Guidelines For The Approvability of Towing Vessels
Guidelines For The Approvability of Towing Vessels
OF TOWING VESSELS
No: 0021/NDI
PREFACE
This document has been drawn with care to address what are likely to be the main
concerns based on the experience of the Noble Denton organisation. This should not,
however, be taken to mean that this document deals comprehensively with all of the
concerns which will need to be addressed or even, where a particular matter is
addressed, that this document sets out the definitive view of the organisation for all
situations. In using this document, it should be treated as giving guidelines for sound
and prudent practice on which our advice should be based, but these guidelines
should be reviewed in each particular case by the responsible person in each project
to ensure that the particular circumstances of that project are addressed in a way
which is adequate and appropriate to ensure that the overall advice given is sound
and comprehensive.
CONTENTS
SECTION PAGE NO.
1 INTRODUCTION 4
1.1 Background 4
1.2 Towing Vessels Approvability Scheme 4
1.3 Summary of Requirements 4
1.4 Other Noble Denton Guidelines 4
1.5 Bollard Pull and Equipment Tests 4
2 DEFINITIONS 5
3 TOWING VESSEL CATEGORIES 7
3.1 Ocean-Going Salvage Tug (ST) 7
3.2 Unrestricted Towages (U) 7
3.3 Restricted Towages (RI) 7
3.4 Benign Area Towages (R2) 8
3.5 Restricted Benign Area Towages (R3) 8
3.6 Limited Duration and Short Distance Towages 8
4 DOCUMENTATION 9
4.1 General Specification 9
4.2 General Arrangement Plans 9
4.3 Towing/Anchor-Handling Winches 9
4.4 Towing Equipment 9
4.5 Certificates 10
4.6 Salvage Equipment 10
5 TOWING EQUIPMENT 11
5.1 Ocean-Going Salvage Tugs (ST) 11
5.2 Unrestricted Towages (U) 12
5.3 Restricted Towages (RI) 12
5.4 Benign Area Towages (R2) 12
5.5 Restricted Benign Area Towages (R3) 13
5.6 All Entered Vessels 13
6 TOWING WINCH 15
7 TOWING WIRE PROTECTION AND CONTROL 16
7.1 Protectors 16
7.2 Tow Bars, Cargo Protection Rail, Bulwarks, Stern Rail, Tailgate and Stern Roller16
7.3 Adjustable Gogwire System 16
7.4 Fixed Gogwire System 16
7.5 Towing Pod 16
8 STABILITY 17
9 MANNING AND ACCOMMODATION 17
10 SEAKEEPING 18
11 ADDITIONAL EQUIPMENT FOR SALVAGE TUGS (ST) 19
APPENDICES 20
Summary of Requirements 21
Bollard Pull Tests 23
Towing Equipment Tests 26
1 INTRODUCTION
1.1 Background
1.1.1 These guidelines are the basis for the approval of towing vessels for specific
towages.
1.1.2 The guidelines are also the standard for owners, charterers, managers or builders of
towing vessels when they seek entry of a vessel into the Noble Denton Towing
Vessel Approvability Scheme.
1.1.3 These guidelines include a category for ocean-going salvage tugs.
2 DEFINITIONS
Approved Bollard Pull
For entry into the Noble Denton Towing Vessel Approvability Scheme vessels shall
normally be tested for bollard pull every 10 years.
The Approved Bollard Pull is the bollard pull which Noble Denton are prepared to
accepts for towing service. Where a certificate of Continuous Static Bollard Pull less
than 10 years old can be produced then this would normally be equated to the
Approved Bollard Pull.
For specific towage approvals, where the age of the Bollard Pull Certificate does not
comply with the above, Noble Denton may determine the bollard pull by using the
formula: 100 BHP (Certified BHP) = 1 tonne of bollard pull.
Benign Area
A “benign area” is defined as an area which is free of tropical revolving storms and
travelling depressions (but excluding the North Indian Ocean during Southwest
monsoon season, and South China Sea during Northeast monsoon season). The
specific extent and seasonal limitations of a benign area should be agreed with the
Noble Denton office concerned.
