Abandonment Handbook 2008
Abandonment Handbook 2008
S E
E C
C U
U R
R II N
N G
G A
A R
R II ZZ O
O N
N A
A S
S W
W A
A TT E
E R
R FF U
U TT U
U R
R E
E
S
SEEP
PTTE
EMMB
BEER
R 22000088
PHONE: 602-771-8500
1-800-352-8488
FAX: 602-771-8691
www.azwater.gov
Table of Contents
I. Introduction 1
II. Overview of the Well Abandonment Process 2
III. Surface Seal Requirements Applicable to the Upper 20 Feet of All Wells to be Abandoned
and Special Requirements for Debris-Filled or Obstructed Wells 5
A. Surface Seal Requirements 5
Surface Casing Removal Option 5
Surface Casing Non-Removal Option 5
B. Special Requirements for Debris Filled or Obstructed Wells 5
IV. Abandonment Methods 5
A. Standard Abandonment Method 5
B. Alternative Abandonment Methods 6
Alternative 1 Applies to wells that do not penetrate aquifers, including wells that have
gone dry, and no vadose zone contamination issues exist 6
Alternative 2 Applies to wells that do not penetrate aquifers, including wells that have
gone dry, and vadose zone contamination issues exist 6
Alternative 3 Applies to wells that penetrate single or multiple aquifers, and water
quality contamination issues exist 6
Alternative 4 Applies to wells that penetrate a single aquifer only without vertical
flow components, and no water quality contamination issues exist 8
Alternative 4 (Variance Option) 8
Alternative 5 Applies to wells that penetrate single or multiple aquifers with vertical
flow components, and no water quality 9
Alternative 5 (Variance Option 1) 9
Alternative 5 (Variance Option 2) 9
References 12
APPENDIX A A.A.C. R12-15-816, The ADWR Well Abandonment Rule 13
APPENDIX B Definitions 15
APPENDIX C Questions and Answers about the Abandonment Handbook 19
ADWRs well abandonment rule requires The well abandonment methods described in
that well abandonment be accomplished this Handbook are presented in much greater
through filling or sealing the well so as to detail than in ADWRs well abandonment
prevent the well, including the annular space rule. However, the Handbook is not
outside the casing, from being a channel intended to change any of the requirements
allowing the vertical movement of water. in the rule or to impose any additional
A.A.C. R12-15-816(G). The rule prescribes requirements. The purpose of including the
the fill materials that must be used in certain abandonment methods in the Handbook is to
aquifer conditions. A.A.C. R12-15-816(H). assist well owners and well drillers in
The rule also requires the filing of a pre- complying with A.A.C. R12-15-816(G) by
abandonment notice with ADWR (unless the informing them of fill materials and
well is a new well being abandoned in the emplacement methods ADWR considers to
course of drilling the well) and the filing of be adequate to seal a well in a manner that
post-abandonment reports. A.A.C. R12-15- will prevent the well from being a channel
816(B), (E) and (F). allowing the vertical movement of water. A
person who abandons a well in accordance
The purpose of this Handbook is to provide with the applicable well abandonment
a step-by-step guide to the abandonment of a method described in this Handbook will be
well in a manner that complies with assured of complying with A.A.C. R12-15-
ADWRs well abandonment rule. The 816(G).
Handbook describes the abandonment
process from the filing of a Notice of The next section presents an overview of the
Intention to Abandon with ADWR prior to abandonment process. Section III describes
commencing abandonment, to the filing of surface seal requirements for the upper 20
post-abandonment reports by the well owner feet of all wells and special requirements for
and well driller. Most importantly, the debris-filled or obstructed wells. Section IV
Handbook describes procedures that may be describes the standard abandonment method
used to adequately abandon a well, and the five alternative methods. Appendix
including fill materials and emplacement B contains definitions of terms used in this
methods. Handbook and Appendix C contains
questions and answers regarding this
A standard abandonment method is Handbook.
described that may be used for any well,
regardless of the aquifer and vadose zone
conditions applicable to the well. Five
alternative abandonment methods are also
well falls within the condition to which the The latitude, longitude and well
alternative method applies and whether elevation of the abandoned well, and the
appropriate fill materials were chosen. method used to determine these data.
