Chapter 1
Chapter 1
of Acquiring a Business
The Tax Aspects
of Acquiring a Business
Second Edition
W. Eugene Seago
The Tax Aspects of Acquiring a Business, Second Edition
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Keywords
applicable federal rate (AFR), contingent liabilities, contract price, cost
recovery period, covenant to not compute, depreciation recapture, good-
will, gross profit ratio, installment sale, limited liability company (LLC),
qualified indebtedness, section 197 intangible assets, tax basis, tax lives
Contents
Acknowledgments....................................................................................ix
Chapter 1 The Purchase and Sale of an Unincorporated Business........1
Chapter 2 The Purchase and Sale of an Incorporated Business..........25
Chapter 3 The Purchase and Sale of an S Corporation......................47
Chapter 4 The Purchase of a Corporation’s Subsidiary......................61
Chapter 5 Tax-Deferred Acquisitions of C Corporations..................71
Chapter 6 Business Investigation Costs.............................................83
The value of a business is the present value of the future net-of-taxes cash
flows the business will produce. A tax adviser has little influence over the
pattern of future revenues a corporation may earn, but the tax adviser
may have some influence over the deductions allowed in calculating the
taxable income. An important determinant of future tax deductions is
how the purchase price is allocated among the assets.
Assets Valuations
The basic assets of an unincorporated business can be viewed as future tax
deductions that will yield cash flow equal to the owner’s marginal tax rate
in the year of the deduction multiplied by the amount of the deduction.
The tax lives that are used to allocate the assets’ costs over their lives are
established by the Internal Revenue Code and Regulations. Therefore,
once the costs of the various assets, their tax lives, the tax owner’s expected
tax rate, and discount rate are determined, the present value of future tax
benefits can easily be determined. Assuming the tax rate does not change,
the shorter the cost recovery period, the greater the present value of the
cash flow from the asset.
The purchase of an existing business is the acquisition of more than
identifiable tangible assets. Tangible assets generally can be purchased in
an open market for a price that is based on the expected present value
of the asset’s future after-tax cash flow. The unique value of a particu-
lar business lies in its intangible assets. The intangible assets can create
a return above and beyond what can be derived solely from the replace-
able tangible assets. The business may have a variety of intangible assets
2 THE TAX ASPECTS OF ACQUIRING A BUSINESS
1
See IRC §197.
2
Section 1060.
3
Reg.§1.1060.
The Purchase and Sale of an Unincorporated Business 3
Goodwill and going concern value is the residual after the price has
been allocated to the other classes.
Generally, classes VI and VII are the section 197 intangible assets
acquired as a part of existing business purchased by the taxpayer. With a
few exceptions, their cost can be amortized over 15 years. This is generally
true regardless of the legal or economic life of the particular asset.4 Thus,
if the buyer of an extended care center paid a premium for the fact that
the facility was operating at a certain capacity, the premium paid must be
amortized over 15 years, although the patients might not be expected to
remain in the facility for another 15 years.
Some of the exceptions to the 15-year amortization of intangibles are
leaseholds and mortgaging service contracts.5 These assets can be amor-
tized over their legal lives. Also, off-the-shelf computer software can be
amortized over 5 years,6 but the seller’s custom-made software is a section
197 intangible that is subject to 15-year amortization.
As previously discussed, the present value of the future deductions for
the cost of assets depends upon the cost recovery period for tax purposes
as well as the owner’s marginal tax rate and discount rate. The following
are some asset classes, their cost recovery periods, cost recovery methods,
and the present value of the cost recovery deductions, assuming a 37 per-
cent marginal tax rate for an individual, or a 21 percent marginal tax rate
for a corporation and a 10 percent discount rate. Thus, an individual’s
tax benefits are 29 percent of the cost of a tractor, whose cost recovery
period is 3 years, and 11 percent of the cost of a commercial building.
4
Section 197(c).
5
Section 197(e).
6
Section 197(e)(3).
4 THE TAX ASPECTS OF ACQUIRING A BUSINESS
For intangible assets, the tax benefits are almost 11 percent (0.107) of the
cost of the asset.
