Paper 11 PDF
Paper 11 PDF
ABSTRACT
This paper examine the key consumer behaviour attribute and relation among them in E-
marketing perspective. Attempt has been made to study the acceptance rate of e-marketing among
the Jaipur consumers and its impact on their purchase decision. Result shows that people
irrespective of age and gender surf internet. However significant difference exists between the
age and attributes of online trading but it do not have any relation with the gender. Most of the
respondents are hesitant to purchase items over internet because of security concerns. Most of the
respondents irrespective of gender of different age group (especially age group of 18-30 years)
find e-shopping more convenient & time saving and prefer credit card as the convenient mode of
the payment. Paper give direction to improving delivery and advertising web-products &
services to achieve objective of E-marketing and E-commerce in long run.
International Refereed Research Journal ■ www.researchersworld.com ■ Vol.– III, Issue 2(2), April 2012 [107]
-Journal of Arts, Science & Commerce ■ E-ISSN 2229-4686 ■ ISSN 2231-4172
1. INTRODUCTION:
E-marketing can be defined as marketing of products and services on electronic media. E-marketing is one of
the latest and emerging tools in the marketing world. It include the creative use of internet technology including
use of various multimedia, graphics, text etc with different languages to create catchy advertisements, forms, e-
shop where product can be viewed, promoted and sold. E- marketing does not simply entail building or
promoting a website, nor does it mean placing a banner ad on another website. It include advertisement (flash,
text, graphics, audio or video), product display, product navigation, 3-D products view, basket selection,
checkout and payment. E-marketing & internet marketing terms are used in the same sense. This form of
marketing is equally applicable in most of the business models:
• E-commerce — Direct sales of goods to the mass customer/consumer or the business customers.
• Publishing Services — where advertisement are sold
• Lead-based websites — like policy bazaar, sulekha where sales leads are generated are sold to either
third party or used in-house to convert them into sales through appropriate channel.
• Affiliate marketing — a referral marketing strategy where reward is given for referring product,
company, or website to other friends, relative or in nutshell other potential customer or target segment.
Think of a situation where each time marketer has to do media planning and repeated telecast of same
advertisement to reach the different customer as and when they can be targeted and very less option of
customization per segment is available but E- marketing is a very cost effective tool where customization is
very easy and affordable along with very less criticality of managing the marketing efforts. As respondent hit
can be stored easily with the monitoring and statistical software’s it become inexpensive, fast, reliable to
perform data analytics and majorly all the aspects of an e- campaign can be traced, stored, analysed, and tested.
The advertisers can use a variety of methods: pay per impression, pay per click, pay per play, or pay per action.
Therefore, marketers can determine which messages or offerings are more appealing to the audience. E-
marketing is convenient than the traditional marketing for both customer and the marketer. It offers large
number of variety for the particular product relatively with lower prices and in less time.
But use of E-commerce requires customers familiarity with the latest innovation both in digital technology as
well financial and legal domain. In this way it appeal is limited due to requirement of High speed Internet
connections, overly-complicated websites, from the buyer's perspective, the inability of customer to touch, taste
or to smell or to have the trail before making them purchase online , and among them biggest is the concern of
security with online payments etc.
2. LITERATURE REVIEW:
The Internet is an open worldwide communication network, linking countless number of computer networks
throughout the world, through an intensive network of telephone lines. The increased availability of Internet is
influencing the growth of Internet users around the world. The popularity of e-marketing has been increased
tremendously in last 15 years. Companies are investing heavily in promotion of their products & services via
internet based marketing. But its growth rate is relatively slower as compared to other emerging technologies.
The prominent reason of slower growth than expected may be due a large proportion of population in India as
well as other developing & under developed countries that people are still not aware of computers & internet
technology also security concern regarding personal information on websites. Companies need to create buying
behavior of the consumers.
Studying buying behaviour, motives and intention along with the attitude of the online buyers is within the
theoretical constructs of the Theory of Reasoned Action. The Theory of Reasoned Action (Fishbein, 1980)
examines the relationship between attitudes and future intention to participate in these buying behaviors. The
behaviors include: when they click on banner ads (with which site and age group), response to e-mail
advertisements, way in which product information is searched using search engines and within the site, use of
comparision engines, attention and time to customer review and reaction toward them, product basket, online
support services, use of e-mail service, feedback form, checkout.
