Rochester Institute of Technology

RIT Scholar Works

Theses Thesis/Dissertation Collections

4-28-1992

NACA four-digit airfoil section generation using

cubic parametric curve segments and the golden
section
William T. Scarbrough

Follow this and additional works at: http://scholarworks.rit.edu/theses

Recommended Citation
Scarbrough, William T., "NACA four-digit airfoil section generation using cubic parametric curve segments and the golden section"
(1992). Thesis. Rochester Institute of Technology. Accessed from

This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Thesis/Dissertation Collections at RIT Scholar Works. It has been accepted for inclusion
in Theses by an authorized administrator of RIT Scholar Works. For more information, please contact [email protected].
NACA FOUR-DIGIT AIRFOIL SECTION GENERATION
USING CUBIC PARAMETRIC CURVE SEGMENTS AND
THE GOLDEN SECTION

William T. Scarbrough

Department of Mechanical Engineering

Rochester Institute of Technology
One Lomb Memorial Drive
Rochester, New York

Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of

Master of Science of Mechanical Engineering

28 APRIL 1992

Dr. Panchapakesan Venkataraman, Graduate Thesis Advisor

Dr. Hany Ghoneim, Professor of Mechanical Engineering

Dr. Amitabha Ghosh, Professor of Mechanical Engineering

Dr. Joseph Torok, Professor of Mechanical Engineering

R-I-'l'
• '._>';' -,·Y.··· .. _. -J--- _._·e_·_· Rochester Institute of Technology
........,".: _... ~ ...
Wallace Library
Post Office Box 9887
Rochester, New York H623·088i
i16·475·2562 Fax i16-4i5-6490

SAMPLE statements to reproduce an RIT thesis:

PERMISSION GRANTED
Trtleofthesis N"e,A E'ou(?- DIG IT AI{2.fo(L SC'-TLolV bl!.N~YlATlot0
USI~b CuBIC. PA..I!.AJ1cnt.lc CIJR.v4 SCCrJ"'\GNTS AND TH<!

I LUlu.. lAM ::?cA.eB/?ou'H hereby grant permission to the

Wallace Memorial Library of the Rochester Institute of Technology to reproduce my
thesis in whole or in part. Any reproduction will not be for commercial use or profit.

Date: 03 SNq'l,. Signature of Author:

PERMISSION FROM AUTHOR REQUIRED

Title of thesis _

I prefer to be contacted each time a

request for reproduction is made. I can be reached at the following address:

PHONE:

Date: Signature of Author:

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------_._-----------
PERMISSION DENIED
Title of thesis _

I hereby deny permission to the Wallace

Memorial Library of the Rochester Institute of Technology to reproduce my thesis in
whole or in part.

Date: Signature of Author:

Table of Contents

Abstract v

Acknowledgements vi

List of Symbols vii

List of Figures ix

1. Introduction i

1.1 A Brief History Airfoils and

of 1
Aeronautical Development

1.2 Direction of Research 4

1.3 The Golden Section 4

2. NACA Four-Digit Airfoils 5

2.1 Symmetric Airfoils 5

2.1.1 Nomenclature 5

2.2.1 Thickness Distribution 5

2.2.2 Leading Edge Radius 6

2.2.3 Trailing Edge Angle 6

2.2 Cambered Airfoils 7

2.2.1 Mean Line 7

2.2.2 Method of Combining Thickness 8

Distribution and Mean Line
 2.3 NACA Designation Scheme 9

2.4 Method of Manual Layout 9

3. Approximation Techniques n

3.1 Polynomial Approximation 11

3.1.1 Cubic Spline Interpolation 11

3.1.2 Discrete Least-Squares 11

Approximations

3.2. Parametric Curves 17

3.2.1 Bezier Curves 19

3.2.2 Matrix Formulation for Bezier Curve 21

3.2.3 Derivatives of Bezier Curve 22

24
4. Results of Analysis

4.1 Symmetric Airfoils 24

4.1.1 Cubic Spline interpolation 24

4.1.1.1 Natural Cubic Splines 24

4.1.1.2 Clamped Cubic Splines 26

4.1.1.3Overcoming the Problem of 30

Specifying Zero Slope

4.1.2 Least-Squares Polynomial 30

Approximations

u
 4.1.3 Parametric Bezier Curves 30

4.1.3.1 Leading Edge Surface 30

4.1.3.2 Trailing Edge Surface 62

4.1.3.3 Assembling the Pieces 71

4.1.3.4 Error Analysis 71

4.2 Cambered Airfoils 72

4.2.1 Review 72

4.2.2 Detennining Points of Zero Slope 73

4.2.2. 1 Linear Fit of Upper Surface 92

Ordinate

4.2.2.2 Polynomial Fits 93

4.2.2.3 The Arc Method 94

4.2.2.4 The Curve Method 95

4.2.2.5 Areas of Triangles 95

4.2.2.6 Dimensionless Parameter 98

Combinations

4.2.2.7 The Linear Correction Factor 99

4.2.3 Utilization of Properties at Point of 121

Maximum Camber

4.2.3.1 Further Review 121

4.2.3.2 Enclosing Tangent Triangle 122

4.2.4 Conventional Cambered Airfoil 150

Generation

152
5. Conclusions

m
Appendices

A. The Golden Section A-l

B. Cubic Spline Derivation B1

C. References c_1

D. Comparative Graphs of NACA D1

Four-Digit Symmetric Airfoils

and Bezier Curve Emulations

E. Comparative Graphs of NACA E_1

Four-Digit Cambered Airfoils

and Bezier Curve Emulations

F. FORTRAN Computer Programs F1

G. Pertinent Data Files G-l

IV
 ABSTRACT

A simple, elegant and modern method of geometric description of NACA Four-digit airfoil

shapes is presented. Results found to closely match conventionally described NACA Four
are

Digit airfoil shapes. The method developed allows user flexibility, and is easily adaptable to
manufacturing processes.
 Acknowledgements

The author acknowledges the following people,

gratefully without whose help this project might
never have occurred.

Dr. Charles W. Haines, Dr. Panchapakesan Venkataraman, Dr. Mark H. Kempski, Dr. Chris
Nilsen (who unknowingly led me on the path to the Bezier curve), Mr. George Komorowski and
David Hathaway, all faculty and staff of the Mechanical Engineering Department at RTT.

Mr. Ralph Culliton, my supervisor at AC Rochester, for his patience and understanding during
the last months of this project.

My daughters, Kelly and Megan, who never questioned my absence during the many long nights

away from home.

Lastly, but importantly, my wife Coleen, who gave

most me moral support and took control of

all family matters during the course of my education.

This manuscript was prepared on an IBM PS/2 with WordPerfect Version 5.1; imbedded figures
were generated using DrawPerfect Version 1.1. The majority of the plots were generated using
the Professional Graphics Facility (PGF) on an IBM mainframe. The remainder of the plots were
produced with DIS8, a plotting package available on the Digital Equipment VAX at RIT.

vi
List of Symbols

ah bt, c^ d{ cubic spline interpolant coefficients

Bernfx) Bernstein basis polynomial

B, Bezier curve defining polygon vertex

c chordlength

E Young's modulus of elasticity

f,g arbitrary functions

Fn nth number in Fibonacci sequence

I moment of inertia

Jn,i ith nth-order Bernstein basis function

m maximum camber

M(x) bending moment

P chordwise position of maximum camber

PC*') parametric description of a point

Pn(x) generic polynomial

r leading edge radius

S.(x) cubic spline interpolant

t thickness ratio/distribution

x chordwise position

chordwise position of intersection ofleading

Xint(r)
edge radius and thickness distribution;

^int chordwise position of intersection of trailing

edge angle and the line y=tl2

chordwise position of maximum thickness

(symmetric airfoils)

ordinate of camber line

ordinate of intersection of leading edge radius

yuu
and thickness distribution

yi lower surface ordinate (cambered airfoils)

ordinate of thickness distribution

y,

yu upper surface ordinate (cambered airfoils)

vu
oi correction factor

9 angle between camber line tangent and

horizontal

v parameter

I trailing edge angle

p(x) radius of curvature

t golden section number ( 0.618033989)

$*

golden number ( 1.618033989)

fl, dimensionless parameter

vin
List of Figures

2.1 Typical Symmetric Airfoil Section 5

2.2 Typical Cambered Airfoil Section 7

2.3 Detail of Cambered Airfoil Generation 8

2.4 Illustration
of Airfoil Layout (Upper Surface) Using 9
Loftsman's Spline and Ducks

3.1 Bezier Curve and Defining Polygon 19

3.2 Bernstein Basis Functions 20

3.3 Method of Combining Two Bezier Curves 21

4.1 Illustration of Oscillation Phenomenon 25

4.2 Detail of Intersection of NACA Airfoil and Leading Edge 26

Radius

4.3 Point of Departure -

NACA Airfoil and Leading Edge Radius 28

4.4 Slope at Point of Departure NACA Airfoil and Leading 29

Edge Radius

4.5 Leading Edge of Airfoil and Bezier Defining Polygon 31

4.6 Symmetric Thickness Distribution -

NACA0012 vs. Bezier 33
Case (1,1)
4.7 Symmetric Thickness Distribution -
NACA0012 vs. Bezier 34
Case (1,2)
4.8 Symmetric Thickness Distribution -
NACA0012 vs. Bezier 35
Case (2,1)
4.9 Symmetric Thickness Distribution -
NACA0012 vs. Bezier -
36
Case (2,2)
4.10 Symmetric Thickness Distribution -
NACA0012 vs. Bezier -
37
Case (3,1)
4.11 Symmetric Thickness Distribution -
NACA0012 vs. Bezier -
38
Case (3,2)
4. 12 Symmetric Thickness Distribution NACA0006 vs. Bezier -

40
Case (3,2)
4.13 Symmetric Thickness Distribution NACA00 14 vs. Bezier -
41
Case (3,2)
4.14 Steps in Golden Section Refinement to Determine y, 42

IX
4.15 Symmetric Thickness Distribution -
NACA0012 vs. Bezier 43
Case (4,2)
4.16 Symmetric Thickness Distribution -
NACA0012 vs. B6zier -
44
Case (5,2)
4. 17 Symmetric Thickness Distribution -
NACA0012 vs. Bezier -
45
Case (6,2)

4.18 Symmetric Thickness Distribution -

Leading Edge, Upper 46

Surface NACA0007 vs. B6zier
-

4.19 Symmetric Thickness Distribution Leading Edge, Upper 47

Surface -

NACA0009 vs. Bezier

4.20 Symmetric Thickness Distribution Leading Edge, Upper 48

Surface -

NACA0010 vs. Bezier

4.21 Symmetric Thickness Distribution Leading Edge, Upper 49

Surface -

NACA0012 vs. Bezier

4.22 Symmetric Thickness Distribution -

Leading Edge, Upper 50

Surface -
NACA0014 vs. B6zier

4.23 Symmetric Thickness Distribution -

Leading Edge, Upper 51

Surface NACA0018 vs. Bezier

4.24 Symmetric Thickness Distribution Leading Edge, Upper 52

Surface NACA0020 vs. Bezier

4.25 Refinement of x2 Using Golden Section Method 53

4.26 Symmetric Thickness Distribution -

Leading Edge, Upper 55

Surface NACA0007 vs. Bezier -
Final Iteration

4.27 Symmetric Thickness Distribution -

Leading Edge, Upper 56

Surface NACA0009 vs. Bezier -
Final Iteration

4.28 Symmetric Thickness Distribution Leading Edge, Upper 57

Surface -
NACA0010 vs. Bezier Final Iteration

4.29 Symmetric Thickness Distribution Leading Edge, Upper 58

Surface -
NACA0012 vs. Bezier -
Final Iteration

4.30 Symmetric Thickness Distribution -

Leading Edge, Upper 59

Surface -
NACA0014 vs. Bezier Final Iteration

4.31 Symmetric Thickness Distribution Leading Edge, Upper 60

Surface NACA0018 vs. Bezier Final Iteration

4.32 Symmetric Thickness Distribution Leading Edge, Upper 61

Surface NACA0020 vs. Bezier -
Final Iteration

4.33 Trailing Edge Bezier Defining Polygon 63

4.34 Edge Symmetric Thickness Distribution
Trailing -
65
NACA0012 vs. Bezier Case (1,1)
-

4.35 Edge Symmetric Thickness Distribution

Trailing -
66
NACA0012 vs. B6zier Case (1,2)
-

4.36 Trailing Edge Symmetric Thickness Distribution -

67
NACA0012 vs. B6zier Case (2,1)
-

4.37 Trailing Edge Symmetric Thickness Distribution 68

NACA0012 vs. B6zier Case (2,2)
-

4.38 Edge Symmetric Thickness Distribution

Trailing -
69
NACA0007 vs. Bezier Case (2,1)
-

4.39 Edge Symmetric Thickness Distribution

Trailing -
70
NACA0020 vs. B6zier Case (2,1)
-

4.40 Chordwise Position of Zero Slope vs. Thickness Ratio 74

=
m .01c

4.41 Ordinate of Zero Slope vs. Thickness Ratio -

m =
.01c 75

4.42 Chordwise Position of Zero Slope vs. Thickness Ratio 76

=
m .02c

4.43 Ordinate of Zero Slope vs. Thickness Ratio -

m =
.02c 77

4.44 Chordwise Position of Zero Slope vs. Thickness Ratio 78

=
m .03c

4.45 Ordinate of Zero Slope vs. Thickness Ratio -

m =
.03c 79

4.46 Chordwise Position of Zero Slope vs. Thickness Ratio 80

=
m .04c

4.47 Ordinate of Zero Slope vs. Thickness Ratio -

m =
.04c 81

4.48 Chordwise Position of Zero Slope vs. Thickness Ratio 82

=
m .05c

4.49 Ordinate of Zero Slope vs. Thickness Ratio m =

.05c 83

4.50 Chordwise Position of Zero Slope vs. Thickness Ratio -

84
=
m .06c

4.51 Ordinate of Zero Slope vs. Thickness Ratio m =

.06c 85

4.52 Chordwise Position of Zero Slope vs. Thickness Ratio 86

=
m .01c

4.53 Ordinate of Zero Slope vs. Thickness Ratio -

m =
.07c 87

4.54 Chordwise Position of Zero Slope vs. Thickness Ratio 88

=
m .08c

XI
4.55 Ordinate of Zero Slope vs. Thickness Ratio -
m =
.08c 89

4.56 Chordwise Position of Zero Slope vs. Thickness Ratio -

90
m =
.09c

4.57 Ordinate of Zero Slope vs. Thickness Ratio -

m =
.09c 91

4.58 Attempt At Line Fit To Determine Zero Slope Point 93

4.59 Illustration of The Arc Method 94

4.60 Illustration of The Curve Method 95

4.61 Area of Triangles Method 95

4.62 Cube Plot of Area Ratio for Limit Values of Parameters 96

4.63 Results of Area Ratio Analysis 97

4.64 Linear Correction Factor vs. Chordwise Position of 100

Maximum Camber -
1 =
.05c

4.65 Linear Correction Factor vs. Chordwise Position of 101

Maximum Camber t =
.06c

4.66 Linear Correction Factor vs. Chordwise Position of 102

Maximum Camber t =
.07c

4.67 Linear Correction Factor vs. Chordwise Position of 103

Maximum Camber t =
.08c

4.68 Linear Correction Factor vs. Chordwise Position of 104

Maximum Camber t =
.09c

4.69 Linear Correction Factor vs. Chordwise Position of 105

Maximum Camber -
1 =
.10c

4.70 Linear Correction Factor vs. Chordwise Position of 106

Maximum Camber -
1 =
.lie

4.71 Linear Correction Factor vs. Chordwise Position of 107

Maximum Camber -
1 =
.12c

4.72 Linear Correction Factor vs. Chordwise Position of 108

Maximum Camber -
1 =
.13c

4.73 Linear Correction Factor vs. Chordwise Position of 109

Maximum Camber / =
.14c

4.74 Linear Correction Factor vs. Chordwise Position of 110

Maximum Camber t =
.15c

4.75 Linear Correction Factor vs. Chordwise Position of 110

Maximum Camber t =
.16c

xn
4.76 Linear Correction Factor vs.Chordwise Position of 111
Maximum Camber -
1 =
Ale

4.11 Linear Correction Factor vs. Chordwise Position of 112

Maximum Camber -

1 =
.18c

4.78 Linear Correction Factor vs. Chordwise Position of 113

Maximum Camber -
1 =
.19c

4.79 Linear Correction Factor vs. Chordwise Position of 114

Maximum Camber t =
.20c

4.80 Linear Correction Factor vs. Chordwise Position of 115

Maximum Camber t =
.21c

4.81 Linear Correction Factor vs. Chordwise Position of 116

Maximum Camber t =
.22c

4.82 Linear Correction Factor vs. Chordwise Position of 117

Maximum Camber t =
.23c

4.83 Linear Correction Factor vs. Chordwise Position of 118

Maximum Camber t =
.24c

4.84 Linear Correction Factor vs. Thickness Ratio m =

.02c 119

4.85 Arbitrary Cambered Airfoil Upper Supper Surface, 0<x<p, 122

and Tangent Triangle

4.86 Triangles Generated About Cambered Airfoil 126

4.87 Bezier Emulation NACA2412 -

Case (1,1) 130

4.88 B6zier Emulation -

NACA2412 Case (1,2) 131

4.89 Bezier Emulation -

NACA24 12 Case (2,1) 132

4.90 Bezier Emulation -

NACA2412 Case (2,2) 133

4.91 Bezier Emulation -

NACA3612 Case (1,1) 136

4.92 Bezier Emulation -

NACA3612 -
Case (1,2) 137

4.93 Bezier Emulation -

NACA3612 Case (2,1) 138

4.94 Bezier Emulation -

NACA3612 Case (2,2) 139

4.95 B6zier Emulation -

NACA4412 Case (1,1) 142

4.96 Bezier Emulation -

NACA4412 -

Case (1,2) 143

4.97 Bezier Emulation NACA4412 Case (2,1) 144

4.98 Bezier Emulation -

NACA44 12 Case (2,2) 145

4.99 Bezier Emulation -

NACA24 18 Case (1,1) 146

4.100 Bezier Emulation -

NACA2418 Case (1,2) 147

xiii
 Case 148
4. 101 B6zier Emulation -
NACA2418 -

(2, 1)
4.102 B6zier Emulation -
NACA2418 -

Case (2,2) 149

4.103 Genfoil Program Flowchart 151

xiv
List of Tables
2.1 Coordinates for 12 Percent Thick NACA 6
Four-Digit Symmetric Airfoil (NACA0012)
2.2 Coordinate Generation for NACA2412 Airfoil 8

4.1 Visual Effects of Variation of Bezier Defining Polygon Inner 39

Vertices

4.2 Manual Refinement Process to Determine x2 53

4.3 Absolute and Least-Squares Error for Various Thickness 72

Ratios -

Bezier vs. Conventional

Linear Regression 92
4.4 Coefficients of [4.10] As Determined By
4.5 Limit Values For Descriptive Parameters 97

4.6 Area Ratios For Limit Values of Descriptive Parameters 97

4.7 Results of Dimensionless Parameter Analysis 99

xv
1. Introduction

1.1 A Brief History of Airfoils and Aeronautical Development8

From the earliest of times, man has been enthralled with the idea of flight. From the myth of
Icarus to the first powered flight by the Wright brothers, the human spirit has longed to mingle
with the clouds.

The first manifestations of man's attempts at flight from birds. Various

came directly unnamed

persons throughout ancient and medieval times attached some sort of wings to their arms in an

always futile attempt at flight. The Renaissance period was characterized by mechanical devices
driven by arms, legs or some type of body movement. These machines are known as
ornithopters. The surviving manuscripts of Leonardo da Vinci contain over 35,000 words and
500 sketches that deal with flight1. The great majority of them were of proposed ornithopters.

In the late 1700's, the Montgolfier brothers, French paper makers, constructed a balloon which

trapped hot air produced

by a fire contained within a wicker basket hanging below it. Man was

finally airborne. Although hot air balloons actually did nothing as far as advancing the cause of
powered flight, they did prove publicly that man could rise above the surface of the earth. In
this respect, they fueled the notion that flight was indeed possible. Balloons were the only means
of flight for over one hundred years.

The firstmajor breakthrough in aeronautics came from a now obscure English nobleman, Sir

George Cayley. In 1799, he inscribed on a silver disc the concept of a fixed wing craft which
had a separate means of propulsion. On the opposite side of the disc is an illustration of the
resultant forces on a wing, indicating clearly what are known as lift and drag today. Though this

may seem trivial today, given man's major advances in the field of aeronautics, it was a major
breakthrough at the time. He fashioned the first emulation of a wind tunnel, a long mechanical
arm at the end of which he could attach primitive models of aircraft, although at the time he had
no inclination that after repeated revolutions the air would begin to move with the arm. In 1804,
Cayley designed, built and flew a small model glider which represented the first modern

configuration aircraft in history2. In 1809 and 1810, Cayley authored a monumental triple paper

entitled "On Aerial Navigation", published in various issues of Nicholson's Journal of Natural
Philosophy. It was the first treatment of theoretical and applied aerodynamics ever published.
In these papers, Cayley 's contention was that the basic function of a flying machine is "to make
"
a surface support a given weight by the application of power to the resistance of air. He was

the first to realize that lift on a curved surface (airfoil) is due to a region of low pressure on the

top of the surface. Cayley built and tested a full-size airplane in 1849. During some of these

tests, a young boy rose several meters off the ground while the craft glided down an incline.
Cayley'
This craft was a triplane, and s idea of using multiple wings was prevalent for quite
some years afterward. In 1852, he paper, "Sir George Cayley's Governable
published a
Parachutes"
which appeared in Mechanics Magazine. This monumental paper gave illustrations
of a craft which contained necessary parts for a modern
nearly all aircraft. It is unfortunate that

his works drifted into obscurity shortly after his death in 1857.

9
Much of the material for this section was obtained from Introduction to Flight. Third Edition, reference (2).
The next great pioneer of aviation was Otto
Lilienthal, a German. He recognized the fact that
in order to produce a machine capableflight, one had to have a good grasp of the
of of
"feel"

an aircraft. His book, entitled Der

Vogelflug als Grundelage der Fliegekunst (Bird Flight as the
Basis of Aviation) was an early classic in aviation literature. In
it, Lilienthal studied the structure
of bird's wings and applied the aerodynamic information to the design
of mechanical flight. In

1891, Lilienthal made his firstflight in a glider of his own design. He made over
successful
2500 flights in various gliders over the next five years. He experimented with slats at the end
of each wing, but these efforts result ended in failure. His death in 1896 was the result of a

crash.

Among the pioneers in

America, the director of the Smithsonian Institute and distinguished
scholar Samuel Pierpont Langley began his studies of powered flight in 1887; Langley coined
"aerodromes"
the term for his designs. In 1903, he attempted two highly publicized piloted
flights, the last just weeks before Wilbur and Orville Wright's historic flights at Kill Devil Hills,
North Carolina. In both instances, his aerodromes left their launch platform and went straight
into the Potomac River. Following this public humiliation, he retired in despair.

The Wright brothers hailed from Dayton, Ohio where they ran a successful bicycle shop. Their
interest in flight was largely due to the exploits of Otto Lilienthal, whose pictures in flight were

distributed worldwide. Wilbur's studies of birds in flight led him to the conclusion that birds
"regain their lateral balance when partly overturned by a gust of wind, by a torsion of the tips
of the wings"3. This was one of the most important developments in aviation history; ailerons

are a direct result. After much experimentation with gliders, the Wright brothers decided that
a significant portion of the aerodynamic data published by Lilienthal and Langley was in error.
They in their bicycle shop in Dayton and tested over 200 different
constructed a wind tunnel

airfoils. Additionally, they designed a force balance to accurately measure lift and drag. Their

research culminated on December 17, 1903 when the Wright Flyer took to the air off the sand

dunes at Kill Devil Hills. Aviation would never look back.

The Wright brothers made numerous technical advances after that first flight, but became very
secretive until their machine was finally patented in 1906. After 1910, the Wright's influence
declined due to legal battles between them and another aviation pioneer, Glenn Curtis. During
this time, the Europeans took the forefront in France, Gustav Eiffel
aeronautical research. In
built a wind tunnel complex at the base of his magnificent tower; the French Army built a

laboratory at Chalais-Meudon and there existed also a facility at the Institut Aerotechnique de
St.-Cyr. Germany held facilities at Gottingen University, the technical colleges of Aachen and

Berlin, a government operated laboratory at Adlershof as well as numerous industrial research

sites3. Russia and Italy had advanced laboratories also. Some early work was also performed
by
the British Government at the National Physical Laboratory, leading to a series of airfoils used

during World War I.

With the outbreak of war on the European continent, aircraft became more than just an item of

curiosity; leaders saw it as an effective and efficient tool of war. In 1915, the Smithsonian
Institution sponsored a resolution in the U.S. Congress to legislate a committee to explore and
continue aeronautical research. The political leaders and scientific community of America
realized that they had fallen behind the Europeans in this area. On March 3, 1915 the Advisory
Committee for Aeronautics was formed. At the first meeting, the word was added
"National"

to the name. Thus the NACA was born.

One of the first acts of the NACA was to survey existing facilities in the military, private
industry, and educational institutions in the area of flight research. From this survey it was

concluded that a new

facility was
required, one that would encompass both facets of flight as
it was known:
then for small scale simulation, and facilities to study full size
a laboratory

aircraft in flight. It was decided that ground be broken at a site near

Hampton, Virginia. This
Langley.3
laboratory was to be known as Langley Field, named after Samuel Pierpont

From the wind tunnels at Langley poured tremendous amounts of data. In 1917, Lt. Col. Edgar
S. Gorrell and Major H. S. Martin presented NACA report no. 18, "Aerofoils and Aerofoil
Combinations"
Structural . In this report, Gorrell and Martin reported that

... we are able to design aerofoils only by consideration of those forms which have been successful,
by applying general rules learned by experience, and by then testing the aerofoils in a reliable
wind tunnel.

For the first time, the United States was able to systematically study airfoils. The research center

at Langley soon became the world leader in

1933, aeronautics.460, "The
In NACA report no.
Tunnel"
Characteristics of 78 Related Airfoil Sections from Tests in the Variable-Density Wind
was presented by Eastman N. Jacobs, Kenneth E. Ward, and Robert M. Pinkerton. It was

discovered that airfoil effects could be attributed to two geometric quantities: thickness
distribution and mean line (camber). Out of this work came the NACA four-digit airfoil series.

They are the ones researched in this paper, as they are derived from purely geometric, versus

aerodynamic, parameters. It was found that the thickness distributions of some of the early,
'Y'
more efficient airfoils such as the Gottingen 398 and the Clark were essentially similar to
the NACA four-digit families once the mean lines were removed and they were reduced to the
thickness.4

same maximum It is important to note here that the NACA Five-digit series of

airfoils utilizes the same thickness distribution as the Four-digit series, though camber lines for
the Five-digit series rely on aerodynamic performance for their generation.

In 1949 a monumental work, Theory of Wing Sections (Including a Summary of Airfoil Data),
was published by Abbott and von Doenhoff. This work summarized the work done to that point

by NACA and included wind tunnel test results for many of the airfoil sections then in use. It
is still considered the definitive reference on wing sections. The work of Abbott, von Doenhoff
and others continued at Langley until 1958, when the Russians launched Sputnik I. NACA was

disbanded and absorbed into the newly formed National Aeronautics and Space Administration
(NASA). Very little research went into conventional airfoil design at this time, as all available
resources were utilized in the attempt to catch up to the Russians in the "space race".

With the dawn of the computer age came parallel advances in airfoil design and analysis.

Layer theory, first introduced

by Ludwig 1904, Prandtl in
future designers the gave
Boundary
mathematical tools for airfoil analysis, but not until the advent of high-speed computers were
researchers able to exploit this theory to the fullest. Modern day airfoils are designed using a

process known as conformal mapping, where a known two-dimensional shape (in this case an
 section) is algebraically transformed into a simple shape (an off-center circle) in the
airfoil

complex plane and a simple flow is then analyzed around it. Results of this analysis are then

mapped back into the real plane. While this method yields results which compare quite
favorably
with wind tunnel testing, the ability to slightly alter the shape with the intent of optimizing
aerodynamic performance can
currently only be accomplished between successive iterations. The
speed of new computers and
efficiency of new algorithms are such that one should be able to
analyze fluid flow in the real plane,
"tweaking"
the airfoil shape along the way to produce the
desired results.

1 .2 Direction of Research

Advances in both mathematics and the ability to process calculations quickly and accurately have
radically changed technology. These advances, the rapidly growing field of
coupled with
computer graphics, have revolutionized approaches to design. With these
advances, it seems
logical that airfoil design should proceed along the same lines. In the case of the NACA four-

digit airfoils, it has not. As previously mentioned, the definitive reference on this important
family of airfoils was first published in 19495. In order to facilitate geometric reproduction of
these shapes as a prelude to Computational Fluid Dynamic (CFD) analysis, it was desirable to
determine a method whereby airfoils could be emulated with a minimum of both geometric

parameters and arithmetic operations, while control over their shape and transformation are kept

relatively simple. The importance of redescribing airfoils is to be able to effectively attain local
control of the shape.

In this regard, it first desired to determine a method whereby the aesthetically pleasing
was

shape of the be emulated, then modified. Since the concepts of flight and
airfoil section could

airfoil sections were first influenced by nature, it seemed logical that nature would be an
"regression"

appropriate starting point in the attempt to generate these shapes. This seeming of

technology -getting back to the basics was fundamental -

in this research. This return to nature

begins with the Golden Section.

1.3 The Golden Section

Also known as the Golden Ratio or Golden Number, this ratio and its properties pervade nature

and has intrigued man through the ages. Its existence has been known since ancient times, and
many cultures have attempted to incorporate this proportion into aesthetically pleasing shapes.
Throughout history men have attempted to tie this number into everything from architecture to
the stock market6, and this work will attempt to make a connection with geometric forms

originally derived by other means. While a thorough treatment would encompass many volumes,
a minor overview of this fascinating relationship and numerous examples are included for
reference in Appendix A.
2. NACA Four-Digit Airfoils

2.1 Symmetric Airfoils

2.1.1 Nomenclature

As previously mentioned, the NACA four-digit families can be described in terms of geometric
parameters. The symmetric airfoils are the simplest
case; they will be discussed first. Figure
2.1. provides an illustration of required geometric parameters common to all NACA four-digit
symmetric airfoil sections.

Figure 2.1. Typical Symmetric Airfoil Section

Given parameters are defined as:

c chordlength

t maximum thickness
r leading edge radius

| trailing edge angle

2.1.2 Thickness distribution

The NACA investigations previously mentioned (for the four-digit families) led to a unified
method for defining the thickness distribution for these symmetric airfoil sections which was

dependent only on the maximum thickness, t. The best-fit curve to define these experimentally
derived airfoils is

2843a:3
+
y,
=
-( .2969V5~-. 126*
-.3516x2

+ .
) [2.1]

where y, is the ordinate (y-coordinate) at any chordwise position x. The chordwise position can

take any value from jc=0 to x=l. Thus x and y are not actual numerical values, but ratios of

chordwise position and thickness to chordlength. Established convention dictates that the use of

x,t,or y (or in the case of cambered airfoils x, y m, p, t, yc, xu, xh yu and y;) are assumed to
be decimal of chordlength. The use of this convention allows for ease of notation and will

prevent "notational clutter", aiding the reader.

In order to determine the position on the chord where the airfoil attains its maximum thickness,
the root of the derivative of [2.1] , given by
.14845

,i-L( -

.126
-

.7032a + -

) [2.2]
\fx

must be found.

The resultant value, using the Newton-Raphson technique, is x^

solved 0.299827878c. For =

practical purposes, this value is assumed to be 0.3c and is independent of the value of t.

2.1.3 Leading Edge Radius

The leading edge radius, r, varies with the square of t and is given by
1.1019*2
r =
[2.3]

2.1.4 Trailing Edge Angle

Trailing edge angle, is determined by inserting a value of a=1 in equation [2.2]. At x=l,

tan? =yi(l)
=
-1.16925? [2.4]

Prior to the advent of computers, it was standard practice to look up a table of coordinates for
these airfoils. Because [2. 1] is linearly dependent on t , all one needed to do to reproduce a four-
digit symmetric airfoil of arbitrary thickness was to scale between ordinates of a given thickness
airfoil and the thickness of the desired airfoil. Table 2. 1 is an example of published information5
from which a new airfoil could be constructed.

Table 2.1 Coordinates for 12 Percent Thick NACA Four-Digit

Symmetric Airfoil (NACA0012)

x, percent chord y, percent chord x, percent chord y, percent chord

0.5 30. 6.002

1.25 1.894 40. 5.803
2.5 2.615 50. 5.294

5.0 3.555 60. 4.563

7.5 4.200 70. 3.664

10. 4.683 80. 2.623

15. 5.345 90. 1.448

20. 5.737 95. 0.807

25. 5.941 100. 0.126

2.2 Cambered Airfoils

Cambered (asymmetric) airfoil sections are more complex in nature, requiring more geometric

parameters to define. They are assumed to be a superposition of a symmetric thickness

distribution over a curved line known as the camber, or mean, line. Figure 2.2. illustrates this
scheme.

Figure 2.2. Typical Cambered Airfoil Section

2.2.1 Nomenclature

New parameters, in addition to those listed for the symmetric airfoil, are

yu upper surface ordinate

y. lower surface ordinate

yc camber line
m maximum camber in percent of chord

chordwise position of maximum camber

p

2.2.2 Mean Line

The mean line has been defined as two parabolic arcs which are tangent at the chordwise

position of maximum camber. For NACA four-digit airfoils, these arcs are given by

yc
= H (2px -

x2) , 0<x<p
P [2.5]
m
= [(1 -

2p) + 2px -

x2] p<x<c
yc ,

(i -pY

The slope of the camber line at any point a important quantity in generating
is an airfoil

coordinates. For an arbitrary x (0<a< 1) the tangent is determined by

,
_
2m ,
N
0<A</>
tan0 {p
-
=
y
=
x) ,

P [2.6]
i
2m
tan0
~
p<x<c
= =.
XP x) ,

(1 ~P)
2.2.3 Method of
Combining Thickness Distribution and Mean Line

Generation of cambered airfoils is in the The

accomplished following manner. slope of the
camber line at any arbitrary position x (0 < x <
c) is equal to tan 6, as shown in Figure 2.3.

Cvy_)

Figure 2.3. Detail of Cambered Airfoil Generation

Mathematically, thickness distributions are combined with the camber line by the following
method. The upper surface coordinates are computed
by
=
x -

sin0
xu yt [2.7a]
= + cos0
yu yc y,

The corresponding expressions for the lower surface coordinates are determined by
sinfl
x,=x+yt [2Jb]
cose
-

yt =yc y,

In order to generate a set of coordinates for a four-digit airfoil, a table similar to that illustrated
in Table 2.2 must be constructed.

Table 2.2 Coordinate Generation for NACA2412 Airfoil

X y, yc tanfl sin 6 cos 6 y, sin 8 y, cos 6 *D y *i yL

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

0.005 0.01221 0.00050 0.09875 0.09827 0.99516 0.00120 0.00122 0.00380 0.00172 0.00620 -0.0007

0.05 0.03555 0.00469 0.08750 0.08717 0.99619 0.00310 0.03541 0.04690 0.04010 0.05310 -0.0307

0.25 0.05941 0.01719 0.03750 0.03747 0.99930 0.00227 0.05937 0.24773 0.07656 0.25227 -0.0422

0.50 0.05294 0.00588 -0.2381 -0.2316 0.97281 -0.0123 0.05150 0.51230 0.05738 0.48770 -0.0456

0.75 0.03160 .003990 -0.8333 -0.6402 0.76822 -0.0202 0.02428 0.77020 0.02827 0.72980 -0.0203

1.00 0 0 0 0 1.00000 0 1.00000 0

It is easily seen that construction of a table similar to that shown on the previous page could be
very time consuming, given that the preferred method of calculation of the day was the slide
rule. Even with the new technology, it is estimated that airfoil coordinate generation can
consume up to sixty percent of total processing time.

2.3 NACA Designation Scheme

The four-digit airfoil section

family received its name from the fact that any airfoil in the series,
whether symmetric or cambered could be described using four digits. The designation rules are
as follows: for an airfoil designated NACAwxyz, the following rules apply:

w denotes maximum camber in percent of chord

a denotes chordwise position of maximum camber in tenths of chord

yz denotes maximum thickness in percent of chord

Thus a NACA2412 is a twelve percent thick airfoil with two percent maximum camber, located
at .4c;
a NACA0018 is an eighteen percent thick symmetric airfoil.

2.4 Method of Manual Layout

The first item to be generated is the leading edge radius. On a cambered airfoil, the center of

the radius is assumed to lie tangent to the mean-line at a chordwise position x =

0.005c.
To correlate data as generated in Table 2.2 to a physical medium, a process known as lofting
is used. Given specified data points, a long, narrow plastic or wooden strip, or spline, is shaped
by lead weights called ducks. By varying the number and position of the ducks, the loftsman's
spline is made to pass through the given data points such that the curve appears "smooth, fair
or pleasing to the eye"7. In the case of the airfoil, the loftsman's spline may be clamped at either

end in order to specify a slope. Figure 2.4. shows details of this process as applied to airfoil
layout.

Figure 2.4. Illustration of Airfoil Layout (Upper Surface) Using Loftsman's Spline and Ducks

Considering the spline as a thin elastic beam, the shape of the spline, corresponding to the
deflection of the beam y, is obtained from the bending moment M(a) along the length of the
beam. From Euler's equation8,

M(x) = IL P-8]
p(A)
Where:
E is Young's Modulus, determined
by material properties of the beam
/ is the moment of inertia, determined
by the cross-sectional shape of the beam
p(x) is the radius of curvature at
any point x along the beam

(y'
For small deflections 1), the radius of curvature is
closely approximated by
1 _
y"

y"

3/2
-
[2.9]
P(x) [1 +
(y')2]

Thus, according to Euler's equation,

/'
= ^1 [2.10]
EI

Assuming the ducks act as simple supports and the spline is of uniform material and cross-

section (E and / are constant over the entire length of the spline), the bending moment is known
to vary linearly between supports8. Making the substitution M(x) =
Ax + B, Euler's equation

becomes

Ax + B
[2.11]
y"
=
J
EI

Integration twice yields

y
=
Ax3
+
Bx2
+ Cx + D P12!

Where the flexural modulus (EI) has been absorbed into the coefficients A,B,C and D. Thus
between any two supports (data points), the geometric description of the shape of the loftsman's
spline is a cubic real polynomial. This is used as a starting point for further research.

10
3. Approximation Techniques

3.1 Polynomial Approximation

3.1.1 Cubic Spline Interpolation

As previously mentioned, the loftman's spline can be described mathematically as a piecewise

cubic polynomial. Given n+\ data points,
(pcy} {i=0,l,...,n} , the (n-1) cubic spline segments
St(x) that make up the set of spline interpolants S for a function/is a function that must satisfy
the following conditions9:

a) S is polynomial, denoted 5 on the

a cubic sub-interval [aa1+1] for each i =0,1,..., n-1;

b) Si(x^=jXx,) for each *'=0,l,...,n;

c) Si+i(xi+l)=S{(xi+1) for each i=0,l,...,n-2;

d) S'i+l(pcl+J=S'ficl+J for each z=0,l,...,n-2;
e) S"i+l(xi+l)=S"i(xi+l) for each i=0,l,...,n-2;
f) one ofthe following sets of boundary conditions is satisfied:

i) "(a0) =S"(xn) =0 (Free boundary)

ii) S '(a0) =f'(x0) and S '(a) =/'(a) (Clamped boundary)

Mixed boundary conditions are also possible, but will not be considered. A thorough treatment
of the theory of cubic splines and the mathematical derivations of both types is contained in
Appendix B.

The n+1 data points are used to generate n cubic spline segments of the form

5(a) =
a.(x
-
a,.)3

+ b.(x -
a.)2
+ c.(x -

a.) + d. [3-1]

One of the disadvantages of natural cubic splines is that end conditions are assumed. If slopes

at the ends are specified, more useful information is used in generating the spline coefficients.

3.1.2 Discrete Least-Squares Approximations

The concept behind least-squares approximation theory is minimizing the square of the
one of

error involved in fitting a polynomial to a data set. For the problem attempted in this research,
a linear fit to data corresponding to an airfoil would be ridiculous, and will not be considered.

Higher order (rational) polynomials, however will be investigated, and as such will be discussed
here9.

11
Missing Page
The general objective boils down to approximating data
a set {(a y,) | /=0,1,...,M}, with a

polynomial, Pn(x), given by

Ea***
PW =
n<M

which requires
finding the optimum polynomial coefficients, ak, to minimize the least-squares
error

e =
E <yt
i =
0
-

nxt)f

MM M
=
E?,-2 E(^,))2
-2E^)r
i = 0 i =
0 I = 0

M M M

=E*2-2E
i =
0 i =
0
E = 0
aixi *.?
I =
o
E = 0
a;xJ
7 7

M M M
EV"
=E^2-2E^-

i 0 o
E ytxt
i 0
+
E E 0 k 0
ajak
i 0
=
; = =
] = = =

For E to be minimized, it is necessary that dE/da. 0 for 7=0, l,...,n. Thus for
=
each

each;,
M n M

0 = =
-2Yy.xi +
2TakTxr
^ kA^
[3.2]
^ ' l '
da. i =
0 it =
0 i =
0

This yields (n+1) equations in (n+1) unknowns, called the normal equations,

n M M
+
*= E?.*/' [3-3]
k
EJ>/
=
0 i =
0 i - 0
;=0,l,...,n

The solution to this set of equations is unique provided that the a for i =0, 1 , . . . ,M are distinct.
The scope of this research entailed analyzing least-squares polynomials of orders two and three,
as it felt that any higher-order polynomials would not add any value in reaching the final
was

objective; there is also a serious drawback prohibiting the use of these polynomials, which will
be explained in section 3.2.1.

3.2 Parametric Curves

In two dimensions, a curve is commonly represented as the explicit relation

[3-4]
y
=
F(x)

17
For a single value of a, a distinct value of y is obtained. Equation [2.1] is the thickness
distribution for a NACA four-digit airfoil section in explicit form. The explicit form cannot
represent a multi-valued curve that loops over itself or a closed curve11. An alternative in this
situation is to utilize the implicit form

G(x,y) =
0 [3.5]

Finding a point on the curve G(x,y) may, however, require determining the root of an algebraic
or transcendental equation. Both the explicit and implicit forms of curve representation are axis-

dependent. Thus the choice of coordinate axes affects their ease of use. For example, if, in the
chosen coordinate system, an infinite slope is required as a boundary condition, difficulties arise.
This infinite slope cannot, therefore, be directly used as a boundary condition. Either the
coordinate system orientation must be changed (coordinate transformation), or the infinite slope
boundary condition must be represented by a very large (but finite) positive or negative value.
Furthermore, when points on an axis-dependent non-parametric curve are computed at equal

increments in either x or y, they are not evenly distributed along the length of the curve. This
unequal distribution of points affects the graphical
quality of the curve11. An alternative to this
approach is the use of parametric curves. These geometric representations use an arbitrary

parameter v to specify both a and y coordinates, such that

x =f(p) [3.6]
=
y <?(")

There are several advantages to the parametric form over the explicit form. Each parametric

value, v, defines a unique pair of coordinates, a and y, for a point on the curve. A bounded
segment on the curve can be obtained by limiting the values of v to lie within a specified range.

It is usually possible to express parametric curves as a matrix, a form that will be useful in
computer implementation of coordinates for these curves. A point P thus described can be put

into matrix form as

P(") =
> <

The derivative of the curve for any value of the parameter, v, is given by

x'(v)
p'dO =
.

y'()

'
where the denotes differentiation with respect to p.

According to the chain rule, the slope of the curve, dyldx, is given by

dy dyldv y'(v)
=
_
[3.7]
dx dxldv x'(v)

18
Note that when x'(p)=Q, the slope of the curve is infinite. Therefore, an infinite slope can be
easily specified by making one component of the tangent vector equal to zero. In this way,
computational difficulties arising from specifying an infinite slope as a boundary condition are

easily overcome.

3.2.1 Bezier Curves

The cubic spline interpolant curves described in section 3.1 are constrained by the fact that the
curve is required to pass through existing data points. In order to efficiently reproduce a NACA
four-digit airfoil, a minimum number of function evaluations of equation [2. 1] are desired (one
evaluation to determine the ordinate for a given chordwise position). The Bezier curve,
introduced French Pierre Bezier, is which was developed
by mathematician a parametric curve

from both functional and aesthetic concerns. Although this ah initio design tool was initially
derived through geometric considerations, it has been shown that the result of the curve is a

special case of the Bernstein basis, or polynomial approximation function7. Given a function/
defined9
defined on [0,1], the Bernstein polynomial of degree n for /is as

n
(1
A)B
[3.18]
E
A*

Bern(x) =
f -

k = 0

In the case of the Bezier curve, /(a) = 1.

A Bezier curve is determined by a defining polygon as shown in Figure 3.1, below.

B2

Figure 3.1 Bezier Curve and Defining Polygon

be derived from the Bernstein basis, several properties of these

Because the Bezier curve can

curves are known7. Some of the more important are:

The basis functions are real.

The degree of the polynomial defining the curve segment is one less than the number

of defining polygon points.

The curve generally follows the shape of the defining polygon.

The first and last points on the curve are coincident with the first and last points of

the defining polygon.

19
 The tangent vectors at the ends of the curve have the same direction as the first and
last polygon spans, respectively.

The curve is contained within the convex hull the i.e. ,

of defining polygon, within the
largest convex polygon obtainable with the defining polygon vertices. In Figure 3.1,
the convex hull is shown by the dashed lines.

The curve exhibits the variation

diminishing property: the curve does not oscillate
about any straight line more often than the polygon itself.

The curve is invariant under an affine (linear) transformation.

Mathematically, a parametric Bezier curve is defined by

P(?) =
EB,J 0<<1 [3-9]
i =
0

where B, denotes the (2x1) matrix for the ith defining polygon vertex and the Bezier, or
basis^
Bernstein is

Jn.i.(p)
v '
=
V\l
~
I*)'"'

[3.10]

with

n n!

i\(n -

/)!

JnJ(p) is the Bernstein basis function. In this notation, n is the degree of the defining
z'th nth-order

Bernstein basis function and also the degree of the Bezier curve. It is also one less than the
number of vertices in the
defining polygon. Figure 3.2, on the following page, illustrates the
Bernstein basis functions for (a) n =2, (b) n=3.

(a) (b)

Figure 3.2 Bernstein Basis Functions

1
The terminology 7Bi is consistent with the source of this material, Mathematical Elements for Computer Graphics.
reference (7), and should not be confused with similar terminology denoting Bessel functions.

20
Another useful
property of B6zier curves is the ability to specify the slope of the curve at a
predetermined point. This is accomplished by utilizing two curves and two defining polygons,
with the two polygons having an aggregate three consecutive collinear vertices, ABC, as
illustrated in Figure 3.3 below.

Figure 3.3 Method of Combining Two Bezier Curves

3.2.2 Matrix Formulation for Bezier Curve

The equation for a B6zier curve can be expressed in matrix form as

POO =[f][g]

where

Br
B,T

[F] =
[Jn,0 Jn,X -

Jn,n] and
[g] =

Of particular interest are Bezier curves of order n=2 and n=3. Recall that previously for n=2,
the resulting curve is parabolic in nature, and the defining polygon is described by three points.
Thus

B0T

B.T

P(j>) =
[(1 -
p)2

2p(\ -

p) p2]
B2T

Expanding the preceding into powers of the parameter p, the following is obtained

21
 1 -2 1
[p2 B,T
P(0 =
p
l] 2 2 0

1 0 0 B2T

Similarly, for n=3 (a cubic curve with four defining polygon vertices),

-1 3-3 1 V
[p3
3-630 sr
P(j>)
p2
=
p
l] B2T
-3300

10 0 0 B3T

3.2.3 Derivatives of Bezier Curve

For any point on the Bezier curve, the first derivative P'(*0> is computed by
n

Ybj'
v'(p)
v '
=
_!_
i
.

n,i
i =
0

The second derivative, P"^) is given by

p =

e *Ki
i = 0

By formal differentiation,

J'M = {iV-!(l -
p)"-'
-

(n -

*>'(!
"

pY'1'1}

[3.11]

and

(i -

npf
-
np2
-

i(l -

2p) [3.12]
j:m =

-
p)2
\JnM
*>2(1

22
Numerical evaluation of equations [3.11] and [3.12] at p=0 and p=\ creates difficulties. Thus
the rth derivative at p=0 is given by

i r
-'W =
B [3.13]
i

The derivative at p=\ is

n[ r
Pr(l) y (-1V
V ' B [3.14]
(n -

r)! & i

First derivatives at both ends of the Bezier curve are therefore

P'(0) =
n(Bt
-

B0)
[3.15]
P'(l)=n(Bn-Bn.1)

Thus the tangent vector at each end of the parametric curve segment has the same direction as

its respective polygon span. (Recall that each B, is a (2x1) matrix in itself).

Second derivatives at the ends are given as

P"(0) =
n(n -

1)(B0 2B, B2)

-
+
[3.16]
P"(l) =n(n
-

1)(B_-2B..1 +B.2)
For the cubic Bezier curves used in this analysis the first and second derivatives can be
expressed in matrix form as

"B0T"

-3 9-9 3 B,T

[p2
P'(j>) =
p
l] 6-12 6 0

-3 3 0 0 B/

B3T.
and

B,T

-6 -18 6
V"(p) =
[p l] 6 6 0 B2T

B3T

This difficulties in computing slope and curvature

method alleviates at endpoints and will

simplify coding to determine derivatives at the endpoints of the curves.

23
4. Results of Analysis

The schemes presented in the previous sections were implemented in the attempt to discover an

efficient method of reproducing the NACA four-digit airfoils. FORTRAN computer programs
for all the routines involved in the analysis are included as Appendix
F, in order of appearance
in this section. Because symmetric airfoil sections are
computationally less complex than their
cambered counterparts, a decision was made not to attempt to emulate cambered airfoils with

methods that proved unsuitable in the symmetric case. In the analysis that follows, symmetric
airfoil sections are discussed and a viable method for reproducing them is finally established.

4.1 Symmetric Airfoils

4.1.1 Cubic Spline Interpolation

As previously mentioned, cubic spline interpolants have some distinct disadvantages in emulating
the shape of the airfoils in question. Among these are:

The curve must pass through the specified data points. Logically, one may infer that
the interpolant need not necessarily pass through points on the desired curve which are
not specified.

A predefined slope at some intermediate point on the desired curve cannot be

specified.

It is possible for the cubic spline interpolant between two consecutive data points to
possess two points of inflection12. In effect, the cubic spline interpolant will vary along
the length of the desired shape, with error between the two curves becoming less as

the slope of the desired curve decreases. This property shall be referred to as the
oscillation phenomenon. See Figure 4.1 on the following page for an illustration.

All the symmetric airfoils discussed possess the property of having an infinite leading
edge slope. (This is evident from equation [2.2] with a=0).

4.1.1.1 Natural Cubic Splines

The last disadvantage listed above proved to be the most limiting. From this property, a cubic
spline segment to fit the leading edge portion of the curve must possess a first-order variable
coefficient of infinity. This obstacle alone eliminates natural splines from contention in the
search for a more computationally efficient method of airfoil emulation.

24
 LU
z if)
h-
Zi
Q. z
CO o
O Q_
fl m

1
-J

o o o

fl <
Q
Ld
z
o
Q.
< 2
"?
o 2
3
s <
z O
o
o

o 1 i
i
o

fl c
o
c
u

o
c
,fl u
mm

cm
c
o

fl O
o
H

ctf fi
3

o
CO
o

o
axBUipio

25
4.1.1.2 Clamped Cubic Splines

In order to bypass the infinite leading edge slope difficulty, recall from section 2.2.2 that
equation [2.1] describes a circle for the initial portion of its path. Thus it seems logical that
finding the point where the prescribed curve departs from the circle
defining the leading edge
radius is a natural first step in attempting to overcome the problem of infinite slope at the
leading edge, as illustrated in Figure 4.2 below.

NACA Four-Digit Airfoil

Leading Edge Radius

Chord Line

Figure 4.2 Detail of Intersection of NACA Airfoil and Leading Edge Radius

Knowing the leading edge radius of the airfoil from equation [2.3], it is a simple matter to

determine the formula for a circle having this radius in Cartesian coordinates. Defining the
origin as the leading edge,

(a
r)2 y2 r2
-
+ =

or

=
+V*(2r -a) =
t1 [4-1]
y -a)

The positive and negative values of [4.1] correspond to the upper and lower surfaces,
respectively. For the upper surface, the point of intersection of the leading edge radius and

NACA thickness distribution is obtained by solving

0 =
5t(.2969s[x -

.126a
-
+ -

.1015a4)
[4.2]
-
^(2.2038^ -

a)

Note that [4.2] is dependent upon the thickness distribution of the airfoil section, t. It is obvious
from this equation that a root lies at a=0, yet this root is meaningless to the task at hand. The
FORTRAN program NEWTON.FOR was implemented in order to attempt find the root to [4.2]
for numerous values of t. Newton-Raphson did not converge to a solution, although the reason
for this was not obvious until the true root was found (this equation possesses a local minimum
between a=0 and the desired root).

26
It should be
here that conventionally this particular point is taken to be the airfoil
noted

coordinate at The ordinate values at a=. 0005c are

.0005c.
for the defined shape of .003945479

the NACA0012 airfoil, and for the ordinate of the circle which describes the leading
.003951881

edge radius of the same airfoil. This represents a relative error of acceptable
.16225
percent,
at this point, but the two slopes
when are computed, the relative error grows to nearly half a
percent. This may seem insignificant, however experience shows that a very minor deviation
between the true curve and the leading edge radius is
greatly amplified by the cubic spline
interpolant.

The bisection method, guaranteed to provide meaningful results without regard to computational

efficiency, was then employed. A plot NACA

of chordwise position of
leading edge radius and
four-digit airfoil upper surface intersection points versus thickness ratio is given as Figure 4.3
for .02
<t< .40 on the following page. Additionally, tangents to the leading edge radius at these
points, given by
<1-1019'2 -
W/W2-2'"8'2 -

,
.
[4.3]
y*
W2.2038 <*-*,,)

as a function of thickness ratio were also tabulated. Figure 4.4, page 29, was generated using
these results. This data is compiled in the files S_INT.DAT and S_SLOPE.DAT, located in
Appendix G.

Least-squares curve fitting techniques were used to determine if any functional relationship
existed between (a) thickness ratio and point of intersection, and (b) thickness ratio and the slope
at the point determined from (a). For the point of intersection, (A_,y_), the least-squares

approximating function is given by

12 9.96043?3 18.657f4
a.,
=
.00488874
-

. 190253 1 + 2.22379 -
+

[4.4]
)W>
-
/W2-2038/2-W
The slope at this point is given by the least-squares approximating function

,'

J radius
-. 418408 -
2.11113. * -5^5

*
*
-2
[4.53

Computationally, [4.5] is not nearly as efficient as desired, yet it fits very well to the data from
which it came. The fit of intersection points given by [4.4] is marginal, and not nearly accurate
enough for the purpose of this research. Regardless of efficiency, the cubic spline technique still

requires function evaluations at a number of points on the desired airfoil, which is contrary to
the of data points supplied to generate the cubic
the objective of this research. Increasing number

spline interpolant did lessen the magnitude of overshoot on the leading edge, but even with 200
points supplied on the upper surface as data points, the rippling effect on the leading edge could

not be totally eliminated.

27
 i-

L_

CO
UJ
(Z
< <
3
h- O
O <
CM
to
1 _J

h- <
3 O
CO
1 CM
iS O CM

09
_l
<
d> 3
**>
1
1 1 O
O
CM
C0
fl O
-+-5
O CO
?H
cd W

P.
<S
<u g
cd
Q eg
i-4
^t-

*
oo
oo
0)

<*-H j_4
o
O s CM

sa
, ^ o
-

1 <M
O
O

.s*

O
o I- CO
O
CL, S3
O
I- CO
o

o
1 1 1 1 ~r T o
o o o o
I oo <o
o o
S
o o
o o 3 o o 8 o o
o o o o o o o
I
uojv>dSJ9)tq jo uonisod asiMpjoqo

28
 1

b_

CO
Ld
a:
< < o
z>
r-

o <
CM
CO
1 _J

r-
< o 3
co 3 CM "3
CM
iS O
_J
< <D
00
i O a
i 1 o
CM c

o
CO
I

<
u
ol
<
mm
^-

00 I
t-
00
fi
'1 1
c
CM S <u
Q

O
O &
cd

I 8.
O _2

I- CO
O i

O S
t- <o 3
an
o

o
o
^*-

1 1 r
CO r
oo
T I
co m
1
^ 'O cm *-
o
o

}B adoxs
uorpasia^ui jo )tno<i

29
4.1.1.3 Overcoming the Problem of Specifying Zero Slope

In order to circumvent the zero slope requirement at the point of maximum thickness, it was
decided that perhaps an effective method may be to break the airfoil into two distinct portions.

By splitting the airfoil at the a =.3point, a clamped cubic spline could feasibly be used to fix
the slope at zero at this point. Although the cubic spline methods discussed in this section were
deemed unsuitable for the purpose, this was an important step in reaching the final objective.
The technique splitting the
of airfoil at the a=.3c point proved vital to the eventual success

encountered in this research.

