Unit 8 Time Study Work Measurement: Structure
Unit 8 Time Study Work Measurement: Structure
WORK MEASUREMENT
Structure
8.1 Introduction
Objectives
8.1 INTRODUCTION
'Time is money', whether it is observed by anybody or not, it is definitely followed by
any industrial engineer through the time study and work measurement. The work is
measured in terms of certain time elements for which the remuneration is suitably
designed. According to F. W. Taylor, any work can be split into small units called
'elements'. These elements are timed. Such times are standardised by suitable
measurenlent technique, with the help of which the targets are fixed. The targeted job is
then called 'task'. In Taylor's words the worker is to be provided by three basic 'definite'
requirements - Definite Time, Definite Task and Definite Method so as to perform a job
in most efficient and effective way.
\\'ark System Design Objectives
t
After studying this unit, you should be able to
understand the time study and conduct a time study,
rate a job and a worker doing certain job,
calculate the basic time, normal time and standard time of a job or element,
and
fix the target for job.
(', :,
Description Stopwatch
Work System Design Cycle Time Study Sheet
(Note : Work place layout is to be drawn on the backside of cycle time study sheet)
Department : ..........................Department code : .............................
Operat'or : .............................. Employment No. : ..............................
Operation : ........................... Drawing No. : .....................................
Machine : ..............................Machine No. : .....................................
Product : .................................Part No. : ............................................
Material : ................................Tools/Guages : ...................................
Clock No. : .............................Srudy No. : ........................................
Study conducted by : ..............Date of Study : ...................................
Checked by : ...........................Date of Checking : ............................
Approved by : .........................Date of Approval : .............................
i:.b; ~escription
Element Reading on Stopwatch (Observed Time) Avg
Time 1
I Rating I Basic
Time
1
Taken '
_1
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 0
-------
II
I
Ii
I
I
Example 8.1
A job has been sub-divided into five elements. The time for each element and
respective rating are given below :
1 Element Number I Observed Time I Rating Factor '10 I
Calculate the normal time and standard time for each element and for the job if the
alIowance is 15%.
Solution Time Study -
Work Measurement
For Element 1
Normal Time = Observed time x Rating Factor
80
= 0.7 x -= 0.56 min.
100
Standard Time = 0.56
For Element 2
100
Normal Time = 0.8 x -= 0.8 min.
100
100
Standard Time = 0.8 x = 0.94 min.
100 - 15
For Element 3
120
Normal Time = 1.3 x -= 1.56 min.
100
100
Standard Time = 1.56 x = 1.835 min.
100-15
For Element 4
90
Normal Time = 0.5 x -= 0.45 min.
100
Calculate the normal time and standard time for each element and for the
job if the allowance is 5%.
(e) The observed time for an element is 2 minutes. I'hr rating factor is 80%. If
standard time is 1.76, how much allowance is given for the element?
Activity 1
Conduct a time study for the following :
(a) Toasting of a bread.
.........................................................................................................................
(b) Juice making.
.........................................................................................................................
(c) Crimpling a cap on a cool drink bottle.
.........................................................................................................................
(e) Assembling of nut and bolt.
'lhe time taken for a job varies from person to person attributed to various reasons such
as environme17tal factors and ;~umanfactors discussed in mqtion study (Unit 10 of this
block). Sometimes. we come across some complaints such as the worker is intentionally
doing delay or the observer's judgement is prejudiced. To overcome such disputes, the
normal rating is compared with performance rating to standardise the time and thence fix
up the target of an element or job.
V;rnuus systcms of performance rating are as follows . Tirtlc Study -
Work ~Mrusuretnenl
(a) Westinghouse system of rating
(b) Synthet~crating
(c) Objective rating
(d) Skill and effort rating
(c) Condition
(d) Consistency
Various ratings are tabulated in the Table 8.1 as glven by Westinghouse. The actuals are
conlpared and suited with one of the ratings in each of the above four factors and
t summed up for finding total rating. This is added (or subtracted) to unity to find the
rating factor. On multiplyiilg with the actual (Observed) time, we get Normal or Basic
time. The standard time is then calculated by adding allowances to the normal time. This
is illustrated through the numerical problems given below.
Table 8.1 : Westinghouse Performance Rating Table
1 1
From the Performance Rating tables of Westinghouse system:
skill
Effort
Fair
--
Excessive
El
A,
!
