MBALN707 - Topic 5 - Overview
MBALN707 - Topic 5 - Overview
4. Determine the need for external financing and how to present the
business plan in a convincing manner to interested parties.
Introduction
This topic will help us understand the importance of presenting a business plan in
a convincing manner to interesting parties in order to make them “buy” the idea
and invest in its implementation. Of course, investors do not just buy an idea,
they also “buy” the people and the management of the business. The investors
analyze the ability of a business to produce results through effective and efficient
deployment of the business resources. The Entrepreneur should evaluate the
potential sources for gathering the necessary capital. The financial resource
comes first in priority for the business start-up and operation. The financial
resources can give the ability to the business to obtain all the remaining
necessary resources, as covered in the previous topic.
The Entrepreneur must ensure that the business will be able to apply an effective
and efficient resource management in order to produce results that can keep all
stakeholders content. Think for example, that the Entrepreneur is like the
Maestro of an orchestra, who needs to ensure that all the elements of the
business are working in harmony, just like the maestro in an orchestra where
musicians, musical instruments and other equipment all work together to make
the audience happy.
The interested parties for investment can include financial institutions, investors
(potential shareholders), governmental institutions such as the Ministry of
Economy or Commerce that give grants to new small businesses.
Main Analysis
“Why collaborate?
These are the advantages of collaboration given by almost all of the 106 co-
owners in the East Anglian study:
Being able to share the burden. Partnerships give mutual support,
companionship, and someone to share the problems
Very few individuals have all the skills and knowledge needed to run
a business successfully. Another person brings another set of skills,
knowledge and experience.
Being able to look at problems from many angles can help to achieve
better often more creative solutions: more people means more
perspectives
Less autonomy
That is, not being able to do your own thing and not always getting your
own way
Sharing ownership does mean that you can't always do what you want
Differences in personal aims and objectives for the firm
Different views on personal rewards versus investment in the business
People have different views about their own future which may not be
compatible
People differ in how they see the future of the firm; some are ambitious
for their firm and want to build an empire, some want a quieter life.
Decision making can be slower
Having to win consensus often slows decision making.
Collaboration often means that the cost of a wider perspective
on problems is a loss of spontaneity
Source: http://www.startups.co.uk/pros-and-cons.html
At this point, please read the following interesting article in order to learn
about the 5 most common mistakes new business owners make when
budgeting, and how to avoid them.
“Q: What are the most common mistakes new business owners make when budgeting,
and how can I avoid them?
A: If the past five years have taught us anything, it's that flashy business and marketing
plans mean nothing if they are unaccompanied by a sensible long-term financial
strategy. Numbers can lie in the short-term, but the truth almost always comes out in the
end. So as we prepare for the real New Economy, how can entrepreneurs learn from the
mistakes of their predecessors? Avoiding these five common mistakes will help keep
your million-dollar idea from becoming a million-dollar nightmare:
1. Overstating projections. Enron was not the first company to over-promise and
under-deliver, and, unfortunately, it won't be the last. Investors are occasionally fooled
by numbers in the short term, but in the end the funded company almost always gets
hurt. Realistic budgets and projections may lengthen your search for funding, but when
the money does arrive, it will be honest money, and you should then have a profitable
plan to follow for several years to come.
2. Ignoring your immediate budgetary needs. On the other hand, if your plan shows
that you need $50,000 to take a product to market, don't ask for only $30,000. Potential
investors and bankers will only wonder why they should give you money for a project
that will fail without additional funding. This was the sad lesson of the dotcom bubble.
Companies burned through their initial seed money without coming close to profitability
and then gave up. Investors have become more savvy and would rather spend $50,000
in a smart fashion than throw $30,000 out the window.
3. Assuming that the existence of revenue is indicative of being cash-flow
positive. In virtually every transaction, there is a lag time between the finalization of the
deal and the completed cash collection. This is a fact of business and should not be a
problem, assuming you are prepared. Unfortunately, many businesses aren't and run
into serious cash-flow problems because they spend money they don't yet have.
Perhaps what's most troubling is many of these purchases could easily have been
delayed for 30 days, when the available money is finally in the bank. A little wisdom,
discretion and foresight can go a long way toward corporate survival.
Need to brush up on your financial management know-how? Read Fundamentals
of Financial Management by Eugene F. Brigham and Joel F. Houston.
4. Forgetting about Uncle Sam. End-of-the-day balances can often appear larger than
they really are. Sales tax on revenues and employee withholdings may sit in your
account temporarily but will ultimately be owed to the government. Your balance sheets
should not count these finances as holdings, otherwise you run the risk of budgeting for
future projects and costs that you will not be able to afford.
5. Mismanaging the advertising timeline. It seems so elementary: Advertising leads to
sales. However, many budgets show advertising costs as a percentage of sales in the
same period. To be truly effective, an advertising/marketing campaign will have to be
initiated at least one period before sales can be expected. When the additional out-of-
pocket costs are taken into account, a healthy advertising budget is needed before any
revenue can be assumed. Failure to budget the appropriate items in a strategic time
frame will under-utilize finances needed to achieve these sales goals and can lead to
overspending in later months.
