adaptive coping
behavior as an alternative to addictive behavior.
In addition to addiction, music neuroscience research has implications for psychiat-
ric treatment with other various disorders, including disorders typically diagnosed in
childhood (such as autism), affective disorders, and eating disorders. Research on
the neurophysiologic effects of music for each of these populations are discussed.
Diagnostic terminology used in this article reflects that used by the investigators of
the individual studies reported, which may be based on the Diagnostic and Statistical
manual of Mental Disorders, Third Edition (DSM-III), DSM-IV, or DSM-IV Text Revision,
depending on when and where the article was published. Readers wishing to know
more about diagnostic criteria for participants in the studies reviewed are referred
to the original articles. Although awareness of a clients diagnosis is an important
component of music therapy research and guides treatment planning, music therapy
treatment is designed based on the individual needs of the client, regardless of their
diagnosis. For this reason, several studies reviewed here include descriptions of music
therapy treatment of groups of clients with various diagnoses that have similar needs.
4 Yinger & Gooding
Autism
A recent study by Emanuele and colleagues12 compared dopamine receptor expression
in peripheral blood lymphocytes in adult healthy musicians with age-matched and
gender-matched nonmusicians (controls) and adults with autism spectrum disorders
(ASD). Significant differences in DRD4 mRNA expression were found between the con-
trol group and both experimental groups (musicians and adults with ASD; P<.05). No
significant differences in DRD4 mRNA levels were found between musicians and adults
with ASD, nor were any significant differences found between groups in DRD3 mRNA
levels (P>.05).12 The finding that adults with ASD were similar to musicians in their levels
of DRD4 mRNA may help explain the pronounced interest in music that many individuals
with ASD display and provides a rationale for further research into the use of music ther-
apy with this population. Wan and colleagues13 proposed that music may serve as an
effective treatment of social communication in individuals with ASD by activating the
mirror neuron system, although more research in this area remains to be done.
Affective disorders
In a study by Field and colleagues,14 28 depressed adolescent females showed
increased activation of the right frontal lobe (a characteristic of chronic depression)
during pretest electroencephalography (EEG). Fourteen participants were randomly
assigned to listen to upbeat rock music while undergoing EEG. The other 14 partici-
pants served as a control group and were asked to relax their minds and their muscles
for the same period of time that the treatment group listened to music. The treatment
group showed significantly decreased right frontal lobe activation and increased left
frontal lobe activation during and after listening to the music (P<.05), both of which
are more typical of those without depression. The treatment group also showed signif-
icantly decreased salivary cortisol after listening to rock music (P 5 .02), although their
observed and reported mood did not change significantly (P>.05). The control group
did not show significant changes on any of the measures. The 3 participants in the
treatment group whose EEGs showed frontal lobe shifts further to the right while
listening to rock music reported preferring classical music over rock. When these 3
participants were tested again while listening to classical music, they showed frontal
lobe shifts to the left. This study shows the importance of considering preference when
designing music interventions.14
Koelsch and colleagues15 speculated that changes in anterior hippocampal activity
induced by music listening are relevant for individuals with depression or posttrau-
matic stress disorder, who show reduced hippocampal volume. In their 2010 study,
Koelsch and colleagues15 showed that participants who participated in socially
directed music-making showed improvements in mood compared with control partic-
ipants, who maintained a steady beat but lacked both the rich musical experience and
the social experience within the study condition. The results of the study by Koelsch
and colleagues may indicate the role of dopamine in socially directed music-
making. In animal research, zebra finches showed significant increases in dopamine
after socially directed singing compared with no singing or singing that was not
directed at another finch (P<.05).16 Although further research is necessary examining
the role of dopamine in socially directed music-making in humans, current findings
generally support the use of group music therapy over individual music therapy
when treating individuals with affective disorders. Information regarding group music
therapy is highlighted in relation to specific disorders later in the text.
Eating disorders
In a study by Uher and colleagues,17 women with eating disorders and healthy con-
trols were asked to rate line drawings of underweight, normal weight, and overweight.
Music Therapy for Children and Adolescents 5
Women with eating disorders showed weaker responses in the lateral fusiform gyrus
and the parietal cortex (measured by fMRI) when compared with healthy controls while
viewing line drawings of underweight, normal weight, and overweight female bodies.
