Scribd
Upload
209 views

The Cultural Nature of Human Development

First chapter of Barbara Rogoff's Cultural Nature of Human Development

Uploaded by

tysonleewoolman
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF or read online on Scribd
209 views

The Cultural Nature of Human Development

First chapter of Barbara Rogoff's Cultural Nature of Human Development

Uploaded by

tysonleewoolman
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 18
I Orienting Concepts and Ways of Understanding the Cultural Nature of Human Development Human developments cultural proces. As. biological species, humans are deine in tern of out cull parsiipation. Weare prepared by both ‘our eltural and biologi heritage to we language snd other cultural ol hd eam fom each eter, Using ich means as language ad erry, we ‘an cllecsinely remember evens that we have not personally experienced coming invalved viciously in other peopl’ experience over many prensions cing human inva conseine and possibile stemming from log, issore of human practices. At he same time each generation conics to revise and adapts human clr and biologi heiae inthe ice of ‘My am in this Books wo contribue ro he understanding of euler perms of human development by examining the regulates hat make Sense of difrences and sic in commune’ practices and ea tions neering clr proceses, [watt draw anti othe con Faueaions of roine ways doing things in any commas’ ppreach | living fcas on people's participation in thei communi cultura prac tices and wadivons rather than equating culture with the nacional o chic of ndvidhals. For undersanding cular apts of human developmen, primary palo this book isco develop che stance hi ppl deco pertiipans| Sh eularal commit, Thi deeopment ca be nero oly ight of ‘the lal pratcs and circumstances of ter commantes—ubich eho hone Ta dt, he sty of hua deepens ha bon bse ag 0: seach and tory coming from mises communities in Europe and Non Americ Such revearch ad theory often hare Been sued Be ern al people Indeed, many resucher make onsksons from work dlve ina single group in overly general erm liming that" eld does such-and- eather than “hese cde did sacha For example great del of research has attempted to detrmine a what age one should expec “the chlo be capable of certain sills, For ‘he most par, che aim have een generic regaing the age which chil dren emer a sage o shouldbe capable of eran sil ‘call approach aoe ht difeent curl communis may ex pet children wo engage in actits ae aly dees in chlo and | may rgen “timeahle”ofdevsopmcne ner commis 2s prising lor even dangerous. Consider dhs quesons of when chen can bein to dbo cerain things and nepors of curl vain in when the do When does blr development permit them 10 be niponible fr ther When cathe be ted ake ce of on inf? In mile-clss US. amis, cident often ot rgd capable of cating fr themselves or ening another child unl perhaps age ofr later imsome regions. In the UK, iran offense to eave u child under age 4 Yeas without dae persion Subbu, 1999 Howexe in many thet communities around the world, children begin to take on spony for tending other children at age 57 (Rov al 7 se Figure), ad i some paces even younger children begin to asune his responsibilty For ‘xample among the Kar of Oceania ‘The year ols ae sled workers ia the garden and house calle caregies of ther younger siblings, and accomplished ac sexialimeraction. Although young chile alo have eto pa. _many ofthe functions f ply sce o be mex by work For bath ‘cults and children, works accompanied by singing, joking, vba ‘lay and entertaining conversation, seid of playing with dll shite cate for el babies. ln adton o working nthe amily ga dens, young children have her own gd pls. The latter may seem lk ply but by hice or Four year of age many chide age taking produce they have grown theme othe market ssl thereby making ignfcan and valued conrbuson co the faily income. (Watson. Gegeo, 930. #7) ‘This year-old Mayan (Goer) gies ale ee for hr When cide udgment and coordination allow heme tw bande sharp ive sf? Although U.S. middle se adults often do noe ra cilres below about with nies, rong the Ff ofthe Democratic Republi of Cong. in fans routine) woe machee sally (Wilke personal communication, 189 see ite 3), Likewise, Fore (New Gina inns handle knives an fire ‘Sly by che time they ae able to walk (Sorenson, #979) Aka pens of Cental Ala each ro 1-month od infants how wo chow sal seats td use sal pointed digging ticks and mini axe with sharp eet ‘de: Tang fr aronomy begs in nny Ian at llowed cel cr walk whatee hey wantin camp and allowed Ye