4.1.2 Least-Squares Polynomial Approximations

Least-squares curve fitting techniques were attempted for this application. Due to the fact,
however, that even with a significant number of generated data points, no great degree of
accuracy in emulation was achieved, this technique was dropped from contention as a viable
method to achieve the final objective.

4.1.3 Parametric Bezier Curves

The properties of Bezier curves seem ideally suited to fulfill the objective of this research. By
sectioning the airfoil at the chordwise position of maximum ordinate, zero slope at this point is
easily attained. In addition, by placing successive defining polygon vertices along the line a=0
(the y-axis), the heretofore troublesome problem of infinite slope at the leading edge is
overcome, while placement of a polygon vertex along the line y=tl2 somewhere between a=0
and a =.3 will ensure zero slope at the point of maximum thickness. These requirements of the
Bezier curve thus eliminate the investigation of quadratics; the lowest order Bezier curve to

accomplish the objective will be a cubic one. Further, because the Bezier curve utilizes only the
defining polygon points in its generation, the specification of large numbers of points through

which the curve must pass is unnecessary; only the points which determine the first and last
vertices of each defining polygon (and are coincident with the airfoil) must be specified.

4.1.3.1 Leading Edge Surface

The question that now arises is one of how to go about determining the optimum placement of

the two remaining defining polygon vertices to minimize error between the Bezier curve and the
true (desired) shape. Upon further inspection, it is noted from Figure 4.5 on the following page
that of the two undetermined polygon vertices, one coordinate of each is predetermined.

30
 B3-(.3,1/2)

Desired Shape

Defining Polygon

>
B-(0,0) .3c x

Figure 4.5 Leading Edge of Airfoil and Bezier Defining Polygon

Thus it is desired to find only two values: the y-coordinate for the vertex B! on the y-axis,
and the A-coordinate for the vertex B_ on the line y=tl2. For the initial portion of the

analysis, the NACA0012 airfoil was chosen as the target of the attempt to fit a Bezier curve
to the actual shape.

The matrix formulation for the Bezier curve now becomes

1 3 -1 1 0 0

3 -6 3 0 0 ?i
2
P(") =[ V P
1] 3 3 0 0 0.06
X2
1 0 0 0 0.3 0.06

There are a multitude of optimization methods that could have been employed to hone in on

the two values required, but as a first approach, it was thought that some ballpark estimates
of these values should be obtained. In order to arrive at some preliminary estimates for the

y-coordinate of polygon vertex B_, integer multiples of the leading edge radius were thought

to be good starting points. A preliminary (and purely arbitrary) assumption that polygon
vertex Bi have a y-coordinate value no larger than til was made. This limited possible values
of yx for the initial attempt to emulate the NACA0012 to

r 0.015867 (D

?i
=
Ir 0.031735 (2)
3r 0.047602 (3)

31
In the matter of selecting the A-coordinate of polygon vertex B_, the interval [0,.3] (assuming
a standard chord length of unity) was divided by golden section (see Appendix A for details
of this method). Thus

=
(1-t)(0.3) +
t(0.0) =0.11459 (1)
X2
(1-t)(0.0) +t(0.3) =0.18541 (2)

Where, from Appendix A,

t = V^_____i =
0.6180339

This scheme led to six possible Bezier curves. Each of the possible combinations is plotted in
Figures 4.6-4.11, pages 33-38. They are designated as "Case (a,b), denotes the yx
where a

value of vertex Bt and b denotes the a2 value of vertex B_. Note here the indices are in order
of the Bezier defining polygon vertices and not of the form (A^y^), where the subscripts i
and j denote the various values of yt and a2 as given above.

32
 ^->

b
z
w
o
o
Ul >-

CO _l

CM < o o
O Q_
O
O or: or:
UJ UJ
<
(J CO
N M
< Ld Ul o
z CD m
If) <D
U
1 1 * CM
*i
CO

4J

1
>
CS
m*

8
<:
u
<

'fi
V]

</]
ti

o
c
41

E
>
CO
I

s
3

Um

o o
apuipjQ

33
 CM
z
o
Ul

CM o o
Q_
O
or
Ul
Ct.
Ul
3.1
1 N
Ul
CD
M
Ul
CD
<>
O ~T

l\ i\ ! 1 1 * CM CO

o
*4 t-i .a

mm
CU t \ ! \i o |
o r^
CQ -mm \.\- \ o >
CM tN
mm)

8
\ X i \1 <

. Vj \ ; \ j 1 ID
CU CQ
> I
mm 3
J3

fi
[ i\..NL\...: \ -
a
ca

O CJ) _ j :..\.....\.> _. g
to
5
n
: : : \ :
\ o
E
! ! ! ^Ov > ^\* ^w
E
>.
co
: : : :
CU i

: ^-. -i?__vA
_2

P O <a
3

O
lO
V/J | i i i 1 1 1
o o o o o o o o
co in to CM o
o o o o o O o o
o o o o o

apujpjQ

34
p c.
u
mm.

pH

*H *H .2
'S
H-)
0) a
cn
>
rH
N
mm

0) 8
cn
PQ <
u
<
cn z
<D CQ 3
O
t>
fl 3
03
c
02
Q
WI
so

,d
0 <u

&
E-h 0 O
03

! H
o
OO c

! E
*H E
& >
co

<D 00

8
3
00

CO

O O
apujpjQ

35
d
o
<N
of

"S
U

*M *H
^_P
o
cn fH
>
fH
N CN
Q O
<

8
cn
PQ <
u
cn
O CQ c

fl > o
*5
3
03
c
CV2 co

5
CO
co

.A
o <U

JS
E-h o
<
u
OO c

< E
E
& >
co
o

a 60

CO

o o
9}DUjpJ0

36
 ^"N
^
*
2
to o
o
Ul >-

(/) _J

CM < o o
o Q_
O
or: Cl.
O O
Ul Ul -__;
<
O M INI *C0
< Ul Ul O
z m CD o-

m a> CJ
1 1 t cm
*i
co

?H *h P
H-> o
O
cn i-H co

o u >
^H
N CM <N

03
CQ u
<
cn 2

o CQ e
o

fl > *3
3
03

CM
co
CO
O
.fl
O
E-h O
U
OS
H
<J o

o O c
<u

<d E
"C E
!z: >>
CO
I
o

a a
3
60
Urn

CO

o o
opinp-io

37
fl
o
fH CN

"3 U
mO

Sh u "S
h?
o a
cn i-H co
>
.H
N CN
*^

Q O 8
<
cn
PQ
<
Ul z

o cn c

fl ? 3
03
c
CV2

u
pfl
O .5

E-h o
<
c
OO D

t . < E
E
co

a fi
3

a at

CO

9)DUipJ0

38
Some observations on the previous plots, Figures 4.6-4.11, are in order. Varying the two
inner defining polygon vertices changes the nature of the B6zier curve that lies within the
polygon. Table 4.1 below summarizes the effects of
changing yt and x2 from their smallest to
largest values (intermediate values of yt are not included).

Table 4. 1 Visual Effects of Variation of Bezier Defining Polygon Inner Vertices

Case yi value a2 value Effect

(1,1) 0.015867 0.11459 sharp nose

(1,2) 0.015867 0.18541 sharpest nose

thin leading edge

(3,1) 0.047602 0.11459 blunt nose

(3,2) 0.047602 0.18541 best fit

Noting the changes in Bezier curve shape attained by varying the defining polygon inner
vertices (Bj and B_) will be useful should one desire to manipulate or perturb a shape
generated using Bezier curves. It should be noted here that changing only one of these inner
vertices will affect a change on the entire leading edge surface.

It is noted that case 4.11, seems to be a relatively good fit

(3,2), Figure to the desired shape.
Although further refinement of the defining polygon vertices is in order, the results thus far

were checked against other airfoils in the NACAOOry family. A number of these surfaces

(from the to the thickness) were generated and compared

leading edge point of maximum

against the corresponding NACA four-digit thickness distribution (equation [2.1], shown

again for reference).

+ =
1( -.126a-.
3516a2
+
2843a3
) [2.1]
y, .

It is further observed from plots generated using the Bezier curve versus the true shapes, that
in the the NACA0012 does not carry over to airfoils
the reasonably good fit obtained case of

of different maximum thicknesses (see Figures 4.12 and 4.13, pages 40-41). Again the
distribution has been provided for comparison.
conventionally described NACA thickness

the outcome of Figures 4.12 and 4.13, it is recognized from section 4.1 that
Reflecting upon
"
the curve is invariant under an affine (linear) transformation"7. Because the leading edge
radius was used to determine yx of polygon vertex B_, the relative distance from the leading
thickness ratio in a non-linear manner (recall from equation
edge to vertex Bx changes with

varies with f2).

[2.3] that leading edge radius, r,

39
 CN
CO

S3

1
CO
>

<
U
<
55

c
o
J3
3
03

co
CO
4>

U
c
4

<u
E
E
>>
CO
I

CN

fi
3
60
E

apujpjQ

40
 <*
m
CO

^sll

-CM ___

o
m o
UIO) >-
c/>r^ -J CN
<<-
<* o cn

Oco 0. Si
o o:9
ed

o or: U
UJ
<
o ISI s
< Ul,- Ul
z CD>- m

1 1 ? CO
>

<
u
<
55

e
o
Z3
3
03
c

co
CO
U

0=
H
u
c
u
E
E
>-.
co

CO
*^

>*

fi
3
60

O O
GpUipjQ

41
Thus for the affine transformation property to hold, the defining polygon vertices must be
generated using a term that is linear in t (or independent of t). Since good first approximation
results were obtained on
a2 using the golden section method, this was deemed a good place to
continue in the search for y,. Figure 4.14 illustrates the manual refinement that went into
determining a value of yj that would hold for any value of t. Because this golden section
search was performed with the aid of a hand calculator, it was possible in some instances to
select new bounds on both ends of the shortened search interval.

0.06 -i

i
N 0.05125 -I
-| 0.04917
O.I
I J
T
0.04584J o.,
1.04790

I
A
0.03708
L
I
N
T 0.02292
E
R

A
L SUCCESSIVE MANUAL
ITERATIONS "^-

0.0

Figure 4.14 Steps in Golden Section Refinement to Determine yl

Prior to the first iteration above, the search interval is [0,0.06]. Because the desired value of

yx is known to be in the vicinity of 0.047602, the next interval subject to golden section
search is [0.03708,0.06]. The second iteration of the golden section yields two values which

bracket the desired value, and thus both endpoints of the interval may be replaced. The
search interval then becomes [0.04584,0.05125]. The asterisk (*) in Figure 4.14 above

denotes the fact that it has replaced one of the interval bounds. It was felt that after the first
iteration yt would not be close enough to the desired value of 0.047602 to warrant plotting
the result. Successive iterations, however, bracketed the desired value on a small enough
interval to deserve a closer look.

Figures 4.15 -
4.17 (denoted cases (4,2), (5,2) and (6,2), pages 43-45) show the results of

this further manual refinement in the emulation of the NACA0012. Because the value for yt
obtained above are linear in t (see Appendix A for an explanation), it is logical to assume
that employing this method to generate airfoils of varying thicknesses will provide accuracy
for all t. Figures 4.18-4.24, (pages 46-52), show the results as applied to airfoil leading
edges of various thickness ratios. It should be mentioned here that the refinement was

accomplished leaving the A-value of polygon vertex B_ at a2=t(.3c)

=
. 1854c.

42
o
CN

'mO
mO

*H u
H?
o 1
cn i-H co
>
i-H
N CN
m*

Q O
PQ 1
u
cn <
cn 55

o cn e
o

fl > a
3
03
c
C\2
co
co

A O
E- O
< o

OO c

<*! E
t .
E
>>
co

fi
3

a 60

CO

o o
9pUipjQ

43
 *
m
CO

^11

-"> z
mx o
e>
>-
UjTh
CN
t/>00 _i

CM <m o
o^ Q. 3*
O o:9
cd
at. U
^3 Ul i

u
o N u
*H FH < UJCM Ul
H-)
O
z m>- CQ
I
cn
pH
-H

N
1 1 + CO
>
CN

Q O
<
cn
PQ u

cn o 55
m
o cn e
o

fl ? *4I
3
03

fi
CM o
co

I- o
CO
co

pfl
O U

E-h O 0=
H
<5J o
O O '
c . <! E
E
CO

a fi
3

a 60

CO

o o
apuipjQ

44
 "

m
00

-OI
o
d cox O g o
O UIO
o
>- ;__;
(DO) 1 "co CN

CM <r- o O
O-*-
Q. o-

O or9 m to
or:
UJ CM CO

i-H o M
pH PH
< UJCM UJ
z CD>- CD
H^>
o o a
cn
w*\
N
1 1 ? o
CO
>
CM CN

Q O 8
<
CQ
PQ
<
O 55
CQ in
CD GQ 3

d > *4-
3
03
c
CM CO

5
CO
co
9i

,4
o .fi

E-" O
O
0=
E-
*J3 u
c
OO 4.I
CJ

< E
E
Zm >>
co

CU r

a <*

fi
3

a 60
E
>^
CO

apujpjQ

45
 1*

o N

d g o
21
o co
>
pH CO
r-

4__} o
0.
d O <D
<
U
m
rCi

pH cm
'
.2

t
"D
Jh pH
H-J
O o
_c
1t:
cn o 3
CO
pH IS o
Q o o ex
CM D
cn
CQ of
00
cn 3
o cn 00
e

fl > o
in
"2
3
e
o
o a
3
o 03
pfl fi
E-h o o co

o Q
<3 ^
co
CO
<U
OO .5

"pH <3 03
E->
& o
u

o fi
m ti
o E
a E
>.
CO

00
m*

Tf
o
o fi
CO o 3
&o
**

tu

o o
aiDUipjQ

46
d
o
apH
f_P

d
r-m

pH

PH PH
4-J
o
cn
^-i
N
Q O
cn
PQ
cn
o cn
fl >

o
pfl
o
E-h o
<
O O

cu

a
a
CO fi
3
00

apuipjQ

47
 o wt

3
g o
4-*
CO
>

CO O
o
Q_ 8
<
o o u
in .2
<
cm mm

1
-o
k_ ti
o
_c t:
3
o CO

o
o
CM
1
P

00

a
60
c
o "2
in
3
e
o
<*_

3
03
c
V5
o
o Q
^"
co
co
<D

5
o
mm

fr>

o
o c
m <u
o E
E
>-

CO

o
CN

Tt
o
o fi
3
o

apujpjQ

48
 ti

d i
o co
>
CN

8
<
u

PH Sh
H-?

(W
CU i3
co
pH
N
Q CU I
o.
D
tX)
CQ eu
oo
cn s
o CO 00
8

fl >
CM
I
e

,d
O 03

fi
Eh o co

< CO
co

O O <U

<
.5

55
o fi
ti
E
a E
>>
co

a CN

?
fi
3
00

apujpjQ

49
 o
o N

a
s'
o
t-t
CO
>
CO m*

o
Q_ 8
<
o u
m.2 <
cm 55
*
-D
PH %^ i_ H
*-> o
o _c

cn pH o 3
CO
p>4
tsa o
Q o o cl

CM D
cn
PQ u
00
cn a
o GQ 00
c

fl > o
m
I
-* c
o
a
3

.A
O 03

fi
E-h O co

< co
co
U
OO
. < u

o
c
o
E
E
>
co

a CN
CN

CO fi
3
00

apujpjQ

50
 i
co
>
00
mm

I
u
<
mm

i
mm
1-
3
co

8.
a
D
_f

oo

a
00
c

2
c
o
a
3
03

fi
co

CO
co
U

o
-

OS

o
c
m*
ti
E
E
co
i

cn
CN

s
3
00
E

o o o
apuipjQ

51
 .2

a
CO
>
O

<

I3
CO

&
53
<o
00

a
00
c

I
e

3
03
c
co

CO
co
U

o
X.
H
o
c>
*

ti
E
E
>%
CO
I

<t
CN

fi
3
oo

o o
apuipjQ

52
Cubic Bezier curves were plotted against the desired curves after each
iteration; it was
determined that the best fit was obtained in iteration 2, case (4,2), with

yl
=
(1 -

t)(0.06) +
t2(0.06)
=
(1 -

t)(0.06) + (1 -

r)(0.06)
=
2(1 -

t)(0.06)

-2(l-r)L2
=(l ~T)t

Refinement of the rvalue of polygon vertex B_ was accomplished in a similar manner.

Figure 4.25 illustrates this refinement process.

0.0 0.3c

'
0.11459 I 0.18541
0.15836*
0.14164 L

0.17508'
0.16869 U

Figure 4.25 Refinement of % Using Golden Section Method

Table 4.2 below to clarify the iterative process illustrated in figure 4.25. As in the
will serve

refinement process for y_, the asterisks above denote a change in the interval bound.

Table 4.2 Manual Refinement Process to Determine x2

Iteration Lower Bound Upper Bound

0 0.0 0.3

1 0.11459 0.18541

2 0.15836 0.18541

3 0.17508 0.18541

4 0.17902 0.18146

53
The final result of the refinement on x2 is

x2
=
.3(22t
-

13)

and is independent of the maximum thickness.

There may be some confusion as to the origin of the

last equation. Because of the nature of
the golden section, and the value of zero of the lower bound on the initial search interval,

any iteration of the golden section division of this interval can simplified to an equation that
is linear in t. Furthermore, one of the coefficients will be a Fibonacci number, and the other
will be an integer either one less or one more than the next number in the Fibonacci
sequence.

For the segment of the NACA symmetric airfoil of arbitrary thickness t from the leading
edge to the chordwise position of maximum thickness, the polygon that best defines the cubic
Bezier curve is

"B0T"
0 0

0 (1 -

T)t

t
B2T
=
.3(22r
-

13)
2

B3T t
.3

Plots of the front section for airfoils of various thickness ratios between seven and
twenty
percent thick are provided as Figures 4.26 -
4.32 on the pages immediately following. Notice
that the B6zier curves follow their respective NACA curves very closely, regardless of the

thickness ratio. Results thus far are promising.

54
 Z
o
d _j

o e
pH
r* or: o e
o ^ 0- o
d o
.2

pQ

pH
or:
UJ
or:
Ul 8 >-*

N
-#-

PH s* a Ul CO
o
a
c
z CD m [it
CQ Q_ 1

pH
1 1 * o
in .2
&
N

cm
*
* a
-a
__
co
>
o
-C fc
<^p5J O 8
o <
o <
p*
CM 55
O CQ
c
o
4-

3
03

o
in
5
CO
co
U

43 I &
O
0> Si OS
H
o
o fi
E
E
>
CO
t>
00

o
a
00
m c
*jd;z; o .wm

T3

w
&
o
CN

o
d o
01
s
3
pH o 00

nd O o Urn
m o
cd to ro
cp o o
o o
apujpjQ

55
 c

I
Si
mm

13
s
mm

o
apuipjQ

56
 Z
a _i o
o
2
o or: o
< 0. o 8
a
o
o or: or: S
UJ Ul o B
mm

M
a
z
t_
CD
UJ
MM

CO
73
c
CD o Ph
Q_
1 1 + o g fc
m. S3 8
CM *
*
a
-D
L_ co
>
o
JZ O

o
8
o <
u
o <
CM 55

e
o

3
03

o fi
m
5
co
co
<D

5
CJ
OS
H
o CJ

o
ti
E
E
>
CO
u
00

o
a
00
m c
o 'o

J
00
CN
*
o
o fi
3
o 00
mm

o o
apuipjQ

57
 o o

i
Ss -t-

73
CO c
o CU
Q_ 1

o >
m.2 S
CM a
-a .

co
i_
>
o
CN
-C

o
8
<
o u
o
CM z

c
o
*-

fi
co

co
co
<0

.5

CJ

g
CJ
c
ti
E
E
>
co
ti
oo

a
00
8

1
ON
CN

fi
3
00
E
cd
O O
ajDUjpjo

58
 z
d _j O

<*
or: o
< 0.
d o o

pQ
Q or
UJ
or 1
UJ o B
3
?

pH mm
: M
PH ^ N 73
< UJ Ul CO c
H-* i-H
03 m o mm

CQ *
Q_ 1

S *H
1 ? o
1m

m.2 N

cp CM \x
*
a
TO -o
"Jo L-
o
CO
>

cp cp
*
-C

o
d 8
o <
u
p . o <
CQ CM 5r
O
a

A
:\
V^ o
.wm
-*

3
03
c
i

o 41

CO

cj.!*? m

\^
c co
co
U
H^> I i
.S

CP PH

o u
o o
c

pt< E
E
>>
co

Jo u
00

cp <J o
a
oo
m c
o

w 3
o
bD CO

o
d o fi
pH i i i i i I 1 W o
3
00
o o o o o o o o
<o m ro CM o
E
cd o o o o o O o o
cp o o d o o o o
apuipjQ

59
 c
o o

i
o S3

73
CO s
o CU
a. 1

o fc
m .2

cm
*
a
TJ
L. co
>
o
00

o
8
o <
o <
CM

c
#g
*a
3
03
c

S
CO
CO

I
U
03
H
cj

fi
u
E
E
>>
CO
u
00

a
00
c

3
CO

fi
3
oo
T3 E
cd
cp o o o
P-H
apujpjQ

60
 a
o
n
e

73
e
CU

.a

i
CO
>
O
CN

8
<
u

55

c
o
a
3
03

fi
co

co
co

1
CJ

CJ

fi
E
E
>i
co
o
00

a
00
c

3
CN

fi
3
oo
wi

Urn

cd
cp o o
pJ apujpjQ

61
4.1.3.2 Trailing Edge Surface

A strategy similar to that employed for determining the

defining polygon of the third order

B6zier curve of the leading edge section will be attempted for the section of the airfoil aft of

the maximum thickness point.

Recall from equation [2.4] that the is

trailing edge angle given by
tan = -

1.16925 1 P-4]

To ensure that the trailing edge slopeis identical to that defined for the NACA four-digit
airfoil, a polygon vertex must be placed on the line (in point-slope form) such that

(y
-

0.0105 0 = -

1.16925 t(x -

1.0) t4-6!

The reader should observe here that the ordinate at the trailing edge is a small number, but
not zero. This can be verified by inserting an *-
value of 1 in equation [2.1].

Simplifying into slope-intercept form,

y =f(x,t)
=
t(-l. 16925a: +
1.17975) t4-7!

The chordwise position at which the line defined by [4.7] and the line y=tl2 intersect will be
denoted Xj_t and is determined by solving

I =
t (-
1.16925 x.t
""
+
1.17975) [4.8]
2

This yields

x.,
ml
=
0.58135557

Note that this value is independent of the thickness ratio t.

62
In order to maintain at be line
continuity x=.3c, a polygon vertex Bt must placed on the
y=f/2. The cubic Bezier defining polygon at this stage is illustrated in Figure 4.33.

y As

Bo-(.3, J/2) V(*i>r/2)

B_-t>_. /_.<))

(1,0.01050

Xjm=
0.58135557 c 1.0c

Figure 4.33 Trailing Edge Bezier Defining Polygon

The B6zier curve defining polygon for the segment aft of the chordwise position of maximum

thickness becomes

t
.3c

2
B,T
t
= xi 2
B2T

B3T X2 f(x2,t)
1.0 0.0105 1

where, from equation [4.7], f(x,t) is given as

f(x,t) =
f( 1.17975
-
1.16925 x)

As in the case of the leading edgesegment, only two coordinates of the defining polygon
vertices are left undetermined. Proceeding as before, the golden section method was utilized
to divide each of the intervals .3
<x_ <xmt and xmt<x2< 1.0. Four possible cases were thus
(a,b)"

created, denote as before "Case with a denoting the values for x^ and b representing

63
the values for x2 as determined by golden section on their respective intervals. These are
included as Figures 4.34 -

4.37, pages 65-68.

These values are

(1 -

t)( 0.58135557) +
t(0.3) =0.407468 (D
xi
=
J
(1 -

t)(0.3) +
t( 0.58135557)
=
0.473887 (2)

and

(1-t)(1.0) +t(0.58135557) =0.741263 (D

X2
(1 -

t)( 0.58135557) +t(1.0) =0.840092 (2)

Surprisingly, only one iteration of the golden section method was required to achieve
excellent results; this corresponds to case (2,1). From these results, the matrix formulation
for the cubic Bezier curve emulating the section of a NACAOQry airfoil from .3c<x<
1.0c is

1 3 -1 1 .3c tl2

3 -6 3 0 a til
[ 1 ]
3 p2

P() =
v
3 3 0 0 0 f(r3,0
1 0 0 0 1.0 0.0105 1

where

a =
0.3 + 0.2813557 r =
0.473887

j8 =
1 + -

1) =
0.741263
r(xint

And^jS,*) is as given in [4.7].

As in the case of the leading edge section, because the cubic Bezier defining polygon vertices

are linear in t , the affine transformation property guarantees that the shape of the curve is

invariant regardless of the value of t. Figures 4.38 and 4.39, pages 69-70 will
visually
confirm this.

64
 ?"s

m
z
w
o
o
Ul >-
_l

CM 2 o
ti *"

o
o Q.
or or
o UJ UJ
pH
o M M
^__P
< Ul Ul
2 m m
ti u
'B

^
pH
1 1 ? a
CO
>
pH PH CN
H-?
0)
CQ pH
8
<
pH
LS u

O 0) 55

GO
PQ e

CQ 3
03

<D GO c

d > co
CO

CM

43 O o
c
Eh O eg
E
<H E
>-,
OO co
u
e <U
.
ai

s
Of,

o
"1

fi
OX
CO

apujpjQ

65
 ^-s
CM
*
___

O o
o
UJ >-
-J

CM 5 o
ti O
o 0. CN
.

mm
*m*
or or
o o
UJ UJ a
pH <
U
^__P g
<
M
Ul
M
UJ
z m m
ti
r~m
1 I ? I
p*H co
>
PH PH
CN
H-^
0)
CQ <
pH N u
Q 0) 55

CQ
PQ c
o
*3

CQ 3
03

O CQ
d ? co
CO
2
CV2

pd
O U
n
E-h O u

<< E
o o co

c . <J 00

a
00
0)

fi
3

CO 00
E

O O
apujpjQ

66
 ^-s

z
CM 0
0
UJ >-.
-J

CM 3 0
ti O
O Q>
CN
or or
o 3 Ul Ul
S
CO
U
M
3 a
CO
Ul
CQ

1 1 + I
co
>
PH PH CN
fJ
o 8
CQ
pH
N u
<
Q O 55

CQ
PQ e
o
'Zm
3
CQ 03
c
0) CQ
d > co
CO
CJ

CM CJ
0=
H
^d o cj
c
E-h O ti
E
< E
>-

OO co
V
<U ox

a
5^i ox

o
G
a
a cn

fi
?> ox
CO

o o
ajDUipjo

67
 ^-*v
CM
z
CM o
o
Ul >-
_J

ti
CM
8
o
o
Q_ CN
CN
O or:
or
o
pH 5 Ul Ul
U
^__P g
<
M
UJ
M
Ul
z CO CO
ti 'n
mO

pH
1 l ? a
co
>
pH PH
CN
H?
o
CQ 8
<
pH
N u
<:
Q O 55

CQ
PQ c

CQ 3
03

O CO
d > co
CO
U
CM .S

o
o=
E->

pd
o CJ
c
E-h o ti
E
<*! E
oo co
4>
<t! 00

a
55 00
c
o

a
a cn

^> fi
3
CO oo
tu

O O
apujpjQ

68
 z
_i
o
d o
o
I
lo_
or
>]
r^ o
o < Q_ o *m\

d o
or or 9 c
o CN
Ul Ul \m*
"-

< o
i-h to
o M M -M
a
PH < Ul Ul (0 U
H-> m O
z m
CC P
i-H
i 1 ? '3
a
PH CO

cn CD "U >

72 -i-H
O r^
CD N _c
9
o o <
CO U
<
55
O .

"7J era e
o
w

o 3
03
r-
c
p-

C/5
"'
CD
Q
co
co
CJ

o
5
CJ
CD 03
*
H
o
c
So *-

ti
E
s
O >%
m CO
a
oo

a
00
c

be o
^ ?
W oo
cn

<*
<u
*

o 3
- 00
ro
CU

PH

o
apuipjQ

69
 z
o
d
_J

o
o u. >]
i-H or
H^> o o
CM < Q_
d O
or or
O CN
Ul Ul
fH
< &
o M M
PH < Ul UJ U
z m m
CO
i 1 ?
.2
i-H

a I
PH co

CO >
CD
O
cn -^h CN
CD N 8
<
d u
<
55
O .

c
o

03
H-^>

Q
CO
CO

I
CJ

So E
E
co
a
oo

a
00
c
&*
I
W a\
cn

>*
SjO
fi
d 3
oo

cd
wi
O
apuipjQ

70
4.1.3.3 Assembling the Pieces

By first generating the leading edge section coordinates and

appending to them the list of
Bezier points generated on the
trailing section, fitting a close replica of the upper surface

may be obtained. Because thus far only symmetric airfoils have been considered, the
ordinates on the lower surface are simply the negative of their upper surface counterparts.

Since the intermediate polygon vertices at

B_ B3 for the leading for
and edge and Bq and B,
the trailing edge are collinear
coincident), continuity at*=.3c is
(B3feflifln8 and
)}_____ are
maintained. Should, however, tangent or curvature information be required (for example, in
generation of an orthogonal coordinate system with the entire airfoil as the origin) the tangent
and curvature vectors, though possessing identical directions, do not share the same
magnitude. This minor inconvenience is easily overcome by normalizing all tangent and
curvature vectors and using a slope-intercept form in conjunction with the airfoil coordinates
at the point of computation.

The FORTRAN program SYMMFOIL.FOR, located in Appendix F, will generate both

upper and lower surfaces of NACA four-digit symmetric airfoils using the material presented

here. Examples of NACA0005 through NACA0024 airfoils are illustrated in Appendix D.

4.1.3.4 Error Analysis

There are some minor differences between the desired shape and that generated using the
Bezier curves. First, the chordwise position of maximum thickness for the true airfoil section
lies very close to .3c, but not exactly; the maximum thickness at x=.3c exceeds the
maximum thickness by a minute amount. The Bezier curve allows the user to place this point

precisely at the desired coordinate. These differences are minimal, however. Table 4.3 on

the following page shows both absolute and sum-of-squares error between the two types of

airfoil for various values of the thickness distribution t, computed by generating 99 points on

the upper surface of each airfoil.

71
 Table 4.3 Absolute and Least-Squares Error for Various Thickness Ratios
Bezier vs. Conventional

99 99
Thickness Ratio, t
Y \y ' ' J true
-

y Bezier
J 1
' * ->

y true J
Bezier)
(Percent of Chord)
_L

I =
1 i = 1

10"6
5 0.0084086656 1.2260476 x

10^
6 0.0100903911 1.7655083 x

8 0.0134538600 3.1386803
xlO"6

10"6
10 0.0168173172 4.9041857 x

10"6
12 0.0201807829 7.0620328 x

10"6
13 0.0218625263 8.2880832 x

10"5
15 0.0252259816 1.1034424 x

105
17 0.0285894519 1.4173112 x

10"5
20 0.0336346468 1.9616762 x

10"5
23 0.0386798413 2.5943183 x

10"5
24 0.0436159884 2.8248186 x

4.2 Cambered Airfoils

With the success obtained in the attempt to emulate NACA Four-digit symmetric airfoils, it
seems logical that strategy be employed for the cambered case. The generation of
a similar

cambered airfoil surface data points as described in section 2.2 is a tedious procedure.

Because the upper surface of a generic NACA four-digit airfoil has only one point of zero
Any (or methods)
slope, the investigation will concentrate on this surface. viable method can

then be extended later to the lower surface.

4.2.1 Review

The coordinates of the upper surface of a NACA four-digit cambered airfoil are defined as

the combination of the mean line coordinate and the thickness distribution along a line
perpendicular to the mean line. Mean lines, given by equations [2.5] are

m
yc
= 1 (2px -

x2) , 0<x<p
P
[2.5]
m
=
[(1 -

2p) + 2px -x2] p<x<c

yc ,

(1 ~P2)

72
where m is the maximum ordinate of the camber line and p is the chordwise position where
the maximum ordinate occurs.

The tangent to the camber line is obtained via

/ .
n 2m , v

yc
=
tanfl =
(p -
__.

x) , 0<x<p

i
=
2m , .

yc
-

-2(p x) , p<x<c
(i -

p)

and the upper surface coordinates are computed from

=
X "

* y'
yu
=
yc +
y,
\ co&e
[2-7] (a)

4.2.2 Detennining the Points of Zero Slope

Theoretically, the most accurate method of determining zero slope points is to find the root(s)
of the derivative of the cambered airfoil (equations [2.6]). Equations [4.9] show the derivatives

of these equations for the upper surface.

dxu dyt sin 8

~1S_
"
yt cos 0 d 0
dX
[4.9]
dy_ dyc dytcos8 yr sin 0 30

dx dx dx dx

When the root of dyjdxu is found, the chordwise position of zero slope is obtained. Obviously,
determining the root of this equation requires a numerical evaluation; an analytical solution is
impractical. For the task attempted, this equation would have to be solved for nine values of

maximum camber, nine values of chordwise position of maximum camber and twenty values of

thickness ratio -
for a total of 1620 iterations. Discounting the combinations where p=. 3c (and

the zero slope point lies at (.3,tl2+m)), the total decreases to a still unmanageable 1440.

Using small angle approximations simplify the computations with the cost of this
will

simplification being a loss of accuracy; due to this inaccuracy, this approach was abandoned.
A decision was made to find these zero-slope points using a simple scheme whereby the entire

data file of each cambered airfoil is scanned for a maximum value in the case of the upper

surface, and a minimum and maximum value on the lower surface (it is possible for the lower

surface to possess two points of zero slope). The FORTRAN program CAMBER.FOR
(Appendix F) was written for this purpose. The results of these tedious comparisons are
contained in the data files UTRENDS.DAT and LTRENDS.DAT, located in Appendix G. Plots
of the upper surface data are included as Figures 4.40 4.57 on the pages following. -

73
<D
C~<
O *D O* CM -
1 o>
m !
o
C^ at O* 3J
Q.

A
CM
a 05K _

CM
w
_

o 00
00
00
U
t-4 a O* Q. s
CD a O*
> II
CM O s
IS!
o
a O* -
B D
a. 3
Urn
co < 09
?a O* _

O 11 to 1
P*

D O*
Q.
09
<o
a O + X _
>

in _2

5 a ?a O + X V)
II
a. 2
-

"S3 a O + X _

?
a

1
^a < u a O + X
/^.f
CN
U
Q.
a.
? a O + X _

a 8

? a O + X 1o
03
Q. U
o
? a O * _
1

O
? a O +X -
CN

ti ? a O +X -
CO
CO +
? a O +X -
T

u
pH o.
? ? O + X -
CO
X
t* ? a ' v
+
Mh i tp i T T
o o o O O CD
P< s CO ^ CM
ro
O
ro
00
CM
C0
CM
ro ro
> 2 o o o
;
doc
adois oaaz jo aonjsod aspipioiK)

74
 <D
Ph
O
CM *

o>
U
CO 1
0.

A
|

o 03
1 n
0.

|
> CJ

0
ES3 II
1
u
Q. s
<4-H co 0
ft - < 3
o II CO
.3
06
09

R
0.

<2 -
co

^1
09
>
* H
0.
1
co
3 ?
R

^a "L _
CM
D
CL
O
2
eg

D -S

V
O M ro 0
1

D
Q.
_
O ^t

"^ O
CM
1
2
3
M
P*

O.
-
00
+

pH H
-
CO 0.

X
Ph 1 1 1 1 1 1
0 O O O O O C3
to, <-
CM O CO CO
*
Csi
-r- r-
O O O C
0 0 0 0 0 0 c
adois oiaz jo syBurpjo

75
CD
Oh
O G OfX _
r
<-

CM **
at
m

o n
CO a OfX a.
g A
ta OfX CNrg
w
CM
O 00 00
00
mm: ?a OfX <p Q.

<D oJ >
a O* CM O

c3 m a O+X s
r>
0
Q.
^.
CO <
?a O+X
O
^"

CO
t a O+X I
Q.

i CD <m a O+X
CO
^"~
09
>

I
"Si t a O+X
Tl-
in

a.
CO

I
a* D O+X
oi ?
*

^a <a +
a

a
a o + x

o + x
CM
CL
P4
*->
pN

^-

a
? D o +x ro i
o

o Q. 6
? a o +x *-*
i

O
? a o +x CM
2
3
a. BO
? a o +x CO
CO +
*1 ? D o +x -
,-

a.
e* ? a O + X -
CO
CD X
a n A 1IV
Oh r
nlV-

T 7 a 1 i
V y\

o O O O O o
Oh o tO O lO O m
m ** ro ro CM
. .

o o o o o

ado_s ojaz jo nomsoj astupjoqo

76
 CD
Oh
O
CM *

o>
u
CO cv

A
CM_g
W
CM
o oo OO
00
Sh o
B

CD
o CM O s
CS3 r>
CM
B
o
*M oo o
-

o II 1
co
B
PH
GO CD co
I
_

0 1 B
>

pH
ed -
a
i
co
O O
_

Oh M- I
a
B*
cm
O

CM a
0) 3 _ eg
s

'
O a
f-HJ
ro O

B
CC _
o
<4-H cd
2
pH S CM Urn

2 -
00
fl
Ol

in

pH B
-
CO a.
0)
&, r
o o O o o o o
Ph CM O CO CO CM
o o o O
t> o o o o
adots oiaz jo a^Buipio

77
0)
Ph
O ? ? O-K
<+
CM +*

B
CO D 0-K a.

? O-K H ***
CM
o 00 ; 00 t

a O-K
09 I II <J
fl
PH q
CD a O-K
_ol

CM
g Li
O
II
s
) r>
*^
co a O+X -
g o.
iS
*<-H CO
a O+X
o li holi
D O-K
PH
co
a O-K >

H^, 1
o; a D O-K B
a.
53
R

"Sc. ? a O+X Cm
o
a
o
a O+X
^a -?

? a O+X
CM
fl
a.
&
a

mi ? a O +X ro I
B m\

cd M a. u
ad! ? a O +X
g| i cd
5
mi ? a O +X CM
fl
0 ? a O +X -
00
CL

CO
ix ? a O +X
fl
^1 4>< ? a o +x -
CO a.

CD X
f-*-
Oh f
-a-r-

Ar>,<3
r
o o o o o o o o
Oh m o in o m
ro
o
ro
m
cm
o
CM
m in
o o o d d d d
adois oiaz jo uoriisod asrjipioqo

78
CD
Oh
O ^*

CM -M
CO
CM

O fl
CO 2
CL

A
_CM_g w
CM
O 00 00
00
mm CP Cl

CD .oil
> fl
CM P o

.
s fl
Cl

-
co <
?""

II CO
Om
-

1
PH CL J3
CO CD CO
_
^~

0 1 in

B
>

pH
cd *r
Ol
1
53
O
_

o ?

Ph * I
a
CM
o
CL
CM &
_

s
<D D
*~

'
O a .
ro o

CO X _
O CL

4-H cd *""

o 2
pH a -
CM
3
SO
mm

2 -
CO
1
Cl

CO +
r-

pH -
CO O.
0) X
Ph
o o o o o o o
Ph CO CM o CO co
o o o
p^
o o o o
adois ojaz jo a)Bmpjo

79
 CD
Pm:
O a o+x
O)
ft

B
CO -*a O-K '

< D O-K _CMc8

1
W
CL

A
CM
O 00 oo
00 B
rM *? a O-K
2 CL

CD ? a > II
O-K CM O
IS] r>
s

B
t
*

*? a O+X -
B
o
4-H co
CL
I
p*

? a O+X _ < 09

o
1

II
*? a O+X
CO
B
1
CJ

CL
CQ PH
0) co Cfl
<? a O+X _
>

8.
0
'W^i
1
cd
m. ? a o +x
<-
m
B
CL
o
CO

1
o o M. ? D o +x _

? cm
O

PL, ma ? a o +x
M-

a CM
fl
CL
'53
o
CU
13 > ? a o +x _

<D D Si

O a 4* ? a o +x ro
II 5
cd M o CL u
cd *< h> a 0 +x _
i

<+-H O 5?
Jh 2 GKl ? D o +x CM
*

2
0 j2> ? D o +x -
CO
a.
3
00
Urn
CO +
A> <1 ? Q o+x
*H B
CL
a > < m ? a O + X -
CO
CD X
' ^

Oh f\
A IV
0 U 1
| X
Pp-

r
-k
1 j*
| | ?
o o o o o o o o o
Oh o in o m o m o m o
CO in in -* ^f ro ro cm CM
S=> o o o o o o
.

o o c)
adois ojaz jo noi^isoj asiupjoqo

80
CD
Oh
O 0B<IGA _
*
CM +
o>

O B
CO *a<a&A CL
Sj A
oj&a CMrg
W
CM
O 00 oq
00
t>ffl<IPA
*H N
CL

0) 4SI>BWCA ol >
CM O
CS] r>.

<B*if<lpA g B
CL
*H CO <
HMWPA
o
^~

II co
a<JPA 0
o.
GO PH
CD CO
I
^~

o 1
cd
OtSlOPA
m

CL
09
>

I
'o IPA <<f
?
cfl

Ph <* 1
Cm

a CM
fl
CL
0

1
PA
CD a
*~
.9

O a DA ro
8
cd H o CL

cd *"

O
S OKHCA CM
3
s?

o 4BB4CA 00
CL

CO +
ym>

CO CL

0) X
Oh r
o o o o o o o
Oh CO CM o 00
o
co
o
*-

o
E3 o o o
adoig ojaz jo a^nrpiQ

81
 0)
Ph
O at a o+x CM*
en
B
CO ? a o+x

ant a o+x
3
w
CL

o CM
00 00

pH At a o+x fl
CU CL
q
> II
? D o+x
_o5

O
CM
LS3
a* a o+x -
a V
CL

oo < 09
<? a o+x _

II CO CJ
wa ? a o+x
CO PH
R
CL 9
CD ao o 09

a o+x _
B >

8.
J*

0 *m+ d o+x
in
11
53
pH CL
cd "t-

o o ? a o+x __

? Cm
O

Ph *jb ? a o +x
a CM
II
CL
a
'&>

4XB ? a o +x _

a
O a a* b ? a 0 +x ro
5
ftH
II
CL
1
? o
cd ->< b a o +x _

<4-H O 00

pH 2 A>< B ? D o +x CM
2
2 a><j b ? a o +x -
00
H
H
CL
3
60

CO +
a >< b ? a o+x
pH II
a > < m ? a o+x --
CO CL
<D X
v>

Ph
A A
* a x
1 A| y n T I i 7 '1
o o o o o o o o o c)
Ph in o m o m o m o m c>
c>
m in ro ro cm 4
> CO CO ^ -^
d d o od d <d d d ci
adois ojaz jo ttORisoj aspipioqo

82
CD
Ph
O <Boa<t>A _
<*

CM"-*
o
m

B
CO ob>a o
3
CL

A
W
CM
o 00 00
h>b<j>a 00
2 CL

<D ^?a<>A .ol > CJ

CM O 8
4H4BOA -
1 II
CL

OB>A _
CO <
O 11
r-

co
set
mm

OBt>A
Cl
co o
I
B>A -
B
01
m
a B>A >

<B*B<I>A "<f
a.
I
OcS _

?
R

^a 4BMM>A m
Cm
B O
a. 2
>A _
CM et
*~

D .3

V
>A .
ro

CL
t>A _
O
*"~

O
3
BO
>A -
CM
p*

CL
t>A -
CO
CO +
t>A m-

PA -
CO CL
CD X
r
o o o o O o o
Oh CO CO CM o CO CO
o o
o o o o

adois oiaz jo a^BrnpiQ

83
<r>

Ph
O ? a O+X r
CM *>
o>
m

B
CO ? a O+X
CNrS
I
? a O+X CM
w
o 00 oo
00
? a O+X B CJ
pH a> Cl 8
cl)
<? a O+X
o
CM
aP >
L^
CO
*? a O+X
o CL
*rH oo
,3
MB4-
a O+X _ <
O ||
mb ? a O+X
CO
I
B
^
>
&1
^^ 4*b ? a O +X -
CO 09
>

mb ? a O +X
m 1
fl
a R
A
o c3 *i ? a o +x ? Cm
O

^ 4xj ? a o +x S
a CM
II
CL
&< a ? a o +x

ax ? a o +x ro 2
H
cd M
a><i ?
.

O CL a
* a o +x _

4-H O o
m
*h3
a><j ? a o +x CM
2
0 a> ? a o+x -
-
CO
fl
CL 3,
Urn
!

A > < ? a O + X -

0
A > < ? a O + X -
-
CO Cl

X
A
l_v_
* A 1 V
1
o O o g o o
0. CO
*
ro CM

E3 O o d d d d
adofs ojaz jo uorjTsod asiiipjoqo

84
 p.
o <&? >A
+*
CM CO
m

CO HOB<J >A o B
Cl

A
?< >A CM W
_g

o CM
oo 00
\< >A 00 II
PH
CL

3BOfl<J >A LolC_

CM
> CJ

8
N
CO ii
l< >A B
Cl
5
<<-h CO o
i

< >A _
< a
O n
eft
Cm
co V)
?< >A
B
cn PH CL a
CD < >A -
CO
X-
* a <*H< >A
in
*

fl
09
>

B<>A
Cl
i
?
1
^a 4St>flOA

>A CM
B
Cl
cm
O
2
I
_

a
H
O S ro
o
1

B
cd
w*

o CL
>A _

o
1
60
CM

o OlflOA -
CO
B
CL

co +
>A

II
PA -
CO CL
<D X
Oh r
-8wf**A-

o o o o o o o
Oh CO co CM o CO CO
o o
E3 o o o o o
adofs ojaz jo a^ainpio

85
CD
Oh
O D O+X _
Th
CM <+

o
m

O
CO ? a o+x CL
g
cd A
CM PS
Mi ? D O+X CM
O 00 00
00 Cj
**? a o+x o>
H
CL
r
o

CD MB ? ? O+X
O J3 > II
CM S

Mfl ? D O+X fl
CL

CO <
4*a ?a o+x
O ,|
V"

CO JS
Mfl ?a o+x fl
CL
co & CO
& ? a o+x ir~
fl >

4x1 ? a o+x
m I
CO

CL

ocS 4xl b ? a o+x

<*

?
I
*

^a A><1

A>< fl ?
? ?

D
o+x

O +X
CM
1
CL
a
55
O
a.
t-

a
A>< fl ? D O+X ro
fl
g a> < ? a o + x
O
*~
Q.

O
a > < ? a o + X CM

o a > <j h> a o + X CO

CL 60

co +
a > < h> a o + X H V"-

Jh 1
CL
a > < ? a o + X CO
CD X
fl
Oh -* r-3
j ? pB
fr +
o o o o o o
Oh r>. co m ^ ro CM
o o o o o O

ado_s oiaz jo noRisoj aspipjoqo

86
 0)
Ph
O 4HH> <] >A
**
CM

CO 4BL+ M< >A

I
B> fl<J >A CM_g
O CM
00 oo
3B>fl<1 PA 00 II
pH
CL
0) LoJ CJ
KOfl >A
O
LS3 CM
rs.
q
II
?< >A
B
CL S

<KOfl >A _
oo
cd
II CO
m,

?< >A
CO PH
l
CD <:? >A _
co

0 a ?< >A
m
B
Ol
>

pH
cd <-
CL
1
o o B3fl<J >A _

?
53

Ph l< >A
I
a II
CL
cm
O

2
l< >A CM
<D
-

.1

O a l< P-A ro
"2
O

U
cd o CL
fi

cd IOA
<-t
_.

o
?H 2 B*fl>A CM
3
60

0 BflOA
B
cl
-
00
CO +
4H)fl<JPA
?H
>A -
CO
CD
Ph r
o o o
l]
o o o o
P-i O 00 CO CM o oo
CM o
& o o o o
adofs oiaz jo a^Bnipjo

87
CD
Oh
O Mi ? D O+X cm CO

II
CO ? D O+X CL

A
CM eg
MB ? D O+X w
CM
O oo 00
00 fl cj
m* ? D O+X 00
o

CD ol
4* h> n o+x CM O
tSJ
j* a ? d o+x II
S
4xj fl co
? Q O+X _

II co 1
4X B ? D O +X II

co
4<j ? a o+x _
>

8.
si m o
ax ? a o +x 53
II
a. R
AX fl ? D O +X ?
e
A>< fl ? a O+X o

a. o
CM ft.
a> < ? a o +x
D
a> < ? a o + X ro "E
o
II
Cd M o a.
J3
u
A > < fl ? Q o + X _

O
ph 2 a > < m ? a o + X CM
co
<r

2
0 a > o ? a o + X -
00
fl
CL

CO
a > <j h> a o + X H
pH B
A H> d o + CL
> <J X CO
0) X
Oh r4-
H X
o o o o O O
P< CO m ro CM
o o o o o

adoxs oiaz jo uoRisod asutpjoqo

88
CD
Ph
O m+ < > a cm -*
o>

N
CO K+ < >A CL

A
CM
^s> < >a CM
W
_g

o 00
oo
00

^:* < > a II

mm 0) CL

ol > CJ
00
<? < > a CM O o

LSI
L^N
co II
43Z+ < > A s
CL

00 <J
< >A _

II CO
<;? a < > a
I
co fe KOB<l >A _
CO

in >

Oil ? < > a fl

1
53
^[?B<3 >A
R
fl
^a < >A

10 >A
CM
I
CL
Cm
O

2
S3
.s

si
p

|<J >A ro
fl cn

cd M O CL

* l< >A _

S-t O 2
mH S at>a< >a CM
3
60

I
o -
CO
CL

co
>A

>A -
CO
<D
Ph r
H>A- ll
o o O o o O o
Ph o 00 CO
H-
CM o 00
o
CM
mO
o OO O o

adois ojaz jo ajBurpio

89
 CD
Ph
O *? D O-tX __
<+
+
CM Ol
k

II
CO ? a o+x o
CL
5 A
4<fl ? a o+x CM
w
O 00 00*
00 II CJ
mH 4<ifl ? a o+x cu CL

CD > n
ckib ? a o+x .ol

CM O
CSJ r>
5

1
i

4<j ? a o+x .
B
o CL
+"H &
co <
4*j n ? a o +x _ 09

o II M
I
CO
4*< ? a o +x
CO PH
B
a. i
CD a>< ?
Cfl

a o +x
_co

>
mm) T

0 a a>< ? a o +x
m
u
1
CO
n
pH CL
cd "*-

&< ? fl
o o a o +x _

? cm
0

Ph a>< ? a o +x |
a CM
B
CL
'55

CD 0 a>< ? a o +x _

a 8
O a a> < ? a o +x ro
'5
o

cd o OL
mm

U
cd a> <j ? a o +x _
1
<4-H T

O
PH 2 A > < ? ? o +x CM
2
0 A > < ? a o+x -
00
B
Ol
3
6d

CO +
a > < m ? a o+x
pH 1
a > < ? a o+x -
co Ol
0) X
Ph i Al *
*1 l
*
H
A
Y
1 \
* _,

o o o o o o o
Ph CO r>. co m
h-
ro cm
d d
& 0
ado|S ojaz
0
jo
0
uoRisod asiiipjoqo
0 c>

90
 CD
Oh
O S* < > A
CM >

CO ^X+ fl <3 > A CL

A
CM
<&? < > A w
_g

CM
O oo 00
oo B
Jh <:? fl < > A 4) Ol

CD < > A ol
CM O
tsi o
05 II
<&? a < > a B
o Ol s
*M CO
< > A _

o II CO
cd
dm
09
(? B < > A 09
O

CO PH
CD ? a < > a -
CO

0
'i^i
1
cd
? a < > a
m
B
Ol
>

1
o 43C+ a < > A ?
o R
fl
Oh <J > A
a
cm
B O
Ol 2
CM
B< > A _

O a < >A ro
1i
r-H
B
cd H O
m

cd l< >A _
<*
<4-H 2
pH 2 HB0H< >A CM
g,

0 49tB< >A -
00
B
Ol

CO
*B>A -

pH
>A -
CO Ol

CD X
P< r
o o o o o O
Ph CM o CO CO CM O
CM CM
t=3 o o o o o
adois ojaz jo a^Buipio

91
4.2.2.1 Linear Fit of Upper Surface Ordinate

From these plots, it appears visually that the behave for

ordinates of zero slope points linearly
given values of the maximum camber. Linear regression (i.e. the line which minimizes least-
squares error) on a line of the form

y
=
at + b {m,p constant) [4.10]

performed on this it to be nonlinear, though only slightly so. Table 4.4

data, however, shows
illustrates the results of this regression.
Because of the affine transformation property (the key
to golden section division of intervals between successive iterations to determine unknown
polygon vertex coordinates in the symmetric case), it is imperative that a linear
relationship
between the zero slope points and the descriptive parameters defining the airfoil be determined.

Table 4.4 Coefficients of [4.10] As Determined By Linear Regression

P=.i .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 .8 .9

a .5 .5 .5 .5 .5 .5 .5 .49 .49

m=.01
b .0096 .019 .029 .0386 .048 .05827 .0681 .078 .0876

a .5 .5 .5 .5 .5 .5 .5 .5 .5

.02

b .0099 .02 .03 .04 .05 .06 .069 .079 .089

a .5 .5 .5 .5 .5 .5 .5 .5 .5

.03

b .01 .02 .03 .04 .05 .06 .07 .08 .09

a .5 .5 .5 .5 .49 .49 .49 .49 .49

.04

b .0096 .01952 .029 .04 .05 .06 .07 .08 .09

a .5 .49 .49 .49 .48 .48 .48 .48 .47

.05

b .0089 .018 .028 .038 .048 .058 .0683 .078 .088

a .5 .49 .49 .48 .47 .47 .46 .46 .45

.06

b .0081 .017 .026 .036 .046 .056 .066 .076 .086

a .5 .49 .48 .48 .47 .46 .45 .44 .44

.07

b .0073 .016 .025 .034 .044 .054 .064 .074 .084

a .5 .49 .48 .47 .46 .45 .44 .43 .42

.08

b .0067 .014 .023 .032 .041 .051 .061 .071 .081

a .5 .49 .48 .47 .46 .45 .44 .43 .41

.09

b .0061 .013 .021 .03 .039 .048 .058 .071 .077

Due to the non-linearity of the coefficients, other methods were investigated.

92
The chordwise positions of zero slope, as evidenced by Figures 4.40-4.56 (even) proved to be
highly nonlinear, and will not be discussed until a workable method for determining ordinates
of zero slope have been obtained.

Using the least information known about a particular cambered airfoil, there some points that
are to be considered significant. For the upper surface considered,
they are:

The origin

The symmetric thickness distribution point of maximum thickness at (.3c,tl2)

The point at which maximum camber occurs (p,m)
The maximum ordinate y=t/2+m when p=.3c

4.2.2.2 Polynomial Fits

"given"

Attempts at fitting a series of polynomials through the points discussed above were

made. Because the non-linearity of the zero slope points, not much in the way of
of useful

information from these techniques was expected. In the case of linear fit between the points

(.3c,t/2) and (p,t!2+m), as illustrated in Figure 4.58, no clear pattern emerged. Under no

circumstances did the zero slope point lie on this line.

x-.3 x-p

Figure 4.58 Attempt At Line Fit To Determine Zero Slope Point

93
4.2.2.3 The Arc Method

If a circular arc is drawn connecting the last three points mentioned above, the following, as
shown in Figure 4.59 must be true:

The y-coordinate of the center of the circle must lie on the line v =
(tl2 + m)l2
The three points define a unique circle
passing through them

x-.3 x-p

Figure 4.59 Illustration of The Arc Method

Analytically, a circle of the form

b)2
(x
a)2 r2
+
(y =
- -

fits the above criteria. Given the three points mentioned above, a system of three equations in
three unknowns may be generated, as illustrated in equations [4.11].

(.3 -aY
(- "

b)' =
r2

(a)
v2
[4.11]
(.3 -
a)2

+ (L + m
-

b)
=r2

(b)

b): r2

(m (c)
a)2

(p + =
- -

Subtracting (c) from (a), it can be shown that

2pa
p2
-
= -

.09 .6a

This method proved unacceptable for the following reasons:

The ordinate of the center of the circle is independent of the chordwise position of

maximum camber, p. From the data generated (UTRENDS.DAT), this is not the case.

The ^-coordinate of the center of the circle is independent of the maximum camber.

94
4.2.2.4 The Curve Method

The next attempt at the task

was to try and
identify a curve that passed through the points
(.3c,tl2+m), fr^ow) and (p,m), as shown in Figure 4.60. The results of this analysis, done
by HP-15C programmable hand calculator, show no correlation between airfoils for curves of
second and third order passing through these points.

x-.3 x-p

Figure 4.60 Illustration of the Curve Method

4.2.2.5 Areas of Triangles

For triangles drawn between the origin, the x-axis and the points (.3c,tl2+m) and (p,m) as
shown in Figure 4.61, the areas can be expressed as xy!2.

x=.3 x=p

Figure 4.61 Area of Triangles Method

95
Thus the areas of the two triangles shown are

At =l(.3)(^+m)

A2 =
1(
^(P)(m)
2

and the ratio of areas A2/At is

A,
\m"
mp
A ^(.3)(l+m) .3(L+m)

It was desired to determine the range of the ratio of these two areas for any combination of
NACA four-digit airfoil considered. Figure 4.62 gives values of A2/A! for the descriptive
parameters m, p and t, and the vertices of the cube correspond to minimum and maximum values

of the respective parameter.

