Accessibility and Sprawl
Accessibility and Sprawl
4VNNFS
QQ o
"WBJMBCMF BU IUUQKUMVPSH
3BOEBMM $SBOF
6OJWFSTJUZ PG $BMJGPSOJB
-PT "OHFMFT B
*OUSPEVDUJPO
ɨFSF JT MJUUMF EPVCU UIBU 3PCFSU #SVFHNBOO EJE USBOTQPSUBUJPO BOE VSCBO EFWFMPQNFOU
SFTFBSDIFST B HSFBU TFSWJDF XJUI IJT SFDFOU XPSL PO UIF IJTUPSZ PG VSCBO GPSN )F
TJUVBUFE DPOUFNQPSBSZ EJTDVTTJPOT PG iTQSBXM
w JUT QSPCMFNT BOE NBOZ QPMJDZ SFTQPOTFT
JO XFMMSFTFBSDIFE IJTUPSJDBM DPOUFYUBOE IF BOBMZ[FE UIPTF SFTQPOTFT BOE UIBU DPOUFYU
JO TVCTUBOUJWF
QVSQPTFGVM EFUBJM ɨBU IF NBOBHFE UP DBSSZ UIJT PĊ JO B CPME
FOHBHJOH
BOE TVDDFTTGVMMZ NBSLFUFE NBOOFS POMZ MFBWFT POF BMM UIF NPSF FOWJPVT PG UIF PWFSBMM
QBDLBHF " SFBM DPOTFRVFODF JT UIBU JU JT OPX NPSF EJċDVMU UP BSHVF UIBU TQSBXM JT
OFX
QFDVMJBSMZ "NFSJDBO
PS VOJWFSTBMMZ CBE
IPXFWFS POF NJHIU NFBTVSF TQSBXM
OFX
"NFSJDBO
PS CBE ɨF DPOWFOUJPOBM JNBHF PG TQSBXM BT MJUUMF NPSF UIBO B TUJDL mHVSF
TDBQFHPBU JT B MPU MFTT DSFEJCMF
BOE QFSIBQT FWFO OFBSFS UIF FOE PG JUT VTFGVM SIFUPSJDBM
MJGF
#SVFHNBOOT FTTBZ GPS UIJT KPVSOBM WPMVNF TVNNBSJ[FT UIF CBDLCPOF PG UIBU TUPSZ
GPVOE JO MPOHFS GPSN JO 4QSBXM " $PNQBDU )JTUPSZ
BOE UIFO BQQMJFT JU UP
UIJT KPVSOBMT EPNBJO
MBOE VTFUSBOTQPSUBUJPO QSPCMFNT BOE SFNFEJFT ɨF CPMEOFTT
GFSPDJUZ
BOE NFSDJMFTTOFTT PG IJT BUUBDLT PO TQSBXM DSJUJDT BOE i4NBSU (SPXUIw BEWP
DBUFT BMJLF BQQBSFOUMZ FODPVSBHFE UIF FEJUPST UP BTL UIBU *
BO JOOPDFOU SFWJFXFS PG UIF
PSJHJOBM TVCNJTTJPO
QSFQBSF B DPVOUFSQPJOU 5P XIBU
* SFQMJFE 5P IJT QPJOUT
UIFZ
BOTXFSFE #VU IJT CPPL DJUFT NZ SFTFBSDI JO TVQQPSU PG JUT USBOTQPSUBUJPO BSHVNFOUT
* SFQMJFE CBDL
XJUI XIJDI * BHSFF BOE GPS XIJDI * BN HSBUFGVM :PVSF B QSPGFTTJPOBM
UIF FEJUPST JOTUSVDUFE EP ZPVS CFTU
ɨJT XJMM CF CSJFG
#SVFHNBOOT UIFTJT DFSUBJOMZ IBT TUSFOHUIT BT XFMM BT XFBLOFTTFT "T NFOUJPOFE
JU JT SJDI JO IJTUPSJDBM BOUFDFEFOUT UP UIF EFDFOUSBMJ[FE VSCBO GPSNT QPQVMBSMZ EJTQBS
BHFE BT NPEFSO TQSBXM
QBSUJDVMBSMZ BT FYQMBJOFE CZ UIF UXJO