Under the modified asset cost recovery system (MACRS), all depre-
ciable assets are assigned to a class. Typical assets with their class lives and
depreciation methods, along with expected tax benefits, are available for
bargaining with the buyer as shown in Table 1.1.
As discussed earlier, the purchase price of the business must be allo-
cated among the assets acquired and the final allocations can affect the
present value of the tax benefits of the depreciation and amortization.
Obviously, there can be differences of opinions among experts about the
value of an asset. In the following example involving a corporation with
a 21 percent tax rate, Appraisal 2 allocates more value to the land and
building than Appraisal 1. Because the land will produce no tax benefits
until it is sold, and the cost recovery period for the building is 31.5 years,
the present value of the tax benefits of Appraisal 2 is 20 percent less than
the Appraisal 1 tax benefits.
Under the 2017 Tax Act, all of the cost of tangible personal property
with a depreciable life of less than 20 years can be expensed in the year of
purchase. (The immediate write-off is referred to as bonus depreciation.)
Therefore, the cost of equipment in Table 1.2 can be deducted in the year
of purchase, and the present value of the tax benefit for the Appraisal
1 is .21 × $450,000 = $94,500, and the value of the tax benefits for
Appraisal 2 is .21 × $300,000 = $63,000.
As a practical matter, the buyer and seller must agree on the alloca-
tion of the purchase price. This is true because tax forms must be filed by
the buyer and the seller disclosing the allocations.7 Differences between
the buyer’s and the seller’s allocations will likely trigger an IRS exami-
nation. In the previous example, the buyer would prefer the allocations
in Appraisal 1 because of the greater present value of the tax benefits.
But the seller would benefit from Appraisal 2 because it yields a greater
gain from the land and building, which are eligible for capital gain treat-
ment, and less ordinary income ($20,000) from the accounts receivable
and equipment ($150,000 as recapture of depreciation). Appraisal 2
yields $170,000 more capital gain and $170,000 less ordinary income
7
Form 8594, Asset Acquisition Statement Under Section 1060.
Table 1.1 Tax benefits as a proportion of cost
Present value of Tax benefits as a Tax benefits as a
Depreciation depreciation @ 0.10 p roportion of asset’s p roportion of asset’s
Class Typical assets method discount rate cost (0.37 tax rate) cost (0.21 tax rate)
1year Supplies Expense 1.0 0.37 0.21
3year Small tools, tractors, 200% decl. bal. 0.83 0.307 0.175
horses, specialized man-
ufacturing devices
5year Computers, autos, light 200% decl. bal. 0.773 0.286 0.162
trucks, small aircraft,
construction equipment
7year Office furniture, 200% decl. bal. 0.722 0.267 0.152
fixtures and equipment,
commercial aircraft,
and most machinery
10year Specialized heavy man- 200% decl. bal. 0.654 0.242 0.137
ufacturing machinery,
mobile homes
15year Intangibles Straight line 0.508 0.188 0.107
27.5year Residential real estate Straight line 0.337 0.125 0.071
property
31.5year Office and other non- Straight line 0.30 0.112 0.063
residential real estate
5
6 THE TAX ASPECTS OF ACQUIRING A BUSINESS
for the seller. For the seller, the capital gain and ordinary income dif-
ference could be the difference between the ordinary and capital gains
rates multiplied by $170,000. Typically, this would be (0.21 − 0.15)
$170,000 = $10,200. Because of these differences, and the need for con-
sistency between the buyer and seller, it becomes necessary for the buyer
and seller to renegotiate the allocation of the purchase price. Thus, for
example, the seller may agree to the first allocation only if the price is
increased to $1,820,000. The increase in price would be allocated to the
goodwill, since goodwill is the residual. As such, the buyer will recover (in
present values) $20,000 × 0.107 (see Table 1.1) = $2,140 in tax benefits,
for an after-tax increase in cost of $20,000 − $2,140 = $17,860.
The bonus depreciation rules will be phased out between 2023 and
2027. Section 179, which is not to be phased, allows expensing up to
$1,000,000 per year the cost of tangible personal property and certain
building improvements.