1
0.04
0.13
1
1 Condition I Good c j 0.02 ,
I
I Ovesall (Total) Rating 0 . 2 2 I
i.e. positive rating by + 0.22 over unity = I + 0.22 = I .22
Normal Time = Observed Time x Rating Factor
Find the Normal Time and Standarc! Time for an element. which has the following
ratings in Westinghouse system, and observed tiwe is 1.2 minute.
Skill Avcragc
Averagc 1
Effort
Condition Fair
+
I Consistency Poor I
I Allowance 1 10% 1
110
Standard Time = 1.1 16 x = 1.24 min.
100 - 10
SAQ 2
(a) Find the standard time for an element of one minute observed as average in
all the factors of Westinghouse system and 15% allowances are given.
(b) The observed time for an element was one minute and the rating were found
Wor
to be as follows :
i I ii
c1 Skill
"fort
Condition
super
Fair
Ideal
A,
132
A
/
!
I I
Consistency Average D I
Deterln~nethe normal time or basic time for the element under observation.
(Westinghouse perforinance rating table will be provided).
(c) Calculate normal time for an element of 2 minutes with skill, effort.
condition and consistency as 0.11, 0.05, - 0.03 and 0.00, respectively.
(d) The following observations of actual time taken by worker for doing a job
repeatedly were taken by a time study observer. The rating were found to be
as follows :
r
Skill Good CI 1
I
I Ef'ort ( Exccsrive AI
I
/ Condition Excellent B
!
i Consistency I ~'oor I F 1
1 Observation No. 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1
1 Time in Minutes 0.2 1 0.3 0.4 1 0.6 1 0.4 1 0.2 )
Determine the normal time or basic time for the element under observation. (Refer
Westinghouse performance rating table).
[Hint : Take actual time of an average time of the six observations.]
Element No. 1 2. 3 4 5 6
Average Actual
I
,
0.5 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.6
Time (A)
Predetermined
Motion Time (P) 1 0 . 4 5 1 I 1 0 . 4 6 1i I I
Solution
P 30.45)
Performance Rating ( R ) = - = j -i x 100 = 90% for first element.
A i 0.5 )
Performance Rating ( R ) =
A
= !El
\ 0.4
x 100 = 1 1 5% for fourth element.
)
( 1 15 + 90)
Average R = = 102.5'/6
2
Normal Tiines for the elements are
Normal Tinie
Element No. Actual Time
(Actual Time x Average Rating)
Adjustment
Amount of body Finger used loosely
used Wrist and Fingers
Elbow, wrist and fingers
Arm, etc.
Trunk. etc.
List with leg from floor
2 Food pedals F No pedals or one pedal with
fulcrum under foot
G Pedal or pedals with
fulcrum outside the foot
3 Bi-manualness HI Hands help each other or
I alternate
Hands work simultaneously
doing the same work
.--
Summary
Base Time = Pace Rating x Observed Time (P.T)
Normal Time = Base Time x Secondary Adjustment (B.M) = PMT
Standard Time = N + A = PMT +A
Example 8.5
The observed time for an element is 1.2 minutes. The pace rating for the element
is 120% and job difficulty is found to be 30%. Find Normal Time o f the element.
Also find standard Time a t a n allowance o f 10%.
Solution
120
Base Time = 1.2 x -= 1.44
100
120 130
Normal time (NT) = 1.2 x -x -- = 1.872
100 100
110
Standard Time = 1.872 x = 2.08 min.
I00 - 10
\\'arlc Syhtc~nDesign Example 8.6
An Element is observed to be carried out in 0.8 minutes. Given pace rating is
110% and the secondary adjustment by 20'96, find the time on any tBir day. If*
0.2 minute per element is given as allowance, what is the standard time taken for
20 repeated actions?
Solution
110
Base Time = 0.8 x - = 0.8800
100
120
Normal Time = 0.88 x -= 1.056
100
100
Standard Time = 1.056 x = 1.32 min.
100 - 20
SAQ 3
(a) The observed time for an element is 0.4 minute and the pace rating is 90%
and the sum of all secondary adjustments amount to 20%. Find the normal
time.
(b) The observed time of an element is 0.7 minute and the pace rate is 80%. If
the normal time is decided as 0.73 minute, find what percent of adjustment
is added towards job difficulty.
(a) Diviele the operation into smallest measurable elements (smallest time is
2 3 seconds).
(b) Time the element with the help of a stopwatch having sixty divisions on its
dial.
