Identity and Eating Disorders
Identity and Eating Disorders
Task
Read the following information on personal identity, using it to help you explore
who you are, who you want to be and how recovery can help you achieve this.
Let us begin by clarifying the definition of ‘identity’. It is:
• the distinct personality of an individual, regarded as a persisting entity,
i.e. individuality
• the set of behavioural or personal characteristics by which an individual
is recognisable as a member of a group.
Merged identities
Some specialists believe that eating disorders arise as a result of inappropriate
attachments during childhood. For example, a young person might struggle to
become independent from their parents, making it difficult for them to develop
their own identity. Childhood and adult relationships can mould personalities to
fit a need. For example, the child of an alcoholic parent may need to develop
certain personality traits and coping strategies inappropriate for their age,
affecting the natural development of identity in line with their peers.
• 44 •
Identity and Eating Disorders
A new person
Some people believe that the development of their eating disorder completely
changed their personality and made them a nicer person – more likeable or
vulnerable, for example.
Low self-esteem
Most, if not all, people struggling with an eating disorder also have issues with
low self-esteem, caused by a variety of issues (usually over a long period of time).
Feeling unworthy of good things and being unable to assert oneself has a knock-
on effect on personal identity. It isn’t uncommon for a person with an eating
disorder to ‘want’ something but feel unable to ‘have’ or ‘ask’ for that something
because they don’t feel that they deserve it. This restricts the development of
identity and the benefits associated with being more confident and assertive.
Therefore, it is necessary to develop improved self-esteem in conjunction with
personal identity/opinions as part of the recovery process.
Identity idol
Celebrity, fashion and the television industry promote idolised figures, even
though many of the visual images are airbrushed and the stories embellished.
A person vulnerable to an eating disorder might find themselves influenced by
such media, believing that they would feel better about themselves if they were
• 45 •
Eating Disorder Recovery Handbook
more like a particular celebrity, again suggesting that their personal identity is
‘not good enough’ in comparison.
Who’s in charge?
Is an eating disorder a separate entity/voice in your head, that you’re able to
argue with, or simply your mind as a whole? Some people describe themselves
as being separate from their eating disorder – sometimes feeling overwhelmed
by its strength and other times able to fight and overcome its power. Others
say that they feel that they are 100 per cent eating disorder, not knowing any
difference in their mind. The sufferer’s perception has a profound effect on how
an eating disorder should be challenged, bearing in mind that if someone feels
that they are their eating disorder, then fighting it would actually be fighting
themselves.
Recovery
The longer a person has an eating disorder, the harder it usually is to give
up the eating disorder identity. Worries about what other people think creep
into vulnerable minds. Long-standing behaviours, habits and beliefs can’t be
changed overnight, but they can be changed! Recovery is possible!
Reflection time!
Recovery is a process of small steps towards increased self-esteem, better
coping strategies and a more developed positive identity. Who could you
be and what could you achieve if you allowed yourself to meet your full
potential?
Before recovery, I couldn’t even tell you the basics about myself –
what I liked doing, what made me happy, who I enjoyed spending time
with – my identity was all about my disordered eating. Today, I know
what music I like, what helps me relax, my favourite place to walk. I feel
like I have found myself.
• 46 •
Identity and Eating Disorders
4.2 Who Am I?
Objective
Every person is born a unique individual, who then experiences life from their
own perspective, influenced by the environment and characters that surround
them. Key personality traits are apparent from a very young age and then further
developed throughout adolescence and into adulthood. It is not unusual for
people to feel swept away and overwhelmed by life, leaving them feeling a little
lost and confused about who they are and what they want in life. An eating
disorder can exacerbate this situation, hindering the road to recovery. The aim of
this worksheet is to explore who you are and to help pave the road to recovery.
Task
Write down some key words that describe you before the eating disorder in the
first column and who you are at the moment in the second column. This could
relate to your key beliefs/morals, personality, spirituality, interests and ambitions.
The only rule is that your notes shouldn’t be directly linked to weight or food.
• 47 •
Eating Disorder Recovery Handbook
Reflection time!
The only thing in life that you can really rely on is change. An individual’s
personality develops throughout life, meaning that nothing is set in stone
and that you do have a choice about how your future evolves. So, who do
you want to be? You can make it happen!
