Bell Hooks - Ain't I A Woman. Black Women and Feminism
Bell Hooks - Ain't I A Woman. Black Women and Feminism
Matriarchy versus Patriarchy - as we see it 4 The New Testament: The Goddess and the Sacred King 15
Women in Ancient Egypt and Fertility Control 6 Stone Circles and Energy Lines 20
Old Testament: Covenant against the Goddess 8 Patriarchy, the Indo-Europeans and World Religions 22
Trees, Sacred Groves and the Goddess 10 Book List and Information 23
BEYOND PATRIARCHY
The history of existing society is the history of Because several of us already had observed
women's oppression. Whatever other forms of oppression evidence for a previous universal Goddess religion,
have been in existence - lord and serf, guildmaster and we called ourselves the Matriarchy Study Group. In
journeyman, capitalist and labourer, the most severely looking at various areas, we found the evidence so
exploited has been the woman. She has been the victim vast that it has been impossible to do more than
of more than double oppression: that of the class of point to it. It is the more difficult since a total
under-dog whichever that was; within that class, she annihilation of its existence was attempted throughout
has provided slave labour both for the benefit of the 2,000 years by proponents of patriarchy; although
principal exploiter - i.e. in order to keep the male almost successful," their efforts did not completely
worker at work - and in all classes for the personal blot out the evidence, which today is being assembled
benefit of the male himself. Where the woman personally on a wide scale but by disparate efforts.
contributes any kind of paid labour directly into the
system it has had to be in addition to the two other We are publishing this GODDESS SHREW now as
and major tasks. This is still the case. part of work in progress. These are our aims:
It must be repeated: this is still the case. 1. We want to share with other women our growing
It is the case under capitalism, in the Western confidence that women have not always been
industrial societies of the second half of the "inferior", subject and oppressed by men in their
twentieth century. It is the case under socialism, families and in society. There was a time,
in the countries which give themselves this description. universally, it seems, from the beginning of the
It is the case under the feudal and semi-feudal systems human race until from 5,000 - 2,000 B.C. where
still existing in many parts of the world. everyone took for granted matriarchy values and
society was organised on the basis of a woman-led
Why have women for so long accepted - and
culture. The Goddess was worshipped not only in
still, for the most part, accept - this unequal
terms of fertility and survival but as a way of
situation?
life in which the feminine, and female, were
It is obvious that a society which believes that it is considered pre-eminent. Great civilisations were
quite in order for more than half its members to built in these cultures.
suffer lifelong exploitation, not only of labour, but
of total personal being, must have immensely strong 2. However, we do not wish merely to contemplate
conditioning in that direction. It must believe, and the past. Our aim of understanding the past is to
the super-exploited themselves must believe, that influence the present. We see the part that male
there ia,good reason for it. based religion and philosophy has played in
The reasons, in fact, are made plain from demeaning and exploiting women. In exposing this,
the time of birth to the time of death. They are built we want to share our regained confidence in
into the structure of society based on the patriarchal ourselves with other women. We extend to them the
system of religion. A male-God based society existing thought that we all have the psychological power
for 5)000 years in some areas became dominant totally to change our lives.
in the rise of so-called civilisations of the last 3. Further, we see that such control of the spirit
2,000 years. Today, even where people are not church- as well as of our bodies will extend the
going or even "religious" they are conditioned through possibility of change in society. Male domination
life in every sector of society to accept its tenets - and the assumption of traditional male roles is
of a Father God, or even, (if very advanced) of the rampant, not only in rightwing reactionary circles.
brotherhood of man. We move from the importance of feminist social
Our roles today have been stereotyped by past demands to total re-appraisal of patriarchy in
religion and by the culture based on it. politics generally.
In 1976, a group of women in London, formed 4« Such advances as have been achieved in the near
a collective to examine the basis for the assumptions past can be withdrawn at any minute. What has not
resulting from this culture. In particular, we yet been achieved is the understanding that women
tried to look beyond patriarchy to find if human- (and men) are still constantly under the oppression
kind had always been organised on these lines. Were of male-based conditioning. Until this is removed,
there can be no real political advance.
such ideas inherent in "human nature"?
2
Why on earth join a matriarchy study
group?
How many terries have complete s t r a n g e r s , How could aduttervj be anything
on the other- end of the telephone, asked whether you othe^r -than a sir. when paternity is impossible to prove
a r e Mi99 or Mrs? If you refuse to t e l l there, do they and has been made 'into CXIA important issue?
decide which they think Moa might be? fvnd So on and so on. Of course the man from t h e
Do men from places like the Worth Thames Gas Board Worth Thames G-as fcoand talks down to me, he holds
Co-L I you c l o v e ; or ° d e a r ' ? If you cal ( them c sonny a l l ttve tramp cards.
i n re-turn, do they sound put o u t f
C
$fe°|
WOULDN'T I.
miNp 7
COMV'eRTIWcV I
rtfcR To
MORTHóE/^ 5
''•pí (-+D rît J
B a t t h e n i t i s a l l very w e l l , t a l k . n g t» women
If uoa have voiced any objection to t h i s s o r t a b o u t such t h i n g s . If is n o t <xt All t h r e a t e n i n g to
of treatment, hove Jou been to Ld that it [-:, a l l very Learn t h a t uwenstrual b l o o d w a s c o n s i d e r e d i m p o r t a n t
t r i v i a l , j u s t the s o r t of I r r e l e v a n t complaint to loe
o n c e , a n d t h a t us why i t i s c o n s i d e r e d uric Lean by t h e
expected from a half-baked '«omen's L¿bber?