During the review process ADWR may Latitude and longitude coordinates
contact the well owner to request additional determined from readily available
information or discuss modifications to the Global Positioning System (GPS)
proposed abandonment plan, if necessary. equipment are preferred because of the
high level of accuracy and comparative
ease of measurement. If GPS equipment
Once the proposed well abandonment is used to determine these coordinates,
methods and materials meet the the general grade of equipment should
requirements of the abandonment rule, a be specified (for example: survey grade
well abandonment authorization card is or hand-held). Latitude, longitude and
mailed to the designated well driller and well elevation coordinates may also be
well abandonment operations may begin obtained from conventional surveying
(See Figure 1). methods or through estimation from a
topographic map.
Figure 1
Well Abandonment Process
Yes
Yes
Well Abandoned
III. Surface Seal Requirements specific conditions will determine the actual
Applicable to the Upper 20 Feet method of abandonment.
of All Wells to be Abandoned and
Special Requirements for Debris- IV. Abandonment Methods
Filled or Obstructed Wells
In addition to the well sealing and A. Standard Abandonment
abandonment methods and materials that are Method
discussed in the following section, ADWRs The ADWR standard abandonment method
well abandonment rule requires a cement meets the requirements of ADWRs well
grout surface seal (plug) to be installed in abandonment rule under any given
the upper 20 feet of any well that is combination of aquifer and vadose zone
abandoned. Special requirements may also conditions. The standard abandonment
be necessary if casing obstructions and/or method may be followed to obtain expedited
debris hamper the abandonment of a well. processing of an NOIA and issuance of a
These requirements are described below: well abandonment authority.
and estimated volume of grout material The materials or mixtures are recommended
should be specified on the NOIA form. Any to exceed the casing volume by
discrepancies between the estimated volume approximately 30 percent.
of grout to be used, and the actual amount of
grout that was used for abandonment should In the course of drilling a new well, the well
be reported and explained on the Well may be abandoned using drill cuttings from
Abandonment Completion Report. the well being drilled if the well does not
penetrate an aquifer, and no vadose zone
B. Alternative Abandonment contamination issues exist.
Methods
Alternative 2 Applies to wells that do
There are five alternatives to the standard not penetrate aquifers, including wells
abandonment method described above. that have gone dry, and vadose zone
Each alternative method is designed for a contamination issues exist.
different vadose zone or aquifer condition,
If the well does not penetrate an aquifer or
and only one alternative method is
has gone dry, and vadose zone
appropriate for a specific well. The
contamination issues exist, but there is no
conditions described at the beginning of
free-product contamination, the well must be
each alternative and the depictions in Figure
filled with one or more of the following
2 should be carefully reviewed to determine
materials or mixtures: cement grout
the appropriate alternative method if the
(including neat cement grout, cement-
standard abandonment method is not
bentonite grout and sand-cement grout),
selected. If an alternative method is
concrete grout, sand-bentonite grout, high-
selected, the method must be identified by
solids bentonite grout (granular or powder
number in the NOIA and the well owner
mixtures) with a minimum of 15% solids by
may be required to submit information
weight, high-solids bentonite chips or high-
demonstrating that the applicable vadose
solids bentonite pellets. See Table 1 for
zone or aquifer conditions exist for the well.
mixing ratios. High-solids bentonite chips
and high-solids bentonite pellets must be
Alternative 1 Applies to wells that
hydrated to manufacturers specifications.
do not penetrate aquifers, including
The materials or mixtures are recommended
wells that have gone dry, and no
to exceed the casing volume by
vadose zone contamination issues
approximately 30 percent.
exist.