(d) Estimate the efficiency of the operator in tenns of B values assuming the
average worker must obtain 6 0 9 per hour and maximum B value can be
80 B per hour. Thus convert the observed time in terms of B's with
reference to a standard of 60 B per hour values.
(e) Allow the relaxation factors as shown in Table 8.3 Time Study -
Work .Measurement
Table 8.3 : Relaxation Factors
1 Medium work
Heavy work
Very heavy work
1 1.20 to 1.35
1
(9 Now calculate B values for work element by the formula
The number of B's per work element = Observed Time x Speed of work
=0.2 B
SAQ 4
Find the B value of the work element whose relaxation allowance is 1.25 and the
worker with 72 B speed is observed to do in 20 seconds.
2
- -
( Normal Time*
Work Content
I Standard .I'irne 1
Figure 8.3 : Standard Time
*Normal Time and B a s ~ cTlme are usually taken in the same sense ~f the work delay 1s not considered
or negligible (when there IS no work delay, both are equal)
8.5 ALLOWANCES
Thc determination of allowances is the most controversial part of the time study, because
it varies from person to person. situation to situation, place to place, job to job, season to
season and many more. Therefore the industrial engineer feels it most difficult job.
However. certain standardised norms of allowances are in regular practice by the
industrial engineers. These are narrated under five heads as follows :
(a) Interference allowance
(b) Relaxation allowance
(c) Process allowance
(d) Contingency allowance
(e) Special allowance
8.5.1 Interference Allowance
This is provided on a job where the operator is working on several machines. The
machine interference may occur due to settings, positioning, etc. which may influence
the skill and effort of the operator. However, this may not be added always for
calculating standard time as it belongs to machine controlled element.
8.5.2 Relaxation Allowance
In every computation of standard time, this allowance must be considered for manual
work, irrespective of the nature of the job. The relaxation allowances are usually
expressed in percentage of normal time.
British Standards Institution (BSI) has defined relaxation allowances as follows, which
arc world-wide accepted :
(a) 3138 : 1959
35004 - Relaxation Allowance (R. A.) - Compensating rest allowance.
An addition to the basic time intended to provide the worker with the
opportunity to recover from the physiological effects of carrying out
specified conditions and to allow attention to personal needs. The amount of
allowance will depend on the nature of the job.
35005 - Fatigue Allowance - A sub-division of relaxation allowance Tinic Stucly -
(b)
Work Measurement
intended to cater for the physiological and psychological effects of carrying
out speci tied work under specified conditions.
25% ofNor~nalTime
on automatic machine
-1
i
I
I
It is often expressed as percent of basic time and is less than 5% if recolnmended by the
observer. According to British standards. it is a small allowance to meet legitimate
expected items of work or delays. The accurate measurement of this time is not
worthwhile and unecono~nicalas it occurs irregularly and rarely.
8.5.5 Special Allowance
'These include all the other allowances such as policy allowances and others given by the
company such as when a new job is given to worker, he takes time to learn. a relief
allowance given to operators to facilitate their leader to address on a certain occasion,
etc.
SAQ 5
(a) Explain various allowances provided to the operators working in industry.
(b) Give short notes on
(i) Westinghouse rating system
(ii) Skill and effort rating systeni
(iii) Objective rating system
(iv) Synthetic rating system
(c) Distinguish between Observed Time, Norinal Time and Standard Time.
Activity 2
(a) Go to an industry in your vicinity and interview a few people to identify the
various allowances provided by the management.
(b) 111 the same industry conduct the performance rating and Westinghouse rating
system.
- -
.1..lnle Studv -
8.6 PREDETERMINED MOTION TIME STANDARDS Work Measurement
- (PMTS)
If you hake to assess certain activity or a job you need some standard with which you
compare, so also, for an element of a work study. Anything rated as good, better, normal,
average, fair, poor, bad. worse or worst are all relative terms, which evolve by comparing
with a standard data. In the present context of time study, to standardise the time of an
operation we need to divide the job into small work elements, which are to be repeated
in various combinations. The time valaes of these work elements are then established
accurately to make use of these without any further time study, whenever such element
occurs. This is known as standard data for all further references. However. all this
standardisation is to be done if standardised method exists, otherwise the method is to be
standardised first.
Methods o f Determining PMTS
The following PMTS systems are in common practice :
(a) Work Factor System (WFS)
Developed during 1940, J. H. Quick, W. J. Shea and R. E. Kohler.