p a t r i a r c h a l r e v o l u t i o n . Nor t h a t a l l m a n n e r of sumbols
Has anyone ever t o l d you. t h a t , without t h e which 'jjere S a c r e d tri m a t r i a r c h a l t i m e s become e v t t in
family, s o c i e t y w o u l d collapse 7 . Or ever* t h a t femmn.sfh the bible. Nbt a t a IL w o r r y i n g , guiti? logical, listen ft>
is OL mOa-Mst (Sic) plot to overthrow the s a r c U t y of i t f o r h o u r s w i t h o u t a qualívi. Bat J u s t t r y f a i t l y i a
family life? Have ^on ever hod the bible quoted at a b o u t I f t o wen, o r even a man.
yoa to prove t h a t a woman's place LA in the home /child
recurlng / s u p p o r t i n g men? Ha-S i t ever occurred to you I t 16 amazing how h o s t ' d « <nem c a n b e , j u s t to
t h e I d e a of woman t a l k i n g t o e a c h o t h e r a n d aettvrva a
t h a t i t IS odd t h a t women, even qa'i t e grown-up ones,
S o r b of p e a c e &f rr]ir,¿ ^ ^ ¡ £ . fj 0 m a t t e r bow offer)
should be ' g i v e n away' by t h e i r fathers in. church
t h e y m a y be i n t h e h a b i t of s p e n d i n g t h e vr t i m e with
Vveddmg ceremonies? And however remote jyowr
g r o u p s of o t h e r men, in pubs or- w h e r e v e r , ¿h«. L did o f
relbgLous beLLefs may be, a-re you plagued by a Larking
s u p e r s t i t i o n t h a t they might be rug h t a f t e r a i l , VuOhaen t a l k i n g t o g e t i o e r and ejnichuna t t s e e m s t c s e t
family Ufe might be .sacred and adultery Vvrong ? off a l l k i n d s of -fanta^-ifS. Wowen j u s t a r e not
T h a t tornen reaily rvught b-e inferior because ut e>a.us Supposed te g e t on well ttgeflner., not if the y h a v e
60 en the bible ? t h e a l t e r n a t w € of being With men.
Then t r y t h e c o n c e p t cf p a t n a r c h u . d i s a s t e r .
I c a n ' t remember u>ben I f i r s t s t a r t e d tfc T h a t means you must be q n t i - m a n , qettùra at them.
n o t i c e the put-downs, but i t Seems a. very bong t i m e I n s t a n t aggressLon,
»— — -.-- s—uHl k , s u s p i•c i-o n . 5<
ago. ALI tine while I \¿as asking myself question s Lite , you s a y .
Iwhy-is the family so Important, p a r t i c u l a r l y to is important to me to t^dersttvnd t h a t I am not chnoh-
p o l i t i c i a n s , why do people g e t married, why curt &tttrter, j u s t because I am a Woman, 'it helps rne t o
c h i l d r e n e i t h e r ignored or treated a s runners en a kinow dViat t h e r e \were matna^ohal societies exit.*, anc/
p a r e n t a l ego- race, why are old people treated as though they lasted for a w€ry U>ng tifW, Mes, i t i s veri)
they are useless arid put crto homes and trercted a s difficult to know exactly what they wer« t i k e ,
sab- human . . . . and votay do complete s t r a n gers cal1 me but nev'&r mi nd, they existed.
' d e a r ' and expect to knew rtiy marital " s t a t u s " ? VxJoume^ wjere important then, and not
j u e t because people were l y i j h ^ a. specaL effort to
Feelung very wary, | found myself ¡40 ov Concede Some s t a t u s becauet fhf^ t h o u g h t They should,
women's matriarchy study group. Ar\d What a t r e a t it b u t actually important because -ewerwene tloou^iAt so.
was- Here were people who knew exactly how I t f e e l s
to be put dowtA dozens of times a day, o f t e n in very Having got oi/er t h a t , t h e r e i s ç,tluL
t r i v i a l ways, but put down j u s t the same. Angry about p a t r i a r c h y to deal UJitt, and 'it 'isn't easy. There is
I t , bat n o t shouting, not t r y i n g to bulldoze anyone, no g e t t i n g away from t h e word:
l i s t e n i n g to what was s a i d , Without trying to g a i n If matn arohaL £octef,p5 were overthrown
S t a t u s with c l e v e r answers. No competitive mess. Ary) and piAt down by men who mere corxiertyed about ttve
What were they s a y i n g 9 p a t e r n i t y of theiyr cti.Ldr-en, who im vested a lot of
ru^fs axid r e l a y o n s a n d beu'efs to Ke-e-p women down^
They we-r€ saying t h a t a very Long time before. then VJ€ stvUl tlue im a. pflitrii^rc^al soa'ety. There
the bob Le, thenf were m a t r l a r d n a l s o c i e t i e s . Women is a lot of p a t r i a r c h y aloout— a lot of Bkzunwashing
W&re important f o r a very long time. 5u_t they were to (vinki women feet îvifen'or and c^uitty.
Overthrown by Men who Invented the p a t r i a r c h a l
r e l i g i o n s wivch are s t i l l with us- Qui-ltiy a b o u t not having children o r , hauing
There were p i c t u r e s of sculptures and pots and figures had chbldeen, g a l l t y about megleotirvg them in ajiy way!
