Consequences of Concurrent Delay On Construction Projects
Consequences of Concurrent Delay On Construction Projects
8
9ÿ7ÿ
78
8ÿ
ÿ78ÿ
789
78ÿ7
9
!"#$%&
'ÿ)
*"+&,-.%,$"+ÿ/01$&"-2ÿ3ÿ4$&#.,5&
'ÿ)
*"+&,-.%,$"+ÿ0$&#.,5&
6789:;<:8=:9ÿ7?ÿ=78=<@@:8AÿB:CDEÿ78
=789A@<=AF78ÿG@7H:=A9
I+JK$&LÿM+0ÿN%",,$&Lÿ%".-,&ÿLM15ÿ,MO5+ÿMÿ0$PP5-5+,ÿM##-"M%Lÿ,"ÿ0$&#.,5&ÿMQ".,ÿ05KM2&ÿ$+ÿ%"+&,-.%,$"+
#-"R5%,&ÿS$,LÿT"-5ÿ,LM+ÿ"+5ÿ%M.&5UÿV5%5+,ÿ%M&5&ÿLM15ÿ+",ÿ-5&.K,50ÿ$+ÿMÿ.+$P$50ÿM##-"M%LU
*"+&,-.%,$"+ÿ0$&#.,5&
*"+&,-.%,$"+ÿ/01$&"-2ÿ3ÿ4$&#.,5&
W+P-M&,-.%,.-5
XY
I.-"#5
Z[\]ÿ_`\abÿcd]ÿed]fÿ̀gadfbaÿ\hÿi`ejÿklmn
!L5ÿ,5-Tÿo%"+%.--5+,ÿ05KM2oÿ$&ÿ.&50ÿ$+ÿ%$-%.T&,M+%5&ÿSL5-5ÿMÿ#5-$"0ÿ"Pÿ05KM2ÿ,"ÿ,L5ÿ%"T#K5,$"+ÿ"PÿM
#-"R5%,ÿ$&ÿ%M.&50ÿQ2ÿ,S"ÿ"-ÿT"-5ÿPM%,"-&pÿ"+5ÿ"PÿSL$%Lÿ$&ÿ,L5ÿ%"+,-M%,"-q&ÿ-5&#"+&$Q$K$,2ÿM+0ÿ"+5ÿ"P
SL$%Lÿ$&ÿ,L5ÿ5T#K"25-q&ÿ-5&#"+&$Q$K$,2UÿW+ÿ#-M%,$%5pÿ,L5ÿ#L-M&5ÿ$&ÿT"-5ÿ"P,5+ÿ.&50ÿ,"ÿ05&%-$Q5ÿ,L5
&$,.M,$"+ÿSL5-5ÿ,L5ÿ%"T#5,$+Jÿ515+,&ÿ"%%.-ÿM,ÿ0$PP5-5+,ÿ,$T5&ÿQ.,ÿ,L5$-ÿ05KM2$+Jÿ5PP5%,&ÿ"+ÿ,L5ÿS"-O
M-5ÿP5K,ÿM,ÿ,L5ÿ&MT5ÿ,$T5U
W+ÿI+JK$&LÿKMSpÿ,L5ÿJ5+5-MKK2ÿM%%5#,50ÿ05P$+$,$"+ÿSM&ÿ%"$+50ÿQ2ÿr"L+ÿsM--$+ÿt*ÿ$+ÿMÿ#M#5-ÿ#-"0.%50
P"-ÿ,L5ÿN"%$5,2ÿ"Pÿ*"+&,-.%,$"+ÿuMSÿvN*uwÿ$+ÿxyyxpÿM+0ÿ-5z.$-5&ÿo,S"ÿ"-ÿT"-5ÿ5PP5%,$15ÿ%M.&5&ÿ"Pÿ05KM2
SL$%LÿM-5ÿ"PÿM##-"{$TM,5K2ÿ5z.MKÿ%M.&M,$15ÿ#",5+%2oUÿ|L$K5ÿo,-.5oÿ%"+%.--5+%2ÿ$+ÿ,L$&ÿ&5+&5ÿ$&ÿ15-2
-M-5}ÿ,L5ÿ$&&.5ÿ"Pÿ%"+%.--5+,ÿ05KM2ÿ-5#5M,50K2ÿ-M$&5&ÿ$,&ÿL5M0ÿ#-"R5%,ÿMP,5-ÿ#-"R5%,pÿM+0ÿLM&ÿQ55+ÿ,L5
&.QR5%,ÿ"PÿT.%Lÿ%"TT5+,ÿQ2ÿQ",LÿR.0J5&ÿM+0ÿ%"+&,-.%,$"+ÿKMSÿ%"TT5+,M,"-&U
W,ÿS$KKÿ"P,5+ÿQ5ÿ,L5ÿ%M&5ÿ,LM,pÿ,L-".JLÿMÿPM%,.MKÿM+MK2&$&ÿ"Pÿ,L5ÿ0M2ÿ,"ÿ0M2ÿ#-"J-5&&$"+ÿ"PÿMÿ#-"R5%,p
