A Review On Machining Parameters Influencing The Responses On CNC: An Optimization Technique
A Review On Machining Parameters Influencing The Responses On CNC: An Optimization Technique
Key words: Anova, CNC Machine, Depth of cut, feed rate, Optimization, RSM, Spindle speed, Surface roughness
The main objectives are firstly focused on delimiting the to locate global optimum. It is because of this feature that
hard turning domain and investigating tool wear and GA goes through solution space starting from a group of
forces behaviour evolution versus variations of workpiece points and not from a single point. The cutting conditions
hardness and cutting speed. Secondly, the relationship are encoded as genes by binary
between cutting parameters (cutting speed, feed rate and encoding to apply GA in optimization of machining
depth of cut) and machining output variables (surface parameters. A set of genes is combined together to form
roughness, cutting forces) through the response surface chromosomes, used to perform the basic mechanisms in
methodology (RSM) are analysed and modeled. The GA, such as crossover and mutation.
combined effects of the cutting parameters on machining Crossover is the operation to exchange some part of two
output variables are investigated while employing the chromosomes to generate new offspring, which is
analysis of variance (ANOVA). The quadratic model of important when exploring the whole search space rapidly.
RSM associated with response optimization technique Mutation is applied after crossover to provide a small
(Khaider Bouacha, 2009). randomness to the new chromosomes.
The prediction of optimal machining conditions for good To evaluate each individual or chromosome, the encoded
surface finish and dimensional accuracy plays a very cutting conditions are decoded from the chromosomes
important role in process planning. The present work and are used to predict machining performance measures.
deals with the study and development of a surface Fitness or objective function is a function needed in the
roughness prediction model for machining mild steel, optimization process and selection of next generation in
using Response Surface Methodology (RSM) (P.V.S. genetic algorithm. Optimum results of cutting conditions
Suresh, 2002). are obtained by comparison of values of objective
The effects of cutting speed, feed rate, work piece functions among all individuals after a number of
hardness and depth of cut on surface roughness and iterations. Besides weighting factors and constraints,
cutting force components in the hard turning were suitable parameters of GA are required to operate
experimentally investigated. Four-factor (cutting speed, efficiently. GA optimization methodology is based on
feed rate, hardness and depth of cut) and three-level machining performance predictions models developed
fractional experiment designs completed with a statistical from comprehensive system of theoretical analysis,
analysis of variance (ANOVA) were performed. experimental (Milon D. Selvam, 2012)
Mathematical models for surface roughness and cutting B. RESPONSE SURFACE METHODOLOGY
force components were developed using the response Surface Roughness Measurement
surface methodology (RSM) (HamdiAouici, 2014).The A portable Surtronic 3+ was used to measure the
best surface roughness was achieved at the lower feed surface roughness (shown in Fig. 1).
rate and the highest cutting speed. Four readings have been taken in the traverse direction. In
Two independent data sets were obtained on the basis of case there is a large deviation, extreme values are
measurement: training data set and testing data set. discarded and Additional readings have been taken so that
Spindle speed, feed rate, depth of cut, and vibrations are the total number of readings is four
used as independent input variables (parameters), while
surface roughness as dependent output variable. On the
basis of training data set, different models for surface
roughness were developed by genetic programming (M.
Brezocnik, 2004). Accuracy of the best model was proved
with the testing data. It was established that the surface
roughness is most influenced by the feed rate, whereas the
vibrations increase the prediction accuracy.
In this framework, the present study is focused on study
of the effect of process Parameters on the surface
roughness for a different value has been investigated.
Moreover, this work treats the effect of spindle speed,
feed rate and depth of cut on surface roughness in turning Figure- 1 SURF TESTER
operation with various tool has been discussed.