*-
+

Figure 4.62 Cube Plot of Area Ratio for Limit Values of Parameters

96
Table 4.5 shows the limit values used for this analysis, and Table 4.6 provides the resultant area
ratios.

Table 4.5 Limit Values For Descriptive Parameters

Parameter Minimum Value Maximum Value

(-) (+)

m .01 .09

P .1 .9

t .05 .24

Table 4.6 Area Ratios For Limit Values of Descriptive Parameters

Vertex A B C D E F G H

NACA 9105 9905 1905 1105 1124 9124 9924 1924

A2/A. .2609 2.348 .8571 .0952 .02564 .01429 1.2857 .23077

Figure 4.63 illustrates the results of this analysis.

-
+

Figure 4.63 Results of Area Ratio Analysis

97
Thus each of the descriptive parameters produces significant effects on the area ratio. This
method was deemed unusable due to the fact that there is no systematic way to arrive at an area
whose value is between At and A2 without first knowing the coordinates of the zero slope point.

4.2.2.6 Dimensionless Parameter Combinations

Often in the field fluid mechanics, it is helpful to represent flow characteristics in terms of
of

dimensionless quantities. Reynolds, Froude and Prandti numbers are examples. For the NACA
Four-Digit airfoils discussed, it was desired to determine whether any trends could be observed
in the points of zero slope when the parameters m, p, and t were combined. Although each of
these parameters is non-dimensional, they may, for the purpose of this analysis, be considered
as having a "length". In order to arrive at a non-dimensional number
using first order
combinations of these numbers, the chordwise position of maximum thickness of the symmetric
thickness distribution (jc=.3c) was included also.

With m and t representing quantities closely related to ordinate, it would seem logical that they
be lumped together. The quantities/? and .3c are descriptive of chordwise position and initially
they will be used in a similar manner. A decision was made to alter the parameter p to reflect
the fact that when p=.3c, there is no effect on the x-coordinate of zero slope for the upper
surface.

This leads to the following possibilities:

X\X2 mt
nt
yxy2 .3(p-.3)

^i m(p-.3) [4 12]
n2 = =

x2y2 -3r

xxy2 .3m

n3
x2yl t(p-.3)

Choosing an arbitrary airfoil ( for this analysis, the NACA 4412) this yields

_ (.04) (.12) _

16
n!
.3(.4-.3)

_
(.04)(.4-.3) _

nl
n2
(3)(.12)

=
(.3)(.04) =10
'3
(.12)(.4-.3)

Zero slope points of other airfoils having the same dimensionless numbers were then analyzed.

Table 4.7 illustrates the results of this analysis.

98
 Table 4.7 Results of Dimensionless Parameter Analysis

II Group II Value NACA Airfoil ^zero slope J zero slope

l .16 4412 .35355 .10380

.16 2424 .32275 .13903

.16 4524 .35470 .15527

.16 8512 .42746 .13516

2 .111 4412 .35355 .10380

.111 8424 .35526 .19763

.111 6418 .35200 .14826

.111 2512 .35362 .077681

3 1.0 4412 .35355 .10380

1.0 2406 .35467 .04935

1.0 8424 .35526 .19763

1.0 6418 .35200 .14826

Clearly, the results in Table 4.7 show no correlation between these dimensionless numbers and

the points of zero slope. Other combinations were attempted, all of which failed the objective.

4.2.2.7 The Linear Correction Factor

A final attempt to determine some relationship between the descriptive parameters and the points
of zero slope was to assume that, for the upper surface, the ordinate of zero slope could be
expressed as a function of m,p, and t. Taking into account the fact that aip=.3c, y=f/2 + m,
an expression of this form is given by

= + m +
y _

a(p-.3)

where a is a correction factor intended to account for the effects of chordwise position of

maximum camber on the ordinate of zero slope. It is evident from Figures 4.64-4.84 (pages
linear relationship for alpha does not exist.
100-120) that a simple

99
 O)
o

CO
o

CO
1
CL
*
cd
B
A
E
in f
> o
+ m
o

a D

CE II + E
*
I -m
*

o
a II
II
B
E
_j

CD

CE 10
o

e 0
E

CM
9
a
E

B
E

(Dljd|V) JOjODJ UOJ|09JJO0

100
 O)
q
II
E

CO
?
co
q
II
-

E
03 *
TJ r>.
L.
o
q
_c II
o
E
o *
a to
_c
CO
o
Hp

cd c II
m^

CD \- E
in cd
vT ?
> CO
o
+
CD
_Q
m
q
s E II
in o
o
CE II +
E
E

*
I -M
*
3

E q
o
a II
* X
D
II

>>
E

CD H- *
CE CD
ro
o

c
ro
q
o 11
Hp-

*w E
o 4>
a.
CM CM
q
II
E

T
+
^*

q
II
E

*
(DLjd|V) JOjODJ UOipaJJOQ

101
 O)
q
II
E

fT%
\j*
?
CO
o

0
E r
C

CO *
T3 IN.
X- o
O
^ n >

o
E c

o *
a (0
_c

^M
CO
o
'

c d :
CD
CD | E
in m
1. ? :
CD
> JQ
o
___ (

E B
LO O
o E
CE E *
X 3
E
H"

O*

a * X
o
0
E
2
*- *
o
CE ro c
ro
O
o
_ n

*5> E
o 4>
Q_
CM CM
O

II
E

^-
+
T~

D
o
E
? T i I
*
(Dijdiv) Jojodj uojpajjoo

102
 O)
o

II
E
?
CO
o

r*.
o

o. CO
q
II
E

> 2 m
o

II
E
CE M

a II
E

CE ro
o

n
E
4>
CM
o

E
+

R
E
I I I I
*
(Dqdiv) jojodj uojpajjoo

103
 o>
q
0
E

fT\
\J*
?
a
0

D
E ,
'
CO *
-a in.
L.
O
q
_c R -

0 E ,

0 *
Q_ w
^
m^m
co
0
.

c u ;
CD
<D h- E
m
?
CD
10
_Q
0
E II
m 0
0 E
CE E *
X 3
E O

a * x
0
H
E
2
H-

O
CE ^>
ro
0

H
0 R
4_BM

*5 E
0 4>
Q_
<N CM
O

H
E

T~
+
*"

R
E
*
(Di|d|v) -1040DJ uojpejjoo

104
 0
E

O)
?
CO
o

R
E
CO 4
o fN
v. O
o
_c R
o
E
o *
o. CO
_c
3
H)m

C H
CD
to E
CM
?
CD
-Q
m
o
E R
LO O
o E
CE 11
E *
X 3
E
a * x
o
0
E
2
- fl
CE to
o
c
ro
o
o R
-y-

W E
o 4>
CL
CM CM
O

R
E

T
+
*

H
E
*
(Di|d|y) jojodj uojpejjoo

105
 o>
o*

II
E

r-
Ol
CO
Q

-
CO
"O in
o
o
II
o
E
o
GL CO
_c
co
o

"c H
CD
CD E

CD
_Q
8
E
no

CE *
X E
a * X
a
H
E

CE ro
a

R
E
O
a. -1

CM CM
O

n
E

0
E

(DL|d|V) JOjODJ UOJJ09JJOO

106
 I I I I

(Dt|d|v) Jojodj uojpejjoo

107
 O)
o

R
E

to
o

R
E

a co
o

U
E

m
o

R
E
CE
1
X -H-

a
E

J*
CE ro
O

U
E

CM
O

II
E

R
E
I I I I
*
(Dljd|V) JOjODJ U0|p9JJ0Q

108
 o>
o

H
E

O)
?
CO
o

R
E
CO *
TJ px
k. O
o
_c R
o
E
1^ M_

o *
(0 co
__c o
Hp

c R
CD
<D E

k. ?
CD
-Q
m
o
E II
m o
o E

E *
3 Mh
E q
*x R
o
E
*- fl
o
ro
c O
ro
o R
Hpi

*5) E
o
Q_ ?
CM CM
O

H
E

^~
+
T

R
E
I I I I
*
(oi|d|v) jojodj uoipejjoo

109
 o

R
E

IN
o

R
E

a 8
H
E

m
o

CE E

x M-

a R
E

1.
CE ro
O

R
E

CM
O

H
E

E
I I

(DL|d|V) JOjODJ UOJ409JJOQ

l*j

110
 o

H
E

_?.

co
o

R
E

r-
o
*

II
E
CO
1
a. 8
*
3
,d

in
> CO + tn
o

a R

(E II + E

X *M
*
in
_

H-

O
o
a II
R
E
-i
CD
*.
CE ro
o
*

R
E

H
E

R
E
I l l l
*
(Dijdiv) jojodj uojpejjoo

111
 o

fl
E

co
o

R
E

IN.
o

OL co
o

R
E
in
> m
o
*

CE E

X ?
a H
E
J*
CE ro
o

H
E

CN
O

E
+

R
E
*
(DL|d|V) JOJODJ UOJpdJJOQ

112
 o

II
E

?_
CO
o

H
E 00

_i

IN.
O

a 8
II
!
2
h
E
!
m
o

R
E
CE
X M

O 2
>
u

3
a H
E

CE to
o
u
o

I
?
CM
o

E
+

H
E

*
(Dl|d|V) JOpDJ U0H09JJ0Q

113
 o

II
E

00
o

a co
o

> a m
o

II

CE E

I JL M-

a U
E

*.
CE ro
o

II
E

CN
q
II
E

II
E
I I I I

(Di|d|v) J040DJ uoipajJOQ

114
 01
o

CO
o

II
E

fN.
o

m
o

II
E

*.
ro
O

?
CN
O

E
+

H
E
*
(DL|d|V) JOjODJ U0ip9JJ0Q

115
(Dijdiv) jojodj uoipejjoo

116
 q
II
E

co
o

IN.

q
n
E

a CO
q
H
E
in
> m
q
II

CE E

I _

M-

q
a II
E

CE ro
O

II
E

CN
O

E
+

H
E

(Di|d|v) JO+odj uoipejJOQ

117
a

in
>

CE
X
a

CE

I l I

(oqd|v) Jojodj uoijoejJOQ

118
 i O)
i o

ie!

tli
8|
R
j
E 4*
CM

IN- -

E
s
-

o .a

'SS
R
lo
p

hV
in j*
'
Q
B

CE 11 E If
!o s

a
*
'
!a
! B ii2

-i
z ;a
CE ro
q
!3
0
8

E is
iS3
CM
O

E
+
o O o o o o o o o
^-
CM o CM ro in CO
O o o o o o o o o 8

O o o o o o o o o E
1 1 1 1 1 1
*
(Dl|d|V) JOJODJ U01P9JJ0Q

119
 CO p. CO m ro CM
R n II 1 1 R 1 1
Q. Q. a a. CL a.

t * k * * + *

cN

II
s
I

O
**>

I
09
CO

I
la
a

t
00

w\

Urn

T"

o
o
o o
o o
o

120
4.2.3 Utilization of Properties at Point of Maximum Camber

Somewhere late in the course of this research, this researcher had the notion that for the
cambered case, quite possibly the wrong track was taken. The futility in attempting to fit
cambered airfoils by determining relationships for the points of zero slope as a function of
descriptive parameters is evident from the previous examples. The thought occurred that rather

than finding the point of zero slope and generating a curve from these points, a more viable

method may be one of using the airfoil coordinates at the x=p chordwise position and this

point's corresponding ordinates and tangents.

4.2.3.1 Further Review

Recall from equations [2.7a] and [2.7b] that the relations which govern the combination of mean

line and thickness distribution are

=
x x
-

y, sin0
[2.7a]
+ co&e
yu=yc y,

and

=
x + sin0
xt yt [2.7b]
= -
cose
yt yc y,

It is important to note from the mean line, given by equation [2.5]

r\(2px-x2) ,
0 < x <
p
[2.5]
yc
=
P
m
[(1 -

2p) + 2px -

x2] , p < x < c

(1 ~PY

the camber line is yc=m. Similarly, the camber line tangent at any
that at x=p, the ordinate of

chordwise position x is given by [2.6], below.

=-

(P
~

x ) ,
0 < x <
p
=
tanfl =
J
P [2.6]
yj
2m < x < c
(P
~

x) , p
(1 ~P)

Of interest in [2.6] is the fact that the camber line possesses (with the exception of the case

This point will be important as the discussion progresses.

p=.5) only Cj continuity.

121
4.2.3.2 Enclosing Tangent Triangle

A triangle constructed about the leading edge of the upper surface of

any arbitrary airfoil is
shown in Figure 4.85. This triangle is unique for each combination of
m,p and t. In
Figure 4.85 the line AB is perpendicular to the camber line tangent at the origin
(leading edge);
the line BC is the tangent to the airfoil at the point (p,yu(p)).

C (p,yt +m)

A (0,0) x -
p

Figure 4.85 Arbitrary Cambered Airfoil Upper Surface, Ottxt^p, and Tangent Triangle

In order to compute the equations for tangent line AB, it is a simple matter to determine the
camber line slope at the origin and find its negative reciprocal. Because the leading edge lies on

the origin, the equation for this line is

"

P
y
=
ttLx [4.13]
2m

The slope of the tangent BC is determined with much more difficulty, by determining an

expression for dyjdxu at x =

p.

From the chain rule it is known that

__^
= _____ _*
[4-14]
dx dx dx .

For the upper surface, differentiating [2.7a] yields

dx ag dy,
1 i =
1 -
v cos 8^-
-
--'sin0
y'
dx dx dx
[4.15]
^y dy d8 <*y,
JJL = _Lf
-
v
'
sin 8 + cos 8
dx dx dx dx

122
For the lower surface, differentiating [2.7b] yields

dx, aft dv
! =
1 +y ' ,cos0_ + _'sin0

dx dx dx
[4.16]
dyt dyc .

8
bft dyt
= +
y
''
sin -

cos 8
dx dx dx dx

The slope of the airfoil surface at

any chordwise position x is given by
dyu dyu ax
dx. dx dx
[4.17]
9y i =
3y i dx_
dxt dx dxt

In order to obtain an expression for d8ldx, differentiation of [2.6] is necessary, and yields

',
0 < x
<p
(P)2

2/. d8 [4.18]
8
sec2
=

dx -2m
< x < c
2
' p
(1 ~P)

One may determine expressions for sin0 and cos0 by squaring [2.6] and implementing the
trigonometric identity sec20 =
tan20 + 1. After some algebraic manipulation, this yields

lm(p
-

x) 0 <x <p
+p*

\l[lm(p [4.19]
sin0 =

2m(p
-

x) < c
p <x

si[2m(p + (1 -pf

and

123
 0 <x <p
+p*

\l[2m(p [4-20]
COS 0 =

(I-P)2

< c
p <x
J[2m(p + (1 -p)4

Solving [4.18] for 30/9* gives

-2mp2

0 <x <p

30 [2m(p +p4

[4.21]
dx p)2
-

-2m(l
< c
p <x
[2m (p + (1 -pY

Rather than expending effort to obtain an expression for the slope of the airfoil at some arbitrary
chordwise position, it will be more efficient to determine the slope only at the leading edge, the

chordwise position of maximum camber, and the trailing edge (the use of the Bezier curve
precludes the determination of the slope at any other points).

At the chordwise position of maximum camber (x=p), the following simplifications can be
made:

0
3*

cos 0 =
1

sin 0 =
0

and

30 -2m
x-*p
dx

30 -2m

dx (1 -pY

124
Given the above simplifications, at x=p

_____
= _

'
dx dx
[4.22]
dju =
dy,
dx dx

and the slope at the chordwise position of maximum camber is thus

[dy, P2

x-+p'

dx 2ytm +
p2

By. [4.23]
dx,.
dyt (i
x-+p
dx 2ytm + (1 -
p)2

In a similar manner, the slope of the lower surface at x=p is

b2i
p2

x-*p
dx p2

2myt
-

b2i [4.24]
dx,
dyt (i x-*p^

dx (1
2myt
- -

p)

At the trailing edge (x=l), the simplifications below may be made:

=
sin0
Jim2 + (1 -
P)2

1 -p [4.25]
=
COS0
P)2
y4m2
+ (1 -

30 -2m

[4m2
dx + (1 -p)1]

125
 "reduces"
and the slope of the upper surface to

dyu
+ (*
-4m2yf
+ ^(1 -
p)[4m2
+ (1 -

p)2]
[4.26]
dx. [4m2
+ (1 + 2my,(l -
+
2mZ'[4m2 3y.\ + (1
p) 3*
-p)2]

Similarly, the lower surface slope at the is defined

trailing edge by
-2m [4m2 ay,
dy>
+ (1 +
4m2y,
-

f'(l -/>)[4m2

+ (1 -

p)2]
w 3x
_

[4.27]
dx,i [4m2
+ (1 -
p)2Vu

2myt(i - -
2m^[4m2
+ (1
p)
-

lx p)2]

where y, and 3y/3x are evaluated at x=l.

This may, at this point, seem a tedious process, but one must keep in mind that if this method

is successful, these formulae are used only to compute the Bezier defining polygon vertices, and
"sub-quantities"
as such will be evaluated only once for each airfoil. Additionally, many of the

used in equations [4.23], [4.24], [4.26] and [4.27] may be computed once and combined

differently to obtain the slope of the upper or lower surface at either the chordwise position of

maximum camber or at the trailing edge.

Thus the triangles which are generated by this method (there are four) are as shown in Figure
4.86 below.

Figure 4.86 Triangles Generated About Cambered Airfoil

This analysis will concentrate on the leading edge of the upper surface of the NACA2412 airfoil.
Should promising results be obtained, the method will be checked against the same surface of

the results of the second objective, the method will be expanded to the
other airfoils. Pending
portions of the NACA2412, and continue to other airfoils.
remaining

126
As in the case of the symmetric airfoils, the intervals over which the legs of the enclosing
triangles traverse will be divided by golden section. There are three choices of the interval to
be divided for each leg, however. They are:

1. Golden section search along thex-axis projection

2. Golden section search along the y-axis projection

3. Golden section search along the triangle side itself

The third option listed above was ruled out due to over-complicated axis shifts. In order to
perform either of the first two, the point at which the two sides of the triangle intersect must be
determined. The sides of the triangle in question can be expressed in point-slope form as

=
~P
y tLx

2m
[4.28]
dy^
y
-

(yt +
m)
=
(x -

p)

As x-+p~, these equations become

~P
y
= tt-
x
2m
[4-29]
dy, D2

(x -

(y, + =
p)
-

y m) i -

dx 2y m +
p2

linear equations, and a unique solution exists. All the quantities

They represent a system of

in [4.29] may be computed from [2.1] and [2.2] (with;t=p) or obtained directly from the NACA
designation.

The discussion here should mention the discontinuity that exists using this method. At the

chordwise position of maximum camber, the slope of the tangent forward of p for the

NACA2412 is computed to bedyjdxu =

-0.036715316. The corresponding tangent at x=p for
the upper surface trailing edge is dyjdxu
=
-0.037009336. This represents an absolute error of
0.00029402 and a relative error of approximately 0.8 percent. This difference is minimal, and

most likely is indiscernible to the eye.

127
In the case of the NACA2412, the point of intersection of the two tangent lines is given by the
solution to the set of linear equations as determined by [4.29] on the previous page. The matrix

formulation becomes

10 1 0
[4.30]
0.036715316 1 0.092716235

the solution of which is

-0.00930579

.0930579

As in the case of the symmetric NACA Four-Digit airfoil, golden section on the projection on

the x-axis is the initial starting point for the attempt to fit the Bezier curve to the conventionally
defined shape. This leads to four possibilities, denoted as before by the notation Case (a,b)
Golden section search performed on the interval [-0.00930579,0] yields

(1 -

t)(0) +
r( -0.00930579)
=
-0.005751295
(1)

(1 -

r)( -0.00930579) +
t(0)
=
-0.003554495 (2)

and also on [-0.00930579,. 4] yields

(1 -

t)(0.4) +
t( -0.00930579)
=
0.14703511 (D

(1 -

t)( -0.00930579) +
t(0.4) =0.2436591 (2)

According to the conventions set forth above, case (1,1) will be a third-order Bezier curve whose

defining polygon vertices are:

BT

0 0

BxT
-0.005751295 0.05751295

B2T
0.14703511 0.087317794

B3T 0.4 0.078030109

128
The B6zier defining polygon for is
case (1,2) given by
B0T

0 0

B,T

-0.005751295 0.05751295

B/ 0.2436591 0.083770214

B3T 0.4 0.078030109

Similarly, case (2,1) is defined by

"BT"

0 0

B,T

-0.003554495 0.03554495
=

B2T
0.14703511 0.087317794

0.4 0.078030109
3T_
Lastly, the defining polygon vertices for case (2,2) are:

BT

0 0

V -0.003554495 0.03554495

0.2436591 0.083770214
B/
B,T 0.4 0.078030109

Figures 4.87 through 4.90, on the pages following, illustrate each of the four cases along with
the desired curve. It is observed that case (2,1) is apparently a very good fit to the leading edge
upper surface of the NACA2412. In order to determine if the above method provides similar
results with others, this method was attempted on NACA3612 and NACA4412 airfoils.

129
 X-N
T-

t z
N_X
o
o
UJ >-

CM to _J

o o
CM <
o CL
a: g o

5!
O
LU
M
LU
M
C\2 < LU LU
o
LO Q.
o
ZSL CD CD
a . co

O 1 1 ?
fe
o
ro
CO
cd
U

CN

I CN
<
u
<
mH

o c
o

3
e
Urn
cd
1
r-.
00

a 8
3
an
m-H

mH

<D

"n
0)
D3
O O
9|DU]pJ0

130
02

C\2

CN

U
co
cd
O

CM

l CN
<

a
o
a

3
S
ID

00
00

8
3
00

<D

"n
CD
PQ
O O
9|DUJPJQ

131
 CN,

8
cd
U
i

CN

^?
CN
<
u
<
55

c
o.
.

>

-5

3
E
U
w
4)

1
00

<t

8
3
at

O O
9|DUJpjQ

132
 ^-N.
CM
___

CM o
<N_>

LU >-

CM CO _J

o o
CM <
o CL
mm. a: o
3!
O
LU
N
LU
ISI
CM < LU LU
21 CD CD

1 1 ?
CN
CN

WH

CN

I <*
CN
<
u
<
mm

c
o
. *
?J

_g

*3
E
Urn
k.
U

o
ON

8
3
M

mH

CD

"n
CD
PQ
o o
9|DU|pJ0

133
In the case of the NACA3612 airfoil leading edge upper surface, the point of intersection of the
two tangents is

-0.012557811

0.12557811

Golden section search performed on the interval [-0.012557811,0] led to the following initial
values

(1-t)(0) + t (-0.012557811) =-0.007761154 (1)

(1 -

t)( -0.012557811) +
t(0) =-0.004796657 (2)

search of [-0.12557811,0.6] led to

(1-t)(0.6) + t (-0.012557811) =0.221418453 (D

(1 -

t)( -0.012557811) +
t(0.6)
=
0.366023736 (2)

By the conventions outlined for this airfoil, the four initial Bezier curves generated to mimic the
NACA3612 are (Case (1,1)):

B0T

0 0

BXT
-0.007761154 0.07761154

0.221418453 0.106501037
B/
0.6 0.075633691
K
se (1,2):

0 0

B,T
-0.007761154 0.07761154

B2T
0.366023736 0.094710760

B3T 0.6 0.075633691

134
Case (2,1) is defined by the control points

V 0 0

BJ -0.004796657 0.04796657

B/ 0.221418453 0.106501037

0.6 0.075633691
B3T.
and Case (2,2) is the curve defined by

V 0 0

B.T
-0.004796657 0.04796657
=

B2T
0.366023736 0.094710760

0.6 0.075633691
B3T.

The resulting curves, compared with a conventionally generated NACA3612 leading edge upper
surface are provided as Figures 4.91 through 4.94 on pages 136-139. By visual inspection, it
is seen that Case (2,1) also provides a good fit to the desired curve.

135
 ^

*
___

N^
O
o
LU >-
I

CM 3
O
o
CL
CD
QC C
CV2 3 LU LU
M
3
Z
a
CD
LU
CD
CO
CO 1 1 ?
<
o V
a
< cd cd
U
mZ,

1
1
CO
i

CN

NO
m
1 %M <
U
0) <
ft
A ft
o p c
o
i-H
^__^
CM

<D
I
E
cd ? Urn
r~H
w S3
f-*

etc 1
9 I cd <*

8
3
M

i-H

PQ

136
 ^-N

CM
^~
z
*~*
o
o
LU >-

CO _J

CM < o o
o CL r co
CO
a: a:

CM 3
o
LU
ISI
LU
LU
M
< LU
z CD CD
CO o
CO 1 1 ?
< CN

s
cd
U
i

CN

cn
l <
U

fl a
o o

3
3
lis
fl i
a CN
ON

8
3
oo
wi
PH mm

"n
PQ

137
 ^
^"*

Cfe
z
CM o
o
LU >-

CO I

CM < o r-

T-
O CL CO
co
ac Ol.
CM 2
cj
LU
M
LU
M
< LU LU
CD CD
CO o
CO 1 1 ? ID

<
o CN.

<d
u
I

CN

I <
U
<
fl 2

e
o

'I
3
Id E
w
ha
eg

fl
1
a cn
ON

8
3
00
PH

<D
i-H

N
0)
PQ

138
 d)mms

CM
Z
o
o
LU >-
CO -J

CM < o o
o CL
r <o
CO
ro 01 Ol.
LU LU
CM <
O N M
< LU LU
z CD CD
CO o
CO 1 1 ? lO

CN

o
a
cd
o U
<cj-
i

CN

NO

I cn
<
U
<
fl __
O
I

o e
o
I I
H-^>
i
3
E
cd w
l-i
u

1
a ON

8
3
00
PH

<D
pH

N
0)
PQ

139
In a manner similar to that developed for the NACA2412, the results for the NACA4412 show

that the intersection of leading edge upper surface tangents occurs at

-0.022665927

y 0.113329637

As before, Golden section division of the interval [-0.022665927,0] yields

(1-t)(0) + t (-0.022665927) =-0.014008314 (1)

(1 - t)(-
0.022665927) +
t(0) =-0.008657614 (2)

Division of the interval [-0.022665927,0.4] yields

(1-t)(0.4) + t (-0.22665927) =0.138778091 (1)

(1 -

t)( -0.02266597)
+
r(0.4) =0.238555982 (2)

and the matrix containing the Bezier defining polygon vertices for Case (1,1) is

V 0 0

BtT
-0.014008314 0.070041568
=

B2T
0.138778091 0.107485737

0.6 0.098030109
B3T.
The defining polygon vertices for Case (1,2) are

V 0 0

BtT
-0.014008314 0.070041568
=

B2T
0.238555982 0.103874009

0.6 0.098030109
B3T.

140
For Case (2,1), the defining polygon matrix becomes

0 0

B_T

-0.008657614 0.04328807

B2T
0.138778091 0.107485737

0.6 0.098030109
B3T.
Finally, Case (2,2) is determined by

V 0 0

BtT
-0.008657614 0.04328807
=

B2T
0.238555982 0.103874009

0.6 0.098030109
B3T.

As is evidenced by Figures 4.95 through 4.98, pages 142-145, none of these cases provided any
accurate of emulation to the NACA4412. This was not totally unexpected. The reader should

notice that the airfoils analyzed in this section were not chosen at random; they all possess the
same thickness ratio, and were also chosen such that effects
changing only the maximum
of

could be discovered. Additionally, the NACA3612 was chosen because the ratio -pllm is the
same as that for the NACA2412. A fourth airfoil, NACA2418 was also plotted utilizing the

same strategy (Figures 4.99 through 4.102, pages 146-149) to visualize effects of thickness ratio

variation. It is clear that the defining parameters have significant effects on the placement of the

defining polygon vertices. Had this researcher more time available to mount the task, it is quite

possible that relationships between m,p and t could be found that would be used to generate
Bezier polygon vertices to generate NACA Four-Digit airfoils without having to resort to the
conventional method of cambered airfoil generation. This would represent a significant jump in
computational efficiency in comparison to conventional airfoil generation. Also, under ideal
circumstances, coefficients used in golden section division of the triangles generated about the
airfoil woulddefault to the symmetric case when m=0 and p=.3.

141
 *^-N

^i

z
N_X
o
CD
LU >-

CM CO -J

o
CM < O
o CL
*

Cl. Cl.
5
O
LU
ISI
LU
ISI
o o
< LU LU
m o.
z CD CD
<D

1 1 ? W

8'
ro o
_C

o cd
U
o
LO CN

I CM . t

<
U

i
o e
o

3
E
U
cd b

1
m
ON

s a
3
00

CD
*N
CD
P3
O O
9|DUJpjQ

142
CM O
O

o o
LO CL

_*2

8' CN

ro o

o 8
WH
tf
o
m CN
CM
I Tf
Tf
<
u
o <
o mm

CM 1
*

a
o
a
o _g

3
LO E
*"~

ID
w.
Cv>
N
o
o
fi
*~

NO
ON
*

o a
3
LO 00
PL,

mH o
o
o

"tM o
LO
CD o
I
PQ
o o
9|DU}pJ0

143
 *~*s
fM

t* ~7
CM O
o
LU >-
CM CO I

CM < o
O CL
Ol. Cl.
LU LU

g
<
ISI
LU
N
LU
z CD CD

1 1 *
CN,

cd
U

CN

I
U
<
rZ

___

3
E

r>
o\

8
3
0

CD

CD
PQ
o o
9|DU|pjQ

144
CM

O
CN

&
6
CN
I i-H

I
<
mH 55

o e
o
a
2
3

cd

0 I

oo

a
On

8
3
00
E

(D
"n
PQ
o o
9.DUJPJ0

145
 y'^
^.

k Z
N_X O
o
LU >-

CO -J

00 < o o
o Q.
*-

or Cl. o

CO 3 LU
ISI
LU

3
z
LU
CD
K o o
LO OL
CD
^H cp

CM 1 1 ? M

<U
fc
o 0) ro o
8
<1 ed cd
U
!z; 1 i

oo
mm

CO
i CN
1 M <
0) u

fl
ft
ft
$I

o t> c
o
>~A
H-J d>
I
3
E
cd W
H
w 15
wi

a On
On

w
8
3
oo
PH
PL,
0)
i-H

N
0)
m

o o
94DU1PJQ

146
 ^^

CM
___

V-*' O
o
LU >-

CO -J

CO < o o
O CL
a: Cl. o

CO 3
o
LU
m
LU
M
o o
< LU LU
LO CL
z CD CD
<P

CV2 1 1 + CO

CN

4>

<
ca
cd
U
55 oo
T-H

CN
I <
U

c
o
cd
-^

3
E
3 PL!

S3

a 8
H
8
3
PH 00
E

"n
PQ

o o
9|DUJPJ0

147
00

^
CM
<J
CN.
O d)

<U ed
u
55
1
CO
oo

1
1 mM U
CP
ft $
a e
i

o D o
a
pH
^__) <P 3
cd I
^"^ w is
wi

i
a
w
8
3
PH oo
'mm

"n
CQ

o o
9JDUJPJ0

148
CO

CM
< CN
CN
O
< cd
U
55 i

oo

CN
I <
U
<
55
el
o
a
3
E
cd PLl

S3

a CN
O

w
8
3
PH 00
wi

mm

"is
CQ

o o
9JDU1PJQ

149
4.2.4 Conventional Airfoil Generation

As alast resort, the method of combining thickness distributions and camber lines described in
section 2.2.2 can be employed to generate cambered airfoils
using the Bezier symmetric
thickness distribution. The non-linearity of the trigonometric terms would seem to be the
deciding factor in the determination that the successful method found in the symmetric case
would not work for cambered airfoils, due to the affine transformation property.

The interactive FORTRAN program GENFOIL.FOR (Appendix E) was written to generate

user

NACA Four-Digit airfoils of the user's choice. The difference between the conventional method
and the method outlined in this paper is that the x-coordinates of the symmetric thickness
distribution must be generated by the Bezier algorithm. It is these values that must be used to
determine final chordwise positions on a cambered airfoil. Figure 4.103 shows the logical flow
path of this program.

150
 GENFOLL PROGRAM FLOWCHART

oonffcm nAiuNO mxB

OONVBnUL oooasMAim

Figure 4. 103 Genfoil Program Flowchart

151
5. Conclusions

The intent of this research was to develop a computationally efficient method to generate a
NACA family of airfoil sections.
Considering only the number of basic operations to compute
ordinates for the conventionally defined airfoil versus both chordwise position and ordinate with
the Bezier curve, the method presented fails in this respect. The findings of this research,
however, have shown the airfoil shape to be linked with the golden section, a ratio which
pervades nature. Additionally, the method presented has some benefits not available to

conventionally described NACA airfoils. Airfoils generated using this method can be readily
according to the user's discretion. One disadvantage of employing Bezier curves as
altered

compared to B-splines is the fact that changing one of the defining polygon vertices on the

Bezier curve affects a global change on the curve (and the corresponding segment of the airfoil),
whereas local control can be obtained through the use of B-splines.

Perhaps there exists a method whereby these shapes can be generated without resorting to
conventional methodology. Evidence would seem to suggest this to be the case. It is hoped that
this project will not end here; plenty of opportunity for potential research exists in this area.

152
Appendix A. The Golden Section

A.l Origin and Early Uses

$*

Consider a number such that, when squared, yields plus or a number fi

one; whose
reciprocal equals the original number minus one.
Mathematically, these two statements can be
expressed as:

($-)2 $*
= + 1 [A.1]

and

=
n -

1 [A.2]

By some minor algebraic manipulation, it is easily seen that [A.l] and [A.2] are equivalent, and
one can therefore safely assume that equals fi. In this text, this number be denoted
will by
<->*. The solution to [A.l], from the quadratic formula, is given by
1 yr
<K
_
=
[A.3]

The numerical values of which are

$*
=
{ 1.618033989,-0.618033989 }

For the purposes of this discussion, only the positive root of [A.l] will be considered.

The value of has, through the ages, been called many things: the golden number, the divine

proportion, the golden mean and the golden ratio to name but a few. While the origin of mans
**

awareness of this particular number is obscure, the earliest use of is in the construction of
the Great Pyramid at GizehA1, whose faces have a slope height of exactly 1.618 ($*) times half
the base length. This ensures that the height of the Pyramid is at the same time the square root
of times half the base. Additionally, the area of the faces is times the base area. For a
graphical illustration, refer to Figure A. 1-1.

Figure A-l.l The Great Pyramid of Gizeh

A-l
Mathematically, the Great Pyramid exhibits the following characteristic:

$*

h,
slope
=
[A.4]

Thus, from the Pythagorean Theorem (which was non-existent at the time),
b2^
h2
+ b- =
($*)2

b2
h2 {(**)2
= -

1}
4

h2
=
<K (from equation [A.l])
4

h =
t/i

The area of the faces is given by

A =
4 Ih.
r\ slope
b

=
4
.\*'\Y

<Kb2
=

The ancient Greeks were well aware of the aesthetic values of the golden mean also. A
rectangle drawn around the front of the Parthenon will be a golden rectangle whose length is
times its height. A golden rectangle as shown in Figure A-1.2 below has the property that
when a square is removed from it, the remaining portion is itself a golden rectangle, and this

process may be carried on indefinitely.

k\
/
\ x
\/

B
/
A\

A /
/
/ \
I

?f- /
/
I
\ /
/
\ c/
""^

Figure A-1.2 Golden Rectangles

A-2
The diagonals of the two largest rectangles as shown in Figure A-1.2 have some interesting
$*
properties as well. The longest diagonal is times the length of the next longest diagonal,
and their point of intersection is the theoretical point from which the"whirling squares",
A,B,C,D,E and F emanate. The spiral in Figure A-1.2 is generated by connecting the
intersection points of adjacent squares. This shape is known as the golden, or logarithmic,
spiral, and is found in a multitude of places throughout nature. Swirling galaxies, hurricane
clouds, snail shells, sea horses, ocean waves, animal horns, and the seed patterns of
sunflowers and daisies all take the form of the golden spiral. A curled human finger (the
bones of which are in golden proportion to one another) also takes the shape of the golden

spiral.

The Order of Pythagoras, an ancient Greek society, took as its symbol the five-pointed star,
shown as Figure A- 1.3 below.

Figure A-1.3 The Badge of the Order of Pythagoras

The star in Figure A-1.3 has the following properties: for any line segment, the next larger
segment is times the length of that segment, or

at: =
cp-(ctj)

AB =
**(BC)

beforehand that the line segments of the star are all in

Mathematically, if one assumes

constant ratio to each other, it can be said that

CD =
ATJ -

ATJ

ATJ =
AC
ATJ CD

A-3
If we assign the values m to AD, to AC,
arbitrarily n and o to CD, we obtain

o =
m -

m n

n o

from which

n2

m(m -

n)
=

m2 n2

mn =
-

n2

Dividing by yields

2
m m _
1
n n

Solving this quadratic shows that mln =

A.2 The Fibonacci Sequence and the Golden Section

Leonardo Fibonacci da Pisa the son of a prominent merchant and city official. Fibonacci
was

became one of the most prominent mathematicians of the thirteenth century. The sequence of
numbers that bears his name originated from a problem posed to him by ruler of the Holy
Roman Empire, Emperor Frederick II. The problem:

How many pairs of rabbits placed in an enclosed area can be produced in a year from one pair of

rabbits if each pair gives birth to a new pair each month starting with the second month?

Tree"
The "Rabbit Family as shown in Figure A-2.1 does not take into account the mortality
rate for the rabbits, and assumes that the rabbit pairs are incapable of reproduction until they
reach the age of one month. Upon close inspection, a mathematical pattern emerges.

Month Pain

1 1

2 1

3 2

4 3

5 5

6 8

7 _
13

8 21

Figure A-2. 1 Propagation of Rabbit Pairs

A-4
Fibonacci came up with a sequence of numbers
describing the solution to the problem posed,
a sequence which has proved to be descriptive of much more than merely the population
growth of rabbits. The Fibonacci sequence, denoted
F, is defined as the sequence of
numbers such that

F=lA> F=l
Cl 1> F=F +F
+
n =
2,3,. [A.4]
0 r r-2 r-l

The Fibonacci sequence has many interesting properties. Most importantly,

Fn + 1
lim
<p*

n-*oo
p
[A.5]

and

lim =
T
n-oo
pn + 1
[A.6]
<P

where

1
T
_
=
_
=
0.618033989

$"

It is t and not that will be used most extensively in this research.

Additionally, the Fibonacci sequence appears as the sum of the diagonals of Pascal's triangle,
shown in Figure A-2.2, below.

Figure A-2.2 Pascal's Triangle

A-5
A.3 Leonardo da Vinci

The great Renaissance artist and scientist Leonardo da Vinci was well aware of the aesthetic
value of the golden section. In one of his most famous drawings, shown as Figure A-3.1, he
realized that proportion would play a vital part in
making his paintings seem realistic.

>c
BCA4fl= Golden section ratio

Figure A-3.1 Leonardo da Vinci's Study of the Human Proportion

Interestingly enough, on a statistical basis, the average ratio of BC/AB above is equal to <!>*,
and it holds separately for both genders.

A.4 The Golden Section and Univariate Optimization Theory

Consider a function of one independent variable whose minimum value is to be found. There
are a variety of methods to accomplish this task, the golden section interval search is a
method which is very versatile in cases where the function is not well behaved. The method
performs equally well when the function is well behaved. It has the added advantage of being

easily implemented on the computer; hence its wide appeal.

$*

It is r and not that will be used most extensively in this research.

Consider the function F on the interval [a,b] as illustrated in Figure A-4.1. The independent
variable in this instance is x such that a The assumption must be made that a single
_*__.

minimum exists on [a,b] and that the function can be evaluated for any x in the interval. If
we now pick two intermediate points xt and x2 such that Jt_ ^x2 and evaluate the function, we

obtain F_ and F_. Because the assumption in this case was made that the function was

unimodal, either xx or x2 must form a new bound on the minimum.

A-6
 Figure A-4.1 The Golden Section Method

In the figure above,Ffa) is greater than F(xz) so that the new lower bound becomes x;. If
Ffr_J had been larger than Ffa), x2 would become the new upper bound. One of the
objectives of this type of optimization technique is to reduce the bounds on the minimum as

rapidly as possible. Because xr or x2 will become the new bound, both x, and x2 should be
chosen to be symmetric about the center of the interval such that

Xu X2 -

X_ X{ [A.7]

The values of Xj and x2 are picked such that

xi Xl X2 xi [A.8]
K-
* ~

*i xi

Thus, if x} becomes lower bound xh then x2 will become the new xt

the new such that the
ratio of x2-xx to the total interval xu-x, will remain constant. Normalizing the interval, we set

x,=Q and xu=l so that jc2=1-x_. Equation [A.8] now becomes

Solving for xl, we obtain the following result:

X,' = i____V =
0.38197
2

X2 =
1 -

X2 =
0.61803

and

*
-i
=
1.61803 =
$

A-7
For each iteration of the golden section method, only one new function evaluation is

required, and the new bounds (original) interval become

X.1 =
(1 -
t)X.
'
+ tX
"

[A.10]
X2 =
rX,
+ (1 -

t)Xu

Had x2 become the new bound, the equations in [A. 10] would be reversed. This procedure
has the added attraction that a specific number of iterations can be specified to achieve a
given accuracy.

Because use of the golden section in this research was limited to analysis of data points, all
of the iterations were performed by programmable hand calculator. After using the method to
refine locations for the undetermined defining polygon vertices, some simplification was
desired to make FORTRAN coding simpler and more understandable. A useful property of t

was found to be:

1 1
r2
= -

-1 T

2 2t
r3

-1
=
-1 +

2 2 3t
r4

= -

-3

5 5t
r5

-3
=
-3 +

5 5 St
r6

= -

-8

-8 13
r7

=
-8 + 13 t

(- i-irl

f.s
r"

+
=
K _2

and t to any (integer) power becomes linear in r, with the resultant coefficients successive
numbers in the Fibonacci sequence.

In conclusion, it should be noted that there is a wealth of published material dealing with the

golden section, and that this section has barely made a scratch in the uses and occurrences of
proportion"

the "divine .

A-8
Appendix B. Cubic Spline Derivation

For a piecewise cubic

spline, the conditions above can be applied to the cubic polynomials
described as

St(x)
x.)3
=
a.(x -
+ b.(x -

xf + ct(x -

x.) + d. [B.l]

Equation [B.l] holds for each i=0,l,...,/i-l. It is clear that

W =
dt =
/(*,.) =
yt

If condition (c) is applied,

4+i =
SM(xM) =
St(xM)
=
xt)3
+ x.)2
[B.2]
Z>,.(x.+1
-

at(xM +
-
+
4
-

c,(*.+1 ^.)

for each i=0,l,...,n-2.

Because the term (xi+rxt) will be used repeatedly, the substitution

h. = -
x.
xM

for i=0,l,...,n-l will be much simpler and more convenient.

If we also define d=fixn)=yn it can be seen that

di+l =
ath] +
bg +
ctht +
dt IB-3]

holds for each i=0,l,...,n-l.

Similarly, define cn=S'(xn) and notice that

2bt(x 3a_(*
x.)2

S.'(x) =
c. + -

xt) + -

which implies that S'(xd=ci for each i=0,l,...,/i-l. By applying condition (d),
3a,7*(2

c,.+1
=
ct *
2bfit + P.4]

for each /=0,l,...,n-l.

By defining bn=S"(x)l2 and applying condition (e), another relationship between coefficients

may be obtained.

B-l
 b.+l =

bt + 3a.h. [B.5]

for each i=0,l,...,n-l.

Solving [B.5] for a, and substituting into equations [B.3] and [B.4] yields a new set of
equations

4+i -
4 +
ctht + i(2ft. +
2>.+1) [B.6]

and

c,.+1
=
c. + ht(b. +
&.+1) [B.7]

for each i=0,l,...,/i-l.

By solving [B.6], first for c,

c,
=

(<*,?, "

4) "

3 (2&f
+
*+1) P.8]

and, with a reduction of the index, for c,-.,,

When the index of equation [B.7] is reduced by one and the values immediately above are

inserted, the following linear system of equations results:

*i-,*,-, +
2(Vi +
h,)b, +
htbi+l =
l(di+l
ni
-

dt) -

-L(d,
"-i
-

dt_x) [B.9]

3.1.1.1 Natural Cubic Splines

By specifying the free, or natural, boundary conditions S"(x^=S"(x,)=0, then

0 =
S"(*0) =
2b0 +
6a0(x0 -x0) ^b0
=
0

and the boundary conditions also imply that bn=S"(x^l2=0, and thus b=0.

The two equations b0=0 and bn=0, along with the equations described by [B.9] produce a

B-2
linear system described by the vector equation A is the
Ax=b, where (n+1) by (n+l) matrix

10 0 0

h0 2(h0 +
/j_) hx
0 \ 2(\ +
^)
A =
h2
0

0 0 0 1

and b and x are the vectors

\id2-dx)-l(d, -<*)

b =
and x =

n-i n -
z

Because matrix A is strictly diagonally dominant, a unique solution is guaranteed for this
system of equations10. Once this system is solved for the &,'s, it becomes a simple matter to
determine the other coefficients of each spline, a, and c by utilizing equations [B.5] and
[B.8] (the coefficients a\ are the y-values of the data points).

3.1.1.2 Clamped Cubic Splines

The derivation for clamped cubic splines follows in much the same manner as that for free
splines. For the beginning condition S'(x0)=f'(x0)=c0, it can be observed from [B.8], with

i=0 that

d. -

dn hn

Consequently,

2Vo+Vi"rK -4.) -3/'K) [B.10]

B-3
 Similarly,

/,W-<?_-c_._+*_._(ft_._ +
*_)

so that equation [B.8] with i=n-l implies that

/'(*.)-*-*-'
+ *_)+
hn -
1
r<2*.-i *..!(*_.! +
aj
dn dn h
-

1 ,

A. n -
1

and

*. A- -
1
+
2A. .
_*>
-
3/'(*) -

_3_(rf. -rf. .
t) [B.ll]
n -
1

Equations [B.9], [B.10], and [B.ll] form the linear system Ax=b, where A is the
(n+1) by (n+1) matrix

2o o 0 0

K 2(0 +
_) A_
0 h2)
A =
t 2(nx +
h2
0

\-2 2(*.-2+*.-l) *.-!

0 . . 0 2hn
n -
1 -
1

and b and x are the vectors defined such that

3
(d,
-

d0) -

3f(xQ)
h,

hd2 -

dj
-

hd, -

d0) K

b =
and x =

3
(d" -

d ,)
n~l)
-

(d"-1 ,
-

d ,)
n-2)

hn~i/ hrt ~
,
2,

3f'(xn)-J-(dn-dn_1)
nn -
1

This linear system is also diagonally dominant, thus a unique solution exists for it as well.
As in the case of natural splines, the remaining coefficients can be obtained through the use
of equations [B.5] and [B.8]. Computer programs to perform cubic spline interpolation (both

types discussed) are included for reference in Appendix F.

B-4
Appendix C. References

1. Gibbs-Smith, Charles H., The Aeroplane: An Historical Survey.

Her Majesty's Stationery Office, London 1960

2. Anderson, John D. Jr., Introduction to Flight. 3rd ed.,

McGraw-Hill,New York 1989

3. Anderton, David A., Sixty Years of Aeronautical Research 1917-1977.

NASA/ U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington 1980

4. Bertin, John J., and Smith, Michael L., Aerodynamics for Engineers. 2nd ed.,
Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey 1989

5. Abbott, Ira H., and von Doenhoff, Albert E., Theory of Wing Sections.
McGraw-Hill, New York 1949 (also Dover, New York 1959)

6. Frost, and Prechter, The Elliot Wave Theory: Your Key to Financial Success
New Age Press, New York 1989

7. Rogers, David F., and Adams, J. Alan, Mathematical Elements for Computer Graphics.
2nd ed., McGraw-Hill, New York 1990

8. Beer, Ferdinand P. and Johnston, E. Russell, Jr. Mechanics of Materials. McGraw-Hill,

,

New York 1981

9. Burden, Richard L., and Faires, J. Douglas, Numerical Analysis. 3rd ed.,
PWS-Kent, Boston 1985

10. Noble, Benjamin, and Daniels, James, Applied Linear Algebra.

Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey 1988

11. Akin, J. Ed, Computer-Assisted Mechanical Design

Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey 1990

Springer-
12. de Boor, Carl, A Practical Guide to Splines. Verlag, New York 1978

13. Huntley, H. E., The Divine Proportion: A Study in Mathematical Beauty.

Dover, New York 1970

14. Gibbs-Smith, Charles H., and Rees, Gareth, The Inventions of Leonardo Da Vinci.
Charles Scribner's Sons, New York 1978

15. Vanderplaats, Garret N., Numerical Optimization Techniques for Engineering Design:
With Applications. McGraw-Hill, New York 1984

C-l
Appendix D. Comparative Graphs of NACA Four-Digit
Symmetric Airfoil Sections and Bezier Curve Emulations

Note: The plots contained in this appendix were generated using both the conventional and

B6zier methods. Each plot shows the conventionally described airfoil section with a solid red

line, and the Bezier emulation with a dotted blue line. The plots were produced using the IBM
Professional Graphics Facility (PGF).
 _J

_J
O

e a:
q: <
< on
< UJ
g N
o < UJ
i-H 2 DO
H->

1
.

__j *H

torn
on
n ?
ro _____

CU -Th tn
o

II

i-H I
-\mt O

0)0

CO r
"T"

o o o o o o o o
00 CO LO ro CN
o o o O O O o
dlBurpjo

D-l
 _j

-J
o
u.
e 0_
a: <
< o_
< LU
g M
o < LU
z OQ

"

CO

O) ."S co
o

II

r-l I

<5o

a2

co r "T
o o o o o o o o
00 CO m ro CM
o o o O O O o
a^urpJO

D-2
 -J

_J
O
Ll.
s 0_
on <
<
< LU
g N
o < LU
i-H 2 CQ
H->

0)

i-H

X >
^ _____

CD -Th

fl 5jD
II

rH I

Eh 3
O

0>O

a
CO r
"T~

o o o o o o o o
00 CO to ro CN
o o o o o o o
ayBUipjQ

D-3
 -J

_J
o

p C_
Cl. <;
< o_
LU
<

o S*
Z
i.
I
I CO
H->

rt
1
CD
LS3
<D

Q CO
cn >
ro _____

0) .Th

II
o
i-*
T
i
JL_j ^h

a
CO r "T T
o o o o o o o o
00 co LO ro CN

o o o O O O o

D-4
 _J

1
o
L_
p 0_
0_ <
< Cl. o
< LU r- O
o M
o < LU
H 2 CQ
H-^ o
1
-

r o>

pO -i-H
r1
n r*
__
o
oo
H
roCQ
rH __
o

CO
03 > o o
co :s

0) ^ Oi
o
09
O

o
II QQ

I I
E-" rt
O r~
O
o
*H

o
U
CM
0)O

a
o
CO r T o
o o o o o O o o o
00 CO LO ro CM o
o o O O O o
ayBurpio

D-5
 -J

_J
o

p c_
or <
< 0_ o
LU o
<
o N
o < LU
i-H CQ
H-> o
.

1 1
.-O --H
o
00
H *>

pH o

*
co
a. > -.
o
rt
o
GO co 3
._,
'%
o

rt S> o
II
*Q
I 'I
rt
fa
o o
ro
Ofx,
<* O
CM
cuO
a^

o
CO I I 1 1 1 1
J-

o
o o o o o o o o o
oo r** co lo ^ ro cn o
*

o o o o o o o

9^BinpJ0

D-6
 -J

_J
o
Ll.
p or
on <
< or o
< LU o
g M
o < LU
i-H 2 CQ
H-> o
1
-

pH ?H O)

S
pO
<^
-i-H
o
00

i-H o

co
m > *
o
rt
o
co
ro .3

^ oo
CD .tn o

o
II 00

o
i-H
V
I
I
Q fe
rt
h
o O
ro
Of*,
s< O
CM
0)0

a
a
o
CO r T O
o o o o o o o o O
00 CO LO ro CM O
o o o o o o o o

a^Burpjo

D-7
 _J

_J
O

p or
or <
< or
LU
<

o %
2
a
CQ

1
Zs
i-H

Q CO
cn >
ro ____>

o -Th CM

II
o
rH
V
I -
- P
.rt
*h
eh rt
o

cd o

co r n 1 1 1 r
o o o o o o o o
00 Is- CO LO "* rO CM
*
__?

o o o o o o o
a^BinpJO

D-8
 -J

-J
O

p
on. <
< or o
< LU o
g N
<
p 2
LU
CQ
o
fH fH 1 Oi

pO -i-H
O
00

wPQ
O

CO > ^
o
rt
p
CO co 3
55
oo
0) CO
O
wA

rt i-H
o
Wi

II

I u2S

rt
o o
ro
Ofx,
'P-H

O
CM
cuo

a S5
a
o
CO r n 1 1 1 1 r o
o o o o o o o o
00 h* co lo -^ ro cm
o o o o o o

ayraipJO

D-9
 _J

_J
O

p or
or <
< or
LU
rt <
g M
< LU
2 CQ
"43
1
fO -pH

rH

cn >

o) :rt WA

rt Sf m
II 00

*Q
i
lI
-iji p
T.A
S rt
o
Ofx,
fH

<*
0)0

CO r T
o o o o o o o
00 Is- CO LO ro CM
o o o o o o o
a^BnipJO

D-10
 _!

-J
o
li_
p or
or <
< or
LU
rt <
o N
o < LU
CQ

rH
'-'
pH I
Q)
pO -pH

n
r_

co
tn >

0) .tn

rt S
II
*
<4->

-, I
-^ P

h rt
o
^
i-H

<!
<D O

a12

co r T
o o o o o o o
00 Is- CO LO ro CM
o o o O O O o

D-ll
 _j

_J o

p or
or <
< or
< LU
o
o < a
rH CO

5
tnPQ
o

0) >
CO
^
o> :rt CO
wi

rt SP II
*S
O i
rH I
rt

Eh
fa
rt
O

c5o
a^

a
CO r T
o o o o o
00 co LO
o o o o o o

D-12
 _J

-J
O
u.
p or
or <
^ or
LU
<
o N
o <
2
LU
CQ

1
5.2
H o)
otPQ
pH

Q CO
n >
co
^
o> :rt
rt w>
II
^Q
o
rH
VI
<4->

rt
fa
O
Ofx,
rH

cuO

a
CO r nr -i 1 1 -r
o o o o o o o
^"
00 co LO ro CM
_ ?
o o o o o o

a^nipjo

D-13
 _j

_l
o

p or
or <
< or o
< LU o
o M
o < LU
CQ
H-> o
I
.
O)
.

rO -pH

r! n o
oo

CO n
o

CO
K > o p
ro co m3
^ s
<D S 00
wA
p
Ph
^ S O
II oo

o
rH
V
I
I
t-2S
-^
Eh
fa
rt
O o
ro
Ofx,
o
CM
0) o

a
o
CO i 1 1 1 i 1 r o
o o o o o o o
oo r> co lo "^ ro cm
o o o o o o o

D-14
 _J

-J
O

p or
or <
< or
LU
rt <
g N
o < LU
pH 2 CQ
H->
rH 1
CD
rQ pH

N
PH
0)

rH

**
co
< ?
ro _____

CD -tn
O)
wA

II

pH I
^
Eh
fa
rt
O

'&<
OO
a^

a
CO i 1 i 1 1 r
o o o o o o
oo Is- co lo -* ro
o o o o o o
a^Binpio

D-15
 _J

J O
Lt.
p or
or <i
< or
< LU
g ISI
o < LU
2 CQ
H^>
.

pH 1
pO -pH

torn
pH

? l
CO
m >
CO
_^
CD -tn
CM

II
4->

pH
II
rt
fa
O
Ofx,
IK
0)0

CO r
o o o o o
00 CO LO
o o o o o o

OyBUipJO

D-16
 -J

_J
O
Lu
p or
or <
< or
LU
ti <
o
o < a
2 CQ

^
1
O)
r1 tsj
h o

pH

m >
co
_^

CM

II
o
ph
V
i
rt
fa u*.s
b-> ti
O
Ofx,
rH

<
0)O

a
CO r "T T T
~T~

o o o o o o O
00 CO LO ro CN
o o o o o o o
ajBTjipio

D-17
 -J

-J
O
Ll.
p or
or <
< or
LU
<
g M
o <
2
LU
CQ
"4-3
pH
.

pH 1
pO -pH

Q CO
CO
CO TJ
03 53
CD -Ih CM
CM
rt *f II

pH I -
_ P
prt
*h
EH rt
o
^
pH

<!
<d o
a^

a
CO r T
o o o o o o o
00 CO LO ro CM

o o o o o o o

D-18
 _j
-J
o
LL
p or
or <
< or
< LU
g M
o < LU
pH CQ
H->

rt
pH I
pO pH
-p^i
N
PH
CD
lo m
Q __

CO >
co __,

o) :rt CO
CM
rt _p II
^Q
iH I
-
\X P
-a
fa
b-l ti
o
Ofx,
<$
<U o

a
CO r
o o o o o o o
00 CO LO ro CM
o o o O O O o

D-19
 _j

i
o
Li_
p or
or <
< or
ti < LU
N
g
o < LU
pH CQ
H->

^
pH i
0)
pQ pH
'W^
N
pH
H->

CO PQ
**
CO
n >
CO
^
O) .tn if
CM
ti bJD
II

-
^ p
mti
fa
Eh rt
O
Ofx,
pH

0)0
a^

a
CO r
o o o o o o o
00 CO LO ro CM
o o o o o o o

D-20
Appendix Comparative Graphs of NACA Four-Digit
E.
Cambered Airfoil Sections and Bezier Curve Emulations

Note: The plots contained in this appendix were generated using both the conventional and
Bezier methods. Each plot shows the conventionally described airfoil section as the

corresponding Bezier emulation The plots were produced using the DIS8 plotting
. package on

the VAX at RIT (a legend for the plot is not available using this software).
o c
o

D
cn
D
E
CxJ
^"

CO
o 00
cm

cn
LJ o
cn
M
LJ
DQ

ro-cro-ro-KO-ro-
s*o **o *o zmQ ro co
eq.Dunpjg

E-l
 1

*
1

1 7o
! C77

o c
0
/ !
70

:,s:
oo

c
.m>
:o 0
+)

D
CC :5
o 1 .
0 w
0
LJ E
LiJ : lo &-
:>
c__: CO .
Q (D
ZD t
i W
1
CJ
T

ct: cn L
LiJ CJ : to 0
r
cn
M
LJ ! CM

OQ 70

1
V/
1 1 1 1 i i III!
L 0
1 1 1
1
' 2" 0' 0-2" 0-E"

S"l D D Q VD r D-K 0S"0

8'

IF 0

E-2
 T
1

/ I CD

o
Li
c
0
/ I oo

o 0

0
cn _)
- - '

.
o CO
0
LJ Q-
: in

.
0
X 1 1

T
1 .

