Example of Chapter 1 and Review of Related Literature
Example of Chapter 1 and Review of Related Literature
Introduction
This research was thought by the author because BA Philippine Arts is in the Health Science
University – University of the Philippines Manila, and it is also important to study if art can be
used as an intervention in medicine. This thesis will give the possibility of having a graduate
degree in Art therapy in the University of the Philippines in the near future because of its high
This study focused on the physical, emotional, and psychological benefits of Chinese
painting therapy on patients. In definition, Painting is the process in which the artist applies
paint, pigment, color, or other medium to surface. As we can see, there is a painting and an artist
involve in the definition of a painting. To add to that, painting involves a process of freeing out
the feelings and experiences of an artist. That sometimes, in criticizing a painting an art critic
will look upon the context of why the artist mixed this colour, why did he created this lines, why
the subject is sad, petrified, happy, etc. , why does the light hits the object in this angle, .
Examples of artist that conveyed their feelings and emotion through their paintings were Van
It does not mean that art is a kind of an outburst of emotion but art gives the artist an ability
convey their emotions and feelings through painting. It not just a mood, or temporary emotion
but it is an emotional experience that was transcended to the artist’s paintings. It is not just an
emotion of a moment, but a higher emotion that the artist was hiding that only the canvass and
1
the brush can convey. This high emotions and feelings must be analyzed and given importance
because there is a possibility that painting can help individuals having problems hiding their
The thesis of Paguio, Pestano, Pfeiffer, Funk, and other art therapists proved that art therapy
patients. Art therapy before is often correlated with psychotherapy or the treatment for mental or
emotional disorder or of related bodily ills by psychological means (Merriam- Webster, 2015).
But recently, studies suggest that art therapy is not only beneficial emotionally and mentally
to patients but also physically. Painting therapy can alleviate the symptoms of HIV/AIDS
(Nainis, Williams, et al., 2015). Art therapy is being applied to a wide variety of health issues
including cancer: chronic illnesses such as asthma, epilepsy, and renal disease; neurological
disorders and traumatic brain injuries; physical disabilities; and Alzheimer’s disease and
dementia to improve individual’s wellness, symptoms, and quality of life (Malchiodi, 2013).
This kind of intervention is being studied and done in many countries, especially in European
The researcher believes that BA Philippine Arts should also include art therapy in its units of
courses because of its huge benefit to the graduates of the course and also in the field of
medicine in the Philippines. The development of arts in the country should not only focus on
2
Research Question
“How can painting therapy improve and enhance the physical, mental, emotional well-being of
patients?”
Objectives
4. To introduce painting therapy to the University of the Philippines and to have graduate
The Chinese Painting Therapy of the College of Allied and Medical Professions, University
of the Philippines Manila is the chosen subject matter for the study.
discipline with principles and refined techniques, with purposeful use of brushes, ink, paper,
color and composition. Depicting subjects such as people, birds, flowers, and landscapes, these
paintings represent one of the oldest styles of art in existence today. It is a form of meditative art
because it uses feelings and sentiments of the artist in his/her reality, that is why this research
was created and it is to see if Chinese painting is not only a relaxing, meditative form of art but
therapy that is being done to cerebral palsy and stroke patients in the College of Allied and
Medical Professions, University of the Philippines Manila. The physical effects that is researched
in Chinese painting is concentrated in the fingers, eyes, and wrist muscles of the patients because
of the method of the style. The researcher will also venture in discovering the emotional and
mental benefits of Chinese Painting Therapy to motor movement disorder patients. In doing this,
the author enumerated the emotional, physical, and mental effects of art therapy to patients
conducted in the College of Allied and Medical Professions about this new kind of therapy.
The methods and instruments in Chinese Painting therapy that were conducted to patients
were recorded and given observations. Also, the brief history of the founding of this kind of
therapy in the Philippines was included. The development and the training for this kind of
therapy were discussed. Background regarding the methods and the spiritual context of Chinese
Painting therapy were also included in thesis. Also the people behind must be given importance
in the thesis, because they started this new kind of therapy to cerebral palsy and stroked patients.