Bollard Pull
“BP” = Certified Continuous Static Bollard Pull in tonnes.
Breaking Load
“BL” = Certified Minimum Breaking Load of wire rope, chain or stretcher material
in tonnes.
Continuous Bollard Pull
The Continuous Static Bollard Pull (CBP) is the bollard pull obtained by a test at
100% of the Maximum Continuous Rating (MCR) of main engines, over a period of
10 minutes.
Maximum Bollard Pull
The Maximum Static Bollard Pull (MBP) is the bollard pull obtained by a test at
110% of the Maximum Continuous Rating (MCR) of main engines over a period of 5
minutes.
Maximum Continuous Rating
“MCR” = Manufacturer’s recommended Maximum Continuous Rating of main
engines.
Noble Denton
The term Noble Denton means any operating office of the Noble Denton Group.
Vessels which are entered into the Scheme or proposed for towing duties will be
designated one of five (5) categories. The requirements for each category are stated
below, and summarised in Appendix A.
3.3.1 Vessels shall be equipped with a minimum of one main towing wire which shall
comply with the strength and length requirements of Section 5.3.
3.3.2 Vessels in this category shall comply with the requirements for manning and
seakeeping as outlined in Sections 3.2.2, 3.2.3, 9 and 10.
3.3.3 If proposed as the lead or only tug for a particular towage, as may be allowed in
Section 3.6, vessels shall be equipped with a workboat with sufficient power and
capacity to carry four (4) persons plus material/equipment to the tow,.
4 DOCUMENTATION
Prior to a survey of the vessel being carried out for entry into the Scheme, and in
order to assess the likelihood of successful entry, copies of the following documents
should be submitted to NDE for review.
4.5 Certificates
Copies of the following valid documents shall be submitted to NDE, or made
available to the surveyor at time of survey:
• Certificate of registry
• International load line certificate
• Certificates of class for hull and machinery
• Cargo ship safety equipment certificate
• Cargo ship safety radio certificate
• Certificate of safe manning
• Certificates for all required bridles, chains, tow wires, pennants, stretchers,
and shackles and connecting links.
• Bollard Pull Certificate (see Section 2.1)
• Approved Stability Booklet.
5 TOWING EQUIPMENT
5.1 Ocean-Going Salvage Tugs (ST)
5.1.1 Vessels shall be equipped with two (2) main towing wires on separate winch drums,
and one spare towing wire, each of adequate strength to satisfy the requirements of
Minimum Breaking Load (BL) as follows:
Bollard Pull (BP) Minimum Break Load (BL)
Up to 90 tonnes (3.8 - BP/50) x BP
Over 90 tonnes 2.0 x BP
5.1.2 The length (L) of both main wires and the spare towing wire shall be determined
from the formula:
L = (BP/BL) x 2000 METRES
except that in no case shall the length be less than 800 metres (see Section 5.6.4).
5.1.3 A towing log indicating service history, maintenance and inspections shall be kept
for each tow wire and each synthetic stretcher held on board the vessel.
5.1.4 Vessels shall be equipped with at least four (4) towing pennants of not less than the
required BL of the towing wire, and of the same lay.
5.1.5 If a surge chain is supplied then the minimum breaking load (BL) shall not be less
than that of the main towing wire. The surge chain shall be a continuous length of
welded studlink chain, having a length of not less than 27.5 metres, with an enlarged
open link at each end.
5.1.6 Vessels shall be provided with the components for one towing bridle, which may be
either all chain, or a combination of chain and wire. The strength of each bridle leg
shall be not less than the actual BL of the towing wire plus 40 tonnes.
5.1.7 Vessels shall be equipped with at least twelve (12) towing shackles in accordance
with the requirements of Section 5.6.13 or 5.6.14
5.3.2 The length (L) of the towing wire shall be determined from the formula:
L = (BP/BL) x 1800 METRES
except that in no case shall the length be less than 650 metres (see also Section
5.6.4).
5.6.11 If synthetic stretchers are used, the pennants should be in a sound condition and the
minimum breaking load should not be less than:
- 2.0 times the required towline BL, for tugs with bollard pull less than 40
tonnes.