CJ 1

m cn L
: to o
LJ CJ "JC
ml
cn -
o
N
LJ I CM

\1 o

. -1

'

i I I i i
. . . .
1
9
1
0-E"
0' J-
S"

0 0
E"

o <r o r0 o r o-cr O-K OS'C

eq-Dunpjg

E-3
_]

o c
L_ o
._>

o
az

LJ
LJ
cm OO

CJ CD

C cn
LJ CJ
cn
M
LJ
DQ

rO-crO-;'0-fr-DS"0-
9*0 K0 CO LVO I"0 O'O
S^DLnpjQ

E=4
 CD

O
-

OO
-J
o

o c
-

fx
C
L_ O o 0
cm ._>

" ._)

-P
o CO
cn
o CO
-
0
LJ E 0_
ID
r_j

cn oo
1 O CD
CO
ZD o ._)
-^
CJ oo 5
LO o
"O
L
cm cn
to o
LJ o .n

cn u
CJ
INI
LJ j CM

O
CQ
-

\ a

V _

"

o
111'
Mil 1 i
l'0-cVQ-E'0-*"0S"0-
9*0 v'U '0 Z'Q I'O O'O
a^DunpjQ

E-5
 1
1

/ !
70
oi

o
L_
c
0 ,
/ '.
7o
00

"0 0
cm )
-?->

o
cn _)

/
70 CO
0
LJ E
: lo
&-
QJ
0
cm 00 I

ID i
x

o 1

CD .
-0
cm cn L
: to 0
LJ CJ
cn
:
LJ '. CM

OQ 70

\ .
rH

V/ -
O

. r-t

pin 1 1 1 1
1 O
1 1 i i
r 1
Z' 0-'
'
S"

0 V0 0 0 V 0 O'la v O-K OS^O -

e q.DU
0

E-6
 1i

! oi

I
7o

'. oo

70

o c
Ll_ 0 :,s: c
70 0
cm

cn
0
_J
'<*.'
70 CO
E 0
LJ : lo a-

cm LO .
0 <d
ID O CO
o CO
CD a
-0
cm en L
: 0
l_j CJ
cn l 1 _
to
_c

"
:

n
! CM

DQ 0

v
\
70

.... III! 1 1 1
la
i i i i i III! 1 1 1 1
1
S' > ' Z' Q-2' 0-"

0 0 D o r 3 Cr 0 f D-V OS'O
9'
u npj
0

E-7
_J

o c
L_ o
cm
o
cn __>

D
LJ
LJ

cm CD
ID O
CJ CD
OO

cm cn
LJ o
cn
ISI
LJ
OQ

ro-s-o-L-o-v'os-o-

s'b ro 'o zmu ro o-o

eq.DunpjQ

E-8
Appendix F. FORTRAN Computer Programs
* MODULE NAME : NEWTON

?PROGRAMMER : BILL SCARBROUGH

*

?CREATION DATE : JUNE 12, 1987

*

?OBJECTIVE : THE PURPOSE

OF THIS SUBROUTINE IS TO DETERMINE THE
* ROOT OF A SPECIFIED EQUATION USING THE NEWTON-
* RAPHSON METHOD OF TANGENTS.
*

?VARIABLE DESCRIPTION
*

? XOLD ORIGINAL ESTIMATE OF ROOT

? XNEW NEW ESTIMATION OF ROOT
? FOLD FUNCTIONAL VALUE OF XOLD
? FPRIME DERIVATIVE OF FUNCTION AT XOLD
? EPSX ABSOLUTE ERROR BOUND OF X VALUE
? REPSX RELATIVE ERROR BOUND OF X VALUE
? EPSF ABSOLUTE FUNCTIONAL UNCERTAINTY
? ITMAX MAXIMUM NUMBER OF ITERATIONS ALLOWED
? IT COUNTER FOR NUMBER OF ITERATIONS
*

SUBROUTINE NEWTON ( W , T , FHAT , FHPRIME , XOLD ,

& EPSX, REPSX, EPSF, ITMAX, XNEW)
*

IMPLICIT NONE
*

EXTERNAL FHAT
INTEGERM IT, ITMAX ,I,MAXPTS

REAL FHAT, FHPRIME, XOLD, XNEW, FOLD, FNEW, FPRIME

REAL EPSX, REPSX, EPSF, T, W

*

LOGICAL^l ENCLOSED, CONDITION( 3 ) , CONVNR

*
******************************************************************

IT = 1
=

WRITE(6,^) 'IT ,IT

FOLD = FHAT (T, XOLD)

FPRIME = FHPRIME ( T , XOLD )
*

THEN
IF (ABS( FPRIME ).GT.1/EPSF .OR. ABS ( FPRIME ). LT .
EPSF)
WRITE(6,M*
STOP. DERIVATIVE TOO LARGE OR TOO SMALL.

?
IT, XOLD, FOLD, FPRIME
WRITE (6, 2004)
RETURN
END IF
*

XNEW =
XOLD -
FOLD /FPRIME
FNEW = FHAT (T, XNEW)
*

? TABLE HEADINGS
OUTPUT
? '
NEWTON-RAPHSON METHOD FOR DETERMINING ROOT
WRITE (6, 2002)
*

?
WRITE (6, 2006) 'INITIAL GUESS =',XOLD

?
WRITE(6,M
?
WRITE (6, 2007) "FUNCTIONAL ERROR BOUND =', REPSX
? 2006 FORMAT(/,T10,A15,F6.2)
?
2007 FORMAT (T10, A24,E10. 5,/) ',' X'
? ITERATION # ', 'ORIGINAL X F OF ,
WRITE(6,2003) '
+
'
DERIVATIVE AT X ,

F-l
 ' ' ' '
+ NEW X , F OF NEW X
DOWHILE(IT .LE. ITMAX. AND.
+ . NOT . CONVNR ( XOLD , XNEW , FOLD , FNEW , EPSX ,
+ REPSX, EPSF, ENCLOSED, CONDITION))
*

? WRITE (6, 2004) IT, XOLD, FOLD, FPRIME, XNEW, FNEW

FOLD = FNEW
XOLD =
XNEW
FPRIME = FHPRIME (T, XOLD)
IF (ABS( FPRIME ) .GT.l/EPSF .OR. ABS ( FPRIME ). LT .
EPSF) THEN
WRITE(6,A)'
STOP. DERIVATIVE TOO LARGE OR TOO SMALL.
?
WRITE(6,2004) IT, XOLD, FOLD, FPRIME
RETURN
END IF
*

XNEW =
XOLD -
FOLD /FPRIME
FNEW =
FHAT (XNEW)
IT =
IT+1
'IT
='

WRITE(6,^) ,IT

ENDDO
*

?
WRITE(6,2004) IT, XOLD, FOLD, FPRIME, XNEW, FNEW
*

?
IF(CONDITION(3) ) THEN
? WRITE (6, 2005) 'ABSOLUTE BOUND ON FUNCTIONAL UNCERTAINTY
'
? + SATISFIED.
? ENDIF
*

? FORMAT SECTION
*

? 2002 FORMAT (40X,A45//)

? 2003 FORMAT(10X,A12,10X,A10,8X,A6,10X,A15,10X,A6,9X,A10,//)
? FORMAT(10X,I4,15X,E15.7,5X,E15.7,5X,E15.7,5X,E15.7,5X,E15.7,/)
2004
? 2005 FORMAT(10X,A55)
RETURN
END
*

FUNCTION DNACA4DIG(T,X)
*

IMPLICIT NONE
*

INTEGER N
DOUBLE PRECISION DNACA4DIG,X,T,B(4)
*

B(l) = X
? X
B(2) =
B(l)
? X
B(3) =
B(2)
3516*B(2 )+. 2843*B(3 )
-

DNACA4DIG = 5*T^
( .
2969*SQRT(X)-. 126*B( 1) -.

& .1015^B(4))

RETURN
END

? PROGRAM NAME F2
*

? PROGRAMMER BILL SCARBROUGH

*

? CREATION DATE 13 NOVEMBER 1989

FUNCTION DF2(T,X)

F-2
IMPLICIT NONE

DOUBLE PRECISION DF2 ,T,X,R,NACA4DIG,F1

R =
1.1019 ? T ?
T
Fl =
5 0^ (
. . 2969^SQRT (X) -
126^X-. 3516^X+. 2843^X^X-
.
. 1015*X*X*X*X>
DF2 =
Fl -

SQRT(X^(2^R-X) )
RETURN
END

F-3
?MODULE NAME : CONVERGE

?PROGRAMMER :BILL SCARBROUGH

*

?DATE :JUNE 8, 1987

*

?PURPOSE : TO DETERMINE IF A ROOT SEARCHING METHOD HAS CONVERGED

*

**************************************************************************
**

? VARIABLE DESCRIPTION
*

? XLEFT LEFT BOUND ON ROOT VALUE

? XRIGHT RIGHT
BOUND ON ROOT VALUE
? FLEFT FUNCTION VALUE OF XLEFT
? FRIGHT FUNCTION VALUE OF XRIGHT
? EPSX ACCEPTABLE ABSOLUTE UNCERTAINTY BOUND OF ROOT
? REPSX ACCEPTABLE RELATIVE UNCERTAINTY BOUND ON ROOT
? EPSF ACCEPTABLE ABSOLUTE BOUND ON FUNCTION VALUES
? ENCLOSED FLAG TO DETERMINE IF XLEFT < ROOT < XRIGHT
? CONDITION ARRAY OF FLAGS TO DETERMINE WHICH CONDITION (S)
? ARE SATISFIED
*

******************************************************************************

?SUBROUTINE AND FUNCTION SUBPROGRAMS REQUIRED

? NONE
*

FUNCTION CONVNR ( XLEFT , XRIGHT , FLEFT , FRIGHT , EPSX , REPSX , EPSF ,

+ ENCLOSED, CONDITION)

IMPLICIT NONE

REAL XLEFT , XRIGHT , FLEFT , FRIGHT , EPSX , REPSX , EPSF

LOGICAL^l CONVNR , ENCLOSED, CONDITION(3)

ENCLOSED = .TRUE.

CONDITION(l) = ENCLOSED .AND.

(XRIGHT-XLEFT) /2
ABS .0 .LE. EPSX
= ENCLOSED + XRIGHT)
ABS (XLEFT 0.0
CONDITION^) .AND.
.NE. .AND.

+ ABS ( (XLEFT-XRIGHT)/ (XLEFT + XRIGHT)) .LE. REPSX

= ABS (FLEFT) EPSF ABS (FRIGHT) EPSF
CONDITIONS) .OR. .LE.
.LE.

CONVNR =
CONDITION(l) .OR.
CONDITION^) .OR.
CONDITIONS)

RETURN
END

F-4
 PROGRAM BCALL

IMPLICIT NONE

DOUBLE PRECISION AAA, BBB,T,R,DF2 ,DFPRIME,DNACA4DIG, ROOT, SLOPE

DO T =
0.01,0.40, .01

R = 1.1019 ^T^T
AAA = 1.0E-6
BBB =
R
CALL DBI SECT
(T, AAA, BBB, ROOT)
SLOPE DFPRIME(T,ROOT)
=

' '
WRITE ( 6 , ? ) ROOT , ROOT
=

'
WRITE(6,^) 'SLOPE =', SLOPE
WRITE(12,10) T,ROOT
WRITE (13, 10) T, SLOPE
ENDDO
10 FORMAT(T5,F6.3,3X,D12.7)
STOP
END

F-5
SUBROUTINE DBISECT(T, A, B, P)

IMPLICIT NONE

INTEGER I, ITMAX
DOUBLE PRECISION A,B,DF2 , P,EPSX,T,X1,X2 ,DFPRIME

1 =
1
ITMAX =
1000
EPSX =
5.0E-12
DOWHILE (I . LE . ITMAX )
P =
A+(B-A)/2
IF(ABS(DF2(T,P) ) .LE. EPSX. OR. (B-A) /2 .O.LE.
EPSX) THEN
BISECTION'
PRINT ?. 'SUCCESSFUL
EQUALS'
PRINT ?, 'ROOT ,P, 'ITERATIONS REQUIRED =',I

RETURN
END IF
I =
1+1
XI DFPRIME(T,A)
=

X2 DFPRIME(T,P)
=

IF ( X1^X2 GT 0 ) THEN . .

A=P
ELSE
B=P
END IF
ENDDO
AFTER" ' '
PRINT ?, 'BISECTION FAILED , ITMAX, ITERATIONS
RETURN
END

F-6
 PROGRAM BEZ CALL

IMPLICIT NONE

INTEGER MAXN,NPTS,CPTS,I,J
PARAMETER(MAXN=500 )
DOUBLE PRECISION DBEZIER3,B(4, 2 ) ,P(MAXN, 2 )

B(l,l) =
0.0
B(l,2) =
0.0
B(2,l) =
0.0
B(2,2) =
2.5787E-2
B(3,l) = 1.185307E-1
=
B(3,2) .06

=
B(4,l) .3

=
B(4,2) .06

NPTS =
4
CPTS = 201

CALL DBE ZIER3( NPTS, B, CPTS, P)

"NEW"
OPEN(UNIT=6,FILE='BEZIER.OUT'

,
STATUS=
)
f

DO I = 1,CPTS,1
WRITE(6,10) (P(I,J),J=1,2)
ENDDO
10 FORMAT(3X,D14.6,5X,D14.6)
STOP
END

F-7
*

?
PROGRAM NAME MINPOINTS
*

?
PROGRAMMER BILL SCARBROUGH
*

?
CREATION DATE 12 NOVEMBER 1989
*

?
DESCRIPTION
*

?
THIS FORTRAN PROGRAM UTILIZES CLAMPED CUBIC SPLINES
?
TO FIND A FUNCTION TO FIT THE SHAPE OF A SYMMETRIC AIRFOIL.
?
ITERATIONS WILL PROCEED UNTIL THE BEST FIT IS OBTAINED. THE
?
PROGRAM WILL THEN INFORM THE USER OF THE NUMBER OF POINTS
?
REQUIRED TO ACHIEVE THAT " BEST FIT " .

? SUBROUTINES REFERENCED
*

? NEWTON-
NEWTON-RAPHSON METHOD FOR DETERMINING ROOTS
*

? CLAMPS-
CLAMPED CUBIC SPLINE ROUTINE
*

?
VARIABLE DESCRIPTION
*

PROGRAM MINPOINTS
*

IMPLICIT NONE
*

INTEGER MAXPTS,I,J,N,ITMAX,K,NPTS,NBEST
PARAMETER (MAXPTS= 500 )
REAL NACA4DIG,X(1:MAXPTS,0:MAXPTS) , Y ( 1 : MAXPTS , 0 : MAXPTS )
REAL A(0:MAXPTS) ,B(0:MAXPTS) , Q ( 1 : MAXPTS , 0 : MAXPTS ) , FSPLINE, FIXPT
REAL C(0:MAXPTS) ,D(0:MAXPTS) ,H(0:MAXPTS) ,L(0:MAXPTS) , MU ( 0 : MAXPTS )
REAL T, ALPHA(0: MAXPTS) , Z ( 0 : MAXPTS ), FPO , FPN , XOLD , FPRIME
REAL EPSX, REPSX, EPSF, FHPRIME, CHORD, XSTART,MAXERR,P, AAA
REAL YCALC ( 1 : MAXPTS , 0 : MAXPTS ) , ERROR ( MAXPTS ),SUM,X0,R,BBB
*
FORM'
PRINT ?, 'ENTER DESIRED THICKNESS IN DECIMAL
READ(5,^) T
*

1 =
1
DOWHILE ( T EQ 0 0 OR T GT 1 0 AND I
. . . . . . . . . . . LE . 3 )
AGAIN'
PRINT ?, 'INVALID INPUT. TRY
READ(5, ?) T
I = 1+1
ENDDO
*

IF ( T EQ . . 0 . 0 OR T GT
. . . . 1 . 0 AND
. . I . GE . 3 ) THEN
'
PRINT ?
,
'
THREE TRIES AND YOU ARE OUTTA HERE
STOP
END IF
R =
1.1019^T^T
*

J =
1
NPTS =
2
*

' '
PRINT ?
, ENTER LENGTH OF CHORD

READ(5,^) CHORD
*

FPN =0.0
*

AAA=1.0E-6
BBB =
R

F-8
?
CALL FIXPT(T,XO,XSTART)
? CALL BISECT(T, AAA, BBB, XSTART)
FPO =
.0671927
-
.017408^T
-
3.55908^T^2 + .388474/T

XSTART =
.00488874 -,190253^T +2.22379^T^2 -
9.96043^T^3 +
& 18.6574^T^M
PRINT ?, 'STARTING POINT EQUALS ', XSTART
PRINT ?, 'STARTING SLOPE EQUALS', FPO
? ' '
PRINT , TRAILING EDGE SLOPE : , FPN
MAXERR =
100.0
N=l
X(N,0) =
XSTART
Y(N,0) =
SQRT(X(N,0)^(2.^R-X(N,0)))
PRINT ?, 'ORDINATE AT STARTING POINT =
',Y(N,0)
? ENDDO
*

? N =
4
?
DOWHILE(N.LE.NPTS)
?
P (CHORD =
XSTART) /(N-l)
-

? P
H(0) =

? DO I =
1,N-1,1
?
H(I) =
P
?
X(N,I) =
X(N,I-1) + P
?
Y(N,I) =
NACA4DIG(T,X(N,I) )
? ENDDO
*

X(N,1) =
.2999491

Y(N,1) =
T/2.
? =
1.
X(N,2)
?
Y(N,2) = .0105^T

CALL CLAMPS (MAXPTS, T,X,Y,N, FPO, FPN, H, A, B,C,D,L,MU,Z, ALPHA)

Q(N,0) =
X(N,0)
*

K =
1
DOWHILE(K.LE.MAXPTS-l)
Q(N,K) Q(N,0) + FLOAT (K) /FLOAT (MAXPTS)
=

YCALC(N,K) = FSPLINE(MAXPTS,N,X,Q(N,K),A,B,C,D)
K =
K+l
ENDDO
ERROR(J) =0.0
*

DO I = 0,NPTS,1
SUM =
(YCALC(N,I)-NACA4DIG(T,Q(N,I) ) )**2
ERROR(J) =
ERROR(J) + SUM
ENDDO
*

IF(ERROR(J) .LT.
MAXERR) THEN
MAXERR =
ERROR(J)
NBEST =
N
ENDIF

J = J+l
N = N+1
*

?
ENDDO
DO I =
0, MAXPTS, 1
WRITES, ?) Q(NBEST,I), YCALC(NBEST, I )
ENDDO
PRINTS NBEST =
", NBEST
PRINTS ERROR =
*, ERROR (NBEST-3 )
STOP
END

F-9
*

? SUBROUTINE NAME CLAMPS

*

? PROGRAMMER BILL SCARBROUGH

*

? CREATION DATE 12 NOVEMBER 1989

*

? DESCRIPTION
*

? THIS FORTRAN SUBROUTINE WILL COMPUTE CLAMPED CUBIC SPLINE

? COEFFICIENTS FOR A GIVEN INPUT OF A SET OF X-Y DATA POINTS
? AND THE SLOPE OF THE CURVE AT THE END POINTS
*

? VARIABLE DESCRIPTION
*

? X,Y ARRAY OF DATA POINTS TO WHICH CURVE IS TO BE

? FIT
? I INTEGER, ARRAY SUBSCRIPT, LOOP COUNTER

SUBROUTINE CLAMPS (MAXPTS, T,X,Y,N, FPO, FPN, H, A, B,C,D,L,MU, Z, ALPHA)

IMPLICIT NONE

INTEGER N, MAXPTS, I, J, NPTS

REAL X(1:MAXPTS,0:MAXPTS),Y(1:MAXPTS,0:MAXPTS),ALPHA(0:MAXPTS)
REAL A(OiMAXPTS)
REAL B(0:MAXPTS) ,C(0:MAXPTS) ,D(0:MAXPTS) ,
MU ( 0 : MAXPTS )
Z FPN,T,NACA4DIG
REAL L(0:MAXPTS) ,H(0:MAXPTS) , (0:MAXPTS) ,FP0,

EXTERNAL NACA4DIG

DO I = 0,N-1,1

A(I) Y(N,I)
=

H(I) X(N,I+1)-X(N,I)
=

'H('
PRINT ?. ,1, ") ",H(I) =

ENDDO

=
3MA(1)-A(0))/H(0) 3^FP0 -

ALPHA(O)
ALPHA(N) = 3^FPN 3*-

( A(N) -A(N-l) ) /H(N-1 )

DO I = 1,N-1,1

3.0*(A(I+1)*H(I-1)-A(I)*(X(N,I+1)-X(N,I-1))+A(I

=
ALPHA(I)
& H(I))/(H(I-1)*H(I))

ENDDO

L(0) =
2.0^H(0)
MU(O) = 0.5
Z(0) =
ALPHA(0)/L(0)

DO I = 1,N-1,1

= 2.0MX(N,I + 1)-X(N,I-1))
-
H(I-l)*MO(I-l)
L(I)
MU(I) =
H(I)/L(I)
=
(ALPHA(I)
-
H(I-irZ(I-l))/L(I)
Z(I)

ENDDO

L(N) = H(N-1)M2.0 -

MU(N-l))
=
(ALPHA(N)
-
H(N-1)^Z(N-1))/L(N)
Z(N)
C(N) =
Z(N)

F-10
DO J =
N-1,0,-1

C(J) =
Z(J) -

MU(J)^C(J+1)
B(J) =
(A(J+1) -

A(J))/H(J) -

H(J)^(C(J+1) + 2.0^C(J))/3.0
D(J) =
(C(J+1) -

C(J))/(3.0^H(J))
ENDDO

RETURN
END

F-ll
******************************************************************************
* *

? PROGRAM NAME: DBEZIER3 ?

* *

? PROGRAMMER: BILL SCARBROUGH ?

* *

? ?
CREATION DATE: 10 APRIL 1990
* *

******************************************************************************

* *

? ?
DESCRIPTION: THIS FORTRAN ROUTINE WILL, FOR A GIVEN SET OF DEFINING
? ?
POLYGON VERTICES, GENERATE THE THIRD-ORDER TWO-DIMENSIONAL
? ?
BEZIER CURVE AND ITS FIRST AND SECOND DERIVATIVES.
* *

******************************************************************************

* ?

? ?
USAGE: THIS ROUTINE IS CALLED BY DBEZIER3 (NPTS, B,P,DP)
* ?

?
? USER INPUTS: B -
THE 4x2 MATRIX OF DEFINING POLYGON VERTEX COORDINATES
?
? NPTS -
THE NUMBER OF POINTS ON THE CURVE TO BE COMPUTED,
*
? NOT TO EXCEED 500
* ?

THE ?
? OUTPUTS: P(NPTS,2)
-
MATRIX OF X,Y COORDINATES OF POINTS ON
? *
CURVE
* ?

?
? DP (NPTS, 2) -
MATRIX CONTAINING INFORMATION;
DERIVATIVE
?
? FIRST COLUMN, FIRST DERIVATIVE, SECOND
?
?
COLUMN, SECOND DERIVATIVE AT P.
?
*
******************************************?????????????????*??????????????????

?
*
*
? INTERMEDIATE VARIABLES:
?
*
*
? INTEGERS
*
*
*
? MAXN -
MAXIMUM ARRAY SIZE (SET AT 500)
*
? ICOUNT -
INDEX COUNTER FOR P, DP ARRAYS
*
? I -
COLUMN COUNTER
?
*
*
? REALS
*
*
*
* T -
PARAMETER VALUE, 0 .LE T .LE 1
?
? TSTEP -
INCREMENT ON T, DETERMINED BY NPTS
?
? COEFF -
4x4 COEFFICIENT MATRIX USED IN COMPUTATIONS
?
OF CURRENT PARAMETER VALUE TO THE J-l POWER
? TMAT -
1x4 MATRIX
*

*****************************************

*
*
? SUBROUTINES REFERENCED:
*
*
? MATPROD -
PERFORMS MATRIX MULTIPLICATION

***

SUBROUTINE DBEZIER3 (NPTS, B, P,DP,DDP)

*

IMPLICIT NONE
*

INTEGER MAXN,NPTS,NPTS2,I,J,K
PARAMETER (MAXN=500) , M

DOUBLE PRECISION B (4, 2 ) ,P(MAXN, 2 ) ,DP

(MAXN, 2 ) ,COEFF(4, 4) , TSTEP, TMAT( 1, 4)
4) 1, 3 ) 1, 2 )
DOUBLE PRECISION DCOEFF(3, 4) ,DDCOEFF(2
, ,DTMAT( ,DDTMAT(

DOUBLE PRECISION TEMP( 1, 4) ,TEMP2

( 1, 2 ) ,DTEMP
( 1, 4) ,TEMP3
( 1, 2 ) ,DDTEMP( 1, 4)
DOUBLE PRECISION TEMP4 ( 1, 2 ) ,DDP(MAXN,
2)

F-12
*

******************************************************************************

? determine if number of points requested is larger than memory alloted. . .

DOWHILE ( MAXN . LT NPTS

.
)

PRINT ?, 'ERROR:', NPTS, 'POINTS REQUESTED IS LARGER THAN ALLOCATED

OF' '
MEMORY , MAXN, 'POINTS.
THAN' '
PRINT ?, 'ENTER NUMBER OF POINTS DESIRED (LESS , MAXN, ').
READ(5*) NPTS2
NPTS = NPTS2
ENDDO
*

******************************************************************************

? initialize variables...
*

I COUNT =
0
T =
0.0
TSTEP =
1.0/(NPTS-1)
TMAT(1,4) =1.0
*

? set coefficient matrix...

up
*

DO 1=1,4,1
DO J=l,4,l
COEFF(I,J) =0.0

ENDDO
ENDDO
*

=
COEFF(l,l) -1.0

COEFF(l,2) =3.0
=
COEFF(l,3) -1.0

COEFF(l,4) =1.0

COEFF(2,l) =3.0

=
COEFF(2,2) -6.0

=3,0
COEFF(2,3)
=
COEFF(3,l) -3.0

COEFF(3,2) =3.0

=1.0
COEFF(4,l)

? time for computation. . .

DOWHILE (T.LE. 1.0)

I COUNT =
I COUNT + 1
*

DO J=3,l,-1
? T
TMAT(1,J) =
TMAT(1,J+1)
ENDDO
*

CALL MATPROD ( TMAT , COEFF , TEMP ) -._,_,

COEFF...
product of TMAT and
? note: the matrix temp is the 1x4 matrix
CALL MATPROD ( TEMP , B , TEMP2 )
*

DO 1=1,2,1
P(ICOUNT,I)
=
TEMP2(1,I)
ENDDO

matrices.
generate first and second derivative coefficient

DO I = 1,3,1
DO J = 1,4,1
DO K = 1,2,1

F-13
 DCOEFF(I,J) =
0.0
DDCOEFF(K,J) =0.0
ENDDO
ENDDO
ENDDO
*

DCOEFF(l,l) =
-3.0

DCOEFF(l,2) =9.0

DCOEFF(l,3) =
-9.0

DCOEFF(l,4) =3.0

DCOEFF(2,l) =
6.0
DCOEFF(2,2) =
-12.0

DCOEFF(2,3) =6.0

DCOEFF(3,l) =
-3.0

DCOEFF(3,2) =3.0
*

DDCOEFF(l,l) =6.0

DDCOEFF(l,2) =
18.0
DDCOEFF(l,3) =
-18.0

DDCOEFF(l,4) =6.0

DDCOEFF(2,l) =6.0

DDCOEFF(2,2) =
-12.0

DDCOEFF(2,3) =6.0
*

? generate DTMAT and DDTMAT parameter matrices.

*

DTMAT (1,1) =
TMAT (1,2)
DTMAT (1,2) =
TMAT (1,3)
DTMAT (1,3) =
TMAT (1,4)
*

DDTMAT(1,1) =
TMAT(1,3)
DDTMAT (1,2) =
TMAT (1,4)
*

? compute derivatives...
*

CALL MATPROD ( DTMAT, DCOEFF,DTEMP)

CALL MATPROD ( DDTMAT, DDCOEFF,DDTEMP)
CALL MATPROD (DTEMP,B,TEMP3)
CALL MATPROD ( DDTEMP , B , TEMP4 )
*

DO I =
1,2,1
1S,1
DP(ICOUNT,I) =
TEMP3(1,I)
DDP(ICOUNT,I) =
TEMP4(1,I)
ENDDO
)DO

T =
T + TSTEP

ENDDO
RETURN
END

F-14
*****************************************************************************
?
PROGRAM NAME: SYMMFOIL ?

? *

? PROGRAMMER: ?
BILL SCARBROUGH
* *

? ?
CREATION DATE: 15 MAY 1990
* *

*****************************************************************************

* *

? DESCRIPTION: ?
THIS FORTRAN MAIN PROGRAM WILL GENERATE A TWO-DIMENSIONAL
? ?
NACA FOUR-DIGIT SYMMETRIC AIRFOIL WITH MAXIMUM THICKNESS
? ?
SPECIFIED BY THE USER USING CUBIC BEZIER CURVE SEGMENTS.
? ?
THE PROGRAM WILL AUTOMATICALLY GENERATE DEFINING POLYGON
? ?
VERTICES FROM THE MAXIMUM THICKNESS PARAMETER AND
? ?
DETERMINE FIRST AND SECOND DERIVATIVES.
* *

*****************************************************************************

* *

? ?
USER INPUTS: THE USER IS PROMPTED FOR THE THICKNESS RATIO AND A NAME
? ?
FOR THE OUTPUT FILES. THE PROGRAM DOES EVERYTHING ELSE.
?
? NUMBER OF DATA POINTS GENERATED IS LIMITED TO 400 POINTS
* *
ON EACH (UPPER AND LOWER) SURFACE.
* *

* *
OUTPUTS: THE USER-SPECIFIED DATAFILES.
*
*
***************************************************************************
**
*

* *
INTERMEDIATE VARIABLES:
* *

* *
INTEGERS
1f *

*
* MAXN -

PARAMETER, LIMIT ON ARRAY SIZE, NUMBER OF

*
* POINTS GENERATED PER AIRFOIL SURFACE
*
* SEGMENT -
DENOTES SEGMENT OF AIRFOIL BEING GENERATED -

*
* FORWARD OR AFT OF POINT OF MAXIMUM THICKNESS
*
* I,J,NN -
LOOP COUNTERS
*
* FILENO -
LOCATIONS OF FILES TO MAINFRAME
SEGMENT *
* NPTS -
NUMBER OF DESIRED DATA POINTS PER
*

*
* REALS
*
*

VERTICES *
* B -
4x2 ARRAY OF DEFINING POLYGON
*
* P -
MAXNx2 ARRAY OF AIRFOIL SEGMENT SURFACE
*
* COORDINATES
*
* DP -
MAXNx2 ARRAY OF FIRST DERIVATIVE VECTOR
*
* COMPONENTS
*
* DDP -
MAXNx2 ARRAY OF SECOND DERIVATIVE VECTOR
*
* COMPONENTS
*
* T -
MAXIMUM THICKNESS RATIO
*
* TAU -
GOLDEN SECTION NUMBER
*

*
* CHARACTERS
*
*
*
* FILE1 -
FILENAME FOR OUTPUT STORAGE
*
* TEMPFILE -
STORAGE OF DEFINING POLYGON VERTEX
*
* COORDINATES FOR EACH SEGMENT
*
*
******************************************************************************

F-15
 PROGRAM SYMMFOIL

IMPLICIT NONE

INTEGER MAXN , NPTS , I , J , NN , SEGMENT , FILENO

PARAMETER (MAXN=500 )
DOUBLE PRECISION DBEZIER3,B(4, 2 ) ,P(MAXN, 2 )
DOUBLE PRECISION T, SURF (MAXN, 2 )
CHARACTERS
30 FILE1,TEMPFILE
*

? user inputs.
*

RATIO'
PRINT ?, 'ENTER THICKNESS
READ(5,M T
?,' COORDINATES'
PRINT ENTER NAME OF FILE FOR AIRFOIL
' '
READS, (A) ) FILE1
*

* define tau. . .

TAU =
(DSQRT(5]1 -
1.0J/2.0
*

* begin algorithm. . .

DO SEGMENT =
1, -2,1

IF ( SEGMENT .
EQ 1 ) THEN
.

'TEMP1.DAT'
TEMPFILE =

FILENO =
9
B(l,l) =
0.0
B(l,2) = 0.0
B(2,l) =
0.0
? T
B(2,2) = (1.0 -

TAU)
? ?
B(3,l) =
(22.0 T -

13.0) .3

B(3,2) =
T/2.0
B(4,l) = 0.3
B(4,2) = T/2.0
ELSE
' '
TEMPFILE = TEMP2 . DAT
FILENO = 8
B(l,l) = 0.3
B(l,2) = T/2.0
=
B(2,l)
B(2,2) = T/2.0
=
B(3,l)
? T
=
(-1.16925*B(3,1) + 1.17975)
B(3,2)
B(4,l) =
1.0
= ? T
B(4,2) .0105

END IF

NPTS = 201

CALL DBEZIER3(NPTS,B,P,DP,DDP)

OPEN (UNIT=FILEN01,FILE=TEMPFILE1,STATUS='NEW )

DO I = 1,NPTS,1
WRITE (FILENOl, 10) (P( I , J) , J=l, 2 )
ENDDO

CLOSE (FILENOl)

10 FORMAT(3X,D14.6,5X,D14.6)

ENDDO

F-16
*
PROGRAM NAME: GENFOIL
*

*
PROGRAMMER: BILL SCARBROUGH
*

*
CREATION DATE: NOVEMBER 10, 1990
*

*******************************************************************
*

?
PURPOSE :
? THIS USER-INTERACTIVE FORTRAN PROGRAM UTILIZES BEZIER CURVES TO
GENERATE
*
A NACA FOUR-DIGIT AIRFOIL OF THE USERS CHOICE. THE PROGRAM ASSUMES
*
A CHORD OF UNIT LENGTH FOR EASE OF COMPUTATION. THE PROGRAM WILL
* ALSO ALLOW THE USER TO GENERATE A CONVENTIONALLY DEFINED AIRFOIL
* FOR PURPOSES OF COMPARISON.
*

* USER INPUTS:
*

* THE USER IS PROMPTED FOR THE TYPE OF AIRFOIL, THEN THE NAME OF THE
* DATA FILE TO WHICH THE GENERATED DATA POINTS ARE TO BE WRITTEN.
* THE USER IS THEN PROMPTED FOR THE THICKNESS RATIO OF THE SYMMETRIC
* THICKNESS DISTRIBUTION. IF A SYMMETRIC AIRFOIL IS CHOSEN, A FLAG
* IS SET TO THE FALSE AND SUPERPOSITION OF THICKNESS
POSITION,
* DISTRIBUTION ON THE CAMBER LINE IS NOT PERFORMED. IF A CAMBERED
* AIRFOIL IS CHOSEN, THE USER IS THEN PROMPTED TO INPUT VALUES FOR
* THE MAXIMUM CAMBER AND CHORDWISE POSITION WHERE MAXIMUM CAMBER
* OCCURS .

* SUBROUTINES REFERENCED:
*

* NONE
*

* INPUT VARIABLES:
*

* T -
SYMMETRIC THICKNESS DISTRIBUTION
* TYPE -
DENOTES EITHER CAMBERED OR SYMMETRIC AIRFOIL
* COMP -
DENOTES USERS OF WHETHER OR NOT TO
CHOICE
* GENERATE CONVENTIONALLY GENERATED AIRFOIL FOR
* PURPOSE OF COMPARISON
* NPOINTS TOTAL NUMBER OF POINTS TO BE GENERATED ON
* AIRFOIL
* FILENAME FILE TO WHICH BEZIER OUTPUT IS TO BE WRITTEN
* FILE2 FILE TO WHICH CONVENTIONALLY GENERATED
* COORDINATES IS TO BE WRITTEN
* M MAXIMUM CAMBER OF AIRFOIL, EXPRESSED AS A
* DECIMAL OF CHORD
* P CHORDWISE POSITION OF MAXIMUM CAMBER, EXPRESSED
* AS A DECIMAL OF CHORD
*

* INTERMEDIATE VARIABLES!
*

* MAXN PARAMETER, LIMIT ON ARRAY SIZE

"TYPE"
* FLAG LOGICAL VARIABLE TO DENOTE FROM ABOVE
"COMP"
* COMPARE LOGICAL VARIABLE TO DENOTE FROM ABOVE
* TAU GOLDEN SECTION NUMBER
* INTERSECTION OF TRAILING EDGE ANGLE AND THE LINE
XINT
* Y=T/2
* ALPHA NUMBER DERIVED FROM GOLDEN SECTION SEARCH ON
*
[.3, XINT]
* NUMBER DERIVED FROM GOLDEN SECTION SEARCH ON
BETA
* [XINT, 1.0]
* POLY1 4x2 MATRIX CONTAINING COORDINATES OF LEADING
* EDGE BEZIER DEFINING POLYGON
* 4x2 MATRIX CONTAINING COORDINATES OF TRAILING
POLY 2
* EDGE BEZIER DEFINING POLYGON
* SEGPTS NUMBER OF POINTS GENERATED ON EACH SEGMENT OF
* THE CURVE , BETWEEN [0, . 3 ] AND [.3,1.0]
* SURFPTS NUMBER OF DATA POINTS GENERATED ON EITHER THE
* UPPER OR LOWER SURFACE OF THE AIRFOIL (SEGPTSx2)

F-17
*
COORD 1 SEGPTSx2 MATRIX, OUTPUT OF SUBROUTINE DBEZIER3,
*
COORDINATES OF SYMMETRIC THICKNESS DISTRIBUTION
*
FROM [0,.3]
*
COORD 2 SEGPTSx2 MATRIX, OUTPUT OF SUBROUTINE DBEZIER3,
*
COORDINATES OF SYMMETRIC THICKNESS DISTRIBUTION
*
FROM [.3,1.0]
*
YC ORDINATE OF CAMBER LINE
*
CONST1 CONSTANT TERM USED FOR CAMBER LINE FROM [0,P]
*
CONST2 CONSTANT TERM USED FOR CAMBER LINE FROM [P,1.0]
*
YCP TANGENT OF CAMBER LINE
*
MULT(n) CONSTANTS USED IN GENERATION OF CAMBERED
*
COORDINATES
*
XU UPPER SURFACE COORDINATE OF CHORDWISE POSITION
* YU UPPER SURFACE ORDINATE
*
XL LOWER SURFACE COORDINATE OF CHORDWISE POSITION
*
YL LOWER SURFACE ORDINATE
*

PROGRAM GENFOIL
*

IMPLICIT NONE

INTEGER MAXN
PARAMETER (MAXN=2000 )
INTEGER I , TYPE , NPOINTS , SEGPTS , SURFPTS , COMP
INTEGER N,ICOUNT,I,II,J,JJ,K,KK,L,LL
LOGICAL^l FLAG, COMPARE
CHARACTERS
30
FILENAME, FILE2
DOUBLE PRECISION T,M,P,TAU, XINT, ALPHA, BETA, POLY1 (4, 2 ) , POLY2 (4, 2 )
DOUBLE PRECISION COORDl(MAXN,2) , COORD 2 (MAXN, 2 ) ,XU(MAXN) ,YU(MAXN) ,

DOUBLE PRECISION XL (MAXN) , YL (MAXN) , CONST1, CONST2 (6) ,MULT

DOUBLE PRECISION NU,NUSTEP,TEMP1(4,4) ,POLY(4,2) ,NUMAT(1,4)

DOUBLE PRECISION OUT(MAXN,2) ,TEMP2(1,4) ,TEMP3(1,2) ,TEMP4(1,2)
PROGRAM'
PRINT ?, 'WELCOME TO THE INTERACTIVE AIRFOIL GENERATION
? ' '
PRINT ,

PRINT ?, 'PLEASE INDICATE CHOICE OF AIRFOIL TYPE ( 1=SYMMETRIC, 2=CAMBERED)

READ(5,^) TYPE

must now check to see that user inputs are within expected values

IF(TYPE.NE.1.0R.TYPE.NE.2) THEN
TERMINATED."
PRINT ?, 'ERROR: INCORRECT INPUT. PROGRAM
STOP
END IF

' '
PRINT ?
, PLEASE ENTER NAME FOR OUTPUT FILE
' '
READS, (A) ) FILENAME

' ' ' '

FILE= STATUS= NEW
OPEN ( UNIT=12 ,
FILENAME , )
AIRFOILS?'
PRINT ?, 'WOULD YOU LIKE TO COMPARE BEZIER vs. CONVENTIONAL
PRINT *,'(1 NO, 2 YES) = =

READ(5, ?) COMP

IF ( COMP EQ 1 ) THEN
. .

COMPARE = .FALSE.

ELSE I F ( COMP EQ 2 ) THEN . .

COMPARE = .TRUE.

ELSE
TERMINATED.'

PRINT ?, 'ERROR: INCORRECT INPUT. PROGRAM

STOP
END IF

IF (COMPARE) THEN AIRFOIL.'

PRINT ?, 'ENTER NAME OF OUTPUT FILE FOR NACA
' '
READ (5, (A) ) FILE2
' '
STATUS= NEW
OPEN ( UNIT=6 , FILE=FILE2 , )
END IF

F-18
 IF(TYPE.EQ.l) THEN
FLAG =
.FALSE.

ELSE
FLAG =
.TRUE.

END IF

IF (FLAG) THEN
? '
PRINT , ENTER AMOUNT OF MAXIMUM CAMBER IN DECIMAL OF CHORD
'

READ(5, ?) M
PRINT ?.'ENTER CHORDWISE POSITION OF MAXIMUM THICKNESS IN DECIMAL
FORM'

READ ?
(5, ) P

CONST1 =
M/(P^P)
CONST2 =
M/((1.0 -
P)*(1.0 -

P)

END IF

PRINT ?, 'ENTER MAXIMUM THICKNESS OF SYMMETRIC DISTRIBUTION'

READ(5, ?) T

PRINT ?, 'ENTER TOTAL NUMBER OF POINTS DESIRED ON ENTIRE ARIFOIL (2000

MAX)
READ (5,*) NPOINTS
*

? set initial values and counters

*

TAU 1.0)/2.0 (= 0.618033988852495

=
(SQRT(5.0) - -

approximately)
XINT =
.58135557

ALPHA =
.473887

BETA 1.0 + TAUA(XINT

= -

1.0)
SEGPTS = NPOINTS/4
SURFPTS =
SEGPTS + SEGPTS
11= 1
JJ =
4
KK =
4
LL =
2
I COUNT =
1
NU =
0.0
NUSTEP =
1.0/DFLOAT(N-1)

? bezier
setup defining polygons
-

leading edge surface

*

POLYl(l,l) =0.0

POLYl(l,2) =0.0

POLYl(2,l) = 0.0
POLYl(2,2) = (1.0 -
TAU)^T
POLYl(3,l) = (22.0^TAU -
13.0)*. 3
POLYl(3,2) = T/2.0
=
POLYl(4,l) .3

POLYl(4,2) =
POLYl(3,2)
*

* surface
setup defining bezier polygons
-

trailing edge

=
POLY2(l,l) .3

POLY2(l,2) =
POLYl(3,2)
POLY2(2,l) = ALPHA
POLY2(2,2) =
POLYl(3,2)
POLY2(3,l) = BETA
POLY2(3,2) = T*(l. 17975 -
1. 16925^BETA)
POLY2(4,l) =
1.0
POLY2(4,2) = 0.0105^T

=
TEMPI (1,1) -1.0

TEMPI (1,2) =3.0

F-19
 TEMPI (1,3 -3.0

TEMPI (1,4 1.0

TEMPI (2,1 3.0
TEMPI (2,2 -6.0

TEMPI (2,3 3.0

TEMPI (2, 4 0.0
TEMPI (3,1 -3.0

TEMPI (3, 2 3.0

TEMPI (3,3 0.0
TEMPI (3,4 0.0
TEMPI (4,1 1.0
TEMPI (4, 2 0.0
TEMPI (4, 3 0.0
TEMPI (4, 4 0.0

DOWHILE (NU.LE. 1.0)

NUMAT(1,4) =
1.0
NUMAT(1,3) =
NU
?
NUMAT(1,2) =
NU NU
NUMAT ? NU
NUMAT(1,1) =
(1,2)

note: this step computes an intermediate matrix of the parameter values

and coefficients of those values as defined by the third order

Bezier curve.

DO I =
1,JJ,1
TEMP2(1,I) =0.0

DO J =
1,KK,1
TEMP2(1,I) =
TEMP2(1,I) + NUMAT( 1, J) ?TEMPI ( J, I )
ENDDO
ENDDO
*

* note: this step computes actual coordinates of the leading edge using
the
* intermediate result obtained above

DO I = 1,JJ,1
TEMP3(1,I) =0.0

DO J= 1,LL,1
TEMP3(1,I) =
TEMP3(1,I) + TEMP2 ( 1, J) ?POLY1 ( J, I )
ENDDO
ENDDO

note: this uses the same intermediate result as employed above to

step
the coordinate
compute trailing edge

DO I = 1,LL,1
TEMP4(1,I) =0.0

DO J = 1,JJ,1
=
TEMP4(1,I) + TEMP2 ( 1, I ) ?POLY2 ( J, I )
TEMP4(1,I)
ENDDO
ENDDO

COORDl(ICOUNT,l) =
TEMP3(1,1)
COORDl(ICOUNT,2) =
TEMP3(1,2)
COORD2(ICOUNT,l)
=
TEMP4(1,1)
COORD2(ICOUNT,2) =
TEMP4(1,2)

I COUNT =
I COUNT + 1
NU = NU + NUSTEP

ENDDO

is the time to generate mean line and its components

if cambered, now

DO 1=1, SEGPTS,!

F-20
 IF (FLAG) THEN
t

IF ( COORD1 ( I , 1 ) . LE . P ) THEN
YC CONST1^COORD1(I,1)^(2.0^P
=
COORDl(I,l)) -

YCP = CONST1 ? 2.0 ? (P COORDl(I,l))

-

ELSE
YC =
CONST2^(1.0 -
2.0^P + COORD1 ( I, 1) ? (2 . O^P -

COORDl(I,l))
YCP =
CONST2 *2.0*(P-COORD1(I,1))
END IF
*

THETA =
DATAN(YCP)
MULT(l) =
DCOS( THETA)
MULT (2) =
MULTl^YCP
MULT(3) =
COORDl(I,2)AMULT(l)
MULT(4) =
COORDl(I,2)*MULT(2)
XU(I) =
COORDl(I,l) MULT(4)
-

YU(I) =
YC + MULT(3)
XL(I) =
COORDl(I,l) + MULT(4)
YL(I) =
YC MULT(3)
-

IF (COMPARE) THEN
MULT(5) DNACA(T,COORDl(I,l) ) ?MULTl
=

MULT(6) DNACA(T, MULTl) ?YCP

=

NACAXU(I) COORDl(I,l) MULT(2)

= -

NACAYU(I) YC + MULT(l) =

NACAXL(I) COORDl(I,l) + MULT(2)

=

NACAYL(I) YC MULT(l) = -

END IF
*

ELSE
*

XU(I) =
COORDl(I,l)
YU(I) =
COORDl(I,2)
XL(I) =
XU(I)
YL(I) = -

YU(I)
*

IF (COMPARE) THEN
NACAXU(I) COORDl(I,l) =

NACAYU(I) DNACA(T,COORDl(I,l) ) =

NACAXL(I) COORDl(I,l) =

=
NACAYL(I) -NACAYU(I)
END IF
*

END IF
*

ENDDO
*

1 = 2
J = SEGPTS + 1
*

DOWHILE (J . LE . SURFPTS )
*

IF (FLAG) THEN
*

IF(COORD2(I,l) .LE.P)THEN

? (2
( I , 1)
-

YC = CONST1*(1.0 -
2.0^P + COORD2 .O^P

COORD2 (1,1)))
?
YCP = CONST1 ? 2.0 (P -

COORD2(I,l))
ELSE
?
(1, 1) (2 -

YC = CONST2M1.0 -
2.0*P + COORD2 .O^P

COORD2(I,l) ) ) ?
YCP = CONST2 ? 2.0 (P -

COORD2(I,l))
END IF
*

THETA =
DATAN(YCP)
MULTl =
DCOS( THETA)
MULT2 = MULTl ?YCP
MULT5 = COORD2(I,2)^MULTl

F-21
 MULT6 =
(I,2)
COORD2 ^MULT2

XU(J) =
COORD2(I,l)
-
MULT6
YU(J) = YC + MULT5
XL (J) =
COORDl(I,l) + MULT6
YL(J) = YC -
MULT5

IF (COMPARE) THEN
NACAMULT3 DNACA(T,COORDl(I,l) ) ?MULTl
NACAMULT4 NACAMULTl^YCP
NACAXU(I) COORD 1(1,1) -
NACAMULT4
NACAYU ( I ) YC + NACAMULT3
NACAXL ( I ) COORD 1(1,1) + NACAMULT4
NACAYL ( I ) YC -
NACAMULT3
ENDIF

ELSE

XU(J) COORD2 (1,1)

YU(J) COORD2 (1,2)
XL(J) XU(J)
YL(J)
-

YU(J)

IF ( COMPARE ) THEN
NACAXU(J) COORD2 (1,1)
=

NACAYU (J) DNACA(T,COORDl(I,l) )

=

NACAXL (J) COORD2 (1,1)

=

NACAYL (J) =
-NACAYU
(I)
ENDIF
ENDIF
ENDIF

ENDDO
*

? output data points

DO I = 1,SURFPTS-1,1

WRITE(12,101) XU(I),YU(I)

ENDDO

DO I = SURFPTS-2,1,-1

WRITE(12,101) XL(I),YL(I)

ENDDO

101 FORMAT(5X,D14.8,5X,Dl4.8)

STOP
END

F-22
Appendix G. Pertinent Data Files
NACA Designation

1105 0 .27994D+00 0 34569D-01

1106 0 27993D+00 0 .39563D-01
1107 0 .28492D+00 0 44558D-01
1108 0 28491D+00 0 .49555D-01
1109 0 28490D+00 0 .54552D-01
1110 0 .28988D+00 0 .59550D-01

1111 0 .28987D+00 0 .64550D-01

1112 0 .28986D+00 0 .69549D-01

1113 0 .28985D+00 0, .74549D-01

1114 0 .28984D+00 0, .79548D-01

1115 0 .28982D+00 0,.84548D-01

1116 0 .28981D+00 0. 89548D-01
.

1117 0 .29480D+00 0,.94547D-01

1118 0 .29478D+00 0, .99548D-01

1119 0 .29477D+00 0. 10455D+00

.

1120 0 .29476D+00 0. .10955D+00

1121 0,.29475D+00 0, 11455D+00

.

1122 0,.29474D+00 0. 11955D+00

.

1123 0,.29472D+00 0. .12455D+00

1124 0,.29471D+00 0. .12955D+00

1205 0,.28497D+00 0. .34873D-01

1206 0, .28996D+00 0. .39871D-01

1207 0..28995D+00 0. .44871D-01

1208 0, .28994D+00 0. 49870D-01

1209 0. .28994D+00 0. .54870D-01

1210 0. .28993D+00 0. .59869D-01

1211 0, .29492D+00 0. .64870D-01

1212 0. .29491D+00 0. 69871D-01

1213 0. .29490D+00 0. 74872D-01
1214 0. .29490D+00 0. 79873D-01
1215 0. .29489D+00 0. 84874D-01
1216 0. .29488D+00 0. 89875D-01
1217 0. .29487D+00 0. 94876D-01
1218 0. .29487D+00 0. 99877D-01
1219 0. .29486D+00 0. 10488D+00
1220 0. .29485D+00 0. 10988D+00
1221 0. .29484D+00 0. 11488D+00
1222 0. .29484D+00 0. 11988D+00
1223 0. .29483D+00 0. 12488D+00
1224 0. 29482D+00 0. 12988D+00

1305 0. .30000D+00 0. 35007D-01

1306 0. 30000D+00 0. 40009D-01
1307 0. 30000D+00 0. 45010D-01
1308 0. 30000D+00
, 0. 50012D-01
1309 0. 30000D+00
, 0. 55013D-01
1310 0. 30000D+00 0. 60014D-01
1311 0. 30000D+00 0. 65016D-01
1312 0. 30000D+00 0. 70017D-01
1313 0. 30000D+00 0. 75019D-01
1314 0. 30000D+00 0. 80020D-01
1315 0. 30000D+00 0. 85022D-01
1316 0. 30000D+00 0. 90023D-01
1317 0. 30000D+00 0. 95024D-01
1318 0. 30000D+00 0. 10003D+00
1319 0. 30000D+00 0. 10503D+00
1320 0. 30000D+00 0. 11003D+00
1321 0. 30000D+00 0. 11503D+00
1322 0. 30000D+00 0. 12003D+00
1323 0. 30000D+00 0. 12503D+00
1324 0. 30000D+00 0. 13003D+00

G-UTRENDS.DAT-1
NACA Designation

1405 0 .33981D+00 0 .34638D-01

1406 0 .33476D+00 0 .39610D-01
1407 0 .33472D+00 0 .44590D-01

1408 0 .32965D+00 0 .49572D-01

1409 0 .32961D+00 0, .54557D-01

1410 0 32453D+00 0,.59545D-01

1411 0 .32449D+00 0,.64535D-01
1412 0 .31940D+00 0, .69525D-01

1413 0 .31935D+00 0..74519D-01

1414 0 .31930D+00 0. .79512D-01

1415 0 . 31925D+00 0,.84506D-01

1416 0 . 31920D+00 0. .89500D-01

1417 0 .31410D+00 0, .94496D-01

1418 0,.31404D+00 0. .99493D-01

1419 0,.31399D+00 0. .10449D+00

1420 0, .31394D+00 0. 10949D+00

.

1421 0, .31389D+00 0. .11448D+00

1422 0. .31383D+00 0. .11948D+00

1423 0, .31378D+00 0. 12448D+00

.

1424 0, .30865D+00 0. 12947D+00

.

1505 0, .36473D+00 0. .33911D-01

1506 0, .35466D+00 0. .38847D-01

1507 0. .34958D+00 0. .43798D-01

1508 0. .34451D+00 0. .48759D-01

1509 0. .33943D+00 0. , 53727D-01

1510 0. .33434D+00 0. 58699D-01
1511 0. .33428D+00 0. 63678D-01
1512 0. .32919D+00 0. 68658D-01
1513 0. .32912D+00 0. ,736430-01

1514 0. .32905D+00 0. 78628D-01

1515 0. .32395D+00 0. 83616D-01
1516 0. .32388D+00 0. 88606D-01
1517 0. .32381D+00 0. 93595D-01
1518 0. 31871D+00
. 0. 98587D-01
1519 0. .31863D+00 0. 10358D+00
1520 0. .31856D+00 0. 10857D+00
1521 0. .31849D+00 0.H357D+00
1522 0. .31842D+00 0. 11856D+00
1523 0. .31330D+00 0. 12355D+00
1524 0. .31323D+00 0. 12855D+00

1605 0. .37469D+00 0. 33118D-01

1606 0. .36461D+00 0. 38033D-01
1607 0. 35453D+00 0. 42967D-01
1608 0. 34945D+00 0. 47918D-01
1609 0. .34437D+00 0. 52877D-01
1610 0. .33928D+00 0. 57844D-01
1611 0. 33921D+00 0. 62816D-01
1612 0. 33412D+00 0. 67794D-01
1613 0. 32903D+00 0. 72773D-01
1614 0. 32895D+00 0. 77757D-01
1615 0. 32888D+00 0. 82742D-01
1616 0. 32378D+00 0. 87729D-01
1617 0. 32370D+00 0. 92718D-01
1618 0. 32363D+00 0. 97707D-01
1619 0. 32355D+00 0. 10270D+00
1620 0. 31845D+00 0. 10769D+00
1621 0. 31837D+00 0. 11268D+00
1622 0. 31829D+00 0. 11768D+00
1623 0. 31821D+00 0. .12267D+00

1624 0. 31814D+00 0. 12766D+00

,

G-UTRENDS.DAT-2
NACA Designation

1705 0 37968D+00
.
0 .32372D-01
1706 0 36960D+00 0 .37277D-01
1707 0 35952D+00 0 42208D-01
1708 0 .34943D+00 0 47153D-01
1709 0 34435D+00
.
0 52111D-01
.

1710 0 33927D+00
.
0 .57077D-01
1711 0 .33920D+00 0 62049D-01
.

1712 0 33411D+00 0 .67026D-01

1713 0 .33404D+00 0 .72004D-01
1714 0 .32895D+00 0 76988D-01
1715 0 . 32887D+00 0 81973D-01
1716 0 .32378D+00 0 .86959D-01
1717 0 32370D+00 0.91949D-01

1718 0 .32363D+00 0.96938D-01

1719 0 . 31853D+00 0 10193D+00

.