SFMFOUMFTT GPSDFT PG SJTJOH
SFBM JODPNFT BOE GBMMJOH SFBM USBOTQPSUBUJPO DPTUT )F BMTP BSHVFT UIBU UIF DPOWFSTF
IJHI EFOTJUZ
DBO DBVTF NPSF USBċD QSPCMFNT UIBO JU TPMWFT 4QSBXM IBQQFOT
JO PUIFS
a
DSBOF!VDMBFEV
XPSET *O JUT DPME EFUFSNJOJTN
JU JT OJHI VOJWFSTBM BOE SFMBUJWFMZ VOZJFMEJOH UP QPMJDZ
PS QSBZFST
3BUIFS UIBO TUPQ UIFSF
BU UFTUBCMF FWJEFODF PG SFBTPOBCMF FYQMBOBUJPOT PG UIF FN
QJSJDT
UIF BVUIPS HPFT PO UP GPSDFGVMMZ QSPDMBJN NBOZ PG TQSBXMT GFBUVSFT BT NFSJUT
BOE
CZ FYUFOTJPO
UIF DPVOUFSQSPEVDUJWF OBUVSF PG BOUJTQSBXM QPMJDJFT
TVDI BT TNBSU
HSPXUI
#SVFHNBOOT OPSNBUJWF OBSSBUJWF IBT UXP GVOEBNFOUBM QSPCMFNT ɨF DPTUT PG
TQSBXM BSF TVCTUBOUJBMMZ NPSF OVBODFE UIBO SFQSFTFOUFE
BOE 4NBSU (SPXUI JT JOBE
FRVBUFMZ DIBSBDUFSJ[FE &BDI BSHVNFOU NBZ TUJMM CF VTFGVM JO QPMJDZ EFCBUFT CVU UIFZ
BSF BMTP FTTFOUJBMMZ TQFDVMBUJWF
BOE UIVT EP NVDI UP VOEFSNJOF IJT MBSHFS MFTTPOT BCPVU
UIF DBVTFT BOE DPOTFRVFODFT PG TQSBXM GPS USBOTQPSUBUJPOMBOE VTF QPMJDZ
* FMBCPSBUF TMJHIUMZ JO XIBU GPMMPXT
CZ mSTU QSPQPTJOH IPX UP UIJOL BCPVU TQSBXM
BT B QSPCMFN
BOE UIFO IPX UP UIJOL BCPVU 4NBSU (SPXUI BT BO BQQSPQSJBUF SFTQPOTF
ɨF DPODMVTJPO SFUVSOT UP BDDFTTJCJMJUZ BOE USBOTQPSUBUJPO QPMJDZ
XIP UFOE UP mOE UIF JEFB PG MPPLJOH BIFBE BUUSBDUJWF JO QSJODJQMF CVU BSF VOBXBSF PG B
QSPGFTTJPO EFEJDBUFE UP UIBU QVSQPTF
UIBU JU FYQMBJOT B MBSHF TIBSF PG UIF QVCMJD JOUFSFTU
JO 4NBSU (SPXUI
ɨF TFDPOE JOJUJBUJWF FNQIBTJ[FT TQFDJmD UFDIOJDBM UPPMT
PG UIF TPSU UIBU NJHIU CF
DBMMFE iDPNQBDU EFWFMPQNFOU CFTU QSBDUJDFTw *U JODMVEFT UIF UIJOHT QMBOOFST UBML BCPVU
NPTU XIFO UIFZ UBML BCPVU 4NBSU (SPXUI
OBNFMZ
IJHIFS EFOTJUJFT
HSFBUFS NJYFE VTF
VSCBO HSPXUI CPVOEBSJFT
BOE JNQSPWFE QFEFTUSJBO BOE USBOTJUPSJFOUBUJPO ɨJT JT
XIBU UIF 4JFSSB $MVC
UIF /BUVSBM 3FTPVSDFT %FGFOTF $PVODJM
UIF "NFSJDBO 1MBOOJOH
"TTPDJBUJPO
UIF $POHSFTT GPS UIF /FX 6SCBOJTN
BOE PUIFS FOWJSPONFOUBM DPOTUJUVFO