Activity in the right medial apical prefrontal cortex was positively correlated with rat-
ings of fear and disgust reported by the participants with eating disorders.17 Because
decreases in ventromedial prefrontal cortex activity have been noted when partici-
pants listen to preferred music that gives them chills, further research regarding the
effectiveness of music therapy in treating eating disorders is warranted, as is research
into the therapeutic mechanism of music specific to treating this population.9
Although more neuroimaging research studying children and adolescents with spe-
cific psychopathologies is warranted, the current research suggests that the ability of
certain preferred music to activated neural reward circuits supports the use of music
therapy in mental health care. Box 1 summarizes important considerations when using
music in music therapy or music medicine, based on current neuroimaging research.
Box 1
Summary of recommendations based on music neuroscience research
Music therapists work with individuals of all age groups and with a wide range of
diagnoses, including children and adolescents with attention deficit/hyperactivity dis-
order (ADHD), posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), developmental delays/learning
difficulties, and anxiety disorders, patients with chronic mental illness, adults with sub-
stance abuse disorders and chemical dependence, victims of intimate partner
violence, and couples in counseling.37,46,47,57,6065 Music therapists work in a variety
of settings, including inpatient (acute and chronic), outpatient, and community
venues.37,61,62,65,66 Music therapists are often asked to work in situations in which
psychopharmacologic treatments have shown limited success. These situations
include working with individuals who present with negative symptoms, poor social
interactions, low motivation, and flattened or blunted affect.58,67 Referrals are often
made for patients with low motivation, and music therapy has been consistently
shown to be effective with individuals considered to be poor candidates for verbal
group therapies. Research suggests that this situation is in part caused by the ac-
tivation of basic perceptual and arousal mechanisms, which are associated with
an emotional response from individuals. The therapist can then use this affective-
motivational nature of music57(p69) to guide therapeutic change or behavioral
change.57,6769
Music therapy can facilitate symptom management and allow individuals to ex-
press feelings related to their experiences.68 Research increasingly shows its ef-
fectiveness in several areas of mental health treatment, including increased
participation, improved compliance, increased motivation during treatment, and
improved attendance (A Davis, unpublished masters thesis, State University of
New York at New Paltz, 2008).58,61,68 It has even been found to reduce symptoms,
increase competencies, and improve quality of life.44 Patients themselves often
have a positive response to music therapy. When surveyed, inpatients valued the
use of music therapy and found it helpful in improving aspects of psychiatric deficit
areas.59,62,70 Music therapy has been rated as more pleasurable than other forms of
treatment, and has been viewed by participants as an effective tool for recovery
(A Davis, unpublished masters thesis, State University of New York at New Paltz,
2008).71
Studies can be found involving music therapy treatment with a wide range of disor-
ders usually first diagnosed in childhood (including behavior disorders, ADHD, intellec-
tual disabilities, learning disabilities, and autism), as well as chemical dependence/
substance abuse, mood/anxiety disorders, and eating disorders. The next section
provides an overview of research on music therapy for children and adolescents
with mental health needs.
Effectiveness Research
Disorders typically diagnosed in childhood
According to a meta-analysis conducted by Gold and colleagues,38 music therapy has
a medium to large positive effect (d 5 .61, P<.001) on clinically relevant outcomes, and
children and adolescents with behavioral disorders, developmental disorders, and
multiple psychopathologies may benefit from music therapy. Specific goal areas for
individuals with childhood disorders are also addressed in the research literature,
including the effect of music therapy on attention and hyperactivity symptoms, the
impact of music therapy on self-esteem, and the impact of music therapy on self-
expression.22,30,33,38,50,53,72 Additional areas studied include the impact of music ther-
apy on social skills development, the effect of music therapy on aggressive behaviors,
and the effectiveness of music therapy in improving symptoms and quality of
life.22,26,32,37,52
8 Yinger & Gooding
Results from the literature have shown music therapy to be effective with a wide
variety of childhood diagnoses in22,23,26,28,30,32,37,50,52,53:
1. Reducing aggression and hostility
2. Reducing motor activities and increasing on-task behavior
3. Improving social functioning
4. Increasing attention and motivation
5. Improving self-concept
6. Improving symptoms and quality of life
The results of several key studies in this area are summarized here.
