Point of No Return
Point of No Return
GENERAL
The previous chapter discussed the provisions made for the determination of the Critical
Point or Equi-Time Point. However it may also be necessary to establish the point in a flight,
where it would be impossible to return to the aerodrome of departure due to a shortage of
fuel. Such a position is the Point of No Return (PNR) & represents the maximum distance the
aeroplane can travel over a specific route, & then return, and still have a specific, or agreed,
fuel reserve when back over the departure aerodrome.
The point of no return is that point along a track from a departure aerodrome beyond which
there is insufficient flight fuel remaining to return to that aerodrome with all the mandatory
fuel reserves intact.
The point of no return is a totally different concept to the equi-time point. Whereas the ETP is
purely concerned with “time to a landing”, the PNR is determined primarily by the amount of
fuel available.
a) The aeroplane is unable to plan to carry enough fuel for a suitable operational
alternate(s) for the planned destination, or that during the actual flight progress such
alternate requirements may no longer be needed.
b) The weather at the planned destination and alternate(s) deteriorates below permitted
landing minima.
In such cases the flight may continue to the PNR and still be operationally capable of
returning to the departure aerodrome.
The PNR should generally be determined for both the normal planned operation as well as
the emergency operation (as with the CP).
Beyond the PNR a flight has insufficient fuel to return and land at the departure
aerodrome with all statutory fuel reserves intact
At the equi-time point for any given flight there must always be sufficient fuel remaining to
either continue on to the destination, or return to the departure/alternate aerodrome
concerned. We can therefore see that:
The PNR will always lie at or beyond the ETP between two aerodromes
The greater the amount of flight fuel carried by an aero plane, the closer to the planned
destination aerodrome the PNR will be. The position of the ETP, however, is never affected
by changes in the amount of flight fuel.
The simple formula for determination of PNR is similar to that for CP, except that flight
endurance replaces the total distance.
Having extracted the total endurance from the fuel flight plan; it is then necessary to establish
a MAXIMUM SAFE ENDURANCE (i.e. total endurance less operational reserve, holding &
departure alternate fuel requirement), in other words just the fuel required for en-route flight;
which is generally given in time (Hrs: min).
T = time to PNR
O = G/S OUT (G/S from departure to PNR)
H = G/S Home (G/S from PNR back to departure)
E = Maximum Safe Endurance
The formula is :
Example
Then Time to cover total distance = 1000 @ G/S 450 Kt. = 2 Hrs 13 min
and
Distance to PNR = 52.5 x 450 nm = 394 nm
60
Proof equals :
1. Set G/S Out (O) + G/S Home (H) on the OUTER SCALE (800) against G/S Home (H)
on the INNER SCALE (350)
2. Against Max. Safe Endurance (in minutes) on the OUTER SCALE (120) read off time
to PNR or the INNER SCALE (52.5 minutes)
oOo