According to Cheung et al (Online Consumer Behavior: A Review and Agenda for Future Research, 2003), a
base model called Model of Intention, Adoption, and Continuance (MIAC) for the development of an online
consumer behavior framework. This model predicts that behavior is governed by intention. Satisfied consumers
are most likely to continue hence adoption and continuance are connected to each other through several
mediating and moderating factors such as trust and satisfaction. Their are Individual/Consumer characteristics,
Environmental Influences, Product/Service Characteristics, Medium Characteristics, and Online Merchants and
International Refereed Research Journal ■ www.researchersworld.com ■ Vol.– III, Issue 2(2), April 2012 [108]
-Journal of Arts, Science & Commerce ■ E-ISSN 2229-4686 ■ ISSN 2231-4172
4. RESEARCH METHOD:
Research on the effect of consumer behaviour towards e-marketing is a descriptive research. Here population
represents residents of JAIPUR (Rajasthan, India) city. Sample selected comprises of business professionals,
students & other educated people of urban area only. Study undertaken use stratified sampling i.e. population is
divided into a 3 strata according to age, income & occupation. For each stratum, 25 respondents were picked by
random means from different areas. Sample size of research is arbitrarily taken as 75 for the convenience of
research. Questions were prepared using Nominal scale & Ordinal scale as attributes studied were non
parametric. After checking the validity & reliability of the questionnaire primary data was collected from
respondents in city malls(City Pulse, Vishal Mega Mart, Inox) , cyber cafes including Reliance Web World, Sify
internet cafe. Since scale used in the questionnaire was non- parametric in nature therefore data was coded in
order to analyze data. SPSS (Statistics Packages of Social Software) 17.0 was used as analysis tool. To
determine the causal-effect relationship between different variables, CHI Square test was used.
30-45 years 28
45-60 years 5
More than 60 years 4
less than Rs.10,000 7
Rs.10,000-Rs. 20,000 9
Monthly Rs. 20,000-Rs. 30,000 21
Income Rs. 30,000-Rs. 50,000 11
More than Rs. 50,000 12
Not Applicable 40
Hypothesis 1: Age group between 18-30 years surf internet most. In order to prove above hypothesis CHI
SQUARE test is conducted.H0: There is no significant difference between age & internet surfing or there is no
relation between age of the respondents & internet surfing. HA: There is significant difference between age of
the respondents & internet surfing, in other words there is relation between age of the respondents & internet
surfing. Test statistics showed that Chi-Square calculated at 12 degree of freedom is 111.373 at 0.00%
significance level (Table-1). Hence null hypothesis is rejected at α=0.00 & alternate hypothesis (i.e. there is
strong relation between age of the respondents & internet surfing) is accepted. However Test statistics shows
that there is significant relationship between occupation and internet surfing frequency of the respondents
(Table-2)
Hypothesis-2: Gender does not play any role in internet surfing. Chi-square test between gender of the
respondent & internet surfing data is done. Test statistics shows that Chi-square calculated at 72.9%
significance level is 31.093 (Table-3). It means that null hypothesis is accepted i.e. there is no relation between
gender and internet surfing of the respondents.
Hypothesis-3: There is high degree correlation between income of the respondents and their purchase decision.
Chi-square test is conducted between income of the respondents & their purchase decision affected by e-
marketing. Chi-square statistic shows that at 0.0% of significance level calculated value comes out to be 57.653
at 15 degree of freedom (Table-4a). Hence it can be concluded that null hypothesis is rejected & alternate
hypothesis is accepted that there is significant difference of a strong relation between income of the respondents
& purchase decision. Also a significant difference is found between age, occupation of the respondents and
their purchase decision (Table-4b, 4c).
Hypothesis-4: Respondents find e-shopping more convenient because it is time saving, availability of
alternatives to choose from & possibly less expensive products and services. In study likert scale (five point
agreement-disagreement scale) was used to determine respondents’ response. It was found that 65% were highly
agreed on easy accessibility of online products. Further, most of the respondents found online shopping more
convenient & time saving than brick & mortar system. Pie chart depicting the same is shown below.