- 1.5 times the required towline BL, for tugs with bollard pull greater than 90
tonnes.
- linearly interpolated between 1.5 and 2.0 times the required towline BL for tugs
with bollard pull between 40 tonnes and 90 tonnes.
When determining the required towline breakload the comments in Section 5.6.4.
shall be taken into account.
5.6.12 The synthetic stretchers shall have a heavy-duty gussetted thimble at each end and be
adequately protected against chafe.
5.6.13 Vessels shall be equipped with at least 6 (12 for category ST) towing shackles or
approved connecting links.
5.6.14 The required capacity of towing shackles or connecting links shall be determined
from the Certified Breaking Load (BL) or the Certified Safe Working Load (SWL).
If the BL of a shackle is known, then the BL shall not be less than 110% of the
required BL of the towing wire.
5.6.15 Where the BL of the shackle cannot be determined, but is of high-quality and from a
reputable manufacturer, with a stated ratio of BL/SWL of not less than 4, then the
following may be used:
Bollard Pull (BP) Safe Working Load (SWL)
(tonnes) (tonnes)
Less than 40 1.0 x BP
40 or more (0.5 x BP) + 20
except that the comments contained in Section 5.6.4 shall be taken into account as
appropriate, and the shackle SWL be increased in proportion.
6 TOWING WINCH
Vessels in all categories shall be provided with at least one towing winch, (for
category ST two towing winch drums).
6.1 The towing winch and its connection to the vessel shall be strong enough to
withstand a force equal to the breaking load of the tow wire acting at its maximum
height above deck, without over-stressing.
6.2 If the power for the towing winch is supplied via a main engine shaft generator
during normal operating conditions, then another generator shall be available to
provide power for the towing winch in case of main engine or generator failure.
6.3 If a multi-drum winch is used, then each winch drum shall be capable of independent
operation.
6.4 The towing winch drum(s) shall have sufficient capacity to stow the required
minimum length of the tow wire(s).
6.5 A spooling device shall be provided such that the tow wire(s) is effectively spooled
on to the winch drum(s).
6.6 The towing winch brake shall be capable of preventing the towing wire from paying
out when the vessel is towing at its maximum continuous static bollard pull and shall
not release automatically in case of a power failure.
6.7 The winch shall be fitted with a mechanism for emergency release of the tow wire.
6.8 There shall be an adequate means of communication between the winch control
station(s) and the engine control station(s) and the bridge.
7.2 Tow Bars, Cargo Protection Rail, Bulwarks, Stern Rail, Tailgate and Stern
Roller
7.2.1 The top of the tow bars, cargo protection rail, bulwarks, stern rail, tail gate and stern
roller shall be free of sharp edges, corners or obstructions which could damage the
towing wire or prevent it from free lateral movement.
7.2.2 Where, during normal towing conditions, the towing wire bears on tow bars, cargo
protection rail, bulwarks, stern rail or tailgate, the radius of bend shall be at least ten
(10) times the diameter of the towing wire.
8 STABILITY
8.1 The stability of the vessel shall never be less than that required by the ”Guidelines
for the Design and Construction of Offshore Supply Vessels” (Resolution A.469
[XII] adopted by the International Maritime Organisation 1981) and the Merchant
Shipping (Load Line) Rules 1966, S.I. 1053.
9.1 Vessels in all categories shall be manned to meet the minimum requirements laid
down by Statutory Regulations.
9.2 Manning levels for vessels in all categories will be subject to the requirements of a
specific towage.
9.3 Where vessels are required to undertake long duration towages, difficult towages or
where the tow is unmanned, they shall have adequate certified accommodation to
enable manning levels to be increased. Any increase in manning levels will be
subject to the limitations of the regulations relating to life-saving appliances.
9.4 In general, to satisfy category ST, certified accommodation and life-saving
appliances shall be provided for a minimum of twelve (12) persons.
9.5 Vessels in category ST shall, when engaged in towing operations, carry a minimum
of five (5) certificated officers. These would normally be the Master, two (2) Deck
Officers and two (2) Engineer Officers.