(b) Method Time Measurement (MTM)
Developed by Method Engineering Council of Pittsburgh,
Pennsylvania.
(c) Basic Motion Time Study (BMTS)
Developed by J. D. Woods and Gordon Ltd., Toronto, Canada.
(d) Motion Time Analysis (MTA)
Developed by Segur in 1930.
(e) Di~nensionalMotion Time Study (DMTS)
Developed by Bridgeport, Connecticut Plant.
Now let us discuss the above methods in detail.
8.6.1 Work Factor System (WFS)
We cannot compare a horse with a donkey just by the virtue of both being four-legged
mammalian animals. Similarly, all works cannot be measured with same scale and same
formula of efficiency (outputiinput). since there are many factors involved.
For example, therc are two lecturers teaching two subjects, say Xteaches technical
subject and Y teaches a management subject. Now, if we have to decide who is better, it
is not an easy job. Even though various factors attributed to human factors such as ability
to explain, gestures, postures, style, language, moods, perceiving capacity of students,
health conditions and environmental conditions are kept constant, the subject complexity
itself is another variable that play a major role here. In a good number of occasions we
come across rating the lecturers by student pass percentage or number of ranks obtained
in the examination. But think, how far it is justified. There are many variables that can
be accounted here. The students might not have concentrated in learning the subject, the
question paper could be tough: the questions might have mislead or out of syllabus, the
evaluator might have expected a different way of answering and many more reasons like
these. l'he degree of these factors again varies with the persons, subjects, institutions,
circumstances and environments. Hence. it is suggested to take average in all
combinations and rate each job with its own standard, which can be acceptable as most
appropriate with allowing a standard deviation.
In factory works also where physical work is more involved, such situations arise,
particularly while calculating the incentive. In such occasions, it is assumed that the time
required to perform a task is affected by four factors.
l'hesc are :
(a) Body members used such as arm. forearm swivel, trunk. foot, legs, fingers,
hand, head, eyes, ears. etc.
(b) Distance moved, measured in terms of centi~netresor inches.
(c) Manual control required to eliminate or reduce the difficulties involved
such as directional controls, speed controls, stopping and starting, priming
and pumpi~ig,precautionary measure, etc.
(d) Weight or resistance Qr loads.
The Work-Factor System recognise some elements of work which are shown in
Table 8.5.
Table 8.5 : Elements of Work
I SI. No. Activity
I
1 Symbol Explanation 1
I
I I Assembles 1 ASY Putting the objec~stogether 1
/ 2 1 Diasscmbbs / DSY Separaling dillbent parts of 1
-I
I
3
1
4
/
(
Hand
Activity
No. of readings ( N ) =
( 4 0 Jn /n X' - (Zx,)'
1 1 x,
Example 8.9
For a particular task 15 observations were taken by a time study observer. Check
whether the number of observations is sufficient for 5% limit of accuracy and 95%
confidence level. Indicate the ininiinum number of observations required.
Solution
x in Minuter r j 1 j.x 1 x2 I . x2 I
'l'inie Study -
Work hlersurenie~it
1-
1
No. of readings ( N ) = 40
4 1 5 x 180 - 2304
48 1 = 16.55
SAQ 8
Ten observations were taken by a time study observer for a particular task. Check
whether the number of observations is sufficient for 5% limit of accuracy and 95%
confidence level, Indicate the minimum number of observations required.
Time Frequency
P
0.2 2
Example 8.10
To fix up the standard time of a particular work, 5 operators were kept under
observation for 4 days by a sample study group. The perfonnance rating and
number of times the workers were found working each day were noted and given
below.
I\ork System Design The total number of observations on each day was 50. The working hours per day
is 8 hrs. and the total products produced during these four days are 1200.
Calculate Standard time for the iob. Assume 10% allowance.
Sol ution
( 4thJanuary, 2K 1 43 1 7 \
i
1
#
Total 169 31
= 5 x 4 x 8 x 60 = 9600 minutes.
Since performance rate of each operator is different, the average performances
will differ and the computations are as follows :
(5 + 8 + 7 + 1O)x 100=3000
(10 + 9 + 6 + 8 ) x 110 = 3630
(I0 + 1 0 + 9 + 1 l ) x 120 =4800
(9 + 8 + 8 + 7 ) x 125 =4000
(10 + 5 + 12+ 7 ) x 130=4420
Tota! = 19850
Total number of times workers found working = 169
19850
.4verage performance rate = -= 1 17.5
169
Standard time in minutes per component
= [Totalworking time in min x (Percent working timeIl00) x (Average
performance rate1100) 1 Total quantity produced during the observed period]
+ Allowance Factor.