-from very old rr0trL0.rc.hal Societees. Without knowing hot buying the n g h t baby food, not attending t o the t r
exactly how)) when or tvhere, we were a l l gtiite sure that every need, twenty ft>ar hours a. day. (kitltu aJoout
"it had happened. i^duitcLuiin« o,ri identity of ones oum-G-wlitu a b o a t
men ttro . Tiutbtu O-bpat not being supportive enough,
It all f i t s . It i s a g neat comfort to know not Looking) o r behau un« Uke t h e n g b t s o r t of
t h a t women have hot been con^Ldered inferior since -the packaged 'Lvifer-lor anlfnitL. faxLitu aboat damaging) the
beginning of t u n c - t u t t h a t they have been Important a l l - uviportant rnaJe ego.
much longer than not. I t is enlightening to know that
the hdbte is p a t r i a r c h a l propaganda, which set s o a t to •However^ p a t r i a r c h y is SO outworn thrxt i t
put women down- Of coarse the family must be d o e s n ' t even do imany hoen n»vuch gjood either. It h a s
Considered saored, w i t h o u t I t hem coald t h e r e he heirs, 3 0 t t c 0,0. Mot to be he placed by mat»-la/vchg, b u t
s o n s , pairLlán-eai societies ~> pertna^s a. b i t hnore t r u s t and ree>pe<t- would t e a start.
Matriarchy f^atrîarchy
as we s
-n-tt; 8><*S-AE ^ e u E T
a,,«nîfi..>tft
THE notio n of a matriarchal stage in social history seems to be We believe that at some t i m e , approximately 5,000 years age,
dead and burled w i t h the 19th Century of Engels and Bachofen. simultaneously all over the planet, there was what has been called a
Modern anthropologists do not hesitate to tell us that men have Patriarchal Takeover. It lasted roughly 2000 years and was complete
always been d o m i n a n t , even in matrillneal systems of social by 500 A . D . We believe that the takeover happened by force, and
organisation, and say that the evidence of surviving matrilineal that the Amazon legends may describe the last groups of women who
societies as vestiges of earlier matriarchies does not hold up! But defended themselves against it.
is their evidence really conclusive?
In Europe and the Middle East, the takeover involved the
For instance, there seems to be some confusion over invasions of the Aryans or Indo-Europeans, hunter-fisher tribes from
terms of reference. We, along w i t h other feminists, do not envisage the Caucasus, w i t h a strongly patriarchal culture. Their volcanic sky
matriarchy as a mirror image of patriarchy, so that as patriarchy = gods replaced the earth goddesses of the earlier cultures and their
male dominance, so therefore matriarchy • female dominance. Dare own myths and values succeeded the earlier ones. These included:
we suggest that this could even be a 'Patriarchal' n o t i o n . We are
indeed investigating women-based culture as part of a search into
1. The appropriation and ownership of the sources of p r o d u c t i o n ,
our cultural past, but also, and equally i m p o r t a n t l y , as a kind of
including w o m e n .
vision of a society in which women w o u l d be t r u l y free. We are
exercising our Imagination, imagining ourselves w it h power, but w i t h
2. Opportunism - the m y t h of infinite development w i t h i n a finite
a very different sort of power. As Murray Bookchin has said:
world.
"the very essence of the matricentric world is that it vitiates rule as such." 3. The worship of power and domination leading to armed and
military violence.
He maintains that polarities cannot be found between patriarchy
and matriarchy as t w o differing forms of rule: the comparison must 4. The monopoly of force.
be between rule and anarchy, between the presence and the absence
of d o m i n a t i o n . A w o r l d w i t h less of the hierarchy that seems inherent We believe that as men discovered the concept of paternity,
to male society w o u l d be a tat cry from the very structured one we they began the appropriation of agriculture. The Neolithic culture
now inhabit! based on cultivation of the soil by hoe, was replaced by an agri-
culture based on fire and irrigation, which began the devastation
Our starting point has been the Neolithic period of prehistory. of the planet and depletion of resources, by destroying vast areas
In this pre-dominantly agricultural society, many functions belonging of land which had been the granaries of the ancient w o r l d . Together
to women were given structural expression; securit,. receptivity, w i t h this, there was the beginnings of the population explosion caused
enclosure and nurture. The rounded w o m b l i k e house and temple forms by the over-fertility of women and men's appropriation of the means
and the early importance of containers for storing f o o d , keeping out of contraception. This is w h y we have included an article on
insects and storing surplus in good harvests are a c o n t r i b u t i o n to culture contraception in ancient Egypt which shows its ready availability to
often overlooked in favour of the machine. w o m e n compared to all the centuries f o l l o w i n g , up to our o w n .
There was also an intimate biotechnic relationship w i t h the soil We believe that capitalism is only the last stage of the much
and the seasons w h i c h we are only beginning to rediscover. Knowledge wider problem of patriarchy. The technological society and all
of the calendar was vital in this cycle and was recorded in stone in that follows come from the premises of patriarchy. Our work is
megalithic cultures all over the w o r l d (see article on Stones). The set in a historical c o n t e x t , and the images of our o w n , pre-patriarchal
material and spiritual worlds were united long before the m i n d , body culture that have emerged, have inspired us as painters, architects,
split of Platonic t h o u g h t , and later of Christianity. We have been inspired poets and writers, as well as in our everyday lives. A reply to those
by the seeingly guilt-free and j o y f u l religion of the Goddess, illustrated modern anthropologists is, in Mumford's words:
in Crete, w i t h its concept of life in life, as opposed to life after death.