515+,&ÿSL$%LÿS5-5ÿ"-$J$+MKK2ÿ,L".JL,ÿ,"ÿQ5ÿ%"+%.--5+,ÿM%,.MKK2ÿM-5ÿ+",ÿM+0pÿSL5-5ÿ,L52ÿM-5pÿP-5z.5+,K2
"+5ÿ$&ÿ&L"S+ÿ,"ÿQ5ÿ"PÿT"-5ÿ&$J+$P$%M+,ÿo%M.&M,$15ÿ#",5+%2oÿ,L5+ÿ,L5ÿ",L5-UÿW+ÿ,L5&5ÿ%M&5&pÿM-J.T5+,&
MQ".,ÿ%"+%.--5+%2ÿS$KKÿ"P,5+ÿPMKKÿMSM2ÿSL5+ÿ,L5ÿPM%,&ÿM-5ÿ5{MT$+50ÿM&ÿ$,ÿS$KKÿQ5ÿ&L"S+ÿ,LM,ÿ,L5-5ÿ$&
M%,.MKK2ÿ"+K2ÿ"+5ÿ,-.5ÿ%M.&5ÿ"Pÿ05KM2U
~ÿÿ
ÿ
ÿÿ
!L5ÿK5M0$+JÿI+JK$&LÿKMSÿ%M&5&ÿ"+ÿ%"+%.--5+%2ÿ0M,5ÿQM%Oÿ,"ÿ,L5ÿKM,5ÿy&ÿM+0ÿ5M-K2ÿxyyy&Uÿ!L5
M##-"M%LÿM0"#,50ÿ$+ÿ,L5TÿLM&ÿQ55+ÿ05#M-,50ÿP-"Tÿ$+ÿN%",KM+0pÿP"KK"S$+JÿSL$%Lÿ$,ÿSM&ÿ.+%K5M-ÿP"-ÿM
&L"-,ÿ,$T5ÿSL5,L5-ÿMÿ&$T$KM-ÿM##-"M%LÿS".K0ÿQ5ÿP"KK"S50ÿ&".,Lÿ"Pÿ,L5ÿQ"-05-U
9227
72
827
92
789
78979
92
789
789
92
789
8
97
78
8
78
789
787
92 02
012321405 6789
8
9ÿ7ÿ
78
8ÿ
ÿ78ÿ
789
78ÿ7
9
!"#$ÿ"&ÿ$'(ÿ)(*+,-.ÿ/*#(#ÿ0()*$(+ÿ$"ÿ/"-$0*/$#ÿ1#,-.ÿ2",-$ÿ3"-$0*/$#ÿ40,51-*)ÿ62347ÿ#$*-+*0+ÿ&"08
/"-$0*/$#ÿ"0ÿ#,8,)*0ÿ90":,#,"-#ÿ0()*$,-.ÿ$"ÿ/"89)($,"-ÿ*-+ÿ(;$(-#,"-#ÿ"&ÿ$,8(<
=ÿ>???ÿ/*#(ÿ,-:"):,-.ÿ@(-0AÿB""$ÿ3"-#$01/$,"-ÿ*-+ÿ$'(ÿ!*)8*,#"-ÿ'"$()ÿ,-ÿ!*-/'(#$(0ÿC*#ÿ$'(
)(*+,-.ÿ/*#(ÿ1-+(0ÿD-.),#'ÿ)*Cÿ&"0ÿ8*-AÿA(*0#Eÿ*-+ÿ,#ÿ$'(ÿ/*#(ÿ$'*$ÿC*#ÿ(&&(/$,:()Aÿ/'*))(-.(+ÿ,-ÿ$'(
F/"$$,#'ÿ/"10$#<ÿG-ÿ$'(ÿ/*#(ÿ!0ÿ21#$,/(ÿHA#"-ÿ01)(+ÿ$'*$ÿ*ÿ/"-$0*/$"0ÿC*#ÿ(-$,$)(+ÿ$"ÿ*-ÿ(;$(-#,"-ÿ"&
$,8(ÿ&"0ÿ$'(ÿ9(0,"+ÿ"&ÿ+()*Aÿ/*1#(+ÿ5Aÿ*ÿI0()(:*-$Iÿ(:(-$ÿI-"$C,$'#$*-+,-.ÿ$'(ÿ/"-/100(-$ÿ(&&(/$ÿ"&ÿ$'(
"$'(0ÿ(:(-$I<
=#ÿ*-ÿ(;*89)(Eÿ$'(ÿJ1+.(ÿ0(&(00(+ÿ$"ÿ*ÿ'A9"$'($,/*)ÿ#/(-*0,"ÿ,-ÿC',/'ÿ-"ÿC"0KÿC*#ÿ9"##,5)(ÿ"-ÿ$'(ÿ#,$(
&"0ÿ*ÿC((Kÿ5(/*1#(ÿ"&ÿI(;/(9$,"-*))Aÿ,-/)(8(-$ÿC(*$'(0Iÿ6*ÿI0()(:*-$ÿ(:(-$I7Eÿ51$ÿ*)#"ÿ5(/*1#(ÿ$'(
/"-$0*/$"0ÿ'*+ÿ*ÿ)*5"10ÿ#'"0$*.(ÿ6-"$ÿ*ÿI0()(:*-$ÿ(:(-$I7<ÿ=##18,-.ÿ$'(ÿ&*,)10(ÿ$"ÿC"0Kÿ+10,-.ÿ$'*$