Formulating a vision is the hard part. Crunching the numbers is far more simple, yet it is
where many dreams are shattered. Entrepreneurs who treat their budgets with the same
meticulous care as their other components are the ones who survive.”
Source: http://www.entrepreneur.com/article/49360
At this point, please read the following feasibility checklist for starting a
small business before capital investment.
Feasibility Checklist for Starting a Small Business
Perhaps the most crucial problem you will face after expressing an interest in
starting a new business or capitalizing on an apparent opportunity in your
existing business will be determining the feasibility of your idea. Getting into the
right business at the right time is simple advice, but advice that is extremely
difficult to implement. The high failure rate of new businesses and products
indicates that very few ideas result in successful business ventures, even when
introduced by well established firms. Too many entrepreneurs strike out on a
business venture so convinced of its merits that they fail to thoroughly evaluate
its potential.
Here are some questions and worksheets to help you think through what you
need to know and do. Answer each question with a YES or NO. Where the
answer is NO, you have some work to do.
Preliminary Analysis
The first questions ask you to do a little introspection. Are your personality
characteristics such that you can both adapt to and enjoy small business
ownership/management?
Yes No
The next series of questions stress the physical, emotional and financial strains
of a new business.
Yes No
Do you understand that owning your own business may entail working 12
to 16 hours a day, probably six days a week, and maybe on holidays?
Yes No
Do you know which skills and areas of expertise are critical to the success
of your project?
Do you have these skills?
Does your idea effectively utilize your own skills and abilities?
Can you find personnel that have the expertise you lack?
Do you know why you are considering this project?
Will your project effectively meet your career aspirations?
The next questions emphasize the point that very few people can claim expertise
in all phases of a feasibility study. You should realize your personal limitations
and seek appropriate assistance where necessary (i.e. marketing, legal,
financial).
Yes No
To determine whether your idea meets the basic requirements for a successful
new project, you must be able to answer at least one of the following questions
with a "yes."
Yes No
Major Flaws
A "Yes" response to questions such as the following would indicate that the idea
has little chance for success.
Yes No
Are there any causes (i.e. restrictions, monopolies, shortages) that make
any of the required factors of production unavailable (i.e. unreasonable
cost, scarce skills, energy, material, equipment, processes, technology, or
personnel)?
Are capital requirements for entry or continuing operations excessive?
The following questions should remind you that you must seek both a return on
your investment in your own business as well as a reasonable salary for the time
you spend in operating that business.
Add the amounts in (A) and (B). If this income is greater than what you can
realistically expect from your business, are you prepared to forego this additional
income to be your own boss with the prospects of more substantial profit/income
in future years?
Yes No
Can you make a list of every item of inventory and operating supplies
needed?
Do you know the quantity, quality, technical specifications, and price
ranges desired?
Do you know the name and location of each potential source of supply?
Do you know the price ranges available for each product from each
supplier?
Do you know about the delivery schedules for each supplier?
Do you know the sales terms of each supplier?
Do you know the credit terms of each supplier?
Do you know the financial condition of each supplier?
Is there a risk of shortage for any critical materials or merchandise?
Are you aware of which suppliers have an advantage relative to
transportation costs?
Will the price available allow you to achieve an adequate markup?
Expenses
Yes No
Do you know what your expenses will be for: rent, wages, insurance,
utilities, advertising, interest, etc.?
Do you need to know which expenses are direct, indirect, or fixed?
Do you know how much your overhead will be?
Do you know how much your selling expenses will be?
Miscellaneous
Yes No
Are you aware of any major risks associated with your product, service
and/or business?
Can you minimize any of these major risks?
Are there major risks beyond your control?
Can these risks bankrupt you?
Venture Feasibility
Yes No
Are there any major questions remaining about your proposed venture?
Do the above questions arise because of a lack of data?
Do the above questions arise because of a lack of management skills?
Do the above questions arise because of a "fatal flaw" in your idea?
Can you obtain the additional data needed?
Can you obtain the additional managerial skills needed?
Are you aware that there is less than a 50-50 chance that you will be in
business two years from now?”
Source: http://www.canadabusiness.ab.ca/index.php/component/content/article/8-
start- up/429-feasibility-checklist-for-starting-a-small-business
At this point, I would like to refer to the BBC’s programme “Dragon’ Den’’. Do you
know the motto of Peter Jones who is one of the presenters?
Peter Jones
Entrepreneurs usually do not have all the necessary capital to start up and
operate their business, as well as to face unforeseen incidents that need financial
backup to cope with.
In cases where the Entrepreneur needs capital from external parties they need to
present the business plan in a convincing manner to them in order to make them
“buy” the idea and invest. The interested parties for investment can be financial
institutions, investors (potential shareholders), governmental institutions i.e. the
Ministry of Economy or Commerce that give grants to new small businesses.