Class IIIA
Recap
In short, the allocation of the purchase price affects the future tax benefits
to the buyer and the present tax cost to the seller. Moreover, as a practical
matter, the buyer and seller must agree to the allocations as well as the
total price. It follows that the allocations will often affect the price.
Contingent Amounts
The contract for the purchase of the business may contain contingent
amounts. For example, the seller may receive 10 percent of earnings for
a period of years. Generally, the contingent amounts paid will be added
to the cost of the intangible asset, assuming the noncontingent amount
is equal to or greater than the fair market value of the assets in Classes I
through IV. The amortization period is the remaining number of years
from the original purchase. Thus, a contingent payment in the 3rd year
after the original transactions will be amortized over 12 years.
Table 1.3 illustrates the benefits to the buyer and detriment to the seller of
reclassifying $1 of cost from one of the other asset classes to intangibles.
8
Reg. §1.263(a)-1(f ).
8
Table 1.3 Present value of tax benefits of the cost of tangible versus intangible assets
Tax benefits as a
proportion of asset’s From intangible—buyer From intangibles—selle’s
Class Typical assets cost (0.21 tax rate) benefit (detriment) benefit (detriment)
1 year Supplies, and tangible property eligible 0.21 0.21 − 0.107 = 0.103 0.15 − 0.21 = (0.06)
for bonus depreciation
3year Small tools, tractors, horses, specialized 0.175 0.175 − 0.107 = 0.068 0.15 − 0.21 = (0.06)
manufacturing devices
5year Computers, autos, light trucks, small 0.162 0.162 − 0.107 = 0.055 0.15 − 0.21 = (0.06)
aircraft, construction equipment
7year Office furniture, fixtures and equipment, 0.152 0.152 − 0.107 = 0.045 0.15 − 0.21 = (0.06)
commercial aircraft, and most
machinery
10year Specialized heavy manufacturing 0.137 0.137 − 0.107 = 0.02 0.15 − 0.21 = (0.06)
machinery, mobile homes
15year Intangibles 0.107 0 0
27.5year Residential real estate property 0.071 0.071 − 0.107 = (.036) 0
31.5 year Office and other nonresidential real 0.063 0. 63 − 0.107 = 0.044 0
estate
N/A Land 0 0.0 − 0.107 = 0.107 0
The Purchase and Sale of an Unincorporated Business 9
Generally, the buyer will benefit if the cost of the intangible is allocated to
tangible personal property whose depreciable lives are less than 15 years.
On the other hand, this same reclassification is a detriment to the buyer
of an almost equal amount, because the gain is reclassified as ordinary,
rather than capital gain. However, both the buyer and the seller benefit
from reclassifying the price from real estate to intangibles. This is not to
suggest that the buyer and seller are free to allocate the price in any man-
ner they can agree to. However, the real estate and intangible assets are
frequently the most difficult to value, and thus, the buyer and seller have
some ability to allocate in a tax efficient manner.
9
Beulah B. Crane v. Commissioner, 331 U.S. 1 (1947).
10 THE TAX ASPECTS OF ACQUIRING A BUSINESS
Installment Sales
The seller does incur the risk that the installment obligation will not
be paid, but that risk would also be incurred on alternative investments
made from the proceeds of a cash sale.
The Purchase and Sale of an Unincorporated Business 11
10
Sections 453(b) and (i).
12 THE TAX ASPECTS OF ACQUIRING A BUSINESS
11
Reg. §15A.453-1(b)(2).
The Purchase and Sale of an Unincorporated Business 13
indebtedness,”12 which generally means the debt must have been used to
finance the property or the business.
The previous discussion was based on the assumption that the buyer’s
installment note bears interest at least equal to the applicable federal
interest rate (AFR). If the debt instrument does not bear interest at the
federal rate or greater, the installment obligation will be revalued (down-
ward), by imputing interest. The purpose of the imputed interest rules is
to prevent the seller from converting ordinary interest income into capital
gain from the sale of the assets. To avoid these complications, the notes
should bear interest at the federal rate or greater. AFRs are published
monthly by the IRS.13
The required rates are those for the month the purchase and sale occur.