C((KÿC*#ÿ),K()Aÿ$"ÿ+()*Aÿ$'(ÿC"0K#ÿ5(A"-+ÿ$'(ÿ/"-$0*/$1*)ÿ/"89)($,"-ÿ+*$(ÿ5Aÿ"-(ÿC((KEÿ*-ÿ(;$(-#,"-
"&ÿ$,8(ÿ#'"1)+ÿ5(ÿ.0*-$(+ÿ0(.*0+)(##ÿ"&ÿ$'(ÿ&*/$ÿ$'*$ÿ$'(ÿ+()*AÿC"1)+ÿ'*:(ÿ"//100(+ÿ,-ÿ*-Aÿ(:(-$ÿ+1(ÿ$"
$'(ÿ)*5"10ÿ#'"0$*.(<
4'(ÿ(&&(/$ÿ"&ÿ$',#ÿ/*#(ÿC*#ÿ$'*$ÿ90":,+,-.ÿ"-(ÿ"&ÿ$'(ÿ/"-/100(-$ÿ/*1#(#ÿ"&ÿ$'(ÿ+()*AÿC*#ÿ*$ÿ$'(
(89)"A(0L#ÿ0,#KEÿ$'(ÿ/"-$0*/$"0ÿ0(/(,:(+ÿ*ÿ&1))ÿ(;$(-#,"-ÿ"&ÿ$,8(ÿ&"0ÿ$'(ÿC'")(ÿ9(0,"+ÿ"&ÿ+()*AÿMÿ(:(-
$'"1.'ÿ$'*$ÿ+()*AÿC*#ÿ/*1#(+ÿ,-ÿ9*0$ÿ5Aÿ8*$$(0#ÿ&"0ÿC',/'ÿ$'(ÿ/"-$0*/$"0ÿC*#ÿ,$#()&ÿ0(#9"-#,5)(<
G-ÿ*ÿNOOOÿ/*#(ÿ,-:"):,-.ÿP"A*)ÿB0"89$"-ÿ@"#9,$*)ÿQ@Fÿ401#$ÿ*-+ÿR0(+(0,/Kÿ@*88"-+ÿ*-+ÿ"$'(0#E
21+.(ÿF(A8"10ÿ/"88(-$(+ÿ$'*$ÿ$'(ÿ01)(ÿ,-ÿ$'(ÿ!*)8*,#"-ÿ/*#(ÿ#'"1)+ÿ-"$ÿ*99)Aÿ$"ÿI*ÿ#,$1*$,"-ÿ,-
C',/'EÿC"0Kÿ*)0(*+Aÿ5(,-.ÿ+()*A(+ÿ<<<ÿ*-ÿ(:(-$ÿ"//10#ÿC',/'ÿ,#ÿ*ÿ0()(:*-$ÿ(:(-$ÿ*-+ÿC',/'Eÿ'*+ÿ$'(
/"-$0*/$"0ÿ-"$ÿ5((-ÿ+()*A(+ÿC"1)+ÿ'*:(ÿ/*1#(+ÿ',8ÿ$"ÿ5(ÿ+()*A(+Eÿ51$ÿC',/'ÿ,-ÿ&*/$ÿ5Aÿ0(*#"-ÿ"&ÿ$'(
(;,#$,-.ÿ+()*Aÿ8*+(ÿ-"ÿ+,&&(0(-/(I<
21+.(ÿF(A8"10L#ÿ*-*)A#,#ÿ'*#ÿ/"8(ÿ,-ÿ&"0ÿ/0,$,/,#8ÿ&0"8ÿ/"88(-$*$"0#Eÿ*-+ÿC*#ÿ0(J(/$(+ÿ5Aÿ$'(
F/"$$,#'ÿ/"10$#ÿ,-ÿ*ÿ/*#(ÿ,-:"):,-.ÿ3,$AÿG--<ÿ@(ÿ&*:"10(+ÿ*ÿ:(0Aÿ-*00"Cÿ+(&,-,$,"-ÿ"&ÿ/"-/100(-/AÿM
(##(-$,*))AEÿI$01(Iÿ/"-/100(-/AÿC'(0(ÿ$'(ÿ$C"ÿ/"89($,-.ÿ(:(-$#ÿ#$*0$ÿ*-+ÿ&,-,#'ÿ*$ÿ$'(ÿ#*8(ÿ$,8(<
21+.(ÿF(A8"10L#ÿ*-*)A#,#ÿ,#ÿ.(-(0*))Aÿ/"-#,+(0(+ÿ$"ÿ5(ÿ$""ÿ-*00"Cÿ*-+ÿ'*#ÿ-"Cÿ)*0.()Aÿ5((-ÿ)(&$
5(',-+<
STUÿWXYUÿZX[\ÿ]W^_ZX`a
G-ÿ*ÿNO>Oÿ/*#(ÿ,-:"):,-.ÿ3,$AÿG--ÿ*-+ÿF'(9'(0+ÿ3"-#$01/$,"-ÿ$'(ÿF/"$$,#'ÿ/"10$#ÿ&"1-+ÿ$'*$
*99"0$,"-8(-$ÿ5($C((-ÿ$'(ÿ/"89($,-.ÿ/*1#(#ÿ8,.'$ÿ5(ÿ*990"90,*$(ÿ,-ÿ/*#(#ÿ"&ÿ/"-/100(-$ÿ+()*A<ÿ4'(