DJFT UFOE UP GPDVT PO *U JT BMTP XIBU #SVFHNBOO UBLFT JTTVF XJUI
ɨF MBTU 4NBSU (SPXUI DPNQPOFOU GFBUVSFT QSPDFTT
PS iEFBM NBLJOH
w JHOPSFE CZ
#SVFHNBOO BOE NPTU QPQVMBS BOE QVCMJTIFE BOBMZTFT
PS DIBOHFT JO IPX MBOE VTF EFBMT
BSF NFEJBUFE ɨF EJĊFSFODF CFUXFFO UIJT BOE UIF USBEJUJPOBM QSPDFTT NPEFMXIFSF
MBOE PXOFST BOE MBOE SFHVMBUPST QBSMFZ PWFS QSPKFDU QMBDFNFOU BOE EFUBJMTJT UIBU UIF
FOWJSPONFOUBM DPNNVOJUZ JT CSPVHIU JOUP UIF HBNF NVDI FBSMJFS
MBSHFMZ EVF UP UIFJS
FĊFDUJWFOFTT JO VTJOH DJUJ[FOFOGPSDFE FOWJSPONFOUBM SFHVMBUJPOT FH
UIF &OEBOHFSFE
4QFDJFT "DU
UIF $MFBO "JS BOE 8BUFS "DUT
UIF $BMJGPSOJB &OWJSPONFOUBM 2VBMJUZ "DU
UP EFMBZ PS CMPDL QSPKFDUT ɨVT 4NBSU (SPXUI JT NPSF QBSUJDJQBUPSZ UIBO UIF BMUFS
OBUJWF
UIPVHI CZ IPX NVDI JT OPU BU BMM DMFBS *U DFSUBJOMZ JT OPU PQFO UP BMM BĊFDUFE
QBSUJFT
%PFT 4NBSU (SPXUI
BT EFmOFE IFSF
NBLF UIJOHT XPSTF PS CFUUFS *O QBSU B SF
TQPOTF EFQFOET PO XIJDI MFH PG UIF MFHHFE 4NBSU (SPXUI TUPPM POF SFGFST UP
BOE PO
UIF DBTF BU IBOE .PSF UP UIF QPJOU PG UIJT FTTBZ
#SVFHNBOOT DPNQMBJOU JT TUSPOHFTU
XIFSF IF TVHHFTUT UIBU VSCBO EFTJHO TUSBUFHJFT BJNFE BU SFEVDJOH DBS VTF DBO HP BXSZ
PS BU MFBTU VOEFS QFSGPSN 0O UIF POF IBOE
UP UIF FYUFOU HSFBUFS BVUPNPCJMJUZ EFMJWFST
OFU CFOFmUT
BOZ QPMJDJFT MJNJUJOH UIFTFTVDI BT CVJMEJOH GFXFS SPBET PS SBJTJOH UIF
DBTI PS UJNF DPTUT PG ESJWJOHNBZ XFMM MFBWF USBWFMFST BOE UIFJS DPNNVOJUJFT XPSTF
PĊ 0O UIF PUIFS
FWFO XIFSF DBST JNQPTF OFU TPDJBM DPTUT
JU JT GBS GSPN DMFBS XIJDI
VSCBO EFTJHO QPMJDJFT DBO JOnVFOUJBMMZ SFEVDF USBċD DPOHFTUJPO PS 7.5
PS JNQSPWF
BDDFTTJCJMJUZ
PS GPS XIPN FH
#PBSOFU BOE $SBOF
ɨF DMPTJOH TFDUJPO CFMPX
EJTDVTTFT UIJT GVSUIFS
#VU 4NBSU (SPXUI JT BMTP BCPVU QMBOOJOH QSPDFTT
HPWFSOBODF
BOE QBSUJDJQBUJPO
FBDI XJUI UIF QPUFOUJBM UP EFMJWFS NPSF BDDPVOUBCMF
FHBMJUBSJBO BOE SFTQPOTJWF EFWFMPQ
NFOU PVUDPNFT )PX FĊFDUJWFMZ UIJT BQQSPBDI DBO PS XJMM BEESFTT UIF HBNVU PG SFHVMB
UPSZ BOE QBSUJDJQBUPSZ GBJMVSFT BTTPDJBUFE XJUI GSBHNFOUFE