• 48 •
Identity and Eating Disorders
Task
Read the descriptions below, thinking about how they might apply to you, and
then put the appropriate letters in order of relevance to you. Below you will find
a description of the combination of letters you have come up with.
How you gather and use your energy: (E) you derive
Extraversion or
(E) (I) excitement from engaging with the world, or (I) you
Introversion
conserve energy through mostly private activities.
• 49 •
Eating Disorder Recovery Handbook
The Protector: ISFJ As a protector, you value helping others and will do anything
(Introverted-Sensing- to protect your friends, family or children from harm. You can
Feeling-Judging) be overprotective at times, not giving those you care for the
chance to find their own solutions.
The Counsellor: INFJ You can easily spot emotional cues, and you can quickly
(Introverted-Intuitive- read the motives that inform people’s actions. Your sincere
Feeling-Judging) devotion to the needs of others hides your greatest fear – being
unwanted or unworthy of love.
The Provider: ESFJ You are a people-person; highly attuned to the needs of others,
(Extroverted-Sensing- and eager to support and encourage. This could cause you to
Feeling-Judging) take on responsibilities that aren’t yours. Many individuals who
suffer from an eating disorder share a strong desire to please
others.
The Healer: INFP Artful, spontaneous and individual self-expression are more
(Introverted-Intuitive- paramount than the practicalities of the moment. People value
Feeling-Perceiving) your commitment and desire to support them.
The Teacher: ENFJ You see opportunities where others see obstacles, and your
(Extroverted-Intuitive- commitment and passion to see people succeed are some of
Feeling-Judging) your admirable qualities. However, if those who you support
are struggling, you are likely to blame yourself.
The Inspector: ISTJ Your life is predictable, logical and orderly. Should you develop
(Introverted-Sensing- an eating disorder, the same applies to eating: measuring
Thinking-Judging) calories, arranging food and cutlery in a precise order, or
weighing yourself constantly. You are great at restoring and
keeping order in chaos.
The Mastermind: INTJ Besides your positive qualities – like working consistently to
(Introverted-Intuitive- improve yourself and others – you can be overly perfectionistic
Thinking-Judging) and invoke high standards for yourself and others.
The Craftsperson: ISTP You don’t care much for emotional matters, but the mechanics
(Introverted-Sensing- behind how the world works on a practical level make you
Thinking-Perceiving) come alive. You are action-oriented and can form close ties
with those who work with you to find answers to practical
problems.
The Composer: ISFP You tend to live in, and for, the moment. Seeking and finding
(Introverted-Sensing- beauty in the world matters a lot to you, and sharing this with
Feeling-Perceiving) others makes you thrive. However, your impulse to support
others, without expecting or demanding rewards, can lead to
exhaustion.
The Architect: INTP You are an independent spirit, and spend much of your time
(Introverted-Intuitive- deep in thought, trying to devise new, unconventional ways of
Thinking-Perceiving) doing things. Following the crowd isn’t for you, which is why
you are constantly inventing novel worlds in your head.
The Dynamo: ESTP You are a thrill seeker, and avoid serious emotional discussions,
(Extroverted-Sensing- even though you have some awareness of the emotional needs
Thinking-Perceiving) of loved ones; having fun-filled action in the moment is more
important for you.
• 50 •
Identity and Eating Disorders
The Performer: ESFP Generally full of charm and entertaining, you have a keen
(Extroverted-Sensing- sense of who you are with and what is happening around
Feeling-Perceiving) you. You like to share with others your immediate, humorous
impressions of the world, because you have a need to generate
laughter.
The Champion: ENFP Your curiosity about people and need for close, authentic
(Extroverted-Intuitive- relationships draw others to you. You are passionate about
Feeling-Perceiving) life, and know how to motivate people to go on creative
explorations.
The Visionary: ENTP When others feel stuck and see no way out of a situation, you
(Extroverted-Intuitive- get excited because you see an opportunity to try out something
Thinking-Perceiving) new. The confidence you have in your ability to adapt and
come up with answers on the spot is admirable.