/*#(ÿ/"-/(0-(+ÿ/)*,8#ÿ&"0ÿ(;$(-#,"-ÿ"&ÿ$,8(ÿ1-+(0ÿ$'(ÿ>?bOÿ234ÿ#$*-+*0+ÿ&"08ÿ51,)+,-.ÿ/"-$0*/$ÿ5A
F'(9'(0+Eÿ$'(ÿ/"-$0*/$"0<
=$ÿ&,0#$ÿ,-#$*-/(Eÿc"0+ÿH0188"-+ÿd"1-.ÿ/"-/)1+(+ÿ$'*$ÿ$'(ÿ$*#Kÿ"&ÿ$'(ÿ+(/,#,"-ÿ8*K(0ÿ1-+(0ÿ/)*1#(
Neÿ"&ÿ$'(ÿ234ÿ/"-$0*/$ÿC*#ÿ$"ÿ8*K(ÿ*ÿIJ1+.(8(-$Iÿ*-+Eÿ1)$,8*$()AEÿ*00,:(ÿ*$ÿ*ÿI&*,0ÿ*-+ÿ0(*#"-*5)(I
+(/,#,"-ÿ"-ÿ*-ÿ(;$(-#,"-ÿ"&ÿ$,8(<ÿ4'(ÿ/"10$ÿ+(/,+(+ÿ$'*$ÿC'(0(ÿ$'(0(ÿC*#ÿ/"-/100(-/AEÿ,00(#9(/$,:(ÿ"&
C'(-ÿ$'(ÿ(:(-$#ÿ5(.*-ÿ"0ÿ(-+(+Eÿ,-ÿ$'(ÿ*5#(-/(ÿ"&ÿ"-(ÿ(:(-$ÿ5(,-.ÿI+"8,-*-$Iÿ*ÿ&*,0ÿ*-+ÿ0(*#"-*5)(
"1$/"8(ÿ8*Aÿ,-:"):(ÿ*-ÿ*99"0$,"-8(-$ÿ(;(0/,#(<
3,$AÿG--ÿ*99(*)(+Eÿ*-+ÿ$'(ÿ*99(*)ÿ/"10$ÿ0(J(/$(+ÿ$'(ÿ*99(*)<ÿ@*:,-.ÿ0(:,(C(+ÿ$'(ÿ*1$'"0,$,(#ÿ*-+ÿ$'(
&,0#$ÿ,-#$*-/(ÿ/"10$L#ÿ*-*)A#,#Eÿ$'(ÿ/"10$ÿ#*,+f
gh'(0(ÿ*ÿ#,$1*$,"-ÿ(;,#$#ÿ,-ÿC',/'ÿ$C"ÿ/*1#(#ÿ*0(ÿ"9(0*$,:(Eÿ"-(ÿ5(,-.ÿ*ÿ0()(:*-$ÿ(:(-$ÿ*-+ÿ$'(ÿ"$'(0
#"8(ÿ"$'(0ÿ(:(-$ÿ&"0ÿC',/'ÿ$'(ÿ/"-$0*/$"0ÿ,#ÿ$"ÿ5(ÿ$*K(-ÿ$"ÿ5(ÿ0(#9"-#,5)(Eÿ*-+ÿ-(,$'(0ÿ"&ÿC',/'ÿ/"1)+
5(ÿ+(#/0,5(+ÿ*#ÿ$'(ÿ+"8,-*-$ÿ/*1#(Eÿ$'(ÿ/)*,8ÿ&"0ÿ(;$(-#,"-ÿ"&ÿ$,8(ÿC,))ÿ-"$ÿ-(/(##*0,)Aÿ&*,)<ÿG-ÿ#1/'ÿ*
#,$1*$,"-EÿC',/'ÿ/"1)+Eÿ*#ÿ*ÿ8*$$(0ÿ"&ÿ)*-.1*.(Eÿ5(ÿ+(#/0,5(+ÿ*#ÿ"-(ÿ"&ÿ/"-/100(-$ÿ/*1#(#Eÿ,-ÿ*ÿ50"*+
#(-#(Eÿ,$ÿC,))ÿ5(ÿ"9(-ÿ$"ÿ$'(ÿ+(/,#,"-M8*K(0EÿC'($'(0ÿ$'(ÿ*0/',$(/$Eÿ"0ÿ"$'(0ÿ$0,51-*)Eÿ*990"*/',-.ÿ$'(
9227
72
827
92
789
78979
92
789
789
92
789
8
97
78
8
78
789
787
92 12
012321405 6789
8
9ÿ7ÿ
78
8ÿ
ÿ78ÿ
789
78ÿ7
9
"##$%ÿ"'ÿ(ÿ)("*ÿ('+ÿ*%(#,'(-.%ÿ/(01ÿ2,ÿ(33,*2",'ÿ24%ÿ+%.(0ÿ"'ÿ24%ÿ5,63.%2",'ÿ,)ÿ24%ÿ/,*7#ÿ,55(#",'%+
24%*%-0ÿ(#ÿ-%2/%%'ÿ24%ÿ*%.%8('2ÿ%8%'2ÿ('+ÿ24%ÿ,24%*ÿ%8%'29:
;4%ÿ"+%(ÿ24(2ÿ('ÿ(*54"2%521ÿ(#ÿ+%5"#",'ÿ6(7%*1ÿ5,$.+ÿ(33,*2",'ÿ*%#3,'#"-"."20ÿ),*ÿ+%.(0ÿ-%2/%%'