EFDFOUSBMJ[FE NFUSPQPMJUBO
HSPXUI JT JNQPTTJCMF UP TBZ JO UIF BCTUSBDU /FJUIFS DBO JU CF EJTNJTTFE PVU PG IBOE BT
DPVOUFSQSPEVDUJWF
ɨVT
#SVFHNBOOT CSPBETJEFT BHBJOTU 4NBSU (SPXUI NBLF POF GBJS QPJOU /BÕWFMZ
DSVEF BOUJDBS QSPHSBNT
XIFUIFS FĊFDUJWF PS OPU
BSF OBÕWF BOE DSVEF .Z DPVOUFS
QPJOU JT UIBU UIJT JT TDBSDFMZ B OPWFM
TZTUFNBUJD
PS FTQFDJBMMZ VTFGVM DSJUJRVF 4NBSU
$PVOUFSQPJOU "DDFTTJCJMJUZ BOE TQSBXM
HSPXUI JT NPTUMZ TJHOJmDBOU BT B CSBOEJOH UBDUJD GPS TPNFXIBU NPSF JODMVTJWF
OFHP
UJBUFE
BOE FOWJSPONFOUBM QMBOOJOH FMFNFOUT UIBO JO ZPVS NPUIFST EBZ *O HFOFSBM
UIPTF BSF CFTU FWBMVBUFE DBTF CZ DBTF
FMFNFOU CZ FMFNFOU "T UP UIF DPNQBDU EFWFM
PQNFOU BTQJSBUJPOT PG TQFDJmD 4NBSU (SPXUI QMBOT
UIF KVSZ JT TUJMM PVU PO XIBU UIFZ
DBO PS TIPVME BDDPNQMJTI 0WFSTUBUJOH UIBU VODFSUBJOUZ
BT #SVFHNBOO EPFT XJUI TPNF
WFSWF
NBZ OPU NPWF UIFTF EJTDVTTJPOT BMPOH BOZ GVSUIFS UIBO VOEFSTUBUJOH JU
BT VOEVMZ
PQUJNJTUJD QPQ QMBOOFST PGUFO EP XJUI BU MFBTU BT NVDI IFBSU
#SVFHNBOO PO BDDFTTJCJMJUZ
)BT TVCVSCBOJ[BUJPO JNQSPWFE PS XPSTFOFE USBWFM BDDFTT "T XJUI TQSBXM BOE 4NBSU
(SPXUI
UIF MBOHVBHF PG BDDFTTJCJMJUZ DBO CF DPOGVTJOH BOE QMJBCMF
EFQFOEJOH PO POFT
QVSQPTF ɨBU TBJE
UIFSF JT HSPXJOH BHSFFNFOU BNPOH USBOTQPSUBUJPO TDIPMBST UIBU
BDDFTT SFGFST TQFDJmDBMMZ UP UIF QVSQPTF PG USBWFM
XIJMF NPCJMJUZ TJNQMZ SFQSFTFOUT UIF
FBTF PG HFUUJOH GSPN QPJOU " UP TPNF PUIFS QPJOU # FH
-FWJOTPO BOE ,SJ[FL
*O UIBU WJFX
BDDFTT JT BCPVU CFJOH QMBDFT BOE EPJOH UIJOHTJU JT BCPVU UIF WBMVF PG
PCUBJOJOH UIF PQQPSUVOJUJFT BU #XIFSF NPCJMJUZ JT BCPVU UIF DPTU PG EPJOH TP "DDFTT
JT B DPNNPEJUZ NPCJMJUZ JT JUT VOJU QSJDF
8IFO #SVFHNBOO BSHVFT UIBU 4NBSU (SPXUI
BOE SFMBUFE QPMJDZ TDIFNFT BJNFE
BU DVSCJOH UIF FYDFTTFT PG TQSBXM
XJMM SFEVDF BDDFTTJCJMJUZ
* VOEFSTUBOE IJN UP NFBO
UIBU BOUJDBS QPMJDJFT NBZ SFEVDF CPUI NPCJMJUZ
CZ SBJTJOH UIF DPTU PG DBS VTF
BOE
BDDFTTJCJMJUZ