"No reference to village life among surviving tribes, supposedly primitive,
We are searching to find w h y this rich cultural heritage has been can hope to give a true account of that early inchoate culture, still in
lost to us for so long. Our evidence for the once widespread w o m e n - the making. For what we call primitive today, even when it shows few
based culture has been emphasised more by the force of its suppression traces of recent contact with more developed cultures, has behind it con-
and annihilation than anything else. Aspects of our studies have involved tinuous linkages and changes over as great a span of history as any more
complex national group or urban unit. Perhaps the best sources of early
I, The evidence o f . t h e world-wide worship of the Goddess religion, village culture remain in the surviving customs and superstitions, still kept
through the Palaeolithic and Neolithic eras, f r o m 25,000 to alive in rural areas until our own day. This archaic culture ... seems to be
5,000 B.C. (Compare the relatively short timespan of the unweathered stratum beneath all the Old World cultures, however
Patriarchy!) civilised and urbanised."
2 The importance of the women's role in societies where they So we look to poetry and m y t h , to trees and stones, to
served as priestesses and priest-queens. the form of the landscape ... and dedicate our inspiration to the Muse.
^V\\\\x
^lrZr>ù*-*ts
OLD TESTAMENT by Eve w h o listens to the advice of the serpent to disobey God's
injunction not to eat of the f r u i t of the tree of knowledge; she tempts
Adam to eatjthey b o t h do,so God punishes t h e m , and humankind
for ever. Eve, in one version has been created by God out of Adam's
rib, to be a "helpmeet to h i m " : in another the record merely says
" male and female created he t h e m " . Extra Biblical material suggests
that Lilith was the female. However, Eve's appearance f r o m the rib
and her tempting of Adam are intrinsic to the Judaeo-Christian religion
v
She was at fault, was evil, she did the bad t h i n g , and look what
happened.
1j
V
\ r,
» The events of the Old Testament are fairly w e l l - k n o w n , and
it w o u l d be tedious to re-document t h e m . This survey w i l l attempt
y
^
ë to deal w i t h only a few and to show how history was re-written w i t h
the purpose of subjugating the female religion.
•*,
w
This was the worship of the Great Goddess which existed
from earliest time until the period of the Old Testament - which
deals w i t h events from about 5000 B.C. to just before the birth of
Christ. During those years the Goddess religion which had flourished
in the Middle East where the chronicled events took place, was
9 <f i overthrown . It appears that the purpose of the Old Testament
was to make sure that It disappeared from human history. Descript-
ions of the evidence for the Goddess religions w i l l be found in the
book list. There is no d o u b t that despite extreme prejudice and
: sabotage by male anthropologists and historians, this evidence is
now generally accepted. But the work which was done to destroy
itjhas stood for 2000 years as the cornerstone of religion, ethics and
m \
m o r a l i t y . This survey can only deal w i t h some of theelues ; w.pr.k js
3°Á n j6.pn.t.o.rppt.put.more.
7.
••< K
••
i
//
/
í
u
^'iiu '
r
/
I
0 Mu/d u& chairo Tfcuvmf oujocû the bfejj. Hadrian cyunotey acaL.
In ancient Babylon, the Mother Goddess was called Tiamat,
who was the sea, and also a sea-creature, a dragon, or sea-serpent.
She was represented as chaos, encompassing a total world of sea and
sky together. The Babylonian Creation Epic tells how she is cut in
two by her son Marduk, the sea going below, the sky above.
Fish o r Egg ( î o d d e s s , Danube B a s i n , c 6 , 0 0 0 BC.
In the Old Testament Genesis the word ' T e h o m ' to describe
chaos in the beginning has the same linguistic root as Tiamat.
" T h e earth was w i t h o u t form and void ( T e h o m ) " then god divided
Covenant against the Goddess the "waters which were under the f i r m a m e n t f r o m the waters which
were above the firmament ... he called the firmament heaven, the
THE BIBLE, Old Testament and New, was created as propaganda to dry land earth, and the gathering together of the waters, the seas".
enslave » m e n . It also recorded the annihilation in the Middle East Obviously Tiamat's being cut in t w o by Marduk, and God cutting
of the previous universal Goddess worship. It provided an alter- chaos in t w o have similar roots.
native religious philosophy whose aim was to underpin concepts of
male superiority. Joseph Goebbels, during the rise of the Nazis to Tiamat's form as a sea serpent or dragon (remembering that
power in Germany in the 1930s, said : " H i s t o r i c a l t r u t h can be studied she is the most ancient Mother Goddess) leads to more about her
by professors of history. The purpose of propaganda is success". being put d o w n by the God of the Old Testament. Rahab and
Leviathan, b o t h names for the sea dragon, are referred to in the •
The success of the Bible's message about the i n f e r i o r i ty of Psalms and in Isaiah: Is. 27.1 says: " Y a h w e h w i t h his sore and great
w o m e n and its attempted destruction of almost all evidence about and strong sword shall punish Leviathan the swift serpent and
their previous leading and honoured place in the world's c o m m u n i t y Leviathan the crooked or winding serpent and he shall slay the dragor
is the basis of Western civilisation. that is in the sea". In Is. 51.9-10 " A r t thou O Lord though that cut
Rahab in pieces, that pierced the d r a g o n . " There aremany other
Women have been conditioned to believe that they are the such references. Students of the Goddess religions w i l l also know
'weaker sex', that power must be left to men, that they must feel that the serpent (which, of course, tempted Eve) was the symbol
guilty most of the t i m e . This guilt, in connection w i t h child care, of the Mother Goddess and can be seen today in statues of the
man service, w o r k , one's own appearance, and any specific personal Goddess in Crete while St. George is seen slaying the dragon in
need is c o m m o n to all Western w o m e n , at least, and has its roots in Christian mythology, in the so-called service of a holy helpless virgin,
the Biblical description of women and their role. who stands there ready to serve her hero.
