PIONEER RADIO ENGINEER GIVES VIEWS ON POWER

by Nikola Tesla
Previous | Next | TOC
New York Herald Tribune, September 11, 1932

Tesla Says Wireless Waves Are Not Electromagnetic, But Sound In Nature
Holds Space Not Curved—Predicts Power Transmission to Other Planets

by Nikola Tesla

The assumption of the Maxwellian ether was thought necessary to explain the propagation of light
by transverse vibrations, which can only occur in a solid. So fascinating was this theory that even
at present it has many supporters, despite the manifest impossibility of a medium, perfectly mobile
and tenuous to a degree inconceivable, and yet extremely rigid, like steel. As a result some
illusionary ideas have been formed and various phenomena erroneously interpreted. The so-called
Hertz waves are still considered a reality proving that light is electrical in its nature, and also that
the ether is capable of transmitting transverse vibrations of frequencies however low. This view
has become untenable since I showed that the universal medium is a gaseous body in which only
longitudinal pulses can be propagated, involving alternating compressions and expansions similar
to those produced by sound waves in the air. Thus, a wireless transmitter does not emit Hertz
waves which are a myth, but sound waves in the ether, behaving in every respect like those in the
air, except that, owing to the great elastic force and extremely small density of the medium, their
speed is that of light.

Suggested Short Waves Early.

Since waves of this kind are all the more penetrating, the shorter they are, I have urged the experts
engaged in the commercial application of the wireless art to employ very short waves, but for a long
time my suggestions were not heeded. Eventually, though, this was done, and gradually the
wavelengths were reduced to but a few meters. Invariably it was found that these waves, just as
those in the air, follow the curvature of the earth and bend around obstacles, a peculiarity exhibited
to a much lesser degree by transverse vibrations in a solid. Recently, however, ultrashort waves
have been experimented with and the fact that they also have the same property was hailed as a
great discovery, offering the stupendous promise to make wireless transmission infinitely simpler
and cheaper.

It is of interest to know what wireless experts have expected, knowing that waves a few meters long
are transmitted clear to the antipodes. Is there any reason that they would behave radically
different when their length is reduced to about half of one meter?

Waves Go Around World.

As the general knowledge of this subject seems very limited, I may state, that even waves only one
or two millimeters long, which I produced thirty-three years ago, provided that they carry sufficient
energy, can be transmitted around the globe. This is not so much due to refraction and reflection
as to the properties of a gaseous medium and certain peculiar action, which I shall explain some
time in the future. At present it may be sufficient to call attention to an important fact in this
connection, namely, that this bending of the beam projected from reflector does not affect in the
least its behavior in other respects. As regards deflection in a horizontal plane, it acts just as
though it were straight. To be explicit the horizontal deviations are comparatively slight. In a
proposed ultrashort wave transmission, the vertical bending, far from being an advantage, is a
serious drawback, as it increased greatly the liability of disturbances by obstacles at the earth's
surface. The downward deflection always occurs, irrespective of wavelength, and also if the beam
is thrown upward at an angle to the horizontal, and this tendency is, according to my finding, all the
more pronounced the bigger the planet. On a body as large as the sun, it would be impossible to
 project a disturbance of this kind to any considerable distance except along the surface.

It might be inferred that I am alluding to the curvature of space supposed to exist according to the
teachings of relativity, but nothing could be further from my mind. I hold that space cannot be
curved, for the simple reason that it can have no properties. It might as well be said that God has
properties. He has not, but only attributes and these are of our own making. Of properties we can
only speak when dealing with matter filling the space. To say that in the presence of large bodies
space becomes curved, is equivalent to stating that something can act upon nothing. I, for one,
refuse to subscribe to such a view.

Need Radio Channels.

The chief object of employing very short waves is to provide an increased number of channels
required to satisfy the ever-growing demand for wireless appliances. But this is only because the
transmitting and receiving apparatus, as generally employed, is ill-conceived and not well adapted
for selection. The transmitter generates several systems of waves, all of which, except one, are
useless. As a consequence, only an infinitesimal amount of energy reaches the receiver and
dependence is placed on extreme amplification, which can be easily affected by the use of the so-
called three-electrode tubes. This invention has been credited to others, but as a matter of fact, it
was brought out by me in 1892, the principle being described and illustrated in my lecture before
the Franklin Institute and National Electric Light Association. In my original device I put around the
incandescent filament a conducting member, which I called a "sieve." This device is connected to a
wire leading outside of the bulb and serves to modify the stream of particles projected from the
filament according to the charge imparted to it. In this manner a new kind of detector, rectifier and
amplifier was provided. Many forms of tubes on this principle were constructed by me and various
interesting effects obtained by their means shown to visitors in my laboratory from 1893 to 1899,
when I undertook the erection of an experimental world-system wireless plant at Colorado Springs.

During the last thirty-two years these tubes have been made veritable marvels of mechanical
perfection, but while helpful in many ways they have drawn the experts away from the simpler and
much superior arrangement, which I attempted to introduce in 1901. My plans involved the use of a
highly effective and efficient transmitter conveying to any receiver at whatever distance, a relatively
large amount of energy. The receiver is itself a device of elementary simplicity partaking of the
characteristics of the ear, except that it is immensely more sensitive. In such a system resonant
amplification is the only one necessary and the selectivity is so great that any desired number of
separate channels can be provided without going to waves shorter than a few meters.

For this reason, and because of other shortcomings, I do not attach much importance to the
employment of waves, which are now being experimented with. Besides, I am contemplating the
practical use of another principle, which I have discovered and which is almost unlimited in the
number of channels and in the energy three-electrode tubes. This invention has been credited to
others, but as a matter of fact, it was brought out by me in 1892, the principle being transmitted. It
should enable us to obtain many important results heretofore considered impossible. With the
knowledge of the facts before me, I do not think it hazardous to predict that we will be enabled to
illuminate the whole sky at night and that eventually we will flash power in virtually unlimited
amounts to planets. It would not surprise me at all if an experiment to transmit thousands of
horsepower to the moon by this new method were made in a few years from now.