CZ SFTUSJDUJOH UIF USBWFM PQUJPOT DBST PGUFO QSPWJEF
ɨFTF BSF JNQPSUBOU QPJOUT
BOE * NPTUMZ BHSFF .BOZ DSJUJDT PG UIF TPDJBM DPTUT
PG BVUPNPCJMFT OFHMFDU UP DPOTJEFS UIF NBSLFE CFOFmUT PG NPCJMJUZ PS
NPSF USPVCMF
TPNF TUJMM
IPX UIPTF CFOFmUT BOE DPTUT BSF EJTUSJCVUFE ɨFTF DSJUJRVFT MBUFMZ UBLF UIF
GPSN PG QSPNPUJOH BDDFTTJCJMJUZ BT B USBOTQPSUBUJPO QFSGPSNBODF DSJUFSJPO PWFS UIF USB
EJUJPOBM POF PG NPCJMJUZ ɨFSF JT EJTBHSFFNFOU PWFS XIFUIFS NPSF PG POF DBO CF IBE
XJUIPVU MFTT PG UIF PUIFSJG UIFSF JT BO BDDFTTJCJMJUZNPCJMJUZ FċDJFODZ GSPOUJFS
TP UP
TQFBLCVU JU JT FBTZ UP JNBHJOF XIFSF MFTT PG CPUI NJHIU IBWF TJHOJmDBOU OFHBUJWF DPO
TFRVFODFT $SBOF
WBO )FOHFM
BOE 4DIXFJU[FS
'VSUIFS
FWFO XIFSF DPODFSUFE
USBOTQPSUBUJPOMBOE VTF TUSBUFHJFT TVDDFTTGVMMZ QSPNPUF BDDFTT
UIPTF EJTBEWBOUBHFE CZ
IJHIFS DBS DPTUT NBZ OPU CF UIPTF CFOFmUJOH GSPN HSFBUFS BDDFTTJCJMJUZ UP QBSUJDVMBS
QMBDFT &JUIFS XBZ
#SVFHNBOO GBJMT UP EJTTFDU UIFTF EJĊFSFODFT JO B SJHPSPVT NBOOFS
ɨJT JT OPU UP TBZ EPJOH TP JT OFDFTTBSZ
KVTU UIBU UIF JTTVFT BSF PUIFSXJTF DPOGPVOEFE
1VU BOPUIFS XBZ
UIPVHI TVCVSCBOJ[BUJPO JT DPNNPOMZ CMBNFE
JNQMJDJUMZ PS FY
QMJDJUMZ
GPS XPSTFOJOH UIF DJSDVNTUBODFT PG UIF VSCBO QPPS
JU JT IBSE UP JNBHJOF IPX
QPMJDJFT UIBU JO TPNF NBOOFS MJNJU UIFJS BVUPNPCJMJUZ
BOE UIVT BDDFTT UP XPSL BOE
PUIFS BNFOJUJFT
DPVME QPTTJCMZ IFMQ :FU JEFOUJGZJOH UIF XJOOFST BOE MPTFST VOEFS EJG
GFSFOU VSCBO GPSNUSBOTQPSUBUJPO TDFOBSJPT
B UPQJD #SVFHNBOO BMTP OFHMFDUT
JT XPF
GVMMZ VOEFSTUVEJFE
+ĠĦģğĒĝ Ġė 5ģĒğĤġĠģĥ Ēğĕ -Ēğĕ 6ĤĖ ǺǺ
*G #SVFHNBOO PWFSTJNQMJmFT CPUI TQSBXM BOE JUT DSJUJDT JO PSEFS UP GPDVT PVS BU
UFOUJPO PO IJT DFOUSBM UIFTJT UIBU TVCVSCBOJ[BUJPO JT VOEFSBQQSFDJBUFE
IJT QPJOU JT XFMM
UBLFO )PXFWFS
DVUUJOH UIPTF DPSOFST JOWJUFT IJT PXO QSJNBSZ PCKFDUJPO
UIBU MPHJD
BOE FWJEFODF XIJDI EPFT OPU OFBUMZ mU UIF TUPSZ JT CFJOH QVSQPTFGVMMZ EJTSFHBSEFE *U JT
OP TNBMM JSPOZ UIBU B NPSF FWFOIBOEFE BOE OVBODFE USFBUNFOU XPVME HFU IJN XIFSF