Even women awakening to liberation still have unexplained Of Eve, who was created from Adam's rib to be a helpmeet
guilt and inferiority feelings, all nurtured by society and blessed to him : the Babylonian earlier version tells another story. Professor
by every article of its Establishment. Hooke in Middle East Mytholog y recounts: The Goddess Ninhursag
caused eight plants to grow in the garden of the gods: the god Enki
The Old Testament is a collection of writings by men first ate them and as a result, eight of his bodily organs were attacked by
published as a whole in 100 A . D . in Hebrew, and about one hundred disease; Ninhursag created eight goddesses of healing to heal each of
years later in Greek, the latter version containing added material • the diseased part of Enki's body. The goddess who cured the rib
A great deal of so-called scholarly interpretation and higher criticism was named N i n t i , which means lady of the rib. But the same w o r d
exists, and deals w i t h methods of analysing who wrote w h a t and when also means l i f e ; The Hebrew name for Eve was Havvah, or life.
The Old Testament' s subject matter deals w i t h the creation of the Obviously N i n t i and Eve were the same person, and healed the rib
universe and the animal k i n g d o m , by a patriarchal god, who enters rather than were created by it.
into a compact w i t h a pastoral tribe. They, the Hebrews, (otherwise
Israelites), w i l l worship him monotheistically, and he w i l l look
after t h e m . The adventures of this people, their heroes and prophets
Noah w a s a Woman
A similar trick w i t h names was played in the story of Noah
artvdealt w i t h , and eventually provide the basis of the later patriarchal and the F l o o d . Babylonian literature is rich w i t h stories of great
stage of the same religion, Christianity, documented in the New floods and prayers to avert them - Babylon itself being built on the
Testament. t w o great rivers, Tigris and Euphrates. The prayers were addressed
to the Goddess of Floods , by name, Nuah: her symbols were an green trees were symbols of life, fertility and survival.
olive branch and a dove. It w i l l be recalled that in the Bible story Jeremiah addresses his erring nation again (2.20): " U p o n
both these symbols are used by God's righteous man, Noah. Through every high hill, and under every green tree, thou wanderest playing
out the early part of the Old Testament, there is constant source the h a r l o t " . But Ezekiel (6.13) has the answer: " T h e n shall you know
material from the earlier mother religion. Moses placed in the that I am the Lord. When the slain shall be among the idols around
bulrushes in a casket by his mother and found by the Egyptian about their altars, upon every high hill and under every green tree,
princess, in the waters of the N ¡le, recalls according to Freud's and under every thick oak, the place where they did offer sweet
'Moses and Monotheism' as well as Esther Harding's 'Women's savour unto all their idols, so will I stretch out my hand and make the
Mysteries', the Moon Boa b u i l t by Isis in which to carry and then land desolate, and they shall know I am the L o r d " .
search for her child. The flood goddess Nuah also built a crescent
boat to carry her children, the seed of all living things. Moses's sister
Miriam was Queen of Heaven.
Tabu
There are many more references, but one more area is important
Later in his life, there is a curious The laws given to the Israelite peopl e in the first five books of
incident involving Moses and a 'brazen serpent'. Numbers 21.6-9 the Old Testament include a whole range of those establishing paternity,
tells how serpents bit the Israelites in the desert; Moses made a punishing by death female adultery, emphasising the uncleanness and
serpent out of brass which allowed anyone who had been bitten the male abhorrence of menstrual b l o o d , and all matters connected
with parturition and childbirth (basis of the uncleanness and the later
to look on it and live. Later kings and prophets denounced this
Churching o f W o m e n before they could join a congregation, basis, too,
episode: II Kings 17 says: "Hezekiah brake in pieces the brazen
of the ban on women handling any kind of " h o l y " sacrament or be-
serpent that Moses had made for in those days the children of
coming priests.) In addition, the well-known Jewish dietary laws are
Israel did burn incense to it and he called it Nebushtan." This
set out w i t h stress on utter avoidance of eating pig meat. Freud in
last name appears to mean serpent and comes through in a
'Totem and T a b o o ' , Briffault in 'The Mothers', Evelyn Reed in
number of biblical references. There is no doubt that the
'Women's E v o l u t i o n ' all make the point that what becomes tabu was
Israelites were worshipping the great Goddess through her major originally sacred. Marija Gimbutas:'The Gods and Goddesses of Old
symbol. Europe'jSpeaks of " t h e curious connection between the Vegetation
Sarah i n E g y p t Goddess and pigs. Sculptures of pigs are known from all parts of Old
Europe and date from every period ... the Fast growing body of a pig
Earlier, Abraham, father of the Hebrew people, came must have impressed early agriculturalists. Its fattening compared to
from Ur of the Chaldees, itself documented as a Moon City wor- corn growing and ripening, so that its soft fats came to symbolise
shipping the Goddess. His father Terah appears to have been the earth itself, causing the pig to become a sacred animal no
a moon priest. The story of Abraham's wife Sarah, w h o m he later than 6000 B.C." Later the many-breasted Diana, Demeter
pretends is his sister when he goes into Egypt, shows that when the bare-breasted Queen of Corn and Queen of the Dead, and her
the Pharoah there treated her w i t h f u ll honours, and when the daughter Persephone, herself called killer of suckling pigs, are all
deception was found out, Sarah left w i t h gifts and procured connected w i t h mysteries involving identification of the pig w i t h
by her status her husband's safety. There are two very similar the Goddess. Kerneyi and Jung ('Introduction to Science of
episodes telling this story. Later it w i l l be recalled that Mythology') write of a " M o o n maiden who is linked w i t h a pig,
Abraham was about to sacrifice his son Isaac, and God told him becomes a pig, her child is a pig and her second form is a p i g " .