5,63%2"'<ÿ5($#%#ÿ/(#ÿ/"+%.0ÿ#%%'ÿ(#ÿ(ÿ+%3(*2$*%ÿ)*,6ÿ/4(2ÿ4(+ÿ3*%8",$#.0ÿ-%%'ÿ5,'#"+%*%+ÿ('
%#2(-."#4%+ÿ3*"'5"3.%=ÿ24(2ÿ24%ÿ5,'2*(52,*ÿ"#ÿ%'2"2.%+ÿ2,ÿ('ÿ%>2%'#",'ÿ,)ÿ2"6%ÿ),*ÿ24%ÿ/4,.%ÿ,)ÿ24%
5,'5$**%'2ÿ+%.(0ÿ3%*",+1ÿ*%<(*+.%##ÿ,)ÿ"2#ÿ,/'ÿ*%#3,'#"-"."20ÿ),*ÿ('0ÿ,)ÿ24%ÿ+%.(09ÿ?,/%8%*1ÿ24%
+%5"#",'ÿ())"*6%+ÿ24%ÿ(33*,(54ÿ2(7%'ÿ3*%8",$#.0ÿ-0ÿ24%ÿ@5,22"#4ÿ5,$*2#1ÿ"'ÿ24%ÿABBCÿD("'<
E('(<%6%'2ÿF@5,2.('+GÿD2+ÿ8ÿH,4'ÿI,0.%ÿJ,'#2*$52",'ÿD2+ÿ5(#%9
KLMÿOPQRLSTPURLÿVWXWVM
Y,..,/"'<ÿ24%ÿJ"20ÿZ''ÿ5(#%1ÿ24%*%ÿ/(#ÿ(ÿ.,2ÿ,)ÿ"'2%*%#2ÿ(#ÿ2,ÿ/4%24%*ÿ24%ÿ['<."#4ÿ5,$*2#ÿ/,$.+ÿ),..,/
24%"*ÿ@5,22"#4ÿ5,$'2%*3(*2#ÿ('+ÿ(+,32ÿ24%ÿ3*"'5"3.%ÿ,)ÿ(33,*2",'6%'2ÿ"'ÿ5(#%#ÿ,)ÿ5,'5$**%'2ÿ+%.(09
E*ÿH$#2"5%ÿ[+/(*+#\@2$(*2ÿ+"+ÿ',2ÿ*%)%*ÿ2,ÿ24%ÿJ"20ÿZ''ÿ5(#%1ÿ,*ÿ2,ÿ(33,*2",'6%'21ÿ"'ÿ4"#ÿ]$+<6%'2ÿ"'
('ÿ['<."#4ÿ+"#3$2%ÿ-%2/%%'ÿI%ÿ^%%*#ÿ_2,#ÿ̀*"<"'ÿZ;ÿ@%*8"5%#1ÿ',2/"24#2('+"'<ÿ24%ÿ)(52ÿ24(2ÿ"2ÿ/(#
+%."8%*%+ÿ(ÿ)%/ÿ6,'24#ÿ()2%*ÿ24%ÿ(33%(.ÿ5,$*2a#ÿ+%5"#",'ÿ"'ÿJ"20ÿZ''9ÿZ'ÿ24"#ÿ5(#%1ÿ-,24ÿ24%ÿ5,'2*(52,*
+%.(0ÿ('+ÿ24%ÿ%63.,0%*ÿ+%.(0ÿ/%*%ÿ5*"2"5(.ÿ('+ÿ,3%*(2%+ÿ5,'5$**%'2.01ÿ"'ÿ24%ÿ#%'#%ÿ24(2ÿ%"24%*ÿ+%.(0
/(#ÿ#$))"5"%'2ÿ,'ÿ"2#ÿ,/'ÿ2,ÿ+%.(0ÿ5,63.%2",'9
;4%ÿ<%'%*(.ÿ*$.%ÿ"'ÿ24%#%ÿ5(#%#1ÿ(55,*+"'<ÿ2,ÿ24%ÿ]$+<%1ÿ/(#ÿ24(2ÿ24%ÿ5,'2*(52,*ÿ/(#ÿ%'2"2.%+ÿ2,ÿ('
%>2%'#",'ÿ,)ÿ2"6%ÿ-$2ÿ5,$.+ÿ',2ÿ*%5,8%*ÿ"'ÿ*%#3%52ÿ,)ÿ24%ÿ.,##ÿ5($#%+ÿ-0ÿ24%ÿ+%.(09ÿ;4"#ÿ/(#ÿ-%5($#%
b',2ÿ,'.0ÿ6$#2ÿ24%ÿ5,'2*(52,*ÿ5,63.%2%ÿ/"24"'ÿ(ÿ*%(#,'(-.%ÿ2"6%ÿ-$2ÿ(.#,ÿ24%ÿ5,'2*(52,*ÿ6$#2ÿ4(8%ÿ(
*%(#,'(-.%ÿ2"6%ÿ/"24"'ÿ/4"54ÿ2,ÿ5,63.%2%b1ÿ4%ÿ#("+9
Z2ÿ24%*%),*%ÿ+"+ÿ',2ÿ6(22%*ÿ")ÿ24%ÿ5,'2*(52,*ÿ/,$.+ÿ4(8%ÿ-%%'ÿ$'(-.%ÿ2,ÿ5,63.%2%ÿ-0ÿ24%ÿ5,'2*(52$(.