The Commander: Few people can spot flaws in a situation like you do, which is
ENTJ (Extroverted- why you make a great manager and group leader. Your ability
Intuitive-Thinking- to work on new solutions is also commendable, except that you
Judging) can be blunt and insensitive when others don’t quite see your
point.
The Supervisor: ESTJ You believe in order, structure, convention and logic, and
(Extroverted-Sensing- know how to bring stability to a situation. Others perceive you
Thinking-Judging) as someone who is always in control. Although friendly and
outgoing, you don’t have much time for those who don’t play
by the rules.
Reflection time!
So, which personality (or mix of traits) are you? Can you see any links
between your personality and disordered eating? Just by recognising these
links, you are better placed to address them. Indeed, which personality traits
can you use to help you achieve health?
I was (and still am) the Counsellor. However, I now use this to identify
my own emotional needs as well (not just those of others).
• 51 •
Eating Disorder Recovery Handbook
Task
Take your time to complete each of the exercises below, even those you find
uncomfortable at first. They will help you start to build up your feeling of worth,
which in turn will help you see that you are worth recovery.
• 52 •
Identity and Eating Disorders
_______________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________
Self-praise
Many people with an eating disorder find it difficult to praise themselves. They
feel arrogant or self-satisfied if they acknowledge positive aspects of themselves,
and often actively engage in thought processes that seek to maintain a negative
mindset and self-punishment. This behaviour can become habitual and obsessive,
which is something that must be challenged in order to overcome our inner critic.
Using the above exercise, share something good about yourself with a friend
or family member. You may wish to start with ‘I am a good person because…’
or ‘I am proud of being…’
• 53 •
Eating Disorder Recovery Handbook
You may feel uncomfortable doing this exercise, but the more you’re able
to repeat it, the more you’ll be able to believe it. You could argue that the
more uncomfortable you feel, the more you actually need to hear the positive
self-praise.
Reflection time!
Self-development is a continual process that requires ongoing attention, but
the benefits outweigh the effort overall. How can you be patient and kind to
yourself throughout this journey of self-development, utilising all the positive
support surrounding you on the way?
I still struggle to feel worthy, but the difference is that I now challenge
the lack of self-worth by treating myself better.
• 54 •
Identity and Eating Disorders
Task
Each of us will have things about ourselves that we find hard to accept, which
will have an impact on how we live our lives. First, let’s consider what some of
these things might be and then we can look to how we can be more accepting
of ourselves.
• ‘I don’t like my body!’
• ‘I can’t accept a healthy weight.’
• ‘If I don’t do well, then I am worthless – I must over-achieve to compensate.’
• ‘I feel like a freak – I need things a certain way in order to cope; I can’t
cope with uncertainty.’
• ‘I can’t accept not being the best – if I’m not the best, then I’m not good
enough!’
• ‘I can’t accept that I deserve good things.’
• ‘I can’t trust or allow myself to rely on anyone.’
• ‘I can’t accept that someone else could love me.’
• ‘I can never take on board positive compliments.’
• ‘I can’t accept help.’
• 55 •
Eating Disorder Recovery Handbook
It’s important to recognise that the above comments are all examples of negative
thought processes that stem from a source in your life. Where has the message
come from? Who, if anyone, has reinforced this message? What do you do to
reinforce this message in your everyday actions?
_______________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________
Is it time to re-evaluate?
Changing a thought process or belief takes time and commitment. Often, it is
necessary to explore the reasons behind negative thoughts in order to overcome
them, which might require the support of a counsellor. Don’t expect instant
change – long-lasting recovery requires a sufficient timeline.
List the things you find it hard to accept about yourself and any reasons why
you might be struggling with this.
_______________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________
• 56 •
Identity and Eating Disorders
Reflection time!
True Courage…
Comes from knowing that change is constant;
Involves accepting your limitations;
Is strengthened by believing in your abilities;
Comes from accepting imperfections;
Is needed to embrace all life stages;
Involves honest communication;
Is necessary to admit when you need support;
Knows that everyone makes mistakes, and that’s OK…that’s life;
Looks at the future with open eyes and open arms;
Embraces the sun, the rain and the rainbow.12
Accepting myself has been the hardest part of this journey, but it has
been the only way for me to move beyond my eating disorder.