to put a ram in his place: this was the start of the original
covenant w i t h the Hebrew people, and has been used countless
times, to show that their God was of a higher form than those In bringing anything to do w i t h the i g into outstanding
who required human sacrifice. However, Isaac was, of course, abhorrence, the writers of the Old Testament were certainly trying
male; an equivalent story w i t h a different ending is seen in to banish links w i t h the Goddess /
Judges 11.30.40.
Jepthah's Piet y Whilst this survey has dealt only w i t h the Old Testament,
During the war between the Israelites and it should not be thought that matters Improved w i t h the New
the A m m o n i t e s , Jepthah of Israel vowed that i.f he could succeed Testament. In fact, women's position became even worse: the
in battle he would then sacrifice as a burnt offering the first Church identified women and sexuality w i t h sin,' and all women's
living things he met coming from the doors of his house: after matters were cast aside as being at best of no importance, and
"a very great slaughter" when the children of A m m o n were sub- usually evil and of fearful temptation to men. This is a matter
dued, Jepthat returns. The first person to come from his house for another survey.
is his daughter meeting him w i t h "timbrels and dances". Her
father " d i d w i t h her according to his v o w " . The daughters Also, the reasons why patriarchy took over from Goddess
of Israel " w e n t yearly to lament the daughter of Jepthah four worship, how women were so enslaved (Engels termed it " t h e
days in a year". There is more information in this story, apart first world defeat of w o m e n " in 'Origin of the Family, Private
from her sacrifice: that appears to indicate she was part of a Property and the State'), the different areas of the.world where
group of women worshipping on the mountains. Possibly this there is overt evidence of Goddess worship (Crete, Catal H u y u k ,
was the reason that the male God saw no reason to save her as Etruscan remains, Carthage, Malta, and many others) are being
researched and written about by women authors today. In
he hadsaved Isaac.
particular Monica Sjoo, Merlin Stone and Elizabeth Gould Davies
TREES and their One of the most commonly referred to is the apple tree. It could
be interpreted as being the moon tree, the sacred tree, or the tree
of knowledge. It is used as a symbol of immortality, fertility and
if consummation. It is sacred to Aphrodite/Venus, the goddess
significance in • f love.
ik V "^ Jk
Western Europe the man in the moon is said to carry a bundle
of faggots - and in Greece is depicted cutting down a tree
which grows up again every month.
Soma, the drink of the Gods, was the juice of the The ivy has a five-pointed leaf. It was sacred to Osiris and
fruits of the sacred moon tree, and those who drank of it Dionysius. It was used as an intoxicant by the Bassarids and Maeniads
were believed to acquire both knowledge and immortality. In ivy ale was a medieval drink. It grows spirally like the vine.
Egypt to eat of the fruit of the moon tree was to eat of the flesh
of the Goddess.
@ © @ © ©
10
The hawthorn, also kndwn as whitethorn or may, is again The Asherim were the Groves of the Goddess Ashtarte.
a tree with five-pointed leaves. It is the tree of the Goddess Maia, In the Bible the Lord is constantly being made angry by, and
whose month is May. She uses a hawthorn branch with which to destroying these Asherim, as they were temples of the Goddess
cast spells. Olwen, the Celtic May Queen, was a daughter of the and not the God.
hawthorn.
mm PRIESTESS WITH
SfiCRED TREE.
FROM THE Hflir/H
The laurel, also the bay and the daphne, is evergreen and a
symbol of immortality. TRIRDR SftRCOPH-
RÇ-US, CRETE.
The Maeniads, the priestesses of Daphne at Tempe, chewed 1/fOOßC
laurel to bring them into a frenzy - the chewing of laurel was taboo
in Greece for all but priestesses. Daphne was turned into a laurel
tree after Apollo had captured her shrine.
It has constantly been associated with poetry and the muses - In II Kings 17.10: "And the children of Israel did secretly
because of its power as an intoxicant and its relationship to the those things that were not right against the Lord their God ...
Goddess. and they set them up images and groves in every high hill, and
under every green tree".
Culpepper claims that laurel resists witchcraft.
Sitting on the roof of the Heraklion Youth Hostel Two Cretan men,
I spoke to a self-confessed expert on classics: Polite and gentle Cretan men -
"It has been suggested that Minoan Crete may But:
Possibly have been "It has been suggested that Minoan Crete might
a matriarchy!' at some stage
"A What!" he said aghast, quite possibly
"There is absolutely no evidence anywhere » have been a "
or at any time Matriarchy is not an English word
to support matriarchy". With which Greeks are familiar.