If the well does not penetrate an aquifer or If free-product contamination issues exist,
has gone dry, and vadose zone the entire well must be sealed with neat
contamination issues do not exist, the well cement grout.
must be filled with one or more of the
following materials or mixtures: clean fine Alternative 3 Applies to wells that
sand, cement grout (including neat cement penetrate single or multiple aquifers,
grout, cement-bentonite grout and sand- and water quality contamination issues
cement grout), concrete grout, sand- exist.
bentonite grout, high-solids bentonite grout If the well penetrates a single or multiple
(granular or powder mixtures) with a aquifer system and water quality
minimum of 15% solids by weight, high- contamination issues exist, then site-specific
solids bentonite chips or high-solids conditions will determine the appropriate
bentonite pellets. See Table 1 for mixing seal material and emplacement method. The
ratios. High-solids bentonite chips and seal material must be no more permeable
high-solids bentonite pellets must be than the formation being sealed. A target
hydrated to manufacturers specifications.
Figure 2
Alternative Abandonment Methods Applicable to
Five Commonly Occurring Vadose Zone
and Aquifer Conditions
(No Vadose Zone (Vadose Zone (Water Quality (No Water Quality (No Water Quality
Contamination Issues Contamination Issues Contamination Issues Contamination Issues Contamination Issues
Exist) Exist) Exist) Exist) Exist)
-7
hydraulic conductivity of 10 cm/s may be well may be sealed with the same material
used for sealant materials. The types of that is used to seal the well below the water
acceptable materials or mixtures are: cement level. High-solids bentonite chips and high-
grout (including neat cement grout and solids bentonite pellets must be hydrated to
cement bentonite grout), high-solids manufacturers specifications if used in the
bentonite grout (granular or powder vadose zone. If free-product contamination
mixtures) with a minimum of 15% solids by issues exist, the vadose zone portion of the
weight, high-solids bentonite chips or high- well must be sealed with neat cement grout.
solids bentonite pellets. See Table 1 for
mixing ratios. A minimum of 15% Materials or mixtures must be emplaced
bentonite solids will be acceptable in most under sufficient pressure to fill all voids,
cases. However, a higher minimum of including all annular space(s), and displace
bentonite solids may be required in areas of water from the well. A tremie pipe must be
high water quality contamination. Acid used to emplace the grout from the bottom
resistant cement (see definitions) may be up. The end of the tremie pipe shall remain
required in certain areas where corrosive in close proximity to the rising grout surface
(low pH) groundwater conditions are as the grout is pumped into the well.
encountered. The materials or mixtures are
recommended to exceed the casing volume Except as provided below for recently
by approximately 30 percent. constructed monitor wells, if the casing is
not removed, either the entire length of the
If there is no free-product contamination at casing must be reperforated (from 20 feet
the well site, the vadose zone portion of the
above the highest historic water level to the level of confidence to determine that no
total depth of the well), or the condition of aquifer boundaries and no vertical flow
the casing perforations must be determined components exist within the length of the
by running a video log that must be well, and if water quality contamination
submitted to the ADWR for review. If a issues do not exist, the well must be filled
video log demonstrates that the existing with one or more of the following materials
perforations are sufficiently open for grout or mixtures: cement grout (including neat
to enter the annular space outside the casing, cement grout, cement-bentonite grout and
no additional perforations or casing sand-cement grout), concrete, high-solids
treatments will be required. If the video log bentonite grout (granular or powder
demonstrates that the existing perforations mixtures) with a minimum of 15% solids by
are not sufficiently open for grout to enter weight, high-solids bentonite chips, high-
the annular space outside the casing, solids bentonite pellets, and sand-bentonite
additional perforations and/or casing grout. See Table 1 for mixing ratios.
treatments such as mechanical brushing,
scraping or sonic cleaning will be required, In the course of drilling a new well, the well
unless it is determined that disturbance of may be abandoned using drill cuttings from
the casing and/or gravel packed zones would the well being drilled if the well does not
negatively influence the sealing of the well. penetrate an aquifer, and no vadose zone
Casing perforation and/or casing cleaning contamination issues exist.