Chi-Square test is conducted to determine significant difference between easy accessibility, convenience & time
saving attributes of online trading and age of the respondents. Statistics showed that null hypothesis is rejected
at α=0.00% (Table-5a). Hence alternate hypothesis is accepted; it implies that there is a significant difference or
relation exists between age and attributes of online trading. Also a significant difference is found between
income, occupation and above attributes (Table-5b, 5c). Furthermore it was found that there is no significant
International Refereed Research Journal ■ www.researchersworld.com ■ Vol.– III, Issue 2(2), April 2012 [110]
-Journal of Arts, Science & Commerce ■ E-ISSN 2229-4686 ■ ISSN 2231-4172
difference between gender of the respondents and above three attributes. At α =72.9% (Table-5d) null
hypothesis is accepted; hence gender has no relation with above attributes.
Moreover respondents had positive response regarding seasonal/special offers on internet. Respondents’
reaction is shown below. To determine the relationship between age of the respondents and special/seasonal
offers in web advertisements, Chi-Square test is conducted. Test statistics showed that null hypothesis is
rejected at 0.00% significance level (Table-6a); hence alternate hypothesis is accepted i.e. there is significant
difference between the two variables. Since sample size largely consists of respondents of age group between
18-30 years hence it can be inferred that young respondents are more attracted towards seasonal or special
offers. Also it was found that gender has no relation with seasonal offers (Table-6b).
Respondents’ reaction was mixed regarding price & quality of the products/services offered online. 35% of the
respondents agreed regarding fair price & 31% on quality of products/services offered, while 28% disagreed on
the former & 33% on the later. 37% & 36% of the respondents had a neutral view on the two attributes
respectively.
There was higher percentage of disagreement on “privacy of personal information & on time delivery of
products/services”. 61% & 50% of the respondents disagreed on above two attributes respectively. 24% & 28%
agreed & 15% & 22% had neutral view on two attributes respectively.
To determine relationship between price, quality, on time delivery of products/sevices & personal information
privacy of the online traded products/services and gender & age of the respondents, Chi-Square test was
conducted. Test statistics showed that at α=72.9% (Table-7a) there is no relation between above attributes of the
online traded products/services and gender of the respondents. It can be inferred that both male & female have
simiar response regarding above attributes. While a significant relationship is found between age of the
respondents and price, quality, & personal information privacy of the online traded products/services(Table-7b).
It implies that a significant number of respondents of all age groups have a neutral view regarding fair pricing &
quality of the products/services, while other respondents of younger age between 18-30 years agree and
respondents of higher age than 30 years disagree on two attributes. While there was no significant difference
found between age & personal information privacy of the online traded products/services of the respondents
(Table-7c). It implies that nearly all respondents have a similar view they highly disagree on above attribute.
Hypothesis-5: Most of the respondents are hesitant to purchase items over internet because of security concerns.
International Refereed Research Journal ■ www.researchersworld.com ■ Vol.– III, Issue 2(2), April 2012 [111]
-Journal of Arts, Science & Commerce ■ E-ISSN 2229-4686 ■ ISSN 2231-4172
In order to prove the above hypothesis respondents were asked to rate the drawbacks of the online shopping in
the rating scale of 1-5 and it was observed that 52% of the respondents claimed security concern regarding
disclosure of personal information as first rank. 47% of them rated lack of physical approach on
products/services offered, second. While quality & authenticity of products/services offered was rated fourth by
48% of the respondents. Chi-Square test is conducted to determine that whether there is any relation between
gender and security concern, lack of physical approach and quality & authenticity of the products/services
offered via online trading. Test statistics showed that null hypothesis is accepted at alpha is equal to 72.9%
(Table-8a) between gender and security concern, lack of physical approach and quality & authenticity of the
products/services offered via online trading. Hence it implies that there is no relation or there is no significant
difference between drawbacks of online trading & gender of the respondents. Chi-Square test showed that there
is relation between age group, income of the respondents and above drawbacks (Table-8b, 8c).
Hypothesis-6: Usage of newer technology in online trading has made process more complicated, affect buying
behavior of respondents. Consumers were asked if product/service of their requirements is being offered online
at reasonable price, then will they prefer to buy that product/service online or purchase the same from brick &
mortar system. It is found that 68% of the respondents claimed product/service of their requirement through
traditional shop, while 32% favoured online purchases. To prove the hypothesis statistically Chi-Square test is
conducted between age & preference of the respondents in purchasing product/service. Test statistics showed
that null hypothesis is rejected at significance level 0.00% (Table-9) and alternate hypothesis is accepted i.e.
there is relation between the two variables. Hence people do not prefer online trading as compared to traditional
purchasing. It can be inferred that besides other drawback of online trading, respondents are conventional and
have traditional approach towards shopping. People resist changes and introduction of newer technology has
indeed made process of online shopping much complicated.