Self-assuredly and finally he folded his arms in satisfaction. It doesn't come into a tourist vocabulary
Which does manage to encompass Loch Ness plus inhabitant.
"Most experts agree it was matrilineal
And an omnipotent Goddess was worshipped," No, it was not possible for women to rule.
I tried to re-open the question. The Goddess was one of fertility only,
Important in those days,
"Oh, there have been so many far fetched religious theories And weren't my boobs large like the figurines' -
postulated on those three Goddess figurines in the Museum." I must be very fertile, nudge, nudge;
Full stop. And, dogmatically,
Retsina is not made from grapes marinated in pine resin -
" o u t if a patrilineal, omnipotent God worshipping society is They grew like that in Attica!
patriarchal . . ." Amazing.
"No evidence for matriarchy -
Men have always been in charge - * * * * *
always will be
No evidence. No evidence." Sitting on the boat to Rhodes
He rushed to buy another bottle of Retsina. Comparing ideas on the symbols - bull's horns, double axe -
I suggested to the English teacher that
"It is possible that Minoan Crete was a matriarchy."
Silence.
"What do you think?"
Silence.
Then, thoughtfully : "Hm."
Gazing out to sea, she said:
"We spent a day at Phaistos,
Comparing the old and new palaces.
It was tremendous ...
And the feeling very different from
Anything I had seen on the mainland."
Thoughtful pause.
"Yes, yes. Perhaps it could have been,
Couldn't it!
Why not."
The conversation exploded and continued for hours.
J
On the plane back from Athens with a history student:
"After seeing the Minoan s t u f f
I said casually,
"Most of the Greek seems very dead and lifeless."
* * * * * *
if/
:ä*V $
Half Over Heard
What happened: nothing
As the hills Who did you meet on the spiral stair: nothing
I shall be What have you to day in summing.up: nothing
vast
my bones are miles Nice nothing:
long the trees step off over water
under hills the reeds lean into silence
under fields hidden in wood
deeper than fields a candle burns for my daughter
I should away
silence for my daughter, in darkness
Miriam Scott
13
WOMEN'S SEXUALITY
THIS is the time to speak about sexuality.
Stone looers ÇQà
The worship of the Goddess showed understanding of the whole y triple a t
of life, ¡n which ordinary tasks were considered important and
sacred. The totality of birth, living and death were expressed
through magical rituals restating the cycles of fertility and sur- RP IOOO
vival, and bringing a sense of the immanence of the sacred to
everyday events. These were expressed sexually in women-led
cultures.
18
WHY
MATRIARCHY c
It is interesting to examine a certain strand of irrationality
which oftens appears when male archeologists talk about matriarchy.
In response to Michael Dames' discovery that Silbury Hill is an
earthwork of the Great Goddess, Glyn Daniel expostulates "Absolute
nonsense. It's th« wilder shores of archeology, and very sad . It's
the biggest round barrow in existence, no more than t h a t ; "
R.J.C.Atkinson is very categorical: " I t ' s a waste of time taking
about the religion of pre-history, because there's no w r i t t e n evidence
of it ... We can know nothing about prehistoric religion except that
they believed in an after-life - but only because of objects found
buried w i t h their dead ... The mystery of Silbury Hill is unanswerable
and always w i l l b e . " I There seems to be an injunction here that
one must only use one's eyes for reading; Dames' visual evidence
happens to be particularly clear. And the shrines of pre-history w i t h
their contents and imagery contain a great deal of information about
early religions.
Goddess in Temple at Ayia Irin i on KeoE
Cyclades, 2nd Millenium BC.
Nicholas Platon, the director of the Archeological Museum in
Heraklion, Crete, and excavator of the palace of Zakro, in his intro-
duction to the museum guide, says: " I t is fairly certain that there was
MATRIARCHY: G overnment by a mother or by mothers.
no polygamy in Crete." He goes on to say: " T h e women took a
An order of society where the descent is notable part in religious life. They also participated in dangerous and
reckoned in the female line. active sports, and hunted wild animals w i t h spears and bows, and w i t h
hounds." But ... "This freedom of women does not seem to be based
MATRILINEAL: Property and name reckoned through the on any kind of matriarchy."
mother or through females alone.
I agree that there was no polygamy; I think polyandry (marriage
MATRILOCAL: A form of marriage where the husband of the woman to more than one husband at a time) is more likely in
goes to live with the wife's community. that context. The organically developing cellular architectural structures
were ¡deal for accomodating large extended family and clan groupings.
MATRIARCHATE: A matriarchal condition or community. Women may have customarily chosen new mates at cult festivals.
MATRIX: T he womb.
Sinclair H o o d , in 'The M moans', diso does an about t u r n ;
The cavity in which anything is formed. " T h e dominance of goddesses in religion meant that women took an
That in which anything is embedded.
important part in religious rites and ceremonies, ás well as in the bull-
leaping games. The queens as high priestesses clearly had important ritual
functions, if not themselves divine.
G OD HAS BEEN WORSHIPPED AS A WOMAN FOR AT LEAST 25,000 YEARS:
as a man only during the last 5,000. The earliest creation myths
"Matriarchy or mother rule seems to have been l i k e l y " :
feature a goddess, w i t h occasionally a hermaphroditic deity.
Goddess figures made from stone and bone have been found all "Matrilineal traditions persisted on the nearby Anatolian coast
over the w o r l d , out of all proportion to figures of gods, over a until 400 B.C."
period of many thousands of years.