5,63.%2",'ÿ+(2%ÿ")ÿ24%*%ÿ4(+ÿ-%%'ÿ',ÿ-*%(54%#ÿ,)ÿ5,'2*(52ÿ-0ÿ24%ÿ%63.,0%*1ÿ-%5($#%ÿ4%ÿ"#ÿ%'2"2.%+ÿ2,
4(8%ÿ24%ÿ2"6%ÿ/"24"'ÿ/4"54ÿ2,ÿ5,63.%2%ÿ/4"54ÿ24%ÿ5,'2*(52ÿ(..,/#ÿ,*ÿ/4"54ÿ24%ÿ%63.,0%*c#ÿ5,'+$52ÿ4(#
6(+%ÿ*%(#,'(-.0ÿ'%5%##(*09
Z'ÿ(ÿABddÿ5(#%ÿ-%2/%%'ÿ_+0(*+ÿ_-$ÿI4(-"ÿ('+ÿ@IÿE(*"'%ÿ@%*8"5%#1ÿE*ÿH$#2"5%ÿ?(6-.%'ÿ%>3*%##.0
*%]%52%+ÿ24%ÿ"+%(ÿ,)ÿ(33,*2",'6%'29ÿY,..,/"'<ÿ24%ÿE(.6("#,'ÿ5(#%1ÿ24%ÿ['<."#4ÿ.(/ÿ(33*,(54ÿ/(#ÿb2,
*%5,<'"#%ÿ24(2ÿ24%ÿ-$".+%*ÿ"#ÿ%'2"2.%+ÿ2,ÿ('ÿ%>2%'#",'ÿ,)ÿ2"6%1ÿ',2ÿ('ÿ(33,*2",'6%'2b9
;4%ÿ5,$*2ÿ,'5%ÿ(<("'ÿ*%]%52%+ÿ24%ÿ"+%(ÿ,)ÿ(33,*2",'6%'2ÿ24%ÿ),..,/"'<ÿ0%(*1ÿ"'ÿ(ÿ+"#3$2%ÿ"'8,.8"'<
e(.2%*ÿD"..0ÿ('+ÿf".%#ÿE(57(09ÿE*ÿH$#2"5%ÿ_7%'4%(+ÿ(52$(..0ÿ+%#5*"-%+ÿ4,/ÿ24%*%ÿ/%*%ÿ2/,ÿ#54,,.#ÿ,)
24,$<42ÿ,'ÿ24%ÿ3,"'2=ÿ24%ÿ['<."#4ÿ('+ÿ24%ÿ@5,22"#4ÿ#54,,.#1ÿ%>%63.")"%+ÿ-0ÿE(.6("#,'ÿ('+ÿJ"20ÿZ''
*%#3%52"8%.09ÿ?,/%8%*1ÿ4%ÿ),$'+ÿ24(2ÿ24"#ÿ/(#ÿ',2ÿ(ÿ5(#%ÿ"'ÿ/4"54ÿ5,'5$**%'2ÿ+%.(0ÿ(33."%+1ÿ6%('"'<
24(2ÿ',24"'<ÿ24(2ÿ4%ÿ#("+ÿ,'ÿ24%ÿ#$-]%52ÿ5('ÿ#2*"52.0ÿ#3%(7"'<ÿ-%ÿ*%."%+ÿ$3,'ÿ"'ÿ)$2$*%ÿ5(#%#9
gMhMiRWPOÿPjÿkllPQRWPOmMORÿWOÿnOopkOV
H,4'ÿE(**"'ÿqJÿ*%2$*'%+ÿ2,ÿ5,'#"+%*"'<ÿ5,'5$**%'50ÿ"'ÿABdAÿ"'ÿ(ÿ),..,/\$3ÿ3(3%*ÿ+%."8%*%+ÿ2,ÿ24%
@JD9ÿZ'ÿ4"#ÿ3(3%*1ÿ4%ÿ('(.0#%+ÿ24%ÿ['<."#4ÿ5,$*2#aÿ*%]%52",'ÿ,)ÿ(33,*2",'6%'2ÿ\ÿ('+ÿ24%"*ÿ5,'2"'$%+
),..,/"'<ÿ,)ÿ24%ÿE(.6("#,'ÿ(33*,(54ÿ\ÿ-0ÿ*%)%*%'5%ÿ2,ÿ24*%%ÿ3*"'5"3.%#9
rstutvwxyvÿ{sxv|x{}t
Z)ÿ24%ÿ%63.,0%*ÿ3*%8%'2#ÿ24%ÿ5,'2*(52,*ÿ)*,6ÿ5,63.%2"'<ÿ,'ÿ2"6%ÿ24%'1ÿ$'.%##ÿ24%ÿ5,'2*(52ÿ%>3*%##%#ÿ(
5,'2*(*0ÿ"'2%'2",'1ÿ24%ÿ%63.,0%*ÿ5('',2ÿ5.("6ÿ."~$"+(2%+ÿ+(6(<%#9ÿ;4%ÿ%>2%'#",'ÿ,)ÿ2"6%ÿ6(54"'%*0
"'ÿ5,'#2*$52",'ÿ5,'2*(52#ÿ"#ÿ+%#"<'%+ÿ2,ÿ,8%*5,6%ÿ24"#ÿa3*%8%'2",'ÿ3*"'5"3.%a1ÿ-0ÿ3%*6"22"'<ÿ24%
%63.,0%*ÿ2,ÿ%>2%'+ÿ24%ÿ2"6%ÿ),*ÿ5,63.%2",'ÿ"'ÿ*%#3%52ÿ,)ÿ+%.(0#ÿ5($#%+ÿ-0ÿ"2#ÿb(52#ÿ,)ÿ3*%8%'2",'b9
9227
72
827
92
789
78979
92
789
789
92
789
8
97
78
8
78
789
787
92 2!