Mode of Payment:Respondents were asked to select the mode of payments while shopping online. 52%
preferred credit card payment, while 28% opted for debit card payments, 12% preferred payments through
cheques and 8% preferred for demand draft or pay order services. Chi square test is conducted to determine
whether the relationshSip between mode of payment & income group of the respondents exist or not. Test
statistics showed that null hypothesis is rejected at α=0.00% (Table-10) and alternate hypothesis is accepted i.e.
there is significant difference between the two variables or mode of payment is depended upon income of the
respondents. People having monthly income Rs 10,000 or more prefer credit card payments.
Hypothetical Web Advertisement Attributes: Respondents were asked to rate hypothetical web advertisement
having attributes; frequency of occurrence (very high-very low), attractiveness in presentation of web
advertisement (high, average), content of web advertisement (good, average, below average), offers (yes, no).
Different combinations of these attributes were assigned hypothetical web advertisements. It was found that
32% respondents ranked WEB AD. A as their first choice having attributes; frequency (very high),
attractiveness in presentation of web advertisement (high), content of web advertisement (average), offers (yes).
Also 32% of the respondents ranked WEB AD. B as their first choice having attributes; frequency of occurrence
(high), attractiveness in presentation of web advertisement (high), content of web advertisement (good), offers
(yes). While 23% of the respondents ranked WEB AD.C as their first choice having attributes; frequency of
occurrence (average), attractiveness in presentation of web advertisement (high), content of web advertisement
(below average), offers (yes). And WED AD. D & WEB AD. E were ranked 7% and 4% as their first choice
respectively.
International Refereed Research Journal ■ www.researchersworld.com ■ Vol.– III, Issue 2(2), April 2012 [112]
-Journal of Arts, Science & Commerce ■ E-ISSN 2229-4686 ■ ISSN 2231-4172
Chi-Square test
is conducted to
determine the
relation between
age of the
respondent and
hypothetical web
advertisement.
Test statistic
showed that null
hypothesis is
rejected at
α=0.00 (Table-11a) between Web Ad. A, B, D, E & age of the respondents. It means that there is significant
difference between age & web advertisement attributes or there is strong relation between age of the
respondents and attributes of web ad. preference. Chi-Square test to identify the relationship between web ad.
preference and gender of the respondents is also conducted. Test statistics showed that at α=72.9% (Table-11b)
null hypothesis is accepted i.e. there is no significant difference between the two variables or gender does not
play any role in preference of web advertisement attributes.
Preferred Products/Services & Websites For Online Shopping: Respondents were asked to rate various
online products/services according to their preference. It was observed that respondents preferred e-ticketing
(660 out of maximum rating points 750) followed by e-billing (553 out of maximum rating points 750), e-
banking (525 out of maximum rating points 750) & online shopping of products (305 out of maximum rating
points 750). E-ticketing was found to be the most preferred choice out of four choices.
Chi-Square test
statistics showed
that there is no
significant
difference between
gender and e-
ticketing, e-billing,
e-banking online
shopping of
products (Table-
12).It can be
inferred that preference of online products/services has no relation with the gender of the respondents. Also it
was found that there is significant difference between age, income and above online services. It implies that
people of younger age between 18-30 years and monthly income Rs.20,000 or less prefer e-ticketing.
Respondents were asked to recall name of any three websites where they prefer/would prefer online shopping.
International Refereed Research Journal ■ www.researchersworld.com ■ Vol.– III, Issue 2(2), April 2012 [113]
-Journal of Arts, Science & Commerce ■ E-ISSN 2229-4686 ■ ISSN 2231-4172
It was observed that 19% of the respondents preferred IRCTC website (Indian railways online reservation
website), 15% preferred Yahoo (comprehensive website for products/services), while 14% opted for ebay
(comprehensive website for products/services).