Aggressive behaviors
Choi and colleagues22 studied the effects of group music intervention on aggression
and self-esteem in children with highly aggressive behavior using a pretest/posttest
control group design. Significant differences were found between posttreatment
groups in scores of aggression (P<.001) and self-esteem (P<.05). A study by Montello
and Coons30 found that preadolescents with emotional, learning, and behavioral dis-
orders who received passive music therapy for 12 weeks followed by active music
therapy for 12 weeks showed significant improvements in attention, motivation, and
hostility (all P<.024). Participants who received active music therapy followed by
passive music therapy showed an initial increase in hostility (P<.05) during the active
music therapy phase, followed by a significant decrease in hostility during the passive
music therapy phase (P<.05). Because the groups in this study were made up of
preadolescents with diverse needs, the results indicate that the type of music therapy
treatment should be tailored to the individual needs of the clients.
ADHD
Cripe53 used a repeated measures factorial design to study the effects of rock music
on 8 males between the ages of 6 and 8 years with attention deficit disorder (the diag-
nostic terminology used at the time; most likely from DSM-III). Although no significant
changes in attention span were observed, participants showed significant reductions
in the number of motor activities performed during the music periods of the study
(P<.05). Gooding37 studied the effects of a music therapy-based social skills interven-
tion program on social competence of children and adolescents with a variety of diag-
noses including ADHD (using the DSM-IV definition) through 3 experiments with
participants in school, residential, and after-school care settings. Results indicated
significant improvements in on-task behavior in all 3 settings after 5 sessions, as
measured by behavioral observations (P<.05). Participants from all 3 settings also
showed improvements in social functioning as measured by either self-report or the
report of the researcher or a case manager (P<.05).
Autism
Research on music therapy for children with autism has received much attention from
music therapy researchers in recent years.24,40,7377 In 2011, Reschke-Hernandez77
published a historical review of music therapy treatments from 1940 to 2009 for
children with autism, which indicated that although research in this area has improved,
there is a need for more high-quality studies. Although it included few studies, a meta-
analysis conducted by Whipple40 suggests that music therapy is an effective treat-
ment of children and adolescents with autism, with an overall effect size of d 5 .77.
Outcomes of music therapy treatment of children with autism included improvements
in social behaviors, communication, and cognitive skills. Five of the 10 studies
included in Whipples meta-analysis were conducted by music therapists, whereas
the other 5 were conducted by occupational therapists, educators, or psychologists
using music medicine techniques. Two studies used a group treatment approach,
whereas the remaining 8 provided individual treatment. Four studies used a develop-
mental social pragmatic approach; 4 studies used a discrete trial-traditional behav-
ioral approach, and 2 studies used a contemporary applied behavioral analysis
approach. In this meta-analysis, all 3 approaches (developmental social pragmatic,
discrete trial-traditional behavioral, and contemporary applied behavioral analysis)
were found to be equally effective when incorporating music therapy treatment.40
Regardless of the positive outcomes noted in Whipples meta-analysis, further
research on the use of music therapy in treatment of children and adolescents with
autism is warranted, given the small number of studies.
were not appropriate. Most of the studies that reported effective or partially effective
results used music therapy to address social skills (81%) or academic skills (19%).
Substance abuse
According to current research, music therapy is effective in engaging patients in sub-
stance abuse treatment regardless of age (25 years and younger vs 25 years and
older) and substance use (alcohol only vs other drugs).79 When asked if they would
continue participation, 83% of individuals in a study conducted by Dingle and col-
leagues79 said Yes, with no differences because of age in motivation to participate
(X2(4) 5 7.44, not significant). Jones80 also found that music therapy can be effective in
evoking emotional change in substance abuse patients (P<.05). In addition, the data
suggest that music therapy can promote a healthy attitude toward self and recovery.29
James29 found that music therapy activities positively influenced adolescents
perceived locus of control and facilitated positive attitudes toward themselves and re-
covery. He studied the effects of values clarification within music therapy on adoles-
cents with substance abuse or dependency diagnoses, using a pretest-posttest
control group design. Significant differences between the experimental and control
groups were found in posttest scores (P<.05).29 Music therapy has even been shown
to be effective in promoting on-task behaviors (off-task during music 5 1%; 1.3%) in
women and adolescents with chemical addictions.36 Music therapy has been linked to
longer treatment stays. In a study by Ross and colleagues43 of dually diagnosed pa-
tients, those who attended more than 6 music therapy sessions had significantly
longer treatment stays (P<.05) than those who attended 6 or fewer, with attendance
being predictive of successful follow-up.