Looking closely, the research could establish the basis for giving more funding and development
This research did not go through the experiments to found out the emotional and mental
effects of Chinese Painting therapy to the patients because many researches have been done to be
used as references in this part. The research only gave a brief explanation of the effects of
Chinese Painting therapy to the emotional and mental to the patients through observation and not
through tests or experiments. But in the physical effects, tests and experiments were conducted
Since art therapy is new to the country compared to other forms of therapy, a lot of art
majors could be very interest in this. Also the huge impact of this kind of therapy will be greatly
experience in patients having problems with their motor movements (Parkinson’s disease,
cerebral palsy, stroked patients, traumatic brain injury, etc.). A new breed of artists will be
created if this thesis will be given more development and research, those artist who does not only
create works of art for corporation, entertainment, and visually, but also for patients having not
This may be the first study for the effects of painting therapy to stroke and cerebral palsy
patients in the Philippines and this will yield huge benefits not only to patients but also pride and
glory to the University and the course. The researcher may be insufficient in some areas like in
the field of therapy and psychology but this research will spark more researchers in studying this
field of art and therapy. This will give a wider scope of art in the society and country.
By studying this matter of therapy, universities and hospitals may find the probable
implications of this therapy to society. And will lead to opening courses in art therapy and
opening jobs for art therapists in the future. In conclusion, this research can be a benefit not only
Research Design
5
Methodology
Qualitative and Descriptive research designs were used in the thesis. The challenge for
the author is describe the process of Chinese painting and find the effects of it through a
qualitative research design approach. The researcher’s duty is to understand the probability of
Chinese painting therapy to be used as a beneficial for patients having motor movements
disorders, although it is being conducted already. The experiments and tests that will be
An interview is vital in knowing the background, the process, and the proper guidelines
that were used in conducting Chinese Painting therapy to the patients. The interview with Prof.
Arnold Esguerra, the therapy facilitator, was vital because he gave the proper methods and the
instruments to be used in the therapy. Also he gave the reason why Chinese painting therapy is
more useful for motor movement disorder patients. Lastly, library research and internet research
on Chinese Painting by for articles, journals, and theses created in the field of Chinese painting
therapy will be used to know the method and way of practicing the painting style these were
several ways to conduct the study in order for the researcher to discuss the benefits of art therapy
Observation will also be conducted by the author to know the psychological and
emotional effects of Chinese Painting to the patients. Also participative observation will be done
by the researcher to feel the essence and effects of Chinese Painting therapy personally to create
a bigger and wider analysis of the therapy. Through observing the process, and jotting down the
visible joy and happiness of the patients undergoing the therapy will also prove the benefits of
6
Lastly, the interview with the Clinical Supervisor, Ms. Jennifer C. Guevarra, OTRP, is
vital because she sets the proper guidelines that is to be followed in conducting the therapy. It
must be understood and taken into account in the research the guidelines for the therapy, because
To measure the physical effects of Chinese painting therapy to patients through their
hand and wrist muscle coordination. Dynamometer wrist and strength manual testing will be
conducted with physical therapists to know the efficiency of the therapy to them. Patients will be
measured one week before their sessions and will be measured after the week to know the
efficiency of the therapy. The process of measuring will be done by a license physical therapist
or occupational therapist. The data and measurements were analyzed and were included in the
thesis. The researcher will go undergo the interviews after the session will be made.
Schedule:
January 7, 2015
- Measure the dynamometer wrist and the strength of the wrist to one cerebral palsy patient
7
January 21, 2015
- Participative observation, attend the session to experience the emotional and psychological
- Measure the dynamometer wrist and the strength of the wrist of the two patients
- Analysis of data
8
Operational Framework
After the researcher introduced the topic and the problem of the research, the researcher has
come up with the conceptual framework of the research. The framework of the study is a step by
step procedure for knowing the benefits of art therapy to patients having motor movements
9
disorder. First, the researcher will choose one stroke patient and cerebral palsy patient who is
currently in the Chinese Painting therapy session by understanding that the patient is able and is
capable of having his/her strength tested and measured. The choosing of the participant will
handled with great precautionary measures because the research may be able do more harm than
good. The patient will be observed and measured (by a certified physical therapist) both
physically and psychologically before he/she will undergo the session. And then, the session will
commence.
After the session, the patient will be observed by the researcher and his/her wrist and hand
muscle coordination and will be measure via dynamometer wrist and wrist control strength
manual testing. And then, all the data, measurements, and observation will be written in the
The interviews to Mr. Esquerra and Ms. Jennifer, will be used as data for the
recommendation of the thesis. Their inputs will be used for the development and more funding of
the art therapy. Also, their inputs will be used by the author to push his objective to introduce art
therapy as a course that universities should think about and in the future will be an undergraduate
or graduate course in the university and spark the need of art therapists in every hospital in the
society.