requirements for wells with water quality
contamination issues will be made by
ADWR on a case-by-case basis. The vadose zone portion of these types of
wells may be filled with any of the mixtures
or materials described above or allowed in
Wells requiring additional perforations must Alternative 1. High-solids bentonite chips
be perforated a minimum of two cuts per and high-solids bentonite pellets must be
foot and sealed by pressure grouting. The hydrated to manufacturers specifications if
intervals to be perforated must be used in the vadose zone. The materials or
determined based on site-specific mixtures are recommended to exceed the
information. However, if no vadose zone casing volume by approximately 30 percent.
contamination issues exist, the perforations
need only extend 20 feet above the static
water level in the well. Materials or mixtures must be emplaced
under sufficient pressure to fill all voids,
including all annular space(s), and displace
Video logging and/or casing re-perforation water from the well. A tremie pipe must be
may not be required in the case of the used to emplace the grout from the bottom
abandonment of recently constructed up. The end of the tremie pipe shall remain
monitor wells. However, that determination in close proximity to the rising grout surface
must be made by ADWR on a case-by-case as the grout is pumped into the well.
basis.
Alternative 4 (Variance Option)
Alternative 4 Applies to wells that
penetrate a single aquifer only A variance option is available to abandon
without vertical flow components, wells that are 8 inches or greater in diameter
and no water quality contamination and that fall under Alternative 4 aquifer
issues exist. conditions. Alternative 4 (Variance Option)
allows the use of clean fine sand to fill the
If the well penetrates an aquifer and well.
hydrogeologic and stratigraphic information
is available for the well at an acceptable
Please note that anyone wishing to use this video log demonstrates that the existing
alternative abandonment method must first perforations are sufficiently open for grout
apply to ADWR for a variance from the well to enter the annular space between the
abandonment rule. casing and the well bore, no additional
perforations or casing treatments are
Alternative 5 Applies to wells that necessary. If the video log demonstrates
penetrate single or multiple aquifers that the existing perforations are not
with vertical flow components, and sufficiently open for grout to enter the
no water quality contamination annular space outside the casing, additional
issues exist. perforations and/or casing treatments such
If the well penetrates a single or multiple as mechanical brushing, scraping or sonic
aquifer system with vertical flow cleaning are recommended, unless it is
components, and if water quality determined that disturbance of the casing
contamination issues do not exist, the well and/or gravel packed zones would
must be sealed to prevent the vertical negatively influence the sealing of the well.
migration of fluids with cement grout A well requiring additional perforations
(including neat cement grout, cement- should be perforated a minimum of two cuts
bentonite grout and sand-cement grout), per foot and sealed by pressure grouting.
high-solids bentonite grout (granular or
Alternative 5 (Variance Option 1)
powder mixtures) with a minimum of 15%
Alternative 5 (Variance Option 1) is
solids by weight, high-solids bentonite chips
available to abandon wells that are 8 inches
or high-solids bentonite pellets of sufficient
or greater in diameter and that fall under
volume, density, and viscosity to prevent
Alternative 5 aquifer conditions.
fluid communication between aquifers. See
Alternative 5 (Variance option 1) allows the
Table 1 for mixing ratios.
use of alternating layers of 50 feet of clean,
fine sand and 10 feet of one of the approved
The vadose zone portion of this type of well Alternative 5 materials or mixtures
may be filled with any of the mixtures or mentioned above.
materials described above or allowed in
Alternative 1. High-solids bentonite chips Please note that anyone wishing to use this
and high-solids bentonite pellets must be alternative abandonment method must first
hydrated to manufacturers specifications if apply to ADWR for a variance from
used in the vadose zone. The materials or ADWRs well abandonment rule.
mixtures are recommended to exceed the
casing volume by approximately 30 percent. Alternative 5 (Variance Option 2)
Alternative 5 (Variance Option 2) is
available to abandon wells that are 8 inches
Materials or mixtures must be emplaced
or greater in diameter and that fall under
under sufficient pressure to fill all voids,
Alternative 5 aquifer conditions.
including all annular space(s), and displace
Alternative 5 (Variance Option 2) allows
water from the well. A tremie pipe must be
the installation of seals at aquifer
used to emplace the grout from the bottom
boundaries if boundaries exist and if
up. The end of the tremie pipe shall remain
hydrogeologic and stratigraphic information
in close proximity to the rising grout surface
is available for the well at an acceptable
as the grout is pumped into the well.