012321405 6789
8
9ÿ7ÿ
78
8ÿ
ÿ78ÿ
789
78ÿ7
9
"##$%&'()ÿ+$ÿ,-%%'(.ÿ+/0ÿ,-12-'3$(ÿ-44%$-#/ÿ&$03ÿ($+ÿ$550(&ÿ+/0ÿ4%060(+'$(ÿ4%'(#'410.ÿ70#-830ÿ+/0
#$(+%-#+$%ÿ)0+3ÿ-ÿ5811ÿ09+0(3'$(ÿ$5ÿ+'20:ÿ"44$%+'$(20(+.ÿ$(ÿ+/0ÿ$+/0%ÿ/-(&.ÿ&$03ÿ$550(&ÿ+/0ÿ4%060(+'$(
4%'(#'410ÿ70#-830ÿ'5ÿ+/0ÿ#$(+%-#+$%ÿ$(1;ÿ)0+3ÿ-(ÿ09+0(3'$(ÿ$5ÿ+'20ÿ5$%ÿ4-%+ÿ$5ÿ+/0ÿ&01-;.ÿ+/0ÿ0241$;0%
3/$81&ÿ)0+ÿ+$ÿ%0#$60%ÿ1'<8'&-+0&ÿ&-2-)03ÿ5$%ÿ+/0ÿ$+/0%ÿ4-%+ÿ=ÿ-(ÿ0550#+'60ÿ#-830ÿ$5ÿ>/'#/ÿ283+ÿ70ÿ+/0
0241$;0%?3ÿ-#+ÿ$5ÿ4%060(+'$(:
@ABCDECÿGDHAICJ
K(ÿ&01-;ÿ#1-'23.ÿ+/0%0ÿ>'11ÿ70ÿ&'%0#+1;ÿ$44$3'()ÿ5'(-(#'-1ÿ#1-'23:ÿK5ÿ+/0ÿ&01-;ÿ'3ÿ#-830&ÿ7;ÿ+/0
#$(+%-#+$%.ÿ+/0ÿ0241$;0%ÿ'3ÿ0(+'+10&ÿ+$ÿ1'<8'&-+0&ÿ&-2-)03:ÿK5ÿ'+ÿ'3ÿ+/0ÿ0241$;0%?3ÿ5-81+.ÿ+/0ÿ#$(+%-#+$%ÿ'3
0(+'+10&ÿ+$ÿ'+3ÿ1$33ÿ-(&L$%ÿ0940(30:ÿM$)'#ÿ&'#+-+03ÿ+/-+ÿ$(1;ÿ$(0ÿ$5ÿ+/030ÿ#$240+'()ÿ#1-'23ÿ#-(ÿ38##00&:
N/'3ÿ'3ÿ3$20+'203ÿ%050%%0&ÿ+$ÿ-3ÿ+/0ÿ?$760%30ÿ4%$7102?:
N/0ÿ-44%$-#/ÿ'(ÿ+/0ÿ,-12-'3$(ÿ#-30ÿ-6$'&3ÿ+/'3ÿ4%$7102ÿ'(ÿ#-303ÿ$5ÿ#$(#8%%0(+ÿ&01-;ÿ'(ÿ+/0ÿ30(30ÿ+/-+
+/0ÿ#$(+%-#+$%ÿ'3ÿ0(+'+10&ÿ+$ÿ+'20.ÿ78+ÿ($+ÿ2$(0;:ÿ"44$%+'$(20(+.ÿ7;ÿ'+3ÿ(-+8%0.ÿ&05'03ÿ+/0ÿ?1$)'#?ÿ$5ÿ+/0
$760%30ÿ4%$7102ÿ7;ÿ-11$>'()ÿ7$+/ÿ#1-'23ÿ+$ÿ38##00&.ÿ-+ÿ10-3+ÿ'(ÿ4-%+:
OPQRÿSHDOÿTUQEURVHW
,-%%'(ÿ-##04+3ÿ+/-+ÿ+/0ÿ,-12-'3$(ÿ-44%$-#/ÿ%0<8'%03ÿ-ÿ%01-9-+'$(ÿ$5ÿ+/0ÿ?78+ÿ5$%?ÿ+03+ÿ$5ÿ#-83-+'$(.
>/'#/ÿ%0<8'%03ÿ-ÿ4-%+;ÿ+$ÿ3/$>ÿ+/-+ÿ'+ÿ'3ÿ2$%0ÿ1'X01;ÿ+/-(ÿ($+ÿ+/-+ÿ+/0ÿ/-%2ÿ38550%0&ÿ>-3ÿ#-830&ÿ7;ÿ-
7%0-#/ÿ$5ÿ&8+;ÿ7;ÿ+/0ÿ$+/0%ÿ4-%+;:ÿY$>060%.ÿ+/-+ÿ+03+ÿ'3ÿ($+ÿ-ÿ/-%&ÿ-(&ÿ5-3+ÿ$(0.ÿ-(&ÿ+/0ÿ#$8%+3ÿ/-60
/'3+$%'#-11;ÿ%0#$)('30&ÿ+/-+ÿ'+ÿ2-;ÿ70ÿ-44%$4%'-+0ÿ+$ÿ%01-9ÿ'+ÿ'(ÿ-44%$4%'-+0ÿ#'%#823+-(#03:
N/0ÿZ83+'5'#-+'$(ÿ5$%ÿ&$'()ÿ3$ÿ'(ÿ#$(#8%%0(#;ÿ#-303ÿ'+ÿ+/-+ÿ'+ÿ'3ÿ(0#033-%;ÿ'(ÿ$%&0%ÿ+$ÿ-6$'&ÿ-ÿ%0381+ÿ+/-+
%8(3ÿ#$(+%-%;ÿ+$ÿ+/0ÿ4-%+'03?ÿ094%033ÿ'(+0(+'$(3ÿ=ÿ+/-+ÿ'3.ÿ+/-+ÿ'(ÿ[\Nÿ#-303ÿ-+ÿ10-3+.ÿ+/0ÿ#$(+%-#+$%ÿ'3
0(+'+10&ÿ+$ÿ-ÿ]5-'%ÿ-(&ÿ%0-3$(-710]ÿ09+0(3'$(ÿ$5ÿ+'20:ÿ,-%%'(ÿ-13$ÿ38))03+3ÿ+/-+ÿ,-12-'3$(ÿ-&$4+3ÿ-ÿ5-'%
-44%$-#/.ÿ-3ÿ+/0ÿ?78+ÿ5$%?ÿ+03+ÿ'3ÿ%01-90&ÿ'(ÿ%01-+'$(ÿ+$ÿ+'20ÿ78+ÿ($+ÿ2$(0;:
,-12-'3$(ÿ%02-'(3ÿ+/0ÿ10-&'()ÿ#-30ÿ1->ÿ-8+/$%'+;ÿ'(ÿ^()1-(&.ÿ-(&ÿ'+3ÿ-44%$-#/ÿ+$ÿ#$(#8%%0(#;
%02-'(3ÿ+/0ÿ)0(0%-1ÿ-44%$-#/ÿ'(ÿ^()1-(&ÿ-(&ÿ_-103`ÿ5811ÿ09+0(3'$(ÿ$5ÿ+'20.ÿ78+ÿ($ÿ0(+'+1020(+ÿ+$ÿ1$33
-(&L$%ÿ0940(30:ÿ"44$%+'$(20(+ÿ'3ÿ$(1;ÿ-6-'1-710ÿ($%+/ÿ$5ÿ+/0ÿ7$%&0%:ÿ,-%%'(?3ÿ&05'('+'$(ÿ$5
#$(#8%%0(#;ÿ5%$2ÿ7-#Xÿ'(ÿabbaÿ-13$ÿ%02-'(3ÿ+/0ÿ)0(0%-11;ÿ-##04+0&ÿ&05'('+'$(ÿ8(&0%ÿ^()1'3/ÿ1->:
N/0ÿ\$8%+ÿ$5ÿ"440-1ÿ#$(5'%20&.ÿ'(ÿc$%+/ÿ,'&1-(&ÿd8'1&'()ÿM+&ÿ6ÿ\;&0(ÿY$203ÿM+&.ÿ+/-+ÿ-ÿ#1-830ÿ'(ÿ-
#$(3+%8#+'$(ÿ#$(+%-#+ÿ>/'#/ÿ-11$#-+0&ÿ+/0ÿ%'3Xÿ$5ÿ#$(#8%%0(+ÿ&01-;3ÿ+$ÿ+/0ÿ#$(+%-#+$%ÿ'3ÿ6-1'&ÿ-(&
0(5$%#0-710:ÿN/0%05$%0.ÿ'(ÿ^()1-(&ÿ-+ÿ10-3+.ÿ+/0ÿ)0(0%-1ÿ-44%$-#/ÿ+$ÿ#$(#8%%0(#;ÿ'3ÿ387Z0#+ÿ+$ÿ+/0
094%033ÿ+0%23ÿ>/'#/ÿ+/0ÿ4-%+'03ÿ/-60ÿ-)%00&:
efghifjÿlfminop
K(5%-3+%8#+8%0
"11ÿ30#+$%3
qnrpiosmitnrÿjtpusifpÿvstjfp
w%-#+'#-1ÿ'241'#-+'$(3ÿ$5ÿ40(-1+;ÿ#1-8303ÿ'(ÿ^()1'3/ÿ1->
"&60%30ÿ)%$8(&ÿ#$(&'+'$(3ÿ'(ÿ+/0ÿx"^
\$(3+%8#+'$(ÿ&'348+03`ÿ#-(ÿKÿ%01;ÿ$(ÿ-(ÿ8(3')(0&ÿ#$(+%-#+y
\$241'-(#0ÿ>'+/ÿ+/0ÿ4%0=-#+'$(ÿ4%$+$#$1ÿ5$%ÿ#$(3+%8#+'$(ÿ-(&ÿ0()'(00%'()ÿ&'348+03
9227
72
827
92
789
78979
92
789
789
92
789
8
97
78
8
78
789
787
92 2!
012321405 6789
8
9ÿ7ÿ
78
8ÿ
ÿ78ÿ
789
78ÿ7
9
!"#$%&'()ÿ+,-ÿ)#-.'/0)'/1ÿ0ÿ$,/()-2$)',/ÿ$,/)-0$)
345675ÿ9:;75<=>5?:;ÿ@?7A=567ÿB6C7
D,E#-/.#/)ÿ0//,2/$#(ÿ/#F)ÿ()#G(ÿ,/ÿ$,.H2()'H&#ÿ$&0II'/1ÿJKÿL#$ÿMJNO
PQRÿ-#G#0&(ÿ0-H')-0),-(SÿS,HT#$)'E')Uÿ0/Iÿ'/)#1-')USÿG#/0&)'#(ÿJVÿL#$ÿMJNO
RW!ÿ$,/)-0$)(ÿ'/ÿX0)0-Yÿ0IE'$#ÿ+,-ÿ$,/)-0$),-(ÿJZÿL#$ÿMJNO
!,2-)ÿ,+ÿQGG#0&ÿ2G",&I(ÿ-'1")ÿ),ÿH#1'/ÿS)-2#ÿE0&2#Sÿ0IT2I'$0)',/ÿJ[ÿ\,EÿMJNO
]'/10G,-#ÿ$,2-)ÿ-#E#-(#(ÿS/0)2-0&ÿT2()'$#SÿH-#0$"ÿ+'/I'/1ÿZJÿ^$)ÿMJNO
_:?;ÿ̀aÿb=5c34C
d66ÿ:;eaÿ5f6ÿ>:;56;5ÿ5f45ÿg4556<7ÿ5:ÿa:=
h4?e:<ÿb=5c34Cÿ5:ÿa:=<ÿ6i4>5ÿ;66@7
d4j6ÿ5f6ÿg:75ÿ=76k=eÿ>:;56;5ÿk:<ÿe456<ÿ<64@?;l
h4?e:<ÿ:=<ÿC66meaÿ6B6C7e6556<ÿ5:ÿa:=<ÿ?;56<6757
n,'/ÿoUÿ^2)pq0r
Q&-#0IUÿ('1/#Iÿ2Gÿ),ÿoUÿ^2)pq0rs
]'1/ÿ'/
t?;76;5ÿ̀47:;7
uiA6<5?76
vwxyzw{ÿ}~{
W0-)/#-
'#rÿG-,+'&#
o,-#ÿ0H,2)ÿW'/(#/)ÿo0(,/(
ÿ!,GU-'1")ÿW'/(#/)ÿo0(,/(ÿqqW