The operation of the research must not be changed or else the data and the measurements of
the research will be changed, knowing that it must be avoided in a quantitative research.
10
Definition of Terms:
Art therapy - Art Therapy is a mental health profession in which clients, facilitated by the Art
Therapist, use art media, the creative process, and the resulting artwork to explore their feelings,
reconcile emotional conflicts, foster self-awareness, manage behaviour and addictions, develop
social skills, improve reality orientation, reduce anxiety, and increase self-esteem (American Art
Dynamometer wrist – Accurately measures the strength of the wrist muscles during flexion,
extension, abduction and the forearm muscles during supination and pronation, (Rehabmart,
2015).
Strength Manual Testing - It is done to assess muscle strength of a patient, which can provide the
physical therapist (PT) details that can assist him or her in planning appropriate interventions or
11
Review of Related Literature
The review of the literature for this study focuses on the effects of painting therapy and
its benefits to people experiencing depression, anxiety, stress, and trauma. This RRL also focuses
on the possible use of Chinese painting therapy as a means of aiding patients mentally,
physically, and emotionally. The chapter begins with the proven effects of art therapy to patients
having chronic illnesses and mental problem. Also this chapter gives some insights to the
benefits of painting therapy in the spiritual aspect of the patients and gives a discussion on how
art can heal a person. The research outcomes to the potential benefits of art therapy in terms of
physical, mental, emotional, and spiritual aspect of a person, the spiritual context of Chinese art
Many researchers proclaimed that there is indeed a potential benefits of art therapy to
patients in terms of physical, mental, emotional, and spiritual. Dominic Paguio’s thesis entitled,
Children with Cancer (Paguio, 2005)”, proved the effectiveness of art therapy in improving the
self-esteem of children with cancer. He found out that art therapy for cancer patients can improve
self-esteem and alleviates anxiety to children with cancer. He even recommended that art therapy
must be included to the care to children with cancer because of its proven potentialities.
Both self-esteem and anxiety levels are the main problems medical practitioners face
when intervening patients with chronic illnesses. The ‘will to fight and live’ of the patients
cannot be cured with medicine, especially patients with cancer. Knowing that cancer and chronic
illnesses not only are detrimental to the body of the patients but also they have damaging effects
12
to the psychosocial aspect of the patients. This is when art therapy intervention follows, to help
patients cope with their situation and give them hope for the future.
Empirical Art Therapy Research Protocol (Pfeiffer, 2012),” the author developed an
experimental design that aims to find out whether using art therapy with pediatric patients before
surgery and other procedures requiring anesthesia can reduce patients’ anxiety. The author also
explained the effects of various art therapy intervention techniques on anxiety. Lastly, the author
emphasized that quantitative research and evidence-based practice is the future of art therapy.
This only proves that art therapy is not only in qualitative in nature, but can be objectified
and measured with concrete evidence. Its effects has integers and can be measured
quantitatively. Pfeiffer’s research only proves that the there is a future for art therapy use in
healing patients mentally and emotionally. But what was interesting is the research is when the
author uses a quantitative research design to the research, because qualitative research design is
always used in research art therapy. This just means that art therapy can be measured
According to Caroline Even in her thesis entitled, “Making Time for Culture Change:
Therapy as Method for Cultivating Lived Time in Dementia Care,” and Doric-Henry’s article
entitled, “Pottery as Art Therapy with Elderly Nursing Home Residents. Art Therapy”, Art
therapy can be a useful and fulfilling activity to help elderly psychologically. Art, dance, and
music inspire people suffering from frustrating circumstances (being old, unable to express
oneself, etc.) to connect with others. Both studies proved that art therapy can improve the
13
psychological well-being of the elderly. Lastly, art therapy can be used to nurture relationships
These two researches proved that art therapy can connect people in a community. Art
therapy not only can be used to an individual but to the community as a whole. An artwork can
convey messages and can be used as a symbol to groups of people. Their researches is a vital
part of the research because it will be used as a basis of community painting therapy.
According to Nainis, Williams, et al. in their thesis entitled, “Art therapy for Relief of
Symptoms Associated with HIV/AIDS”, art therapy can be used to manage the symptoms of
HIV/AIDS and can be used as care management to the patients. Their study shows that the
physical symptoms of the HIV/AIDS victims were better after attending one art therapy session.
They conclude that there is indeed potential benefits of art therapy in relation to symptoms
This research will be used as part of the benefits of art therapy to patients in the thesis.
the author believes that not only medicines, antibiotics, or surgery can heal someone but also to
heal a person, he/she must be healed physically, mentally, emotionally, and spiritually.