9.6 In general, to satisfy categories U and R1, certified accommodation and life-saving
appliances shall be provided for a minimum of eight (8) persons.
9.7 Vessels in categories U and R1 shall, when engaged in towing operations, carry a
minimum of four (4) certificated officers. These would normally be the Master, one
(1) Deck Officer and two (2) Engineer Officers.
9.8 Vessels in categories R2 and R3 shall, when engaged in towing operations, carry a
minimum of three (3) certificated officers. These would normally be the Master, one
(1) Deck Officer and one (1) Engineer Officer.
10 SEAKEEPING
10.1 Vessels in all categories shall be of such a design to allow them to operate safely and
effectively in their designated areas.
10.2 Vessels in all categories must be purpose-built for towing operations or be of a multi-
purpose design having towing capability.
10.3 Vessels must be assigned an appropriate Classification by a recognised Classification
Society.
10.4 The length and normal operating draft of the vessel shall be adequate to maintain
propeller effectiveness and reduce slamming in heavy weather conditions.
10.4.1 For vessels in category ST, the ratio of Loadline draft (D) to length between
perpendiculars (LBP) shall comply with the formula:
D/LBP > 0.080
10.4.2 For vessels in categories U and R1, the ratio of Loadline draft (D) to length between
perpendiculars (LBP) shall comply with the formula:
D/LBP > 0.060
10.4.3 For vessels in categories R2 and R3, the ratio of Loadline draft (D) to length between
perpendiculars (LBP) shall comply with the formula:
D/LBP > 0.045
10.5 Vessels in category ST shall have a raised forecastle.
10.6 Vessels in categories U and R1 shall have a raised forecastle or have sufficient deck
sheer and flare of the bow to minimise water on deck during heavy weather. The
forecastle shall be of such a design to ensure minimum water retention.
APPENDICES
APPENDIX
A
SUMMARY OF REQUIREMENTS
Category ST U R1 R2 R3
General design and range
Raised fo’c’sle Yes Yes, or sheer/ Yes or sheer/ - -
flare flare
Minimum D:LBP ratio 0.08 0.06 0.06 0.045 0.045
Bunker capacity 35 days at 80% - - - -
power
Certificates/documentation
Registry Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Loadline Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Class, hull Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Safety equipment Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Safety radio Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
All towing equipment Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Bollard Pull Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Towing wire log Yes - - - -
Towage and salvage equipment
Towing winch Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Number of winch drums 2 1 1 1 1
Number of main tow 2 1 1 1 1
wires
Number of spare tow 1 1 - 1 -
wires
Minimum towline BL, 2.0 x BP 2.0 x BP 2.0 x BP 2.0 x BP 2.0 x BP
tonnes (BP> 90 t)
Minimum towline BL, (3.8-BP/50)xBP (3.8-BP/50)xBP (3.8-BP/50)xBP 2.0 x BP 2.0 x BP
tonnes (40<BP< 90 t)
Minimum towline BL, (3.8-BP/50)xBP 3.0 x BP 3.0 x BP 2.0 x BP 2.0 x BP
tonnes (BP<40 t)
Towline length, metres (BP/BL) x 2000 (BP/BL) x 1800 (BP/BL) x 1800 (BP/BL) x 1200 (BP/BL) x 1200
Minimum towline length 800 metres 650 metres 650 metres 500 metres 500 metres
Towing pennants 4 2 2 2 2
Shackles/Conn Links 12 6 6 6 6
Surge chain Optional - - - -
Towing bridle 1 - - - -
Salvage equipment Yes - - - -
Work boat Yes Yes Yes* Yes* -
Crane/derrick 2 tonnes - - - -
Pumps Yes - - - -
Compressor Yes - - - -
Welding equipment Yes - - - -
Damage control Yes - - - -
Spares Yes - - - -
Manning and accommodation
Accommodation 12 8 8 - -
LSA 12 8 8 - -
Number of certificated 5 4 4 3 3
officers
APPENDIX
B
B.1 General
B.1.1 The following guidance notes apply to the bollard pull test of any towing vessel
which Noble Denton is requested to approve or attend.