Thus, if the installment note is to be paid over 10 years, the note should
bear interest throughout its term at the federal long-term rate published
for the month of the sale.
The seller may owe money for services that have been performed, but
have not been taken into account as an expense in calculating the seller’s
taxable income. If the purchaser assumes these obligations, the amount
owed becomes a part of the total cost of the assets acquired. Therefore,
12
Reg. §15A-1(b)(2)(iv).
13
http://apps.irs.gov/app/picklist/list/federalRates.html
14 THE TAX ASPECTS OF ACQUIRING A BUSINESS
buyer. In the previous example, if the seller had retained the liability for the
warranty expense, the price of the business would have been $1,000,000.
If the buyer assumes the liability, the price would be reduced by the esti-
mated amount that will be paid. The seller will then be permitted to
deduct as an expense the actual payments for services under the warranty.
Another form of debt financing often used is leasing. The buyer can lease
the seller’s real estate used in the business. Leasing is especially appealing
in the case of an anxious seller and a buyer who is cash strapped, or is sim-
ply interested in investing in an operating business rather than real estate.
All of the seller’s income from rent is ordinary, rather than section 1231
gain (potentially taxed as a capital gain), but the income is deferred until
the rent is collected, and the seller retains the possibility of the benefits of
appreciation in the property.
14
Reg. §1.1060-1(b)(7).
16 THE TAX ASPECTS OF ACQUIRING A BUSINESS
15-year period as other intangibles. From a tax point of view, the buyer
is indifferent between an allocation to intangibles or to a covenant to not
compete. However, for the seller, the payments received for the covenant
to not compete is ordinary income rather than capital gain. Therefore, the
seller would prefer more of the price allocated to the customer base or other
intangible assets and less to the covenant to not compete, but the buyer is
indifferent. As discussed earlier, the buyer and seller generally should be
consistent in the allocation of the purchase price. This may give the buyer
some bargaining power over the terms. That is, the seller may accept more
in deferred payments for assets, rather than a covenant to not compete.
The payments over time for a covenant to not compete are installment
sale payments for property.15 As such, the cost of the property must be dis-
counted for the imputed interest. The imputed interest can be deducted
as it accrues. Thus, if the buyer agrees to pay the seller $100,000 at closing
and $100,000 each year for the next 4 years, and the imputed interest rate
is 4 percent, the capitalized amount is $100,000 plus the present value
of an annuity of $100,000 per year for 4 years with a 4 percent interest
rate = $100,000 + $362,990 = $462,990. In year 1, the buyer is permit-
ted to begin amortizing the entire $462,990 over 15 years, and deduct
the imputed interest on that amount over the 5 years as the payments are
made. The seller is allowed to spread the payments as ordinary income
received over the 5 years.16
In the final analysis, typically a covenant to not compete should be
included in the purchase agreement. The important tax issue is how much
of the total amount that will be paid to the seller should be allocated to
the covenant. For the seller, any amount allocated to the covenant is to the
seller’s disadvantage, when the alternative is to allocate that amount to the
intangible assets eligible for capital gain and installment sales treatment.
15
Reg. §1.197-2(k) Example 6.
16
Rev. Rul. 69-643.
The Purchase and Sale of an Unincorporated Business 17
The former owner may serve as a consultant as the business goes through
the transitional effects of a change in ownership. The compensation is
ordinary income for the seller, much the same as the amounts received
under a covenant to not compete. However, for the buyer, if payments
under the consulting agreement are diverted from goodwill, the buyer
18 THE TAX ASPECTS OF ACQUIRING A BUSINESS
80 0 20 Buyer benefits
0.103 × 20 = 2.06
80 20 Seller’s detriment
(0.15 − 0.37) × $20 = ($4.40)
gains a tax benefit—the acceleration of the deductions for the cost of the
business. Instead of amortizing over 15 years as intangibles, the compen-
sation can be deducted as paid. As discussed earlier, the present value of
the tax benefits of the 15-year amortization of intangibles is 10.7 percent
of their cost, when the buyer’s tax rate is 21 percent, but the tax benefit
of currently deductible compensation is 21 percent of the amount paid.