level of confidence to determine the
depth(s) of aquifer boundaries. Aquifer
If the casing is not removed, it is boundary seals must be composed of one of
recommended, but not required, that the the approved Alternative 5 materials or
condition of the casing perforations be mixtures mentioned above.
determined by running a video log. If the
Table 1
Acceptable Well Abandonment Materials and Mixtures
Abandonment
Permeability
Applicable
Mixing Ratio
Category
Methods
(cm/sec)
Specific Material Special Considerations
Solids Water
the well being drilled NA NA Alts. 1,4 a single aquifer with no vertical flow
and abandoned components. No vadose zone and no water
quality contamination issues may exist.
A minimum of 15% solids bentonite will be
High-Solids Bentonite Fifty (50) lbs. dry acceptable in most cases. However, a higher
Thirtyfour (34)
Grout (powder or bentonite powder minimum of bentonite solids may be required
gallons (powder
granular mixture) with (powder mixture) in areas of high water quality contamination.
mixture) 10 7
a minimum 15% or Cannot be used under Alternative 2 if free-
or to Alts. 1-5
solids by weight One hundred fifty (150) product contamination issues exist. Also
One hundred 10 8
Minimum grout lbs. granular bentonite cannot be used in vadose zone portion of an
(100) gallons
density = 9.2 & 1 qt. Polymer Alternative 3 well if free-product contamination
(granular mixture)
lbs./gallon (granular mixture) issues exist. Granular mixtures generally
Forms of Bentonite1,2
6. The name and well drilling license sand with bentonite, or cuttings from the
number of the well drilling contractor or well.
single well licensee who abandoned the
well. 2. A well penetrating a single or multiple
aquifer system with vertical flow
7. The date of completion of the components shall be sealed with cement
abandonment of the well. grout or a column of bentonite drilling
mud of sufficient volume, density, and
8. The reason for abandonment. viscosity to prevent fluid communication
between aquifers.
9. Such other information as the Director
may require. J. Materials containing organic or toxic
matter shall not be used in the
G. The abandonment of a well shall be abandonment of a well.
accomplished through filing or sealing
the well so as to prevent the well, K. The owner or operator of the well shall
including the annular space outside the notify the Director in writing no later
casing, from being a channel allowing than 30 days after abandonment has been
the vertical movement of water. completed. The notification shall
include the well owners name, the
H. A well not penetrating an aquifer shall location of the well, and the method of
include a surface seal which shall be abandonment.
accomplished as follows:
Hazardous Substance: has the same dry bentonite powder and eighteen (18)
meaning prescribed by A.R.S. 49-201. gallons of water.
ADWR has become aware of some A. The well abandonment rule does not
misunderstanding among well owners and apply to:
well drillers concerning the requirements of
the well abandonment rule, A.C.C. R12-15- 1. man-made openings in the earth not
816. This Handbook is intended to provide commonly considered to be wells,
guidance to well owners and well drillers on such as construction and mining
what is required by the rule. blast holes, underground mines and
mine shafts, open pit mines, tunnels,
septic tank systems, caissons,
In addition, this Handbook describes the basements, and natural gas storage
procedures and materials that should be used cavities;
to abandon wells not detailed in the rule.
The well abandonment rule requires a
2. an injection well or vadose zone well
person abandoning a well to fill or seal the
that is subject to regulation by the
well in order to prevent the well, including
Arizona Department of
the annular space outside the casing, from
Environmental Quality (ADEQ),
being a channel allowing the vertical
provided that ADEQ has issued a
movement of water. Any well owner or
letter or other document asserting
well driller who abandons a well in
explicit regulatory authority over the
compliance with this Handbook will be
well;
deemed to be in compliance with this
requirement.