1720 0 .31845D+00 0, 10692D+00

.

1721 0 .31837D+00 0,.11191D+00

1722 0 .31830D+00 0,.11691D+00
1723 0 . 31822D+00 0, 12190D+00
.

1724 0 .31814D+00 0, 12689D+00

.

1805 0,.37968D+00 0..31705D-01

1806 0..36960D+00 0..36611D-01
1807 0, .35952D+00 0.
.41542D-01

1808 0. 34944D+00
. 0.
.46489D-01

1809 0. .34436D+00 0.
. 51449D-01
1810 0. .33929D+00 0.
. 56415D-01
1811 0. 33921D+00
. 0.
.61388D-01

1812 0. 33413D+00 0.
, 66366D-01
1813 0. .32905D+00 0.
.71346D-01

1814 0. .32898D+00 0. 76331D-01

1815 0. .32890D+00 0.
81315D-01

1816 0. 32382D+00 0. 86305D-01

1817 0. .32374D+00 0.
, 91294D-01
1818 0. .32367D+00 0. 96283D-01
1819 0. 31858D+00 0. 10128D+00
1820 0. 31850D+00
, 0. 10627D+00
1821 0. 31843D+00 0. 11126D+00
1822 0. 31835D+00
, 0. 11626D+00
1823 0. 31828D+00 0. 12125D+00
1824 0. 31318D+00 0. 12624D+00

1905 0. 37969D+00 0. 31123D-01

1906 0. 36461D+00 0. 36033D-01
1907 0. 35453D+00 0. 40968D-01
1908 0. 34946D+00 0. 45919D-01
1909 0. 34439D+00 0. 50881D-01
1910 0. 33931D+00 0. 55851D-01
1911 0. 33424D+00 0. 60825D-01
1912 0. 33417D+00 0. 65804D-01
1913 0. 32909D+00 0. 70787D-01
1914 0. 32902D+00 0. 75772D-01
1915 0. 32394D+00 0. 80759D-01
1916 0. 32387D+00 0. 85749D-01
1917 0. 32380D+00 0. 90738D-01
1918 0. 31871D+00 0. 95730D-01
1919 0. 31864D+00 0. 10072D+00
1920 0. 31857D+00 0. 10572D+00
1921 0. 31850D+00 0. 11071D+00
1922 0. 31843D+00 0. 11570D+00
1923 0. 31334D+00 0. 12070D+00
1924 0. 31327D+00 0. 12570D+00

G-UTRENDS.DAT-3
NACA Designation

2105 0..25990D+00 0.
44216D-01

2106 0..26488D+00 0.
.49192D-01

2107 0..26985D+00 0.
.54174D-01

2108 0.
.27483D+00 0.
.59159D-01

2109 0.
.27481D+00 0.
64148D-01

2110 0..27978D+00 0.
69138D-01

2111 0..27976D+00 0.
74131D-01

2112 0..27973D+00 0. 79125D-01

2113 0..27971D+00 0. 84119D-01
2114 0.28468D+00 0.
.89115D-01

2115 0.
.28466D+00 0.
.94112D-01

2116 0.
.28463D+00 0. 99109D-01
2117 0.
.28461D+00 0. 10411D+00
2118 0.
.28459D+00 0. 10910D+00
2119 0.
.28457D+00 0.
.11410D+00

2120 0.
.28953D+00 0. 11910D+00
2121 0.
.28951D+00 0. 12410D+00
2122 0.
28948D+00 0. 12910D+00
2123 0.
.28946D+00 0.
.13410D+00

2124 0.
28944D+00 0. 13910D+00

2205 0.
.27494D+00 0. 44771D-01
2206 0.
27993D+00 0. 49763D-01
2207 0.
27991D+00 0.
, 54757D-01
2208 0.
.28489D+00 0. 59752D-01
2209 0.
.28488D+00 0. 64749D-01
2210 0.
28487D+00 0. 69746D-01
2211 0.
.28485D+00 0. 74743D-01
2212 0.
.28983D+00 0. 79742D-01
2213 0.
.28982D+00 0. 84741D-01
2214 0.
.28980D+00 0. 89741D-01
2215 0.
.28979D+00 0. 94740D-01
2216 0.
.28978D+00 0. 99740D-01
2217 0.
28976D+00 0.
, 10474D+00
2218 0.
.28975D+00 0.
, 10974D+00
2219 0.
.28973D+00 0.
, 11474D+00
2220 0.
.28972D+00 0.
, 11974D+00
2221 0.
.29469D+00 0. 12474D+00
2222 0.
.29467D+00 0. 12974D+00
2223 0.
.29466D+00 0. 13474D+00
2224 0.
.29464D+00 0.
13974D+00

2305 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.45007D-01

2306 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.50009D-01

2307 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.55010D-01

2308 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.60012D-01

2309 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.65013D-01

2310 0.
.30000D+00 0.
70014D-01

2311 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.75016D-01

2312 0.
30000D+00 0.
80017D-01

2313 0,
.30000D+00 0.
.85019D-01

2314 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.90020D-01

2315 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.95022D-01

2316 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.10002D+00

2317 0.
.30000D+00 0. 10502D+00
.

2318 0,
.30000D+00 0, 11003D+00
.

2319 0.
.30000D+00 0, 11503D+00
.

2320 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.12003D+00

2321 0.
.30000D+00 0. 12503D+00
.

2322 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.13003D+00

2323 0,
.30000D+00 0.
.13503D+00

2324 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.14003D+00

G-UTRENDS.DAT-4
NACA Designation

2405 0.35975D+00 0.44492D-01

2406 0.35467D+00 0.49435D-01
2407 0.34957D+00 54385D-01
2408 0.34950D+00 59342D-01
2409 0.34439D+00 64306D-01
2410 0.33925D+00 69271D-01
2411 0.33918D+00 0.74243D-01
2412 0.33911D+00 0.79216D-01
2413 0.33395D+00 0.84194D-01
2414 0.33387D+00 0.89172D-01
2415 0.32869D+00 0.94151D-01
2416 0.32860D+00 0.99135D-01
2417 0.32852D+00 0.10412D+00
2418 0.32843D+00 0.10910D+00
2419 0.32322D+00 0.11409D+00
2420 0.32313D+00 11908D+00
2421 0.32304D+00 12407D+00
2422 0.32294D+00 12906D+00
2423 0.32285D+00 13404D+00
2424 0.32275D+00 0.13903D+00

2505 0.39961D+00 0.43376D-01

2506 0.38949D+00 0.48221D-01
2507 0.38437D+00 0.53093D-01
2508 0.37422D+00 0.57984D-01
2509 0.36908D+00 0.62892D-01
2510 0.36394D+00 0.67813D-01
2511 0.35878D+00 0.72743D-01
2512 0.35362D+00 0.77681D-01
2513 0.35351D+00 0.82628D-01
2514 0.34833D+00 0.87581D-01
2515 0.34822D+00 0.92536D-01
2516 0.34303D+00 0.97499D-01
2517 0.34291D+00 0.10246D+00
2518 0.33771D+00 0.10743D+00
2519 0.33758D+00 0.11240D+00
2520 0.33745D+00 0.11737D+00
2521 0.
.33224D+00 0.12235D+00
2522 0.
.33211D+00 0.12733D+00
2523 0.
33198D+00 0.13230D+00
2524 0.
.32675D+00 0.13728D+00

2605 0.42955D+00 0.42049D-01

2606 0.41441D+00 0.46811D-01
2607 0.39925D+00 0.51620D-01
2608 0.38909D+00 0.56464D-01
2609 0.38395D+00 0.61335D-01
2610 0.37377D+00 0.66225D-01
2611 0.36862D+00 0.71131D-01
2612 0.36346D+00 0.76050D-01
2613 0.35829D+00 0.80979D-01
2614 0.35816D+00 0.85916D-01
2615 0.35298D+00 0.90862D-01
2616 0.34780D+00 0.95812D-01
2617 0.34766D+00 0.10077D+00
2618 0.34247D+00 0.10573D+00
2619 0.34233D+00 0.11069D+00
2620 0.33713D+00 0.11566D+00

2621 0.33698D+00 0.12063D+00

2622 0.33684D+00 0.12560D+00
2623 0.33163D+00 0.13057D+00
2624 0.33148D+00 0.13555D+00

G-UTRENDS.DAT-5
NACA Designation

2705 0 44451D+00 0 40699D-01

2706 0 .42436D+00 0 .45409D-01
2707 0 .40920D+00 0 .50183D-01
2708 0 39905D+00
.
0 55002D-01
2709 0 .38889D+00 0 .59854D-01
2710 0 .37872D+00 0 .64731D-01
2711 0 37357D+00 0 69627D-01
2712 0 .36841D+00 0 .74539D-01

2713 0 .36325D+00 0 .79462D-01

2714 0 35808D+00
.
0 .84396D-01
2715 0 35291D+00
.
0 .89336D-01
2716 0 .35277D+00 0 .94283D-01
2717 0 .34759D+00 0 .99238D-01
2718 0 .34241D+00 0 .10419D+00
2719 0 34227D+00
. 0 10916D+00
.

2720 0 .33708D+00 0 .11412D+00

2721 0 .33693D+00 0 11909D+00

.

2722 0 .33679D+00 0, 12406D+00

.

2723 0 .33159D+00 0, 12903D+00

.

2724 0 .33144D+00 0, .13401D+00

2805 0,.45450D+00 0, .39420D-01

2806 0,.42934D+00 0. .44104D-01

2807 0..41419D+00 0. .48864D-01

2808 0, .39903D+00 0. 53675D-01

.

2809 0. .38888D+00 0. .58523D-01

2810 0, .37872D+00 0. .63398D-01

2811 0. .37357D+00 0. 68294D-01

,

2812 0. 36841D+00 0. .73206D-01

2813 0. 36326D+00
. 0. 78130D-01
2814 0. .35810D+00 0. .83064D-01

2815 0. 35294D+00 0. 88007D-01

2816 0. .34777D+00 0. 92955D-01
2817 0. .34763D+00 0. 97911D-01
2818 0. .34246D+00 0. 10287D+00
2819 0. .34232D+00 0. 10783D+00
2820 0. .33714D+00 0. 11280D+00
2821 0. 33700D+00 0. 11777D+00
2822 0. 33686D+00 0. 12274D+00
2823 0. 33167D+00 0. 12772D+00
2824 0. 33153D+00
, 0. 13269D+00

2905 0. 45449D+00 0. 38250D-01

2906 0. 42934D+00 0. 42928D-01
2907 0. 41420D+00 0. 47688D-01
2908 0. 39905D+00 0. 52502D-01
2909 0. 38890D+00 0. 57354D-01
2910 0. 37874D+00 0. 62234D-01
2911 0. 37360D+00 0. 67134D-01
2912 0. 36344D+00 0. 72051D-01
2913 0. 35829D+00 0. 76979D-01
2914 0. 35314D+00 0. 81917D-01
2915 0. 35300D+00 0. 86863D-01
2916 0. 34785D+00 0. 91817D-01
2917 0. 34269D+00 0. 96773D-01
2918 0. 34255D+00 0. 10174D+00
2919 0. 33739D+00 0. 10670D+00
2920 0. 33725D+00 0. 11167D+00
2921 0. 33711D+00 0. 11664D+00
2922 0. 33194D+00 0. 12162D+00
2923 0. 33181D+00 0. 12660D+00
2924 0. 33167D+00 0. 13157D+00

G-UTRENDS.DAT-6
NACA Designation

3105 0..24986D+00 0.
.53921D-01

3106 0..25483D+00 0.
.58875D-01

3107 0..25979D+00 0.
.63839D-01

3108 0..26476D+00 0.
.68810D-01

3109 0..26473D+00 0.
73787D-01

3110 0..26969D+00 0.
.78768D-01

3111 0..26965D+00 0.
.83752D-01

3112 0.
.27461D+00 0.
.88737D-01

3113 0..27458D+00 0.
.93727D-01

3114 0.
.27455D+00 0.
.98716D-01

3115 0..27950D+00 0.
10371D+00

3116 0.
.27947D+00 0.
.10870D+00

3117 0,.27943D+00 0.
.11369D+00

3118 0.
.27940D+00 0.
.11869D+00

3119 0..27937D+00 0.
12368D+00

3120 0.
.28432D+00 0.
.12867D+00

3121 0.
.28428D+00 0.
.13367D+00

3122 0.
.28425D+00 0.
.13867D+00

3123 0.
.28421D+00 0. 14367D+00
.

3124 0.
.28418D+00 0.
.14866D+00

3205 0.
.26992D+00 0.
.54690D-01

3206 0.
.26990D+00 0.
.59674D-01

3207 0.
.27488D+00 0.
.64662D-01

3208 0.
.27486D+00 0.
.69651D-01

3209 0.
.27983D+00 0.
.74644D-01

3210 0.
27981D+00 0.
.79638D-01

3211 0.
.27979D+00 0.
.84632D-01

3212 0.
.28476D+00 0. 89627D-01
3213 0.
.28474D+00 0. 94625D-01
3214 0.
28472D+00 0.
.99622D-01

3215 0.
28470D+00 0. 10462D+00
3216 0.
28468D+00 0. 10962D+00
3217 0.
.28466D+00 0.
, 11461D+00
3218 0.
.28962D+00 0.
, 11961D+00
3219 0.
.28960D+00 0.
12461D+00

3220 0.
28958D+00 0.
.12961D+00

3221 0.
.28956D+00 0.
.13461D+00

3222 0.
.28954D+00 0.
.13961D+00

3223 0.
.28951D+00 0.
.14461D+00

3224 0.
.28949D+00 0.
.14961D+00

3305 0.
.30000D+00 0. 55007D-01
,

3306 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.60009D-01

3307 0.
30000D+00 0.
.65010D-01

3308 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.70012D-01

3309 0.
30000D+00 0.
75013D-01

3310 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.80014D-01

3311 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.85016D-01

3312 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.90017D-01

3313 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.95019D-01

3314 0.
.30000D+00 0. 10002D+00
.

3315 0.
.30000D+00 0.
10502D+00

3316 0.
.30000D+00 0. 11002D+00
.

3317 0.
.30000D+00 0. 11502D+00
.

3318 0.
.30000D+00 0. 12003D+00
.

3319 0.
30000D+00 0.
.12503D+00

3320 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.13003D+00

3321 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.13503D+00

3322 0.
30000D+00 0.
.14003D+00

3323 0.
30000D+00 0.
.14503D+00

3324 0.
.30000D+00 0. 15003D+00
.

G-UTRENDS.DAT-7
NACA Designation

3405 0. 36972D+00
. 0.
.54415D-01

3406 0..36461D+00 0.
.59337D-01

3407 0. 35948D+00
. 0.
64266D-01

3408 0..35941D+00 0.
.69204D-01

3409 0. 35425D+00
.
0.
.74148D-01

3410 0.
.35417D+00 0.
.79096D-01

3411 0. 34898D+00
. 0.
.84051D-01

3412 0. 34888D+00
. 0.
.89007D-01

3413 0.
.34367D+00 0.
.93968D-01

3414 0.
.34357D+00 0.
.98933D-01

3415 0..34346D+00 0.
.10390D+00

3416 0.
.33821D+00 0.
.10887D+00

3417 0..33810D+00 0.
11384D+00

3418 0.
.33799D+00 0.
.11881D+00

3419 0.
.33269D+00 0.
.12379D+00

3420 0. 33257D+00
. 0.
.12876D+00

3421 0..33245D+00 0.
13374D+00

3422 0.
.33233D+00 0.
.13872D+00

3423 0.
.32699D+00 0.
.14370D+00

3424 0.
.32686D+00 0.
.14868D+00

3505 0.
.42457D+00 0.
.53074D-01

3506 0.
.41441D+00 0. 57846D-01
3507 0.
.40423D+00 0.
62648D-01

3508 0.
.39907D+00 0. 67476D-01
3509 0.
38884D+00 0.
.72323D-01

3510 0.
.38365D+00 0.
77189D-01

3511 0.
.37845D+00 0. 82069D-01
3512 0.
.37323D+00 0. 86961D-01
3513 0.
.37309D+00 0. 91864D-01
3514 0.
.36785D+00 0.
.96778D-01

3515 0.
.36261D+00 0. 10170D+00
3516 0.
.36245D+00 0. 10662D+00
3517 0.
35718D+00 0.
.11156D+00

3518 0.
.35701D+00 0.
. 11649D+00
3519 0.
35173D+00 0.
.12144D+00

3520 0.
.35156D+00 0.
.12638D+00

3521 0.
.34625D+00 0. 13133D+00
,

3522 0.
.34608D+00 0.
.13629D+00

3523 0.
.34590D+00 0. 14124D+00
,

3524 0.
.34057D+00 0.
.14620D+00

3605 0.
46448D+00 0.
.51396D-01

3606 0.
.44930D+00 0. 56020D-01
.

3607 0.
.43409D+00 0.
60704D-01

3608 0.
.42389D+00 0.
.65436D-01

3609 0.
.41367D+00 0.
.70206D-01

3610 0.
.40343D+00 0.
75006D-01

3611 0.
.39823D+00 0.
.79831D-01

3612 0.
.39301D+00 0.
.84676D-01

3613 0.
.38273D+00 0.
89541D-01

3614 0.
37749D+00 0.
.94419D-01

3615 0.
.37224D+00 0.
.99308D-01

3616 0. 37206D+00
. 0.
.10421D+00

3617 0.
36680D+00 0.
.10912D+00

3618 0.
.36153D+00 0.
.11404D+00

3619 0.
.36134D+00 0.
.11896D+00

3620 0.
35605D+00 0.
.12389D+00

3621 0.
.35585D+00 0.
.12883D+00

3622 0.
.35056D+00 0. 13377D+00
.

3623 0.
35036D+00 0. 13871D+00
.

3624 0.
34505D+00 0.
.14366D+00

G-UTRENDS.DAT-8
NACA Designation

3705 0 48943D+00 0 .49609D-01

3706 0 46923D+00 0 .54116D-01
3707 0 .45403D+00 0 .58713D-01
3708 0 .43881D+00 0 .63380D-01
3709 0 .42356D+00 0 68100D-01
.

3710 0 41333D+00 0 72863D-01

3711 0 40309D+00 0 77657D-01
3712 0 39787D+00 0 .82481D-01
3713 0 39265D+00 0 .87324D-01
3714 0 38237D+00 0 .92187D-01
3715 0 .37713D+00 0 .97065D-01
3716 0 .37188D+00 0 10195D+00

3717 0 .37168D+00 0 . 10686D+00

3718 0 . 36643D+00 0 .11177D+00

3719 0 36116D+00 0 .11669D+00

3720 0 .36096D+00 0 .12161D+00

3721 0 .35569D+00 0 .12654D+00

3722 0 .35548D+00 0 . 13148D+00

3723 0,.35020D+00 0. 13642D+00
.

3724 0,.34999D+00 0, 14137D+00

.

3805 0, 50941D+00
. 0..47841D-01
3806 0..48421D+00 0. .52268D-01

3807 0..46399D+00 0. .56813D-01

3808 0, 44376D+00
. 0. .61446D-01

3809 0. .42852D+00 0. .66142D-01

3810 0. .41830D+00 0. .70889D-01

3811 0. .40807D+00 0. .75674D-01

3812 0. .39783D+00 0. .80489D-01

3813 0. 39261D+00
. 0. .85329D-01

3814 0. 38738D+00 0. .90188D-01

3815 0. .37711D+00 0. .95065D-01

3816 0. .37188D+00 0. .99955D-01

3817 0. .37168D+00 0. .10486D+00

3818 0. .36643D+00 0. 10977D+00

.

3819 0. .36118D+00 0. .11469D+00

3820 0. .35593D+00 0. .11961D+00

3821 0. .35573D+00 0. 12455D+00

,

3822 0. 35046D+00 0. 12948D+00

,

3823 0. .35026D+00 0. 13443D+00

,

3824 0. 34499D+00 0. 13937D+00

3905 0. 51939D+00 0. 46158D-01

3906 0. 48919D+00 0. 50542D-01
3907 0. 46397D+00 0. 55064D-01
3908 0. 44374D+00 0. 59685D-01
3909 0. 42852D+00 0. 64378D-01
3910 0. 41831D+00 0. 69124D-01
3911 0. 40808D+00 0. 73912D-01
3912 0. 39785D+00 0. 78731D-01
3913 0. 38761D+00 0. 83574D-01
3914 0. 38240D+00 0. 88440D-01
3915 0. 37718D+00 0. 93321D-01
3916 0. 37195D+00 0. 98216D-01
3917 0. 36672D+00 0. 10312D+00
3918 0. 36149D+00 0. 10804D+00
3919 0. 36129D+00 0. 11296D+00
3920 0. 35605D+00 0. 11789D+00
3921 0. 35081D+00 0. 12283D+00
3922 0. 35061D+00 0. 12777D+00
3923 0. 34536D+00 0. 13272D+00
3924 0. 34516D+00 0. 13767D+00

G-UTRENDS.DAT-9
NACA Designation

4105 0. 23484D+00 0. 63670D-01

4106 0. 24479D+00 0. 68601D-01
4107 0. 24974D+00 0. 73545D-01
4108 0. 25470D+00 0. 78500D-01
4109 0. 25965D+00 0. 83462D-01
4110 0. 25961D+00 0. 88432D-01
4111 0. 26455D+00 0. 93405D-01
4112 0. 26451D+00 0. 98382D-01
4113 0. 26946D+00 0. 10336D+00
4114 0. 26941D+00 0. 10835D+00
4115 0. 26937D+00 0. 11333D+00
4116 0. 27431D+00 0. 11832D+00
4117 0. 27427D+00 0. 12330D+00
4118 0. 27422D+00 0. 12829D+00
4119 0. 27418D+00 0. 13328D+00
4120 0. .27911D+00 0. 13827D+00
4121 0. 27907D+00 0. 14327D+00
4122 0. 27902D+00 0. 14826D+00
4123 0. .27898D+00 0. .15325D+00

4124 0. .27893D+00 0. .15825D+00

4205 0. .25991D+00 0. .64624D-01

4206 0. .26488D+00 0. .69600D-01

4207 0. .26985D+00 0. .74581D-01

4208 0. .26983D+00 0. 79565D-01

4209 0. .27479D+00 0. 84553D-01

4210 0. .27477D+00 0. .89542D-01

4211 0. .27973D+00 0. 94531D-01

4212 0. .27970D+00 0. 99525D-01
4213 0. .27968D+00 0. . 10452D+00
4214 0. .27965D+00 0. .10951D+00

4215 0. .27963D+00 0. .11451D+00

4216 0. 28458D+00 0. . 11950D+00

4217 0. 28455D+00 0. . 12450D+00
4218 0. 28452D+00 0. , 12950D+00
4219 0. .28450D+00 0. .13449D+00

4220 0. .28447D+00 0. 13949D+00

4221 0. .28444D+00 0. 14449D+00

,

4222 0. .28442D+00 0. 14949D+00

.

4223 0. .28439D+00 0. 15448D+00

.

4224 0. .28933D+00 0. 15948D+00

.

4305 0. .30000D+00 0, 65007D-01

4306 0. .30000D+00 0. 70009D-01

.

4307 0, .30000D+00 0. .75010D-01

4308 0, .30000D+00 0, .80012D-01

4309 0. .30000D+00 0. .85013D-01

4310 0, .30000D+00 0, .90014D-01

4311 0, .30000D+00 0, .95016D-01

4312 0, .30000D+00 0 .10002D+00

4313 0, .30000D+00 0, 10502D+00

.

4314 0, .30000D+00 0, 11002D+00

.

4315 0, .30000D+00 0 . 11502D+00

4316 0 .30000D+00 0 . 12002D+00
4317 0, .30000D+00 0 . 12502D+00

4318 0, .30000D+00 0 .13003D+00

4319 0 .30000D+00 0 . 13503D+00

4320 0 .30000D+00 0 . 14003D+00
4321 0, .30000D+00 0 . 14503D+00
4322 0 .30000D+00 0 . 15003D+00
4323 0 .30000D+00 0 .15503D+00

4324 0 .30000D+00 0 .16003D+00

G-UTRENDS . DAT-10
NACA Designation

4405 0 37469D+00
.
0 64368D-01
.

4406 0 36956D+00 0 .69274D-01

4407 0 36948D+00 0 .74191D-01
4408 0 .36431D+00 0 79113D-01
4409 0 36422D+00 0 .84041D-01
4410 0 .35901D+00 0 .88976D-01
4411 0 .35891D+00 0 93914D-01
4412 0 .35366D+00 0 .98858D-01
4413 0 35355D+00 0
.
. 10380D+00
4414 0 .34827D+00 0 .10875D+00

4415 0 .34814D+00 0 .11371D+00

4416 0 .34802D+00 0 .11867D+00

4417 0 . 34268D+00 0, .12362D+00

4418 0 .34254D+00 0. 12859D+00

.

4419 0 34241D+00 0, 13355D+00

.

4420 0 .34227D+00 0, 13851D+00

.

4421 0 .33687D+00 0, .14348D+00

4422 0 .33672D+00 0, 14845D+00

.

4423 0,.33657D+00 0, 15342D+00

.

4424 0,.33642D+00 0. .15839D+00

4505 0,.43955D+00 0. 62881D-01

.

4506 0, .42936D+00 0. .67599D-01

4507 0, .41915D+00 0. 72347D-01

4508 0. .41396D+00 0. .77122D-01

4509 0, .40876D+00 0. .81918D-01

4510 0. .40354D+00 0. .86734D-01

4511 0. .39321D+00 0. .91567D-01

4512 0. .39305D+00 0. .96416D-01

4513 0. .38777D+00 0. .10128D+00

4514 0. .38249D+00 0. .10615D+00

4515 0. .37718D+00 0. .11103D+00

4516 0. .37700D+00 0. .11592D+00

4517 0. .37167D+00 0. . 12082D+00

4518 0. .36632D+00 0. . 12573D+00
4519 0. .36612D+00 0. , 13064D+00
4520 0. 36075D+00
. 0. . 13556D+00
4521 0. .36053D+00 0. 14048D+00
4522 0. .35514D+00 0. 14540D+00
4523 0. .35492D+00 0. 15034D+00
4524 0. .35470D+00 0. 15527D+00

4605 0. 48443D+00 0. 60966D-01

4606 0. 47424D+00 0. 65477D-01
4607 0. 45900D+00 0. 70055D-01
4608 0. 44876D+00 0. 74684D-01
4609 0. 43850D+00 0. 79359D-01
4610 0. 42821D+00 0. 84072D-01
4611 0. 41790D+00 0. 88815D-01
4612 0. 41264D+00 0. 93586D-01
4613 0. 40737D+00 0. 98379D-01
4614 0. 40208D+00 0. 10319D+00
4615 0. 39678D+00 0. 10802D+00
4616 0. 39147D+00 0. 11287D+00
4617 0. 38614D+00 0. 11773D+00
4618 0. 38081D+00 0. 12259D+00
4619 0. 37546D+00 0. 12747D+00
4620 0. 37522D+00 0. 13236D+00
4621 0. 36986D+00 0. 13726D+00
4622 0. 36448D+00 0. 14216D+00
4623 0. 36423D+00 0. 14707D+00
4624 0. 35883D+00 0. 15198D+00

G-UTRENDS DAT-11
.
NACA Designation

4705 0.52439D+00 0.58865D-01

4706 0.50416D+00 0.63194D-01
4707 0.48390D+00 0. 67627D-01
4708 0.46863D+00 0. 72144D-01
4709 0.45838D+00 0. 76728D-01
4710 0.44306D+00 0. 81368D-01
4711 0.43276D+00 0. 86053D-01
4712 0.42244D+00 0. 90775D-01
4713 0.41717D+00 0. 95530D-01
4714 0.40682D+00 0. 10031D+00
4715 0.40152D+00 0. 10511D+00
4716 0.39621D+00 0. 10993D+00
4717 0.39090D+00 0. 11477D+00
4718 0.38557D+00 0.11962D+00
4719 0.38024D+00 0.12449D+00
4720 0.37489D+00 0.12936D+00
4721 0.37464D+00 0.13425D+00
4722 0.36928D+00 0.13914D+00
4723 0.36902D+00 0.14404D+00
4724 0.36365D+00 0.14895D+00

4805 0.55437D+00 0.56720D-01

4806 0.52412D+00 0.60906D-01
4807 0.50387D+00 0.65236D-01
4808 0.48359D+00 0.69679D-01
4809 0.46831D+00 0.74208D-01
4810 0.45301D+00 0.78808D-01
4811 0.43768D+00 0.83463D-01
4812 0.42738D+00 0.88163D-01
4813 0.42211D+00 0.92900D-01
4814 0.41178D+00 0.97669D-01
4815 0.40649D+00 0.10246D+00
4816 0.39614D+00 0.10728D+00
4817 0.39083D+00 0.11211D+00
4818 0.38552D+00 0.11696D+00
4819 0.38020D+00 0.12182D+00
4820 0.37994D+00 0.12669D+00
4821 0.37461D+00 0.13158D+00
4822 0.36928D+00 0.13647D+00
4823 0.36393D+00 0.14137D+00
4824 0.36367D+00 0.14628D+00

4905 0.57436D+00 54621D-01

4906 0.53911D+00 58708D-01
4907 0.51385D+00 62974D-01
4908 0.48856D+00 67376D-01
4909 0.
.46826D+00 71881D-01
4910 0.
.45297D+00 76466D-01
4911 0.
.44269D+00 81113D-01
4912 0.
42737D+00 85810D-01
4913 0.
.41706D+00 90547D-01
4914 0.
41179D+00 0.95318D-01
4915 0.
.40147D+00 0.10011D+00
4916 0.
.39618D+00 0.10493D+00
4917 0.
39089D+00 0.10977D+00
4918 0.
38559D+00 11463D+00
4919 0.38029D+00 11949D+00
4920 0.37498D+00 12437D+00
4921 0.
36967D+00 12926D+00
4922 0.
.36941D+00 13416D+00
4923 0.
.36409D+00 0.13907D+00
4924 0.
35876D+00 0.14398D+00

G-UTRENDS DAT-12
.
NACA Designation

5105 0,.22980D+00 0 .73452D-01

5106 0 .23475D+00 0 .78358D-01

5107 0,.23970D+00 0 .83282D-01

5108 0,.24465D+00 0 .88220D-01

5109 0,.24959D+00 0,.93169D-01
5110 0,.25453D+00 0, .98124D-01

5111 0,.25448D+00 0, 10309D+00

.

5112 0,25941D+00 0. .10805D+00

5113 0,.25936D+00 0, 11302D+00

.

5114 0,.26429D+00 0. 11800D+00

.

5115 0..26424D+00 0, 12298D+00

.

5116 0, .26916D+00 0. 12795D+00

.

5117 0..26911D+00 0. .13294D+00

5118 0. .26906D+00 0. .13792D+00

5119 0, .26901D+00 0. .14291D+00

5120 0. .27392D+00 0. 14789D+00

.

5121 0, .27387D+00 0. .15288D+00

5122 0. .27381D+00 0. .15787D+00

5123 0. .27376D+00 0. .16286D+00

5124 0. .27371D+00 0. .16785D+00

5205 0. .25489D+00 0. .74568D-01

5206 0. 25986D+00 0. .79537D-01

5207 0. 26482D+00 0. 84511D-01

5208 0. .26480D+00 0. 89488D-01
5209 0. .26975D+00 0. 94472D-01
5210 0. 26973D+00 0. .99456D-01

5211 0. .27468D+00 0. .10444D+00

5212 0. 27465D+00 0. 10943D+00

5213 0. .27462D+00 0. .11442D+00

5214 0. .27956D+00 0. , 11941D+00

5215 0. .27953D+00 0. . 12441D+00
5216 0. .27950D+00 0. 12940D+00
5217 0. .27947D+00 0. 13439D+00
5218 0. 27944D+00 0. 13939D+00
5219 0. .27941D+00 0. 14438D+00
5220 0. .28434D+00 0. 14938D+00
5221 0. .28430D+00 0. 15437D+00
5222 0. .28427D+00 0. 15937D+00
5223 0. .28424D+00 0. 16437D+00
5224 0. .28420D+00 0. 16937D+00

5305 0. .30000D+00 0. 75007D-01

5306 0. .30000D+00 0. 80009D-01
5307 0. .30000D+00 0. 85010D-01
5308 0. 30000D+00 0. 90012D-01
5309 0. .30000D+00 0. 95013D-01
5310 0. 30000D+00 0. 10001D+00
5311 0. .30000D+00 0. 10502D+00
5312 0. .30000D+00 0. 11002D+00
5313 0. 30000D+00 0. 11502D+00
5314 0. 30000D+00 0. 12002D+00
5315 0. 30000D+00 0. 12502D+00
5316 0. 30000D+00 0. 13002D+00
5317 0. 30000D+00 0. 13502D+00
5318 0. 30000D+00 0. 14003D+00
5319 0. 30000D+00 0. 14503D+00
,

5320 0. 30000D+00 0. 15003D+00

5321 0. 30000D+00 0. 15503D+00
5322 0. 30000D+00 0. 16003D+00

5323 0. 30000D+00 0. 16503D+00

,

5324 0. 30000D+00 0. 17003D+00

.

G-UTRENDS.DAT-13
NACA Designation

5405 0 37969D+00 0 .74337D-01

5406 0 37454D+00 0 .79233D-01

5407 0 .37446D+00 0 84137D-01

5408 0 .36926D+00 0 89048D-01
5409 0 .36917D+00 0 .93965D-01
5410 0 .36392D+00 0 .98887D-01
5411 0 . 36381D+00 0 .10381D+00
5412 0 .35852D+00 0 .10874D+00
5413 0 .35840D+00 0 .11368D+00
5414 0 .35827D+00 0, 11862D+00
.

5415 0 .35291D+00 0,.12356D+00

5416 0 .35277D+00 0 . 12851D+00
5417 0 .35264D+00 0, 13345D+00
.

5418 0 .34721D+00 0, 13840D+00

.

5419 0 .34706D+00 0..14336D+00

5420 0 .34690D+00 0,.14831D+00
5421 0,.34675D+00 0. .15327D+00

5422 0, .34125D+00 0, 15823D+00

.

5423 0, .34108D+00 0. 16319D+00

.

5424 0, 34091D+00
. 0. 16815D+00
.

5505 0..44954D+00 0. .72748D-01

5506 0, .43932D+00 0. .77425D-01

5507 0. .43414D+00 0. .82130D-01

5508 0. .42386D+00 0. .86862D-01

5509 0. .41863D+00 0. .91617D-01

5510 0. .41337D+00 0. .96392D-01

5511 0. .40810D+00 0. .10118D+00

5512 0. .40280D+00 0. 10599D+00

5513 0. .39749D+00 0. . 11082D+00

5514 0. .39215D+00 0. , 11565D+00
5515 0. .39195D+00 0. . 12050D+00
5516 0. .38658D+00 0. , 12535D+00
5517 0. .38119D+00 0. 13022D+00
5518 0. 38096D+00 0. 13509D+00
5519 0. .37554D+00 0. 13997D+00
5520 0. .37531D+00 0. 14486D+00
5521 0. 36986D+00 0. 14976D+00
5522 0. 36961D+00 0. 15466D+00
5523 0. 36413D+00 0. 15956D+00
5524 0. 36387D+00 0. 16447D+00

5605 0. 50442D+00 0. 70665D-01

5606 0. 48918D+00 0. 75087D-01
5607 0. 47895D+00 0. 79575D-01
5608 0. 46868D+00 0. 84117D-01
5609 0. 45839D+00 0. 88708D-01
5610 0. 44806D+00 0. 93341D-01
5611 0. 43771D+00 0. 98008D-01
5612 0. 43241D+00 0. 10271D+00
5613 0. 42200D+00 0. 10743D+00
5614 0. 41667D+00 0. 11218D+00
5615 0. 41132D+00 0. 11695D+00
5616 0. 40595D+00 0. 12174D+00
5617 0. 40057D+00 0. 12654D+00
5618 0. 39517D+00 0. 13136D+00
5619 0. 39490D+00 0. 13618D+00
5620 0. 38948D+00 0. 14103D+00
5621 0. 38405D+00 0. 14588D+00
5622 0. 37860D+00 0. 15074D+00
5623 0. 37831D+00 0. 15561D+00
5624 0. 37284D+00 0. 16048D+00

G-UTRENDS.DAT-14
NACA Designation

5705 0.54937D+00 0.68330D-01

5706 0.52912D+00 0.72511D-01
5707 0.51386D+00 0.76802D-01
5708 0.49352D+00 0.81183D-01
5709 0.48323D+00 0.85641D-01
5710 0.46786D+00 0.90162D-01
5711 0.45752D+00 0.94737D-01
5712 0.44716D+00 0.99357D-01
5713 0.43677D+00 0.10402D+00
5714 0.43144D+00 0.10871D+00
5715 0.42101D+00 0.11343D+00
5716 0.41565D+00 0.11818D+00
5717 0.41028D+00 0.12294D+00
5718 0.40489D+00 0.12773D+00
5719 0.
.39950D+00 0.13253D+00
5720 0.
.39409D+00 0.13735D+00
5721 0.
.38867D+00 0.14218D+00
5722 0.
.38837D+00 0.14702D+00
5723 0.
.38293D+00 0.15188D+00
5724 0.
.37749D+00 0.15674D+00

5805 0.58434D+00 0.65897D-01

5806 0.55909D+00 0.69874D-01
5807 0.53378D+00 0.74006D-01
5808 0.51346D+00 0.78266D-01
5809 0.49814D+00 0.82630D-01
5810 0.48279D+00 0.87079D-01
5811 0.46742D+00 0.91597D-01
5812 0.45707D+00 0.96173D-01
5813 0.44670D+00 0.10080D+00
5814 0.43631D+00 0.10546D+00
5815 0.42590D+00 0.11016D+00
5816 0.42055D+00 0.11489D+00
5817 0.41519D+00 0.11965D+00
5818 0.40474D+00 0.12442D+00
5819 0.39936D+00 0.12922D+00
5820 0.39397D+00 0.13403D+00
5821 0.39367D+00 0.13885D+00
5822 0.38826D+00 0.14370D+00
5823 0.38285D+00 0.14855D+00
5824 0.37742D+00 0.15341D+00

5905 0.61435D+00 0.63468D-01

5906 0.57907D+00 0.67282D-01
5907 0.55378D+00 0.71301D-01
5908 0.52845D+00 0.75482D-01
5909 0.50811D+00 0.79789D-01
5910 0.48774D+00 0.84200D-01
5911 0.47238D+00 0.88692D-01
5912 0.46205D+00 0.93250D-01
5913 0.44665D+00 0.97865D-01
5914 0.43628D+00 0.10252D+00
5915 0.43095D+00 0.10722D+00
5916 0.42055D+00 0.11195D+00
5917 0.41520D+00 0.11671D+00
5918 0.40478D+00 0.12149D+00
5919 0.39941D+00 0.12628D+00
5920 0.39404D+00 0.13110D+00
5921 0.38866D+00 0.13593D+00
5922 0.38327D+00 0.14078D+00
5923 0.38297D+00 0.14563D+00
5924 0.37757D+00 0.15050D+00

G-UTRENDS.DAT-15
NACA Designation

6105 0.
.21978D+00 0..83260D-01
6106 0..22972D+00 0..88142D-01
6107 0..23466D+00 0..93046D-01
6108 0..23959D+00 0..97967D-01
6109 0.
.24452D+00 0.
.10290D+00

6110 0..24945D+00 0.
.10784D+00

6111 0.
.24939D+00 0.
.11279D+00

6112 0..25432D+00 0.
.11775D+00

6113 0..25426D+00 0.
.12271D+00

6114 0..25918D+00 0.
.12768D+00

6115 0..25912D+00 0.
.13264D+00

6116 0..26403D+00 0.
.13762D+00

6117 0.
.26397D+00 0.
14259D+00

6118 0.
.26391D+00 0. 14757D+00
.

6119 0.
.26384D+00 0.
.15255D+00

6120 0.
.26874D+00 0.
15753D+00

6121 0. 26868D+00
. 0.
.16251D+00

6122 0.
26862D+00 0.
.16750D+00

6123 0.
.26856D+00 0.
.17248D+00

6124 0.
27345D+00 0. 17747D+00
.

6205 0.
.25487D+00 0.
.84521D-01

6206 0.
25485D+00 0. 89482D-01
6207 0.
.25980D+00 0. 94450D-01
6208 0.
.26476D+00 0. 99422D-01
6209 0.
26473D+00 0.
, 10440D+00
6210 0.
.26967D+00 0.
, 10938D+00
6211 0.
.26964D+00 0.
, U436D+00
6212 0.
26961D+00 0.
11935D+00

6213 0.
27454D+00 0.
, 12433D+00
6214 0.
.27451D+00 0. 12932D+00
6215 0.
.27447D+00 0. 13431D+00
6216 0.
.27444D+00 0. 13930D+00
,

6217 0.
.27936D+00 0. 14429D+00
,

6218 0.
.27933D+00 0. 14929D+00
,

6219 0.
.27929D+00 0. 15428D+00
6220 0.
.27925D+00 0. 15927D+00
6221 0.
.27921D+00 0.
.16427D+00

6222 0.
.27918D+00 0.
.16926D+00

6223 0.
.28408D+00 0.
17425D+00

6224 0.
.28404D+00 0. 17925D+00
,

6305 0.
.30000D+00 0.
85007D-01

6306 0. 30000D+00
, 0.
.90009D-01

6307 0.
.30000D+00 0.
95010D-01

6308 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.10001D+00

6309 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.10501D+00

6310 0.
.30000D+00 0. 11001D+00
,

6311 0.
.30000D+00 0. 11502D+00
,

6312 0.
.30000D+00 0. 12002D+00
,

6313 0.
.30000D+00 0. 12502D+00
,

6314 0.
.30000D+00 0. 13002D+00
,

6315 0.
.30000D+00 0. 13502D+00
,

6316 0.
.30000D+00 0. 14002D+00
,

6317 0.
.30000D+00 0. 14502D+00
,

6318 0.
30000D+00 0. 15003D+00
,

6319 0.
.30000D+00 0. 15503D+00
.

6320 0. 30000D+00 0.
.16003D+00

6321 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.16503D+00

6322 0.
30000D+00 0. 17003D+00
.

6323 0.
30000D+00 0.
17503D+00

6324 0.
.30000D+00 0. 18003D+00
.

G-UTRENDS DAT-
. 16
NACA Designation

6405 0. 38473D+00 0. 84312D-01

6406 0. 37956D+00 0. 89203D-01
6407 0. 37436D+00 0. 94096D-01
6408 0. 37426D+00 0. 99001D-01
6409 0. 37417D+00 0. 10391D+00
,

6410 0.
,36889D+00 0. 10882D+00
6411 0.
36878D+00 0. 11374D+00
,

6412 0.
.36345D+00 0.H866D+00
6413 0.
36332D+00 0. 12359D+00
6414 0.
.36319D+00 0. 12851D+00
6415 0.
.35778D+00 0. 13345D+00
6416 0.
.35763D+00 0. 13838D+00
,

6417 0.
.35748D+00 0. 14332D+00
6418 0.
.35200D+00 0. 14826D+00
,

6419 0.
.35183D+00 0. 15320D+00
6420 0.
35166D+00 0. 15815D+00
6421 0.
.35149D+00 0. 16310D+00
.

6422 0.
34591D+00 0. 16804D+00
6423 0.
34573D+00 0. 17300D+00
6424 0.
.34554D+00 0. .17795D+00

6505 0.
.45450D+00 0. 82654D-01
6506 0.
.44933D+00 0. 87296D-01
6507 0.
43905D+00 0. 91968D-01
6508 0.
.43382D+00 0. 96666D-01
6509 0.
42857D+00 0. 10138D+00
6510 0.
42329D+00 0. 10612D+00
6511 0.
.41799D+00 0. 11088D+00
6512 0.
.41266D+00 0. 11566D+00
,

6513 0.
40730D+00 0. .12044D+00

6514 0.
40193D+00 0. .12524D+00

6515 0.
.40171D+00 0. 13006D+00
6516 0.
39629D+00 0. 13488D+00
6517 0.
.39085D+00 0. 13972D+00
6518 0.
39060D+00 0. 14456D+00

6519 0.
.38513D+00 0. .14941D+00

6520 0.
.38487D+00 0. .15427D+00

6521 0.
.37935D+00 0. 15914D+00
.

6522 0.
.37908D+00 0. .16401D+00

6523 0.
.37353D+00 0. 16889D+00

6524 0.
.37325D+00 0. .17377D+00

6605 0.
.51439D+00 0. 80441D-01

6606 0.
.50417D+00 0. .84794D-01

6607 0.
.49391D+00 0. 89208D-01

6608 0.
.48362D+00 0. .93677D-01

6609 0.
.47330D+00 0. .98196D-01

6610 0.
.46294D+00 0, 10276D+00
.

6611 0.
.45254D+00 0. 10736D+00
.

6612 0.
.44721D+00 0. .11199D+00

6613 0.
.44187D+00 0. 11665D+00
.

6614 0.
.43138D+00 0. 12133D+00
.

6615 0.
.42598D+00 0. 12604D+00
.

6616 0.
.42057D+00 0, 13078D+00
.

6617 0.
.41514D+00 0, 13552D+00
.

6618 0.
.40970D+00 0, 14029D+00
.

6619 0.
.40423D+00 0, .14507D+00

6620 0,
.40393D+00 0, .14986D+00

6621 0,
.39843D+00 0 .15467D+00

6622 0.
.39292D+00 0 .15949D+00

6623 0,
.39260D+00 0 .16431D+00

6624 0,
.38706D+00 0 .16915D+00

G-UTRENDS . DAT-17
NACA Designation

6705 0. 56936D+00 0. 77929D-01

6706 0. 54909D+00 0. 81990D-01
6707 0. 53381D+00 0. 86160D-01
6707 0. 51848D+00 0. 90423D-01
6709 0. 50312D+00 0. 94765D-01
6710 0. 49277D+00 0. 99176D-01
6711 0. 47733D+00 0. 10365D+00
6712 0. 46692D+00 0. 10817D+00
6713 0. 46158D+00 0.H273D+00
6714 0. 45112D+00 0. 11734D+00
6715 0. 44063D+00 0. 12198D+00
6716 0. 43523D+00 0. 12665D+00
6717 0. 42981D+00 0. 13134D+00
6718 0. 42438D+00 0. 13606D+00

6719 0. 41894D+00 0. 14080D+00

6720 0. 41348D+00 0. 14555D+00
6721 0. 40800D+00 0. 15033D+00
6722 0. 40251D+00 0. 15511D+00
6723 0. .39701D+00 0. 15992D+00
6724 0. .39150D+00 0. 16473D+00

6805 0. .61436D+00 0. 75273D-01

6806 0. .58909D+00 0. 79071D-01
6807 0. 56376D+00
, 0. 83031D-01
6808 0. .54341D+00 0. 87125D-01
6809 0. .52302D+00 0. 91331D-01
6810 0. .50763D+00 0. 95633D-01
6811 0. .49221D+00 0. 10001D+00
,

6812 0. .48182D+00 0. 10447D+00

,

6813 0. .47141D+00 0. 10897D+00

.

6814 0. .46098D+00 0. 11353D+00

.

6815 0. 45052D+00 0. .11813D+00

6816 0. .44004D+00 0. 12277D+00

6817 0. .43463D+00 0. 12744D+00

,

6818 0. 42921D+00 0. 13213D+00

,

6819 0. .41867D+00 0. .13685D+00

6820 0. .41322D+00 0. .14160D+00

6821 0. .40776D+00 0. 14636D+00

6822 0. .40229D+00 0. 15114D+00

6823 0. .39681D+00 0. 15593D+00

.

6824 0. .39646D+00 0. .16074D+00

6905 0. .64936D+00 0. .72577D-01

6906 0, .61406D+00 0. .76155D-01

6907 0. .58373D+00 0. .79948D-01

6908 0. 55836D+00
. 0. .83917D-01

6909 0, .53799D+00 0. .88032D-01

6910 0. .51758D+00 0. .92265D-01

6911 0, .50218D+00 0. .96597D-01

6912 0, .48675D+00 0, .10101D+00

6913 0, .47636D+00 0, .10549D+00

6914 0, .46087D+00 0, .11003D+00

6915 0 .45043D+00 0, .11462D+00

6916 0 .44505D+00 0 . 11925D+00

6917 0 .43458D+00 0 .12391D+00

6918 0 .42917D+00 0 .12860D+00

6919 0 .41866D+00 0 .13332D+00

6920 0 .41323D+00 0 . 13807D+00

6921 0 .40780D+00 0 . 14283D+00
6922 0 .40235D+00 0 .14762D+00

6923 0 .39689D+00 0 .15241D+00

6924 0 .39143D+00 0 .15722D+00

G-UTRENDS . DAT-18
NACA Designation

7105 0.
.21476D+00 0. 93089D-01
7106 0..21970D+00 0. 97947D-01
7107 0..22961D+00 0. 10283D+00
7108 0..23454D+00 0.
, 10773D+00
7109 0..23946D+00 0. 11265D+00
7110 0..23940D+00 0. 11758D+00
7111 0..24432D+00 0. 12252D+00
7112 0.
.24923D+00 0. 12746D+00
7113 0.
.24917D+00 0. 13241D+00
7114 0.
.25407D+00 0. 13737D+00
7115 0.
.25400D+00 0. 14233D+00
7116 0.
.25890D+00 0. 14730D+00
7117 0.
.25883D+00 0.
15227D+00

7118 0.
.25876D+00 0. 15723D+00
7119 0..26365D+00 0. 16221D+00
7120 0.
.26358D+00 0. 16718D+00
7121 0.
.26351D+00 0. 17216D+00
7122 0.
.26344D+00 0.
. 17714D+00
7123 0,
.26832D+00 0. 18212D+00
7124 0.
.26824D+00 0.
. 18710D+00

7205 0.
.24986D+00 0. 94481D-01
7206 0.
.25482D+00 0. 99434D-01
7207 0.
.25479D+00 0.
, 10440D+00
7208 0.
.25974D+00 0.
, 10936D+00
7209 0.
.26468D+00 0.
, 11433D+00
7210 0.
.26465D+00 0.
, 11931D+00
7211 0.
.26461D+00 0.
, 12429D+00
7212 0.
.26954D+00 0.
, 12927D+00
7213 0.
.26950D+00 0. 13425D+00
7214 0.
.26947D+00 0. 13924D+00
7215 0.
27439D+00 0. 14422D+00
7216 0.
.27435D+00 0. 14921D+00
7217 0.
.27430D+00 0. 15420D+00
,

7218 0.
.27426D+00 0. 15919D+00
7219 0.
.27422D+00 0. 16418D+00
,

7220 0.
.27913D+00 0. 16917D+00
7221 0.
.27908D+00 0.
17417D+00

7222 0.
.27904D+00 0.
.17916D+00

7223 0.
27900D+00 0.
.18415D+00

7224 0.
.27895D+00 0.
.18915D+00

7305 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.95007D-01

7306 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.10001D+00

7307 0.
.30000D+00 0.
10501D+00

7308 0,
.30000D+00 0.
.11001D+00

7309 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.11501D+00

7310 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.12001D+00

7311 0.
.30000D+00 0. 12502D+00
,

7312 0,
.30000D+00 0. 13002D+00
.

7313 0.
.30000D+00 0. 13502D+00
.

7314 0.
.30000D+00 0. 14002D+00
.

7315 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.14502D+00

7316 0,
.30000D+00 0.
.15002D+00

7317 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.15502D+00

7318 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.16003D+00

7319 0.
.30000D+00 0,
.16503D+00

7320 0.
.30000D+00 0.
17003D+00

7321 0.
.30000D+00 0. 17503D+00
.

7322 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.18003D+00

7323 0.
.30000D+00 0,
.18503D+00

7324 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.19003D+00

G-UTRENDS . DAT-19
NACA Designation

7405 0,.38468D+00 0,
.94297D-01

7406 0,.37949D+00 0..99177D-01

7407 0,.37940D+00 0, 10407D+00
.

7408 0,.37932D+00 0.
.10896D+00

7409 0..37403D+00 0.
.11386D+00

7410 0,.37393D+00 0.
.11877D+00

7411 0. 36858D+00
. 0.
.12368D+00

7412 0, 36845D+00
.
0,
.12859D+00

7413 0. 36832D+00
. 0.
.13351D+00

7414 0,.36289D+00 0. 13843D+00

.

7415 0.36274D+00 0.
.14335D+00

7416 0,
.36259D+00 0.
.14828D+00

7417 0,.35706D+00 0.
.15320D+00

7418 0.
.35689D+00 0.
.15814D+00

7419 0.
.35672D+00 0.
.16308D+00

7420 0,.35655D+00 0. 16801D+00

.

7421 0.
.35091D+00 0. 17295D+00
.

7422 0.
.35072D+00 0. 17789D+00
.

7423 0.
.35052D+00 0.
.18284D+00

7424 0.
.35033D+00 0.
.18778D+00

7505 0.
.45948D+00 0.
.92580D-01

7506 0.
45430D+00 0.
97198D-01

7507 0.
.44909D+00 0.
.10184D+00

7508 0.
.44385D+00 0. 10651D+00
,

7509 0.
.43346D+00 0.
.11120D+00

7510 0.
42815D+00 0.
.11591D+00

7511 0.
.42796D+00 0.
.12064D+00

7512 0.
42261D+00 0. 12538D+00
.

7513 0.
.41723D+00 0.
13014D+00

7514 0.
.41181D+00 0.
.13491D+00

7515 0.
.40637D+00 0.
.13969D+00

7516 0.
40613D+00 0. 14449D+00
,

7517 0.
.40065D+00 0. 14930D+00
,

7518 0.
.40039D+00 0. 15411D+00
.

7519 0.
.39486D+00 0.
.15894D+00

7520 0.
.38931D+00 0.
.16377D+00

7521 0.
.38902D+00 0.
.16861D+00

7522 0.
.38342D+00 0.
.17345D+00

7523 0.
38312D+00 0. 17831D+00
,

7524 0.
38282D+00 0.
.18317D+00

7605 0.
52438D+00 0.
.90270D-01

7606 0.
.51414D+00 0.
94566D-01

7607 0.
50387D+00 0.
.98920D-01

7608 0.
.49355D+00 0.
10333D+00

7609 0. 48320D+00 0.
10778D+00

7610 0.
.47790D+00 0.
.11228D+00

7611 0.
.46747D+00 0. 11682D+00
7612 0. 46212D+00 0.
12139D+00

7613 0. 45161D+00 0.
12599D+00

7614 0. 44621D+00 0.
.13062D+00

7615 0. 44078D+00 0.
, 13528D+00
7616 0. 43534D+00 0.
.13995D+00

7617 0. 42987D+00 0.
, 14465D+00
7618 0. 42438D+00 0.
.14936D+00

7619 0. 41887D+00 0.
, 15410D+00
7620 0. 41334D+00 0.
.15884D+00

7621 0. 40779D+00 0.
16360D+00

7622 0. 40744D+00 0.
.16838D+00

7623 0. 40186D+00 0.
.17316D+00

7624 0. 39625D+00 0.
. 17796D+00

G-UTRENDS.DAT-20
NACA Designation

7705 0. 58436D+00 0. 87620D-01

7706 0. 56407D+00 0. 91580D-01
7707 0. 54876D+00 0. 95648D-01
7708 0. 53341D+00 0. 99808D-01
7709 0. 52308D+00 0. 10405D+00
7710 0. 50764D+00 0. 10836D+00
7711 0. 49723D+00 0. 11274D+00
7712 0. 48679D+00 0. 11716D+00
7713 0. 47632D+00 0. 12164D+00
7714 0. 47092D+00 0. 12616D+00
7715 0. 46039D+00 0. 13072D+00
7716 0. 45496D+00 0. 13531D+00
7717 0. 44437D+00 0. 13993D+00
7718 0. 43889D+00 0. 14458D+00
7719 0. 43340D+00 0. 14925D+00
7720 0. 42788D+00 0. 15394D+00
7721 0. 42236D+00 0. 15866D+00
7722 0. .41681D+00 0. 16339D+00
7723 0. .41125D+00 0. 16813D+00
7724 0. .40568D+00 0. 17289D+00

7805 0. 63436D+00 0. 84785D-01

7806 0. 60907D+00 0. 88434D-01
7807 0. .58876D+00 0. 92242D-01
7808 0. .56839D+00 0. 96188D-01
7809 0. .54797D+00 0. 10025D+00
,

7810 0. .53256D+00 0. 10442D+00

7811 0. 51711D+00
, 0. 10867D+00
7812 0. .50669D+00 0. 11299D+00
,

7813 0. .49116D+00 0. 11739D+00

7814 0. .48068D+00 0. .12184D+00

7815 0. .47017D+00 0. .12634D+00

7816 0. .45964D+00 0. .13088D+00

7817 0. 45419D+00 0. 13546D+00

.

7818 0. .44361D+00 0. 14007D+00

.

7819 0. .43813D+00 0. .14471D+00

7820 0. .43263D+00 0. .14938D+00

7821 0. .42712D+00 0. 15407D+00

.

7822 0, .42160D+00 0. .15878D+00

7823 0. .41607D+00 0. .16352D+00

7824 0. .41052D+00 0. 16826D+00

.