B.1.2 The safe working load of the test equipment, fittings and any connection points
ashore shall be at least 10% in excess of the designed maximum continuous static
bollard pull of the vessel.
B.2 Location
B.2.1 The water depth at the test location shall be at least 20 metres within a radius of 100
metres of the vessel.
B.2.2 If a water depth of 20 metres cannot be obtained at the test location, then a minimum
water depth which is equal to twice the maximum draft of the vessel may be
accepted. The owner of the vessel must be advised that the reduced water depth may
adversely affect the test results.
B.2.3 The test location shall be clear of navigational hazards and underwater obstructions
within a radius of 300 metres of the vessel.
B.2.4 The current shall be less than 0.5 metres/second from any direction.
B.2.5 The wind speed shall be less than 5 metres/second from any direction.
B.2.6 The condition of the sea at the test location shall be calm, without swell or waves.
B.3 Vessel
B.3.1 The draft and trim of the vessel shall be as near as possible to the draft and trim
under normal operating conditions.
B.3.2 The propellers and fuel used during the tests shall be the same as the propellers and
fuel used under normal operating conditions.
B.3.3 All auxiliary equipment such as pumps, generators and other equipment which are
driven from the main engine(s) or propeller shaft(s) during normal operation of the
vessel shall be connected during the test.
B.4 Test
B.4.1 The distance between the stern of the vessel and the shore shall be at least 300
metres.
B.4.2 If it is not possible to maintain a distance of 300 metres between the stern of the
vessel and the shore, then a minimum distance which is equal to twice the waterline
length of the vessel may be accepted. The owner of the vessel must be advised that
the reduced distance between the vessel’s stern and the shore may adversely affect
the test results.
B.4.3 Adequate communications shall be established between the vessel and instrument
recording station.
B.4.4 The continuous bollard pull (CBP) test shall be carried out at the manufacturer’s
recommended maximum continuous rating of the main engines (100% MCR), for a
period of 10 minutes with the vessel on a steady heading.
B.4.5 Whenever possible a maximum (MBP) test shall be carried out at the manufacturer’s
maximum rating of the main engines (110% MCR), for a period of 5 minutes.
B.4.6 When requested, continuous bollard pull may also be verified at different RPM
and/or propeller pitch settings or with fewer propellers or engines in use.
B.4.7 The load cell used for measuring the bollard pull shall have an accuracy of ±2% for
the average temperature observed during the test and shall have been calibrated not
more than six (6) months prior to the test date. The calibration certificate shall be
available.
B.4.8 An autographic recording instrument giving a continuous read-out of the bollard pull
shall be connected to the load cell.
B.4.9 If no continuous record of the test is printed, then the bollard pull shall be the mean
of consecutive readings recorded at half-minute intervals over the test period.
APPENDIX
C
C.1 General
C.1.1 The following guidance notes apply to the towing equipment tests of any vessel
which Noble Denton is requested to approve or attend.
C.1.2 Before carrying out any tests, it shall be ascertained that the equipment to be tested
has been installed according to the manufacturer’s recommendations and can be
operated safely.
C.1.3 The wire used during the winch tests shall be equal to the towing wire in breaking
load, diameter and construction and shall be spooled onto the towing winch drum
with a tension of 25% of the vessel’s CBP or 40 tonnes, whichever is less.
C.1.4 During stalling, brake and quick release tests, the wire shall be kept as near as
possible to the centre line of the vessel.
C.1.5 The safe working load of the test equipment, fittings and any connection points
ashore shall be at least ten (10) percent in excess of the designed maximum static
bollard pull of the vessel.
C.3 Fixed Gogwire System, Towing Pod, Line Stops and Guide Pins
Tests
The spooling gear, if fitted, shall be disengaged during the “fixed” gogwire system,
towing pod, line stops and guide pin tests.
The engine power or propeller pitch shall be gradually increased to the CBP.
The test wire shall be at an angle of approximately 60° on each side of the vessel’s
centre line.
The duration of each test shall not be less than one (1) minute.