Art therapy is being applied to a wide variety of health issues including cancer: chronic
illnesses such as asthma, epilepsy, and renal disease; neurological disorders and traumatic brain
injuries; physical disabilities; and Alzheimer’s disease and dementia to improve individual’s
Art therapy is not only done to patients to give them hope and make them feel ‘good’ but
art therapy has quantifiable and detectable effects to patient’s wellness and health. Art therapy is
14
better to be coined as ‘medical art therapy’ because of its benefits and implications to the welfare
of the patients. The research of Malchiodi, proved that a box of crayons and papers can create
big benefits to the patient’s health and wellness. Restoration is the key in completely healing a
patient.
The book of Hass-Cohen entitled, “Art Therapy and Clinical Neuroscience,” shows that
art therapy has a role in giving patients positive outlook in their illnesses, art therapy can be used
together with treatments to cure diseases. This book further proven that art therapy can be used
Another book which shows the healing effects of art therapy to patients is the book
entitled, “The Healing Flow – Artistic Expression in Therapy (Schnetz, 2005)”, its states that art
can heal the emotions of patients by healing the psyche of the patients when they created their
image, wherein they can share their grievances and frustrations that will heal their inner self,
giving them a positive outlook on life even though facing diseases or illnesses. This research will
be used as a basis for proving the healing capabilities of art therapy to patients, thus stressing that
Art therapy is firmly grounded in scientific research, according to the book by Frances
Kaplan entitled, “Art, Science, and Art Therapy”, art and science can relate through the
application of one to the other. Both a science of art and an art of science are conceivable, art
making is inherently therapeutic, art therapists offer something that other professional is unlikely
to provide. Art also has characteristics that can be tailored to alleviate specific types of problems.
method of communication; it can promote group bonding; and facilitate creative problem
15
solving; it can provide success experiences for the severely impaired; and it can ‘make special’
The book proves that art has the capacity to enhance quality of life and can improve the
health of both the sick and the healthy. By giving concrete evidences of the linking of art and
science, art therapists can further research about science not only art as therapist but also science
as an art therapist.
Art therapy is not only applicable to patients having illnesses but also to people having
behavioral problems. In the thesis of Sabina Pestano entitled, “Visual Arts as Adjunct Tool in
Counselling Adolescents with Behavioral Problems”, it is concluded that group counselling for
adolescents having behavioral problems is more efficient if art therapy is included to it. Thus,
visual art activities can help counselling for the behavior problems of the adolescents.
Art therapy can help children experiencing traumatic grief re-engage developmental
coping strategies in order to work through grief and trauma symptoms through creating a warm
therapeutic alliance, with engaged and sustained reciprocal communication (Lu, 2007).
The research performed by Lu, also concluded that artist is different from art therapists.
Because art therapists need to follow rules and guidelines to not harm the patient, art therapy
must be done by professionals who had proper training because it can lead to worsening of the
illness. This research will be used by the thesis to further explore the critical parts of art therapy,
Also, art therapy can be a vehicle for a social justice. Art can serve as a healing and
politicized vehicle of agency, voice, and visibility for those who have experienced trauma related
to oppression (Funk, 2012). Therefore, art therapy spaces can promote healing, connection, and
16
movement within the lives of individuals and communities while also facilitating movement
This only proves that art therapy is a very big topic that have a very huge potential. Art
therapy not only affects the lives of individuals but also the community as a whole. It can help
people who experienced trauma, political violence, and pacification. Art therapy can serve as a
medium of voice them, thus giving them connection and healing in themselves.
But according Edith Kramer, although art therapy have a great impact and huge potentials
as a healing tool for patients or individuals (Kramer, 2000). There must be limitations and there
must be certain rules and guidelines to follow before doing the therapy. An art therapist need to
be prepared to administer psychological first aid in terms of crisis, he/she needs to understand
his/her limitations, and art therapists must adapt to the style and imagery of their clients or
This just shows that art therapy has many limitations because it is still under research.
The thesis that will be done not only will shed light to the subject of the potentials of art therapy
Chinese Painting Therapy is being done in the University of the Philippines Manila for
stroke and cerebral patients to improve their motor skills. This research is intended to promote
the therapy group to the population of the university. But not only does Chinese painting therapy
improve the motor skills of the patients but according to researchers it has more benefits to the
patients.