3. oil, gas, and helium wells drilled
pursuant to the provisions of Title
Q. What types of wells are subject to 27, Arizona Revised Statutes (wells
ADWRs well abandonment rule? regulated by the Arizona Oil and Gas
Commission); and
A. The well abandonment rule applies to
man-made openings in the earth 4. boreholes in the earth less than 100
through which water may be withdrawn feet in depth which are made for
or obtained from beneath the surface of purposes other than withdrawing or
the earth, including all water wells, encountering groundwater (such as
monitor wells and piezometer wells. exploration wells and grounding or
cathodic protection holes less than
100 feet in depth), except that if
The well abandonment rule also applies
to geothermal wells for which the rules
groundwater is encountered in the
and regulations of the Arizona Oil and drilling of the borehole, the well
Gas Commission do not require the abandonment rule will apply.
reinjection of all waters associated with
the geothermal resource to the producing Although the well abandonment rule
strata, as well as exploration wells and does not apply to these types of wells
grounding or cathodic protection holes and boreholes, it is nevertheless
greater than 100 feet in depth (regardless recommended that unused wells or
of whether they intercept groundwater).
boreholes that are not regulated under A. Because significant conduit flow can
ADWRs well abandonment rule be occur through the annular space outside
abandoned in a manner that will protect the casing, it is essential to seal this
the aquifer. pathway to prevent potential vertical
cross-contamination. Therefore, when
Q. What is the benefit of abandoning an water quality contamination issues exist,
unused well, as opposed to capping the unless the well casing is removed or the
well (which is also allowed under casing is re-perforated over its entire
ADWRs rules)? length from 20 feet above the highest
historic water level to the total depth of
A. Proper well abandonment is favored the well, the well owner must run a
over well capping for both video log to determine whether the grout
environmental and safety reasons. material can flow through the casing
perforations and seal the annular space
Unused and unabandoned wells constitute outside the casing.
actual or potential environmental
hazards because they can serve as Video logging and/or casing re-
vertical conduits for hazardous perforation may not be required in the
substances to cross-contaminate case of the abandonment of recently
aquifers. For example, during the last constructed monitor wells. However,
several decades, serious and costly that determination must be made on a
vertical cross-contamination of a case-by-case basis.
multiple aquifer system has occurred
through unabandoned conduit wells at In areas where water quality
the Indian Bend Wash Superfund site in contamination issues do not exist, if the
Scottsdale, Arizona. Owners of unused, casing is not ripped, a video log is
unabandoned wells should also realize recommended, although not required, to
that they may be held legally responsible determine perforation conditions. It is
for secondary contamination if it is important to make sure that the well and
demonstrated that their well served as a the annular space outside the casing are
conduit for vertical cross-contamination properly abandoned even when there are
of an aquifer system. no current water quality contamination
issues. This is because the water could
Public safety issues also favor well become contaminated in the future.
abandonment over well capping.
Capped wells are often tampered with, It should also be pointed out that
and once the well cap is removed there is additional benefits can be derived from
a real danger for humans or animals to running a video log. Those benefits may
fall into the well, or for the well to be include: the determination of the
used for the illegal disposal of hazardous structural integrity of the well casing, the
materials. presence of casing anomalies and
obstructions, the presence of perched or
Q. Why is it generally required to run a cascading water, etc. This information
video log to determine the condition of can be very important in developing an
the casing perforations in areas where effective abandonment design.
water quality contamination exists if
the casing is not ripped? Q. Under what circumstances is it
permissible to use drill cuttings to
abandon a well?
A. In the course of drilling a new well, the Q. What should I do if I have further
well may be abandoned using drill questions concerning a well
cuttings from the well being drilled only abandonment project?
if the well does not penetrate an aquifer
or the well penetrates a single aquifer A. Contact ADWR Hydrology Division at:
only, with no vertical flow components.
Drill cuttings may only be used to 602-771-8500
abandon the well from which they were (Phoenix metro area)
originally removed. Drill cuttings may
not be used to abandon wells or 1-800-352-8488
boreholes that have water quality and/or (outside metro Phoenix)
vadose zone contamination issues.
PHONE: 602-771-8500
1-800-352-8488
FAX: 602-771-8691
WEBSITE: http://www.azwater.gov