Mood/anxiety disorders
In 2008, Baker and Bor81 examined the relationship between music preference and
mental status in adolescents. The investigators concluded that there is limited support
for a connection between music preference and mental health status, stating that
music preference may indicate emotional vulnerability. There has also been some
research that suggests that music-based interventions can positively affect mood
and attitudes. Wooten54 examined the effects on adolescents of listening to preferred
music and found significant increases in positive affect after listening to preferred
music only (P 5 .038). Likewise, James29 found that music therapy activities positively
influenced adolescents perceived locus of control and facilitated positive attitudes
toward themselves and recovery.
Music therapy as an intervention for individuals with specific mood or anxiety disor-
ders has also been addressed in the literature. Hilliard31,48 examined the impact of mu-
sic therapy groups on mood and behavior in grieving children. Results of his studies
suggest that music therapy was effective in reducing grief symptoms. In his 2007
study on the effects of Orff-based music therapy and social work groups on childhood
grief symptoms and behaviors, Hilliard reported that a Wilcoxon signed rank test
revealed that children randomly assigned to a music therapy group showed significant
improvements in behaviors and grief symptoms (P<.05), whereas children who partic-
ipated in a social work group showed reductions in behavioral problems (P<.05) but
not grief symptoms (P>.05), and children in a wait-list control group did not improve
significantly in either area (P>.05). Likewise, Gardstrom51 investigated the use of
clinical music improvisation with adolescents ages 12 to 17 years with PTSD, bipolar
disorder, major depressive disorder, and other diagnoses in a partial hospitalization
program, in a qualitative study. She concluded that music was effective in evoking
emotions and allowing expression of feelings. Henderson27 studied the effects of a
Music Therapy for Children and Adolescents 11
music therapy program on mood awareness, group cohesion, and self-esteem in ad-
olescents diagnosed with adjustment reaction to adolescence. He found significant
improvements in use of group pronouns (as opposed to personal pronouns; P<.05)
and agreement on mood or emotion expressed in music (P 5 .01) for participants in
the music therapy treatment group.
Eating disorders
Research on music therapy and individuals with eating disorders is limited but shows
promise in using music therapy as an intervention for individuals with eating disorders.
In her 1994 article, Justice82 highlighted ways in which music therapy can be used to
treat individuals with anorexia and bulimia in inpatient treatment, including providing
support, facilitating self-regulation and coping, and promoting awareness. Robarts41
discussed the use of improvisation within music therapy to help adolescents with
anorexia develop assertiveness and a sense of self. McFerran49 highlighted how mu-
sic therapy can be used during group work to promote expression among individuals
with anorexia nervosa. In a retrospective study using a modified content analysis
approach, McFerran and colleagues25 identified themes discussed in songs written
by adolescents with anorexia that support the idea that songwriting can be used to
develop a sense of identity and positive self-talk. The themes most commonly used
by participants in this study during songwriting were identity formation (28.2% of
lyrics), relationship dynamics (17.4% of lyrics), and emotional awareness (17.2% of
lyrics). These investigators noted that songs were often effective in eliciting informa-
tion from participants that had not been disclosed to other team members. Partici-
pants were more willing to self-disclose information during music therapy sessions
than at other times during treatment.25 Results from a study investigating the effect
of cognitive-behavioral music therapy on females ages 14 to 45 years with eating
disorders suggest that music therapy was well received by patients, families, and pro-
fessionals, that music therapy was motivating, and that music therapy enhanced pa-
tients positive affect about the treatment process.83 The research that could be found
on the use of music therapy to treat eating disorders consisted of outcomes research
with a qualitative measure. Future research in this area should include the use of con-
trol groups or conditions and quantitative measures.