aes troche, digg sh, nd clay pos sround camp. Onl ian infin begins to stl ino re ois anor hi do pens thers ineie with he infant’ vy wa 20 un, forin Stance ose an eight mon ol th asi inch be choping he branch ee of sos By seo ory faci ten can cook thems amon he and by ten yest 252 Aachen kno enough subssenc loin in he re Aloe if acd be (Hewlet, 99 p39 El baby of w mone ache, under the the a ore of he rect Repl of = So, at what age do cildten develop responsibly for oters sl en ill and judgment eo handle dangsousnplerments? "AKO couse, i depend ra may tay sft ag me Es bs on hr ‘cultural experience. — Inde. edged atom in epeceons for iden make es once we ak ino scout den cman an ins Tey male we th Covet of iene in wha ninvbedin paring mao eng ay what sourcvof apt an dangers conmen, whe cis near ‘athe ler kal ada aw thy eh ition plese tories who gas ce community hs dee "ent tomate enonng inthe tio delta pan ‘Whether he activi ian eve hoe or partion he ot 2 boxer eprint eps mans Spend ae pon he icant in te community aon heey "thy ae eo Wh hy Jo depend imprae ws tc turd meni gen vers andthe socal and onl pare fra he communi lenin nd crying os Cle escech ha sided schol examining theres based on by servations in European and European American commanitis for thet ap- Pail in other craumseances. Some ofthis wok ha provided cri founteresamples demonstrating limitations or challenging bai ssump- tions of theory that was assumed apply oll people everywhere. Es sampler re Bronsaw Malinowski (927) research questioning che Ocal Complex in Sigmund Feud theory and crost-clutl er of cognitive de ‘lopment ht led Jean Paget o drop his cam that adolescents univesaly ‘euch a formal operational” stage of ing ale ro ytematcly est hy pothee (i973 se Dusen & Heron, 198) The importance of understanding cular process as become cleat in recen years. This has been spurred by demographi changes thoughout NNowh America and Earope, wih bing everyone more in contact wih clara radon dilleing fom thir own Scholars now secognize that ‘understanding clr spect of human developmen isimportant for r= solving pressing pata problems a well afr progeess ia undestanding the nature of human development ia worldwide rrms. Clara research isnecesary to move beyond evergencraizaions tha sume thar human developmenc everywhere Functions in the sume ways asin researcher own Communities, and tobe able to accoune for bork smarts and dilzences ‘Understanding seuss in the carl nature of human develop ment i primary aim of tht book: Observations made in Bora Bora oe CGrcinnat can form interesting cultural ports and reve ieiguing di- ference in cum, but more important, they ca help usr discern ep lates inthe diverse patterns of human developmen ia diézenecomm- Looking for Culral Regulavties Beyond demonsteating that kare matters my aim in this bok st in cepiate che available lem and reseuch to contibue to grater under standing of heute mers in human deveopnnt. What elites an felp us make sense of the elt specs of human development? To ‘derstand the proces that characterize the dynamic development of in Jee ow them onthe mya out lve Gives your cide and (ee clue them athe Kinde andi he schools, We il JerThsn ey and make tem acid wih he snd pag. {Goel in Ada 996.748) ‘he asumption that societies devdop along one dimension fom pvimive to advanced survived int the second half of the woos (Col eassis ako Latoache 196) Whe. afer Wold War I the United Ne Bae pannel economic and pital “development” fr newly independ ear calona empires, che gal wae to make them more “developed (in 2 sirecone! ese ike ener tiempos to make chem more “vied”. oval schooling was ake ol Schooling mold on European or Nowth mercanetha sret hroughout he Former colonia empires “ai” Frople oto poverty and ignorance nd bring sem ica “modern” ways “Moving Beyond Assumption fa Single Goal of Haman Development Assmpions based on one own ie about what desirable oc human de- ‘opens ave bee ery iil fr rsearcrs and theorist detec be asso thinly of Backgrounds (being, unl rece, amos ex ‘say hight ehooled men fom Europe and North Amen. As Ulc ‘Neer peated ou self centered deiniins of inlligence form che basis of ineigence ess ‘Academie people are among the stouts defenders ofthe norin of Tocligene the tet sem so obo valid ous who are mem ber ofthe academic commmnie Thee sno doubs that Aca ‘eric nelignc is ely importa free kind of work hat we ‘do, We realy lpn believing hai importa fo kine of Signiane work Thus academic people atin the postion of having focused thet profesional cites around a particle pr oval uly sania ina certain