7905 0, .67437D+00 0, .81874D-01

7906 0. .64408D+00 0. .85247D-01

7907 0, .61373D+00 0, .88839D-01

7908 0, .58834D+00 0, .92615D-01

7909 0, .56795D+00 0, .96547D-01

7910 0, .54751D+00 0, .10061D+00

7911 0 .53208D+00 0, .10478D+00

7912 0 .51662D+00 0 . 10905D+00

7913 0 .50112D+00 0 . 11339D+00
7914 0 .48558D+00 0 .11780D+00

7915 0 .47510D+00 0 .12228D+00

7916 0 .46459D+00 0 . 12680D+00

7917 0 45406D+00
. 0 . 13136D+00
7918 0 .44861D+00 0 .13596D+00

7919 0 .43804D+00 0 .14060D+00

7920 0 .43256D+00 0 . 14526D+00

7921 0 .42707D+00 0 . 14995D+00
7922 0 .42157D+00 0 . 15466D+00
7923 0 .41606D+00 0 . 15940D+00
7924 0 .41054D+00 0 .16415D+00

G-UTRENDS.DAT-21
NACA Designation

8105 0..20974D+00 0.
.10294D+00

8106 0..21467D+00 0.
.10777D+00

8107 0..22458D+00 0.
.11264D+00

8108 0..22950D+00 0.
.11752D+00

8109 0..23441D+00 0. 12242D+00

8110 0..23434D+00 0.
, 12734D+00
8111 0..23925D+00 0.
.13226D+00

8112 0.
.24415D+00 0. 13720D+00
8113 0..24408D+00 0.
.14214D+00

8114 0..24897D+00 0.
.14708D+00

8115 0.
.24890D+00 0. 15204D+00
8116 0..25379D+00 0. 15699D+00
8117 0.
.25371D+00 0. 16195D+00
8118 0.
.25859D+00 0. 16692D+00
8119 0..25851D+00 0. 17188D+00
8120 0.
.25843D+00 0.
.17685D+00

8121 0.
.25835D+00 0. 18182D+00
8122 0.
.26322D+00 0.
.18680D+00

8123 0.
.26313D+00 0. 19178D+00
.

8124 0.
.26305D+00 0. 19675D+00
.

8205 0.
.24486D+00 0.
10445D+00

8206 0.
.24981D+00 0.
.10939D+00

8207 0.
.25476D+00 0.
.11435D+00

8208 0.
.25473D+00 0.
.11931D+00

8209 0.
.25966D+00 0. 12428D+00
8210 0.
25963D+00 0.
. 12925D+00
8211 0.
.26456D+00 0.
, 13422D+00
8212 0.
.26451D+00 0.
, 13920D+00
8213 0.
26943D+00 0. 14418D+00
8214 0.
.26939D+00 0.
, 14916D+00
8215 0.
.26935D+00 0.
, 15414D+00
8216 0.
26930D+00 0. 15913D+00
8217 0.
.27420D+00 0. 16411D+00
8218 0.
.27416D+00 0.
, 16910D+00
8219 0.
.27411D+00 0. 17409D+00
8220 0.
27406D+00 0. 17908D+00
8221 0.
27402D+00 0.
.18407D+00

8222 0.
.27397D+00 0.
18906D+00

8223 0.
.27885D+00 0.
.19405D+00

8224 0.
27880D+00 0.
.19905D+00

8305 0.
.30000D+00 0.
10501D+00

8306 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.11001D+00

8307 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.11501D+00

8308 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.12001D+00

8309 0.
.30000D+00 0.
12501D+00

8310 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.13001D+00

8311 0.
30000D+00 0. 13502D+00
.

8312 0.
.30000D+00 0. 14002D+00
.

8313 0.
.30000D+00 0. 14502D+00
.

8314 0.
.30000D+00 0. 15002D+00
.

8315 0.
.30000D+00 0. 15502D+00
.

8316 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.16002D+00

8317 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.16502D+00

8318 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.17003D+00

8319 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.17503D+00

8320 0.
.30000D+00 0,
.18003D+00

8321 0.
.30000D+00 0,
.18503D+00

8322 0.
.30000D+00 0. 19003D+00
.

8323 0. 30000D+00
. 0.
.19503D+00

8324 0.
.30000D+00 0,
.20003D+00

G-UTRENDS.DAT-22
NACA Designation

8405 0 38463D+00
.
0 .10428D+00

8406 0 38456D+00 0
.
. 10916D+00
8407 0 37932D+00 0
.
. 11404D+00
8408 0 37922D+00
. 0 .11893D+00

8409 0 .37912D+00 0 .12383D+00

8410 0 .37377D+00 0 12872D+00

.

8411 0 .37365D+00 0 .13363D+00

8412 0 37353D+00 0 13853D+00

.

8413 0 .36808D+00 0, 14344D+00

.

8414 0 .36794D+00 0, .14836D+00

8415 0 .36779D+00 0 .15327D+00

8416 0 .36224D+00 0, 15819D+00

.

8417 0 .36207D+00 0, .16312D+00

8418 0 .36190D+00 0. 16804D+00

.

8419 0, 36172D+00
. 0, .17297D+00

8420 0, .35605D+00 0. .17789D+00

8421 0,.35585D+00 0, 18283D+00

.

8422 0, 35566D+00
. 0. 18776D+00
.

8423 0, .35546D+00 0. .19270D+00

8424 0, .35526D+00 0. .19763D+00

8505 0, .46449D+00 0. .10252D+00

8506 0, .45929D+00 0. .10712D+00

8507 0, .45407D+00 0. 11174D+00

8508 0. .44881D+00 0. 11639D+00

8509 0. .44352D+00 0. .12105D+00

8510 0. .43820D+00 0. .12574D+00

8511 0. .43285D+00 0. 13044D+00

,

8512 0. 42746D+00 0. 13516D+00

,

8513 0. .42204D+00 0. .13989D+00

8514 0. 42181D+00 0. .14463D+00

8515 0. .41634D+00 0. .14939D+00

8516 0. .41084D+00 0. 15416D+00

8517 0. .41058D+00 0. 15894D+00
8518 0. .40503D+00 0. .16373D+00

8519 0. .40475D+00 0. 16852D+00

8520 0. 39915D+00 0. 17333D+00
8521 0. .39886D+00 0. 17815D+00

8522 0. .39321D+00 0. 18297D+00

,

8523 0. .39290D+00 0. 18780D+00

,

8524 0. .38719D+00 0. 19264D+00

8605 0. 53439D+00 0. 10014D+00

8606 0. 52415D+00 0. 10438D+00
8607 0. 51386D+00 0. 10869D+00
8608 0. 50352D+00 0. 11304D+00
8609 0. 49314D+00 0.H745D+00
8610 0. 48782D+00 0. 12189D+00
8611 0. 47736D+00 0. 12637D+00
8612 0. 47198D+00 0. 13089D+00
8613 0. 46658D+00 0. 13544D+00
8614 0. 45599D+00 0. 14002D+00
8615 0. 45053D+00 0. 14462D+00
8616 0. 44505D+00 0. 14925D+00
8617 0. 43954D+00 0. 15389D+00
8618 0. 43401D+00 0. 15856D+00
8619 0. 42845D+00 0. 16324D+00
8620 0. 42811D+00 0. 16794D+00
8621 0. 42251D+00 0. 17266D+00
8622 0. 41690D+00 0. 17739D+00
8623 0. 41125D+00 0. 18213D+00
,

8624 0. 41087D+00 0. 18689D+00

G-UTRENDS.DAT-23
NACA Designation

8705 0.59434D+00 0.97373D-01

8706 0.57908D+00 0.10125D+00
8707 0.56376D+00 0.10523D+00
8708 0.54838D+00 0.10930D+00
8709 0.53803D+00 0.11345D+00
8710 0.52256D+00 0.11768D+00
8711 0.51213D+00 0.12196D+00
8712 0.50166D+00 0.12631D+00
8713 0.49115D+00 0.13070D+00
8714 0.48573D+00 0.13514D+00
8715 0.47515D+00 0.13962D+00
8716 0.46968D+00 0.14414D+00
8717 0.45904D+00 0.14869D+00
8718 0.45352D+00 0.15327D+00
8719 0.44799D+00 0.15787D+00
8720 0.44243D+00 0.16250D+00
8721 0.43686D+00 0.16715D+00
8722 0.43127D+00 0.17182D+00
8723 0.42566D+00 0.17651D+00
8724 0.42003D+00 0.18122D+00

8805 0.64935D+00 0.94394D-01

8806 0.62909D+00 0.97916D-01
8807 0.60372D+00 0.10159D+00
8808 0.58838D+00 0.10541D+00
8809 0.56793D+00 0.10934D+00
8810 0.55250D+00 0.11338D+00
8811 0.53701D+00 0.11751D+00
8812 0.52657D+00 0.12172D+00
8813 0.51100D+00 0.12600D+00
8814 0.50048D+00 0.13035D+00
8815 0.48994D+00 0.13475D+00
8816 0.47936D+00 0.13919D+00
8817 0.47388D+00 0.14368D+00
8818 0.46325D+00 0.14821D+00
8819 0.45773D+00 0.15277D+00
8820 0.44704D+00 0.15736D+00
8821 0.44149D+00 0.16198D+00
8822 0.43591D+00 0.16662D+00
8823 0.43033D+00 0.17129D+00
8824 0.42472D+00 0.17597D+00

8905 0.69437D+00 0.91305D-01

8906 0.66407D+00 0.94503D-01
8907 0.63874D+00 0.97918D-01
8908 0.61334D+00 0.10152D+00
8909 0.59292D+00 0.10528D+00
8910 0.57246D+00 0.10918D+00
8911 0.55194D+00 0.11320D+00
8912 0.53644D+00 0.11732D+00
8913 0.52089D+00 0.12153D+00
8914 0.51040D+00 0.12582D+00
8915 0.49988D+00 0.13017D+00
8916 0.48424D+00 0.13458D+00
8917 0.47877D+00 0.13904D+00
8918 0.46817D+00 0.14355D+00
8919 0.45754D+00 0.14809D+00
8920 0.45202D+00 0.15267D+00
8921 0.44135D+00 0.15728D+00
8922 0.43580D+00 0.16192D+00
8923 0.43023D+00 0.16658D+00
8924 0.42466D+00 0.17126D+00

G-UTRENDS.DAT-24
NACA Designation

9105 0,.20472D+00 0, 11280D+00

.

9106 0 .20965D+00 0..11761D+00

9107 0,.21955D+00 0,.12246D+00
9108 0,.22446D+00 0,.12732D+00
9109 0 .22936D+00 0, 13221D+00
.

9110 0,.23426D+00 0,
.13711D+00

9111 0.23419D+00 0, 14202D+00

.

9112 0,.23908D+00 0. 14695D+00

.

9113 0,.24397D+00 0,
.15187D+00

9114 0,.24389D+00 0. 15681D+00

.

9115 0,.24876D+00 0.
.16176D+00

9116 0,.24868D+00 0, 16671D+00

.

9117 0,
.24860D+00 0. 17166D+00
.

9118 0,
.25346D+00 0. 17661D+00
.

9119 0.
.25338D+00 0. 18157D+00
.

9120 0.
.25329D+00 0.
18654D+00

9121 0,
.25814D+00 0.
.19150D+00

9122 0,
.25806D+00 0.
19647D+00

9123 0.
.25797D+00 0.
.20144D+00

9124 0,
.26281D+00 0.
.20641D+00

9205 0.
.24484D+00 0.
.11441D+00

9206 0.
.24481D+00 0.
. 11935D+00
9207 0.
.24976D+00 0.
.12430D+00

9208 0.
.25469D+00 0.
.12926D+00

9209 0.
.25465D+00 0.
.13422D+00

9210 0.
.25958D+00 0. 13919D+00
9211 0.
.25954D+00 0.
.14416D+00

9212 0.
.26445D+00 0.
.14913D+00

9213 0.
.26441D+00 0.
15411D+00

9214 0.
26436D+00 0.
.15909D+00

9215 0.
.26926D+00 0.
, 16407D+00
9216 0.
26922D+00 0. 16905D+00
9217 0.
.26917D+00 0.
, 17403D+00
9218 0.
.26912D+00 0.
.17902D+00

9219 0.
.27400D+00 0. 18400D+00
9220 0.
.27395D+00 0. 18899D+00
9221 0.
27389D+00 0.
, 19398D+00
9222 0.
27384D+00 0. 19897D+00
9223 0.
.27379D+00 0. 20396D+00
9224 0.
.27374D+00 0. 20895D+00

9305 0.
.30000D+00 0. 11501D+00
,

9306 0.
.30000D+00 0. 12001D+00
,

9307 0.
.30000D+00 0. 12501D+00
,

9308 0.
30000D+00 0. 13001D+00
9309 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.13501D+00

9310 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.14001D+00

9311 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.14502D+00

9312 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.15002D+00

9313 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.15502D+00

9314 0.
.30000D+00 0.
16002D+00

9315 0.
.30000D+00 0.
16502D+00

9316 0.
.30000D+00 0.
17002D+00

9317 0.
30000D+00 0. 17502D+00
,

9318 0.
30000D+00 0. 18003D+00
.

9319 0. 30000D+00
. 0.
.18503D+00

9320 0.
30000D+00 0. 19003D+00
.

9321 0.
.30000D+00 0. 19503D+00
.

9322 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.20003D+00

9323 0.
.30000D+00 0.
20503D+00

9324 0.
.30000D+00 0.
.21003D+00

DAT-
G-UTRENDS . 25
NACA Designation

9405 0.38973D+00 0.11427D+00

9406 0.38451D+00 0.11915D+00
9407 0.38442D+00 0.12402D+00
9408 0.37912D+00 0.12891D+00
9409 0.37901D+00 0.13380D+00
9410 0.37890D+00 0.13869D+00
9411 0.37348D+00 0.14358D+00
9412 0.37335D+00 0.14849D+00
9413 0.37321D+00 0.15339D+00
9414 0.37307D+00 0.15829D+00
9415 0.36751D+00 0.16321D+00
9416 0.36735D+00 0.16812D+00
9417 0.36718D+00 0.17304D+00
9418 0.36701D+00 0.17795D+00
9419 0.36132D+00 0.18287D+00
9420 0.36112D+00 0.18780D+00
9421 0.36093D+00 0.19272D+00
9422 0.36073D+00 0.19765D+00
9423 0.35489D+00 0.20257D+00
9424 0.35467D+00 0.20751D+00

9505 0.46951D+00 0.11248D+00

9506 0.46431D+00 0.11706D+00
9507 0.45907D+00 0.12166D+00
9508 0.45380D+00 0.12628D+00
9509 0.44849D+00 0.13093D+00
9510 0.44315D+00 0.13559D+00
9511 0.43777D+00 0.14027D+00
9512 0.43236D+00 0.14496D+00
9513 0.43214D+00 0.14967D+00

9514 0.42667D+00 0.15440D+00

9515 0.42116D+00 0.15913D+00

9516 0.42090D+00 0.16387D+00

9517 0.41534D+00 0.16863D+00
9518 0.40974D+00 0.17339D+00

9519 0.40944D+00 0.17817D+00

9520 0.40379D+00 0.18295D+00

9521 0.40348D+00 0.18775D+00

0.39776D+00 0.19254D+00
9522
0.39743D+00 0.19735D+00
9523
0.39711D+00 0.20216D+00
9524

0.53937D+00 0.11003D+00
9605
0.52911D+00 0.11424D+00
9606
0.51880D+00 0.11850D+00
9607
0.51353D+00 0.12281D+00
9608
0.50313D+00 0.12717D+00
9609
0.49780D+00 0.13156D+00
9610
0.48730D+00 0.13600D+00
9611
0.48191D+00 0.14047D+00
9612
0.47649D+00 0.14497D+00
9613
0.46586D+00 0.14949D+00
9614
0.46037D+00 0.15405D+00
9615
0.45485D+00 0.15863D+00
9616
0.44931D+00 0.16323D+00
9617
0.44374D+00 0.16785D+00
9618
0.43814D+00 0.17249D+00
9619
0.43778D+00 0.17715D+00
9620
0.43214D+00 0.18182D+00
9621
0.42648D+00 0.18651D+00
9622
0.42078D+00 0.19121D+00
9623
0.42038D+00 0.19593D+00
9624

G-UTRENDS . DAT-2 6
NACA Designation

9705 0.60434D+00 0.10717D+00

9706 0.58906D+00 0.11098D+00
9707 0.57373D+00 0.11489D+00
9708 0.56340D+00 0.11888D+00
9709 0.54796D+00 0.12295D+00
9710 0.53754D+00 0.12710D+00
9711 0.52709D+00 0.13131D+00
9712 0.51659D+00 0.13557D+00
9713 0.50606D+00 0.13989D+00
9714 0.50061D+00 0.14425D+00
9715 0.49000D+00 0.14866D+00
9716 0.47935D+00 0.15310D+00
9717 0.47382D+00 0.15758D+00
9718 0.46827D+00 0.16210D+00
9719 0.46270D+00 0.16663D+00
9720 0.45191D+00 0.17120D+00
9721 0.44629D+00 0.17579D+00
9722 0.44064D+00 0.18041D+00
9723 0.43498D+00 0.18504D+00
9724 0.43454D+00 0.18969D+00

9805 0.66437D+00 0.10407D+00

9806 0.64409D+00 0.10749D+00
9807 0.62375D+00 0. 11105D+00
9808 0.60335D+00 0.
11475D+00

9809 0.58795D+00 0.11857D+00

9810 0.57249D+00 0.12250D+00
9811 0.55699D+00 0.
.12652D+00

9812 0.54143D+00 0.
.13062D+00

9813 0.53093D+00 0.
.13479D+00

9814 0.52039D+00 0.13903D+00

9815 0.50981D+00 0.14333D+00
9816 0.49920D+00 0. 14768D+00
9817 0.48855D+00 0. 15208D+00
9818 0.47787D+00 0. 15652D+00
9819 0.47231D+00 0. 16100D+00
9820 0.46674D+00 0. 16552D+00
9821 0.45597D+00 0. 17006D+00
9822 0.45035D+00 0. 17463D+00
9823 0.44472D+00 0. 17923D+00
9824 0.43907D+00 0. 18385D+00

9905 0.71440D+00 0.10084D+00

9906 0.68409D+00 0.10388D+00
9907 0.65874D+00 0. 10714D+00
9908 0.63838D+00 0.
.11059D+00

9909 0. 61290D+00 0. 11420D+00

9910 0. 59241D+00 0.
.11794D+00

9911 0. 57693D+00 0.12182D+00

9912 0. 56141D+00 0.12580D+00
9913 0. 54584D+00 0.12988D+00
9914 0.53023D+00 0.13404D+00
9915 0.51968D+00 0.13827D+00
9916 0.50909D+00 0.14257D+00
9917 49336D+00 0.14693D+00
9918 48784D+00 0.
.15133D+00

9919 47717D+00 0.
.15578D+00

9920 46647D+00 0.
.16027D+00

9921 46089D+00 0.
.16480D+00

9922 45530D+00 0.
.16936D+00

9923 44452D+00 0.
.17395D+00

9924 43889D+00 0. 17856D+00

G-UTRENDS.DAT-27
NACA XMIN YMIN XMAX YMAX

1105 0. 33007D+00 -0. 15578D-01 0. 99001D+00 -0.88498D-03

1106 0. 32508D+00 -0. 20564D-01 0. 99001D+00 -0.11062D-02
1107 0. 32009D+00 -0. 25555D-01 0. 99002D+00 -0.13274D-02
1108 0. 32011D+00 -0. 30549D-01 0. 99002D+00 -0.15486D-02
1109 0. 31512D+00 -0. 35545D-01 0. 99002D+00 -0.17697D-02
1110 0. 31513D+00 -0. 40542D-01 0. 99002D+00 -0.19909D-02
1111 0. 31515D+00 -0. 45540D-01 0. 99003D+00 -0.22121D-02
1112 0. 31016D+00 -0. 50538D-01 0. 99003D+00 -0.24333D-02
1113 0. 31017D+00 -0. 55538D-01 0. 99003D+00 -0.26545D-02
1114 0. 31018D+00 -0. 60537D-01 0. 99003D+00 -0.28757D-02
1115 0. 31019D+00 -0. 65537D-01 0. 99004D+00 -0.30969D-02
1116 0. 31021D+00 -0. 70536D-01 0. 99004D+00 -0.33181D-02
1117 0. 31022D+00 -0. 75536D-01 0. 99004D+00 -0.35393D-02
1118 0. 31023D+00 -0..80535D-01 0.
.99004D+00 -0.37605D-02
1119 0. 30524D+00 -0. 85536D-01 0. 99005D+00 -0.39817D-02

1120 0. 30525D+00 -0..90537D-01 0.

.99005D+00 -0.42029D-02
1121 0.
.30527D+00 -0..95538D-01 0.
.99005D+00 -0.44241D-02

1122 0.
.30528D+00 -0., 10054D+00 0.
.99005D+00 -0.46453D-02

1123 0.
.30529D+00 -0., 10554D+00 0.
.99006D+00 -0.48664D-02

1124 0.
.30530D+00 -0., 11054D+00 0.
.99006D+00 -0.50876D-02

1205 0.
.32005D+00 -0..15195D-01 0.
.99001D+00 -0.85751D-03

1206 0.
31505D+00 -0..20190D-01 0.
.99002D+00 -0.10787D-02

1207 0.
.31506D+00 -0.25187D-01 0.
.99002D+00 -0.12999D-02

1208 0.
.31007D+00 -0..30185D-01 0.
.99002D+00 -0.15211D-02

1209 0.
.31008D+00 -0.35185D-01 0.
.99002D+00 -0.17423D-02

1210 0.
.31009D+00 -0..40184D-01 0.
.99003D+00 -0.19635D-02

1211 0.
.31009D+00 -0.45184D-01 0.
.99003D+00 -0.21846D-02

1212 0.
.30510D+00 -0..50183D-01 0.
.99003D+00 -0.24058D-02

1213 0.
.30511D+00 -0.. 55184D-01 0.
.99004D+00 -0.26270D-02

1214 0.
.30511D+00 -0.. 60185D-01 0.
.99004D+00 -0.28482D-02

1215 0.
.30512D+00 -0..65186D-01 0.
.99004D+00 -0.30694D-02

1216 0.
.30513D+00 -0..70187D-01 0.
.99004D+00 -0.32906D-02

1217 0.
.30514D+00 -0..75188D-01 0.
.99005D+00 -0.35118D-02

1218 0.
.30515D+00 -0..80189D-01 0. 99005D+00
, -0.37330D-02

1219 0.
.30516D+00 -0..85190D-01 0.
99005D+00 -0.39542D-02

1220 0.
.30516D+00 -0..90191D-01 0.
99005D+00 -0.41753D-02

1221 0.
.30517D+00 -0..95192D-01 0.
99006D+00 -0.43965D-02

1222 0.
.30518D+00 -0..10019D+00 0.
.99006D+00 -0.46177D-02

1223 0.
.30519D+00 -0.. 10519D+00 0.
.99006D+00 -0.48389D-02

1224 0.
.30520D+00 -0..11019D+00 0.
.99007D+00 -0.50601D-02

1305 0.
.23038D+00 -0.. 15037D-01 0.
.99002D+00 -0.82225D-03

1306 0.
.29503D+00 -0..20009D-01 0.
.99002D+00 -0.10434D-02

1307 0.
.30000D+00 -0..25010D-01 0.
.99002D+00 -0.12646D-02

1308 0,
.30000D+00 -0..30012D-01 0.
.99002D+00 -0.14858D-02

1309 0.
.30000D+00 -0..35013D-01 0.
.99003D+00 -0.17070D-02

1310 0.
.30000D+00 -0..40014D-01 0,
.99003D+00 -0.19282D-02

1311 0. 30000D+00
. -0..45016D-01 0,
.99003D+00 -0.21494D-02

1312 0.
.30000D+00 -0..50017D-01 0.
.99004D+00 -0.23705D-02

1313 0.
.30000D+00 -0,.55019D-01 0.
.99004D+00 -0.25917D-02

1314 0.
.30000D+00 -0..60020D-01 0,
.99004D+00 -0.28129D-02

1315 0.
.30000D+00 -0..65022D-01 0,
.99005D+00 -0.30341D-02

1316 0,
.30000D+00 -0..70023D-01 0.
.99005D+00 -0.32553D-02

1317 0.
.30000D+00 -0,.75024D-01 0,
.99005D+00 -0.34765D-02

1318 0.
.30000D+00 -0,.80026D-01 0,
.99006D+00 -0.36976D-02

1319 0.
.30000D+00 -0..85027D-01 0,
.99006D+00 -0.39188D-02

1320 0.
.30000D+00 -0..90029D-01 0,
.99006D+00 -0.41400D-02

1321 0. 30000D+00
. -0..95030D-01 0.
.99007D+00 -0.43612D-02

1322 0.
.30000D+00 -0.. 10003D+00 0,
.99007D+00 -0.45824D-02

1323 0.
.30000D+00 -0..10503D+00 0,
.99007D+00 -0.48036D-02

1324 0,
.30000D+00 -0..11003D+00 0,
.99007D+00 -0.50247D-02

G-LTRENDS.DAT-1
NACA XMIN YMIN XMAX YMAX

1405 0. 19561D+00 -0. 16401D-01 0.99002D+00 -0..77533D-03

1406 0. 21567D+00 -0. 21211D-01 0.99002D+00 -0.99650D-03
1407 0. 23073D+00 26093D-01 0..99003D+00
-0. -0., 12177D-02
1408 0. 24577D+00 -0. 31014D-01 0..99003D+00 -0., 14389D-02
1409 0. 25084D+00 -0.35958D-01 0.
99003D+00 -0., 16600D-02
1410 0. 25590D+00 -0.40916D-01 0.
.99004D+00 -0.18812D-02
1411 0.
.26096D+00 -0.45884D-01 0..99004D+00 -0.21024D-02
1412 0.
26601D+00 -0.50859D-01 0.
.99004D+00 -0.23236D-02
1413 0. 27105D+00
. -0.55839D-01 0.
.99005D+00 -0..25447D-02
1414 0.27113D+00 -0..60822D-01 0..99005D+00 -0.27659D-02
1415 0.
.27617D+00 -0..65808D-01 0.
99005D+00 -0..29871D-02
1416 0.
27625D+00 -0..70797D-01 0.
.99006D+00 -0..32083D-02
1417 0.
.27633D+00 -0..75786D-01 0.
.99006D+00 -0..34294D-02
1418 0.
.28135D+00 -0..80779D-01 0.
.99007D+00 -0..36506D-02
1419 0.
.28142D+00 -0..85772D-01 0.
.99007D+00 -0.38718D-02
1420 0.
.28150D+00 -0..90765D-01 0.
.99007D+00 -0..40930D-02
1421 0.
.28157D+00 -0..95758D-01 0.
99008D+00 -0.43141D-02

1422 0.
.28658D+00 -0.. 10075D+00 0.
.99008D+00 -0. 45353D-02
1423 0.
.28665D+00 -0..10575D+00 0.
99008D+00 -0..47565D-02

1424 0.
.28672D+00 -0.. 11075D+00 0.
.99009D+00 -0. 49777D-02

1505 0.
.20057D+00 -0.. 17500D-01 0.
.99002D+00 -0. 70982D-03
1506 0.
.22065D+00 -0..22322D-01 0.
.99003D+00 -0. 93098D-03
1507 0.
.23074D+00 -0..27202D-01 0.
99003D+00 -0., 11521D-02
1508 0.
.24082D+00 -0..32116D-01 0.
.99003D+00 -0., 13733D-02
1509 0.
.24591D+00 -0..37051D-01 0.
.99004D+00 -0. 15945D-02
1510 0.
.25597D+00 -0..42001D-01 0.
.99004D+00 -0. 18156D-02
1511 0.
.25607D+00 -0..46961D-01 0.
.99005D+00 -0. 20368D-02
1512 0.
.26114D+00 -0..51930D-01 0.
.99005D+00 -0. 22580D-02
1513 0.
.26622D+00 -0..56904D-01 0.
99006D+00 -0. 24791D-02
1514 0.
.26631D+00 -0..61880D-01 0.
99006D+00 -0. 27003D-02
1515 0.
.27138D+00 -0.66862D-01 0.
99007D+00 -0. 29215D-02
1516 0.
.27147D+00 -0..71845D-01 0.
.99007D+00 -0. 31426D-02
1517 0.
.27653D+00 -0..76831D-01 0.
.99007D+00 -0. 33638D-02
1518 0.
.27662D+00 -0.81820D-01 0.
.99008D+00 -0..35849D-02

1519 0.
.27671D+00 -0..86808D-01 0.
99008D+00 -0.38061D-02

1520 0.
.28176D+00 -0.91797D-01 0.
.99009D+00 -0. 40273D-02
1521 0.
.28185D+00 -0..96790D-01 0.
99009D+00 -0..42484D-02

1522 0.
.28193D+00 -0.. 10178D+00 0.
.99010D+00 -0..44696D-02

1523 0.
.28202D+00 -0.. 10678D+00 0.
.99010D+00 -0.46908D-02

1524 0.
.28211D+00 -0.. 11177D+00 0.
99010D+00 -0.49119D-02

1605 0.
.20553D+00 -0.. 18351D-01 0.
.99003D+00 -0..61195D-03

1606 0.
.22561D+00 -0..23198D-01 0.
.99003D+00 -0.83309D-03

1607 0.
.23570D+00 -0..28092D-01 0.
.99004D+00 -0.10542D-02

1608 0.
.24079D+00 -0..33013D-01 0.
.99004D+00 -0..12754D-02

1609 0.
.25087D+00 -0..37954D-01 0.
.99005D+00 -0..14965D-02

1610 0.
.25595D+00 -0..42907D-01 0.
99005D+00 -0.17177D-02

1611 0.
.26103D+00 -0.47868D-01 0.
.99006D+00 -0..19388D-02

1612 0.
26113D+00 -0..52837D-01 0.
.99006D+00 -0..21599D-02

1613 0. 26620D+00
, -0., 57812D-01 0.
.99007D+00 -0..23811D-02

1614 0.
.26630D+00 -0.62789D-01 0.
.99008D+00 -0..26022D-02

1615 0.
.27137D+00 -0.67771D-01 0.
.99008D+00 -0..28234D-02

1616 0. 27146D+00 -0.72754D-01 0.

.99009D+00 -0..30445D-02

1617 0. 27653D+00 -0..77740D-01 0.

.99009D+00 -0..32656D-02

1618 0. 27662D+00 -0..82729D-01 0.

.99010D+00 -0..34868D-02

1619 0.
.27671D+00 -0.87717D-01 0.
.99010D+00 -0..37079D-02

1620 0.
.27680D+00 -0..92706D-01 0.
.99011D+00 -0..39291D-02

1621 0.
.28186D+00 -0..97698D-01 0.
.99011D+00 -0..41502D-02

1622 0.
.28195D+00 -0., 10269D+00 0.
.99012D+00 -0..43713D-02

1623 0.
.28204D+00 -0.10768D+00 0.
.99012D+00 -0,.45925D-02

1624 0.
.28213D+00 -0..11268D+00 0.
.99013D+00 -0,.48136D-02

G-LTRENDS.DAT-2
NACA XMIN YMIN XMAX YMAX

1705 0. 21548D+00 -0. 19029D-01 0.94510D+00 -0. 30305D-03

1706 0. 23056D+00 23898D-01 0.99004D+00
-0. -0. 67099D-03
1707 0. 24065D+00 -0. 28805D-01 0.99005D+00 -0. 89208D-03
1708 0. 24573D+00 -0. 33738D-01 0.99006D+00 -0. 11132D-02
1709 0. 25082D+00 -0. 38684D-01 0.99006D+00 -0. 13343D-02
1710 0. 25590D+00 -0. 43643D-01 0.99007D+00 -0. 15554D-02
1711 0. 26098D+00 -0. 48609D-01 0.99008D+00 -0. 17764D-02
1712 0. 26606D+00 -0. 53581D-01 0.99009D+00 -0. 19975D-02
1713 0. 26615D+00 -0. .
58558D-01 0.99009D+00 -0. 22186D-02
1714 0. 27122D+00 -0. 63538D-01 0.99010D+00 -0. 24397D-02
1715 0. 27131D+00 -0. 68521D-01 0.99011D+00 -0. 26608D-02
1716 0. 27638D+00 -0. 73505D-01 0.99011D+00 -0. 28819D-02
1717 0. 27647D+00 -0..78493D-01 0.99012D+00 -0. 31030D-02
1718 0. 27656D+00 -0.83482D-01 0.99013D+00 -0. 33241D-02
1719 0. .27664D+00 -0..88471D-01 0.99014D+00 -0. 35452D-02
1720 0. .28171D+00 -0.93462D-01 0.99014D+00 -0. 37663D-02
1721 0. .28180D+00 -0..98455D-01 0.99015D+00 -0. 39874D-02
1722 0. 28188D+00 -0.. 10345D+00 0.99016D+00 -0. 42085D-02
1723 0. .28197D+00 -0..10844D+00 0.99016D+00 -0. 44295D-02
1724 0. .28205D+00 -0..11343D+00 0.99017D+00 -0. 46506D-02

1805 0. .22044D+00 -0..19580D-01 0.90515D+00 0. 14737D-02

,

1806 0. 23552D+00 -0..24467D-01 0.93017D+00 0. 44005D-03

1807 0. 24060D+00 -0.29388D-01 0.95517D+00 -0. 32164D-03
1808 0. .25068D+00 -0..34329D-01 0.98510D+00 -0. 78407D-03
1809 0. .25576D+00 -0..39283D-01 0.99009D+00 -0.,10136D-02

1810 0. .26084D+00 -0..44247D-01 0.99010D+00 -0. 12346D-02

1811 0. .26592D+00 -0,.49216D-01 0.99012D+00 -0. 14555D-02
1812 0. .26600D+00 -0..54193D-01 0.99013D+00 -0., 16765D-02
1813 0. .27107D+00 -0..59171D-01 0.99014D+00 -0., 18974D-02
1814 0. .27116D+00 -0..64155D-01 0.99015D+00 -0. 21184D-02
1815 0. .27124D+00 -0..69138D-01 0.99016D+00 -0. 23394D-02
1816 0. .27631D+00 -0..74126D-01 0.99017D+00 -0. 25603D-02
1817 0. .27639D+00 -0..79115D-01 0.99018D+00 -0.27813D-02

1818 0. .27647D+00 -0..84104D-01 0.99019D+00 -0.30022D-02

1819 0, .28154D+00 -0..89095D-01 0.99020D+00 -0..32232D-02

1820 0. .28162D+00 -0,.94088D-01 0.99021D+00 -0..34441D-02

1821 0. .28170D+00 -0,.99081D-01 0.99022D+00 -0.36651D-02

1822 0, .28179D+00 -0.. 10407D+00 0.99023D+00 -0..38861D-02

1823 0, .28187D+00 -0..10907D+00 0.99024D+00 -0..41070D-02

1824 0. .28693D+00 -0..11406D+00 0.99025D+00 -0..43280D-02

1905 0. .22541D+00 -0..20037D-01 0.92512D+00 0, .46604D-02

1906 0. .23548D+00 -0..24940D-01 0.93016D+00 0. .37646D-02

1907 0. .24556D+00 -0..29872D-01 0.94022D+00 0. .29337D-02

1908 0. .25064D+00 -0..34819D-01 0.94526D+00 0. .21650D-02

1909 0. .25571D+00 -0..39779D-01 0.95030D+00 0. .14584D-02

1910 0, .26079D+00 -0,.44748D-01 0.95534D+00 0. .81484D-03

1911 0. .26586D+00 -0,.49723D-01 0.96037D+00 0. .23535D-03

1912 0. .27093D+00 -0..54700D-01 0.96539D+00 -0..27919D-03

1913 0. .27101D+00 -0,. 59683D-01 0.97538D+00 -0,.71795D-03

1914 0. .27109D+00 -0,.64667D-01 0.98038D+00 -0,. 10889D-02

1915 0. .27615D+00 -0,.69655D-01 0.98535D+00 -0,.13916D-02

1916 0. .27623D+00 -0,. 74643D-01 0.99032D+00 -0,.16250D-02

1917 0, .27631D+00 -0..79632D-01 0.99034D+00 -0 .18454D-02

1918 0, .28138D+00 -0,.84624D-01 0.99036D+00 -0 .20657D-02

1919 0. .28145D+00 -0..89617D-01 0.99038D+00 -0 .22860D-02

1920 0, .28153D+00 -0..94610D-01 0.99040D+00 -0 .25063D-02

1921 0. .28161D+00 -0,.99604D-01 0.99042D+00 -0 .27266D-02

1922 0. .28168D+00 -0,. 10460D+00 0.99044D+00 -0 29469D-02

1923 0, .28675D+00 -0,. 10959D+00 0.99046D+00 -0 .31673D-02

1924 0 .28682D+00 -0 . 11459D+00 0.99048D+00 -0 .33876D-02

G-LTRENDS.DAT-3
NACA XMIN YMIN XMAX YMAX

2105 0.12404D-01 -0.28792D-02 0.99002D+00 -0.66379D-03

2106 0.18322D-01 -0.42191D-02 0.99003D+00 -0.88494D-03

2107 0.24195D-01 -0.59105D-02 0.99003D+00 -0.11061D-02

2108 0.34524D+00 -0.21204D-01 0.99004D+00 -0.13272D-02

2109 0.33526D+00 -0.26176D-01 0.99004D+00 -0.15484D-02

2110 0.33028D+00 -0.31155D-01 0.99005D+00 -0.17696D-02

2111 0.33031D+00 -0.36140D-01 0.99005D+00 -0.19907D-02

2112 0.32533D+00 -0.41128D-01 0.99006D+00 -0.22119D-02

2113 0.32536D+00 -0.46118D-01 0.99006D+00 -0.24330D-02

2114 0.32038D+00 -0.51110D-01 0.99007D+00 -0.26542D-02

2115 0.32041D+00 -0.56104D-01 0.99007D+00 -0.28753D-02

2116 0.32043D+00 -0.61098D-01 0.99008D+00 -0.30965D-02

2117 0.31545D+00 -0.66092D-01 0.99008D+00 -0.33176D-02

2118 0.31548D+00 -0.71090D-01 0.99009D+00 -0.35388D-02

2119 0.31550D+00 -0.76087D-01 0.99009D+00 -0.37599D-02

2120 0.31553D+00 -0.81084D-01 0.99010D+00 -0.39811D-02

2121 0.31556D+00 -0.86081D-01 0.99010D+00 -0.42022D-02

2122 0.31558D+00 -0.91078D-01 0.99011D+00 -0.44234D-02

2123 0.31060D+00 -0.96076D-01 0.99011D+00 -0.46445D-02

2124 0.31062D+00 -0.10108D+00 0.99012D+00 -0.48657D-02

2205 0.37064D-01 -0.61224D-02 0.99003D+00 -0.60882D-03

2206 0.52637D-01 -0.88268D-02 0.99003D+00 -0.82996D-03

2207 0.33515D+00 -0.15424D-01 0.99004D+00 -0.10511D-02

2208 0.33016D+00 -0.20408D-01 0.99004D+00 -0.12722D-02

2209 0.32518D+00 -0.25397D-01 0.99005D+00 -0.14934D-02

2210 0.32019D+00 -0.30390D-01 0.99005D+00 -0.17145D-02

2211 0.32021D+00 -0.35384D-01 0.99006D+00 -0.19357D-02

2212 0.31522D+00 -0.40379D-01 0.99007D+00 -0.21568D-02

2213 0.31523D+00 -0.45376D-01 0.99007D+00 -0.23779D-02

2214 0.31525D+00 -0.50374D-01 0.99008D+00 -0.25991D-02

2215 0.31527D+00 -0.55371D-01 0.99008D+00 -0.28202D-02

2216 0.31027D+00 -0.60370D-01 0.99009D+00 -0.30413D-02

2217 0.31029D+00 -0.65369D-01 0.99009D+00 -0.32625D-02

2218 0.31031D+00 -0.70369D-01 0.99010D+00 -0.34836D-02

2219 0.31033D+00 -0.75368D-01 0.99010D+00 -0.37048D-02

2220 0.31034D+00 -0.80368D-01 0.99011D+00 -0.39259D-02

2221 0.31036D+00 -0.85367D-01 0.99011D+00 -0.41470D-02

2222 0.31038D+00 -0.90367D-01 0.99012D+00 -0.43682D-02

2223 0.31040D+00 -0.95366D-01 0.99013D+00 -0.45893D-02

2224 0.30539D+00 -0.10037D+00 0.99013D+00 -0.48105D-02

2305 0.66716D-01 -0.87068D-02 0.99003D+00 -0.53824D-03

0.92093D-01 0.99004D+00 -0.75936D-03

2306 -0.12227D-01

0.12729D+00 0.99004D+00 -0.98048D-03

2307 -0.16207D-01

0.16225D+00 0.99005D+00 -0.12016D-02

2308 -0.20564D-01

0.19700D+00 0.99006D+00 -0.14227D-02

2309 -0.25212D-01

0.23642D+00 0.99006D+00 -0.16438D-02

2310 -0.30059D-01

0.27561D+00 0.99007D+00 -0.18650D-02

2311 -0.35019D-01

0.29513D+00 0.99007D+00 -0.20861D-02

2312 -0.40017D-01

0.30000D+00 0.99008D+00 -0.23072D-02

2313 -0.45019D-01

0.30000D+00 0.99009D+00 -0.25283D-02

2314 -0.50020D-01

0.30000D+00 0.99009D+00 -0.27494D-02

2315 -0.55022D-01

0.30000D+00 0.99010D+00 -0.29705D-02

2316 -0.60023D-01

0.30000D+00 0.99011D+00 -0.31917D-02

2317 -0.65024D-01

0.30000D+00 0.99011D+00 -0.34128D-02

2318 -0.70026D-01

0.30000D+00 0.99012D+00 -0.36339D-02

2319 -0.75027D-01

0.30000D+00 0.99012D+00 -0.38550D-02

2320 -0.80029D-01

0.30000D+00 0.99013D+00 -0.40761D-02

2321 -0.85030D-01

0.30000D+00 -0.90032D-01 0.99014D+00 -0.42973D-02

2322
0.30000D+00 -0.95033D-01 0.99014D+00 -0.45184D-02
2323
0.30000D+00 -0.10003D+00 0.99015D+00 -0.47395D-02
2324

G-LTRENDS.DAT-4
NACA XMIN YMIN XMAX YMAX

2405 0. 91450D-01 10727D-01 0..83023D+00

-0. 0. 21040D-03
2406 0. 12174D+00 0..99004D+00
-0..14680D-01 -0. 66541D-03
2407 0. 14696D+00 -0.18941D-01 0..99005D+00 -0. 88650D-03
.

2408 0. 16715D+00 -0..23417D-01 0..99006D+00 -0. 11076D-02

.

2409 0. 18231D+00
.
-0..28036D-01 0..99007D+00 -0. 13287D-02
2410 0. 19743D+00
.
-0..32755D-01 0..99007D+00 -0.15498D-02
2411 0. 21252D+00 -0..37542D-01 0..99008D+00 -0..17708D-02
2412 0..22262D+00 -0..42377D-01 0..99009D+00 -0. 19919D-02
2413 0.
.22777D+00 -0.47247D-01 0..99009D+00 -0.22130D-02
2414 0.
.23784D+00 -0..52141D-01 0.
.99010D+00 -0..24341D-02
2415 0.
24295D+00 -0.. 57055D-01 0.
.99011D+00 -0. 26552D-02
2416 0..24806D+00 -0..61983D-01 0.
.99012D+00 -0. 28763D-02
2417 0.
.25315D+00 -0..66921D-01 0.
.99012D+00 -0..30974D-02
2418 0.
.25334D+00 -0..71869D-01 0.
.99013D+00 -0. 33185D-02
2419 0.
.25841D+00 -0..76825D-01 0.
.99014D+00 -0. 35395D-02
2420 0.
.26348D+00 -0..81784D-01 0.
.99014D+00 -0. 37606D-02
2421 0.
.26365D+00 -0..86751D-01 0.
.99015D+00 -0. 39817D-02
2422 0.
.26869D+00 -0..91718D-01 0.
.99016D+00 -0. 42028D-02
2423 0. 26886D+00
, -0..96693D-01 0.
.99017D+00 -0..44239D-02

2424 0.
.26903D+00 -0..10167D+00 0.
.99017D+00 -0..46450D-02

2505 0.
.11626D+00 -0..12309D-01 0.
78027D+00 0. .18894D-02

2506 0.
.13651D+00 -0..16515D-01 0.
.88026D+00 -0..17467D-04

2507 0.
.16172D+00 -0..20945D-01 0.
.99006D+00 -0..75525D-03

2508 0.
.17693D+00 -0..25525D-01 0.
.99007D+00 -0..97629D-03

2509 0. 19211D+00
. -0..30206D-01 0.
.99008D+00 -0., 11973D-02
2510 0.
.20229D+00 -0..34958D-01 0.
.99009D+00 -0., 14184D-02
2511 0.
.21246D+00 -0..39761D-01 0.
99010D+00 -0..16394D-02

2512 0.
.22261D+00 -0..44600D-01 0.
.99010D+00 -0. 18604D-02
2513 0.
.22779D+00 -0..49468D-01 0.
.99011D+00 -0..20815D-02

2514 0.
.23296D+00 -0.. 54357D-01 0.
.99012D+00 -0. 23025D-02
2515 0.
.23812D+00 -0..59262D-01 0.
99013D+00 -0..25235D-02

2516 0,
.24328D+00 -0..64181D-01 0.
.99014D+00 -0..27446D-02

2517 0.
.24842D+00 -0..69111D-01 0.
.99015D+00 -0..29656D-02

2518 0.
.25356D+00 -0..74047D-01 0.
.99016D+00 -0..31867D-02

2519 0.
.25376D+00 -0..78995D-01 0.
.99016D+00 -0..34077D-02

2520 0,
.25889D+00 -0..83945D-01 0.
.99017D+00 -0..36287D-02

2521 0,
.25908D+00 -0..88902D-01 0.
.99018D+00 -0..38498D-02

2522 0,
.26420D+00 -0..93862D-01 0.
.99019D+00 -0..40708D-02

2523 0,
.26439D+00 -0..98828D-01 0.
.99020D+00 -0..42918D-02

2524 0.
.26458D+00 -0..10379D+00 0.
.99021D+00 -0..45129D-02

2605 0.
.13111D+00 -0..13574D-01 0.
.78027D+00 0. 41114D-02

2606 0. 15133D+00
. -0.. 17942D-01 0.
.83033D+00 0. .19681D-02

2607 0. 17154D+00
. -0..22486D-01 0.
.88534D+00 0. .32783D-03

2608 0. 18673D+00
. -0..27144D-01 0.
.95522D+00 -0..68385D-03

2609 0.
.20191D+00 -0..31878D-01 0.
.99010D+00 -0.10010D-02

2610 0.
.21209D+00 -0..36668D-01 0.
.99011D+00 -0.. 12219D-02
2611 0.
.21728D+00 -0.41499D-01 0.
.99012D+00 -0.. 14429D-02
2612 0.
22744D+00 -0..46358D-01 0.
.99013D+00 -0..16638D-02

2613 0.
.23262D+00 -0..51241D-01 0,
.99014D+00 -0..18848D-02

2614 0.
23779D+00 -0..56141D-01 0.
.99015D+00 -0..21057D-02

2615 0.
.24295D+00 -0.61055D-01 0,
.99016D+00 -0,.23267D-02

2616 0.
.24812D+00 -0.65979D-01 0,
.99017D+00 -0,.25476D-02

2617 0.
.24831D+00 -0.70915D-01 0,
.99018D+00 -0,.27685D-02

2618 0.
.25346D+00 -0..75857D-01 0,
.99019D+00 -0,.29895D-02

2619 0.
.25366D+00 -0..80804D-01 0.
.99020D+00 -0..32104D-02

2620 0.
.25880D+00 -0..85759D-01 0.
.99022D+00 -0,.34314D-02

2621 0.
.25899D+00 -0.90716D-01 0.
.99023D+00 -0,.36523D-02

2622 0.
.26413D+00 -0..95679D-01 0,
.99024D+00 -0 .38733D-02

2623 0.
.26432D+00 -0..10064D+00 0.
.99025D+00 -0 .40942D-02

2624 0.
.26450D+00 -0.. 10561D+00 0.
.99026D+00 -0 .43151D-02

G-LTRENDS.DAT-5
NACA XMIN YMIN XMAX YMAX

2705 0. 14600D+00
.
14604D-01 0..80525D+00
-0.. 0. .68547D-02

2706 0. 16620D+00 19089D-01 0..83033D+00

,
-0., 0. .48251D-02

2707 0. 18139D+00
.
-0.23713D-01 0..85540D+00 0. .30384D-02

2708 0. 19657D+00
.
-0.28429D-01 0..88545D+00 0. 15178D-02
.

2709 0..20675D+00 -0..33207D-01 0..91545D+00 0. .29377D-03

2710 0.
.21692D+00 -0.38029D-01 0..94540D+00 -0..59804D-03
2711 0..22210D+00 -0..42884D-01 0..98519D+00 -0..11104D-02
2712 0.
.23225D+00 -0..47763D-01 0..99017D+00 -0..13379D-02
2713 0.
.23742D+00 -0..52662D-01 0..99018D+00 -0.15586D-02
2714 0.
.24259D+00 -0.. 57575D-01 0..99020D+00 -0.17794D-02
2715 0.
.24277D+00 -0,.62499D-01 0..99021D+00 -0..20001D-02
2716 0.
.24793D+00 -0..67434D-01 0..99023D+00 -0..22209D-02
2717 0..25309D+00 -0..72376D-01 0.
.99024D+00 -0.24416D-02
2718 0.
.25327D+00 -0..77324D-01 0.
.99026D+00 -0.26624D-02
2719 0.
.25842D+00 -0..82279D-01 0..99027D+00 -0..28831D-02
2720 0.
.25860D+00 -0,.87237D-01 0.
.99028D+00 -0.31039D-02
2721 0.
.26375D+00 -0..92199D-01 0.
.99030D+00 -0.33246D-02
2722 0.
.26392D+00 -0..97166D-01 0.
.99031D+00 -0.35453D-02

2723 0.
.26410D+00 -0..10213D+00 0.
.99033D+00 -0..37661D-02

2724 0.
.26924D+00 -0..10711D+00 0.
.99034D+00 -0..39868D-02

2805 0. 15591D+00
. -0..15461D-01 0.
.85021D+00 0. .10200D-01

2806 0.
.17609D+00 -0..20030D-01 0.
.86029D+00 0. .85324D-02

2807 0. 19126D+00
. -0..24714D-01 0.
.87037D+00 0. 69700D-02

2808 0.
.20143D+00 -0..29473D-01 0.
.88045D+00 0. .55165D-02

2809 0.
.21160D+00 -0..34286D-01 0.
.89554D+00 0. .41768D-02

2810 0.
.22176D+00 -0..39136D-01 0.
90561D+00 0. .29594D-02

2811 0.
.22693D+00 -0..44011D-01 0.
.91566D+00 0. .18629D-02

2812 0.
.23708D+00 -0..48907D-01 0.
.93069D+00 0. 89694D-03
2813 0,
.24224D+00 -0..53820D-01 0.
.94071D+00 0. 64987D-04

2814 0.
.24241D+00 -0..58744D-01 0.
.95567D+00 -0.62393D-03

2815 0.
.24757D+00 -0..63680D-01 0.
.97057D+00 -0..11667D-02

2816 0.
.25272D+00 -0..68623D-01 0.
98541D+00 -0..15539D-02

2817 0.
.25289D+00 -0..73571D-01 0.
.99036D+00 -0.17936D-02

2818 0.
.25804D+00 -0..78528D-01 0.
.99038D+00 -0.20139D-02

2819 0.
.25821D+00 -0..83486D-01 0.
.99040D+00 -0..22341D-02

2820 0.
.26335D+00 -0..88451D-01 0.
.99042D+00 -0..24543D-02

2821 0.
.26352D+00 -0..93418D-01 0.
99044D+00 -0..26745D-02

2822 0.
.26866D+00 -0..98386D-01 0.
99046D+00 -0..28947D-02

2823 0.
.26883D+00 -0.. 10336D+00 0.
99048D+00 -0.31149D-02

2824 0.
.26899D+00 -0.. 10834D+00 0.
.99050D+00 -0..33351D-02

2905 0. 16583D+00
. -0.. 16184D-01 0.
91516D+00 0. .14305D-01

2906 0. 18600D+00
. -0.20817D-01 0.
.91519D+00 0. .13256D-01

2907 0.
20116D+00 -0..25548D-01 0.
.92028D+00 0. .12230D-01

2908 0.
.21131D+00 -0..30344D-01 0.
92032D+00 0. .11235D-01

2909 0.
22147D+00 -0..35182D-01 0.
92542D+00 0. .10272D-01

2910 0.
.22663D+00 -0.40053D-01 0.
.92547D+00 0. .93297D-02

2911 0.
.23178D+00 -0..44945D-01 0.
.93059D+00 0. .84317D-02

2912 0.
.23694D+00 -0..49856D-01 0.
.93570D+00 0. .75457D-02

2913 0.
.24209D+00 -0., 54780D-01 0.
.93576D+00 0. .67120D-02

2914 0.
.24724D+00 -0., 59716D-01 0.
.94087D+00 0. 58935D-02
.