17
In the book of Kalmonowitz entitled, “Art Therapy is Asia: To the Bone or Wrapped in
Silk”, Chinese traditional painting may be seen as an aid to meditation, an opportunity to ponder
on life and provide material for deep thinking (Kalmonowitz, 2012). The practice of Chinese
Painting also can cure insomnia and depression and it can be used as a spiritual exercise to foster
spontaneity and creativity. Chinese traditional painting is also used to bring persons to a
spontaneous sensing of what arises in them of what they are doing, feeling, and planning.
Chinese painting therapy have a huge potential to be used as the basis for painting
therapy for patients. Not only it teaches patients self-control, but also inner peace, a medium of
thinking, a spiritual exercise, and give the patients to contemplate their lives and their plan for
their future. It must be inferred that Chinese painting also has a spiritual context to it.
In fact according to Mimi Farelly-Hansen, in her book entitled, “Spirituality and Art
Therapy - Living the Connection”, art therapy is a language of the heart and soul. It can be a tool
so that patients can voice out their inner grief, frustrations, and disappointments to their lives. Art
therapy also can help patients contemplate their value in the society and their value to their self
as persons. And by reaching the spirit of the patient, art therapists can give them more hope and
Painting therapy gives patients a sense of fulfillment and hope. Not only does painting
therapy aids in healing patients physically (e.g. cerebral palsy and stroke patients) but also
need of every human in the world. That is why painting therapy holds a huge potential in
18
Bibliography:
AATA. (2015). Welcome to the American Art Therapy Association. Retrieved from American
Art Therapy Association: http://arttherapy.org/
Doric-Henry, L. (1997). “Pottery as Art Therapy with Elderly Nursing Home Residents. Art
Therapy: Journal of the American Art Therapy Association, 14(3), 163-171. ISSN-0742-1656.
Retrieved from http://www.tandfonline.com.
Even, Caroline (2013). “Making Time for Culture Change: Art Therapy as Method for
Cultivating Lived Time in Dementia Care.” School of the Art Institute of Chicago.
Farrelly-Hansen, Mimi (2001). “Spirituality and Art Therapy – Living the Connection.” London,
England: Jessica Kingsley Publishers Ltd.
Funk, Katrina Ann (2012). “Becoming Visible, Becoming Brave: Broadening the Realm of Art
Therapy Practice.” School of the Art Institute of Chicago.
Hass-Cohen, N., etal. (2008). “Art Therapy and Clinical Neuroscience.” London, England:
Jessica Kingsley Publishers Ltd.
Kalmonowitz, D., etal (2012). “Art Therapy in Asia: To the Bone or Wrapped in Silk.” Retrieved
March 3, 2015 from https://books.google.com.ph/books?id=RHBHi-
3jv3IC&printsec=frontcover&vq=Chinese+Painting+therapy#v=onepage&q&f=false.
Kaplan, Frances (2000). “Art, Science and Art Therapy.” London, England: Jessica Kingsley
Publishers Ltd.
Kramer, Edith (2000). “Art as Therapy.” London, England: Jessica Kingsley Publishers Ltd.
Lu, L. (2007). “I don’t know where is me: Lost and found in art therapy – a transcultural
approach exploring cultural bereavement, trauma, and grief.” Concordia University (Canada)
MAI 46/03, 96. ISBN 9780494347546. Retrieved from
http://search.proquest.com/docview/304784486/abstract.
Malchiodi, C. (2013). “Art Therapy and Health Care.” Retrieved March 3, 2015 from
https://books.google.com.ph/books?id=cvby43NaeNcC&printsec=frontcover&vq=chinese+paint
ing+therapy#v=onepage&q=chinese%20painting%20therapy&f=false.
Mangusan, D. (2014). Physical Therapy Notes. Retrieved May 13, 2015, from
http://www.physicaltherapynotes.com/2010/09/manual-muscle-test-grading.html
Paguio, Dominic Torralba (2005).”Effectiveness of Art Therapy in Improving Self-Esteem and
Alleviating Anxiety among Children with Cancer.” University of the Philippines Diliman.
19
Pestano, Sabina Aponesto (2000). “Visual Arts as Adjunct Tool in Counselling Adolescents with
Behavioral Problems.” University of the Philippines Diliman.
Rao, D., Nainis, N., Williams, L., et al. “Art Therapy for Relief of Symptoms Associated with
HIV/AIDS.” US National Library of Medicine. #10.1080/09540120802068795. Retrieved April
14, 2015 from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19085221.
20