st of sil We have shen fe oie the guar in er of thi sl set and ended by sSring tha pesons wb ack hee speci late unitlige a topeter 6975. p08) tr Enea Jv ache young sas amigo ligase Forays of seach ad hain ouide iowa cuul com nies and growing communication ston india 0 anong idl eed with mow than one commaniys aos have helped the fell move Bod hese wan Recah oy oy in Gevyatiad fin community ol elt o Ke development of cde Super 6 Hake 997 For example cul sich ar rn tation easton in he sceanceof ley an pltecy sin difeen communi. In comin in wich rc i key communication secon es in adulthood, preschoolers may need ro earn to diinguish beowcen ‘he cao and shaper of alin as Howes ery or oe ina communiys paces, young cies in deteing wasn io ‘ink squiggles might have litle import. . Slay. if Teac serves impor eligi uncon, dul may impesitimpotanc on young chien Ge ge). Fr expe it Jewish commusnities of earh th Eu i ry wen entry Eup, boy fi ay at ‘choot ined major ceremony dt command the elves and ar tense abn Wri) ey ar wen cy in to schol covered by a prayer shes sae woud ot ey se anything um holy long the way ands school the rab would wate the alpha in hey on sate ile ier ads showered he boy with ends eling i thang hem own sos he wuld wan to td \. scot ie ways poking alin some commis bu no hc on hen become lied ning he ate le aed eeSsemunay Onde MeCabe 995 Min 19 Selon & Se eno Wal & Hest, 190) For eample the are se ed eset” how andl by Afan Amen coe ioe Tie teme i conected cps, wear he nara wl tran Ameican chen may employ sisted coun ccd on asng wpe wich mre dol toenble the ete ss SUS ache am foe cae 8 Caden, 6), When pe dit aration which nomaionepding ide poup sca ahp wu remored Earpean Aner dale he Espn ‘rutan crn ope moe illo ndings pee chance of ‘RES eting In conan, Azan Ames loud he Aan ‘Soctan ces urate ote ber ore nd inden ngage iting too of meses n eading The al jlgmen eee ‘heir tprecinn oft es eshae erp thet pc ch nrting tela how scr Micha Cane, 6) fc on feacy on edo spe promote in schol may sec told such mporacsin some clang whee it maybe mo ‘Inport fr yung cheno en aed whe mance wee crs or of socal cus ef people rund the, 0 word le JP ort undestan i an beeen man nd oor ees ‘ete the nant te Fie None nitston nb he ommion on Vii oend by Wa and Mary Coleg Imesh ieee ir a You who are wie mut ow, chat diferent ations hve different conceptions of tings: and you wl sherelore nor ake it amis if our “en ofthis kindof education happen not be dhe same with sours We have had some experience of several of our young people were formesy brought up athe college ofthe northern provinces they were instructed nal our sciences but when they me back ow. [they were] ignore of every means of ving in ‘he woods acide fi fr hunters, warn, of counsellors: they ‘vere rot god for noting, We are, however, nor the ls obliged Ubyyour kind fer... and to show or grate sens of it che gealemen of Virginia wil send us a dren oftheir os, we wil ake {ft cof deduction insrac hem i all we know, and make ‘meno them. gpotd in Dae, 83) [A more contemporary xample of dfirencs in gals comes from ‘West Alcan moshets who had scennly immigrate to Pais They cit ine he French use of toys get infin ola something forthe Stare 25 ing ou the abi, and prefered vo jst et abies play without fig Jing them (Rabun Jamin 194) Part of th ers lo rated toa con ‘eam tha such focus on objects may lead 1 impoverished communication and lation (in much sesame ny that US mills parent might ‘expres concen about the negative input of video gies). These Aan mothers seemed to prion soil intlgence ne echnologi intl gence (bain Jamin, 194) They more fen responded o thei r= 5- _month-ldinfansoial aesion and wer ls responsive to the ina in ‘inves regudiag objects than were Hench mothers, The Alien mother fen scared inaction wth hr infused ener people wheres the French mothers on focused interaeon on exploration of animate objects eas Seymour, 1999). When interaction dd fous om object, the African mothers sessed the socal factions ofthe objet such sen ‘hancement of social telaonshipe sheogh shri ‘or acton seme, eather than objct we Prorzation of socal relationship lo oct in Appalachian com ‘munis inthe United States, where commitments o her people fe ‘quent take precedence ver completion of schooling, When hard times tise for amily members or neighbors, Appalachian youth en eae jan ior high or highschool to hep hod chins together (imum & Borman, 1997) Social sda is valued above individ uecomplnent. The pull ‘oF kin and neighbors generally prvi and has for generations. In each communi human