"Paintings repeatedly show women in the place of honour.''
The importance of the observation of lunar phases in order to
predict seasonal changes, and later to regulate the agricultural
calendar, was paramount in human settlements. A connection was
seen between the women's m o n t h l y cycle of bleeding and the monthly
lunar cycle; this was a basis for women's position as moon-shamaness,
the oracle and prophetess for the c o m m u n i t y . Women were also
skilled house-builders, fire-makers, farmers, potters, stock-breeders,
weavers, calendar-makers, as well as being mothers, fertile like the
earth. They were i m m o r t a l souls, perhaps continually reborn, like
the m o o n ; they were astronomers, mathematicians, and creative
artists, singing and dancing and painting and making pots and sculpt-
ing. From 9,000 B C onwards, they began to organise themselves
and their children and men into urban communities, w i t h female
control of religious practice, and matrilineal inheritance of name and
property. Their reproductive ability was honoured and revered;
their prolific and varied productivity constituted the root from which
Fresco of Queen a t t e n d a n t s , Kiossos, Crete,
the urban settlements grew.
c. 1,600 BC.
In Crete, c.2,000 B.C., as these towns grew into cities and Then ... " T r a d i t i o n and analogy suggest that Crete was ruled
society grew more complex, an upper class and a monarchy developed. by kings, w i t h succession to the throne by marriage to the
The sacred queen represented the Goddess for the people, perhaps royal daughter ... It does not necessarily follow from the
as an incarnation, and she was part of a far older tradition of female undeniable importance of women in ritual and cult, that they
monarchy, w h i c h was eventually overturned by the growing power enjoyed more respect and freedom than they did in later Greece."
and status of the male in general and the kings in particular. Robert
Graves talks about an interim period where kings wore the robes of Tradition and analogy ... THe Cretan women were heiresses
the queen and performed some of her ritual functions, as her substitute to an ancient neolithic matriarchal tradition . One can make
analogies w i t h the people of Western Anatolia, Libya, Greece,
However, Crete, being protected by the sea and her strong Thrace, the Cycladic islands, Malta, as well as northern Europe,
navy from invasion, did not develop a military or warrior tendency; all of w h o m grew up w i t h i n this t r a d i t i o n.
and it is quite probably that dynasties of women continued to rule
at the palaces of Crete until 1450 B.C., when the island, having been I suggest that if women controlled the organisation of
;ted by volcanic eruption and earthquake, was invaded by religious practice, and if property remained in female hands,
Vvcenaeans from the Greek mainland. and if women were active in organic and manufacturing production
as well as in reproducing the species, then they probably enjoyed a
There was no matter/spirit split in the culture ; the earth great deal of respect and freedom, not to say power, quite unlike
e-ibodied the d e i t y , flesh was spirit; sexuality and f e r t i l i t y were the women of classical Greece, who had been deprived of all
. - t a i n t e d by the concept of sin. political voice.
19
Keith Branigan says that traditional female activities Crete, Nicolas Platon.
such as pottery making and agriculture moved into the hands of The Minoans, Sinclair Hood.
male specialists in Crete between 3 and 2,000 B.C. I d o n ' t know Foundations of Palatial Crete, Keith Brannigan.
on what he bases this statement; the Kamares ware of 2,000 B.C.
Greek Myths, R. Graves.
to take one example, doesn't look as though it were made by a
m a n ; the smallness and delicacy of much of the art is remarkably
feminine in style. Platon says: "Traces of a woman's hand can be Elizabeth Moore
f e l t in many masterpieces (sic) of d e c o r a t i o n . " The magnificent
and minute seal-stones could wel l have been cut by w o m e n , as
could the exquisite stone necklaces. Possibly metallurgy was
originally the women's province, as keepers of the fire and kilns.
There is nothing t o say whether the directions for running the
farm issued from the women's quarters or the men's, except that
the land and the house belonged to the w o m e n , not the men.
and the idea that : "noble man is unfortunately born out of lust
engendered by blood and semen" and so "emerges mixed with
excrement and water, fouled with the impurities of woman,"
therefore "A wise man will avoid the contaminating society of
women as he would the touch of bodies infested with vermin."
^ "Blessed ¡>
THE SONG OF THE FEMINIST MATERIALIST
Angela Janet
Carol Liz
Matriarchies d o n ' t exist Charlotte
So anthropologists say
Monica
Denise Pat
Women were never equal
N o t in Canaan, not today Pauline
Thanks to
Images of Goddesses
And f e r t i l i t y rites Beverley, Cynthia, Doris, Irene, Maggie, Mandy, Martin,
Sacred kings and crocodiles Miriam, Toni
And dancing moonlit nights
and to
A lot of pretty pictures Robert Graves
Nothing can be proved
Unacademic nonsense
We w i l l not be moved.
Cover designed by Elizabeth Moore.
Fraser is discredited Front : Goddess from the temple of Ishtar,
Engels got it all quite wrong City of Mari, Sumeria, 3rd Millenium BC.
V i c t o r i a i imagining
We knew that all along Back: Marble Goddess from Sparta,
6th Millenium BC.
We d o n ' t need a herstory
We d o n ' t need a past published by: Matriarchy Study Group,
Discard all the evidence 15 Guildford Street,
Marx w i l l save women at last; London WC1.
Oorv«*" Printed by Women in Print, 16a Iliffe Yard, SE 17.