IF XBOUT UP HP UIBU NVDI GBTUFS BOE TBGFS
3FGFSFODFT
#PBSOFU
. BOE 3 $SBOF
5SBWFM CZ EFTJHO DzF JOnVFODF PG VSCBO GPSN PO
USBWFM 0YGPSE
#SVFDLOFS
+
6SCBO TQSBXM %JBHOPTJT BOE SFNFEJFT *OUFSOBUJPOBM 3FHJPOBM
4DJFODF 3FWJFX
#SVFHNBOO
3
4QSBXM " DPNQBDU IJTUPSZ $IJDBHP
4QSBXM BOE BDDFTTJCJMJUZ +PVSOBM PG 5SBOTQPSU BOE -BOE 6TF *O UIJT JTTVF
$SBOF
3
4NBSU HSPXUI JO UISFF FBTZ QJFDFT " EFDPOTUSVDUJPO 6$-" XPSL
JOH QBQFS
$SBOF
3
% WBO )FOHFM
BOE - 4DIXFJU[FS
" OPUF PO TVQQMZ WFSTVT EFNBOE
JO USBWFM BDDFTT 6$-" XPSLJOH QBQFS
'BJOTUFJO
4
1MBOOJOH BOE UIF KVTU DJUZ *O F B 1FUFS .BSDVTF
FE
4FBSDIJOH
GPS UIF KVTU DJUZ 5BZMPS BOE 'SBODJT
(MBFTFS
& BOE . ,BIO
4QSBXM BOE VSCBO HSPXUI *O 7 )FOEFSTPO BOE
+' ɨJTTF
FET
DzF IBOECPPL PG SFHJPOBM BOE VSCBO FDPOPNJDT
WPMVNF /PSUI
)PMMBOE
)BCFSNBT
+
USBOTMBUFE
DzF TUSVDUVSBM USBOTGPSNBUJPO PG UIF QVCMJD TQIFSF
"O JORVJSZ JOUP B DBUFHPSZ PG CPVSHFPJT TPDJFUZ .*5 1SFTT
)BSEJO
(
ɨF USBHFEZ PG UIF DPNNPOT 4DJFODF
)FBMFZ
1
$PMMBCPSBUJWF QMBOOJOH 4IBQJOH QMBDFT JO GSBHNFOUFE TPDJFUJFT
.BD.JMMBO
-FWJOF
+
;POFE PVU 3FHVMBUJPO
NBSLFUT
BOE DIPJDFT JO USBOTQPSUBUJPO BOE
NFUSPQPMJUBO MBOE VTF 3FTPVSDFT GPS UIF 'VUVSF
-FWJOTPO
% BOE , ,SJ[FL
FET
"DDFTT UP EFTUJOBUJPOT &MTFWJFS
1FOEBMM
3 BOE + $BSSVUIFST
%PFT EFOTJUZ FYBDFSCBUF JODPNF TFHSFHBUJPO
FWJEFODF GSPN 64 NFUSPQPMJUBO BSFBT
UP )PVTJOH 1PMJDZ %FCBUF
o
1JHPV
"
DzF FDPOPNJDT PG XFMGBSF .BD.JMMBO
1VUOBN
4
#PXMJOH BMPOF DzF DPMMBQTF BOE SFWJWBM PG "NFSJDBO DPNNVOJUZ
4JNPO 4DIVTUFS
4NBMM
,
6SCBO TQSBXM " OPOEJBHOPTJT PG SFBM QSPCMFNT *O .FUSPQPMJUBO
EFWFMPQNFOU QBUUFSOT
QQ o -JODPMO *OTUJUVUF PG -BOE 1PMJDZ
$PVOUFSQPJOU "DDFTTJCJMJUZ BOE TQSBXM
8IFFMFS
$
6SCBO EFDFOUSBMJ[BUJPO BOE JODPNF JOFRVBMJUZ *T TQSBXM BTTPDJ
BUFE XJUI SJTJOH JODPNF TFHSFHBUJPO BDSPTT OFJHICPSIPPET 'FEFSBM 3FTFSWF #BOL PG
4U -PVJT XPSLJOH QBQFS "
8PMG
$
.BSLFUT PS HPWFSONFOUT $IPPTJOH CFUXFFO JNQFSGFDU BMUFSOBUJWFT .*5
1SFTT