The average value of surface roughness is calculated and
recorded. In this study, Ra values were obtained in the
III. METHODOLOGY
range of 1.25 to 3.50 mm (Vikas Pare, 2014)
C.EXPERIMENTAL CUTTING CONDITIONS
A. GENETIC ALGORITHM
Most of the researchers used statistical analysis methods
An algorithm based on mechanics of natural selection and
in the area of high speed machining. They considered
natural genetics, which are more robust and more likely
different sets of input parameters, output
17
International Journal On Engineering Technology and Sciences IJETS
ISSN(P): 2349-3968, ISSN (O): 2349-3976
Volume III, Issue II, February- 2016
parameters and tried various analysis techniques based on measurements of surface roughness were obtained at
statistics, including structured equation modeling (SEM) different surface of machined work piece and average
analysis, robust design, and Taguchi design approaches. value is used in the further analysis (clinktan, 2016)
observed the results of several projects on high-speed Rough surfaces usually wear more quickly and have
milling for testing the suitability of high-speed milling for
different kinds of materials. The materials machined were
steels, aluminium alloys, graphites and polymer matrix
composites. It is observed that most of the materials can
be machined by high-speed milling. conducted
experiments varying the speed from 2500 to 7500 rpm on
composites. They developed predictive models for
surface roughness and used GSA for optimization. In higher friction coefficients than smooth surfaces
order to determine whether there is uniform variation of Roughness is often a good predictor of the performance
surface roughness over speed variation, the range of 5000 of a quality of the mechanical component, since
to 7500 rpm was taken into consideration. TLBO was irregularities in the surface may form nucleation sites for
used, and the results were studied. studied high-speed cracks or corrosion. On the other hand, roughness may
endmilling of hardened AISI D2 tool steel (58HRC) and promote adhesion. The Surface roughness tester used for
estimated surface roughness and tool wear. measuring surface roughness (Ra) in this experimental
Ozcelik and Bayramoglu considered the step-over ratio in analysis
addition to the three cutting variables and developed a
surface roughness prediction model for wet machining D.CNC MACHINE
conditions. Examined two face milling cutter systems in The CNC Lathe is an automated machine used for
the high-speed cutting of grey cast iron under a machining Purpose and it has greater accuracy and
determined cutting condition productivity (figure 2) shown below which has been used
Deployed mathematical models to enhance the surface in various literature
quality during CNC machining observed, the
experimental results and related empirical models for
Work piece surface integrity (SI) during high-speed
Machining (Vikas Pare, 2015).The experimental work
was divided into two series:
The main aim of the first experiments series was the
determination of the turning domain and the
quantification of surface roughness evolution. This was
carried out through facing operation with continuously
varying cutting parameters.
The purpose behind the second experiments series was to
investigate the effects of cutting parameters on surface
roughness, then to establish a correlation between them
using the response surface methodology
(RSM).Machining process was carried out in CNC lathe.
Figure- 2 CNC Turning Lathe
The measurements of average surface roughness (Ra)
were taken on surface roughness Tester SJ-210P.Three
Table 1. Summary of Review Papers
19
International Journal On Engineering Technology and Sciences IJETS
ISSN(P): 2349-3968, ISSN (O): 2349-3976
Volume III, Issue II, February- 2016
20
International Journal On Engineering Technology and Sciences IJETS
ISSN(P): 2349-3968, ISSN (O): 2349-3976
Volume III, Issue II, February- 2016
11 Prediction of M.Brezocnik ,M. This paper proposes the common Genetic 2004.
surface Kovacic, M.Ficko genetic programming programming.
roughness with approach to predict
genetic surface roughness
programming based on cutting
parameters (spindle
speed, feed rate, and
depth of cut) and on
vibrations between
cutting tool and work
piece.
12 Optimization of Suleyman Neseli a, In order to find out the AISI 1040 Response November
tool geometry Suleyman Yaldz a. effect of tool geometry steel surface 2010
parameters for parameters on the methodology.
end milling surface roughness
operations based during end milling,
on the response response surface
surface methodology (RSM)
methodology. was used and a
Prediction model was
developed related to
average surface
roughness (Ra) using
experimental data.
13 Study on Chen Lu This paper reviews the common Optimization Nov
prediction of methodologies and techniques. 2007
surface quality in practice that are being
machining employed for the
process. prediction of surface
profile and roughness,
each approach with its
advantages and
disadvantages is
summarized. It is
evident that ANNs are
a powerful tool, easy-
to-use, and have a good
prospect for the future
applications.