Also, the TV programme “Dragon’s Den” could be a possible alternative.
At this point, please read the following interesting article about presenting
your idea successfully to potential investors.
Alternatively, identifying current suppliers who service a similar market niche can
give some indication as to which marketing activities are most effective. Of
course, this assumes the incumbent has got it right!
The prospective investor will be keen to understand how exactly you intend to
reach your market. You will also need to articulate the following:
Why would the investor be better off investing in your business rather than
leaving their money in a bank account, or investing in another business?
Why will people part with their cash to buy your product or service?
The percentage of the business you are prepared to sell and its value.
This is their area of expertise; they are seeking an appropriate risk/return for their
investment. Their primary interest will be to assess the ability of the company
(including management) to generate free cash flows to enable the business to
grow while also returning cash to them. Professional advice is highly
recommended if you do decide to go down the equity investment route and it is
important that you have the above points worked out prior to being put on the
spot.
5. Negotiate confidently
If you have succeeded in generating sufficient interest after your original pitch,
the level of questioning is likely to become more in-depth, as the prospective
investors assess whether or not there is a potential opportunity for them. In these
instances, the presenter is on trial as much as the business plan, especially if the
entrepreneur is seeking large amounts of funding and intends to continue to run
the company themselves.
It is worth remembering that the negotiation is not like haggling for a souvenir at
a market, where the transaction is a one–off and neither party is likely to engage
with each other again. It is not about small victories and getting the better of your
opponent. The negotiation takes place in the context of a relationship and hence
must be approached differently.
The negotiation process consists of five main steps:
I. Preparation
Before you begin to negotiate, you must have a clear idea of the issues at hand,
your objectives and your options, from what is the best deal you can get, to the
best alternative to a negotiated agreement (your walk-away position).
In relation to the Dragons’ Den, you need to be clear on:
a. How much you are seeking to raise?
b. What percentage of the company you are offering in return?
c. What type of investor are you seeking: a sleeping partner, or a ‘Dragon’ who
will actively play a role in the company?
II. Discussion
Given the relationship nature of such investments, you need to ensure that the
focus is not solely on ‘the cash’. You need to establish rapport and assess what
exactly the investor requires from the deal. As Stephen R. Covey declares in The
7 Habits of Highly Effective People, “seek first to understand and then to be
understood”. Ask plenty of questions to ensure that the conversation is balanced.
Finally, you must also be transparent with key facts, so as to avoid introducing
‘surprises’ into the negotiation at a later stage; for example, if you have existing
investors on board, this should be disclosed at the outset.
III. Proposals
After you have had a broad discussion and have ascertained their interest, you
can ask them to make you an offer. This offer needs to be specific: they are
offering X in return for Y. After thanking them for their offer, assess it in the
context of your objectives at the start. There is no need to rush to a decision and
it is perfectly acceptable to mull over it or to seek clarification before responding.
IV. Negotiation
Once they have made an offer, you then need to decide (a) how close it is to
what you originally wanted and (b) the bases for negotiation. It is highly
improbable that the proposed terms (i.e. cash, stake, and their role in the
business) will match your objectives exactly. You then need to understand their
position in more detail, including whether there is scope to negotiate, and finally,
seek to reach an agreement that meets both parties’ objectives.
V. Agreement
Once you reach an agreement and have shaken on the deal, it is important to
ensure that both parties feel that they have got a good deal. The last thing the
Dragon wants to hear is you telling the TV Interviewer that you got a much better
deal than you expected. After all, the real value only accrues after the investment
has been put to work on the business idea. The last thing you want is to have
issues with the investor, as a result of them feeling facts were misrepresented or
they were ‘had’.
In summary, to boost your chances of surviving the Dragons’ Den, do not focus
myopically on the product features, but instead ensure that you can clearly
articulate the customer benefits of your idea and how you intend to reach these
customers. It is also important to have a good holistic understanding of the wider
dynamics at play, ranging from the size of the opportunity to the requirements of
the potential investors.”
Source: http://articles.bplans.co.uk/starting-a-business/how-to-survive-
the- dragons-den-2/362
Summary
In this topic we have considered that the Entrepreneur needs to evaluate the
alternative of partnership and in order to make the right decision, they must
understand the pros and cons of partnership. We then proceeded with the
analysis of the financial needs a business must deploy in order to identify the
resources needed to pursue its objectives. We next evaluated the feasibility of
the business described in a business plan. The evaluation involves a process
after the business plan is completed and before presenting it to interested
parties. Finally, we determined the need of external financing, in case the
Entrepreneur does not have all the necessary capital, and how to present the
business plan in a convincing manner to interested parties in order to make them
buy the idea and invest their money.
Further Reading
Think theory 1
Employees are happy if they enjoy a good working environment and fair
compensation
Investors
Suppliers are happy if they are paid according to the payment terms i.e.
prices and credit period
Company must enjoy profits at levels that can keep happy the
stakeholders mentioned above and in addition maintains reserves at a
level can assure future growth and renew depreciable assets