SUMMARY
In music therapy for mental health treatment of children and adolescents, the stron-
gest outcome findings are currently for children with intellectual disabilities, emotional
and behavioral disorders, and learning disabilities, but mainly because there is less
research in other areas of child and adolescent mental health, such as autism,
mood/anxiety disorders, substance abuse, and eating disorders.38,39,77,78 Research
indicates that the most effective clinical treatments using music tend to be those
implemented by music therapists, compared with approaches using music medicine
treatments.7 Although music may be used successfully by other health care profes-
sionals to augment mental health treatment, this treatment should be carried out
with the utmost care or, as Taylor says, If administered independently of its relation-
ship to the therapist, it [music] may serve to intensify the pathology with which the pa-
tient is afflicted.6(p83) Given that musical choices may indicate mental health status
and emotional vulnerability, it is advisable for the health care professional or therapist
to screen patients self-selected music before therapeutic intervention.81
Some music therapists provide consultations for other health care professionals on
ways in which to use music in mental health treatment. The CBMT Web site, http://
www.cbmt.org, has a feature that allows anyone to search for board-certified music
12
Table 2
Authors recommendations
Intellectual/
Emotional/ Develop- Various
Treatment/ Abuse/ Aggressive Bereave- Eating Behavioral mental Juvenile Substance Psychopa-
Approach Trauma ADHD Behavior At-Risk Autism ment Disorders Disorders Disabilities Delinquents Abuse thologies Investigators Opinion
Active music Fair/rec. Fair/ Fair/rec. Fair/rec. Fair/rec. Can be used to address
therapy insufficient self-concept self-
(no psycho- regulation, cognitive
therapeutic functioning, and social/
approach emotional functioning
given) Active music therapy in
adults has been shown
to improve attendance,
participation, percep-
tions of helpfulness,
and learning
Cognitive- Fair/rec. Fair/rec. Fair/rec. Fair/rec. Can be used to address
behavioral self-esteem, social skills
music deficits, developmental
therapy objectives, self-
confidence,
communication,
behaviors, self-esteem,
cognitive functioning;
and motor skills
Cognitive-behavioral MT
research in adults
suggests that it is highly
effective across a broad
range of objectives
Eclectic music Fair/ Fair/rec. Fair/rec. Fair/rec. Fair/rec. Can be used to address
therapy rec. communication,
behaviors, cognitive
functioning, musical or
motor skills, and
psychosocial functioning
The most mental health-
based music therapists
report use of an eclectic
approach.
Humanistic Fair/ Fair/ Fair/rec. Fair/ Fair/rec. Fair/ Fair/ Fair/rec. Can be used to address joint
music insufficient rec. insufficient no data insufficient attention, social/
therapy emotional functioning,
(creative and motivation
Nordoff- Can be used to decrease
Robbins; aggression and improve
Orff; self- esteem
improvisa-
tional)
Passive music Fair/ Fair/rec. Can be used to address self-
therapy rec. regulation, behavior
(music Research suggests that
listening) music therapy is more
effective when patients
actively participate
Psychodynamic Fair/ All studies that used
music insufficient psychodynamic ap-
therapy proaches in children also
(analytical) used other approaches or
provided case study data
only; as a result,
recommendations for use
of a psychodynamic- only
approach cannot be
made
13
14 Yinger & Gooding
therapists in their state. The authors offer the following evidence-based recommenda-
tions for health care professionals seeking to use music in mental health treatment of
children or adolescents:
Use high-quality, client-preferred music. Ask them what kind of music they like
and bring music as close to their preference as possible.
Allow clients to bring in their own music (listen to it before playing it for the group
to screen for appropriateness of content) or give them a choice of several artists
or genres.
If you are uncomfortable performing music, use professional recordings.
Become familiar with copyright restrictions to ensure compliance for you and
your practice/facility.