2915 0.
.25238D+00 -0..64659D-01 0.
.94093D+00 0. .51145D-02

2916 0.
.25254D+00 -0..69608D-01 0.
.94604D+00 0. .43650D-02

2917 0.
.25768D+00 -0..74566D-01 0.
.94611D+00 0. .36409D-02

2918 0.
.25784D+00 -0.79524D-01 0.
.95120D+00 0. .29617D-02

2919 0.
.26298D+00 -0..84491D-01 0.
.95628D+00 0. .22983D-02

2920 0.
.26314D+00 -0.89459D-01 0.
.95635D+00 0, .16850D-02

2921 0.
.26828D+00 -0..94430D-01 0.
.96140D+00 0, .10939D-02

2922 0.
26843D+00 -0..99405D-01 0.
.96147D+00 0, .53651D-03

2923 0.
26859D+00 -0.10438D+00 0.
.96650D+00 0 .18684D-04

2924 0.
.27372D+00 -0.. 10936D+00 0.
.97150D+00 -0 .48127D-03

G-LTRENDS.DAT-6
NACA XMIN YMIN XMAX YMAX

3105 0. 75200D-02 14960D-02 0.86647D-01

-0. 0.11029D-01
3106 0. 80240D-02 -0. 23803D-02 0.99004D+00 -0.66355D-03
3107 0. 85280D-02 -0. 32645D-02 0.99005D+00 -0.88464D-03
3108 0. 15397D-01 -0. 42940D-02 0.99006D+00 -0.11057D-02
3109 0. 16071D-01 -0. 55433D-02 0.99007D+00 -0.13268D-02
3110 0. 22813D-01 -0. 69949D-02 0.99007D+00 -0.15479D-02
3111 0. 34836D-01 -0. 87322D-02 0.99008D+00 -0.17690D-02
3112 0. 34554D+00 -0. 31805D-01 0.99009D+00 -0.19901D-02
3113 0. 34057D+00 -0. 36776D-01 0.99009D+00 -0.22112D-02
3114 0. 33561D+00 -0. 41752D-01 0.99010D+00 -0.24322D-02
3115 0. 33064D+00 -0. 46732D-01 0.99011D+00 -0.26533D-02
3116 0. 33068D+00 -0. 51716D-01 0.99012D+00 -0.28744D-02
3117 0.
33072D+00 -0. 56701D-01 0.99012D+00 -0.30955D-02
3118 0.
.32575D+00 -0..61690D-01 0.99013D+00 -0.33166D-02
3119 0.
32579D+00 -0.. 66680D-01 0.99014D+00 -0.35377D-02
3120 0.
.32583D+00 -0.71670D-01 0.99015D+00 -0.37588D-02
3121 0.
.32085D+00 -0..76663D-01 0.99015D+00 -0.39798D-02

3122 0.
.32090D+00 -0..81657D-01 0.99016D+00 -0.42009D-02

3123 0.
32094D+00 -0..86651D-01 0.99017D+00 -0.44220D-02

3124 0.
32098D+00 -0.91644D-01 0.99017D+00 -0.46431D-02

3205 0. 17299D-01
. -0.39543D-02 0.18070D+00 0.63496D-02
3206 0.
.23076D-01 -0..56910D-02 0.77039D+00 0.28459D-04
3207 0.
.34094D-01 -0.77288D-02 0.99006D+00 -0.80207D-03

3208 0.
.45022D-01 -0..10124D-01 0.99007D+00 -0.10231D-02

3209 0.
.60899D-01 -0.. 12892D-01 0.99007D+00 -0.12442D-02

3210 0.
.86359D-01 -0..16126D-01 0.99008D+00 -0.14652D-02

3211 0.
.33033D+00 -0.25626D-01 0.99009D+00 -0.16863D-02

3212 0.
.33036D+00 -0..30611D-01 0.99010D+00 -0.19073D-02

3213 0.
.32538D+00 -0..35600D-01 0.99011D+00 -0.21284D-02

3214 0.
.32541D+00 -0..40590D-01 0.99011D+00 -0.23495D-02

3215 0.
.32042D+00 -0..45584D-01 0.99012D+00 -0.25705D-02

3216 0.
.32045D+00 -0..50578D-01 0.99013D+00 -0.27916D-02

3217 0.
.32048D+00 -0..55571D-01 0.99014D+00 -0.30126D-02

3218 0.
.31548D+00 -0..60568D-01 0.99015D+00 -0.32337D-02

3219 0.
.31551D+00 -0..65565D-01 0.99016D+00 -0.34547D-02

3220 0.
.31554D+00 -0.. 70562D-01 0.99016D+00 -0.36758D-02

3221 0.
.31557D+00 -0..75560D-01 0.99017D+00 -0.38968D-02

3222 0.
.31559D+00 -0..80557D-01 0.99018D+00 -0.41179D-02

3223 0.
.31059D+00 -0..85555D-01 0.99019D+00 -0.43389D-02

4224 0,
.31062D+00 -0..90554D-01 0.99020D+00 -0.45600D-02

3305 0.
.32096D-01 -0..59468D-02 0.55032D+00 0.55408D-02
3306 0.
.42756D-01 -0..84348D-02 0.69545D+00 0.18910D-02
3307 0.
.58480D-01 -0..11315D-01 0.88035D+00 -0.47063D-03

3308 0,
.79153D-01 -0..14565D-01 0.99007D+00 -0.91705D-03

3309 0.
.99668D-01 -0.. 18162D-01 0.99008D+00 -0.11381D-02

3310 0,
.12002D+00 -0..22079D-01 0.99009D+00 -0.13591D-02

3311 0. 14509D+00
. -0..26277D-01 0.99010D+00 -0.15801D-02

3312 0. 16992D+00
. -0..30719D-01 0.99011D+00 -0.18011D-02

3313 0. 19450D+00
. -0..35359D-01 0.99012D+00 -0.20221D-02

3314 0.
.22363D+00 -0..40154D-01 0.99013D+00 -0.22431D-02

3315 0.
.25247D+00 -0..45058D-01 0.99014D+00 -0.24641D-02

3316 0.
.27633D+00 -0..50028D-01 0.99015D+00 -0.26851D-02

3317 0.
.29528D+00 -0..55025D-01 0.99016D+00 -0.29061D-02

3318 0.
.30000D+00 -0..60026D-01 0.99017D+00 -0.31271D-02

3319 0.
.30000D+00 -0..65027D-01 0.99018D+00 -0.33481D-02

3320 0.
.30000D+00 -0,.70029D-01 0.99019D+00 -0.35692D-02

3321 0.
.30000D+00 -0,.75030D-01 0.99020D+00 -0.37902D-02

3322 0.
.30000D+00 -0..80032D-01 0.99021D+00 -0.40112D-02

3323 0,
.30000D+00 -0,.85033D-01 0.99021D+00 -0.42322D-02

3324 0.
.30000D+00 -0,.90035D-01 0.99022D+00 -0.44532D-02

G-LTRENDS.DAT-7
NACA XMIN YMIN XMAX YMAX

3405 0.46868D-01 -0.76623D-02 0.61033D+00 0.76596D-02

3406 0.67472D-01 -0.10716D-01 0.68545D+00 0.41953D-02
3407 0.82994D-01 -0.14147D-01 0.77553D+00 0.13969D-02
3408 0.10349D+00 -0.17898D-01 0.89541D+00 -0.47549D-03

3409 0.12391D+00 -0.21907D-01 0.99010D+00 -0.99679D-03

3410 0.13927D+00 -0.26124D-01 0.99011D+00 -0.12177D-02

3411 0.15457D+00 -0.30502D-01 0.99012D+00 -0.14387D-02

3412 0.16982D+00 -0.35007D-01 0.99013D+00 -0.16596D-02

3413 0.18499D+00 -0.39608D-01 0.99014D+00 -0.18805D-02

3414 0.19520D+00 -0.44285D-01 0.99015D+00 -0.21015D-02

3415 0.20536D+00 -0.49018D-01 0.99016D+00 -0.23224D-02

3416 0.21061D+00 -0.53798D-01 0.99017D+00 -0.25434D-02

3417 0.22070D+00 -0.58612D-01 0.99018D+00 -0.27643D-02

3418 0.22590D+00 -0.63456D-01 0.99020D+00 -0.29852D-02

3419 0.23108D+00 -0.68321D-01 0.99021D+00 -0.32062D-02

3420 0.23623D+00 -0.73204D-01 0.99022D+00 -0.34271D-02

3421 0.24137D+00 -0.78102D-01 0.99023D+00 -0.36481D-02

3422 0.24649D+00 -0.83013D-01 0.99024D+00 -0.38690D-02

3423 0.25159D+00 -0.87931D-01 0.99025D+00 -0.40899D-02

3424 0.25188D+00 -0.92863D-01 0.99026D+00 -0.43109D-02

3505 0.66716D-01 -0.91416D-02 0.66032D+00 0.10091D-01

3506 0.87185D-01 -0.12602D-01 0.70544D+00 0.68870D-02
3507 0.10762D+00 -0.16395D-01 0.75555D+00 0.40750D-02
3508 0.12302D+00 -0.20445D-01 0.81062D+00 0.17350D-02
3509 0.14338D+00 -0.24691D-01 0.88058D+00 -0.18879D-04

3510 0.15373D+00 -0.29087D-01 0.97025D+00 -0.99480D-03

3511 0.16903D+00 -0.33598D-01 0.99014D+00 -0.12411D-02

3512 0.17933D+00 -0.38194D-01 0.99016D+00 -0.14619D-02

3513 0.18961D+00 -0.42859D-01 0.99017D+00 -0.16827D-02

3514 0.19986D+00 -0.47576D-01 0.99018D+00 -0.19035D-02

3515 0.20515D+00 -0.52334D-01 0.99019D+00 -0.21244D-02

3516 0.21536D+00 -0.57127D-01 0.99021D+00 -0.23452D-02

3517 0.22062D+00 -0.61948D-01 0.99022D+00 -0.25660D-02

3518 0.22587D+00 -0.66790D-01 0.99023D+00 -0.27868D-02

3519 0.23111D+00 -0.71651D-01 0.99025D+00 -0.30077D-02

3520 0.23634D+00 -0.76527D-01 0.99026D+00 -0.32285D-02

3521 0.23665D+00 -0.81415D-01 0.99027D+00 -0.34493D-02

3522 0.24186D+00 -0.86318D-01 0.99029D+00 -0.36701D-02

3523 0.24706D+00 -0.91227D-01 0.99030D+00 -0.38910D-02

3524 0.24737D+00 -0.96145D-01 0.99031D+00 -0.41118D-02

0.81550D-01 0.71031D+00 0.12876D-01

3605 -0.10413D-01

0.10194D+00 0.73542D+00 0.10013D-01

3606 -0.14166D-01

0.12232D+00 0.76554D+00 0.73883D-02

3607 -0.18205D-01

0.79565D+00 0.50267D-02
3608 0.14267D+00 -0.22451D-01

0.83074D+00 0.29610D-02
3609 0.15799D+00 -0.26852D-01

0.86578D+00 0.12289D-02
3610 0.16831D+00 -0.31370D-01

0.17861D+00 0.90573D+00 -0.11986D-03

3611 -0.35972D-01

0.18889D+00 0.95549D+00 -0.10167D-02

3612 -0.40641D-01

0.19916D+00 0.99021D+00 -0.13868D-02

3613 -0.45362D-01

0.20445D+00 0.99023D+00 -0.16074D-02

3614 -0.50123D-01

0.21470D+00 0.99024D+00 -0.18280D-02

3615 -0.54918D-01

0.21997D+00 0.99026D+00 -0.20486D-02

3616 -0.59739D-01

0.22523D+00 0.99027D+00 -0.22692D-02

3617 -0.64582D-01

0.23048D+00 0.99029D+00 -0.24899D-02

3618 -0.69442D-01

0.23573D+00 0.99031D+00 -0.27105D-02

3619 -0.74316D-01

0.23603D+00 0.99032D+00 -0.29311D-02

3620 -0.79206D-01

0.24127D+00 0.99034D+00 -0.31517D-02

3621 -0.84106D-01

0.24649D+00 -0.89013D-01 0.99035D+00 -0.33723D-02

3622
0.24679D+00 -0.93931D-01 0.99037D+00 -0.35929D-02
3623
0.25200D+00 -0.98853D-01 0.99039D+00 -0.38136D-02
3624

G-LTRENDS . DAT-8
NACA XMIN YMIN XMAX YMAX

3705 0. 96415D-01 -0. 11508D-01 0. 76527D+00 0. 16084D-01

3706 0. 11676D+00 -0. 15477D-01 0. 78038D+00 0. 13662D-01
3707 0. 13709D+00 -0. 19690D-01 0. .
79549D+00 0. 11376D-01
3708 0. 15239D+00 -0. 24074D-01 0. 81563D+00 0. 92338D-02
3709 0. 16769D+00 -0. 28584D-01 0. 83074D+00 0. 72466D-02
3710 0. 17798D+00 -0. 33186D-01 0. 84585D+00 0. 54194D-02
3711 0. 18826D+00 -0. 37857D-01 0. 86594D+00 0. 37654D-02
3712 0. 19852D+00 -0. 42582D-01 0. .88601D+00 0. 22939D-02
3713 0. 20380D+00 -0. 47347D-01 0. .90602D+00 0. 10194D-02
3714 0. 21405D+00 -0. 52147D-01 0. 92599D+00 -0. 42883D-04
3715 0. 21931D+00 -0. 56973D-01 0. .94589D+00 -0. 87701D-03
3716 0. 22457D+00 -0..61820D-01 0. .97064D+00 -0. 14613D-02
3717 0. 22982D+00 -0.. 66685D-01 0. .99036D+00 -0. 17764D-02
3718 0. 23507D+00 -0..71564D-01 0. .99038D+00 -0. 19966D-02
3719 0. 23535D+00 -0.. 76455D-01 0. 99040D+00 -0. 22167D-02
3720 0.
.24059D+00 -0..81360D-01 0. 99043D+00 -0. 24369D-02
3721 0.
.24582D+00 -0..86271D-01 0. .99045D+00 -0. 26571D-02
3722 0.
.24610D+00 -0..91191D-01 0. .99047D+00 -0. 28773D-02
3723 0.
25132D+00 -0..96117D-01 0. 99049D+00 -0. 30975D-02
3724 0.
.25160D+00 -0.. 10105D+00 0. 99051D+00 -0. 33176D-02

3805 0.
11130D+00 -0..12455D-01 0. 83021D+00 0. 19807D-01
3806 0. 13160D+00
. -0.16589D-01 0. .84033D+00 0. 17958D-01
3807 0. 14689D+00
. -0..20928D-01 0. .84542D+00 0. 16173D-01
3808 0. 16217D+00
. -0.25414D-01 0. 85555D+00 0. 14452D-01
3809 0.
.17744D+00 -0.. 30005D-01 0. .86065D+00 0. 12807D-01
3810 0.
.18771D+00 -0..34671D-01 0. .86576D+00 0. , 11227D-01
3811 0.
.19796D+00 -0..39395D-01 0. .87590D+00 0. 97235D-02
3812 0.
.20821D+00 -0..44160D-01 0. .88101D+00 0. 82917D-02
3813 0.
.21347D+00 -0..48964D-01 0. 89115D+00 0. 69389D-02
3814 0.
.21872D+00 -0..53793D-01 0. .89625D+00 0. .56615D-02

3815 0.
.22396D+00 -0..58644D-01 0. 90636D+00 0. .44687D-02

3816 0.
.22921D+00 -0..63513D-01 0. .91644D+00 0. 33527D-02
3817 0.
.23444D+00 -0..68397D-01 0. .92152D+00 0. 23282D-02

3818 0.
.23968D+00 -0..73292D-01 0. .93155D+00 0. 13873D-02
3819 0,
.23994D+00 -0.. 78200D-01 0. .93660D+00 0. .53304D-03

3820 0.
.24517D+00 -0..83116D-01 0. .94657D+00 -0..22334D-03

3821 0,
.24543D+00 -0,.88037D-01 0. .95650D+00 -0.88797D-03

3822 0,
.25065D+00 -0..92970D-01 0. .96637D+00 -0.. 14573D-02
3823 0.
.25090D+00 -0,.97903D-01 0. .97618D+00 -0..19278D-02

3824 0,
.25612D+00 -0,. 10285D+00 0, .98108D+00 -0..22914D-02

3905 0.
.12120D+00 -0,. 13283D-01 0. .91017D+00 0. .24192D-01

3906 0. 14147D+00
. -0..17541D-01 0. .91020D+00 0. 23091D-01

3907 0.
.15673D+00 -0..21978D-01 0. .91023D+00 0. .21989D-01

3908 0, 17199D+00
. -0..26542D-01 0, .91538D+00 0. .20938D-01

3909 0. 18724D+00
. -0..31193D-01 0. .91542D+00 0. .19890D-01

3910 0. 19748D+00
. -0,.35908D-01 0. .92060D+00 0. .18853D-01

3911 0.
.20272D+00 -0,.40672D-01 0, .92066D+00 0. 17859D-01
.

3912 0.
.21296D+00 -0.45474D-01 0, .92072D+00 0, .16864D-01

3913 0.
.21819D+00 -0..50304D-01 0, .92592D+00 0. .15898D-01

3914 0.
.22343D+00 -0..55157D-01 0, .92599D+00 0. .14957D-01

3915 0.
.22866D+00 -0..60029D-01 0, .92606D+00 0, 14017D-01
.

3916 0.
.23389D+00 -0..64916D-01 0, .93128D+00 0, 13123D-01
.

3917 0.
.23911D+00 -0..69816D-01 0 .93136D+00 0 .12237D-01

3918 0.
.24433D+00 -0..74724D-01 0 .93657D+00 0 .11364D-01

3919 0.
.24457D+00 -0..79646D-01 0 .93666D+00 0 . 10533D-01

3920 0.
.24979D+00 -0,.84572D-01 0 .93675D+00 0 .97017D-02

3921 0.
.25003D+00 -0,.89506D-01 0 .94196D+00 0 .89049D-02

3922 0.
.25524D+00 -0,.94445D-01 0 .94205D+00 0 .81289D-02

3923 0. 25548D+00
.
-0..99390D-01 0 .94724D+00 0 .73545D-02

3924 0.
.26068D+00 -0,.10434D+00 0 .94733D+00 0 .66341D-02

G-LTRENDS.DAT-9
NACA XMIN YMIN XMAX YMAX

4105 0. 80792D-02 15152D-03 0.91497D-01

-0. 0.20889D-01
4106 0. 86950D-02 96182D-03
-0. 0.87626D-01 0.17213D-01
4107 0. 93108D-02 17721D-02 0.83970D-01
-0. 0.13590D-01
4108 0. 99266D-02 -0. 25824D-02 0.99008D+00 -0.88399D-03
4109 0. 10542D-01 -0. 33927D-02 0.99009D+00 -0.11050D-02
4110 0. 11158D-01 -0. 42030D-02 0.99010D+00 -0.13260D-02
4111 0.
,
19125D-01 -0. 50740D-02 0.99011D+00 -0.15470D-02
4112 0. 19955D-01 -0. 62262D-02 0.99012D+00 -0.17680D-02
4113 0. 27571D-01 -0..73871D-02 0.99013D+00 -0.19890D-02
4114 0. 28538D-01 -0..88092D-02 0.99014D+00 -0.22099D-02
4115 0. 34590D+00 -0..37439D-01 0.99015D+00 -0.24309D-02
4116 0. 34596D+00 -0..42404D-01 0.99016D+00 -0.26519D-02
4117 0. 34100D+00 -0..47374D-01 0.99017D+00 -0.28729D-02
4118 0.
.33604D+00 -0.52348D-01 0.99017D+00 -0.30939D-02
4119 0.
.33610D+00 -0..57327D-01 0.99018D+00 -0.33149D-02
4120 0.
.33113D+00 -0.. 62306D-01 0.99019D+00 -0.35359D-02
4121 0.
.33119D+00 -0..67291D-01 0.99020D+00 -0.37569D-02
4122 0.
33125D+00 -0..72275D-01 0.99021D+00 -0.39779D-02
4123 0.
.32628D+00 -0.. 77261D-01 0.99022D+00 -0.41989D-02

4124 0.
.32633D+00 -0..82251D-01 0.99023D+00 -0.44199D-02

4205 0. 68490D-02
. -0..27660D-02 0.18570D+00 0.16276D-01
4206 0. 13026D-01
. -0..40630D-02 0.18112D+00 0.11589D-01
4207 0. 19177D-01
. -0..55151D-02 0.17662D+00 0.69310D-02
4208 0.
.25329D-01 -0..72019D-02 0.77070D+00 0.43396D-04
4209 0.
.31478D-01 -0..91344D-02 0.99010D+00 -0.99468D-03

4210 0.
.37619D-01 -0..11308D-01 0.99011D+00 -0.12156D-02

4211 0.
.49018D-01 -0..13780D-01 0.99012D+00 -0.14366D-02

4212 0.
.65308D-01 -0..16570D-01 0.99013D+00 -0.16575D-02

4213 0.
.90890D-01 -0..19773D-01 0.99014D+00 -0.18784D-02

4214 0.
.33559D+00 -0..30846D-01 0.99015D+00 -0.20994D-02

4215 0.
.33061D+00 -0..35829D-01 0.99016D+00 -0.23203D-02

4216 0.
.33065D+00 -0..40814D-01 0.99017D+00 -0.25412D-02

4217 0.
.32566D+00 -0..45803D-01 0.99019D+00 -0.27622D-02

4218 0,
.32570D+00 -0..50792D-01 0.99020D+00 -0.29831D-02

4219 0.
.32071D+00 -0..55783D-01 0.99021D+00 -0.32041D-02

4220 0.
.32075D+00 -0..60777D-01 0.99022D+00 -0.34250D-02

4221 0.
.32079D+00 -0..65771D-01 0.99023D+00 -0.36459D-02

4222 0.
.32082D+00 -0..70765D-01 0.99024D+00 -0.38669D-02

4223 0.
.31583D+00 -0..75759D-01 0.99025D+00 -0.40878D-02

4224 0.
.31586D+00 -0..80756D-01 0.99026D+00 -0.43087D-02

4305 0. 17112D-01
. -0..44353D-02 0.37515D+00 0.15015D-01
4306 0.
.28104D-01 -0..63108D-02 0.48040D+00 0.10279D-01
4307 0.
.33866D-01 -0..85100D-02 0.58564D+00 0.60493D-02
4308 0.
.44845D-01 -0.. 11010D-01 0.69580D+00 0.25270D-02
4309 0,
.55783D-01 -0..13803D-01 0.82575D+00 -0.49211D-04

4310 0.
.71757D-01 -0..16894D-01 0.99012D+00 -0.10739D-02

4311 0.
.87578D-01 -0..20260D-01 0.99014D+00 -0.12947D-02

4312 0.
. 10324D+00 -0..23895D-01 0.99015D+00 -0.15156D-02

4313 0.
. 11874D+00 -0..27780D-01 0.99016D+00 -0.17364D-02

4314 0.
.13892D+00 -0,.31900D-01 0.99017D+00 -0.19573D-02

4315 0.
, 15883D+00 -0..36228D-01 0.99019D+00 -0.21781D-02

4316 0.
. 18320D+00 -0..40741D-01 0.99020D+00 -0.23990D-02

4317 0.
.20251D+00 -0..45410D-01 0.99021D+00 -0.26199D-02

4318 0.
.22621D+00 -0..50203D-01 0.99022D+00 -0.28407D-02

4319 0.
.24499D+00 -0.. 55091D-01 0.99024D+00 -0.30616D-02

4320 0.
.26810D+00 -0..60044D-01 0.99025D+00 -0.32824D-02

4321 0.
.28640D+00 -0..65032D-01 0.99026D+00 -0.35033D-02

4322 0.
.29549D+00 -0..70032D-01 0.99027D+00 -0.37241D-02

4323 0.
.30000D+00 -0,.75033D-01 0.99029D+00 -0.39450D-02

4324 0. 30000D+00
. -0,.80035D-01 0.99030D+00 -0.41658D-02

G-LTRENDS.DAT-10
NACA XMIN YMIN XMAX YMAX

4405 0. 27008D-01 58643D-02 0. 53031D+00 0.

-0. 16895D-01
4406 0. 42859D-01 82834D-02 0. 57546D+00
-0. .
0. 12785D-01
4407 0. 53574D-01 11050D-01 0. 63064D+00 0.
-0. .
89913D-02
4408 0. 69368D-01 -0. 14131D-01 0. 68580D+00 0. 55993D-02
4409 0. 85104D-01 -0. 17499D-01 0. 75592D+00 0. 27047D-02
4410 0. 95750D-01 -0. 21123D-01 0. 83091D+00 0. 43706D-03
4411 0. 11137D+00 -0. 24968D-01 0. 93555D+00 -0. 97967D-03
4412 0. 12692D+00 -0. 29000D-01 0. 99017D+00 -0. 13266D-02
4413 0. 14237D+00 -0. 33188D-01 0. 99019D+00 -0. 15473D-02
4414 0. 15281D+00 -0. 37511D-01 0. 99020D+00 -0. 17680D-02
4415 0. 16320D+00 -0. 41940D-01 0. .99022D+00 -0. 19888D-02
4416 0. 17354D+00 -0. 46459D-01 0. 99023D+00 -0. 22095D-02
4417 0. 18382D+00 -0.51053D-01 0. 99025D+00 -0. 24302D-02
4418 0. 19405D+00 -0.55707D-01 0. .99026D+00 -0. 26510D-02
4419 0. 20421D+00 -0.60408D-01 0. .99027D+00 -0. 28717D-02
4420 0. 20952D+00 -0..65151D-01 0. .99029D+00 -0. 30924D-02
4421 0.
21479D+00 -0..69926D-01 0. 99030D+00 -0..33132D-02

4422 0.
.22482D+00 -0..74729D-01 0. .99032D+00 -0..35339D-02

4423 0.
.23003D+00 -0..79557D-01 0. 99033D+00 -0..37546D-02

4424 0.
.23522D+00 -0.84403D-01 0. .99035D+00 -0..39754D-02

4505 0.
.41959D-01 -0..71615D-02 0. .61033D+00 0. .19399D-01

4506 0. 57609D-01
. -0.. 10004D-01 0. 64047D+00
. 0. 15760D-01
.

4507 0.
73249D-01 -0.. 13198D-01 0. .67063D+00 0. 12346D-01

4508 0.
88869D-01 -0.. 16692D-01 0. .70579D+00 0. .91884D-02

4509 0.
.10446D+00 -0..20437D-01 0. 74094D+00 0. .63240D-02

4510 0.
.12001D+00 -0..24388D-01 0. .78606D+00 0. .37967D-02

4511 0,
.13052D+00 -0..28511D-01 0. .83110D+00 0. .16609D-02

4512 0.
.14599D+00 -0..32772D-01 0. .88103D+00 -0..11533D-04

4513 0.
.15645D+00 -0..37146D-01 0. .94071D+00 -0..11107D-02

4514 0. 16687D+00
. -0..41611D-01 0. 99024D+00 -0..15034D-02

4515 0. 17726D+00
. -0..46151D-01 0. .99026D+00 -0..17239D-02

4516 0. 18268D+00
. -0..50752D-01 0. .99028D+00 -0.19445D-02

4517 0. 19302D+00
. -0.. 55406D-01 0. .99029D+00 -0..21650D-02

4518 0. 19840D+00
. -0..60101D-01 0. .99031D+00 -0..23855D-02

4519 0.
.20378D+00 -0..64829D-01 0. 99033D+00 -0..26061D-02

4520 0.
.21403D+00 -0..69590D-01 0. .99035D+00 -0..28266D-02

4521 0.
.21937D+00 -0..74375D-01 0. .99036D+00 -0..30471D-02

4522 0.
.22468D+00 -0.. 79181D-01 0. .99038D+00 -0..32676D-02

4523 0.
.22512D+00 -0..84008D-01 0. .99040D+00 -0..34882D-02

4524 0,
.23042D+00 -0..88851D-01 0. .99041D+00 -0.37087D-02

4605 0. 51797D-01
. -0..83129D-02 0. 68032D+00 0, .22338D-01

4606 0. 72390D-01
. -0.. 11502D-01 0. 69544D+00
. 0. 19187D-01
.

4607 0,
.87924D-01 -0.. 15020D-01 0. .71559D+00 0. .16190D-01

4608 0. 10345D+00
. -0,. 18805D-01 0. .73575D+00 0. 13357D-01
.

4609 0. 11895D+00
. -0..22805D-01 0. .76092D+00 0, .10702D-01

4610 0. 13443D+00
. -0..26975D-01 0. .78106D+00 0. .82407D-02

4611 0.
.14488D+00 -0..31277D-01 0, .80620D+00 0, 59885D-02
.

4612 0.
.16031D+00 -0..35688D-01 0, .83131D+00 0, .39644D-02

4613 0.
.17072D+00 -0..40186D-01 0, .85637D+00 0, .21897D-02

4614 0.
.17614D+00 -0..44754D-01 0, .88635D+00 0, .69176D-03

4615 0.
.18651D+00 -0..49379D-01 0. .91624D+00 -0,.49895D-03

4616 0.
.19191D+00 -0,.54050D-01 0 . 95094D+00 -0 . 13382D-02
4617 0.
.20225D+00 -0..58759D-01 0 .99036D+00 -0 . 17678D-02
4618 0.
.20762D+00 -0..63503D-01 0. .99039D+00 -0 .19879D-02

4619 0.
.21298D+00 -0,.68273D-01 0, .99041D+00 -0 .22081D-02

4620 0.
.21833D+00 -0..73066D-01 0, .99043D+00 -0 .24282D-02

4621 0.
.22368D+00 -0..77878D-01 0 .99045D+00 -0 .26484D-02

4622 0.
.22409D+00 -0..82707D-01 0, .99047D+00 -0 .28686D-02

4623 0.
.22942D+00 -0..87555D-01 0, .99049D+00 -0 .30887D-02

4624 0.
.23473D+00 -0..92413D-01 0 .99052D+00 -0 .33089D-02

G-LTRENDS.DAT-11
NACA XMIN YMIN XMAX YMAX

4705 0.66704D-01 -0.93522D-02 0.75029D+00 0.25724D-01

4706 0.87202D-01 -0.12809D-01 0.76041D+00 0.23128D-01
4707 0.10266D+00 -0.16574D-01 0.77054D+00 0.20626D-01
4708 0.11812D+00 -0.20572D-01 0.78067D+00 0.18221D-01
4709 0.13356D+00 -0.24752D-01 0.79585D+00 0.15919D-01
4710 0.14898D+00 -0.29073D-01 0.80600D+00 0.13727D-01
4711 0.15938D+00 -0.33504D-01 0.81615D+00 0.11643D-01
4712 0.16977D+00 -0.38022D-01 0.83132D+00 0.96787D-02
4713 0.18015D+00 -0.42608D-01 0.84146D+00 0.78327D-02
4714 0.18553D+00 -0.47250D-01 0.85660D+00 0.61180D-02
4715 0.19589D+00 -0.51938D-01 0.87171D+00 0.45347D-02
4716 0.20125D+00 -0.56664D-01 0.88678D+00 0.30905D-02
4717 0.20661D+00 -0.61421D-01 0.90182D+00 0.17934D-02
4718 0.21197D+00 -0.66203D-01 0.91680D+00 0.65167D-03
4719 0.21731D+00 -0.71008D-01 0.93172D+00 -0.32642D-03

4720 0.22265D+00 -0.75832D-01 0.94657D+00 -0.11322D-02

4721 0.22798D+00 -0.80672D-01 0.96624D+00 -0.17554D-02

4722 0.23331D+00 -0.85523D-01 0.98091D+00 -0.21797D-02

4723 0.23368D+00 -0.90392D-01 0.99065D+00 -0.24238D-02

4724 0.23900D+00 -0.95268D-01 0.99068D+00 -0.26432D-02

4805 0.76579D-01 -0.10280D-01 0.82524D+00 0.29620D-01

4806 0.97017D-01 -0.13956D-01 0.83034D+00 0.27681D-01
4807 0.11745D+00 -0.17907D-01 0.83545D+00 0.25791D-01
4808 0.13285D+00 -0.22066D-01 0.84058D+00 0.23949D-01
4809 0.14824D+00 -0.26379D-01 0.84571D+00 0.22157D-01
4810 0.15861D+00 -0.30812D-01 0.85085D+00 0.20417D-01
4811 0.16898D+00 -0.35336D-01 0.85600D+00 0.18727D-01
4812 0.17934D+00 -0.39933D-01 0.86116D+00 0.17091D-01
4813 0.18969D+00 -0.44585D-01 0.86632D+00 0.15508D-01
4814 0.19503D+00 -0.49285D-01 0.87148D+00 0.13979D-01
4815 0.20038D+00 -0.54020D-01 0.87664D+00 0.12505D-01
4816 0.21070D+00 -0.58788D-01 0.88180D+00 0.11087D-01
4817 0.21603D+00 -0.63582D-01 0.89200D+00 0.97265D-02
4818 0.22136D+00 -0.68396D-01 0.89714D+00 0.84296D-02
4819 0.22172D+00 -0.73230D-01 0.90228D+00 0.71916D-02
4820 0.22704D+00 -0.78081D-01 0.90741D+00 0.60133D-02

4821 0.23235D+00 -0.82944D-01 0.91253D+00 0.48955D-02

4822 0.23766D+00 -0.87816D-01 0.91764D+00 0.38389D-02
4823 0.23801D+00 -0.92703D-01 0.92769D+00 0.28488D-02

4824 0.24331D+00 -0.97595D-01 0.93275D+00 0.19271D-02

0.86474D-01 0.90512D+00 0.34129D-01

4905 -0.11112D-01

0.10686D+00 0.91026D+00 0.32993D-01

4906 -0.14963D-01

0.12725D+00 0.91031D+00 0.31892D-01

4907 -0.19064D-01

0.14261D+00 0.91035D+00 0.30791D-01

4908 -0.23345D-01

0.15797D+00 0.91040D+00 0.29689D-01

4909 -0.27760D-01

0.91563D+00 0.28625D-01
4910 0.16831D+00 -0.32278D-01

0.91569D+00 0.27577D-01
4911 0.17865D+00 -0.36874D-01

0.91575D+00 0.26530D-01
4912 0.18897D+00 -0.41529D-01

0.92103D+00 0.25487D-01
4913 0.19430D+00 -0.46234D-01

4914 0.20462D+00 -0.50976D-01 6.92111D+00 0.24494D-01

0.92119D+00 0.23501D-01
4915 0.20994D+00 -0.55752D-01

0.92127D+00 0.22507D-01
4916 0.21525D+00 -0.60554D-01

0.92660D+00 0.21545D-01
4917 0.22056D+00 -0.65377D-01

0.92669D+00 0.20607D-01
4918 0.22587D+00 -0.70217D-01

0.92678D+00 0.19668D-01
4919 0.23117D+00 -0.75072D-01

0.93212D+00 0.18734D-01
4920 0.23150D+00 -0.79944D-01

0.23679D+00 0.93223D+00 0.17851D-01

4921 -0.84826D-01

0.23712D+00 0.93233D+00 0.16968D-01

4922 -0.89715D-01

0.24241D+00 0.93244D+00 0.16084D-01

4923 -0.94618D-01

0.24769D+00 -0.99523D-01 0.93778D+00 0.15236D-01

4924

G-LTRENDS . DAT-12
NACA XMIN YMIN XMAX YMAX

5105 0. 24769D+00 99523D-01 0.91868D-01

-0. 0.30822D-01
5106 0. 24769D+00 99523D-01 0.92241D-01
-0. 0.27087D-01
5107 0. 99069D-02 29014D-03 0.88815D-01
-0. 0.23442D-01
5108 0. 10608D-01 10280D-02 0.85631D-01
-0. 0.19843D-01
5109 0. 11309D-01 -0. 17659D-02 0.86335D-01 0.16323D-01
5110 0. 12010D-01 -0. 25038D-02 0.99012D+00 -0.11038D-02
5111 0. 12711D-01 -0. 32416D-02 0.99013D+00 -0.13247D-02
5112 0. 13412D-01 -0. 39795D-02 0.99015D+00 -0.15455D-02
5113 0. 14113D-01 -0. 47174D-02 0.99016D+00 -0.17664D-02
5114 0. 14814D-01 -0. 54553D-02 0.99017D+00 -0.19873D-02
5115 0. 24247D-01 -0. 63294D-02 0.99018D+00 -0.22082D-02
5116 0. 25196D-01 -0. 73847D-02 0.99019D+00 -0.24290D-02
5117 0. 26146D-01 -0. 84400D-02 0.99021D+00 -0.26499D-02
5118 0. 35048D-01 -0. 97109D-02 0.99022D+00 -0.28708D-02
5119 0. 34643D+00 -0. 48036D-01 0.99023D+00 -0.30916D-02
5120 0.
.34650D+00 -0. 53000D-01 0.99024D+00 -0.33125D-02
5121 0. 34155D+00 -0. 57971D-01 0.99025D+00 -0.35334D-02

5122 0. 34162D+00 -0. 62943D-01 0.99027D+00 -0.37543D-02

5213 0. 33666D+00 -0..67920D-01 0.99028D+00 -0.39751D-02

5124 0.
.33673D+00 -0..72898D-01 0.99029D+00 -0.41960D-02

5205 0.
.72299D-02 -0..21055D-02 0.19059D+00 0.26232D-01
5206 0.
.76759D-02 -0..30203D-02 0.18606D+00 0.21527D-01
5207 0.
.14264D-01 -0..41020D-02 0.18163D+00 0.16836D-01
5208 0. 14873D-01
. -0..53845D-02 0.18187D+00 0.12169D-01
5209 0.
.21497D-01 -0., 68291D-02 0.57104D+00 0.33036D-02
5210 0.
.28070D-01 -0..84328D-02 0.77109D+00 0.62997D-04
5211 0.
.34607D-01 -0..10240D-01 0.99015D+00 -0.11865D-02

5212 0.
.41109D-01 -0..12264D-01 0.99016D+00 -0.14072D-02

5213 0.
.47571D-01 -0..14506D-01 0.99018D+00 -0.16280D-02

5214 0.
.59322D-01 -0.16991D-01 0.99019D+00 -0.18488D-02

5215 0.
.75847D-01 -0..19777D-01 0.99020D+00 -0.20696D-02

5216 0.
.34087D+00 -0..31089D-01 0.99022D+00 -0.22904D-02

5217 0.
.33589D+00 -0..36066D-01 0.99023D+00 -0.25112D-02

5218 0.
.33091D+00 -0..41046D-01 0.99025D+00 -0.27320D-02

5219 0.
.33096D+00 -0.46030D-01 0.99026D+00 -0.29527D-02

5220 0.
.33101D+00 -0.. 51015D-01 0.99027D+00 -0.31735D-02

5221 0.
.32602D+00 -0.. 56004D-01 0.99029D+00 -0.33943D-02

5222 0.
.32607D+00 -0.. 60994D-01 0.99030D+00 -0.36151D-02

5223 0.
.32612D+00 -0.. 65983D-01 0.99031D+00 -0.38359D-02

5224 0,
.32112D+00 -0.. 70975D-01 0.99033D+00 -0.40567D-02

5305 0. 12177D-01
. -0..34789D-02 0.30000D+00 0.24993D-01
5306 0, 18115D-01
. -0..49619D-02 0.35015D+00 0.20002D-01
5307 0.
.24089D-01 -0..66995D-02 0.43545D+00 0.15158D-01
5308 0.
.30094D-01 -0..86845D-02 0.52077D+00 0.10646D-01
5309 0.
.41446D-01 -0..10907D-01 0.60606D+00 0.66084D-02
5310 0.
.47465D-01 -0..13397D-01 0.69625D+00 0.31677D-02
5311 0.
.58721D-01 -0..16118D-01 0.79624D+00 0.47732D-03
5312 0.
.69888D-01 -0..19080D-01 0.93565D+00 -0.11532D-02

5313 0.
.80961D-01 -0..22278D-01 0.99020D+00 -0.14502D-02

5314 0.
.96951D-01 -0..25708D-01 0.99022D+00 -0.16709D-02

5315 0.
.10776D+00 -0..29365D-01 0.99023D+00 -0.18915D-02

5316 0.
.12334D+00 -0,.33239D-01 0.99025D+00 -0.21122D-02

5317 0.
.14346D+00 -0..37319D-01 0.99026D+00 -0.23328D-02

5318 0.
.15848D+00 -0..41589D-01 0.99028D+00 -0.25535D-02

5319 0. 17789D+00
. -0..46033D-01 0.99030D+00 -0.27742D-02

5320 0. 19692D+00
. -0..50628D-01 0.99031D+00 -0.29948D-02

5321 0.
.21559D+00 -0..55352D-01 0.99033D+00 -0.32155D-02

5322 0.
.23392D+00 -0..60180D-01 0.99034D+00 -0.34361D-02

5323 0,
.25632D+00 -0..65087D-01 0.99036D+00 -0.36568D-02

5324 0,
.27398D+00 -0..70048D-01 0.99037D+00 -0.38775D-02

G-LTRENDS . DAT-13
NACA XMIN YMIN XMAX YMAX

5405 0. 22272D-01 46913D-02 0.49028D+00

-0. 0. 26560D-01

5406 0. 27983D-01 66740D-02 0. 52043D+00

-0. .
0. 22186D-01

5407 0. 38948D-01 89389D-02 0. 55562D+00

,
-0. ,
0. 17996D-01
5408 0. 49906D-01 11495D-01 0. 59583D+00
-0. , 0. .14035D-01

5409 0. 60851D-01 14329D-01 0. 64105D+00

-0. ,
0. 10354D-01

5410 0. 71773D-01 17417D-01 0. 68626D+00

-0. . 0. .70081D-02

5411 0. 82664D-01 -0. 20736D-01 0.

.74141D+00 0. 40601D-02

5412 0. 93516D-01 0..80146D+00

-0.24265D-01 0. 15870D-02
,

5413 0.
. 10935D+00 -0..27986D-01 0..86631D+00 -0.29915D-03
5414 0.
. 12008D+00 -0., 31879D-01 0..96061D+00 -0..13919D-02
5415 0.
. 13075D+00 -0..35919D-01 0.99027D+00 -0..16542D-02
5416 0.
. 14136D+00 -0..40088D-01 0.
.99029D+00 -0.. 18747D-02
5417 0.
, 15680D+00 -0.44369D-01 0.
.99031D+00 -0.20952D-02
5418 0.
.16238D+00 -0..48747D-01 0. 99033D+00
. -0..23156D-02
5419 0.
.17278D+00 -0..53209D-01 0.
.99034D+00 -0..25361D-02
5420 0.
.18311D+00 -0..57739D-01 0.
.99036D+00 -0..27566D-02
5421 0.
19337D+00 -0.62326D-01 0.
.99038D+00 -0..29770D-02

5422 0.
19878D+00 -0..66967D-01 0.
.99040D+00 -0..31975D-02

5423 0.
.20416D+00 -0..71647D-01 0.
.99042D+00 -0..34180D-02

5424 0.
.21423D+00 -0.. 76365D-01 0.
.99043D+00 -0..36384D-02

5505 0.
.27034D-01 -0.. 58282D-02 0. 58533D+00
. 0. .29038D-01

5506 0.
37782D-01 -0.82033D-02 0.
.60547D+00 0. .25190D-01

5507 0. 53673D-01
. -0.. 10908D-01 0.
.62563D+00 0. .21491D-01

5508 0. 64435D-01
. -0.. 13917D-01 0. 65083D+00
. 0. .17962D-01

5509 0. 75195D-01
. -0.. 17184D-01 0.
.67602D+00 0. .14623D-01

5510 0.
.91016D-01 -0..20689D-01 0.
70623D+00 0. .11495D-01

5511 0.
.10174D+00 -0..24394D-01 0.
.73643D+00 0. 86014D-02

5512 0. 11747D+00
. -0..28273D-01 0. 76659D+00
. 0. .59706D-02

5513 0. 12812D+00
. -0.32305D-01 0.
.80170D+00 0. .36339D-02

5514 0.
.13874D+00 -0..36462D-01 0.
.84172D+00 0. .16290D-02

5515 0.
.14933D+00 -0..40726D-01 0.
.88160D+00 0. 74415D-05
.

5516 0.
.15988D+00 -0..45080D-01 0.
.93122D+00 -0..11617D-02

5517 0. 16545D+00
. -0..49513D-01 0.
.98546D+00 -0.17620D-02

5518 0. 17593D+00
. -0..54013D-01 0.
.99039D+00 -0..19827D-02

5519 0.
.18146D+00 -0..58566D-01 0.
99041D+00 -0..22029D-02

5520 0.
.19186D+00 -0..63167D-01 0.
.99043D+00 -0..24230D-02

5521 0. 19734D+00
. -0,.67812D-01 0.
.99045D+00 -0..26432D-02

5522 0.
.20281D+00 -0..72490D-01 0.
.99047D+00 -0..28633D-02

5523 0.
.20825D+00 -0..77198D-01 0.
.99050D+00 -0..30835D-02

5524 0.
.21367D+00 -0..81933D-01 0.
.99052D+00 -0..33036D-02

5605 0.
.36966D-01 -0..68625D-02 0.
.66032D+00 0. .32038D-01

5606 0.
.52684D-01 -0..95835D-02 0.
.67546D+00 0. 28734D-01

5607 0.
.63321D-01 -0..12638D-01 0.
.69062D+00 0. 25541D-01

5608 0. 79041D-01
. -0..15988D-01 0.
.70579D+00 0. .22467D-01

5609 0.
.94739D-01 -0..19578D-01 0.
72097D+00 0. .19519D-01

5610 0.
. 10537D+00 -0..23374D-01 0. 73616D+00
. 0. .16705D-01

5611 0.
12102D+00 -0..27344D-01 0. 75638D+00
. 0. .14035D-01

5612 0.
.13161D+00 -0.31456D-01 0.
.77156D+00 0. .11516D-01

5613 0.
. 14219D+00 -0..35687D-01 0.
.79175D+00 0. .91610D-02

5614 0.
.15274D+00 -0..40017D-01 0.
.81192D+00 0. .69786D-02

5615 0.
. 16327D+00 -0..44429D-01 0.
.83205D+00 0. .49820D-02

5616 0.
, 16880D+00 -0..48911D-01 0.
.85213D+00 0. .31844D-02

5617 0.
. 17929D+00 -0..53452D-01 0. 87713D+00
. 0. .16027D-02

5618 0.
, 18479D+00 -0.58042D-01 0.
.90203D+00 0, .25405D-03

5619 0.
, 19029D+00 -0..62673D-01 0.
.92681D+00 -0,.83698D-03

5620 0.
, 19577D+00 -0..67341D-01 0.
.95146D+00 -0,.16442D-02

5621 0.
.20617D+00 -0..72041D-01 0.
.98083D+00 -0,.21316D-02

5622 0.
.20670D+00 -0.76767D-01 0,
.99059D+00 -0 .23620D-02

5623 0.
.21214D+00 -0..81519D-01 0,
.99062D+00 -0 .25816D-02

5624 0. 21758D+00
, -0..86292D-01 0,
.99064D+00 -0 .28012D-02

DAT-
G-LTRENDS . 14
NACA XMIN YMIN XMAX YMAX

5705 0. 46876D-01 78096D-02 0. 74030D+00

-0. 0.35516D-01
5706 0. 62485D-01 10822D-01 0. 74540D+00
-0. 0.32819D-01
5707 0. 78100D-01 14162D-01 0. 75555D+00
-0. 0.30197D-01
5708 0. 93710D-01 17772D-01 0. 76572D+00
-0. 0.27648D-01
5709 0. 10931D+00 -0. 21602D-01 0. 77590D+00 0.25175D-01
5710 0. 11986D+00 -0. 25611D-01 0. 78105D+00 0.22785D-01
5711 0. 13542D+00 -0. 29766D-01 0. 79125D+00 0.20477D-01
5712 0. 14595D+00 -0. 34041D-01 0. 80146D+00 0.18254D-01
5713 0. 15646D+00 -0. 38412D-01 0. 81166D+00 0.16118D-01
5714 0. 16196D+00 -0. 42862D-01 0. 82186D+00 0.14075D-01
5715 0. 17244D+00 -0. 47382D-01 0. 83206D+00 0.12125D-01
5716 0. 18291D+00 -0. 51953D-01 0. 84224D+00 0.10273D-01
5717 0. 18838D+00 -0. 56575D-01 0. 85241D+00 0.85225D-02
5718 0. 19385D+00 -0. 61235D-01 0. 86257D+00 0.68759D-02
5719 0. 19930D+00 -0. 65929D-01 0. .87270D+00 0.53370D-02
5720 0. 20475D+00 -0. 70651D-01 0. .88778D+00 0.39142D-02
5721 0. 21019D+00 -0. 75399D-01 0. .89785D+00 0.26073D-02
5722 0. 21562D+00 -0..80168D-01 0. .90787D+00 0.14191D-02
5723 0. 22105D+00 -0..84955D-01 0. .92278D+00 0.36165D-03
5724 0. 22153D+00 -0..89757D-01 0. .93271D+00 -0.56777D-03

5805 0. 56783D-01
. -0..86784D-02 0. .82025D+00 0.39508D-01
5806 0. 72315D-01
, -0..11933D-01 0. .82537D+00 0.37514D-01
5807 0.
.92898D-01 -0..15502D-01 0. .82543D+00 0.35564D-01
5808 0. 10843D+00
. -0..19317D-01 0. 83057D+00 0.33654D-01
5809 0.
11893D+00 -0.23330D-01 0. .83573D+00 0.31780D-01
5810 0. 13444D+00
. -0..27500D-01 0. .84090D+00 0.29944D-01
5811 0.
.14493D+00 -0.31793D-01 0. .84609D+00 0.28147D-01
5812 0. 15540D+00
. -0..36186D-01 0. .84619D+00 0.26391D-01
5813 0.
. 16587D+00 -0.40660D-01 0. 85139D+00 0.24682D-01
5814 0.
. 17632D+00 -0.45200D-01 0. .85660D+00 0.23014D-01
5815 0.
. 18177D+00 -0..49798D-01 0. .86181D+00 0.21388D-01
5816 0.
. 18721D+00 -0..54438D-01 0. .86702D+00 0.19804D-01
5817 0. 19763D+00
. -0..59118D-01 0. .87224D+00 0.18263D-01
5818 0.
20306D+00 -0..63832D-01 0. 87746D+00 0.16766D-01
5819 0.
.20848D+00 -0..68573D-01 0. .88267D+00 0.15313D-01
5820 0.
.21390D+00 -0..73337D-01 0. .88281D+00 0.13909D-01
5821 0.
.21434D+00 -0..78121D-01 0. .88802D+00 0.12553D-01
5822 0.
.21975D+00 -0..82926D-01 0. .89322D+00 0.11245D-01
5823 0.
.22515D+00 -0..87746D-01 0. .89841D+00 0.99829D-02
5824 0.
.23054D+00 -0,.92577D-01 0. .90359D+00 0.87692D-02

5905 0. 66694D-01
. -0..94754D-02 0. .90514D+00 0.44105D-01
5906 0.
.87207D-01 -0..12935D-01 0. .90517D+00 0.42951D-01
5907 0.
.10268D+00 -0..16690D-01 0. .90520D+00 0.41797D-01
5908 0.
.11816D+00 -0..20669D-01 0, .91044D+00 0.40695D-01
5909 0.
.13363D+00 -0..24822D-01 0, .91050D+00 0.39594D-01
5910 0.
.14408D+00 -0..29113D-01 0, .91055D+00 0.38493D-01
5911 0.
.15452D+00 -0..33511D-01 0, .91061D+00 0.37392D-01

5912 0. 16495D+00
. -0..37995D-01 0, .91594D+00 0.36317D-01

5913 0, 17538D+00
. -0..42548D-01 0 .91602D+00 0.35271D-01

5914 0. 18079D+00
. -0..47156D-01 0 .91610D+00 0.34224D-01

5915 0. 19120D+00
. -0..51813D-01 0 .91618D+00 0.33178D-01
5916 0.
.19661D+00 -0..56509D-01 0 .92159D+00 0.32136D-01

5917 0,
.20201D+00 -0..61236D-01 0 .92169D+00 0.31144D-01
5918 0.
.20741D+00 -0,.65990D-01 0 .92178D+00
0.30153D-01

0. 0 0.29161D-01
5919 .21280D+00 -0,.70769D-01 .92188D+00

0. 0 0.28170D-01
5920 .21819D+00 -0,.75567D-01 .92198D+00

5921 0.
.22358D+00 -0,.80382D-01 0 .92746D+00
0.27221D-01

5922 0, 22399D+00
. -0,.85211D-01 0 .92757D+00 0.26285D-01

5923 0.
.22936D+00 -0,.90058D-01 0 .92769D+00 0.25349D-01
5924 0.
.23473D+00 -0 .94913D-01 0 .92781D+00 0.24413D-01

G-LTRENDS . DAT-15
NACA XMIN YMIN XMAX YMAX

6105 0.23473D+00 -0.94913D-01 0.92236D-01 0.40763D-01

6106 0.23473D+00 -0.94913D-01 0.92684D-01 0.37036D-01
6107 0.23473D+00 -0.94913D-01 0.89556D-01 0.33339D-01
6108 0.23473D+00 -0.94913D-01 0.90207D-01 0.29723D-01
6109 0.11886D-01 -0.19036D-03 0.87539D-01 0.26188D-01
6110 0.12651D-01 -0.86151D-03 0.85057D-01 0.22727D-01
6111 0.13416D-01 -0.15327D-02 0.71647D+00 -0.21707D-03

6112 0.14181D-01 -0.22038D-02 0.99017D+00 -0.13228D-02

6113 0.14946D-01 -0.28750D-02 0.99019D+00 -0.15435D-02

6114 0.15712D-01 -0.35461D-02 0.99020D+00 -0.17643D-02

6115 0.16477D-01 -0.42173D-02 0.99022D+00 -0.19850D-02

6116 0.17242D-01 -0.48884D-02 0.99023D+00 -0.22057D-02

6117 0.18007D-01 -0.55596D-02 0.99025D+00 -0.24264D-02

6118 0.18772D-01 -0.62307D-02 0.99026D+00 -0.26472D-02

6119 0.29793D-01 -0.69273D-02 0.99028D+00 -0.28679D-02

6120 0.30835D-01 -0.78919D-02 0.99029D+00 -0.30886D-02

6121 0.31877D-01 -0.88565D-02 0.99031D+00 -0.33093D-02

6122 0.42016D-01 -0.98365D-02 0.99032D+00 -0.35301D-02

6123 0.43244D-01 -0.11040D-01 0.99033D+00 -0.37508D-02

6124 0.34716D+00 -0.63594D-01 0.99035D+00 -0.39715D-02

6205 0.75696D-02 -0.14299D-02 0.19071D+00 0.36210D-01

6206 0.80835D-02 -0.23084D-02 0.19085D+00 0.31483D-01
6207 0.85974D-02 -0.31869D-02 0.18648D+00 0.26782D-01
6208 0.91113D-02 -0.40654D-02 0.18224D+00 0.22090D-01
6209 0.16328D-01 -0.52511D-02 0.18252D+00 0.17426D-01
6210 0.17031D-01 -0.64845D-02 0.17847D+00 0.12786D-01
6211 0.24180D-01 -0.78778D-02 0.61158D+00 0.32007D-02
6212 0.25014D-01 -0.93815D-02 0.77157D+00 0.88418D-04
6213 0.32147D-01 -0.11094D-01 0.99021D+00 -0.13772D-02

6214 0.39180D-01 -0.12947D-01 0.99023D+00 -0.15978D-02

6215 0.46129D-01 -0.14976D-01 0.99025D+00 -0.18184D-02

6216 0.52999D-01 -0.17200D-01 0.99026D+00 -0.20390D-02

6217 0.65294D-01 -0.19681D-01 0.99028D+00 -0.22596D-02

6218 0.87330D-01 -0.22473D-01 0.99029D+00 -0.24802D-02

6219 0.34124D+00 -0.36310D-01 0.99031D+00 -0.27008D-02

6220 0.33626D+00 -0.41286D-01 0.99033D+00 -0.29214D-02

6221 0.33632D+00 -0.46264D-01 0.99034D+00 -0.31420D-02

6222 0.33134D+00 -0.51246D-01 0.99036D+00 -0.33626D-02

6223 0.33140D+00 -0.56231D-01 0.99038D+00 -0.35832D-02

6224 0.33146D+00 -0.61215D-01 0.99039D+00 -0.38038D-02

0.68627D-02 0.30000D+00 0.34993D-01

6305 -0.27523D-02

0.30000D+00 0.29991D-01
6306 0.13072D-01 -0.40119D-02

0.34017D+00 0.24996D-01
6307 0.19276D-01 -0.54030D-02

0.41052D+00 0.20093D-01
6308 0.19887D-01 -0.70106D-02

0.48090D+00 0.15424D-01
6309 0.26190D-01 -0.88472D-02

0.55126D+00 0.11096D-01
6310 0.32501D-01 -0.10874D-01

0.62158D+00 0.71975D-02
6311 0.44293D-01 -0.13117D-01

0.69679D+00 0.38145D-02
6312 0.50572D-01 -0.15563D-01

0.77682D+00 0.10535D-02
6313 0.62178D-01 -0.18200D-01

0.68407D-01 0.87644D+00 -0.90363D-03

6314 -0.21060D-01

0.79822D-01 0.99028D+00 -0.16043D-02

6315 -0.24121D-01

0.91091D-01 0.99030D+00 -0.18247D-02

6316 -0.27387D-01

0.10721D+00 0.99032D+00 -0.20451D-02

6317 -0.30857D-01

0.11810D+00 0.99034D+00 -0.22655D-02

6318 -0.34537D-01

0.13365D+00 0.99035D+00 -0.24860D-02

6319 -0.38411D-01

0.14886D+00 0.99037D+00 -0.27064D-02

6320 -0.42478D-01

0.16375D+00 -0.46726D-01 0.99039D+00 -0.29268D-02

6321
0.18282D+00 -0.51144D-01 0.99041D+00 -0.31472D-02
6322
0.20139D+00 -0.55712D-01 0.99043D+00 -0.33676D-02
6323
0.21949D+00 -0.60412D-01 0.99045D+00 -0.35881D-02
6324

G-LTRENDS . DAT-16
NACA XMIN YMIN XMAX YMAX

6405 0.11993D-01 -0.38508D-02 0.47027D+00 0.36380D-01

6406 0.17862D-01 -0.54977D-02 0.49040D+00 0.31873D-01
6407 0.29130D-01 -0.74172D-02 0.51558D+00 0.27486D-01
6408 0.35063D-01 -0.95823D-02 0.54580D+00 0.23247D-01
6409 0.41026D-01 -0.11972D-01 0.57604D+00 0.19185D-01
6410 0.52284D-01 -0.14619D-01 0.61131D+00 0.15336D-01
6411 0.63498D-01 -0.17478D-01 0.64656D+00 0.11735D-01
6412 0.74664D-01 -0.20546D-01 0.68681D+00 0.84228D-02
6413 0.85775D-01 -0.23814D-01 0.73200D+00 0.54419D-02
6414 0.96826D-01 -0.27267D-01 0.78210D+00 0.28432D-02
6415 0.10781D+00 -0.30890D-01 0.83204D+00 0.69611D-03
6416 0.11872D+00 -0.34668D-01 0.89666D+00 -0.89993D-03
6417 0.12956D+00 -0.38585D-01 0.98055D+00 -0.17521D-02
6418 0.14032D+00 -0.42627D-01 0.99039D+00 -0.19793D-02

6419 0.14609D+00 -0.46781D-01 0.99041D+00 -0.21994D-02

6420 0.15671D+00 -0.51036D-01 0.99043D+00 -0.24196D-02

6421 0.16724D+00 -0.55376D-01 0.99045D+00 -0.26397D-02

6422 0.17767D+00 -0.59789D-01 0.99048D+00 -0.28598D-02

6423 0.18325D+00 -0.64270D-01 0.99050D+00 -0.30800D-02

6424 0.19353D+00 -0.68807D-01 0.99052D+00 -0.33001D-02

6505 0.22208D-01 -0.48774D-02 0.56531D+00 0.38820D-01

6506 0.27906D-01 -0.68965D-02 0.58548D+00 0.34847D-01
6507 0.38867D-01 -0.92184D-02 0.60064D+00 0.30988D-01
6508 0.49833D-01 -0.11815D-01 0.62084D+00 0.27251D-01
6509 0.60798D-01 -0.14671D-01 0.64106D+00 0.23650D-01
6510 0.71755D-01 -0.17764D-01 0.66129D+00 0.20200D-01
6511 0.82695D-01 -0.21072D-01 0.68153D+00 0.16913D-01
6512 0.93613D-01 -0.24572D-01 0.70678D+00 0.13807D-01
6513 0.10450D+00 -0.28243D-01 0.73201D+00 0.10896D-01
6514 0.11536D+00 -0.32065D-01 0.75722D+00 0.82007D-02
6515 0.12617D+00 -0.36019D-01 0.78738D+00 0.57402D-02
6516 0.13694D+00 -0.40089D-01 0.81747D+00 0.35395D-02
6517 0.14268D+00 -0.44263D-01 0.84747D+00 0.16282D-02
6518 0.15338D+00 -0.48526D-01 0.88231D+00 0.40878D-04
6519 0.16402D+00 -0.52862D-01 0.92190D+00 -0.11734D-02

6520 0.16969D+00 -0.57271D-01 0.96612D+00 -0.19432D-02

6521 0.17534D+00 -0.61732D-01 0.99054D+00 -0.22375D-02

6522 0.18586D+00 -0.66248D-01 0.99057D+00 -0.24572D-02

6523 0.19145D+00 -0.70809D-01 0.99059D+00 -0.26769D-02

6524 0.19702D+00 -0.75409D-01 0.99062D+00 -0.28966D-02

6605 0.27051D-01 -0.58041D-02 0.65032D+00 0.41847D-01

6606 0.37816D-01 -0.81562D-02 0.66045D+00 0.38447D-01
6607 0.48605D-01 -0.10826D-01 0.67564D+00 0.35134D-01
6608 0.59410D-01 -0.13780D-01 0.68581D+00 0.31915D-01
6609 0.75332D-01 -0.16996D-01 0.69599D+00 0.28790D-01