Thus, unlike payments under a covenant to not compete, the buyer
benefits from classifying part of the price as compensation for services of
the former owner, rather than as goodwill or for a covenant to not compete.
The seller is indifferent between a covenant to not compete and consulting
fees, but prefers payments for intangibles. Table 1.5 illustrates the effects of
a $20 reallocation from intangibles to covenant to not compete or a con-
sulting agreement, assuming the seller is in the 37 percent marginal ordi-
nary income bracket and his capital gain rate is 15 percent and the buyer
is in the 37 percent marginal bracket and has a 10 percent discount rate.
The different effects on the buyer and the seller could be used as follows:
The buyer makes an offer for the business, and the seller rejects but offers to
sell for a larger amount. The buyer responds as follows, “I accept your offer
if x amount is allocated to the consulting agreement,” which is tantamount
to making an offer between the buyer’s original offer and the seller’s offer.
17
Section 706.
20 THE TAX ASPECTS OF ACQUIRING A BUSINESS
If D purchased each of the three members’ interests in the LLC, it will
be treated for tax purposes as though the LLC distributed all the assets
equally to A, B, and C. Neither the LLC nor the members would recog-
nize gain or loss from the liquidating distributions; their bases in the LLC
would be allocated among the assets received, and then the former LLC
members would sell the assets to the new owner. The former LLC mem-
bers will recognize gains and losses, a total of $340,000 each ($600,000 −
$260,000 = $340,000); the character of the gain or loss (ordinary or
capital) will generally depend upon the character of the asset to the LLC,
and the new owner will get a cost basis in the assets $1,800,000.
When the member’s interests are bought or sold, the LLC (or partner-
ship) continues. The exiting partner recognizes his or her share of the
LLC’s income up until the date of the sale, and then recognizes ordinary
income and capital gain from the sale of his or her interest generally the
same as if the LLC sold the assets and allocated the gains and losses to the
exiting partner.18 However, under the general rules applicable to partner-
ships, the partnership’s bases in its assets are unaffected by the new part-
ner.19 This gives rise to a difference between the LLC’s inside basis (the
basis of the assets inside the LLC) and the member’s outside basis (the
member’s basis in his or her LLC interest).
For example, if D purchased C’s one-third interest in the aforemen-
tioned LLC for $600,000, D’s basis in the partnership for purposes
of determining D’s gain or loss on the sale of his interest would be
$600,000. However, the LLC would treat D as having a $260,000 basis
in the assets within the LLC. D’s basis in the building, for example, would
be $300,000/3 = $100,000. If the LLC sold the building for $600,000,
D would be required to recognize a $100,000 gain [($600,000 −
$300,000)/3 = $100,000]. This is true even though D paid C the fair
market value of C’s interest in the building and all other assets.
18
Sections 731 and 751.
19
Section 743.
The Purchase and Sale of an Unincorporated Business 21
20
Sections 743 and 754.
22 THE TAX ASPECTS OF ACQUIRING A BUSINESS
may decide to give family members an interest in the real estate but not
the operating business. This is easily accomplished with the real estate in
a separate entity.
Another consideration regarding who should acquire the business is
how the business investigation and start-up costs will be treated. As will
be discussed in Chapter 6, if the purchaser is operating a business in the
same line of business as the business purchased, the business investigation
costs and start-up costs are deductible as business expansion costs, rather
than capitalized and amortized over 180 months.
Other than business investigation cost and start-up cost consider-
ations, the primary consideration in the choice of the entity to make
the acquisition is whether the income from the business should be sub-
jected to corporate tax. As discussed in Chapter 2, generally the corporate
double-tax system renders the use of a C corporation at a considerable
disadvantage. However, in the case of a small business whose earnings do
not reach the highest corporate rate, and whose after-tax earnings are used
to retire the purchase money indebtedness, the C corporation may be the
preferred entity particularly if the shareholder has a high marginal tax rate.