21
International Journal On Engineering Technology and Sciences IJETS
ISSN(P): 2349-3968, ISSN (O): 2349-3976
Volume III, Issue II, February- 2016
VII.REFERENCES
[1] Mihir Thakorbhai Patel, optimization of milling process International Journal (ESTIJ)Vol.2, No.4, August 2012,pp.532-
parameters - a review, International Journal of Advanced 537
Research in Engineering and Applied Sciences 4(9) , (2015) 27 [16] Mr.Ch.Madhu.V.N, .Prof., A.V.N.L. Sharma,
37. Dr.K.VenkataSubbiah, Optimization of cutting parameters for
[2] Milon D. Selvam, optimization of machining parameters for surface roughness prediction using artificial neural network in
facemilling operation in a vertical cnc milling machine using CNC Turning, IRACST Engineering Science and
genetic algorithm, Engineering Science and Technology: An Technology: An International Journal (ESTIJ), Vol.2, No. 2,
International Journal (ESTIJ) 2(4) (2012) 544547. April 2012,pp.207-214
[3] Vikas Pare Geeta Agnihotri, Selection of Optimum Process [17] J.S.Senthilkumaar1; P.Selvarani2 and RM.Arunachalam3,
Parameters in High Speed CNC End-Milling of Composite Selection of Machining Parameters Based On the Analysis Of
Materials Using Meta Heuristic Techniques a Comparative Surface Roughness And Flank Wear In Finish Turning And
Study, Journal of Mechanical Engineering 61(2015)3, 176-186 Facing Of Inconel 718 Using Taguchi Technique, Emirates
[4] Mihir T. Patel, Optimization of Machining Parameters for Journal for Engineering Research, November 2010,pp.1-19.
Turning Different Alloy Steel Using CNC -Review, [18] Mathew.A.Kuttolamadom,SinaHamzehlouia, M. LaineMears,
International Journal of Innovative Research in Effect of Machining Feed on Surface Roughness in Cutting
Science,Engineering and Technology 3(4), (2014) 94239430. 6069Aluminum, Clemson University - International Center for
[5] Navneet K Prajapati, a review on optimization of process Automotive Research,2010,pp.1-19.
parameters for surface roughness and mrr for s.s. 316.on cnc [19] H.M.Somashekara, Optimizing Surface Roughness in Turning
machine, international journal of advanced engineering Operation Using Taguchi Technique And Anova ,International
research and studies 2(1), (2014) 100103. Journal Of Engineering Science And Technology (IJEST)ISSN,
[6] Jitendra Thakkar, A Review on Optimization of Process Vol. 4 No.05 May 2012,pp.1962-1973.
Parameters for Surface Roughness and Material Removal Rate [20] Oktem a, T. Erzurumlu b, H. Kurtaran b, Application of
for SS 410 Material During Turning Operation, Int. Journal of response surface methodology in the optimization of cutting
Engineering Research and Applications 4(2),(2014) 235 conditions for surface roughness, Journal of Materials
242.Sathyavathi, Surface Roughness Optimization Techniques Processing Technology, 12 April 2005, pp.11-16
of CNC Turning: A Review, International Journal of
Engineering and Advanced Technology 2(5), (2013) 447449 [21] S.S.K. Deepak, Applications of Different Optimization
Methods for Metal Cutting OperationA Review, Research
[7] Adnan Jameel, Using Genetic Algorithm to Optimize
Machining Parameters in Turning Operation: A review, Journal of Engineering Sciences,Vol. 1(3), Sept.2012,pp. 52-58
International Journal of Scientific and Research Publications [22] P.V.S. Suresh A genetic algorithmic approach for optimization
3(5), (2013) 16 of surface roughness prediction model International Journal of
[8] Manpreet Singh, Statistical A literature review on machining Machine Tools & Manufacture 42 (2002) 675680.
of different materials with CNC , International Journal of [23] Suleyman Nes_eli Optimization of tool geometry parameters
Emerging Research in Management &Technology 3(8) ,(2014) for turning operations based on the response surface
5053 methodology Measurement 44 (2011) 580587.
[9] Khaider Bouacha, Statistical analysis of surface roughness and [24] M. Brezocnik, M. Kovacic, M. Ficko, Prediction of
cutting forces using response surface methodology in hard surface roughness with Genetic programming,Journal of
turning of AISI 52100 bearing steel with CBN tool, Int. Materials Processing Technology, 2004,pp.28-36
Journal of Refractory Metals & Hard Materials 28 (2010) 349 [25] Jenn-Tsong Horng Investigating the machinability evaluation
361. of Hadfield steel in the hard turning with Al2O3/TiC mixed
[10] Gargi Dey, Enhanced production of amylase by optimization ceramic tool based on the response surface methodology
of nutritional constituents using response surface methodology journal of materials processing technology 2 0 8 ( 2 0 0 8 ) 532
Biochemical Engineering Journal 7 (2001) 227231. 541.