6. Inferences
Purpose of study was have a thorough analysis regarding different attributes of e-marketing with age, gender &
income of the respondents. Our analysis on the respondents of Jaipur city showed various results.
It was found that there is no significant difference between internet surfing & gender of the respondents.
While age group of 18-30 years surf internet most. Main possible reason behind this may be that
younger people are more technology oriented & also they may be working in organizations where they
need to work upon computer and internet.
A strong relation exists between monthly income, occupation and purchase decision of the respondents.
People with higher income group usually have little time to go and purchase products/services from
tradition shops because of their busy schedule. Hence in order to save time they trade online.
Most of the respondents (irrespective of gender) are hesitant to trade online because of security reasons.
There have been cases in the past where personal information regarding passwords & identification
theft has occurred. Those incidences have feared consumers. Besides this lack of physical approach,
time required to deliver products & authenticity of the product merchandised are other factors.
Consumers do not have faith in most of the online trading sites. Also usage of newer technology has
made online trading more complicated & people resist changing, that is why consumers prefer
traditional shopping as compared to online trading.
Most of the respondents irrespective of gender of different age group (especially age group of 18-30
years) find e-shopping more convenient & time saving. A wide range of products/services with variety
are available to choose from and also in general traditional shopping in India has never been pleasant
for Indian consumers. There has been a mixed reaction in response to quality & authenticity of the
products offered.
Most of the respondents irrespective of gender of different age group prefer credit cards as the most
suitable option of payment followed by debit cards. This is probably due to the fact that with credit
cards we can purchase products/services on credit and also now a days they can be easily obtained from
different banks. It was also found in our analysis that there is a strong relationship exist between mode
of payments and income of the respondents. It implies that electronic payment (credit cards, debit
cards) has also gained popularity in middle income group.
Most of the respondents responded similarly as predicted when they have given options to rate various
attributes of hypothetical web-advertisement. By interpreting their reaction graph it can be inferred that
information content, additional service-offered & frequency of web-advertisement leave behind major
impact on people mind. Service offered & the way of presentation of information plays a major role in
positioning an e-product in consumer mindset.
International Refereed Research Journal ■ www.researchersworld.com ■ Vol.– III, Issue 2(2), April 2012 [114]
-Journal of Arts, Science & Commerce ■ E-ISSN 2229-4686 ■ ISSN 2231-4172
Most of the respondents irrespective of gender of different age group prefer e-ticketing as the most
preferred/popular service followed by e-booking & e-billing. This is most popular among all age
groups as it escapes people from long queues, saves time & distance which might people would have to
travel to get their billing & ticketing done on time. Reservation of hotel rooms & tours has become
quite easier at finger-tips.
Most preferred websites among the respondents comes out to be IRCTC, followed by yahoo & e-bay
when given a freedom to recall three website on their own. By analyzing their response we can interpret
that e-ticketing is the major choice among the people for which they use web services followed by e-
booking i.e (YAHOO) & online shopping option i.e (E-BAY) available to them.
7. CONCLUSION:
E-marketing is rapidly changing the way people do business all over the world. In the business-to-consumer
segment, sales through the web have been increasing dramatically over the last few years. Customers, not only
those from well-developed countries but also those from developing countries, are getting used to the new
shopping channel. Understanding the factors that affect intention, adoption and repurchase are important for
researchers and practitioners alike. E-marketing is gaining popularity among people specially the younger
generation but in today scenario to become equally popular among all age groups e-marketing will have to
cover a longer distance. People have hesitations in using e-services due to security concerns, lack of physical
approach towards product offered, delays in product delivery along with price & quality concerns. More-over
people are more resistant to change & not easily adaptable to newer technology. 68% of respondent found
shopping from shop easier, convenient & preferable over online purchasing. Above finding clearly supports our
conclusion that people are tradition bound & have doubt in mindset as far as issue of online shopping/purchase
of product is concerned.
People have dubious attitude towards e-marketing of product & services mainly due to security concern related
to privacy of personal information. Personal information privacy should be given preference by the companies
involved in online marketing of product & services. The other major concern among people includes
authenticity of product & services offered online. Companies involved in online trading should focus on
building their brand awareness among people so that trust-worthy relationship can be developed between
producers & consumers. On-time delivery of products purchased through online shopping will prove to be quite
beneficial in a long run. Significant price-cuts should be offered to customers as there are relatively no/lesser
intermediaries involved as far as e-marketing is concerned. Currency fluctuation should be dealt with great care
& steps should be taken both by government & companies so as to reduce currency fluctuation to its minimal.