• 57 •
Eating Disorder Recovery Handbook
4.6 Assertiveness
Objective
Assertiveness is often confused with selfishness and aggression, even though it
has nothing to do with being strident or demanding and always having your own
way. To be assertive is to recognise that you have rights that you should stand up
for, while also taking the interests and feelings of others into account. The aim of
this worksheet is help you find that balance.
Task
Read the information below to learn more about the importance of assertiveness,
taking note of where you could be more assertive in your own life.
The costs of not being assertive include:
• a lack of choice
• a lack of confidence
• a lack of respect from others
• development of a childlike persona, allowing others to take control
• a lesser experience of work/relationships/family life
• a feeling of resentment towards decisions you feel unable to be assertive
about
• a feeling of inner frustration and possible anger towards yourself.
Everyone has the right to live life in the way that they choose as long as this doesn’t
interfere with the rights of others. You have the right to say ‘no’ and the right to
have your opinion heard. Being assertive means taking responsibility for your life.
It’s important to be clear about your needs and communicate them clearly.
Often, people fail to get what they want because other people don’t know what
they want, not because they don’t want to give it. Suppose you were hungry and
would like to eat early. You could be direct and say, ‘I am hungry; would you
mind if we ate early?’ Or you could be indirect and say, ‘Are you hungry? Do you
want to eat early?’ In either case, the other person may disagree, but by using
the direct approach at least they would know what you want.
When communicating your needs, try to avoid ‘you’ statements, such as ‘You
are so unreliable.’ The person may resent being blamed. Use ‘I’ statements, such
as ‘I feel angry when you say you will do something and you don’t do it.’ This
expresses your feelings without blaming the other person.
You may find it helpful to break down what you want to say into the following
four parts:
• 58 •
Identity and Eating Disorders
Reflection time!
Remember that being assertive is not the same thing as being selfish or
aggressive. Being assertive will enhance not only your life but the lives of those
around you too. Try to set an example of how people should treat each other by
starting to show some respect for your own opinions and needs.
• 59 •
Eating Disorder Recovery Handbook
Task
Let’s take a step today in seeing our inner child and examining what he or she
needs from us to be happier, healthier and consistent with our adult self.
• 60 •
Identity and Eating Disorders
Take a piece of plain paper and some pens or pencils, and draw your inner
child. Consider factors such as:
• How old is he or she?
• What is he or she wearing?
• What is his or her facial expression?
Purely focus on the image of your inner child at the moment, without thinking
too much about what your inner child is thinking or feeling. Don’t worry about
being the next Van Gogh or Monet – just draw. Alternatively, if you lack the
confidence to draw, search for a picture that demonstrates your inner child.
This isn’t about art but about ‘seeing’ your inner child, the one who has been
crying out for help via unhealthy, disordered thoughts and behaviours.
• 61 •
Eating Disorder Recovery Handbook
Look at the picture you drew of your inner child. Really try to listen to him or
her, writing down the following:
• How does he or she feel?
• What does he or she need?
• How can you help?
In your head, speak back to your inner child and soothe him or her. Tell them
they have been heard and explain how you will help them have their needs
met. If you can, imagine holding him or her. It is OK if you are not yet ready to
do this. It is also OK to tell your inner child that you are new to this and might
not always get it right. Children are incredibly understanding – they don’t seek
or need perfection.
Reflection time!
If you completed the exercises in this worksheet, you will have a much better
idea of what your inner child needs. Reflect on how you might help get these
needs met.
Inner child work was by far the most influential aspect of my recovery.
If I hadn’t met the Little Me, hiding inside, I wouldn’t have been able to
heal the pain and fear she was feeling, which was ultimately at the core
of my eating disorder.
• 62 •
Identity and Eating Disorders
Task
Read some of the strategies below that could help you challenge your own body
image distortions, visualising yourself putting them into action.
The media
Few of the images we see in the media are presented to us in their original
form. Most have been retouched, enhanced, edited or altered in some way.
Furthermore, the media tend to focus on weight loss, associating it with health
and happiness, often without explaining the dangers and risks of excessive weight
loss. Focus has moved away from a healthy balanced diet and towards ‘quick
fixes’ that are unlikely to be maintainable in the long term.