SAQ 9 Time Study -
Work Measurement
An operator was kept under observation for I0 days. In 250 observations, he was
found to be on job for 200 times and idle for 50 times. He produced 200 jobs
during the 10 days at a performance rate of 120. If the observation period is
5 hours only per day and 15% allowances are given, find the normal time and
standard time.
(c) Operations are not kept under risks and strains unlike in stopwatch
observations.
(d) Some activities are impractical or costly to study by stopwatch. These can
be estimated easily by this method.
(e) Man hours spent by the observers is very less in this simplified technique of
evaluation.
(g) Sampling study can be stopped at any time without affecting the results.
8.8.6 Disadvantages
(a) Not economical to conduct on a single operation or machine.
(d) The study is based on average group performance and hence the individual
variations are not evaluated.
\\ arli Sjateol Design The clarity and understandings between management. foremen, observers
and operators may miss and varies with attributes.
Biased opinions may lead to wrong interpretations of results.
Method or technological changes and other changes are not taken into
account. If such changes occur between any two observations the results
will be misinterpreted.
Accuracy is based on statistics and therefore probablistic while stopwatch
studies are deterministic.
SAQ 9
(a) What do you understand by work sampling? How do you recognise it as a
work measurement technique?
Distinguish between time study and work sampling.
Discuss the advantages and limitations of work sampling over time study.
Enumerate the applications of the work sampling technique.
What are the objectives of work sampling? How do they fit in work study?
Explain the role of work sampling and time study in improving the
productivity.
Activity 4
Conduct a work sampling programme in your organisation and write down the
results. Give your reco~nmendationsbased on the results.
8.9 SUMMARY
Although desirability of effective method is stressed always and there have been lot of
efforts put in this direction, yet, it is very difficult and not always possible/feasible for an
industrial engineer that the effective method is developed before the work actually enters
the industry. We are well aware of the resistance and barriers put before the
managements while introducing new methods and timing them. In this scenario, the task
of method improvement in one hand and the target fixation for the job on the other hand,
the time study has played a dual role effectively. Though this was originally proposed for
xeating the systematic work culture through definite task, definite method and definite
time which in turn intended to result in improved production (during the period of world
wars and industrial revolution), the time study and work measurement techniques have
become so popular that they are the only proven tools for an industrial engineer today for
improvement of method, kixation of task and time of a job or work or activity and thence Time Study -
Work Illeasureme~it
the productivity. And the time study is not just confined to method improvement and
task and time fixation, but it had spread out its branches in task assessment, wage
fixation and wage incentive decisions too. Hats off to F. W. Taylor for his time study.
Tiine study often called work measurement, was the brainchild of F. W. Taylor. He
suggested to split the work into sinall elements and these elements are to be timed
separately. On summing up these elemental times the standard time can be calculated.
This unit covered the methodology of the time study and work measurement. The use of
stopwatches, calculators, spring balances. tachometers, etc. has been stressed
appropriately. A systematic approach established through vsrious ecluipment is given.
The concepts used in work measurement such as performance rating. allowances, PMTS.
MOST and work sampling are narrated. Under performance rating various methods, viz.
Westinghouse rating, Objective rating, Synthetic rating, Skill and effort rating,
Physiological measurements are explained. An effort is made to provide good
understanding on allowailces to convert the normal time into standard time by dealing
with various allowances. A clear picture on PMTS is structured through the techniclues
such as WFS, MTM, BMTS, etc. A brief description on MOST is also given. The
statistical method of work measurement, proposed by L. H. C. Tippet is elaborately
described under work sampling.
(a) O T = l r n i n ; N T = l ~ n i n :S T = N T
100.- allowances
(b) 2.26
(c) 2.26
(d) 0.4165
Work System Design SAQ 3
(a) 0.43 minute
(b) 30%
SAQ 4
0.5 B
SAQ 7
(a) 4800
(b) Insufficient, some more are required; no. of observations required = 4800.
SAQ 8
14 observations (Four more are required).
SAQ 9
Normal Time = 1.44 minutes
100
Standard Time = Nonnal Time x
100 - allowances