Promotional schemes should be launched to promote e-marketing business. Advertising of web-products &
services is one of the major issues where companies fail to attract potential consumers attention. Companies
should focus on offering informative advertisements which would contain product information along with
additional products & services offering which best suits needs of people. Such advertisements frequency should
be high so as to position the products & brands in consumer mindset. In a nut shell we can conclude that e-
marketing has a potential to grow, only proper boosting needs to be done both at producer and consumer level
apart from government efforts.
REFERENCES:
[1] Baourakis, G., Kourgiantakis, M. & Migdalas, A. (2002), The Impact Of E- Commerce On Agrofood
Marketing: The Case Of Agricultural Cooperatives, Firms And Consumers In Crete, British Food
Journal, 104, 580-590.
[2] Barletta, M. (2003). Marketing To Women: How To Understand, Reach, And Increase Your Share Of
The World’s Largest Market Segment. Chicago, IL, Dearborn Trade Publishing..
[3] Boudreau, M.-C. & Watson, R. T. (2006), Internet Advertising Strategy Alignment Internet Research,16, 23 - 37.
[4] Canavan, O., Henchion, M. & O'reilly, S. (2007), The Use Of The Internet As A Marketing Channel For
Irish Speciality Food International Journal Of Retail & Distribution Management 35, 178 – 195.
[5] Deitel, H., Deitel, P., And Neito, T. (2001), E-Business And E-Commerce (How To Program), Prentice
Hall, New Jersey.
[6] Hanson, W. A. (2001), Principles Of Internet Marketing, Cincinnati, OH, USA, South-Western College
Publishing.
[7] Harridge-March, S. (2004), Electronic Marketing, The New Kid On The Block. Marketing Intelligence
& Planning, 22, 297 - 309.
International Refereed Research Journal ■ www.researchersworld.com ■ Vol.– III, Issue 2(2), April 2012 [115]
-Journal of Arts, Science & Commerce ■ E-ISSN 2229-4686 ■ ISSN 2231-4172
[8] Identifying The Building Blocks For Future Global E-Marketing Research International Marketing
Review 22, 605 - 610.
[9] Krishnamurthy, S. & Singh, N. (2005), The International E-Marketing Framework (IEMF):
[10] KULA, V. & TATOGLU, E. (2003), O’toole, T. (2003), E-Relationships – Emergence And The Small
Firm Marketing Intelligence & Planning 21, 115 - 122.
[11] Reedly, J., Schullo, S., And Zimmerman, K. (2000), Electronic Marketing (Integrating Electronic
Resources Into The Marketing Process), Harcourt College Publishers.
[12] Zaichkowsky, J. (1985). Measuring The Involvement Construct. Journal Of Consumer Research, 12 (3),
341-352. Notes:
[13] Cheung et al (Online Consumer Behavior: A Review and Agenda for Future Research, 2003):
https://domino.fov.unimb.si/proceedings.nsf/0/c9beda3ca328c8b7c1256ea1002c72b8/$FILE/16Cheung.pdf
[14] Dr. Sami Alsmadi , Yarmouk University (Consumer attitude towards online shopping,
2002):http://unpan1.un.org/intradoc/groups/public/documents/ARADO/UNPAN006485.pdf
[15] Ziqi Liao and Michael Tow Cheung (Internet-based e-shopping and consumer
attitudes) :http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/messages/downloadsexceeded.html
APPENDIX
International Refereed Research Journal ■ www.researchersworld.com ■ Vol.– III, Issue 2(2), April 2012 [116]
-Journal of Arts, Science & Commerce ■ E-ISSN 2229-4686 ■ ISSN 2231-4172
International Refereed Research Journal ■ www.researchersworld.com ■ Vol.– III, Issue 2(2), April 2012 [117]
-Journal of Arts, Science & Commerce ■ E-ISSN 2229-4686 ■ ISSN 2231-4172
Depicts that no significant relationship exist between Web Ad. Preference and gender of the respondents.
----
International Refereed Research Journal ■ www.researchersworld.com ■ Vol.– III, Issue 2(2), April 2012 [118]