Positive affirmations
Try to start and end each day with a positive affirmation, such as:
• ‘I am going to feel good about myself all day.’
• ‘I am unique and therefore beautiful in my own way.’
• ‘I have many things to be proud of in my life.’
• ‘Today I am going to achieve all the things I want to.’
• ‘I will look after myself so my body can be healthy, strong and function
well.’
• ‘I can’t wait for the next challenge in my life.’
• ‘I am going to eat healthily and exercise sensibly to improve my health.’
Even if you don’t believe the statements are true at first, eventually they will
trickle into your subconscious and become part of your reality, helping you to
overcome the negative feelings you have about yourself.
Pamper yourself
Instead of focusing on weight and perfection, focus on doing things that make
you feel good about your appearance in other ways. For example, you could:
• ask a friend to paint your nails (or do it yourself!)
• get a haircut, colour your hair or style it in a different way
• use a face-mask (even go the whole hog with cucumbers, relaxing music
and candles!)
• take a long bubble bath
• try some new make-up or give yourself or a friend a makeover
• do some gentle exercise (e.g. yoga).
• 64 •
Identity and Eating Disorders
More tips!
• Limit the amount of time you spend looking at yourself and your body
in the mirror. Remind yourself of the concept and power of body image
distortion, and repeat this question to yourself: ‘When I am feeling fat,
what am I feeling beneath the fat feeling?’
• Refuse to buy magazines that emphasise thinness, and pay close attention
to the messages society and the media give us. Be proactive with this
information, not reactive. Consider writing letters to the editor stressing
your concerns, or boycott the magazines once and for all.
• Begin to focus on the concept of inner beauty for yourself and others.
Look for beauty in personality and attitude, and decrease the focus on
physical appearance.
• Fuel your body as you would fuel your car. Calories are energy; deprivation
of calories can result in greater body image distortion.
• When you find yourself focusing on your body, visualise a stop sign, and
don’t allow this focus to continue. ‘Thought stopping’ will also lead to
decreased focus and distortion.
Reflection time!
Which of the above strategies do you think would help you the most? Why
don’t you try it next time you find yourself thinking negatively about your
body? It can’t hurt.
• 65 •
Eating Disorder Recovery Handbook
Task
Read the following tips, highlighting the advice you feel able to try:
• Appreciate other people for their differences, rather than comparing
yourself with them in a critical way. Notice their facial features and
expressions. Consider how people move and interact with each other.
Appreciate how people express their personality.
• Only use mirrors for practical tasks, such as applying make-up. This
includes avoiding the use of windows as mirrors. Stop assessing your
worth based on the shape and size of your reflection.
• Avoid magazines that criticise and ridicule people about their body image.
Choose magazines that encourage physical and emotional well-being, or
relate to another aspect of life, such as travel or hobbies. Assess whether
they encourage creativity, individuality and positive thinking. Consider
choosing magazines that teach you something that will enhance life.
• Spring-clean your wardrobe! Give away any clothes that make you
feel uncomfortable or encourage you to be unhealthy. Try to introduce
clothes that encourage you to feel confident and positive. Express your
personality through your choices.
• Take good care of your body. Feed it well, exercise in moderation and
allow yourself time to rest and relax. Make time to enjoy a bubble bath
or hot shower, and gently moisturise your skin afterwards.
• Make food choices based on what is natural, what your body needs and
what you like. Avoid counting calories and grams of fat. Instead, eat a
variety of different foods regularly throughout the day.
• Surround yourself with positive people who appreciate you for who you
are as a person. Try not to let another person’s opinion negatively affect
your self-worth. You deserve to be treated well by yourself and others.
• Avoid weighing yourself any more than once a week, if at all! Body
dissatisfaction will turn any number on the scales into a reason to
• 66 •
Identity and Eating Disorders
Reflection time!
If you were to implement three of the above tips today, which would they be
and why? So, what’s stopping you? Start now!
However low I feel about my body, I have a rule that it won’t stop me
seeing my friends. This has helped me a lot, as I have usually forgotten
my body worries after a good laugh with friends.
• 67 •