[11] Shahin Ghafari Application of response surface methodology [26] Optimization of CNC end milling Process Parameters on
(RSM) to optimize coagulationflocculation treatment of INCONEL 718 Using Genetic Algorithm, K.Saravanakumar,
leachate using poly-aluminum Journal of Hazardous Materials M.R.Pratheesh Kumar, Dr.A.K.ShaikDawood, IRACST
163 (2009) 650656. Engineering Science and Technology: An International Journal
[12] HamdiAouici, Mohamed AthmaneYallese, KamelChaoui, (ESTIJ)Vol.2, No. 4, August 2012
TarekMabroukic, Jean-Franois Rigal, Analysis of surface [27] Optimization of cutting parameters for surface roughness
roughness and cutting force components in hard turning with prediction using artificial neural network in CNC end milling,
CBN tool, Prediction model and cutting conditions Mr.Ch.Madhu.V.N, .Prof., A.V.N.L. Sharma,
Optimization, Measurement 45 (2012),pp.344353. Dr.K.VenkataSubbiah, IRACST Engineering Science and
[13] Arokiadass, K. Palaniradja, N. Alagumoorthi, Prediction and Technology: An International Journal (ESTIJ), Vol.2, No. 2,
Optimization of End Milling Process Parameters Of cast April 2012
Aluminium Based MMC., Trans. Nonferrous Met. Soc. China, [28] Selection of Machining Parameters Based On the Analysis Of
21 February 2012, pp. 1568-1574. Surface Roughness And Flank Wear In Finish end milling And
[14] Mahesh, G.; Muthu, S.; Devadasan, S. R. Experimentation and Facing Of Inconel 718 Using Taguchi Technique,
Prediction of Surface Roughness of the Machining Parameter J.S.Senthilkumaar1; P.Selvarani2 and RM.Arunachalam3,
with Reference to the Rake Angle in End Mill,International Emirates Journal for Engineering Research, November 2010
Review of Mechanical Engineering;Nov2012, Vol. 6 Issue 7,
pp.1418-1426
[29] Effect of Machining Feed on Surface Roughness in Cutting
6065Aluminum, Mathew A. Kuttolamadom, SinaHamzehlouia,
[15] K.Saravanakumar, M.R.Pratheesh Kumar,
M. LaineMearsClemson University - International Center for
Dr.A.K.ShaikDawood, Optimization of CNC Turning Process
Automotive Research,2010
Parameters on INCONEL 718 Using Genetic Algorithm,
IRACST Engineering Science and Technology: An
22
International Journal On Engineering Technology and Sciences IJETS
ISSN(P): 2349-3968, ISSN (O): 2349-3976
Volume III, Issue II, February- 2016
[30] Application of response surface methodology in the Franois RigalcHamdiAouici a,, Mohamed AthmaneYallese a,
optimization of cutting conditions for surface roughness. KamelChaoui b, TarekMabrouki c, Jean-Franois Rigal c ,,2
Oktem a,, T. Erzurumlu b, H. Kurtaran b, Journal of Materials December 2011
Processing Technology, 12 April 2005 [33] The evolutionary development of roughness prediction models,
[31] Optimizing Surface Roughness in end milling Operation Using MaciejGrzendaa, Andres Bustillo b,, ,13 March 2012
Taguchi Technique And [34] Applications of Different Optimization Methods for
Anova,H.M.Somashekara*,International Journal Of Engineering MetalCutting Operation A ReviewS.S.K. Deepak,Research
Science And Technology (IJEST)ISSN, Vol. 4 No.05 May 2012 Journal of Engineering Sciences,Vol. 1(3), 52-58, Sept. (2012)
[32] Analysis of surface roughness and cutting force components in [35] Prediction and Optimization of End Milling Process Parameters
hard end milling with CBN tool: Prediction model and cutting Ofcast Aluminium Based MMCR. Arokiadass, K. Palaniradja,
conditions Optimization,HamdiAouici a,, Mohamed N. Alagumoorthi, Trans. Nonferrous Met. Soc. China , 21
AthmaneYallese a, KamelChaoui b, TarekMabroukic,Jean- February 2012
23