21
If the business were not incorporated, the income tax would be $148,000.
The Purchase and Sale of an Unincorporated Business 23
Before consideration of any tax on the sale of the business, the tax sav-
ings as a result of organizing the business as a C corporation is $64,000 of
income tax [(0.37 individual rate − 0.21 corporate rate) × $400,000] less
the $6,400 reduction in tax benefit related to the interest deduction on
the debt. Assuming the individual’s capital gain rate is 15 percent, the tax
upon the sale of the stock will be 0.15 × $271,760 = $40,764. However,
assuming the stock will be held for 5 years, present value of the tax upon
the sale of the stock will be far less than the additional tax paid on ordi-
nary income by the unincorporated entity. To recap let’s look at Table 1.7.
It should be noted that if the corporate tax rate had been higher (say
30 percent), incorporating would be more expensive in terms of total
tax paid.
The new owners must also be concerned with personal liability. There-
fore, the acquired business must ultimately be inside of an LLC or a cor-
poration. The purchaser is not necessarily the entity that operates the
business. For example, an individual could purchase a proprietorship and
then transfer the assets to a corporation in exchange for stock. The trans-
fer will be nontaxable provided the individual has 80 percent control over
the transferee corporation. Or, the individual could transfer the assets to
an LLC. The transfer to the LLC would be a nontaxable event regardless
of whether the individual controls the LLC. However, arrangements with
creditors will be necessary for the new entity to assume liabilities.
Index
A reorganization, 73–76 Class IIIA, and asset valuations, 6–7
AFR. See Applicable federal interest Code, tax, 21, 35, 36, 62
rate Consultant, former owner as, 17–18
Aggregate grossed-up basis (AGUB), Contingent amounts, 7
66–67 Contingent liabilities, 27
AGUB. See Aggregate grossed-up Corporate reorganizations, 71–73
basis Corporation versus proprietor, 23
Applicable federal interest rate (AFR), 13 Corporation’s subsidiary
Assets avoiding triple taxation, 62
character of, 48 Code, 62
eligible for installment sale, 11 election, 68–69
hypothetical sale of, 52–53 liabilities, complications of, 66–68
under installment method, 56–58 taxpayers, groups of, 61
intangible, 1–2 Cost recovery period, 3
sale, versus stock sale, 47–51 Covenant to not compete, 15–16, 44
seven classes of, 2–3 consultant, former owner as, 17–18
tangible, 1 employee, former owner as,
valuations, 1–6 16–17, 44
Class IIIA, 6–7
contingent amounts, 7 Debt, use of, 9
cost classifications, 7–9 installment sales, 10–13
recap, 7 Double taxation, 25, 61
tangible versus intangible assets, 8
tax benefits as proportion of cost, 5 Election, 68–69
Employee, former owner as,
B reorganization, 76–78 16–17, 44
Basis, of assets, 48 Employment agreement, 43–44
versus value, 26 Explicit interest, 13
Bonus depreciation, 4, 6
Business investigation expense, 83 Forward triangular reorganization,
business new to taxpayer, 84–86 79–80
expansion of an existing business, 86
Goodwill, 1–3
C corporations, 25
versus S corporation debt Imputed interest, 13
financing, 42 Incorporated business
tax-deferred acquisitions of covenants to not compete, 44
statutory patterns, 73–79 employment agreement, 43–44
triangular reorganizations, 79–80 net operating loss
unwanted assets, 80–81 built-in gains, 36
versus unincorporated business, built-in losses, 36, 38–39
purchase of, 25 in liquidation, 39–40
C reorganization, 78 personal goodwill, 44–45
90 INDEX
• a one-time purchase,
• that is owned forever,
• allows for simultaneous readers,
• has no restrictions on printing, and
• can be downloaded as PDFs from within the library community.
Our digital library collections are a great solution to beat the rising cost of textbooks. E-books
can be loaded into their course management systems or onto students’ e-book readers.
The Business Expert Press digital libraries are very affordable, with no obligation to buy in
future years. For more information, please visit www.businessexpertpress.com/librarians.
To set up a trial in the United States, please email [email protected].