The strengths of music therapy as a treatment of children and adolescents with
mental health concerns include the fact that music therapy is known to benefit clients
with a wide variety of diagnoses and can be effectively administered in group format,
making it a safe, cost-efficient treatment. An increasing number of insurance providers
offer reimbursement for music therapy as a biopsychosocial treatment.84,85 One weak-
ness of music therapy treatment of children and adolescents is that the mechanism by
which it is effective is not completely understood and requires more research with ran-
domized controlled studies. The bulk of the neuroimaging research that seeks to under-
stand how music listening and participation affect the brain has focused on adults, so
caution must be taken when interpreting results of this research with regards to children
and adolescents. Although future research will better illuminate how music therapy
functions, the existing research on music therapy treatment overwhelmingly indicates
that music therapy does function in mental health treatment of children and adoles-
cents. In addition, it requires a trained professional (music therapist) to effectively
administer treatment; without effective administration, the use of music in mental health
treatment may serve to worsen patients conditions.6 Music therapy may be contrain-
dicated for individuals with profound hearing loss, who have musicogenic seizures (a
rare occurrence), or who can no longer actively participate in music because of health
constraints. Many individuals with mild, moderate, or even severe hearing loss do enjoy
listening to music and can benefit from music therapy.86 In addition to the aforemen-
tioned contraindications, certain types of music may be contraindicated for certain
populations. For instance, an individual receiving treatment of substance abuse would
be advised not to listen to music that they once listened to while getting high, because
this type of music may serve to intensify cravings caused by evaluative conditioning.6
Although there is a growing body of research on music therapy in adult mental
health treatment, further research is needed on the use of music therapy in treating
child and adolescent psychiatric disorders, particularly autism, mood and anxiety dis-
orders, substance abuse, and eating disorders in children and adolescents through
randomized controlled studies. Double-blind placebo studies are not possible in
music therapy because interaction with the therapist is an inherent part of the treat-
ment and there is no way to blind participants as to whether or not they receive music
therapy. However, single blind studies in which the researcher does not know which
participants received music therapy are desirable. Using a variety of measures simul-
taneously (self-report, behavioral observation, and physiologic measurements) in
research on the effects of music therapy is also recommended to help eliminate the
possibility of bias. This research is warranted given the effectiveness of music therapy
with adults who have these disorders and the promising nature of initial pilot studies on
children and adolescents. Table 2 summarizes recommendations based on the
current clinical research and the authors clinical experience.
Music Therapy for Children and Adolescents 15
Music is a useful tool in treating children and adolescents with psychiatric disorders
because of the engagement of multiple areas of the brain that occur during music
listening. Music therapy treatment involves active musical participation and the inclu-
sion of therapeutic techniques by a music therapist, which provide additional levels of
neural engagement and lead to successful outcomes for children with various needs in
the social, behavioral, emotional, cognitive/academic, motor, and verbal domains.
REFERENCES
18. Silverman MJ. Evaluating current trends in psychiatric music therapy: a descrip-
tive analysis. J Music Ther 2007;44:388414.
19. Darrow AA. Introduction to approaches in music therapy. Silver Spring (MD):
American Music Therapy Association; 2004.
20. Cassity MD. Psychiatric music therapy in 2016: a Delphi Poll of the future. Music
Ther Perspect 2007;25:8693.
21. Choi CM. A pilot analysis of the psychological themes found during the CARING
at Columbia-music therapy program with refugee adolescents from North
Korea. J Music Ther 2010;47:380407.
22. Choi AN, Lee MS, Lee JS. Group music intervention reduces aggression and im-
proves self-esteem in children with highly aggressive behavior: a pilot controlled
study. Evid Based Complement Alternat Med 2010;7:2137.
23. Snow S, DAmico M. The drum circle project: a qualitative study with at-risk
youth in a school setting. Can J Mus Ther 2010;16:1239.
24. Boso M, Emanuele E, Minazzi V, et al. Effect of long-term interactive music ther-
apy on behavior profile and musical skills in young adults with severe autism.
J Altern Complement Med 2007;13:70912.
25. McFerran K, Baker F, Patton GC, et al. A retrospective lyrical analysis of songs writ-
ten by adolescents with anorexia nervosa. Eur Eat Disord Rev 2006;14:397403.
26. Chong HJ, Kim SJ. Education-oriented music therapy as an after-school pro-
gram for students with emotional and behavioral problems. Arts Psychother
2010;37:1906.
27. Henderson SM. Effects of a music therapy program upon awareness of mood in
music, group cohesion, and self-esteem among hospitalized adolescent pa-
tients. J Music Ther 1983;20:1420.
28. Kivland MJ. The use of music to increase self-esteem in a conduct disordered
adolescent. J Music Ther 1986;23:259.