development is gud ty locl goals hich riorize learning function within the communi’ cull in stuns and echnoogies. Adu prior the adele and practices thee communes, or ofthe communtis they Frese inthe future and ‘he personal characteris regarded a ing eats roles (Ogbu, 1983), (OF course, fee groupe may benef rom learning fom each her nd ofen people pripus in more than one cull commanity—pic ‘aken up ater in his book) Although cultural variation in goals of development need o be te gnine, this des not mean that eck community has unique se of val us and ols Tera elas among the vartons. MY poi cha the ide of a single desirable “outcome” of devopment neds tobe di) carded s ethnocentric Tadeed, she ids ofan “outcome” of development comes fom apat- sical way of viewing cildod: as peprainfor ie Key telat the separation of chide from the important activites ofthis community) sfc a ccd ne nda in some xis cued fe chapter), The eatment of childhood 2a ime of prpsaton fre Alles from ways of communities in whic cen participate inthe local nate ves no sees rom dul ian placed in pied Hee om td abou comune te thn ou own, we ee © getrond the choc sumptions om which we cach begin Oe see fe and mow ll up oregano ol ews ae troenly fancon of eur ew curl expen, ber han he nly Shr or posible way. This cn be an wneomforaerealzaon, becuse Pedi vrctine sume tas repel undertaning feces ways Teka econ of tty om wpe A leacing tude, with wopended jBlgment of onc own aswel acter ways is ecm for coming 0 vad hw pope bth ac ome snd cheer uncon inhi oa {iitnr and ctumanct and for dein gener undead of human drapes, with nivel ates ikon cal aon The prope of amiga each a eaanced by communication Komen ies ad ouies of parla communes which adres Learning through Insider! Outsider Communication To move our undentaning of human development beyond assumptions and include the perspective of ochercommunits, communication be foveen community “inside” and "outer? is ential Ie nota matt ‘of which perpctiv ix correct both have an ange oa the phenomena that help to build undersanding However, soil science dncuions en question whether the insider ‘or the utiers perspective shouldbe taken ax eprventing the ea Se Chior 98; L king ly of membres sg a ou nd ited Arpt peter cal pacts of mama le 771 communities whose salience to participants may vary.) Toa cr edean of nan cing pele il safer conmantis elcome ied oer arly orc pene O ee kes we wound gs ayn ‘She Ter ndmandng a noe hg ee Teenie eens Pg unending. te {Tad mim mening ee se ee Sine no cea on pons eee Fe penne nent frog odour eee peep romano oh eee i he img move inemmnaon wi he ee ae ie ng unm of pstna makes eimag-erorbe eee tine on etd seh cod orn “sou fea, udp perro daa ee a ee pop wih re iiteien hina oman Slee connate) rn Fe gan mepring sens Hwee ng cera noun tan eae or cing ut seeker png wl cll yl Ouiders Psion In seeking to undersanda commas practices outsides encounter di eules devo peoples reasons other presence Fx inset, poten) swell as thir own unfuiliaiywith the local web of meaning of evens ‘Outsiders te newcomer the meaning sem, with himiedundercand ing of ow practices fi rogether and bow they have developed ro prior cents. At dhe same time they at aed with te assumptions of comm iy members who invariably atempe to gure out what the outsider ole isin the community sing their everday categories of how to eat he “The ousiers emt is aot neta italows aces only somes tons and lcs specifi eactions when the ousder i presen. Foe imple, among the Zinacanteos 2 Mayan group in Mexico, Berry Brazel ton (977) noted ear f observers among both adults and infants in is Jay oF inka development "We were aomaticly endowed with the evileye «tells of ranger ancy in the baby were pomeraly re inforced by his parent’ constant ancy about our presence: We were t= able to rlae vo babies afer nine months of age berase the efece wat 30 Powel” (p17 ‘On the other hand, an obscrvr may elcc intrest and hospi, ‘nhich maybe mote confarable but in becomes apart 0 the events Served, Ruth Munroe and Lee Munre (3970) reported hain Lag house holds Aiea, soon aan abserver aed 0 sady everyday caren practices with infin the infne wa edd for dpi. The Logl moc ‘ewer very cooperative picking up thee infants and briaging sem othe ‘observes fr inspection. Under sich cicumtancs,obsracions would have 1 be interpreted as an aspect of a public greeting. Siri, Mary Ainwworth (977) ported that she was ego a str among he ‘Gand of Ugands the mother ised ut she bere dating the aie noon, ime gency located olinie and entertaining tors, Ta study in four diferent communis, pacts