Session 4 Notes - IChild-UnEducated and IChild UnReality
Session 4 Notes - IChild-UnEducated and IChild UnReality
“More than 50% of parents said the most important reasons their
children watched TV was because they have them watch programs
that will help teach their children something, that it’s good for the
children’s brain development, or because watching TV is something
their children really enjoy doing.” — http://
www.urbanchildinstitute.org/articles/research-to-policy/practice/tv-
can-be-too-stimulating-for-babies-toddlers
Here’s a recent article from the New York Times, titled, “In
classroom of future, stagnant scores.”
So…how’s it going?
“The data is pretty weak. It’s very difficult when we’re pressed to
come up with convincing data.” — – Tom Vander Ark, former
executive director for education at the Bill and Melinda Gates
Foundation and investor in educational technology companies.
Negative effects
1. Attention deficits
2. “Digital dementia”
Right-hemisphere damage
Difficulty with:
• Attention
• Perception
• Learning
• Memory
• Organization
• Insight
• Orientation
• Poor social communication
• Difficulty with recognition and expression of emotion
• Difficulty reasoning and problem solving
• Impulse control
• Decision making
• Emotion
• Controlling emotional responses
• Attention
• Motivation
• Error detection
• Center of the free will
• OCD
• PTSD
• Depression
• Addictions (including drug)
• Poor emotional regulation
• Poor motivation
• Neuroticism
• Sensation-seeking
• Impulsivity
– Various sources
Media Multitasking
“A blind trust that e-learning can replace good teachers often leads
to less-educated children; apps are substituting thinking and
cognitive capacity is shrinking.” – Hermann Maurer, Does the
Internet Make Us Stupid?
Waldorf Schools
• Play
• Artistic work
• Songs
• Games
• Stories
• Outdoor time
• Practical tasks
• Cooking
• Cleaning
• Gardening
•
“The classroom is intended to resemble a home, with tools and toys
usually sourced from simple, natural materials that lend themselves
to imaginative play” – wikipedia.org/wiki/Waldorf_education
No media use!
While the efforts may impress, teaching with tech has yielded
disappointing results. The Organization for Economic Cooperation
and Development, which released a comprehensive study in 2015,
Students, Computers and Learning, has found, “Most countries
that invested heavily in education related IT equipment did not
witness an appreciable improvement in student achievement over
the past 10 years.”
https://phillywaldorf.com/computers-waldorf-eschews-classroom-
tech/?fbclid=IwAR0b5xNRO3-
IxOOP1unXGKNMq5y2B_s90JBSrCSOht9Zic-ravrVFHirxsw
https://phillywaldorf.com/computers-waldorf-eschews-classroom-
tech/?fbclid=IwAR0b5xNRO3-
IxOOP1unXGKNMq5y2B_s90JBSrCSOht9Zic-ravrVFHirxsw
“It’s super easy. It’s like learning to use toothpaste. At Google and
all these places, we make technology as brain-dead easy to use as
possible. There’s no reason why kids can’t figure it out when they
get older.” – Alan Eagle. Computer scientist, executive
communications, Google
“For three weeks, we ate our way through fractions. When I made
enough fractional pieces of cake to feed everyone, do you think I
had their attention?” – Cathy Waheed. Teacher, Waldorf School of
the Peninsula
“You can look back and see how sloppy your handwriting was in
first grade. You can’t do that with computers because all the letters
are the same. Besides, if you learn to write on paper, you can still
write if water spills on the computer or the power goes out.” – Fin
Heilig, Student, Waldorf School of the Peninsula
“I’ve worked clinically with over 1,000 teens over the past decade
plus and one of the most amazing things that I observed was that
kids raised from an early age on a high-tech/high-screen diet
suffered from what seemed to be a digital malaise. They were,
almost universally, what I like to call “uninterested and
uninteresting.” Bored and boring, they lacked a natural curiosity and
a sense of wonder and imagination that non-screen kids seemed to
have. They didn’t know—or care to know—about what was
happening around them in the world. All that seemed to drive them
was a perpetual need to be stimulated and entertained by their
digital devices.” – Dr. Nicholas Kardaras
https://www.vice.com/en_ca/article/how-screen-addiction-is-ruining-
the-brains-of-children
1. Overstimulating
“If a child’s brain gets habituated to that pace and to the extreme
alertness… the child ultimately may find the realities of the world
underwhelming, understimulating.” – Dr. Dimitri Christakis,
pediatrician, University of Washington, http://www.nytimes.com/
2011/05/10/health/views/10klass.html
2. Attention-grabbing/addicting
Dopamine
“If children are left to receive the language from electronics, and not
have the opportunity to use language to express themselves, their
speech and language could be considerably delayed.” – Annette
Stock, speech, language, and literacy specialist, http://
www.nzherald.co.nz/rotorua-daily-post/news/article.cfm?
c_id=1503438&objectid=11724680
Children of Yesteryear….
• Played outside
• Plenty of physical exercise
• Helped with the daily work inside and out
• Learned by exploration
• Experienced real-life consequences
• Learned with pencil, paper, textbooks, and a human teacher
Children of Today
• Playing on smartphone/tablet
• Sedentary/indoors/TV viewing
• Work often replaced by screen-based entertainment
• Spoon-fed pre-baked creativity
• Just press “reset”, or “ctrl Z”. No real consequences felt.
• E-Books, interactive whiteboards, educational games
Fresh Air
• Stronger immune system
• Fewer allergies
• Lower incidence of asthma
• Improves oxygen flow to
• Contains phytoncides
“Phytoncides are antimicrobial allelochemic volatile organic
compounds derived from plants.” –
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phytoncide
Sunshine
• Provides vitamin D
• Improves eye health
• May reduce the risk of diabetes, heart disease
• Raises serotonin levels
• Positively effects sleep by adjusting circadian rhythm and
melatonin levels
“There are but few who realize that, in order to enjoy health and
cheerfulness, they must have an abundance of sunlight, pure air,
and physical exercise. We pity little children who are kept confined
indoors when the sun is shining gloriously without. Clothe your boys
and girls comfortably and properly. . . . Then let them go out and
exercise in the open air, and live to enjoy health and happiness. The
pale and sickly grain-blade that has struggled up out of the cold of
early spring puts out the natural and healthy deep green after
enjoying for a few days the health-and-life-giving rays of the sun.
Go out into the light and warmth of the glorious sun. . . . and share
with vegetation its life-giving, healing power.”-The Health Reformer
April 1, 1871 https://m.egwwritings.org/it/book/504.181#181
Gardening
• self-confidence
• self-esteem
• patient
• persevering
• improved science understanding
• better test scores
• overall better learners
Physical activity
Useful Work
• Teaches cause-to effect reasoning
• Hand-eye coordination
• Problem solving skills
• Perseverance
• Time-management
• Discipline
• Communication skills
Recap…
• Highly Addicting
• Many health risks
• Eye damage
• Negative effects from blue light
• Interactive media often more damaging than TV
• Educational media not helping
• Causing attention deficits
• “Digital dementia”
• Brain imbalance and right-hemisphere damage
• Anterior Cingulate Cortex damage
• Overstimulating
• Not real-world communication
• Not real-world interaction
“The more quiet and simple the life of the child—the more free from
artificial excitement and the more in harmony with nature—the more
favorable it is to physical and mental vigor and to spiritual strength.”
– Child Guidance, 139