29. James MR. Music therapy values clarification: a positive influence on perceived
locus of control. J Music Ther 1988;25:20615.
30. Montello L, Coons EE. Effects of active versus passive group music therapy on
preadolescents with emotional, learning, and behavioral disorders. J Music Ther
1998;35:4967.
31. Hilliard RE. The effects of music therapy-based bereavement groups on mood
and behavior of grieving children: a pilot study. J Music Ther 2001;38:291306.
32. Eidson C. The effect of behavioral music therapy on the generalization of inter-
personal skills from sessions to the classroom by emotionally handicapped mid-
dle school students. J Music Ther 1989;26:20621.
33. Haines JH. The effects of music therapy on the self-esteem of emotionally-
disturbed adolescents. Music Ther 1989;8:7891.
34. Hanser S. Group contingent music listening with emotionally disturbed boys.
J Music Ther 1974;11:2205.
35. Johnson ER. The role of objective and concrete feedback in self-concept treat-
ment of juvenile delinquents in music therapy. J Music Ther 1981;18:13747.
36. Howard AA. The effects of music and poetry therapy on the treatment of women
and adolescents with chemical addictions. J Poetry Ther 1997;11:81102.
37. Gooding LF. The effect of a music therapy social skills training program on
improving social competence in children and adolescents with social skills
deficits. J Music Ther 2011;48:44062.
38. Gold C, Voracek M, Wigram T. Effects of music therapy for children and adoles-
cents with psychopathology: a meta-analysis. J Child Psychol Psychiatry 2004;
45:105463.
Music Therapy for Children and Adolescents 17
39. Brown LS, Jellison JA. Music research with children and youth with disabilities
and typically developing peers: a systematic review. J Music Ther 2012;49:
33564.
40. Whipple J. Music in intervention for children and adolescents with autism: a
meta-analysis. J Music Ther 2004;41:90106.
41. Robarts JZ. Music therapy and adolescents with anorexia nervosa. Nord J
Music Ther 2000;9:312.
42. McQueen C. Two controlled experiments in music therapy. Br J Mus Ther 1975;
6:28.
43. Ross S, Cidambi I, Dermatis H, et al. Music therapy: a novel motivational
approach for dually diagnosed patients. J Addict Dis 2008;27:4153.
44. Gold C, Wigram T, Voracek M. Effectiveness of music therapy for children and
adolescents with psychopathology: a quasi-experimental study. Psychother
Res 2007;17:28996.
45. Gold C, Wigram T, Voracek M. Predictors of change in music therapy with chil-
dren and adolescents: the role of therapeutic techniques. Psychol Psychother
2007;80:57789.
46. Rickson D. Instructional and improvisational models of music therapy with ado-
lescents who have attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD): a comparison
of the effects on motor impulsivity. J Music Ther 2006;43:3960.
47. Rickson DJ, Watkins WG. Music therapy to promote prosocial behaviors in
aggressive adolescent boysa pilot study. J Music Ther 2003;40:293301.
48. Hilliard RE. The effects of Orff-based music therapy and social work groups on
childhood grief symptoms and behaviors. J Music Ther 2007;44:12338.
49. McFerran K. Dangerous liaisons: group work for adolescent girls who have
anorexia nervosa. Voices: a world forum for music therapy. Vol. 5. 2005. Avail-
able at: https://normt.uib.no/index.php/voices/article/view/215/159. Accessed
September 8, 2012.
50. McIntyre J. Creating order out of chaos: music therapy with adolescent boys
diagnosed with a behavior disorder and/or emotional disorder. Music Therapy
Today 2007;8:5679.
51. Gardstrom S. An investigation of meaning in clinical music improvisation with
troubled adolescents. 2003. Available at: http://www.barcelonapublishers.com/
QIMTV1/QIMT20041(4)Gardstrom.pdf. Accessed September 8, 2012.
52. Gold C, Wigram T, Berger E. The development of a research design to assess
the effects of individual music therapy with mentally ill children and adolescents.
Nord J Music Ther 2001;10:1731.
53. Cripe F. Rock music as therapy for children with attention-deficit disorder.
J Music Ther 1986;23:307.