vad in tei pee , bene atempe to understand cron-communiy seus of phenome However, with sensve observation and interpretation we can come ro. smote tisactory understanding ofthe phenomena that intrest ws, which ‘am help guide our actions with eachother. That tht proces of lang Dever ends is ca eson to a0 i Tnded the process of tying wo understand other peopl iesential for aly functioning a well a or choarly work. The diferent perspectives brought bear on inepreting phenomena by differen observers are of n= ‘ert in thee own gh, parca ow that reer prtipant in any parts ofthe word coneibute wth design and incerpreation of research, ot jut responding tothe questionnaires or tes of fog visor Research on issues of culture inherendy requires an efor o examine the meaning af onesjtem in terms of another Some earch is expicly Comparative seos cultural communities, But even in emic research, in hich the sim it describe the ways of ell commit ini mt ‘exms, a deseipcon tha makes seme © people within the community ‘eed o be nated in trs tha also make sense ouside the system, On, decripion aren language diferent fom tha ofthe community mem ‘bers whether the shift from one mason language 10 another oF fom folk ems to academic re, Al languages refer t concept of loca i= portance in ways somewhat diferent rom others, fling cultural con {eps inthe effet communicate. Therefore, heise of "ranslaio™ tei cosidertion ofthe meaning and compari of stains and ideas fers communiis—is inescapable ‘The Meaning of the "Same" Situation acros Communities An nse for any compaion or discussion acs communities she simi- Iai of meaning othe comparably ofthe stations observed (Cole & Means, 1). imply ensuring tha the sare categories of peopl ae pres nto the same insractions wed docs not ensue comparably, because the meaning ofthe particule cast of characters iseracions is ikely wo For example, in cllecing data with American and Miconaian ce versa inf, researcher had dal choie. They could examine ‘xegve nan ineacionsin the most prevalent social eantee in which “egies and infants are found in each community: The American re {Geran children were ually alone with ech other the Miconesian| ‘aegvers and infnes were usally inthe pretence of group. Or they ‘ould hol socal conte constant inthe wo communities (Sstek ta, {oft The researcher decide vo observe in both cicumstances nd com eth ndings they found tat the soil cone oftheir observations Aifeenatedcxegiveinfst interaction in cach communi. Tollowing identical procedarer in reo communis, such at Hiting servations times that mothers and inne ae slone together, clealy docs no ensure comparability of obervation. Stade examining moter ‘infu interaction aru omnes need o wef the varying prevalence of thisnation, For example, several desads ag in yi he United SrsucetiateurhanacUrany eats tleacha ieee ent an Eat Afcan agricultural socey, 98% of mothers were the usta eae vers (Lederman & Lederman, 1974) A study thar compared mother~ ‘ld ineracions in these vo clarl commis would ned inter rec the finding inthe ight ofthe deren purpses and prevalence of ‘mother-child interaction in ech Tn addin o considering wai present, comparisons need wo atend te what people are dong gether fr wha purposes, and how hi ac ig Gite with the practices and wadiins of thee communi, neva the easing of whit observed mut be considered ‘Serious doubs have been rise as 0 whether stone are ever srl comparable in cosa esearch, the es of comparably aay a ume tha eserything excep the aepee of interest is eld conan ‘alton of penal research, Rick Swede (979) conclaed dha st tcions cannot be compaibleacosclral commenti ‘Tall of peronaliy differences one must observe behavior dil nce in euivalene siations, The cri qeston then be- ‘Comes, How are we to decide tat the differential eoponis we ob- Serve rein fit difeenial responses wan equivalent eof stim Wish rpc slic particaerdecigtve componens ma sina (Giwaions cones eniranmen) be hon to be equi? A siuation (envionment, conten, sein) is more than its physical Proper defined by an outside observer «era sited ste ey defined in pat by golf he point of er ofthe act. “What anytaonal peson would do under the circumstance” de- pends upon what che peron i tying co accompli (pp 282~284) ‘Sheder argued that Beaute local mrt forthe appropiate meane of reaching goal mast be writen ito the very defiition ofthe behavioral sieuation, eo actors rein comparable’ equivalent situations ony "he eset ha ay ane member ofthe came earr!™ (p28) Techaps the mout crcl ue inthe question of comparably is de

You might also like