6610 0.86130D-01 -0.20433D-01 0.71122D+00 0.25772D-01

6611 0.96921D-01 -0.24061D-01 0.72647D+00 0.22858D-01
6612 0.10770D+00 -0.27857D-01 0.73668D+00 0.20058D-01

6613 0.11846D+00 -0.31798D-01 0.75192D+00 0.17380D-01

6614 0.12919D+00 -0.35865D-01 0.76716D+00 0.14827D-01

6615 0.13990D+00 -0.40037D-01 0.78239D+00 0.12406D-01

6616 0.15059D+00 -0.44300D-01 0.79760D+00 0.10125D-01

0.15624D+00 0.81780D+00 0.79922D-02

6617 -0.48640D-01

6618 0.16687D+00 -0.53050D-01 0.83295D+00 0.60169D-02

6619 0.17250D+00 -0.57517D-01 0.85303D+00 0.42055D-02

0.17812D+00 0.86809D+00 0.25724D-02
6620 -0.62032D-01

0.18867D+00 0.88804D+00 0.11272D-02

6621 -0.66594D-01

6622 0.19425D+00 -0.71195D-01 0.90789D+00 -0.11664D-03

6623 0.19982D+00 -0.75829D-01 0.92762D+00 -0.11437D-02

6624 0.20537D+00 -0.80492D-01 0.95210D+00 -0.19315D-02

G-LTRENDS . DAT-17
NACA XMIN YMIN XMAX YMAX

6705 0.37038D-01 -0.66642D-02 0.73028D+00 0.45379D-01

6706 0.47691D-01 -0.93069D-02 0.74044D+00 0.42620D-01
6707 0.63466D-01 -0.12271D-01 0.74556D+00 0.39921D-01
6708 0.74154D-01 -0.15523D-01 0.75576D+00 0.37277D-01
6709 0.89925D-01 -0.19010D-01 0.76092D+00 0.34702D-01
6710 0.10061D+00 -0.22707D-01 0.76608D+00 0.32185D-01
6711 0.11130D+00 -0.26573D-01 0.77633D+00 0.29738D-01
6712 0.12197D+00 -0.30583D-01 0.78151D+00 0.27354D-01
6713 0.13264D+00 -0.34717D-01 0.79177D+00 0.25043D-01
6714 0.14328D+00 -0.38954D-01 0.79698D+00 0.22799D-01
6715 0.15391D+00 -0.43276D-01 0.80724D+00 0.20634D-01
6716 0.15951D+00 -0.47672D-01 0.81750D+00 0.18539D-01
6717 0.17011D+00 -0.52133D-01 0.82271D+00 0.16523D-01
6718 0.17569D+00 -0.56647D-01 0.83296D+00 0.14589D-01
6719 0.18127D+00 -0.61206D-01 0.84319D+00 0.12734D-01
6720 0.19180D+00 -0.65805D-01 0.84839D+00 0.10961D-01
6721 0.19736D+00 -0.70442D-01 0.85859D+00 0.92793D-02
6722 0.20290D+00 -0.75107D-01 0.86876D+00 0.76851D-02
6723 0.20348D+00 -0.79801D-01 0.87890D+00 0.61814D-02
6724 0.20901D+00 -0.84519D-01 0.88900D+00 0.47715D-02

6805 0.41897D-01 -0.74643D-02 0.81523D+00 0.49434D-01

6806 0.57560D-01 -0.10360D-01 0.82036D+00 0.47411D-01
6807 0.73232D-01 -0.13576D-01 0.82042D+00 0.45413D-01
6808 0.88905D-01 -0.17059D-01 0.82559D+00 0.43460D-01
6809 0.99517D-01 -0.20770D-01 0.83077D+00 0.41531D-01
6810 0.11518D+00 -0.24661D-01 0.83086D+00 0.39629D-01
6811 0.12578D+00 -0.28708D-01 0.83607D+00 0.37774D-01
6812 0.13638D+00 -0.32879D-01 0.84130D+00 0.35945D-01
6813 0.14697D+00 -0.37153D-01 0.84654D+00 0.34144D-01
6814 0.15754D+00 -0.41512D-01 0.84666D+00 0.32388D-01

6815 0.16310D+00 -0.45949D-01 0.85192D+00 0.30665D-01

6816 0.17365D+00 -0.50442D-01 0.85719D+00 0.28971D-01

6817 0.17919D+00 -0.54992D-01 0.85732D+00 0.27315D-01

0.18472D+00 0.86260D+00 0.25701D-01
6818 -0.59585D-01

0.19025D+00 0.86788D+00 0.24119D-01

6819 -0.64215D-01

0.19577D+00 0.87316D+00 0.22568D-01

6820 -0.68879D-01

0.20129D+00 0.87332D+00 0.21064D-01

6821 -0.73572D-01

0.20679D+00 0.87860D+00 0.19598D-01

6822 -0.78290D-01

0.21229D+00 0.88387D+00 0.18165D-01

6823 -0.83030D-01

0.21778D+00 0.88913D+00 0.16767D-01

6824 -0.87788D-01

0.51850D-01 0.90517D+00 0.54081D-01

6905 -0.82137D-02

0.90521D+00 0.52927D-01
6906 0.67434D-01 -0.11325D-01

0.90524D+00 0.51773D-01
6907 0.83030D-01 -0.14750D-01

0.90528D+00 0.50619D-01
6908 0.98629D-01 -0.18427D-01

0.91059D+00 0.49499D-01
6909 0.10918D+00 -0.22309D-01

0.91066D+00 0.48399D-01
6910 0.12477D+00 -0.26360D-01

0.91073D+00 0.47299D-01
6911 0.13532D+00 -0.30543D-01

0.91079D+00 0.46199D-01
6912 0.14586D+00 -0.34836D-01

0.91086D+00 0.45099D-01
6913 0.15639D+00 -0.39218D-01

0.91632D+00 0.44017D-01
6914 0.16692D+00 -0.43673D-01

0.91641D+00 0.42972D-01
6915 0.17242D+00 -0.48194D-01

0.91651D+00 0.41927D-01
6916 0.17793D+00 -0.52763D-01

0.91660D+00 0.40882D-01
6917 0.18842D+00 -0.57379D-01

0.91669D+00 0.39836D-01
6918 0.19392D+00 -0.62033D-01

0.92226D+00 0.38802D-01
6919 0.19940D+00 -0.66718D-01

0.92237D+00 0.37813D-01
6920 0.20488D+00 -0.71431D-01

0.92249D+00 0.36823D-01
6921 0.21036D+00 -0.76168D-01

0.92261D+00 0.35834D-01
6922 0.21583D+00 -0.80924D-01

0.92273D+00 0.34845D-01
6923 0.21632D+00 -0.85703D-01

0.92836D+00 0.33864D-01
6924 0.22178D+00 -0.90498D-01

G-LTRENDS. DAT-18
NACA XMIN YMIN XMAX YMAX

7105 0.22178D+00 -0.90498D-01 0.96337D-01 0.50721D-01

7106 0.22178D+00 -0.90498D-01 0.93123D-01 0.46993D-01
7107 0.22178D+00 -0.90498D-01 0.93644D-01 0.43275D-01
7108 0.22178D+00 -0.90498D-01 0.91041D-01 0.39661D-01
7109 0.22178D+00 -0.90498D-01 0.88710D-01 0.36092D-01
7110 0.22178D+00 -0.90498D-01 0.89678D-01 0.32636D-01
7111 0.22178D+00 -0.90498D-01 0.87718D-01 0.29287D-01
7112 0.14762D-01 -0.51463D-03 0.85823D-01 0.26025D-01
7113 0.15575D-01 -0.11263D-02 0.76687D+00 -0.69203D-03

7114 0.16389D-01 -0.17379D-02 0.99024D+00 -0.15409D-02

7115 0.17202D-01 -0.23495D-02 0.99025D+00 -0.17614D-02

7116 0.18016D-01 -0.29612D-02 0.99027D+00 -0.19820D-02

7117 0.18829D-01 -0.35728D-02 0.99029D+00 -0.22025D-02

7118 0.19643D-01 -0.41844D-02 0.99031D+00 -0.24231D-02

7119 0.20456D-01 -0.47961D-02 0.99032D+00 -0.26436D-02

7120 0.21270D-01 -0.54077D-02 0.99034D+00 -0.28642D-02

7121 0.22083D-01 -0.60193D-02 0.99036D+00 -0.30847D-02

7122 0.22896D-01 -0.66310D-02 0.99037D+00 -0.33053D-02

7123 0.23710D-01 -0.72426D-02 0.99039D+00 -0.35258D-02

7124 0.36690D-01 -0.78825D-02 0.99041D+00 -0.37464D-02

7205 0.78687D-02 -0.74693D-03 0.19083D+00 0.46189D-01

7206 0.84424D-02 -0.15876D-02 0.19099D+00 0.41462D-01
7207 0.90161D-02 -0.24282D-02 0.18673D+00 0.36738D-01
7208 0.95899D-02 -0.32688D-02 0.18697D+00 0.32042D-01
7209 0.10164D-01 -0.41095D-02 0.18294D+00 0.27353D-01
7210 0.17862D-01 -0.49972D-02 0.18326D+00 0.22692D-01
7211 0.18648D-01 -0.61794D-02 0.17945D+00 0.18053D-01
7212 0.19434D-01 -0.73616D-02 0.17577D+00 0.13440D-01
7213 0.27151D-01 -0.86598D-02 0.63720D+00 0.31421D-02
7214 0.28086D-01 -0.10103D-01 0.77214D+00 0.12081D-03
7215 0.35723D-01 -0.11657D-01 0.97550D+00 -0.15653D-02

7216 0.43209D-01 -0.13323D-01 0.99030D+00 -0.17871D-02

7217 0.44347D-01 -0.15181D-01 0.99032D+00 -0.20075D-02

7218 0.51784D-01 -0.17187D-01 0.99034D+00 -0.22279D-02

7219 0.64970D-01 -0.19390D-01 0.99036D+00 -0.24482D-02

7220 0.77539D-01 -0.21830D-01 0.99038D+00 -0.26686D-02

7221 0.34665D+00 -0.36558D-01 0.99040D+00 -0.28890D-02

7222 0.34167D+00 -0.41530D-01 0.99042D+00 -0.31094D-02

7223 0.33669D+00 -0.46504D-01 0.99044D+00 -0.33298D-02

7224 0.33676D+00 -0.51482D-01 0.99046D+00 -0.35502D-02

0.71224D-02 0.30000D+00 0.44993D-01

7305 -0.23112D-02

0.75469D-02 0.30000D+00 0.39991D-01

7306 -0.32362D-02

0.14087D-01 0.30000D+00 0.34990D-01

7307 -0.44703D-02

0.33017D+00 0.29992D-01
7308 0.14671D-01 -0.57645D-02

0.21273D-01 0.39056D+00 0.25056D-01

7309 -0.73244D-02

0.45100D+00 0.20290D-01
7310 0.27853D-01 -0.90067D-02

0.51144D+00 0.15781D-01
7311 0.34427D-01 -0.10856D-01

0.57185D+00 0.11600D-01
7312 0.40998D-01 -0.12886D-01

0.63220D+00 0.78077D-02
7313 0.47564D-01 -0.15097D-01

0.69744D+00 0.44685D-02
7314 0.54119D-01 -0.17487D-01

0.76749D+00 0.16602D-02
7315 0.60659D-01 -0.20052D-01

0.72573D-01 0.84718D+00 -0.49571D-03

7316 -0.22797D-01

0.79015D-01 0.96090D+00 -0.17307D-02

7317 -0.25732D-01

0.90648D-01 0.99039D+00 -0.19768D-02

7318 -0.28856D-01

0.10208D+00 0.99041D+00 -0.21969D-02

7319 -0.32168D-01

0.11331D+00 0.99043D+00 -0.24171D-02

7320 -0.35671D-01

0.12921D+00 -0.39372D-01 0.99046D+00 -0.26372D-02

7321
0.14466D+00 -0.43263D-01 0.99048D+00 -0.28573D-02
7322
0.15968D+00 -0.47344D-01 0.99050D+00 -0.30775D-02
7323
0.17429D+00 -0.51607D-01 0.99052D+00 -0.32976D-02
7324

G-LTRENDS . DAT-19
NACA XMIN YMIN XMAX YMAX

7405 0.12293D-01 0.
-0.32621D-02 .45525D+00 0,.46268D-01
7406 0..18294D-01 -0..46269D-02 0.
47540D+00 0,.41685D-01
7407 0. 18843D-01
.
0.
-0..62566D-02 .49055D+00 0..37186D-01
7408 0..24964D-01 0.
-0..81033D-02 .51577D+00 0,.32791D-01
7409 0..36561D-01 0. 53600D+00
-0..10159D-01 .
0,.28518D-01

7410 0..42715D-01 0. 56629D+00

-0..12442D-01 , 0..24390D-01
7411 0..48889D-01 0..59157D+00
-0.14920D-01 0..20433D-01
7412 0. 60409D-01 0. 62188D+00
.
-0..17582D-01 .
0. 16671D-01
.

7413 0. 66587D-01
. -0..20456D-01 0,.65719D+00 0..13132D-01

7414 0..78014D-01 -0..23497D-01 0..68746D+00 0..98446D-02

7415 0..84170D-01 -0..26717D-01 0. 72769D+00

. 0..68423D-02

7416 0.
.95485D-01 -0,.30103D-01 0. 76783D+00
. 0..41603D-02

7417 0.
.10671D+00 -0..33638D-01 0.
.80786D+00 0..18446D-02

7418 0.
.11783D+00 -0..37315D-01 0.
.85764D+00 -0..43198D-04
7419 0. 12386D+00
. -0..41125D-01 0.
.91699D+00 -0..14113D-02
7420 0.
.13483D+00 -0..45059D-01 0.
.99050D+00 -0..20814D-02
7421 0. 14570D+00
. -0..49100D-01 0.
.99053D+00 -0..23012D-02
7422 0.
.15645D+00 -0.. 53238D-01 0,
.99055D+00 -0..25209D-02
7423 0. 16227D+00
. -0.. 57468D-01 0. 99058D+00
. -0..27407D-02
7424 0. 17284D+00
. -0.. 61777D-01 0.
.99061D+00 -0.29605D-02

7505 0. 17254D-01
. -0..41610D-02 0.
55532D+00 0.48674D-01

7506 0.
.23063D-01 -0..59064D-02 0.
.57047D+00 0..44622D-01

7507 0.
.28921D-01 -0..79150D-02 0.
.58565D+00 0..40657D-01

7508 0.
.40112D-01 -0..10175D-01 0.
.60085D+00 0..36789D-01

7509 0.
.46039D-01 -0..12691D-01 0.
.61607D+00 0..33027D-01

7510 0.
.57239D-01 -0..15424D-01 0.
.63131D+00 0.29379D-01

7511 0,
.63203D-01 -0.. 18365D-01 0.
.64655D+00 0..25852D-01

7512 0.
.74386D-01 -0..21514D-01 0.
.66684D+00 0..22462D-01

7513 0.
.85535D-01 -0..24838D-01 0.
.68713D+00 0., 19216D-01
7514 0.
.96643D-01 -0.28323D-01 0.
.70742D+00 0.. 16126D-01
7515 0.
.10771D+00 -0..31956D-01 0.
.72769D+00 0., 13205D-01
7516 0. 11365D+00
. -0..35727D-01 0.
.75294D+00 0., 10465D-01
7517 0. 12464D+00
. -0.39620D-01 0.
.77315D+00 0.79234D-02

7518 0. 13557D+00
. -0.43616D-01 0.
.79831D+00 0..55944D-02

7519 0. 14145D+00
. -0..47710D-01 0.
.82339D+00 0.34966D-02

7520 0. 15229D+00
. -0..51890D-01 0.
85334D+00 0.16537D-02

7521 0.
.15812D+00 -0.56145D-01 0.
.88314D+00 0..91560D-04

7522 0.
.16885D+00 -0.60465D-01 0.
91277D+00 -0.. 11552D-02
7523 0. 17461D+00
. -0..64849D-01 0.
95193D+00 -0..20378D-02

7524 0.
.18036D+00 -0..69284D-01 0.
99072D+00 -0..24877D-02

7605 0.
.22163D-01 -0., 50026D-02 0.
64031D+00 0..51712D-01

7606 0.
.27853D-01 -0.70467D-02 0.
65045D+00 0..48249D-01

7607 0.
.38809D-01 -0..94086D-02 0.
.66062D+00 0..44857D-01

7608 0.
,49779D_0l -0., 12034D-01 0.
.67081D+00 0..41539D-01

7609 0.
60755D-01 -0..14909D-01 0.
.68101D+00 0..38300D-01

7610 0. 71732D-01
, -0., 18010D-01 0.
.69123D+00 0..35143D-01

7611 0.
.82701D-01 -0..21315D-01 0. 70652D+00
. 0..32073D-01

7612 0.
.93658D-01 -0..24801D-01 0.
.71677D+00 0..29094D-01

7613 0.
.10460D+00 -0. 28447D-01 0.
.72702D+00 0..26209D-01

7614 0. 11043D+00 -0. 32239D-01 0. 73728D+00

, 0..23419D-01

7615 0. 12133D+00 -0. 36156D-01 0.

75259D+00 0,.20737D-01

7616 0. 13220D+00 -0. 40180D-01 0.

.76284D+00 0..18159D-01

7617 0.
, 13801D+00 -0. 44298D-01 0.
.77813D+00 0. 15696D-01
.

7618 0. 14883D+00 -0. 48506D-01 0.

.79340D+00 0. 13349D-01
.

7619 0. 15460D+00 -0. 52783D-01 0.

.80362D+00 0. 11125D-01
.

7620 0.
. 16536D+00 -0. 57127D-01 0.
.81883D+00 0,.90318D-02

7621 0. 17110D+00
, -0. 61530D-01 0.
83400D+00 0..70728D-02

7622 0. 17683D+00
. -0. 65982D-01 0.
.84912D+00 0,.52553D-02

7623 0. 18254D+00
, -0. 70478D-01 0.
86419D+00 0,.35868D-02

7624 0. 18824D+00
, -0. 75013D-01 0.
87919D+00 0,.20748D-02

G-LTRENDS . DAT-20
NACA XMIN YMIN XMAX YMAX

7705 0..27063D-01 -0.. 57868D-02 0..72528D+00 0,.55282D-01

7706 0..37840D-01 -0..81225D-02 0..73545D+00 0..52479D-01
7707 0.48646D-01 -0..10770D-01 0. 74059D+00
. 0.
.49726D-01
7708 0..59472D-01 0..74575D+00
-0..13696D-01 0,.47023D-01
7709 0. 70310D-01
.
0,.75092D+00
-0..16869D-01 0. 44371D-01
.

7710 0..81153D-01 0..75611D+00

-0..20258D-01 0,
.41770D-01

7711 0..97090D-01 0, 76639D+00

-0..23839D-01 .
0..39225D-01
7712 0. 10791D+00
.
-0..27583D-01 0..77160D+00 0.
.36738D-01

7713 0. 11872D+00
.
-0..31466D-01 0..77683D+00 0.
.34306D-01

7714 0. 12446D+00 -0..35475D-01 0, 78206D+00

.
. 0.
.31930D-01

7715 0. 13524D+00
.
-0..39589D-01 0.
.79239D+00 0.
29618D-01

7716 0. 14601D+00 -0..43790D-01 0..79763D+00

.
0.
.27367D-01

7717 0..15172D+00 -0..48073D-01 0..80288D+00 0.

.25173D-01

7718 0. -0..52420D-01 0,
.16245D+00
.81321D+00 0.
.23051D-01

7719 0. 16814D+00
.
-0..56832D-01 0,
.81846D+00 0.
.20990D-01

7720 0. 17383D+00
. -0..61294D-01 0,
.82878D+00 0.
.18996D-01

7721 0. 17951D+00
. -0..65800D-01 0.
.83402D+00 0.
.17074D-01

7722 0. 18518D+00
. -0..70346D-01 0.
.84431D+00 0.
.15217D-01

7723 0. 19083D+00
.
-0..74929D-01 0.
.84953D+00 0.
.13439D-01

7724 0. 19648D+00
. -0..79543D-01 0.
.85977D+00 0. 11728D-01
.

7805 0.
.31966D-01 -0..65180D-02 0.
.81527D+00 0.
.59379D-01

7806 0.
.47768D-01 -0..91071D-02 0.
.81532D+00 0.
.57333D-01

7807 0. 58472D-01
. -0..12013D-01 0.
.82049D+00 0.
.55315D-01

7808 0. 69197D-01
. -0..15190D-01 0.
82056D+00 0.
.53317D-01

7809 0.
.85026D-01 -0..18611D-01 0.
.82577D+00 0.
.51358D-01

7810 0.
.95762D-01 -0..22233D-01 0.
83100D+00 0.
.49411D-01

7811 0.
.10650D+00 -0..26025D-01 0.
83110D+00 0. 47510D-01
7812 0.
.11723D+00 -0..29963D-01 0.
83636D+00 0.
.45625D-01

7813 0.
. 12795D+00 -0..34026D-01 0.
.83648D+00 0. 43773D-01
7814 0.
. 13866D+00 -0..38193D-01 0.
.84177D+00 0. 41952D-01
7815 0.
. 14936D+00 -0..42447D-01 0.
.84189D+00 0.
40149D-01

7816 0.
. 15501D+00 -0..46784D-01 0.
.84721D+00 0. 38395D-01
7817 0.
. 16066D+00 -0..51180D-01 0.
.85253D+00 0. 36658D-01
7818 0. 17132D+00
. -0..55639D-01 0.
.85268D+00 0. 34954D-01
7819 0.
.17695D+00 -0.60145D-01 0.
.85802D+00 0.
.33285D-01

7820 0.
.18258D+00 -0..64694D-01 0.
.86337D+00 0.
.31636D-01

7821 0. 18820D+00
, -0..69280D-01 0.
86354D+00 0.
.30033D-01

7822 0.
.19381D+00 -0..73899D-01 0.
.86888D+00 0.
.28456D-01

7823 0. 19942D+00
. -0.78548D-01 0.
.86906D+00 0. 26903D-01
7824 0.
.20501D+00 -0.83222D-01 0.
.87441D+00 0.
.25398D-01

7905 0.
41977D-01 -0., 72187D-02 0.
90520D+00 0.
64057D-01

7906 0.
.52583D-01 -0., 10023D-01 0.
90524D+00 0.
62903D-01

7907 0. 68304D-01 -0., 13150D-01 0.

.90528D+00 0.
.61749D-01

7908 0. 84029D-01 -0., 16539D-01 0.

.90532D+00 0.
.60595D-01

7909 0. 94685D-01 -0..20161D-01 0.

90536D+00 0.
.59442D-01

7910 0. 10534D+00 -0..23964D-01 0.

91077D+00 0.
58306D-01

7911 0.
, 11601D+00 -0..27922D-01 0.
91085D+00 0. 57207D-01
,

7912 0. 13171D+00 -0.32012D-01 0.

91092D+00 0.
.56108D-01

7913 0. 13732D+00 -0. 36213D-01 0.

.91100D+00 0.
.55008D-01

7914 0. 14796D+00 -0..40505D-01 0.

91108D+00 0.
.53909D-01

7915 0. 15859D+00 -0. 44871D-01 0.

.91115D+00 0.
.52809D-01

7916 0. 16419D+00 -0. 49306D-01 0.

.91675D+00 0.
.51726D-01

7917 0. 16978D+00 -0. 53793D-01 0.

91686D+00 0.
.50682D-01

7918 0. 18038D+00 -0. 58332D-01 0.

91697D+00 0.
.49639D-01

7919 0. 18596D+00 -0. 62912D-01 0.

.91708D+00 0.
.48595D-01

7920 0. 19154D+00 -0. 67528D-01 0.

.91719D+00 0.
.47551D-01

7921 0. 19711D+00 -0. 72176D-01 0.

91730D+00 0.
.46508D-01

7922 0. 20267D+00 -0. 76850D-01 0.

.92304D+00 0.
.45489D-01

7923 0. 20823D+00 -0. 81548D-01 0.

92318D+00 0.
.44503D-01

7924 0. 20881D+00 -0. 86270D-01 0.

.92332D+00 0.
.43516D-01

G-LTRENDS . DAT-2 1
NACA XMIN YMIN XMAX YMAX

8105 0. 20881D+00 86270D-01

-0. 0.96527D-01 0.60710D-01
8106 0. 20881D+00 86270D-01
-0. 0.93559D-01 0.56958D-01
8107 0. 20881D+00 86270D-01
-0. 0.94152D-01 0.53251D-01
8108 0. 20881D+00 86270D-01
-0. 0.91859D-01 0.49620D-01
8109 0. 20881D+00 86270D-01 0.92717D-01
-0. 0.46047D-01
8110 0. 20881D+00 86270D-01 0.90939D-01
-0. 0.42614D-01
8111 0. 20881D+00 86270D-01 0.89298D-01
-0.
0.39254D-01
8112 0. 20881D+00 -0. 86270D-01 0.90598D-01 0.36005D-01
8113 0. 20881D+00 -0. 86270D-01 0.89156D-01 0.32891D-01
8114 0. 16904D-01 -0. 31305D-04 0.87606D-01
,
0.29832D-01
8115 0. 17754D-01 -0. 59068D-03 0.80226D+00 -0.11060D-02
8116 0. 18604D-01 -0. 11501D-02 0.99031D+00 -0.17578D-02
8117 0. 19454D-01 -0. 17094D-02 0.99033D+00 -0.19782D-02
8118 0. 20305D-01 -0. 22688D-02 0.99035D+00 -0.21985D-02
8119 0. 21155D-01 -0.28282D-02 0.99037D+00 -0.24189D-02
8120 0.
.22005D-01 -0. 33876D-02 0.99039D+00 -0.26392D-02
8121 0. 22855D-01 -0. 39470D-02 0.99041D+00 -0.28596D-02
8122 0.
.23706D-01 -0..45063D-02 0.99043D+00 -0.30799D-02
8123 0.
24556D-01 -0., 50657D-02 0.99045D+00 -0.33003D-02
8124 0.
.25406D-01 -0..56251D-02 0.99046D+00 -0.35207D-02

8205 0.
81298D-02 -0..62540D-04 0.19548D+00 0.56172D-01
8206 0.
.87557D-02 -0..86505D-03 0.19113D+00 0.51442D-01
8207 0.
93817D-02 -0..16676D-02 0.19132D+00 0.46716D-01
8208 0.
. 10008D-01 -0.24701D-02 0.18725D+00 0.42002D-01
8209 0.
, 10634D-01 -0..32726D-02 0.18753D+00 0.37308D-01
8210 0.
. 11260D-01 -0..40751D-02 0.18373D+00 0.32627D-01
8211 0.
. 11886D-01 -0..48776D-02 0.18410D+00 0.27970D-01
8212 0.
.20309D-01 -0.57643D-02 0.18054D+00 0.23339D-01
8213 0.
.21168D-01 -0..68946D-02 0.17714D+00 0.18732D-01
8214 0.
22027D-01 -0..80250D-02 0.17387D+00 0.14160D-01
8215 0.
.30345D-01 -0.91858D-02 0.65790D+00 0.31133D-02
8216 0.
.31367D-01 -0.. 10568D-01 0.77279D+00 0.16130D-03
8217 0.
.32390D-01 -0.. 11951D-01 0.92152D+00 -0.16718D-02

8218 0.
.40682D-01 -0.. 13526D-01 0.99039D+00 -0.19749D-02

8219 0.
.48741D-01 -0., 15166D-01 0.99041D+00 -0.21951D-02

8220 0.
.49991D-01 -0..16951D-01 0.99043D+00 -0.24152D-02

8221 0. 57948D-01
. -0.. 18900D-01 0.99046D+00 -0.26353D-02

8222 0.
.71898D-01 -0..21041D-01 0.99048D+00 -0.28555D-02

8223 0.
.85053D-01 -0..23422D-01 0.99050D+00 -0.30756D-02

8224 0.
.34716D+00 -0..41776D-01 0.99052D+00 -0.32957D-02

8305 0.
.73635D-02 -0.. 18622D-02 0.30000D+00 0.54993D-01
8306 0.
.78362D-02 -0..27635D-02 0.30000D+00 0.49991D-01
8307 0.
.83089D-02 -0..36649D-02 0.30000D+00 0.44990D-01
8308 0. 15205D-01
. -0..48509D-02 0.30000D+00 0.39988D-01
8309 0. 15855D-01
. -0..61128D-02 0.32518D+00 0.34989D-01
8310 0.
.22773D-01 -0..75406D-02 0.37560D+00 0.30033D-01
8311 0.
.23550D-01 -0..90746D-02 0.43110D+00 0.25204D-01
8312 0.
.30516D-01 -0.. 10814D-01 0.48159D+00 0.20576D-01
8313 0.
.37441D-01 -0.. 12670D-01 0.53710D+00 0.16205D-01
8314 0.
.44339D-01 -0., 14672D-01 0.58754D+00 0.12143D-01

8315 0.
.51211D-01 -0..16832D-01 0.64292D+00 0.84352D-02

8316 0.
58057D-01 -0.19154D-01 0.69819D+00 0.51308D-02

8317 0.
.64873D-01 -0.21637D-01 0.75826D+00 0.22898D-02

8318 0. 71655D-01
. -0..24280D-01 0.82304D+00 -0.18534D-05

8319 0.
.83845D-01 -0..27087D-01 0.90716D+00 -0.15865D-02

8320 0.
.90479D-01 -0..30076D-01 0.99050D+00 -0.21269D-02

8321 0.
.10230D+00 -0.33241D-01 0.99052D+00 -0.23467D-02

8322 0.
.11386D+00 -0..36589D-01 0.99054D+00 -0.25666D-02

8323 0.
.12516D+00 -0..40124D-01 0.99057D+00 -0.27864D-02

8324 0. 14100D+00
. -0..43859D-01 0.99059D+00 -0.30062D-02

G-LTRENDS. DAT-2 2
NACA XMIN YMIN XMAX YMAX

8405 0.68695D-02 -0.27455D-02 0.45026D+00 0.56193D-01

8406 0.13095D-01 -0.39863D-02 0.46037D+00 0.51561D-01
8407 0.19325D-01 -0.53467D-02 0.47553D+00 0.46993D-01
8408 0.19943D-01 -0.69516D-02 0.49575D+00 0.42500D-01
8409 0.26287D-01 -0.87441D-02 0.51096D+00 0.38099D-01
8410 0.32651D-01 -0.10714D-01 0.53123D+00 0.33803D-01
8411 0.39034D-01 -0.12867D-01 0.55655D+00 0.29629D-01
8412 0.45434D-01 -0.15198D-01 0.57685D+00 0.25596D-01
8413 0.51844D-01 -0.17700D-01 0.60220D+00 0.21723D-01
8414 0.63700D-01 -0.20393D-01 0.63257D+00 0.18032D-01
8415 0.70088D-01 -0.23245D-01 0.65789D+00 0.14541D-01
8416 0.81796D-01 -0.26250D-01 0.69322D+00 0.11275D-01
8417 0.88141D-01 -0.29423D-01 0.72348D+00 0.82585D-02
8418 0.99691D-01 -0.32735D-01 0.75867D+00 0.55176D-02
8419 0.10597D+00 -0.36193D-01 0.79374D+00 0.30857D-02
8420 0.11735D+00 -0.39783D-01 0.83362D+00 0.10034D-02
8421 0.12859D+00 -0.43493D-01 0.87822D+00 -0.67348D-03

8422 0.13473D+00 -0.47328D-01 0.93229D+00 -0.18597D-02

8423 0.14578D+00 -0.51266D-01 0.99066D+00 -0.24001D-02

8424 0.15181D+00 -0.55301D-01 0.99069D+00 -0.26194D-02

8505 0.12124D-01 -0.36055D-02 0.55033D+00 0.58568D-01

8506 0.18059D-01 -0.51265D-02 0.56047D+00 0.54461D-01

8507 0.24042D-01 -0.68865D-02 0.57063D+00 0.50427D-01

8508 0.30070D-01 -0.88778D-02 0.58585D+00 0.46468D-01
8509 0.36136D-01 -0.11086D-01 0.59605D+00 0.42596D-01

8510 0.47596D-01 -0.13515D-01 0.61131D+00 0.38815D-01

0.53707D-01 0.62659D+00 0.35131D-01
8511 -0.16150D-01

0.65137D-01 0.64189D+00 0.31552D-01

8512 -0.18962D-01

0.71269D-01 0.65719D+00 0.28088D-01

8513 -0.21969D-01

0.82649D-01 0.67250D+00 0.24744D-01

8514 -0.25132D-01

0.88779D-01 0.69285D+00 0.21528D-01

8515 -0.28458D-01

0.10009D+00 0.70816D+00 0.18454D-01

8516 -0.31926D-01

0.10620D+00 0.72848D+00 0.15526D-01

8517 -0.35522D-01

0.11742D+00 0.74877D+00 0.12757D-01

8518 -0.39247D-01

0.76902D+00 0.10156D-01
8519 0.12857D+00 -0.43073D-01

0.78922D+00 0.77373D-02
8520 0.13461D+00 -0.47010D-01

0.80936D+00 0.55120D-02
8521 0.14063D+00 -0.51029D-01

0.83440D+00 0.34952D-02
8522 0.15163D+00 -0.55137D-01

0.85931D+00 0.17046D-02
8523 0.15759D+00 -0.59315D-01

0.88409D+00 0.16221D-03
8524 0.16352D+00 -0.63557D-01

0.63531D+00 0.61616D-01
8605 0.17164D-01 -0.43719D-02

0.64547D+00 0.58106D-01
8606 0.22945D-01 -0.61809D-02

0.65566D+00 0.54654D-01
8607 0.34069D-01 -0.82602D-02

0.66081D+00 0.51268D-01
8608 0.39941D-01 -0.10615D-01

0.67104D+00 0.47948D-01
8609 0.51103D-01 -0.13190D-01

0.68128D+00 0.44695D-01
8610 0.57034D-01 -0.15997D-01

0.69155D+00 0.41514D-01
8611 0.68210D-01 -0.19006D-01

0.70183D+00 0.38407D-01
8612 0.79369D-01 -0.22196D-01

0.70705D+00 0.35378D-01
8613 0.85339D-01 -0.25559D-01

0.71736D+00 0.32430D-01
8614 0.96476D-01 -0.29078D-01

0.72766D+00 0.29566D-01
8615 0.10758D+00 -0.32730D-01

0.74304D+00 0.26790D-01
8616 0.11354D+00 -0.36506D-01

0.75335D+00 0.24104D-01
8617 0.12460D+00 -0.40396D-01

0.76365D+00 0.21513D-01
8618 0.13054D+00 -0.44379D-01

0.77396D+00 0.19019D-01
8619 0.14153D+00 -0.48457D-01

0.78425D+00 0.16624D-01
8620 0.14745D+00 -0.52609D-01

0.79955D+00 0.14338D-01
8621 0.15836D+00 -0.56829D-01

0.80980D+00 0.12161D-01
0.16423D+00 -0.61117D-01
8622
0.82503D+00 0.10096D-01
0.17009D+00 -0.65459D-01
8623
0.83522D+00 0.81527D-02
8624 0.17593D+00 -0.69850D-01

G-LTRENDS . DAT-23
NACA XMIN YMIN XMAX YMAX

8705 0. 22131D-01 -0. 50925D-02 0.72532D+00 0.65213D-01

8706 0. 33035D-01 -0. 71624D-02 0.73045D+00 0.62377D-01
8707 0. 38767D-01 -0. 95464D-02 0.73560D+00 0.59583D-01
8708 0. 49737D-01 -0. 12194D-01 0.74077D+00 0.56833D-01
8709 0. 60720D-01 -0. 15083D-01 0.74596D+00 0.54128D-01
8710 0. 71710D-01 -0. 18192D-01 0.75117D+00 0.51468D-01
8711 0. 82698D-01 -0. 21497D-01 0.75639D+00 0.48854D-01
8712 0. 93680D-01 -0. 24976D-01 0.76163D+00 0.46288D-01
8713 0. 99534D-01 -0. 28614D-01 0.76688D+00 0.43770D-01
8714 0. 11050D+00 -0. 32389D-01 0.77214D+00 0.41301D-01
8715 0. 12145D+00 -0. 36279D-01 0.77741D+00 0.38882D-01
8716 0. 12730D+00 -0. 40276D-01 0.78269D+00 0.36513D-01
8717 0. 13822D+00 -0. 44368D-01 0.79309D+00 0.34203D-01
8718 0.
.
14405D+00 -0. 48539D-01 0.79838D+00 0.31945D-01
8719 0. 15492D+00 -0. 52782D-01 0.80368D+00 0.29742D-01
8720 0. 16073D+00 -0. 57092D-01 0.80898D+00 0.27592D-01
8721 0. 16653D+00 -0. 61455D-01 0.81428D+00 0.25498D-01
8722 0.
. 17233D+00 -0..65868D-01 0.82466D+00 0.23468D-01
8723 0.
, 17811D+00 -0..70325D-01 0.82996D+00 0.21497D-01
8724 0.
.18388D+00 -0..74823D-01 0.83525D+00 0.19583D-01

8805 0.
27072D-01 -0.. 57739D-02 0.81021D+00 0.69337D-01
8806 0.
.37858D-01 -0..80971D-02 0.81537D+00 0.67278D-01
8807 0.
.48676D-01 -0., 10728D-01 0.81543D+00 0.65233D-01
8808 0.
59518D-01 -0., 13634D-01 0.82064D+00 0.63220D-01
8809 0.
.70375D-01 -0..16781D-01 0.82072D+00 0.61222D-01
8810 0.
.81242D-01 -0.20141D-01 0.82597D+00 0.59257D-01
8811 0.
.92111D-01 -0..23686D-01 0.82607D+00 0.57308D-01
8812 0. 10298D+00
. -0.27392D-01 0.83137D+00 0.55393D-01
8813 0.
.11384D+00 -0..31237D-01 0.83148D+00 0.53492D-01
8814 0. 12468D+00
. -0..35201D-01 0.83681D+00 0.51629D-01
8815 0. 13045D+00
. -0..39270D-01 0.83694D+00 0.49777D-01
8816 0. 14128D+00
. -0..43433D-01 0.84231D+00 0.47967D-01
8817 0, 14704D+00
. -0..47670D-01 0.84245D+00 0.46165D-01
8818 0. 15783D+00
. -0..51979D-01 0.84784D+00 0.44410D-01
8819 0. 16357D+00
. -0..56348D-01 0.85323D+00 0.42662D-01
8820 0. 16931D+00
. -0..60769D-01 0.85340D+00 0.40960D-01
8821 0, 17505D+00
. -0..65236D-01 0.85881D+00 0.39270D-01
8822 0.
.18077D+00 -0..69744D-01 0.85900D+00 0.37619D-01
8823 0. 18649D+00
. -0.. 74290D-01 0.86442D+00 0.35988D-01
8824 0.
.19219D+00 -0..78868D-01 0.86461D+00 0.34388D-01

8905 0.
.32004D-01 -0..64185D-02 0.90523D+00 0.74033D-01
8906 0,
.42703D-01 -0..89576D-02 0.90528D+00 0.72879D-01
8907 0.
.58554D-01 -0.. 11815D-01 0.90532D+00 0.71726D-01
8908 0.
. 69303D-01 -0,.14948D-01 0.90537D+00 0.70572D-01
8909 0.
.80066D-01 -0.. 18311D-01 0.90542D+00 0.69419D-01
8910 0.
.90839D-01 -0,.21875D-01 0.90546D+00 0.68265D-01
8911 0.
. 10162D+00 -0..25611D-01 0.91097D+00 0.67116D-01

8912 0.
. 11239D+00 -0..29496D-01 0.91105D+00 0.66017D-01

8913 0.
.12316D+00 -0,.33506D-01 0.91114D+00 0.64919D-01

8914 0.
.13393D+00 -0..37622D-01 0.91123D+00 0.63820D-01

8915 0.
. 14467D+00 -0..41825D-01 0.91132D+00 0.62722D-01

0. 15037D+00 0.91141D+00 0.61623D-01

8916 . -0..46113D-01

8917 0.
. 15606D+00 -0..50462D-01 0.91149D+00 0.60525D-01

8918 0. 16678D+00
. -0.. 54876D-01 0.91725D+00 0.59445D-01
0. 0.91738D+00 0.58403D-01
8919 .17246D+00 -0..59340D-01

0. 17814D+00 0.91750D+00 0.57361D-01

8920 . -0..63848D-01

8921 0. 18381D+00
. -0..68395D-01 0.91763D+00 0.56319D-01

8922 0. 18947D+00
. -0..72977D-01 0.91775D+00 0.55277D-01

8923 0,
.19513D+00 -0,.77590D-01 0.91788D+00 0.54235D-01

8924 0,
.20078D+00 -0,.82229D-01 0.91800D+00 0.53193D-01

G-LTRENDS. DAT-24
NACA XMIN YMIN XMAX YMAX

9105 0.20078D+00 -0.82229D-01 0.96717D-01 0.70701D-01

9106 0.20078D+00 -0.82229D-01 0.93990D-01 0.66931D-01
9107 0.20078D+00 -0.82229D-01 0.94655D-01 0.63237D-01
9108 0.20078D+00 -0.82229D-01 0.92661D-01 0.59599D-01
9109 0.20078D+00 -0.82229D-01 0.93619D-01 0.56052D-01
9110 0.20078D+00 -0.82229D-01 0.92158D-01 0.52628D-01
9111 0.20078D+00 -0.82229D-01 0.90799D-01 0.49267D-01
9112 0.20078D+00 0.92235D-01
-0.82229D-01 0.46075D-01
9113 0.20078D+00 0.91034D-01
-0.82229D-01 0.42948D-01
9114 0.20078D+00 0.92652D-01
-0.82229D-01 0.39952D-01
9115 0.2O078D+00 -0.82229D-01 0.91424D-01 0.37033D-01
9116 0.20078D+00 -0.82229D-01 0.93185D-01 0.34237D-01
9117 0.20078D+00 -0.82229D-01 0.83757D+00 -0.14732D-02
9118 0.20814D-01 -0.47302D-03 0.99039D+00 -0.19735D-02
9119 0.21693D-01 -0.98680D-03 0.99041D+00 -0.21936D-02
9120 0.22571D-01 -0.15006D-02 0.99044D+00 -0.24138D-02
9121 0.23450D-01 -0.20144D-02 0.99046D+00 -0.26339D-02
9122 0.24328D-01 -0.25281D-02 0.99048D+00 -0.28540D-02

9123 0.25207D-01 -0.30419D-02 0.99050D+00 -0.30742D-02

9124 0.26085D-01 -0.35557D-02 0.99052D+00 -0.32943D-02

9205 0.26085D-01 -0.35557D-02 0.19553D+00 0.66167D-01

9206 0.90277D-02 -0.14622D-03 0.19128D+00 0.61423D-01
9207 0.96990D-02 -0.91122D-03 0.19149D+00 0.56698D-01
9208 0.10370D-01 -0.16762D-02 0.19170D+00 0.51973D-01
9209 0.11042D-01 -0.24412D-02 0.18785D+00 0.47272D-01
9210 0.11713D-01 -0.32062D-02 0.18817D+00 0.42581D-01
9211 0.12384D-01 -0.39712D-02 0.18461D+00 0.37913D-01
9212 0.13055D-01 -0.47362D-02 0.18503D+00 0.33260D-01
9213 0.13727D-01 -0.55012D-02 0.18174D+00 0.28644D-01
9214 0.22917D-01 -0.63324D-02 0.17863D+00 0.24053D-01
9215 0.23839D-01 -0.74115D-02 0.17567D+00 0.19498D-01
9216 0.24762D-01 -0.84906D-02 0.53817D+00 0.68239D-02
9217 0.25685D-01 -0.95697D-02 0.67369D+00 0.31078D-02
9218 0.34805D-01 -0.10796D-01 0.77353D+00 0.21104D-03
9219 0.35906D-01 -0.12118D-01 0.89733D+00 -0.17171D-02

9220 0.44755D-01 -0.13462D-01 0.99049D+00 -0.21611D-02

9221 0.45993D-01 -0.14990D-01 0.99051D+00 -0.23810D-02

9222 0.54658D-01 -0.16567D-01 0.99054D+00 -0.26008D-02

9223 0.56006D-01 -0.18279D-01 0.99056D+00 -0.28207D-02

9224 0.64513D-01 -0.20140D-01 0.99059D+00 -0.30405D-02

9305 0.75859D-02 -0.14078D-02 0.30000D+00 0.64993D-01

9306 0.81030D-02 -0.22844D-02 0.30000D+00 0.59991D-01
9307 0.86202D-02 -0.31610D-02 0.30000D+00 0.54990D-01
9308 0.91374D-02 -0.40375D-02 0.30000D+00 0.49988D-01
9309 0.16411D-01 -0.51532D-02 0.30000D+00 0.44987D-01
9310 0.17123D-01 -0.63813D-02 0.32018D+00 0.39987D-01
9311 0.24368D-01 -0.76596D-02 0.36565D+00 0.35018D-01
9312 0.25219D-01 -0.91537D-02 0.41116D+00 0.30147D-01
9313 0.32491D-01 -0.10705D-01 0.46176D+00 0.25435D-01
9314 0.33452D-01 -0.12421D-01 0.50731D+00 0.20932D-01
9315 0.40751D-01 -0.14263D-01 0.55284D+00 0.16680D-01
9316 0.47993D-01 -0.16221D-01 0.60335D+00 0.12717D-01
9317 0.55188D-01 -0.18315D-01 0.64874D+00 0.90778D-02
9318 0.62337D-01 -0.20555D-01 0.69903D+00 0.58027D-02
9319 0.69440D-01 -0.22947D-01 0.75412D+00 0.29380D-02
9320 0.76495D-01 -0.25490D-01 0.80895D+00 0.54874D-03
9321 0.83498D-01 -0.28184D-01 0.87822D+00 -0.12615D-02

9322 0.90445D-01 -0.31027D-01 0.97606D+00 -0.22636D-02

9323 0.10273D+00 -0.34053D-01 0.99064D+00 -0.24943D-02

9324 0.11469D+00 -0.37249D-01 0.99067D+00 -0.27138D-02

G-LTRENDS. DAT-25
NACA XMIN YMIN XMAX YMAX

9405 0.70665D-02 -0.24144D-02 0.44023D+00 0.66140D-01

9406 0.13423D-01 -0.33570D-02 0.45035D+00 0.61473D-01
9407 0.13993D-01 -0.46571D-02 0.46552D+00 0.56859D-01
9408 0.20468D-01 -0.60011D-02 0.48072D+00 0.52302D-01
9409 0.21151D-01 -0.75791D-02 0.49595D+00 0.47815D-01
9410 0.27730D-01 -0.93068D-02 0.51120D+00 0.43410D-01
9411 0.34316D-01 -0.11185D-01 0.52647D+00 0.39096D-01
9412 0.40914D-01 -0.13227D-01 0.54681D+00 0.34888D-01
9413 0.47522D-01 -0.15434D-01 0.56716D+00 0.30801D-01
9414 0.54136D-01 -0.17803D-01 0.59257D+00 0.26848D-01
9415 0.60751D-01 -0.20329D-01 0.61294D+00 0.23047D-01
9416 0.67364D-01 -0.23007D-01 0.63834D+00 0.19413D-01
9417 0.73971D-01 -0.25829D-01 0.66371D+00 0.15963D-01
9418 0.85978D-01 -0.28791D-01 0.69408D+00 0.12715D-01
9419 0.92518D-01 -0.31911D-01 0.71937D+00 0.96890D-02
9420 0.99037D-01 -0.35156D-01 0.74960D+00 0.69053D-02
9421 0.11077D+00 -0.38536D-01 0.78470D+00 0.43882D-02
9422 0.11720D+00 -0.42041D-01 0.81470D+00 0.21674D-02
9423 0.12870D+00 -0.45665D-01 0.85440D+00 0.28083D-03
9424 0.13502D+00 -0.49401D-01 0.89382D+00 -0.12220D-02

9505 0.12362D-01 -0.31304D-02 0.54030D+00 0.68490D-01

9506 0.12834D-01 -0.44693D-02 0.55045D+00 0.64342D-01
9507 0.18969D-01 -0.60461D-02 0.56061D+00 0.60254D-01
9508 0.25139D-01 -0.78129D-02 0.57081D+00 0.56232D-01
9509 0.31346D-01 -0.97803D-02 0.58607D+00 0.52280D-01
9510 0.37587D-01 -0.11943D-01 0.59631D+00 0.48405D-01
9511 0.43856D-01 -0.14292D-01 0.60657D+00 0.44608D-01
9512 0.50148D-01 -0.16816D-01 0.62190D+00 0.40899D-01
9513 0.61869D-01 -0.19534D-01 0.63218D+00 0.37280D-01
9514 0.68174D-01 -0.22407D-01 0.64754D+00 0.33762D-01
9515 0.79816D-01 -0.25427D-01 0.66291D+00 0.30346D-01
9516 0.86114D-01 -0.28610D-01 0.67827D+00 0.27042D-01
9517 0.92410D-01 -0.31920D-01 0.69364D+00 0.23855D-01
9518 0.10393D+00 -0.35364D-01 0.70899D+00 0.20792D-01
9519 0.11019D+00 -0.38926D-01 0.72433D+00 0.17860D-01
9520 0.12160D+00 -0.42598D-01 0.74468D+00 0.15070D-01
9521 0.12781D+00 -0.46376D-01 0.75997D+00 0.12427D-01
9522 0.13400D+00 -0.50241D-01 0.78023D+00 0.99423D-02
9523 0.14523D+00 -0.54202D-01 0.80042D+00 0.76233D-02
9524 0.15136D+00 -0.58238D-01 0.82053D+00 0.54822D-02

9605 0.12009D-01 -0.38337D-02 0.63535D+00 0.71540D-01

9606 0.17897D-01 -0.54597D-02 0.64047D+00 0.67996D-01
9607 0.23834D-01 -0.73207D-02 0.64562D+00 0.64501D-01
9608 0.35190D-01 -0.94342D-02 0.65584D+00 0.61063D-01
9609 0.41204D-01 -0.11769D-01 0.66102D+00 0.57680D-01
9610 0.47252D-01 -0.14302D-01 0.67129D+00 0.54358D-01
9611 0.58640D-01 -0.17043D-01 0.67651D+00 0.51093D-01
9612 0.64730D-01 -0.19963D-01 0.68682D+00 0.47897D-01
9613 0.76102D-01 -0.23059D-01 0.69715D+00 0.44763D-01
9614 0.82212D-01 -0.26308D-01 0.70240D+00 0.41697D-01
9615 0.93548D-01 -0.29708D-01 0.71275D+00 0.38705D-01
9616 0.99659D-01 -0.33233D-01 0.72311D+00 0.35784D-01
9617 0.11094D+00 -0.36887D-01 0.73348D+00 0.32938D-01
9618 0.11704D+00 -0.40644D-01 0.74384D+00 0.30170D-01
9619 0.12825D+00 -0.44506D-01 0.75421D+00 0.27483D-01

9620 0.13432D+00 -0.48456D-01 0.75950D+00 0.24880D-01

9621 0.14037D+00 -0.52483D-01 0.76986D+00 0.22365D-01
9622 0.15147D+00 -0.56591D-01 0.78020D+00 0.19938D-01
9623 0.15748D+00 -0.60763D-01 0.79557D+00 0.17604D-01
9624 0.16348D+00 -0.64994D-01 0.80587D+00 0.15367D-01

G-LTRENDS. DAT-2 6
NACA XMIN YMIN XMAX YMAX

9705 0. 17098D-01 -0. 45229D-02 0. 72029D+00 0.75159D-01

9706 0. 22859D-01 -0. 63778D-02 0. 72543D+00 0.72299D-01
9707 0. 33959D-01 -0. 85384D-02 0. 73059D+00 0.69475D-01
9708 0. 39814D-01 -0. 10932D-01 0. 73577D+00 0.66689D-01
9709 0.
.
50961D-01 13575D-01
-0. 0. 74098D+00 0.63942D-01
9710 0. 62111D-01 -0.. 16423D-01 0. 74620D+00 0.61234D-01
9711 0.
. 68051D-01 -0. 19477D-01 0. 75145D+00 0.58567D-01
9712 0. 79213D-01 -0..22711D-01 0. 75671D+00 0.55941D-01
9713 0. 90362D-01 -0. 26101D-01 0. 76198D+00 0.53358D-01
9714 0. 96335D-01 29641D-01 0.
-0.
76727D+00 0.50818D-01
9715 0. 10746D+00 33313D-01 0.
.
-0. , 77257D+00 0.48322D-01
9716 0. -0..37096D-01 0. 77789D+00
.11344D+00
0.45872D-01
9717 0. 12453D+00 0.
.
-0.40992D-01 78321D+00 0.43467D-01
9718 0.
. 13050D+00 -0.44974D-01 0. 78854D+00 0.41109D-01
9719 0.
. 14154D+00 -0..49043D-01 0. 79388D+00 0.38798D-01
9720 0.
. 14749D+00 -0..53187D-01 0. 79922D+00 0.36536D-01
9721 0.
.15342D+00 -0..57394D-01 0. 80457D+00 0.34323D-01
9722 0.
. 15935D+00 -0.. 61660D-01 0.
.80992D+00 0.32160D-01
9723 0.
. 17029D+00 -0..65981D-01 0.
.81526D+00 0.30048D-01
9724 0.
. 17618D+00 -0..70351D-01 0.
.82061D+00 0.27987D-01

9805 0.
.22107D-01 -0..51603D-02 0.
.81024D+00 0.79312D-01
9806 0.
.33006D-01 -0..72556D-02 0.
.81541D+00 0.77223D-01
9807 0.
.38734D-01 -0.96508D-02 0.
.81548D+00 0.75178D-01
9808 0.
.49705D-01 -0.. 12316D-01 0.
.81555D+00 0.73133D-01
9809 0.
.60692D-01 -0.. 15217D-01 0.
.82081D+00 0.71126D-01
9810 0.
.71690D-01 -0.. 18333D-01 0.
.82090D+00 0.69129D-01
9811 0.
.82692D-01 -0..21639D-01 0.
.82621D+00 0.67159D-01
9812 0.
.88549D-01 -0.25115D-01 0.
.82632D+00 0.65210D-01
9813 0.
.99557D-01 -0..28748D-01 0.
.83167D+00 0.63279D-01
9814 0, 11055D+00
. -0..32510D-01 0.
.83180D+00 0.61379D-01
9815 0. 12153D+00
. -0.36383D-01 0.
.83719D+00 0.59489D-01
9816 0. 12740D+00
. -0..40368D-01 0.
.83733D+00 0.57639D-01
9817 0. 13836D+00
. -0..44434D-01 0.
84275D+00 0.55791D-01
9818 0.
.14422D+00 -0..48589D-01 0.
.84292D+00 0.53990D-01
9819 0.
.15008D+00 -0.52809D-01 0.
.84308D+00 0.52190D-01
9820 0.
.15593D+00 -0..57090D-01 0.
.84854D+00 0.50437D-01
9821 0.
.16682D+00 -0.61429D-01 0.
.84872D+00 0.48687D-01
9822 0. 17265D+00
. -0..65819D-01 0.
.85421D+00 0.46981D-01
9823 0.
.17848D+00 -0..70252D-01 0.
.85440D+00 0.45281D-01
9824 0.
.18429D+00 -0..74723D-01 0.
.85990D+00 0.43623D-01

9905 0.
.27079D-01 -0..57638D-02 0,
.90526D+00 0.84009D-01
9906 0.
.37872D-01 -0..80774D-02 0,
.90531D+00 0.82856D-01
9907 0.
.48699D-01 -0.. 10696D-01 0.
.90536D+00 0.81702D-01
9908 0. 59553D-01
. -0.. 13585D-01 0.
.90542D+00 0.80549D-01
9909 0. 70426D-01
. -0.16713D-01 0.
.90547D+00 0.79396D-01
9910 0.
81311D-01 -0..20050D-01 0.
.90552D+00 0.78243D-01
9911 0.
.92202D-01 -0..23570D-01 0.
.90557D+00 0.77089D-01
9912 0.
. 10309D+00 -0..27246D-01 0.
.90562D+00 0.75936D-01
9913 0.
, 11398D+00 -0..31059D-01 0.
.91128D+00 0.74831D-01
9914 0.
. 11977D+00 -0..34997D-01 0.
.91138D+00 0.73733D-01
9915 0.
, 13065D+00 -0..39036D-01 0,
.91148D+00 0.72636D-01
9916 0.
. 13644D+00 -0.43164D-01 0.
.91158D+00 0.71538D-01
9917 0. 14730D+00
. -0..47373D-01 0.
.91168D+00 0.70440D-01
9918 0. 15308D+00
. -0..51650D-01 0.
.91178D+00 0.69343D-01
9919 0. 15887D+00
.
-0.. 55986D-01 0.
.91188D+00 0.68245D-01
9920 0. 16969D+00
.
-0.. 60375D-01 0.
.91781D+00 0.67175D-01
9921 0. 17545D+00
. -0.64814D-01 0,
.91795D+00 0.66135D-01
9922 0.
.18121D+00 -0..69295D-01 0.
.91809D+00 0.65095D-01
9923 0.
.18697D+00 -0..73811D-01 0,
.91823D+00 0.64055D-01
9924 0.
.19272D+00 -0..78360D-01 0.
.91837D+00 0.63015D-01

G-LTRENDS . DAT-2 7