54. Wooten MA. The effects of heavy metal music on affects shifts of adolescents in
an inpatient psychiatric setting. Music Ther Perspect 1992;10:938.
55. Strehlow G. The use of music therapy in treating sexually abused children. Nord
J Music Ther 2009;18:16783.
56. Cassity MD. The influence of a music therapy activity upon peer acceptance,
group cohesiveness, and interpersonal relationships of adult psychiatric pa-
tients. J Music Ther 1976;8:6676.
57. de lEtoile SK. The effectiveness of music therapy in group psychotherapy for
adults with mental illness. Arts Psychother 2002;29:6978.
58. Gold C, Solli HP, Kruger V, et al. Dose-response relationship in music therapy for
people with serious mental disorders: systematic review and meta-analysis. Clin
Psychol Rev 2009;29:193207.
18 Yinger & Gooding
59. Goldberg FS, McNeil DE, Binder RL. Therapeutic factors in two forms of inpa-
tient group psychotherapy: music therapy and verbal therapy. Behav Sci
1988;12:14556.
60. Ulrich G, Houtmans T, Gold C. The additional therapeutic effect of group music
therapy for schizophrenic patients: a randomized study. Acta Psychiatr Scand
2007;116:36270.
61. Silverman MJ. The effect of lyric analysis on treatment eagerness and working
alliance in consumers who are in detoxification: a randomized clinical effective-
ness study. Music Ther Perspect 2009;27:11521.
62. Silverman MJ. Perceptions of music therapy interventions from inpatients with
severe mental illness: a mixed-methods approach. Arts Psychother 2010;37:
2648.
63. Silverman MJ. The effect of songwriting on knowledge of coping skills and work-
ing alliance in psychiatric patients: a randomized clinical effectiveness study.
J Music Ther 2011;48:10322.
64. Teague AK, Hahna ND, McKinney CH. Group music therapy with women who
have experienced intimate partner violence. Music Ther Perspect 2006;24:806.
65. Gallant W, Holosko M, Gorey KM, et al. Music as a form of intervention with out-
patient alcoholic couples: a quasi-experimental investigation. Can J Mus Ther
1997;5:6784.
66. Schwantes M, McKinney C. Music therapy with Mexican migrant farmworkers: a
pilot study. Music Ther Perspect 2010;28:228.
67. Mossler K, Assmus J, Heldal TO, et al. Music therapy techniques as predictors
of change in mental health care. Arts Psychother 2012;39:33341.
68. Edwards J. Music therapy in the treatment and management of mental disor-
ders. Ir J Psychol Med 2006;23:335.
69. Slotoroff C. Drumming technique for assertiveness and anger management in
the short-term psychiatric setting for adult and adolescent survivors of trauma.
Music Ther Perspect 1994;12:1116.
70. Silverman MJ. Immediate effects of a single music therapy intervention with per-
sons who are severely mentally ill. Arts Psychother 2004;31:291301.
71. Heaney J. Evaluation of music therapy and other treatment modalities by adult
psychiatric patients. J Music Ther 1992;29:7086.
72. Jackson N. A survey of music therapy methods and their role in the treatment of
early elementary school children with ADHD. J Music Ther 2003;40:30223.
73. Kaplan RS, Steele AL. An analysis of music therapy program goals and out-
comes for clients with diagnoses on the autism spectrum. J Music Ther 2005;
42:219.
74. Kim J, Wigram T, Gold C. The effects of improvisational music therapy on joint
attention behaviors in autistic children: a randomized controlled study.
J Autism Dev Disord 2008;38:175866.
75. Kim J, Wigram T, Gold C. Emotional, motivational and interpersonal responsive-
ness of children with autism in improvisational music therapy. Autism 2009;13:
389409.
76. Gold C, Wigram T, Elefant C. Music therapy for autistic spectrum disorder [re-
view]. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2006; Issue 2. Art. No.: CD004381. DOI:
10.1002/14651858.CD004381.pub2.
77. Reschke-Hernandez AE. History of music therapy treatment interventions for
children with autism. J Music Ther 2011;48:169207.
78. Jellison JA. A content analysis of music research with disabled children and youth
(1975-1999): applications in special education. In: American Music Therapy
Music Therapy for Children and Adolescents 19